Board Game Rating Changes - Episode 1 - Chairman of the Board
Transcript
hey everybody today i'm starting a new series called rating changes so normally on this channel i'm always playing new stuff giving ratings out for games that i've i play for the first time um but of course i've got my own collection and i'm always playing games that are already in my collection so i wanted to make a series covering games where um you know i've had them for a long time or had them for a while and if my opinion of those games have changed for the better or for the worse so i've got 10 games i'm going to talk about on this first episodes five of them i've got open ratings five of them have gone down um so let's get started so i think i'll start with the with the negative and get them out of the way and then move on to the positive so the first game i want to talk about is new york zoo i which i've moved from a six and a half down to a six so you know it's not the biggest of changes here and this is a anova rosenberg targe placement style game where you are building your own zoo by placing these polyamino tiles and you're basically trying to fill out this map as quickly as you can because the first person to do so is the winner this game has a little bit of a twist um on to kind of differentiate itself from his other target placement games whereas this one you are placing these animal meeples on your tiles and then every kind of so often they are kind of reproducing and creating more and more and more animals meaning that when you fill those tiles up you can place a new bonus tile down um i like this game it's perfectly fine and you know it's a very standard tile placement style game very accessible the reason why it's fallen slightly for me um is i think i think for a couple reasons so first off if i'm directly comparing this to
other tar placement games by rosenberg i i don't think it's quite as strong as things such as patchwork um i still think this is a has a valid place in the collection because it does scale better because this one actually plays up to four players whereas patchwork is strictly a two-player game um i think the the kind of um economy in patchwork is a bit more interesting um but additionally i think the the game drags on a bit too long for what it is on this higher player counts which has only kind of come to light for me recently um and additionally i think although the production is very nice in the game it can be quite fiddly you know when you're putting a bunch of these different animal meeples on these tiles are you knocking them over and or if you've got big fingers or big hands like me it's quite fiddly and hard to um hard to move things around but still a perfectly pleasant game um but again i i'd rather play some other tar placement games the next game i'm going to talk about is one that's actually lost my shield of quality you know i think objectively this might not be the case it's more of a personal opinion uh this is the king is dead by pier sylvester so the king is dead a very popular area control style game very clever one actually you know and again i i want to make it clear that i think this is a wonderful design um but i think my appeal of this one is just dwindling and dwindling and i really have no interest at all to go back and play this one it just didn't have the vibe and the feel of a game that i want to go and re-explore further so uh this one is again a strange one where you're trying to manipulate these three different nations so you've got the the
scottish the english and the the welsh i believe and then you are trying to basically control certain regions at certain times and get influence with these with those nations uh it's very uh it has very minutes win uh margins in terms of you know wanting to play things just at the right time to get the most out of them you know the margins for victory are extremely small um i also had a really cool card system where all your actions are given to you at the start of the game um but um but you could use those cards as you wished from start to finish and as soon as you've used those cards you can never get them back so you really do have to pace yourself again another game i think is very clever very well done very well put together but ultimately i don't think i can fully endorse a game that i really don't feel the urge or get a lot of enjoyment from anymore so um unfortunately the king is dead has fallen from a seven to a six the next game i'm going to talk about is something a bit lighter this is camel up camel up one of the kind of mainstays of my collections for a long long time so this is a family-friendly racing style game as you're betting on these camels the hitching rides on one another are trying to you're trying to bet the ones you think is going to win either not only the leg but the ultimate race as well you're betting on who you think's going to lose the race you can cause a bit of carnage by making them slip up and things a really fun again family friendly gateway style game that i've had a lot of fun with over the years and i'm not gonna take anything away from this game you know this has done a lot in my
