Skip to main content
Loading video...

The 2025 American Tabletop Awards (guest: What's Eric Playing?) | Ep 152

Transcript 56:58

Hey everybody, welcome to the Going Analog Podcast. The show where board game industry guests bring their own topics and games to discuss. But today there will be only one topic. Only one. Okay, one topic. So I'm Christina, your host. And if you're tuning in to hear about the best games ever, then you're in luck because we are going to talk about the American Tabletop Awards. They were announced super recently, right? Like we're very timely about that. We're right on time. Right at the start of 2025. Yes. Yes. Um, so we are behind on everything and stop stressing us out. But anyway, we're getting to it and since we we just we just moved. We just moved. We just moved. We had to take about a two-month break from the show to get settled in, find all our equipment and everything. So, it's been a mess on our end. Yes. But we are as Going Analog a part of the selection committee for the American Tabletop Awards. So, we wanted to do our traditional deep dive into this year the 2025 American Tabletop Award winners, nominees, and recommended games. So, you can go and see the full list also on American Tabletopaw Awards.com. So, we have asked content creator Eric Jüko of What's Eric Playing and one of the main organizers of the atas to discuss with us. So, hi Eric.

Hello. Thanks for having me. Yes. So, we have Eric here today. We just found out on what about 3 hours of sleep or so. Honestly, less. Oh, man. Staying up all night playing games. So, uh, right. Truly was like, "Okay, I'm going to bed at 2:00 a.m. Check my phone. Ah, I can go to bed at 4:00. Saw the sun coming up. Was like, "Ah, I think I'm pushing it." It hit like 7:30 and I was like, "Okay, I think I need to find a stopping point." Yeah. Yeah. And that was 6:00 a.m. What are you like 14 years old? He can do He's an adult. He gets to do this. It's If if I was going to pick any time to do it, the Saturday night of a long weekend is probably the best time to do it cuz I don't have plans. I don't really have a whole lot going on otherwise. Like I have a friend coming over later today to play a bunch of board games. Um but my Monday is pretty open. So Okay. Yeah. Yeah, it is. This was not important enough. So, you know, it's Hey, I showed up mostly on time. I was 2 minutes late.

So, Shu also remembered to ask for my opinion on voting this year, so he gets to be here with us this year. Yep. Yeah. Yeah. So, are we vote as one? Uh, we only count as one vote, but we work together on that vote. So, it's a shared vote between us. Thanks. Thanks. Mhm. On our wedding anniversary, he has to say this mostly. We mostly agreed on pretty much a lot of things but not not 100%. Remember our our discussions. That is one thing I like about how the jury the jured system works is that most of the time it's just the perils of democracy and me shaking my fist and being like that's not what I would have picked. We picked a good crop of games. I'm not mad about it, but you know, everyone's got their personal favorites. Yeah. So, as a quick background, um why don't we have you discuss how how we have the selection committee pick these games? We went through several rounds. And so what was that? What is how do you organize that, Eric? And we just do what you tell us.

If you do what I tell you, the results might have been different. Uh there's no money involved. So it's not going to truly um no. So um how the how the system works is and we've gotten some questions about this in the past, but uh as you all know, there are a lot of content creators and a lot of folks working in different roles in the industry, different hats. We want to prevent conflicts of interest. So, how the system works for us is there's a nomination process and then two rounds of voting. Every person is allowed to submit five games in each category during a nomination process. To prevent conflicts of interest, we ask people who have any connection to a game, if they're, you know, an artist, a designer, a developer, if they work for the company, to not submit any game that they have a conflict of interest with during that nomination process. And then during round one, we have this incredibly annoying table list. Yes, there is. I have tried. There is not a better way to do it really. Um, but we have a big list of games. And so the goal there is to rank order those games.

Uh, rank everything that you've played, everything that you're excited about. And then we get essentially a smaller like final list of about 8 to 10 games in each category. and uh we'll do one final round of voting. The visibility on the like committee voting side is relatively simple. All you have to do is submit five games for nomination, rank order a list, rank order a second list, and then we've got our uh winners recommended nominated games. The interesting thing too is like because obviously with our categories, there's early gamers, casual games, um strategy games, and then complex games. there's going to be a bunch of games where people categorize them differently. So there was a time where we could say like there was an opinion asked about like where do you think this might go? So that sort of helps too and and this is what we arrived at and I I like the process. Yeah. It's the fundamental nature of taxonomic organization, right?

Like there is no there is no one rule that will satisfy every single person for where a game belongs in terms of like is it a good game for people that are getting into gaming? Is it a good like casual game night game? Does it have some like nice depth of strategy to it? And is it like a heavier like meteor game? And so you're going to have some like overlap to that stratification. Real quick before we get into the first category. So we each category has a winner, a recommended, a few games and recommended and a few games in nominated. Can you explain the difference between recommended and nominated for the audience? Absolutely can. So, um, basically what we wanted to do is we wanted to have, um, you know, a couple different tiers of things because there's just I mean, you all know there's so many good games every year.

You write down was so hard. Yeah. And so, like, if this is our pick for best game of the year in this category, how you're just going to always feel a little bit left like you're going to feel like there's something missing there. So, we wanted to have another another tier that was like, you know, these are games that we still think are very worth playing and then nominated is like, hey, these games are also a lot of fun and we think you should check these out, too. And so having a little bit of a wider spread for each um for each category also means that people's preferences still get to be represented in some way. And you get a nice find some new games. Yeah. And you get a nice mix of mechanics. You get a nice mix of themes. Like even looking at some of these, the themes are kind of pretty varied. Mhm. Which I love. Yeah.

So, let's let's dive into it. So, for early gamers, the winner was Captain Flip. Um, also nominated were Caution Signs and Monkey Palace. And recommended were Flip 7 and Rhino Hero XXL. So, I actually remember playing Captain Flip with you, Eric Jüko, on on uh Board Game Arena. So, we played a lot of games in a row of it. Um, which I thought I would get tired of, but not really. It's such a quick, interesting game. We played a lot of different maps. So, in this game, it's very simple game designed by uh Bruno Cathala and Antoine Bowser. You have the computer, I think. I'm pretty sure. Um, I should have written all of this down. I believe it's Remo Considori and Palo Mori. Totally wrong. Totally wrong. I say I say I believe like I'm not looking it up on this thing right here. So I I happen to have it handy on a I've had another monitor cooking the whole time. Yes. Yes. Yes.

So, it is just like you are a captain of a pirate ship and you have all these different characters that are uh on your ship, but they all have slightly different ways that they score or their different action power powers. Um, and then depending on where you place your person, you can place the uh crew member or you flip them. But when you flip them, you don't know what they're going to be and they could in fact detract from your score or have some interesting unexpected effects. Um, so on the surface, it's like a very simple choice. Um, on your when on your turn, you're just taking a tile and or flipping it and placing it. Um, but the combination of the different maps and the way they interact and how you may affect um, you know, what other people's choices are can be really had a lot of variety. It's been a while since I've played it, but I played so many games in a row of it and I didn't really get tired of it. So, you can also blow yourself up, which I think is just one of the one of the highlights of it. If you the there's a tile, the gunner, that gives you five points, which is a fair bit in Captain Flip, but if you have three of them on your board at the end of the game, uh you lose.

There are also tiles that can flip other tiles. Yeah, too many guns. Uh there are tiles that can flip other tiles, so you can go for a dangerous play of having three gunners face up, but then try to flip one of them later so that you don't uh lose the game immediately. But it's very fun trying to balance out that like press your luck thing. And the theme is nice and whimsical. It's very colorful. Play punk is also new publisher. They have Zenith coming this year. It's been a lot of fun as well. So, no, Captain Flop has been a favorite. Mhm. Oh, what would you have voted for or what did you would you been your pick for winner? Well, the big one that we played the most of was definitely Flip Seven. So, um and also it was it's a really quick card game. We've talked about it on our podcast before. Um, but it's basically a pusher luck. Uh, blackjack is already pusher luck, I guess, but a take on that where you're just hitting at adding extra cards and trying not to uh bust.

If you get any double of a regular card, you will bust, but you're at the same time rewarded for going for higher and higher points. Um, but then the higher the points, the more likely that card exists in the deck. So, they're 1212s, 111s, etc. Um, and they add this little fun a couple little twists that still make it very easy to play. Um, but sort of up that that tension because you can also if you get exactly seven of the standard cards, then you immediately end the round. You get a bunch of bonus points. Um, and it's very exciting. So, we always push people to try to flip seven. I'm currently playing a deeply unholy version of it, which is I'm playing it asynchronously on board Game Arena with a couple friends. And so, Every gamer flip seven takes about a month.

So like once once a week once everyone finally gets around taking their turn, I get to flip one single card and I'm like I feel like essentially like a Victorian orphan just being like please can I have seven points? It just went on to board game Marina and so um I just started a game two with like I don't know six seven players but the issue was my very first card was a freeze. So I'm like, who am I going to screw over immediately and have them have no cards? So there are these fun action cards. They're going to sign in and find out they got no cards. So you pat them on the face and you're like, "Thank you for playing." Yes. Yeah. I think it's a game you need to play either in real time or in person. Yeah. Yeah. super super fun where you get to like, you know, egg each other on and then of course one of the action cards you can force somebody or give it to yourself and force yourself to draw three cards in a row which makes it even more likely that you may bust and everybody laughs at you. So yeah. What about you? Uh same. My pick for early gamers game is uh Flip 7. Uh although I don't I'm not mad about Captain Flip winning. That was a great game as well. The other one uh I want to give a shout out to is uh Caution Signs. We played a lot of that game this year. Probably probably besides Flip 7, our number one played or number two played party game this year.

That was my game of the light game of the year or party game of the year I believe for going analog. Caution S was a very pleasant surprise. I think I played it I think I played like a very quick like round of it in passing at maybe packs unplugged and I remember being like oh there's something to be fair drawing party games is like I think one of the like the what is it like a dark horse genre. I think it's like I think it's very underrated as a genre of of games. Underrated. I don't know. I think Okay. I think it's underrated. I think people scoff at them very quickly and then really yes because I remember seeing costumes I was like oh it's another drawing game but the little twists in the design are like really great that you only have like 10 to 20 seconds depending on like how difficult 20 seconds 20 seconds I played it once with 10 seconds which was ridiculous just for fun. Um, so that just forces you to be really efficient and hilarious in how you draw and be way more creative than just like, "Hey, who draws the best horse?" Nobody cares, you know? That's not what we're here for.

It's actually that's actually the design of my next party game. It's called Who Draws the Best Horse? And that's that's all it is. It's just the title. It's a spin-off of the classic Robinsburgger Hundreds of Horsesh. M. Mhm. But, you know, it it also is just it's nice to play um games where you don't need to be quote unquote good at drawing. Yes. Cuz it hearkens back to like I think fantastic and classic party games like Monstrosity or A Fake Artist Goes to New York where it's like those are games that are kind of in my uh in my scope of like ah if I'm going to a party and I need to bring party games that are going to be crowd-pleasers. These are the ones that I would bring. I think adding caution signs to that pool is not a bad move though. It is a very It seems like it would be a very big hit at game night. Yeah, it is. We should mention I the it's not just a game about drawing quickly. Like the twist is you you draw one card is an adjective and one card's the object and then so you as a drawer you're going to combine those two things. So for example, I might get angry fireman or a static duck or something like that, right? So, got and then everyone at the table has 20 seconds to draw these. You shuffle all the adjectives together uh and then lay them out and then all the object cards together and lay them out and then add a couple more as kind of dummy red herring cards and then the guesser has to kind of take all the drawings at the table and then figure out which adject adjectives and objects go where. But because you only have 20 seconds, the drawings are so bad that is it leaves a lot of room for yourself, a lot of room

for interpretation. give me 5 minutes and my drawing would not be significantly better. Whenever I draw something, someone's like, "Oh my gosh, your child is really bad at art." And I'm like, it's tough. It's tough feedback. But that's the best type for drawing games, you know. Of course, my favorite favorite drawing game if you have enough people is teleustrations where it's just telephone pictionary. And so I like drawing well, but also I it's not fun if everybody draws well. And I'd rather have some really crappy draws in there to make it interesting, which caution science encourages. So, it's agreed. How about you, Eric? What was your was your pick captain flip? My pick was Captain Flip. Captain Flip is I think I've played I think I've played a hundred or two uh games of it. Like I just It's just one of those games. It's up there with like I really like a genre of game where you could essentially be like, "Hey, go to hell. We're going again." And so like Captain Flip is very easy to do that because you just swipe the board, dump everything back in the bag, and you're like, we go, we we play until I win. It's like it's it's the perfect kind of game for like a lunchtime. Like it has the same kind of it has the same ease of play as some of my favorite games like Santorini. And I am a very very big fan of like push your luck as a competitive like a competitive modality.

So Flip 7 was also a big pick for me. Honestly, like any of the games in this in this set of five I think is really really fun. I would like to give a special shout out to like Monkey Palace just because as far as like it is a little bit I would argue it's a little bit on the higher level of complexity for this category just because it has like some deck building and engine building components. For those of you who don't know, Monkey Palace is a Lego uh a Lego board game where you're actually like building and constructing pieces of a of a palace, not cooperatively, but with the other players. Like you're building off of what they've done before to get certain levels of height, certain points, certain placements, and you end up with this really cool like collaborative structure every time you play that's always different. It's a really cool game and it's a great introduction to concepts like engine building and figuring out how you want to like set your cards so you're getting the right number of pieces so that you can build out this big palace. Like super cool. I like it a lot. I think it's a really cool like um Have I mentioned I thought it was cool? But uh Okay. Yeah. Uh I I think that for a like for a modern board game take from Lego, there's a lot of really fun stuff happening there.

And then of course, let's get to caution games. It's caution games. Casual games. I got caught talking about you were just really hyped about caution signs again and I don't blame you. Yeah. So casual games we have for nominated chronologic Paris 1920, Castle Combo. For recommended, we have River Valley Glass Works and Far Away. And the winner was the gang um which is a cooperative poker game which we just talked about with Dominic Crepeets uh in our last podcast our last episode and we have played a lot of the gang too. So ever since Gen Con of last year we've been carrying that around showing it to a lot of people. Um yeah we I think of course any poker pe enthusiast will have an entryway into it. Um, and it's also been really fun to sort of, it's one of those games where you probably will fail the first time with a new group of people and but then you can immediately try again. So, you are trying to rob a bank um successfully three times, which is weird. They should increase their security. And I guess they sort of do.

It's three tries. Three tries. Three tries. But you're supposed to do three successful heists to win. Um, but if you get caught three times, you lose as a team. And yeah, it's the three strikes rule for bank robbery. They're like, "Hey, stop that." And you're like, "I can't." Just addicted to it. Um, and you're you're basically playing regular poker except we instead of trying to win and bet as you're winning, you are trying to figure out who what the final order of um least to mo most powerful poker hands by the end. And so if you successfully guess that together as a team, then you have heisted that vault. So that's basically the game. And it's been super easy to show to a lot of people. People enjoy it. They fail. They want to try again. Uh I've played a lot of the game, especially at cons, too. It's a really easy game to play uh as you're waiting for people to show up or uh in between other heavier games and stuff. So, yeah, very much agreed. You also get to learn how bad people are at valuing poker hands. Like I have maybe I I really like the gang. I have two complaints about it. One of them is they give you a little player aid card that ranks poker hands, but they're not ranked uh what's the name for it? Probability or Yeah.

They don't show you the actual relative probability of it. So people think uh I only I've only got two pair or I've only got three of a kind. There are so many hands that are better than this. I'll I'll rank myself pretty low and you're like you understand that most poker hands are garbage, right? And then uh it is it like like the crew before it. It is fascinating how much more difficult it gets with more players. Like that difficulty spike going like this cuz at three players it's relatively you know it's not easy all the time. But we've we definitely got through all we were playing a game where we just kept playing until we had gotten through all of the um when you successfully heist you can play with a variant that makes the game harder every time. And so we got through all of those cards at three players. At five players, we were desperate to like successfully win a round.

Um, and that's been the fun part like when we have a lot of people at a con. I played this at Dice Tower West with like five, six people and it was just got insane to the point where like can we just win one? Can we just win one? Um, but that one win is very rewarding. So satisfying. Yes. And it's also like the right people. When you're at a con, we're like, "These people really want to win and so we're going to make this happen." Um, so it's very exciting. Yeah. It's also really interesting how much it inherits from like like from like the mind, a game that some people like, I don't particularly care for, but like it has a lot of the same DNA there, but there's a little bit more structure to how the play works. And I think basing it on like that Texas Holde is kind of fun. It feels like it's also you could probably make more variants of it.

So like when I play poker I really like Omaha. So you have a four card pocket and I think that would be a fun variant to try with the gang as well just to see how like a fourcard pocket changes the valuation for like people's it' make the game a lot more difficult. Yeah, I'm pretty sure I'm sure somebody will have that online or it'd be funny to see what I guess I assume if they do expansions it'll be more of those sort of like uh variant twists of in the box it has I don't remember how they did it but I think it's like the Joker variant oh yeah addresses other types of poker so I think it's like built in somehow but I we've only played the regular game with Texas Hold there's a lot there's a lot of base game in that base game so like I it's not like ever going to get bored of it. It's just mostly me being like, "Ah, I do miss having four card pocket." H What about were there any other games here? Would you have was that the your winner that you wanted for casual games, Eric? You know, I and I'm I know I'm going to keep coming back to this point.

I'm not mad about any of this. Like this year, like this year, and in previous years, I'm very pleased with what we've collectively arrived at. I will say that I I very much enjoy chronologic Paris 1920. Like I I love a deduction game. I think there's a lot of like fun in the in Chronologic, you're kind of you're trying to figure out the movement of other players and there's certain amounts of like information that you get. But the system that I really like is um when you ask questions, you're asking questions of the game itself. So you can't replay the same scenario multiple times because it's it's once you've cracked it, you've cracked it. But the information that I get might be like, oh, the journalist was in, you know, the opera room at time 3 and everyone else gets like, oh, at, you know, I think like a person was in the opera room at time 3. So, you get to learn a everyone gets a little bit of information, but only the person who asked the question gets essentially the most useful information, which I think is very fun. It's really clever. So, it's the same designers who did touring machine. Um, and it but it's like way paired down in the way that they you get your information or ask the question, but it's still really clever. You just have like a set of cards per scenario and then you put this little like cardboard overlay onto it. So, as the as the uh asker, you get your special information, you tell everybody else the other one, and it's just like way better clue. So, love this game. So much fun. I

I just like I like so much about it. And like I mean if I think about touring machine for too long it starts to hurt my brain because like it's one of those things I look at I'm like how did they make this? Yes. We had a whole episode on that but I do love touring machine. Mhm. What about you? Uh that was my pick. I I was I love the gang. I also really love Far Away and I think uh in another year that would have been one of my picks. I think it was one of our winner because we categorized for for going analogs awards end of year awards slightly different category. So it was one of our winners. Uh but my pick for this category for the atas was uh chronologic Paris uh 1920 as well is very good. I think far away would be far away is excellent, but uh chronologically like I keep breaking out and it's funny you said you can't play the same scenario more than once cuz a horrible memory so he can literally like I was like I I didn't bother to keep track of which ones I played and Christina may have played some separately from me so we didn't keep track of any of this but I'm constantly showing it to other people and then I'm like I think I've played this scenario before but I have no idea who was the killer or who who stole the diamonds or whatever. I think if you model it enough by playing enough of the game so that you don't really associate the scenarios. Or if you play a random scenario each time rather than playing from start to finish, you can you can get to the point where you're like, I feel like the journalist did something sometime, but I can't be 100% sure.

Yeah, that I've definitely replayed scenarios just like I have no idea what I remember from before. But yeah, very clever game. I I'm so into this kind of new wave of logic deduction games that are like not like crypted where it was dependent on other people giving you correct information. And I do love I do love crypted though. I I liked it at the time a lot but it was my favorite for quite a while. If one human error uh could mess up the game for everybody where this is that is my least favorite thing about crypted is one person being like, "Oh, actually I'm sorry. This should have gone here." And I'm like, "Neat." and I just throw the board off the table and like do it again. Yeah. Whether they're app driven like the search for planet X or the search for lost species or like the ones we talked about chronologically eliminate humans. Yeah. Like they just have really clever systems now that you don't need someone to run it or interpret the clue. It's just like there's the facts and mind X.

Sorry. I I do love the Search of Planet X. Yeah. Yeah. One of our favorites, too. But yeah, uh Chronologic Paris is fantastic. There's just a few simple rules like every person has to from hour to hour they have to move one adjacent room and you just start getting all these little pieces of information. So you could and there's different stories. So you just have to track like the killer or who is the Phantom of the Opera or where is this jewelry being moved around between these several gang uh people in this gang. So uh and it's part of a series of three games. So, I think Chronologic Cusco, the Chronologic specifically for Cusco, Cusco's Chronologic, uh, comes out sometime this year. I think later this year. Yeah, that's going to be an auto play for us auto for me. Yeah. Yeah, same. I think my pick would have been Far Away overall. Like, I love Chronologic cuz I love a deduction game, but Far Away was so quirky and interesting for me that I really, really enjoyed it. So there it's just a card game, a very small card game uh with really quirky art that's sort of I don't know. I don't even know how to describe what it looks like. Very like rich colors but also um we like tribalish but not um so it's just very cute art and you are taking a journey. So as you uh draft cards, you're going to place them in order from left to right. So, you are planning this out, but you don't score until the very end when you've placed only eight cards and then you score them backwards. So, you are the issue is when

you're picking a card, you might want it to score. So, when you're scoring, you need certain um icons and stuff to show up, but you don't know if you have them all yet because they will be played usually after the card that you just played. Um, or you're also balancing, well, if I play a card that with a higher rank, then that's going to give me a better choice for the next, is it higher? Lower a lower choice for the next round, but higher than the previous card means I get a little bonus card that will help me with icons or scoring and things like that. So, you're balancing a lot of different little choices in a manageable way. Um, and then at the very end, you get the payoff of scoring everything backwards to see if you screwed up. And usually you did, or I did. I'm very bad at this game, but I really like it. Um, I had one really great game and I've been riding that high ever since.

A wise man once told me that a good game should be fun to lose and Far Away is definitely a fun game to lose. I will say I I I really I really do agree with you on the art style though. It's very evocative of like it's got it's one of those games kind of like Red Raven in that sense where it's like there's a lot more going on in the world of this game and this game is just one vignette of like a big expansive world of other things. So I hope that they uh I hope that other games kind of revisit that same thing cuz I'm also very excited about the art style and the color scheme used in the game. Yeah, it was really interesting cuz it feels like it does like another land. There's no text. There's no like, you know, real sort of um lore behind it behind it when you play the game, but just like looking at the cards, you feel like something's going on and I like that. Yeah. Is Far Away up for a spiel? I think they It is.

It is for the Kenner Spiel. Yeah, that that makes sense. I think they've been I mean, I think the Spiel has been pulling Kender Spiel a little bit lighter in recent years. They they had this entire thing that they wrote about Dorf romantic a few years ago and about like the idea of growing the hobby being at the heart of like the spiel. I have a lot of respect for how they think about um like approaching games for their awards. I think it's a fantastic system. Mhm. So it is up for the Kender spiel also and Flip 7 was up for the uh regular spiel.

So and strategy games. So, strategy games we had nominated um creature caravan and slay the spire the board game. Recommended were river of gold and rebirth and the winner was let's go to Japan which holds a very special place in our heart. Why shoe? We if you go to goingananalogshow.com and search our features area uh this was maybe a year and a half ago or so. Uh we put out a blog post where we literally uh got an early copy of this game like the well so the game is basically about planning a trip to Japan. You're going to get all these cards and you're going to decide we're going to go shopping or we're going to go see a baseball game or a sumo match or we're going to eat ramen and we're going to do this. And a lot of these are based on real world locations in Tokyo or Kyoto. And then so in the cards they describe what it is. So there's a lot like more flavor text than you get in a lot of cards. But it's great because you like learn about why is this place cool, why do people go, why is it trendy or who what group is it trendy for? Uh how to pronounce these words. But anyways, what you're trying to do is like Monday through is it full week, seven days, six days I think. Uh so you're planning like I want a day for shopping, I want a day of eating, I want a day of uh exploration. So, you start planning all these things and the way the cards combo off of each other and how you travel between uh Kyoto and Tokyo really matters, but it's just like this fun game where there's like a lot of different scoring opportunities depending on how you lay out your trip.

But we got an early copy. We actually went to a lot of these locations in the game and took our pictures. So, there's a picture card up. Yeah. So, it's like a picture of Christine at a cat cafe holding up the and then we're holding up the cat cafe card and all that kind of stuff. So, so now you need them to print a new version of the game where all the cards are just the photos of you holding up the cards, holding the card and then you can then you can go to Japan and do it again. And so you can just keep getting, you know, larger and like eventually like seven tiers from now it's like, you know, a picture of or the game has a card of you holding a card that has a picture of you, you know. Yeah. Yeah. Well, infinite mirror this thing. Yeah. To support this uh new project. I I will I will go along with it. So I mean everyone's flush with cash right now, right?

Exactly. And so I mean the game play is like it's very like they change the drafting every round essentially or every turn and you're passing the cards in a different way. Um things like that. So you you can if you wanted to pay more attention to what other people are doing, but I usually don't. I usually just like try to set up a very cool trip for myself and at the very end I like to make everybody when they're scoring talk about their days. So just a brief little description. I went here and then here and then here and then decide to take a walk. Um so it's it's quite a surprising amount of strategy for a very beautiful quick like little drafting game. Um and then it's just the theme makes it really shine I think. So, um, they will probably do some I heard some other games in this series going to other locations, but, uh, let's go to the grocery store. Like, let's go let's go bury grandma. Like, I mean, you could have visited grandma.

That's okay. You are visiting grandma. She just, you know, she's not there. So dark here. I know. I' I've had a lot of family deaths this year. Oh, okay. Well, anyway, how about what you what any other sort of favorite strategy games on this list for you? I was incredibly unsurprised by Slay the Spire's presence on here, just because I was like, Slay the Despire was a video game made for board gamers. So, as soon as they made a board game based on the video game, I was like, "Yeah, all right. This is going to this is going to hit hard for a lot of people." Uh my my pick is always I I love River of Gold. Yes. Like River of Gold passes what I think is one of my highest. It's going to sound very like it's very low praise, but it's extremely high praise.

It is I have a test that I run on a lot of games on BGA, which is how much fun can I have with this game if I never read the rule book, exclusively play it on board game arena based on what buttons the game will allow me to press. So, I think the first like five or six games that you and I played together, I had no idea what I was doing, but I had a very nice time. I was like, "Ah, the buttons that the game lets me press are satisfying." And I slowly learned how to play up to an including I think one game where I was like, "Oh, the scoring criteria changes every game. I guess I should pay attention to that." I think you told me about that. And I was like, "Yep, it's it's there on the right corner." Yeah. And I was like, not reading. I mean, Office Dog, I think, also has like a like they are a relatively new uh publisher. I think they've they've made a handful of games.

They're I think their latest game, Crafting the Cosmos, is also one to watch. I think that's a really really fun game with some very good-looking art. Mhm. And the the production has been fantastic on their game. So, I've played it on Borg Marina, obviously, with lots of people. And then in real life though, we have our physical copy and it is beautiful. There's like gold foil all over the place and it's just like Yeah, it feels special playing the game. And it also sits at this perfect sort of medium strategy weight for me where it you get a little like a good amount of crunch, but it also plays super smoothly um as you are sailing down this river of gold trying to sort of influence these different factions for points. And then um you get to change the board as you're going along too because um when you sort of take over in c certain like merchant areas you have your color there and you get a little kickback if people use that ability things like that. I like that a lot. It's really really fun. So I just think in general cuz I mean Chronologic does this as well or does this as well to some degree right? The like everyone gets something but I get something a little better. And I I really like that structure, the like the additive nature of it when I'm playing a board game because it makes it not feel as competitive. It makes it feel like we're kind of I like it better when you're It's not I get everything and you get punished. It's we all get something and I get something a little bit better.

Mhm. Mhm. I will say another game that isn't on our five list here that I still really enjoyed was Stone Spine Architects. M like I really It's a um d it's a card drafting game set in like that roleplayer cgraphers universe where you're building a like dungeon every time. So you're not just drafting cards for benefits. You're also drafting cards so you can build a pathway from the top of your board to the bottom of your board and like different rooms have different effects and they have different point values and like money is involved with it as well. I like it a lot cuz it has that same like flexible feel of cgraphers. Um, and I just I think it's a lot I think it's a lot of fun. Yeah, that was a cool game too as well. What about you, Shu? I know you're going to talk about I I love Let's Go to Japan. I I haven't played like just looking at the listed youth name that like those category or those games in this category. We have I haven't played Rebirth. I haven't played Splade Despire the board game. It's huge though. That box I've seen. It's a chunkster. Yeah.

So, I So, I unfortunately I haven't played those. Uh I really like Creature Caravan a lot. We talked about that on a show before, the Red Raven game, where you're basically traveling across the countryside and then building uh different away from very slow zombies. Trying to get away from slow zombies. Very slow zombies. It's better than fast zombies to be fair. Uh but yeah, it's a cool game where it's like I I love dice placement games. Uh but this one is where your your caravan grows bigger and there's more places for you to put the dice in. Uh it can take a little bit of a long time. It's a longer game. Um but it's great. Uh but my pick in this group is also River of Gold. Yeah. I I think you said right like the perfect kind of middleweight maybe on light end of middleweight uh kind of strategy game because you only have so many choices and in some rounds like I don't have any money so I can't build anything on the river. So you don't even have to worry about you're never over uh like uh overloaded with too many choices to make. Uh, and then you have a couple of boats. So, you do have some choice of like which boat do I want to move? And so, uh, and then one nice little touch about the game is you roll your die at the end of your turn. So, while other people are playing, you can start thinking about what you want to do next.

So, the game moves really fast when you play it in real life. I do I do have some friends, God bless them, that only ever think about what they should be doing on their turn when their turn starts. And I'm always just like, you know, there's like I I I genuinely don't know what they're doing like where they're at when I'm taking my turn. is kind of just like looking off into the middle distance being like, "Ah, yes, father. I can hear the drums." Or whatever. But, uh, for those of you listening at home, you will notice an interesting trend so far is that we've the three of us have largely agreed about what our preferences are. So, did they just have me on to validate their own preferences? Yes. Worth thinking about. Yes. Makes us feel better about ourselves. I know. Yeah. We didn't want the opposite here. or the new likes. Just me being like, I actually loved Rebirth. It's my favorite. Nothing bad, nothing wrong with Rebirth, obviously. Just I really like Rever Gold.

Finally, complex games, which uh really sort of I was surprised by the range of sort of length and depth of these different games cuz it's sort of tough to say cuz I think a lot of stuff ends up in the complex games when it it doesn't quite fit into those previous ones either. Yeah. When you read this list, there's I think there's one clear one that doesn't belong in this list in my opinion. This is just me. No, taxonomic breakdown. Oh, wait. I don't mean in terms of like uh should it be nominated just I think it's miscatategorized like really badly. But it's it's a it's a group decision. We did get into a fight about Harvest which I thought was fun. I was like Harvest is like a 60 to 90 minute game. So nominated for complex games were Black Forest, Andromeda's Edge, recommended Recetti and Arcs which are just a bunch of capital letters. Um, and the winner was Fromage. Very, very cheesy. And I know which is not near.

It's like a quarter of the heaviness of the other four games. Shu Shu very much thinks he should have been an early gamers. Get those get those kids their tiny hands looking for looking for alien life. Yeah. Right. Wait, don't you like Fromage is not is not a complex. It's a strategy game. Maybe I I would have preferred it more as a strategy game. Um I can see sort of the argument for complex game in that the planning for the timing. So Fromage has this very interesting mechanic. Uh you are placing your cheese maker into different quadrants and where they go is where you may make some cheese. Um, but you know the it has this very clever mechanism where the direction you place your cheese maker is the time needed to uh age your cheese primarily, right? So some cheese is better when it's younger, some cheese is better when it's super old and gross, you know, whatever. Um, and so it incorporates that. So if you go and make a cheese that takes a long time, you don't get that token back for several turns. So for some gamers that may be a difficult plan for them to do.

They make it very clever in that the whole um circular cheese board turns quadrant to quadrant from turn to turn and you can sort of see by the direction that your cheesemaker is facing when you get that worker back. Right. Um but it still is a planning that that maybe a you know newer medium gamers are not quite as comfortable with is my is my take on it. Yeah. And I think I mean like you said complex is such a like it is it is one of the it's one of a handful of categories that we get that we occasionally catch some flak on because I think like our definition of complex has evolved over time every like and I think that this is this is largely a like a board game awardwide problem in that these categories are fairly moving targets because like as you you know Like I think that if we were to talk about like Kenner Spiel, right, then we think of that as like the enthusiast board game of the year and that is that has skewed, as we mentioned earlier in the podcast, it's skewing progressively lighter and spiel is skewing progressively lighter cuz they're thinking about how to open board gaming as a hobby to more people. I'm very much on the like if it's over 90 minutes, my brain's just like complex cuz you only got so much time. can play Fromage faster than that. So I'm like my main maybe maybe the final say if we could move on from this is like I could play

four or five games with Fromage in the time it takes to play a game with STI. Yeah, I was going to say like I've heard nothing but good things about STI, but I have heard like that's a that's a that's a game that's roughly the size and weight of a small child. I do love the cheese theme of Fromage and I think that it is a good introduction to this sort of interesting timing mechanism that I know you love in Zulkin. So, it reminds me in some ways of that, but Zulkin is a game that has a much more complicated cog situation where you have to time your workers in a really meticulous way. Forage eases up on that. Um, and it has a lot of different interesting scoring and the art is great. It's super colorful. Um, I like the game. I don't know if I would have said it was complex for me either, but I like it. That is why I like that we have this is again another good argument for multiple games per category, right? So that way we still get representation for the like really crunchy heavyweight games like SETI or the like fairly, you know, I as I assume it's I assume since it's a four-letter game from Leader that it's got some asymmetry going on. Um but yeah for arcs like that sort of stuff. Yeah we and this argument about what goes in a category is classic. Like we have even our own awards. We don't agree. I feel like the interest the Fromage probably ended up you know getting a lot bigger of a bump because more people were able to play it too because because in this category it doesn't take as long as the

other games. You're going to have a little bit more representation. This is canonically a very tough category to slot because all the complex games take a little bit of time and we've got a very one thing I really like about the committee's like structure is that we have a nice blend of people who play games from all across the spectrum. I tend to skew fairly light. Uh like uh Annette from Neter's Plays tends to skew like towards fairly heavy towards much heavier games. And so we try to get a good mix of perspectives. But you know, in the same way that me voting like my voting generally tends to pull more like less like lighter games towards like heavier categories because I'm like like I said 90 minutes, who's got time for that?

So I mean my favorite here is is probably SI. Um so I of heavy games like that that's the issue too. If it is a heavy game that I like for that year I've played it multiple times at the expense of other games probably right. So since I played three four different games of SEI I'm not playing some of these heavier games cuz I don't have the time for it you know. Um, but SETI is about the search for extraterrestrial life. Um, with the, you know, given given their blessing from the actual SEI group, um, the designer obviously really is a huge nerd for this stuff. Um, it's super super thematic. You know, we've talked about it in the past. Um, and it's there's a lot going on. The teach up front is quite heavy, but once you get playing, everything makes a lot of sense, I think. And it adds this extra, you know, little taste of being not euroey in that you get the randomness of this these two potential um alien species that you discover that will change up the gameplay. And that's the sort of very exciting part. You're like, "Oo, which alien is it going to be?" And then um you know, one of the aliens may be like a pick them deliver bonus mechanism. Another one may be like, "Ooh, you get these powerful actions, but it's this sort of corruption mechanism." So there's all sorts of little twists on it that add to your exploration of the solar system trying to find these traces of these extraterrestrials. It's so cool. Like they might they won't pop up until maybe a third to a halfway into the game. So

it's like it gives you time to kind of ramp up to it and before it adds new mechanics. Uh and then again it comes with five aliens and you pick two at random for your game. So it changes every game. And then I'm excited about the expansion. It's going to release a few more aliens as well. I do think it's funny that CGE is like I think at least in the non in the non- like hobby gaming sphere sort of known best for code names when they are making a lot of these like really really like coupnahora like even starship captains was fairly heavy for my tastes but I will say starship captains when I played it I was like yeah this is this is pretty much exactly what I would like expect out of a like not Star Trek knockoff but something that's Star Trek thematic so I would like to play it at some point. It's just one of one of those games that I kind of wish was on BGA so I could uh play it without having to deal with I don't know if I would like it on BGA. I was thinking that cuz it's such a gigantic board with a lot of information to look at. I do play Lost Res and I'm always just like on my phone. I'm like this is too small. Yeah.

Yeah. I don't know if you'd want STI on this. Uh hell, we're playing innovations. Sometimes I have to switch over to a computer so I can actually read some of the cards especially. No, I always mess up on my phone on BGA for that one. Um, so that was the given reason for why I keep winning. Yes. Yes. Anyway. Anyway, um, the other one that I really liked that I have Well, I have played four of these. No, did I play Andromeda's Edge also? No, you haven't played. Okay, I played four of the five. Um I personally arcs is exactly not my kind of game. So uh I can see that is a good game. It is uh on the surface maybe trick taking but not really. It's very strategic tactical game. Um not my style of game. Also it involves dice rolling for um space battles and I am horrible with dice.

They will just leave me and give me like the worst thing possible whenever I want it whenever I don't want it. Um, so not my game, but I know some people love it. And then I did really like Black Forest. I need to play it again. Like I I played it once. It's a Uve Rosenberg. I'm I'm still a fan. I love his sort of like um resource management animal like food games basically. And in this one, it's a sort of his revamp of Glass uh Glass Road. and he had a bigger plan for Glass Road a long time ago and they sort of paired it down for that game. So he brought it back. So you are still preparing glass in the Black Forest which is historically where um a lot of glass was made in Germany. Um but you also employ the cakes. Yes. Yes. Where the cakes are also there are no cakes in this game. Um we can fix that next time.

Seems like a missed opportunity. Yeah. Right. Um, so then there's also movement of your people going to villages to gather resources and do certain actions. So there's surprisingly a good amount of player interaction for an Uve Rosenberg game, which a lot of people often claim is like a, you know, multiplayer solitaire game. So I really like that game. I immediately wanted to buy it after playing it and I still haven't played it again, but I I really it it scratches a bunch of different itches of heavy game. A bunch of different itches. Yes, it does. That sounds great, right? Yeah, it's fine, you know. Uh-huh. Yeah. What about you, Shu? Uh, so I've played all the games on at least this part of uh the recommended nominee gamer. God bless you guys. There were two that I don't like as much as uh like gen like the kind of hype that they're getting out there. One I also agree on arcs.

Like I think I liked it better than you, but I also was like I don't quite get the hype around this game. Like people love arts. I think people are very locked in in the leader ecosystem, which is, you know, their their business and their prerogative. Like I like for me it's me going I play I play games too. I like Fort so I'm just like I like Fort. Yeah. Uh so uh Arcet wasn't as crazy about as a lot of people. Black Forest was another one where like a lot of our friends who like these like I also like eBay Rosenberg games. I like farming and all those stuff. Like my my Carver is one of my favorite games of all time, but uh this one just didn't do as much for me as other people. Uh Andromeda's Edge I really liked. Uh so we got to play that. Um and I was like that was one of my nominations as well. Uh so this is kind of like a a light Forex style game where you're just like okay do I invest in technology? Do I want to explore the universe? I want to get these resources. There's different resource tracks or different sort of tracks they could go and compete against with everybody. Uh it is a pretty epic game. Uh it's sort of the spiritual sequel to and I was trying to look on my phone before. What do you remember the game? The one it has like minis with like a sound chip inside them. It's like Elder Eld Dwellings of Elder. Oh yeah.

I've heard of Dwellings of Elder Veil. Yeah. So it it it's like the spirit of that. Uh, I like it better reimplemented uh with a more of a space theme versus a fantasy theme. So, it's a really I prefer space to fantasy myself. Oh, okay. You might like the If you like dwellings, uh, you might like you'll definitely like this one for sure. Uh, but my pick was also SI. Yeah. But if I had to pick one winner in this category, it's come visit for a weekend. We'll get SI played. There you go. I I just every like I I got I got to see a demo of it at one of the cons and even then I was just like ah this seems like a lot of fun actually. So yeah, but it's it's going to be with the teach like probably close to three and a half four hours.

I've I've done you could play you could play five games of Fromage in that time. I've done it before. Well, I think that I think that also my tolerance for um really really heavy games has gone up now that I can play BGA on my phone when it's not my turn. So, someone will look over at me and I'll be like and they're like, "What are you doing?" I was like, "Playing a different game." I was like, "Take as much time strategizing as you need. I got something else going on." Mhm. We one time uh similar story where uh we were on line, we're playing remotely with a game designer on tabletop simulator, which is another program where you could play like a live physics model of a board game. A lot of a lot a lot of uh uh prototypes are being are shown to people this way. But anyways, we're playing with the game designer and the two of us and then uh on my off turn when it wasn't my turn, I quickly switched tabs to uh check on my board game arena. But it made the noise is very classic noise. And like and the game designer called me out. He's like, "Is someone moonlighting with Board Game Arena right now?" Cuz he recognized the tone. And I had to laugh. But you got to have you got to have three monitors. You got your board game arena monitor, you got your tabletop simulator monitor, you got your tabletopia monitor, and you're like, I have no idea what's going on.

But the board game arena monitor has to be on mute. So yeah, I always support Marina on mute specifically for that reason cuz like I got I got mildly called out in a meeting once because I was doing the New York Times crossword and that has a really lovely sound when you finish it. But unfortunately I finished it and someone was like oh got your Wordle I see. And I was like yeah Wordle something that I definitely haven't been doing for the last 20 minutes instead of Oh well. So well those are our opinions. Um, everybody should go try these games out cuz they're all fantastic because they made the cut. This was a really huge cut. So, you can't go wrong basically, right? It's just what your player preference is. Um, and thanks for joining us today, Eric. Where can people follow you and find out what you're playing and what you're up to? Yeah, thanks for having me. Uh, so normally I post two reviews a week on my website, what's.com. Uh recently I've been uh doing a uh podcast with Stella from Mel University and Candace from Board Gamegeeek and some other folks called Life Beyond Board Games. That's been a lot of fun. So uh you can find that wherever podcasts are sold. Mhm. Yes. Um I very cheap nowadays. Yeah. I Yeah. I don't I don't know. I I don't know anything about podcasts. They're like be on a podcast. I was like sure. I love being on podcast because I have to do very little research and I don't have to do any editing which are two of my least favorite things to do. So, yeah. No,

that's where you can find me. I used to be on more social media. I've been taking a ever since I moved up to Seattle, I took a social media cleanse and that's actually been really really good for me. So, I'm kind of I'm only logging back on to talk about like the new pope and stuff like that. So, follow Eric for new pope info. Conclave was like my Olympics. I was just like, "Oh, who's going to be the new pope?" Apparently, it's legal to bet on the new pope. Sad. Okay, the more you know. So, thanks for listening everybody. Please subscribe and rate our podcast if you've been enjoying it. It helps other like-minded f gamers find us. Thanks to the bestest editor, Mike Zipkin. And now you can stop listening and go play one of the ATA games. Bye bye. See y'all.

Progress saved