Skip to main content
Loading video...

Board games we love (in genres we hate), what some games get right (guest: Peter Hayward) | Ep 127

Transcript 1:04:10

hey everybody Welcome to the going out podcast the show where board game industry guests bring their own topics and games to discuss I'm Christina your host and it's February that has absolutely no bearing at all on why we invited back our friend board game designer Peter C Hayward hi Peter it's February Happy Valentine's Day can you both be my Valentine this year that's my question yeah uh I have nothing for you but I'll cook you something I I have low expectations okay great that's the way I like it we did uh establish the last time Peter kind of the first time we met Peter was through this met you on this show didn't I yeah and then uh you were uh your board game soulmate my board game soulmate because we kept wanting to answer a lot of the same things yeah make it we'll make it official this year so we we we've become such friendy friends that I actually forgot we met through this podcast yep yeah and you know obvious Peter is a very fantastic designer of a very eclectic array of games which is exactly uh Peter I think so you know you have the acclaimed two-player abstract at that time you killed me the most recent tiny games from button shy it's a two-player converge gotten really great Buzz uh the party social game a propos which we'll talk about AOS of which we'll talk about uh more later in this podcast uh the one versus many game Word game fiction one of our favorite party games French toast the upcoming super super cute worker placement Critter kitchen one of our most anticipated games of 2024 so lots of stuff to get uh

to look forward to and you're everywhere these days Peter so many of your games everywhere including on this podcast exactly exactly you're listening to it right now and you of course run your own publishing label Jelly Bean games and Blue Beard entertainment so you're always busy so thanks for taking the time to see us again thanks so much for having me and nowhere I'd rather be in February than with my two Valentine's podcast so what's your topic for us today today I brought the topic games you like in a genre you don't normally like mhm I made that more extreme in my notes it was games you love in genres you normally hate but oh that is that that that's that's much better writing than Mine mine's very wishy-washy like stuff that is slightly above average and something slightly blow you're like no your favorite thing and your least favorite thing that's that's much better I'm going to change it that games you love in a genre you hate much snappier and Shu of course is here too Peter's gaming soulmates our Collective Valentine too so yeah what topic is yeah we can expand polycules are a thing right so what's your topic today well our topic from going analog are uh is specific things that specific games got right uh so this was born from uh when the three of us were last together uh we were playing a game istanb and favorite game so I we'll bring it up

a little bit more when we get to the topic but there's like you specifically like just one thing in the game and it's not even necessarily a mechanic or such uh but just like you're like this game got this thing right and know we want to give more examples of that yeah we're g to yeah Peter's going to gush over that real soon so that game gets everything right so I could I could uh could do a full hour on his St and we'd like to start off by highlighting game we want to talk about for us that was a proos of the new sort of mini series you have going these little card games um we actually will be putting up some of these podcasts on YouTube so we're showing the game it's a little button shy game and uh really social so tell us a little bit about the elevator pitch Peter for these yes so appropo of movies and aopo of of board games uh Cooperative trivia games that are sort of randomly generated which I don't think any of that exists outside of these games um but basically you you for whichever topic movies or board games you draw a card and it gives you a requirement so it could be you know uh it must be a movie that has animation so you could say Shrek then you draw another card and let's say that one says has a cat so now you have to put that in in the opposite category so if Shrek has a cat you have to n name a film that doesn't have a cat but does have animation or if Shrek doesn't have a cat you have to name one that has an animation and has a cat and you keep doing that in five card so it's actually an adversarial system so it is working against you mechanically to make your answers harder and harder so by the fifth card it is almost impossible to

name something but if you can name five cards in five if you can get through five cards and name five movies or board games in five minutes you win the game and even though it's only 18 cards including the the two categories must have and but no uh so only 16 content cards there's so many combinations and variations that I've played this game easily dozens if not hundreds of times now and I'm always find like new films and games that answer the question yeah did you actually ever math out how many different combinations are possible I not it'd be interesting though it's uh it's doable I just haven't actually run the math on it I could do it now if I wasn't on video I'd be like yes I'm listening and then quickly have another window open where do some math yeah it's uh it's possible to math it out but uh that'll take a little bit of time I'll tell you the formula it's it's uh 16 P 5 time I think 5 torial it's going to be something very similar to that right but the uh each C each new card you pick can be a must have or but no yes so that that's that's the factorial part it's it's not factorial it's binary so there's 32 combinations of that I think yeah all uh no because yeah anyway it's doable it's kind of stuff I love doing I just told the audience we're like we're not going to do it in and we're started we started I'll tell you um some someone so critic kitchen is is the game that you I've mentioned earlier my upcoming cute little critter game um with Alex Cutler my co-designer someone wrote a paper not not not for publication but like he's a mathematician he wanted to know how many games of that you'd have

to reasonably play to see all the content once and so this this paper has like these formula that take up half a page and it's just it's it's uh everyone in the Discord was like okay and I'm like oh like I watch those math videos like number file and S for fun so I was I was in my element for that that was wonderful cool well to kind of demonstrate to the audience we're going to play a quick game uh again you said a normally uh a game takes 5 minutes we might not even play that full five minutes uh just to give a sample uh so I have the game in front of me we have both game pro pro board games and uh movies but much worse at the movie One Christina I asked her this morning uh and I knew the answer as like would you rather do board games on the show or movies and she's like board games so uh I'm going to play out a card on this side uh it's going to be off screen but I'll read it to the audience so the first card is the game this is a board game and we're the three of us are going to play together must be set in a future go uh is Dune Imperium set in the future is it just a Sci-Fi world oh it's it's a i me it's definitely a Sci-Fi world but I don't know if it was supposed to like be in the future when we' settled other planets I assume sort of related to that cuz if it's not in our world there's no time for you had one Christina oh like underwater cities or something like that underwater cities perfect I know it but I trust that you do okay now underwater cities also must have a single word

title now sorry not under set in the future I said that wrong set in the future it's a game that's set in the future but it's a single word title now so underwater cities no longer works o i uh I'm looking behind you guys where you have a huge collection of games yeah I forget that I can play too I'm like moderating this finally I mean please for once in your life jeez is anacron supposed to take place in the future it is a future game and the oh yes that's right all right the name now it's uh cannot play this is going to get really hard now uh it cannot play three plus players so it means it's a one or two player game it has to be said in the future and it's a single word title Redlands m that's a good one oh that was really good I was like this is we're pretty much done so we don't it's his game he better get this right I don't know all right oh no the pressure pressure uh it has to be set in a future it has to be a single word title it cannot play three or more players and it must have meeples which Redlands I do not believe it has meeples that one is tough ah I I was about to say Clank because I was thinking space Clank but that doesn't fit half of this criteria oh wow okay let me uh what if wait no those those are like cars that would have been more help I had Netrunner but that uh doesn't doesn't fit quite a few it doesn't fit me the

meatles yeah it needs meeples meeples is OD the meeples I think killed it yeah yeah well so we'll move on because we have an entire halfway through the episode one of us like oh I've got it yeah so uh do you guys have an email address you can get people to write in with their answer yeah yeah or when we post this show you can respond to us on social media would great uh so yeah so everyone gets the idea we would go through if we did one more card so the fifth card uh and if we collectively as a group see what it would have been the last would be must have farming oh set in a future farming future set in a future farming me single word tile but cannot play three or more so it's a one or two we so on the Discord we play this every day um someone generates a set so we only get the final five and then we we throw answers around and so far in the weeks and weeks we've been playing it I think we've only found one that we couldn't find anything for but I posted to Facebook and someone found something so oh nice I'm not saying every combination is definitely possible but we're yet to find I think more than one that we we couldn't do um sometimes you so one of the cards is is based on an IP so you'll get like based on an IP two-player contains farming uh you know just it just gets hyper specific but that's the game that that's how it works yeah so you would go through if you could defeat five cards uh I did it this morning I'm very proud

of myself yeah I did it I was practicing with Christina and then she got one uh which is fantastic uh and then the movie version has cards like uh cat like it may or may not contain a cat depending on how you play the game or how you draw the card or named after a or group features a student language other than English spoken animation a character goes on water so you see there's just uh with just a handful of cards it would just create a bunch of different unknown which we all are so undetermined number of combinations possible but that's uh the challenge with those is coming up with different vectors cuz you know if if if two things are diametrically opposite on the same line the game breaks so for example you can't have three plus players and solo you like because if they if they both end up on the must have you it breaks um or I guess they could have multiple modes but anyway that's yeah but you need you need to come up with different vectors and so stuff like you know the title of the contents of the movies is a lot of behind the scenes stuff um I don't think it's in that set but one of the cards uh coming out in the future expansion is one of the actors has died and so um you end up with like a lot of old movies coming out or a lot of very recent movies coming out if if it's on the other side I just yeah coming out with all the different vectors was the fun part of Designing that game that's cool I love that the whole thing where it's like generating the the qualifications itself right like based off of your previous answers so that makes it nice and uh different every time so yeah very proud of that one yeah uh what game did you bring for us today Peter uh so I

have been playing a lot of uh the smoke and Dagger game boop b o p which is uh cute little kittens on a cute little Grid it's a pure abstract two players there's no variable content there's no like complex rules you just have a grid and you put kittens down and that's most of the game right there and normally my taste run to like stuff where you have different permutations like we talking about Istanbul earlier and you can mix up Istanbul into any number of different combinations and there's different expansions and there's different action cards Boop is just so pure and yet like it's always such an interesting little puzzle so i' I've been playing and thinking a lot about Boop lately yeah and then in BO do you want to describe what the kids are there for there's a little bit more to it the goal of the game is to get three cats in a line and the way you get a cat is by getting three kittens in a line and every turn you literally just take one of your kittens from your supply and put it onto the board but uh the title of the game Boop is because when you put it down each of the eight surrounding squares any kittens there will be bounced away so thematically your cat's bouncing on a bed and when you put it down everyone else bounces away so with that restriction it's actually incredibly hard to line up three in a row you think line up three I've played Tic Tac coer I know how this works no as soon as you put put one next to it they all go away again and then your opponent's also bouncing them away and so it's just it's so frenetic and I don't want to say chaotic cuz it is quite a serious like sit down AB but it's it's it's this incredible combination of of different elements and uh and so once once you get three kittens in a row they upgrade to cats and you have to put them on the board again and the thing that makes it

work is that cats can bounce cats and cats can bounce kittens but kittens can't bounce cats so the placement of cats is so important it's uh yeah it's a lot of fun it's so simple to teach too and the way you set it up you put the box upside down and they give you this tiny little quilt that you put on top of it it's like the best packaging ever it's some some of the best presentation I've ever seen in a board game yeah the squares are sewn into the quilt right is there what I remember there some sewn into it yeah you can definitely see them so it looks like a bed it looks like kittens and C jumping onto a bed the sides of the bed sorry the sides of the Box are just the sides of a bed ah it's it's so clever and then all the kittens are these cute little uh custom meeple shapes with like root style painting on them and ah love so it's definitely one of those G the rules are so easy but then the more you play like the better you get at it so like if I've played anybody who's played it more than two times I will definitely lose Soul because I play it tce yeah it rewards like Forward Thinking I like like all abstracts do rewards forward thinking but it's almost deceptive like you look at these kittens you look at this bed you don't think oh I'm going to have to really turn my brain on but then you really do yeah yeah it's basically kitten chest so mhm very cool um but we will go into our first topic and I we are going to I forgot to break again sorry Mike so we're starting this thing where we do a little like brief little music break in between and I'm supposed to break and I never remember how to do that anymore so so we just need to stay

openly each other for a few seconds go so let's move on to our first topic what is that again Shu uh specific things that specific games got right like I said at the introduction uh that uh I just thought of this cuz we were hanging out with Peter it was a couple weekends ago uh he was playing Istanbul and then you mentioned specific so in case you're not familiar with Istanbul uh it's a kind of a classic game it's not new um and then there's a grid there's a sorry 10 years 10 years old okay uh so there's a bunch of different places that you go to and then you have a stack of discs that are moving around the board and then when you go to a new place you have to drop off a disc or pick up a previous Place disc and then uh you just but eventually you might run out of disc and you can't move anymore so you have to move around this board uh in a strategic way to like make sure you have enough disc to move to the right places uh but the thing is it's a Euro Style game so there's like these you know hey I have to get some money from one place yeah turn it into resources turn these resources in for uh gems uh there's a lot of different places in or locations in this game I'm not going to go over them but uh it just plays really quickly that was a thing like that sparked this topic was Peter's like I just love this game like it's just could go fast it's like Boop move and then you're done and then next player the other game but yeah move done move done and so you could play this thing in easily under an hour uh and it's uh but

that was it it was just like you said specific Peter you're like I just love how this one thing this game did right was like how quick the turns are so I'm wondering if we have more examples of this uh so yeah that that came like I said I could just talk about that the the fact that you finished your turn and you just thought just finished thinking about your next tourn it's back to you it's it's so lovely because downtime is such such a killer in so many games but Istanbul is a perfect game and does it well um so my example is a little bit strange the Lost ruins of arac I think has sorry lost ruins of arac is is about a little bit heavier than isul probably around the same weight um it's by uh cge who did codeen names and zul in a bunch of other games uh you you play Indiana Jones style explorers going into arnac to explore the Lost ruins and do research and collect artifacts and fight monsters it's very cool it's just a a little worker placement um uh worker placement engine builder deck builder so it's got It's got a bit of everything it combines them all really well and that game in my mind is best in market for its development which is not something that you normally specifically call out but I play that game and I like it obviously but the thing that as as a as a developer myself the thing that shines to me through that game is how exquisitly developed it is all the little pain points that games have have been not sanded off in a way that makes the game worse but just like integrated so well so I I'll give you the example that I always think of um there's a row of cards that you can buy for your deck building uh and so they just face up I yeah there are some cards that will say

draw I can't remember exctly how it is now but it's basically like you you you'll play an action card and it'll say um draw the top card of the deck and either buy that or one of the existing cards and when you do that if you buy the top card of the deck cool you have the top card of the deck now if you buy one of the existing cards you play the top card of the deck to replace it and again this this might sound so manure and tedious to anyone who's not into game development but the fact that they eliminated any need for a memory aspect because a lot of games would be would say draw two pick one put the other one face down on the deck now there's this aspect of like on a future turn I really should remember what was there and it's just a little it's not even a pain point it's just a little unnecessary bit of work that is probably never going to come in like it's probably never going to be relevant but if I'm really playing the game optimally I should remember that they eliminated that and they've done this in so many different ways and so many different areas it's just such a cool game in terms of uh yeah yeah like I said kind of getting rid of those rough edges and making everything so smooth so even even though it's not as quite as specific as turn length uh that for me lost runs of anac for me is the perfectly developed game and it flows super well like you know talking about that card Market row they have that little staff that shifts throughout the game so as the game progresses you're getting more of the more powerful cards when you can use them versus like the you know beginner cards so that sort of really helps the the pacing and progression of the game too so I think I think that's probably one of the things that I respond to unconsciously yeah

those are they have a cool theme for that one too which is that the the the staff so the things on the left of the staff are artifacts from the islands the things on the right of the staff are supplies from the mainland as the game goes over you get fewer supplies and more things from the island because it represents you going deeper into the island so it's harder to get supplies but it's easier oh it's it's so clever right another thing about that row of cards since we're talking about it is the items when you gain it you have to put that at the bottom of your deck and they won't come up till later uh so those are less useful over time like especially the last round it's like well who cares what goes at the bottom of your deck you might Supply you a point or two but you're not going to see it in play so that's not very rewarding versus the artifacts uh now at the end of the game you get more of those like Christina said but those activate immediately as soon as you buy them so so that's another smart design into how that game so much yeah um I'm I'm going to pull an example from Boop as well uh oh sorry no that that's that's uh I I got I got stuck on good development no I'm uh I'm done with o of an what did you have uh Christina well uh the game I was going to uh mention was um It's a Party game called pictomania uh that uh so the basic idea it's a drawing game you might have a set uh you will have a set of 21 different words there's like three cards so a b and c and then each card has a one through like seven different Clues like 1 through 7even uh so there's a 1 through 7 b 1 through 7 c 1 through 7

and then everyone's going to draw uh a combination so I might get C3 and I look at this uh reference cards and then see okay I know what my secret word is Christine will have a secret word you'll have a secret word when we go we're all drawing frantically uh this word because we want people to guess it but uh at the same time the sooner you finish now you start to guess what other people are drawing so there's this combination of like well I want to draw my picture accurately because I need people to guess my picture correctly but I want to finish so I can move on to the next phase and this is all real time which is like now I'm trying to guess what Christina Drew what Peter Drew and we're all having this race the sooner I can guess Christina's picture the more points I would score over someone who guess as her picture later in that same round uh so I'm racing like to I want to be the first to guess everyone's picture uh but maybe because of doing so uh I rushed my drawing and no one can guess my picture so the game rewards you for every aspect you could think of very simply it's like the faster you're done the faster you could guess the more points you'll get the more accurate you're drawing the more points you'll get the more points you'll get uh and then so the the faster you finish there's these end G end of round like I'm done guessing I'll grab these tokens you get more points so it's like you're rushing to guess and be accurate in those guesses but you have be fast but at the same time if I'm just messing around and guessing halfhazard Le uh then I'm not going to get points there and so on or if I take too long V ofle

design and it's like super well designed same guy who did code names my favorite designer yeah so he uh the really cool part too is like you know sometimes play drawing games and some people are just like better drawers than others you know but like this one really helps balance against it like sure if you're a better artist you might be able to do it faster and like more recognizable but there's still that aspect of like how good of a guesser are you and because you're rushing you're not going to be doing your Masterpiece that you normally would you know so so it's not my favorite party game in the world uh it's very solid but every time I play it I'm like this whole aspect of like the speed versus accuracy of speed of drawing speed of guessing versus accuracy of drawing accuracy of guessing uh is all so finely tuned I'm like I'm so impressed I'm like this is such a brilliant design have you played this one Peter I I don't think I have actually um okay I have to show it to you just I think you'd appreciate from a design point of view yeah for sure no I I'm yet to find a Vish fle game I don't love so it bodes well all right then we'll need to show you this one we'll do a pctto Mania and dungeon pets day okay yes I've never played dungeon pet and I want to see some like dungeon pet poop and stuff and I have to clean it up the one that's top of mine for me is uh I just played Great Western Trail New Zealand finally um huge fan of the series love Great Western Trail in general and I just like I was just by re reading the rules I was reminded like how much I just it's how satisfying this like giant rondel feel of Great Western

Trail it's like you can plan ahead for like how you're going to winow your deck or um you know get better cards because in Great Western Trail original you're you're setting up a a herd of cows that you're going to ship away um and then in New Zealand there's sheep which are fluffier and therefore cuter by the way but just like when I was reading the rules like the feel of like okay as you're traveling you get to take these actions and then of course the the Rondell changes and develops as players put out their own buildings too right and so it's never a boring rondelle um we have a friend who joked that the original Great Western Trail was just you know Monopoly with cows because you know you reached the end you you know turn things in and you pass go come back and do it again um but it's just obviously so much more satisfying than that and then in New Zealand I love the little tweaks they did but the the base game of still like you know this super big journey and you have this payoff at the end if you've played it correctly um there's a little bit of RNG and how you deck build and draw your cards but there's so many ways to adjust the cars that you have in your hand uh it's just really satisfying like I love that that part there's a little bit of interaction but I don't feel like people are super blocking me all the time um because that's frustrating so for me it gets that that Rondell like extended Rondell feel perfect for me so um I I've got I've got one that I have a an example but I'm sure you two will have uh other other better examples which is I'm going to say fantasy Realms which is a little Whiz Kids game it's just a deck of I

think 85 cards something like that and the game is Just building the best hand that you can and at the end you score your hand and the the cards are wild in that it'll be something like you know the the queen is worth 15 points plus plus five points if you have the king plus three points per Army and this Army will be you know 17 points minus two if there's any floods and then the flood like every card affects every other card and has its own scoring condition and it's just it's a a real amazing little like uh the the joke is that playing the game scoring the game takes about as long as playing the game but it's just it's just as satisfying uh so the thing that I think fantasy Realms specifically gets specifically right is setup I only ever play the two-player variant even if I'm playing with more people I still play two-player variant so the setup for Fantasy Realms the way I play it is Shuffle the deck and then you and that's it then you start playing the game so there is no other setup than that and I'm sure you guys can think of other ones where like the setup is just so insanely easy that you don't even have to think about it mhm a lot of party games obviously yeah wa wait what's different about the two player variance having a hand I think yeah in in three or four player you start everyone with a hand of seven and then you're just refining that hand and I found that if you're playing that especially with new players you're saying hey this is a fun game you'll enjoy now do 20 minutes of reading and uh whereas the two-player variant you start with nothing in hand so it it has one extra rule which is that until people have seven cards in hand you either draw two and discard one or take

one from the discard and that's it whereas later in the game it's draw one discard one or take one discard take one from the discard and discard one um so it means there is a rule shift but if you're teaching the game then that rule shift is pretty easy to implement because it's for everyone at the same time and doesn't change again um so I I like I like the two player variant a lot more um it it's a little longer is the cost but I'm totally fine with that actually I don't even know for these it might be the same length Okay yeah we'll have to try that I think that's a really good idea so um I have another quick example uh that uh this is uh what is my example I just had a Oni Tama on Tama okay okay so this is a two-player abstract game and the idea is too bad it didn't take place in the future so the idea is I think it's like one master and then five apprentices uh that's surround uh the master and then your goal is either to eliminate the other players Master uh in sort of a I think the grid is maybe 5x5 or something like that in sort of a chess like fashion and then uh eliminate the other players master or get your master into the opening start spot that the other master was in it's like the entrance to their Temple or something like that uh if you could do either one so but the game play is really simple that you have one of two you have two cards in front of you you pick one of them that lets you pick any one of the characters Apprentice or master and move it into the designated spot so one card might

say okay you can only move the four diagonal directions one spot or one card might say okay you can move either two four or two to the side or two to the other side something like that super simp you might have the night moveing chests or something like that yeah but it's it's uh uh it's you pick one character one card and move one of your pieces in the possible spots that that card outlines for you uh then what you do is you take that card you just played you put it in the middle the other and then you draw the other one that was in the middle then the other player now let's say I'm playing against Peter he'll do the same thing he'll pick one of his two cards put it in the middle the card I previously just played that got put in the middle now goes to him all five of these cards there's always like five cards in play they're all rotating uh you can see very clearly the thing I love about this game is you can see very clearly what all the possible moves are in an inant so unlike chess which I think you know obviously a very big famous game that Millions of people play uh I've never played it but I saw the musical oh is there musical chess it's like the same song Maybe slightly different openings and then famous musical from the 80s called chess about the life of Bobby Fisher oh really yeah yeah oh wow crazy so yeah so unlike chess like if I'm teaching someone for the first time what chess is you have to memorize and sort of imagine and picture where all of these different pieces go Bishops move this way Rooks move this way and the barrier at least

you know initially is that you you you can't see where everything is going like all the possible ways you can die right uh where in this game I think it balances it because I like I can easily see okay based on Peter's two cards here are just a few ways he can spaces he can capture as long as I avoid those spaces I won't get captured or maybe you do it intentionally because I want him to move into a certain space it still has that chest like kind of back and forth of like let me think two step and what is my opponent going to do can I trick that person into making an opening for me and all of that kind of stuff and I'm going to give that person this card eventually in an house that work so it's very easy but just the way they display the cards and make it all open information uh makes it super super easy to play easy to grasp and it's super very CL that would actually even work for our next topic for me I normally don't like very head-to-head two-player games and I really like onama because there's just like you don't have to keep too many things in mind but there's still strategy there yeah onama is a game that I think of in the same breath as code names as a fundamental game in that as a designer you will quite often be working on a thing and then you'll be like oh this will improve it this will improve it this will improve it and it's just onama every time I took a step towards Improvement it got closer to Oni and then it just became on and I was like well cool it's just like dixit's another one actually the the dixit's just such a like if you're working with anything with like abstract thought like that the tweaks you make just keep it close it's a gravitational

pool you just can't like son they found that Perfect Design almost it's yeah code names only time I dicks it there's a few of them where it's just like ah damn you you just you perfected it and now now you you you your gravity is so much that we just can't play in this field without getting sucked into your orbit uh for me I wanted to you know because I I have like I love science games I think the one that hits the sweet spot for me of like that balance between science and like gameplay is genotype for me like there's a lot of good science games out there now um but for genotype I think the balance between like the mandelian genetics part and how they Implement that into the gameplay is like super great for super nerds like me but also still really fun for people who don't care about mendal which is fine cuz he just sat around and grew lots of peas basically and he was a monk but like the way that they uh mimic the punet squares for people are into bi ology is like they have Dice and they have four sides because if you make a small 2x2 Punit square there's four possibilities so they're numbered one 2 3 4 and then you have these other sides that are like mutation sides that that explain why you might be able to get different combinations as you're aiming to get certain genetic combinations um so it's just done really really well they also fully explain in the background like yes we understand mutations don't quite work this way but this is the science and how it's Rel so um still super fun game and I've always

had that struggle where sometimes the science is really good but the gamep play is not there and a genotype I think brings them both together and that's sweet spot for me so I want I want to give an example on the other side of the fence of that which is Alchemists also from cge who did Zulan and uhac I've heard a lot of people in Academia say that game perfectly captures not the science cuz it's a fantasy game but you play Al yeah it's not it's not yeah Alchemy the science of you play Fantasy professors in a school basically and you're all racing to be the first to get your paper published and there's a mechanic in the game where you can get the paper published and get all the all the rewards and then if you're wrong other people can disprove it and get rewards for that or you can disprove it and also get rewards for it and so even though there's no actual science in the game it does have like a sodoku style logic puzzle that the kind of the the papers are based on it does apparently uh very effectively capture what it's like to be in Academia in in in science but not in a in a scientific sense but science in the in the cultural sense of like trying to get papers published I can see that this may be with this in a previous math brief math disc discussion this is like our most academically nerdy episode ever there's been a lot though I don't know about that any other sort of specific Sweet Spot things for you Peter uh I think there the I mean after that i' just be saying like this genre does this genre really well this genre game does like like Cosmic and Canada does negotiation really well but that's just saying this

game is good at its genre yeah I'll do one more really quick example uh cuz just cuz I'm looking at it and I can see it in front of me in our collection P for pizza uh it's a quick party game uh basically they're triangle cards uh and then the on each side of the triangle like yeah it's like a one might say restaurant one might say a type of vegetable one might say a country and then uh on the outside of these triangles are different letters uh that are facing it and it's all randomized right so maybe a might be in front of country or for example or in another game it might be D in front of that country it so randomized the first person to shout out one of those matches like a country that starts with a or a vegetable that starts with with G Etc grabs that card and scores that card uh but the the thing I would want to point out that I always think is so brilliant about this game is you eventually want to get uh you want to get five cards You're Building like a pizza wedge with these triangle cards so it's five cards at the bottom looks like a triangle like three in the middle one on top yeah uh you're trying to make a circle uh you're trying you're trying to make W yeah sort of but you're making a wedge you're making a triangle or like a pyramid but anyways uh in the beginning you can all of the C words on each card are available to you but then when you finish your first row at the bottom row of this triangle and now you're on to level two and getting three cards there you can only use the red and yellow words uh so each card has green word yellow word red word and then when you

reach the very top and you need to finish the top you can only look at the red words so as the game goes there's like this it starts to limit you in terms of like I don't have threee choices it's a catchup mechanism so if someone gets really ahead they have fewer and fewer choices but everyone has that so it doesn't feel unfair uh it just gets like helps people catch up and then it get makes it for a very exciting conclusion because at the end you you can only look at one of the words on the cards as setad of all three while other people might be looking at multiple words so it's a really quick easy thing that's like visually easy to understand people understand it and it's a it just balances out the game really easily uh I'm going to say one more just because it's also about losts of but it's different to my previous one which is that game does an exceptionally good job of rewarding you for everything you do like you go to a space you get some stuff you kill a monster you not only get some victory points but also now you have an ability you you research something you get some stuff like you buy a card you get to use it like everything you do rewards you it's uh one of my one of my fellow game designers calls it candy games like everything you do gives you candy you do this you get candy do this you get candy do this you get candy and it's just uh that game I think doesn't like you can think of a few who do it but that game I think just does an exceptionally good job of just throwing candy at you at all times just a great game I just love it my final quick things I think would be my sweet spot for an expansion is the Marine world's expansion for Arc Nova like i' i' played it twice but I still love the base game I have play it so many so many times but the expansion

does it so well for people who have played the base game it adds just enough of a tweak to the game that makes it exciting because you get to switch out your basic action cards for two slightly different action cards they're a little bit more powerful um even on the or at least different they give you a different little bonus thing for your main action and then when you upgrade it it's even cooler um and then of course you get instead of the little cubes you get little um animal that you can put out for a conservation project so even on an aesthetic sort of side it's like everything's a little bit nicer looking because you can replace the old pieces with that um and you've got this brand new type of animal type so for the people who have been like like me I recognize almost all of the cards on the base game now I've played it a lot but here you have all these exciting like marine animals and they have this add added fun little washing mechanic that gets you through more cards because they added more cards uh so I just think they they did a really great job on this EXP expansion it's like my favorite expansion I have so yeah amazing okay and now moving on to uh your topic of course Peter what's your topic my topic is games you love in a genre you hate that's the phrasing I came up with all by myself and it's excellent phrasing thank you full credit to me uh so my example for this one is it's actually probably not not a very well-known game it's flea by Freedman freeze uh flee is part of um fast forward series he loves the letter F this man and and the fast forward series uh okay so first of all

it's a Cooperative game it's one to four players so you can play it solo you can play it Co-op I have done both I don't like co-op games I don't like solo games and yet I've played this game in both forms I just I I can't even fully explain it I just love this game uh it's Alison Wonderland theme but it's the loosest theme in the world and the thing that that flee or the whole fast forward series does is you open the box and it's just a deck of cards speaking of games with Incredible setup um it is a a preset order set set of cards and there's no rule book there's no other pieces it's just this deck of cards and nothing else so you flip the first card and it says hey here's here's what you're trying to do in the game flip the next card you flip the next one it says great here's some of the basic rules flip a few more cards and then you're playing and as and the goal of the game is to get to the bottom of the deck you win the game if you can reach the bottom of that deck and I don't know if it's mathematically impossible but it's pretty much impossible to do it in one game so you'll get uh you know and the cards will do stuff so uh there's a monster and you lose the game if the current player has the monster in front of them at the start of their turn so the whole game is moving the monster around so you know if if we're going clockwise and it's me then Christina and the monster in front of Christina I need to get that monster away from her otherwise you're about to lose or I need to reverse the turn order and those are both options or I need to skip her turn and so there's all these little tools that you can do to use it uh to to to get rid of it I just got that flea is fle e e and not e a flea oh you got to and it's a little tiny box it's just a big deck of Taro siiz cards which are a little bit bigger than normal poiz cards

and it's so dry and mechanical and my girlfriend who will play anything with me won't play it cuz it's just too much reading and too much like mechanical for her but for whatever reason it exactly perfectly nests into my brain and I just want to solve it I just want to solve that puzzle so if you're playing four if you're playing solo you have to play all four players if you're playing two players you take two each if you're playing three you take one person takes two Etc um so it is the least like it it it my issue with Cooperative games is I'm like why do you need to be here why do I need to be here yeah if I'm the best player I should be playing by myself if you're the best player you should be playing by yourself we don't need to work together on this I'm not a Cooperative game kind of person um I like Cooperative party games so like your code name's duet or whatever where it's about like looking into the other person's eyes and and reading them but games like pandemic or Forbidden Island I think they're very welld designed just not for me at all except for flea I love it I love it I love it I love it I don't know why oh was need to check it out is it a current game that's like I don't even know honestly I got it about I got in 2016 and I've moved countryes since then and I've downsize my game several time and every time I keep it cuz a cuz it's a tiny box which goes a long way and B cuz I'm like even if I only play it once a year I will play it once a year like I just I just really like it okay yeah or yeah we'll play your copy yeah i' I've finished it multiple times so there's nothing new in there for me but I still just like the puzzle okay that's that's says a lot yeah what about you sh uh okay so I

typically I don't like a lot of games that are like uh Miniatures that are moving on a grid on a map like Christina it's where it's kind of like I think I thought you liked it more than I do I do like it more than you but I we don't have a lot part of it is like I I should preface this by saying like uh as a gaming couple Christine and I I think uh her preferences influence my preferen she's like if she's like I'm just really not into this kind of game uh we don't play it as often and then I'm not as interested it just we kind of build upon each other so like there's she influences a lot of what we like because we'll play games together uh but anyways uh she's not a big fan and it's so i' not a big fan of these games where it's like tactical movement of like okay I can move three spaces I can see this far is that person I'm trying to shoot uh within my line of sight is this thing blocking line of sight and those kind of really tactical military style games I'll play video games like that but I don't like board games like that generally um but there's one that I thought uh was done really well was level seven Omega protocol uh it's an older game and there's a level seven Series so if you're looking for this make sure you get this right one it's Omega protocol uh generally regarded as the best one in its series but uh the basic idea you can kind of think of setting kind of like aliens like the mov mov Series where it's like okay there's a team of Marines they might go there's a campaign there's several missions but uh the team of aliens or sorry the team of Marines are playing against the kind

of uh Alien creature uh or this uh it's not really an alien it's kind of a more Area 51 kind of vibe but anyways so you two might be playing together and the mission will vary from uh scenario to scenario but one might be like you have to go into this facility extract some information from a computer and then get out safely with us information uh but you're moving soldiers around you might like okay my guy can move three spaces and he could shoot this weapon and you find other weapons to start upgrade uh but what's cool about it is every action uh that you two do gives me action points so you the the more things you two try to do in a turn the more things I get to do uh on my turn and then uh so me as the kind of the overseer or the enemy will have this whole box of like all these different things like I can uh spawn more monsters I could cause a cave in U I could cause uh this disruption thing I have all these different powers varying by scenario and then this might cost me three action points this might cost me two action points this might cost me five and so the more you two are doing I just like okay you're giving me all this money to spend how I want to or to really mess with you back so it's very well balanced very thematic like I played a game a long time ago with a few friends and then uh that exact scenario that I just described where you're trying to extract some information the only uh uh condition is to get someone has to exit the facility with that information no one everyone doesn't have to live otherwise but one of our friends she fell in combat and she she was basically

like just go like we can win just go on without me and then my other friend and I were looking at we're like we can't do it it's it's like thematically it's like we can't leave one of our soldiers so we went to make sure she got healed Carri her out with us so we could all win together we didn't need to but it's just thematic it's just overall just a really cool Vibe uh like this whole back and forth Action System is just so awesome uh so that's one of the an example of a game I don't think I would normally play but this one is just really welld designed that's cool H for me let's see I think one of the fun ones that I do play a lot and on the surface just sounds like it should not be my thing it is uh Rumble nation and it's this game from Japan that is area control sort of battle and dice chucking and you're like w that does not sound like a game that I would like it's such an interesting weird little game it is and so I guess in that part it's exactly what I like weird little games um the dice tracking is really just three Dice and then you actually get to make a decision from your three dice you're grouping them into a group of Two and a solo and the two sum up to the region where you're going to place your troops while your single die tells you how many basically one to three troops so you're constantly balancing like positional sort of strategy versus like the numbers of troops because in the the first phase is you're just dumping all your troops onto the board using mostly this dice mechanism and then the sooner

you go out the more Advantage you have in ties but at the same time if you take your time maybe you can like happen to put yourself in more valuable positions then the really cool part on the second part is like during the battle phase where everything battles there's a randomized order to the battle where the earlier battles are worth fewer points but if you win an early battle you get to reinforce all adjacent regions that have your color so you're like winding up this spring and I think it was Kellen from board game barrage who first told us about this game and he's like you're spending the first phase winding up this spring hoping it will spring in the way that you want it to um so it's like really fun super quick um on the surface nothing that I would normally like but totally my jam actually and I didn't know the the the Second Hand of romulation if I remember correctly it's completely deterministic right like you don't actually make choices so it reminds me of fantasy Realms like that in that this that's essentially just an extended scoring phase but it's as engaging as the first half like I'm not even kidding like it when when I first played it I was like o what's going to happen next and you can actually look ahead and see what's going to happen next you could theoretically math the whole thing out but there's just this level of like chaos theory to it where it's like you can't quite because something will come oh I I really enjoyed that game I thought that game was super interesting it's really the lower numbers cuz as you said they reinforce every adjacent neighbor so your troop on one can be used multiple times your troop on 12 is only going to be used once at the very end and so getting a bunch of low numbers is actually good because now you can reinforce one oh yeah it does so many

things cleverly I I almost picked that up after I played it yours um I I have a very strict two shelf limit uh so I did not but I was very tempted uh that it's it's just clever it's just like seven clever ideas all tied in together uh-huh and it's like so easy to teach so I love that game and so whenever I my joke is I was I think I ran into I don't remember who I made play at one of the Strategic cons but I was like oh you hate dice games and you hate area control okay you're playing this game I don't know just it's just going to happen I I was excited this topic uh because a lot of my a few of my games have been designed as X for people who don't like X so you know that time you killed me is the abstract for people who don't like abstracts and my old Dracula Feast was a social deduction game for people who don't like social deduction and even even uh French toast to a certain point like some people like I don't like party games I'm like play this and they're like okay I like this one and and I've done this long enough to know when people are just being nice uh so yes and so any other games that come to mind for this topic for you ooh uh I had I had my one prepared and then not much past that that was your one that was that was my big one yeah I I really I've I don't like I don't dislike many genres of games like I will happily play a drawing game or a three-hour strategy or a two-player uh you know 4minute game um but solo Co-op oh no I do have one sorry I remember now um the three types of games that I will typically say ah I'll pass uh solo games I mean why would I

need to sell someone else on passing and playing by myself pure co-ops so like your pandemics your that kind of thing like uh is that going to come through on the video when I when I do this I get I get yeah I don't know for the audio people Peter just made a bunch of balloons appeared on his screen learn from using uh this that every every time I I apparently count to two in my fingers a lot cuz every time I do balloons come up that's so weird I don't know what's called um wait you just put two fingers up and it made balloons pop up yeah it seems to only be me though I don't know why what is going on anyways I don't know I don't know if other symbols will do it um so yeah SOLO games pure Cooperative games and performance games or or no not not performance games as much as like one person is going to judge and pick the winner like your cards against Humanities um but there are actually two of those games that I really like one of them I own and we'll play any time the other one I will say yes to if it comes out on the table the one I'll say yes to is red flags because it's so personal like so in that game you are setting up a date for for like someone let's say shoes it at the moment we're all going to set up a date for shoe by picking some positive qualities from our hands so mine might be loves board games and uh uh know knows how to cook or whatever like and and and if um whereas Christina if you picked for me like loves dogs I'd be like well I don't actually love dogs that's a bad

pick for me so you're trying to impress the the host you're trying to pick the best date for the host but then everyone plays a red flag a negative attribute to the player to their left and so you're trying to create a deal breaker so that they will pick yours instead of someone else's and it's so simple and I think a lot of those games turn into like who drew the funniest card whereas this one is you know it can be a funny card but if it doesn't actually Target Christina then it's not going to work um so red flag is one but the one that I own and recommend to everyone all the time is smug owls have you played this one no I've heard of it I don't remember I play next time next time you guys have a have me over I will bring smals it is a game of of riddles so you random only draw three cards so it could be and it always starts with what and ends with a question mark so it could be what is fast unless it is fragile and so the idea is that you're all ponderous owls sitting around going like hm what is fast unless it is fragile everyone slams their hand down when they have an answer not not in a Speedway just like to show that you've got an answer the last person to put their hand down becomes the judge so to begin with that's just a really clever thing because if you don't have one cool you get to judge everyone else you still get to play and there's not this pressure of like I didn't have a good one but now everyone's looking at me and the second thing it does well so you can answer very literally you can answer very metaphorically um you know you could say I don't know a rocket it's going to be very fast unless it's fragile in which case it's not going to go or you could say uh you know a well

adjusted um a well adjusted racer they're going to be really fast except for the day where they're they're fragile and they're not feeling it whatever you know you can you can go as literal or metaphorical or p or however you like uh and then the judge gives out the three cards that were formed to make that riddle so they're not just picking a winner they can be like that was so good you get all three or all all of those are good you get one or you get two and you get one and it's just all of these little micro decisions in the design add up to one of the most fun experiences I've the most fun experience I've ever had with like a there's a judge game I really I really like smug Al so I was actually at an event with Alex Cutler who's my co designer on critic kitchen and everyone was playing this kind of Cards Against Humanity Style game and I and they were like Peter come play this I was like ah thank you I'll pass and they're like no seriously Peter seriously come play this and I was like okay friend and two of them were the designers so I felt so bad cuz I was going to sit down and be like H yeah cool you sure made a thing that I hate and I went out went out and bought a copy immediately like I love it and not just because I know the designers yeah so smug anded flags are two in that genre that I hate actively hate but I love I love snug Al and I I I don't own red flags but I'll happily play that anytime especially with people I know that was kind of like uh my other my next pick was going to be uh Sky Team where uh we were at an event for uh hasette games at Gen Con uh that was one the the the uh parent publisher but

anyways uh they were like oh it's a two-player only Cooperative game and I'm like uh so it's it's not that we're against two-player games it's just Christine and I host so much we always have friends over locally or like you're ather have friends every everyone play games has no friends count right now yeah so we we don't have a lot of uh time or energy just for Just the Two of Us playing games uh but anyways uh so that's a no no and then we're also not big Cooperative fans like uh like you for reasons that you've said yeah we had a actual full episode with our friend bonds uh who also hate actively hates corpor we talked all about this topic so you can look for that a couple few episodes ago but uh Sky team is one big exception for me I'm like this is really cool because uh and we talked a lot about it so I won't get into it but basically there's a pilot co-pilot you have to land a plane you to make sure like the runway's clear radio into the tower to make sure the runway's clear of other planes your your plane uh is tilted leled out so one Wing's not lower than the other by the time you land uh you have to make sure your speed is just right that you're putting up the flaps in the landing gear just right and this is all done via dice you both will roll dice you'll discuss a strategy then you roll the dice then you have to place these dice like certain dice without collaborating anymore yeah so certain dice can only go into certain spaces too uh some are mandatory some are not so uh

it didn't that's basically it but the idea why it's so clever for me is a Co-op game is once you roll the dice it can't talk anymore you can only place the dice so there's a lot of like there's no quarterbacking like at all so similar to another that we like that too yeah uh a lot of vad shado games coming up today in this episode favorite designer I will I'll do a whole episode on vad Shadle if you let me so you no like think about it no trying to trying to make us look stupid we'll be like oh yeah yeah we know yeah of course everyone knows that yeah we host a board game podcast we know but uh yeah the is Sky Team set in the future and does it have meeples it's a modern day airplane game airplane theme you're Landing in Han airport Etc ET so but anyways uh the the whole idea is because you can't talk during the dice placement part uh similar to another Coop game we like uh the crew is uh it forces you to it takes away that whole quarterbacking problem of like who's the best player they just know what to do right it's just like all right I'm going to place this and I hope Christina understands why I did this and then we we the order that you play it in the order matters hopefully she'll play something moving pictures from buttony no I have a copy I'll bring them next time I play it's a a two-player Co-op where there's no communication so it's sort of like the mind and in fact

you're trying to get your cards in order but thematically speaking you're you're making a movie so you've got six face down cards you've got three cards each and you win if you can place those six cards in order but every card has a power on it so uh for example the 15 uh it goes from 1 through 16 I think um and the 15 is you may show your opponent this card not your opponent your your fellow Co-op player uh and and the one is you can only play it to the left of a card that's already been played stuff like that so they're very restricted and it's a little bit like what you're talking about you have to not only be like oh they play the car but like why did they play that card there and why did they play that card now um there there's a couple up in Toronto two of my close friends uh who it's so funny one of them is so logical and one of them is so emotional and and neither is better or worse than the other and so we're playing uh what's the game with the marbles the the logic programming game oh gizmos no it's a Cooperative um it's by John schelter and Sarah gyel and the name is completely blanking on like break the code code Breakers or break the code or or Pass the Pigs or something like that um and yeah crack the code it's called crack the code and crack the code uh so you're basically you're playing sorry I'm going to too much detail for a tangent off a tangent um you're trying to get your marbles in the right order and playing with those two was so funny because the the my friend who's very emotional will be like in real life hey when I asked you to empty the bin you know I was not

actually asking you to empty the bin I was actually asking you this and and and her partner will be like how how was I me how is anyone meant to know that how is it possible just say the thing that you want don't expect me to read three steps in and then we're playing this logic game and it's exactly reversed she's like I'm going to put this marble here and and her partner staring at her being like H it sounds like I meant to know something from that but you've told me nothing and we're sitting here being like no it's inductive reasoning she's saying I did this one not this one for this reason for this reason and and and so it's funny to see the exact same conversation at two opposite extremes when it's in a game or out of a game yeah this is making me realize that those are the co-op games I like I think like hanabe which is the you you don't know what hand you have your cards are facing away from people but you're giving Clues to different people on the table and then you have to read into why do they give me that clue at this time because they want me to play a certain card or not play a my great contribution to the world of board game design is the concept of there's two types of Cooperative games I did a whole episode of this on board game lab um and it actually was part of my Visa application and I got in the country so it's uh it's legit uh there's two types of Cooperative games there's limited communication and there's against the game and there's sometimes a little bit of overlap but against the game is like Spirit Island pandemic where it's just you against the game limited communication is where the game is can you communicate through limited situation mhm uh and so I love limited Comm communication co-ops and except for

flea I cannot stand against the game co-ops oh yeah yeah that's that's a good way to break it down I never realized but that's yeah those are when I do like coops it's usually coop coop has a really like down the line down down the middle divide that people just don't think about mhm yeah there was another division that Max from um resm games was talking about in our previous episode too that I was like oh that was like it was similar but slightly different about like the control you have whether people can take take control of of what you are doing versus like you know because if it's too much collaboration where anybody could tell you to do what what they want you to do that's going to lead to that quarterbacking where if you have a more agency or if there's just enough complication to the game where nobody can math out what you you need to do like in spirit Island even though it's against you know against the game then you you feel like you have more agency there's less of that quarterbacking because everybody's focused on their own thing you know Spirit Island's uh technique to to combat quarterbacking was just complexity same same as sentence Multiverse same publisher um you could theoretically play someone else's hand in sentence Multiverse but there's too many things to keep track of so you realistically can't um whereas yeah some games will just be like look you don't know what they have or you don't know what they know like cod names D is my example there's no loss condition external to you it's if you make a mistake you lose you can never draw a bad card and lose from codenames duet I love codenames duet um the that's really interesting

yeah uh so we found out we like more things than we thought we hated so there we go it's I don't I don't know yeah I don't know what it is about these like sometimes you'll just find a game where it's like even though I shouldn't like you you you've wormed your way into my heart and uh I I I think yeah there's some there's some uh resistance to it but then it does something else so right like I don't know let's say I didn't like people who like dogs but they were in into board games so much that I was like you know what I will love you anyway I'll be over thanks so much for joining us Peter today um you know we are excited to find out new exciting games that are coming out so where can people follow you and what you're up to I'm actually not on social media as much any days uh as much these days Instagram Instagram is where I live I guess Peter C Haywood h y Ward I post on there all the time mostly book reviews frankly so if you if you don't know what I've been reading 3 years ago that's that's way to find out have been following that and then of course uh you can find out any upcoming games on Board Game Geek sometimes you know you've got lots of announcements coming out things like that uh gigantic thanks to our editor Mike Zipkin and again this is one of those reminders shoe that you haven't posted our quiz show from BG con back in November I actually ran it we had a snow cabin weekend this past weekend I ran it for our board game friends and they had a lot of fun so I'm just guilting you further to

remember and our listeners thanks for listening to us hope you liked our episode please give us a like And subscribe if you haven't already and now you can stop listening and go play a game bye bye bye

Progress saved