collection over the years and stayed a lot longer than pretty much anything else um but i've definitely got to that point where i'm fatigued with the game i don't really have the urge to play it anymore um and a bit like king's dead if that urges now that enjoyment isn't um isn't really screaming out to me um it's going to have to fall so i've actually dipped this one from a seven to a six i think maybe as time goes by it could creep up again because um you know maybe that separation will start to come in and i'll start to get the urge to play it again but right now i'm i'm done with there i've kind of closed the lid on that one and i'm ready to move on from camel up now the next game is something a bit heavier with maharaja so maharaja i've fallen very slightly from a seven and a half to a seven so it still holds my shield of quality this is a wolfgang kramer classic i suppose there's a re-implementation at least the version i'm talking about uh i i like this game it's got a lot a lot i enjoy about it as you're trying to place your kind of pieces around these roads to make traveling cheaper uh you're trying to get influence with the maharaja pieces going to all these different cities uh you've tried to manipulate your or kind of utilize your player powers to your benefit has a lot going on that i like i think it's a very smooth game very fun game and um yeah no i can't really say much negative about it at all the only reason that this has fallen from me is because i think it's unavoidable to to not compare this to something else so uh one of my favorite games in fact my favorite game of all time is el grande
and you know i might i i can't help but compare the two so i think am i going to ever select to play maharaja over el grande never ever so for that reason i had to kind of leave my collection because it's just going to be sat there i'm not getting played but i can still sit back and confidently recommend to check this game out i think it's a solid design but is it as good as our grand a absolutely not and i think by default it's fallen down to that seven because that that factor that i'm not going to get this played um has to reflect on my score uh and the final negative one i'm going to talk about is merv at the heart of the silk road so this has fallen from an eight to a seven and a half and there's one key reason for that i think i think it's the the fact that i mostly play this game at two players and initially i was quite happy with the two player variant of the game but when i played this again i i was left with a little bit of a sour taste in my mouth and i didn't enjoy it as much as i did the first time so if you don't know what merv is it's a a pretty generic but beautiful looking euro game as you are trying to move around this map of merv either going from the horizontal or vertical axes which and the merv is made up of this bunch of tiles with different actions on them and they also determine the resources you can get by selecting these different buildings um but and you're using all these different actions to do lots of different mini games to get points in different ways so it's pretty simple um has that kind of tragenesque feel to it where you're again you're playing all these different mini games
but yeah i'll go back to that two player variant where i always felt like well especially in the most recent time i've played this game i feel like it's a bit obvious about what you want to do in order to shaft the other player and you're obviously going to put it in the most lucrative spot or obviously going to put it in the spot where it's going to hurt your opponent the most and leave and you want to leave them with the fewest options and if that required a bit more thought a bit more kind of savviness about how you're gonna utilize that blocker uh i would have probably enjoyed it more but because the the visuals of the game are so clear about what the other people have invested in i think it's such an obvious choice where you're gonna put it and it's a bit of a no-brainer so again that kind of really did affect the score for me a bit i still think this is a rock solid euro game and a really enjoyable one um and of course playing that three to four player mark i could i could i really think it's fantastic but i had to knock it down to a seven and a half because of that two player variant so let's go on to the positive games here so i'm going to start off with lost city so ryder canezio kind of tug-of-war classic game i've moved this one from a seven to a seven and a half really enjoying this one still i think it's got some amazing decisions on in this one some are great attention and hand management is you've got to be careful at what cars to give your opponent or the opportunity to leave you to your opponent and you're basically trying to play cards of a certain color onto your side of the board but being careful that if you don't reach a certain threshold you can potentially suffer negative points so you're sharing those cards with your opponent which ones are you
going to invest in which ones are you are you worried about your opponent having a stake in as well uh just a great a great game with great pacing a great ramping up effect and some a really amazing decision so yeah very happy with los cities i think it deserves it's kind of classic um title that people consider this one uh next up i've moved from a seven and a half to an eight this is seven wonders duel uh this one of course is the two player variant of the classic uh drafting game seven wonders and this one i like so much more than the original and i'm really enjoying this one still so quick one of the best ratios in terms of depth choices uh all these strategies um in comparison to the time it takes this one only takes about half an hour to play i love the drafting system of this game as you have this pyramid of cards and you can only draft from the kind of base of that one but as you're revealing or drafting more cards you're revealing the ones below it being careful not to leave your opponent with opportunities and i'm just really enjoying the different strategies you can take of this one i love the different progress tokens you can go down the different paths to victory and this one is truly as good as people say it is and i'm so so happy with this one and who knows this one could go up even further now i have the expansions on my shelf to play so yeah very happy with seven wonders jordan just keeps going from strength to strength uh the next game is a very minor climb but a significant climb so this is tawantin suyu so this is kind of an honorary remember of the t series of
game made made famous by daniel dashini but this one is actually by david turtsy and i would say this is probably one of the heavier ones in this series as you have this massive pyramid on this board and you are basically placing meeples down in a worker placement style fashion but the more you compile these meeples together you can get more and more actions and you're trying to cascade down this this this pyramid to get stronger actions as well and i i i know this game is very intimidating i think this is one of the most intimidating games i own in terms of pure symbology being all over the board and i always had that doubt in the back of my head you know is um you know is this going to be a bit too bamboozling for people is it too much who am i going to play this with but the more i'm playing this one i'm kind of having my my thoughts kind of solidified and verified and thinking this is a really solid game of some really fun decisions here i'm still slightly hesitant to give it my shield of or my elite shield because you know i require an eight and a half to get to that level i've just slipped it just under because of those reasons because it is a bit of a teacher it's quite it's quite um it can be quite ap prone there's a lot of choices here available to you at any time so i'm still just thinking you know is it is it just a bit too much of an obstacle to keep it into the higher higher bracket but still really enjoying this one and i was thinking is this going to be as good as i've remembered it and yes it certainly is the penultimate game we're going to talk about is a game that's been in my
collection for years and years and years this is hana makoji i've moved this one from an eight to an eight and a half so giving it my elite shield the best of the best um and the reason for this one is and i will say this one did used to have my shield and my elite shield but a bit like i said with camel up i used to play this one a lot i got quite fatigued with it the draw for me to come back to it did dwindle and dwindle but i've got to that point now where i can just look back at this game and think you know this game is so well designed it's just beautifully made so delicately balanced and the more two-player games i'm playing the more you realize how good this game is so um yeah i i feel a bit silly for actually knocking this one down below an eight and a half because there is no way this doesn't deserve my elite show this is amongst the best um two-player games i've ever played so um definitely i want to check out if you like your two-player games that is hana makoji a brilliant tug-of-all-star game with elegant mechanisms and just the most delicately balanced game i've ever played and my final game i'm going to talk about is actually my biggest jump this is um mandala so mandala i've moved it from an eight to a nine um so i think this game is incredible in fact i think it i'm pretty sure it is my my best and my favorite two-player game of all time at this point this is such a clever game as you're using these cards to bid to collect other cars but when you collect cards they're gonna go into your this row of scoring cards that you get and the
order in which you get these cards kind of determines the value of these cards to go along so the ones you collect later are worth more points but the cards you're collecting are also the cards you're bidding with so you've got to be really careful what you're going to expend which cards you're leaving to your opponent because some cards can be worth a fortune to your opponent but not much to you so clean loads of things to juggle in this one some great restrictions in the game and i just think this game is an absolute masterpiece i think this is a timeless feel and i'm so baffled that this game is only i think a year or two old and it feels like a game from a bygone era that people will be playing for for you know for decades and decades to come i think this is wonderful it's so much fun and i think uh this is just a one of those games that's gonna be be a game that i play for years to come and there aren't many games that stick around for me in terms of that that kind of longevity but i can't ever see me getting tired of mandala and um i'm just completely enamored with this one at the moment so well that concludes that this video i hope i hope you've enjoyed it it's a new concept so give me some feedback if you think this is a good idea for a series um i think it is so um hopefully um you will agree with that so if you have enjoyed this video please hit like and subscribe my channel and check out my other videos too and for everyone else i'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye