Skip to main content
Loading video...

Top 100 Board Games Of All Time (2023) 80-71

Transcript 37:19

welcome to allies or enemies I'm Jess and I am Sean and this is our top 100 favorite board games of all time and today we are counting down the 70s yeah and I'm really excited about the games on this list so I think let's get right to it and I'm starting us off he is Sonora which is a flick and write game you flicked these discs onto a board and then where the discs end up is what you get to do for each of the different areas there are four different areas that match up to the writing bit and each of those four all work a little bit differently for how you cross them off but can lead to some really fun combos upon combos upon combos but the best bit for me is really the flicking part because you can really try and like flick people's discs off the space that they want to be on or really try and Aim so that you end up on like the special times two space or it can lead to some really interesting things yeah it's a super simple like kind of version of croconol which is a Canadian treasure but it's a super simple version of that and we've gotten better and better at first we felt like oh I don't know about this this part's kind of too simple but as we've gotten better at it it gets just a lot more competitive in that part of the game what which is all interactive and then it goes back to like just you writing it down so this is interesting kind of back and forth of

this thing that's so interactive and then this thing that's completely solitary where you're Crossing off and comboing and doing all of this yeah because the crossing off it can be interesting there is a combo you frequently get that lets you choose an area so we do find that we specialize in some of the other areas and that is my number 80. my number 80 is tidal blades part one Heroes of the refin tidal blades on paper is not a game that I should like this is this looks like it is just a dice chucker because it is a ton a ton of dice and you're these characters who are moving around these islands and the islands are beautiful the whole thing just looks like refreshing like I want to just be out there with like a beverage on the beach but you're moving around these islands and you're doing jet ski tricks and you're fighting Kyle you with these dice but secretly this has got all of these cool Euro mechanics hidden underneath that because the dice are really kind of a deck building thing where you're leveling up the dice and you've got different routes you can go and how you level them up and then at the same time you're doing this kind of track mechanic that is actually a dial where you're turning this dial and that dial helps you in different ways where it gives you different dice or access to different cards or whatever it might be and all of that works together in this way that really surprised me yeah it does and what you're saying about the look is totally true it looks amazing and we

just got the retail version which was a lot cheaper than the kickstarter and I don't think you even need the kickstarter the retail comes in a much more reasonable size box and it looks like it would be the fancy version uh it's just it's one of those games you see on the table and you're like what is this I want to know more about this it's really inviting and I think that's a big part of what we're brought me in and it is my number 80. my number 79 is honey buzz and I love the theme your bees that are making honey and selling it to Forest creatures and it looks lovely it probably actually looks a little bit easier than it actually is though because what it is is it's a work replacement game so you have to put your bees out and collect these tiles and lay them out on your beehive but the action of what you're doing is actually like a step removed it's not based on the tile you get it's once you complete a hexagon on your beehive and then you get to perform all of those actions so there's a lot of decisions for when you complete it and which actions you perform in what order yeah it's it's like you've got a few different levels to the game of putting out your bees and then worrying about your hive and then when you're activating those with like your Fanning action it's both what different Nectars do you get so that you can sell that honey to the Woodland creatures and also what actions are gonna happen to build for future turns yeah and the honey that you're fulfilling goes to a changing

Market because once that order is fulfilled a new one comes out so somebody might scoop that customer but also there's this market value where the value decreases so you might just like sell a lot of pollen when it's at a high value so lots of different things to consider and that's my number 79. my number 79 is Merchants Cove and Merchants Cove really shines in its asymmetry this is as asymmetrical as a game can get all basically everyone's playing almost a different game you've got a separate game board and you're making Goods because the game is you are at this Cove and you're merchants and so you've got to sell Goods to these different ships that are coming down to The Cove to buy goods from whoever gets there with the right kind of goods for that color of person like green people want green goods Red people want red Goods but how you make the goods is wildly different based on your character so there's one character that's like this dice playing spin game there's one character that's like a little mini kind of potion explosion there's one of the expansion characters like a rolling right there's a mancala and there's even though it seems at first like there's not a lot of interaction there's a lot of interaction involved in how you're placing those customers and where they're going to those different docks yeah and that interaction can be pretty mean because I do like the asymmetry of the different characters and making the goods but you don't have full control over what docs the customers end up on so I have run into the situation where

I've had a lot of like one colored good and I think oh I'm going to stack this boat filled with that one color and then make sure they get to the dock I need but then you'll be moving that boat before I can and you'll purposely move it to the opposite dog and I'm like no I was going to get so many points so it can be frustrating yeah it definitely can be frustrating because you've gotta really you gotta kind of hedge your bets but you can definitely get screwed and it can feel bad sometimes but I can take that bit of meanness just because it's so much fun for me to use these different characters on my little board and that is my 79. my number 78 is now or never and this is the third in the rzm trilogy by Ryan I unlock it and just like the previous ones it was designed by Ryan Lockett and and the art is also by him too and it's a beautiful world and it's really more of an open exploration than the other two you're this character on a map and you get to visit different locations you can perform actions at those locations you can complete quests you can fight monsters and separately to that you're also spending a lot of time constructing a town and moving people into the different buildings of the town so there's a lot to keep track of I think the tricky is when we first started playing this we were playing the full version and it took about four hours probably overstated it's welcome for me and once we started playing a shorter

version that was posted on BGG that really made it more approachable we were more likely to to play it then yeah it's an official shorter version because I think this was a complaint a lot of people had and Ryan Lockett was like all right cool well how about if you start with all this stuff and do these other things and it it feels a bit like uve Rosenberg has a lot of these short versions that I think always work really well and this works really well and there there are so many Avenues you could take because you didn't even mention there's also asymmetric character sheets it's such a like sandbox and such a culmination of it feels like everything he was working on in the first two games in the trilogy too yeah and I would say it's the heaviest for sure of the three but I do like being able to have that free exploration in that world and being able to make lots of different decisions and it is my number 78. my number 78 is Shakespeare and I like Shakespeare for a few reasons versus I just love Shakespeare I just I love I've been such a big fan of Shakespeare since forever and also this was really hard for us to find and if ever you've really hunted down a game and you finally found that game you know that it's got a little bit of extra glow on it after afterwards but just the gameplay is great this is uh it's just a solid kind of Tableau building game where you're adding these cards which are characters from different Shakespeare plays but also those cards are your actions so it's also an action selection game where

you've got up to five actions you can do each turn but I say up to because that part is also a bidding mechanism because whoever uses the least actions goes first the next turn which can be very important in this game and is always very difficult to do against Jess who really is determined to go first whatever those there's those sorts of mechanics in a game you have to go first that's how you get the best stuff and so if I know Sean's gunning for a first and is only gonna do like three actions I'll be like all right I'll do two and I'll take that first what I really want to try though is the expansion the backstage expansion but it's impossible to find but I hear that that adds a lot yeah I don't even want to think about it because it was so hard to find the the base game and from what I understand that is way harder to find but Shakespeare is just I feel like it's it's it's a modern classic and I wish that they would reprint it because it's been out of print for a while and it's too good a game to be out of print and it's my 78. my number 77 is Earth which just came out this year and one of the best things is that everyone is involved every turn it has this interesting action selection system where on your turn you get to pick one of the four main actions but everybody else also gets to do that action they just do a weaker version of it and it also has Tableau building which I'm a big fan of

the Tableau and where you put your cars is going to affect the scoring but it also is going to affect what else you can do on those turns so it can lead to some really like I get to any time this colors activated all of the ones on my Tableau of that color will activate as well so you can lead to some really interesting combos that go Way Beyond just the base action yeah and on top of the like you're playing out your cards to have those combos there's also all these different goals that everyone's kind of driving towards that are deciding where you are going to put things and it's a bit of this kind of Calico feel where you've got these three different goals telling you you have to put this kind of thing here well you've got like seven goals really telling you you have to put these like this and there's no way you are going to satisfy all of these goals and I always enjoy that in a game that like I just gotta let go of something and I'm I'm just I'm just doing the rose one I'm not going to worry about the columns one right now but but if you can get all the work it feels so good and it is tricky this is how you've won a lot recently is because it's done when somebody has completed their 16 cards and you have been getting that because I've been holding out to be able to achieve all of the goals and if you can get the 16 cards out you're usually in a much better position so you have to give up on some of them and that is my number 77. my number 77 is flamecraft and flamecraft is it's set in

this super adorable world where there's all of these shops and there's people and Dragons working together but the dragons are like non-threatening size they're like half the size of people they're super adorable and in the game it's a work replacement game so most of the time you're putting dragons on stores you're getting resources and you're using Dragon powers and you're adding more Dragon cards to the stores as well which are chaining different things but sometimes you're also putting out these cards which are like enhancements and then that's kind of scoring you the bulk of your points but it's cool because of how the game end triggers where you've got these two different decks one for the enhancement one one for the dragons and some games people are really driving to those enhancements and really getting their engines going and some games is just get more dragons get more dragons and so it can play really different from game to game yeah it is interesting because the pace ramps up throughout the whole game because it starts off with very few dragons and very few shots so the stuff you're getting isn't a lot and you get more and more as you go and you get more and more cards and so all of a sudden you are getting tons of resources or tons of points and really going through those decks and you've also got these like these Dragon goals as well that you can gain more of that also get you a lot of points too so there's a lot of little like customizable touches to it but mostly I just I I love I love the world I love the art and I want to see other kind of side games like how tidal blades does all based in this flamecraft world

just so I can see more of these dragons but that is my 77. my number 76 is Target and Target is a two-player only game and it only uses cards with no board but it's a worker placement game and how it does that is all the actions that go along the outside and then you put in new cards on the inside and when you put your workers down it's where they intersect that lets you do the middle bit so there's different things you have to consider you have to consider what action you want to do to where you want to put your workers on the outside and what cards you want on the inside to get your resources or get those Point scoring cards and what you might want your opponent to not get because they can't go opposite you so if you are see that there's a specific card they might be aiming for you can just stand on that spot or the opposite spot to block that or block the intersection so a big part of really what makes this interesting is you're usually it feels like doing your like second best or third best option on your turn and then just figuring out what what best can I do with this because you also want specific cards to go in this Tableau which is how you score and so you want the cars and your roads to be either matching or all different so it's important what you get in the middle but the other person knows that and they're going to get in your way all the time they definitely will and I feel like the

expansion helps make it not too frustrating because it does add another like off-board piece that you can put your worker on and a wild resource so you still get in each other's way but it does still let you do some things when you're feeling really stuck and makes it a full game and that is my number 76. my number 76 is revive which is a pretty new game and revive is a bit like now or never is this kind of large sandboxy game where there's a lot of different things going on but they all interact um really interestingly you've got this big shared board that you're exploring you're gaining resources from that you're putting out houses and different places on it and then you've also got your own little technology board where you're trying to move along these Tech tracks and add different Tech powers that you can set off on your turn and then you've also got this card system that's kind of the heart of the game where you're playing different cards to these different slots but you can put little bonuses that help give you extra resources when you do those cards and then you've also got asymmetric characters and I love asymmetric characters and all of this stuff works together in just these really interesting ways so it's pretty brain burning but it's also not too brain burny so there's just there's a lot to like here what I find really interesting is these are the same designers that did Trails of tucana which is a much lighter

game so I was really interested to what this heavier game would be and I do like those finding those combo I think one of the strongest Parts is the ability to stretch out the round because you might be able to find ways of doing things and I really like that if you're like oh I really want to explore but I don't have the reach and like oh I can use like lightning to get that extra reach finding those moments to make you feel really clever and those rounds too that's not necessarily like like it's like a game round that's set up everything in this game is kind of like this organically at your own pace so your rounds are really just what's in between your rest actions so it's how much can I stretch out and do everything or do I just want to do a few things and bring it back and do your strong cards and so revive's got a lot of interesting things going on that I want to explore a lot more and that is my 76. my number 75 is so Clover and this is a word guessing party game and I will specify that I really like it when we play it at two players I don't think it's even officially two players no this is a make-believe version this is a slight alteration of someone else's made up two-player only version and then we have since tweaked it to be our own two-player version but how we play it is how I really like it you get four cards that each have four sides and you have to match them up in your Clover where

each Leaf gets two word clues that you have to write something to help give a clue for whoever's gonna guess it afterwards so if I'm I have like shovel and rake I might write tools because all of those will come off a new card gets shuffled in and the other person has to try and line it up for all four clovers but playing with Sean he takes it a step further where it has to be a perfect clue so it would be like comfy furniture and be couch so instead of like one word that fits the umbrella of both of them those two combined make the word yeah I I think the one I'm proudest of is there was one that was like sticky and Satan and I had glucifer which I I feel very good about but yeah it really is finding I always want one to be a little bit funny and for them all to be like interesting how the two things connect because I don't just want it to be this thing is that category this thing is that category but these two together what would they be and that I think is the fun part but how we play is that you we have to get two perfect rounds back to back and if we don't get two perfect rounds it's a loss so they have to be exactly perfect back to back and it'll take us oh wow we won't stop until we nail it to but it will take us a while yeah I was gonna say we have to end on a win and we get tired and Tighter and it's creative and again harder but we do achieve it eventually it can take a while but that is my number 75. my

number 75 is VI counts of the West Kingdom and we're pretty big fans of the Shem Phillips games and specifically of the West Kingdom Trilogy which I think is by far his best and I've had a bit of a like an up and down with VI counselor I loved it at first and first it might have been my favorite of the West Kingdom trilogy but the castle is just overpowered and once we realized that the castle was overpowered it became this rush to the castle but they brought out all these expansions two different expansions this year that I think really go a long way to evening that out not by like nerfing the castle but by buffing everything else in the game so now building is a viable strategy and the books the manuscripts or viable strategy even just really focusing on the cards can be a strategy as well so it's become a lot more interesting although little bit more unwieldy game but it's definitely pulled me back into it yeah the expansions definitely helped even out all the options but I always like doing the castle and that may be why you don't like it so much because it's a bit finicky it maybe stops the game a little bit as people put out these meeples onto the castle and have to combo them up and across and over and that might set off another one which would set off another one but I love the combos I love when you can get lots of combos in a row it just can feel really satisfying but it is nice that now you can really focus on buildings or manuscripts or even just

have a more even strategy too and it's nice now that it is more balanced out because of those expansions and that is why it is my 75. my number 74 is civilization New Dawn and this is a Civ game but it plays so quickly I think that's what I like best about it instead of it being like a two plus hour it's like like for us like an hour full civilization experience and it uses the arc Nova or I should say Arc Nova uses its action selection system of the cards going out for what you can do and the longer it's out than the stronger the action that you can perform and like I just love that choice of do I do what I want to do that's at a lower value or do I wait a couple turns and do it when it's stronger and we didn't know if it would work for two but I I really like it it still feels like you get to you know you get to explore you get to build up your your strength of all your different actions you get to fight either barbarians or forts rarely each other which is nice yeah we rarely fight each other and the exploration actually comes from the expansion but we bought the expansion pretty much when we bought the base game so they're kind of intertwined for us and I think people do say you kind of need the expansion and I agree with that and this one I think just works really well at two yeah and it is one where the end game trigger is

when somebody has completed like a certain number of the goals so it can come at any time and I like that I usually am the one that triggers the end which often leads to the win which is great and that is my number 74. my number 74 is unmatched and I'm kind of just lumping the whole system in together because this is a whole lot of boxes now this fills most of a shelf for us now and I've been playing this since back when it was Star Wars epic duels and I was very excited to hear that that system was coming back and we just jumped into that with both feet but it is really fun to be able to match up like Beowulf versus Alice from Alice in Wonderland or like Houdini versus a T-Rex we've got a whole mishmash of stuff in this game it's just a great simple card blade card playing um like fighting game and you don't even really usually like fighting games but I I can sell you on this one yeah that is true this is one I am happy to play and I think it's just because all of the characters and and things do feel so different that it is fun to switch between like being the Raptors or be an invisible man and games are quick I mean they never really last more than 20 minutes so even if you have like a really bad string and you do terribly I mean you can quickly just start a new game soon afterwards and this is when we we generally play this in tournaments as well so we kind of play this in sports well we're we'll like draft like eight characters each and have a whole 16 character tournament and Jess always

acts like she's not good at this but she usually wins those tournaments and I've got the brackets to prove it I maybe I do win but it usually combat games aren't my favorite but this is one I am happy to play and it is my 74. my number 73 is rolling Realms and this is the second and right game on my list we love the Anne Wright games they are it's just so fun and quick and an easy setup and rolling Realms what it what it does really is adds so much replayability because even with the base one you have these different cards that represent the stonemeyer games and you play with like three of them each round and so the combination of which card you were playing was usually completely different like you might have like tapestry in between two castles and something else and and you're using the dice to be able to cross those off but but again they're all like little mini games they all get crossed off in different ways I think we've played this like like 50 bus times yeah and and like you said it was originally the stonemeyer games but it has now expanded to oodles I don't even know how many different cards we've got quite a few of them and there's some cool ones too like Arc Nova and Terra mystica and I think there might be a baron Parker honey Buzz which means yeah yeah there's a lot of cool games that are represented in this kind of specifically rolling realm style

I mean the card system and how interchangeable that is is it's a really cool idea yeah it uses cards with that you can use the um like dry erase markers on and that system works so well because you can have so many different kinds that you can just write on and and yeah we played it a lot the dice are nice big chunky Dice and it is my number 73. my number 73 is Star Wars rebellion and this is one we play like once a year and the only reason is this low on the list is that it is so hard to bring to the table it's enormous and because we play it so rarely we always have to relearn it there's a lot to it but that's also the plus side is it's enormous and there's a lot to it this is just a huge Star Wars experience and it really feels like Star Wars especially with the expansion which really tweaks the combat system in a really positive way and it adds a bunch of characters from Rogue one and I love Rogue one but this it's it's just got everything you would want from Star Wars it's got all the ships it's got big death stars it's got building death stars it's got sneaking around and as the rebels you've got to like hide out and just kind of build up a little bit until you can blow up that death star and as the Empire you're just trying to find and crush and I do always have to play the rebels in this though you are set on the Empire yes and it's

because it's so scary being the rebels because because the Empire have so many troops and so many ships and are like taking over the Galaxy and it's just your odds feel so slim as the Rebellion so I've tried it I think only a couple of times but each time I think I've been like too scared to move my planet and then you've just discovered me because I've just been like hunkering down hoping for the best whereas I mean you still do very well when you're the Rebellion but as the Empire I just feel like I have like such a better chance yeah Jess is just a fan of the overdog but I do like that hiding in the shadows and it is rare did I win this especially with the Rebellion but when you do is so exciting especially if you can win blowing up the Death Star which I think I've only done once I think I usually win by just being alive long enough to survive but even that is fun and this really is the Star Wars game and it is my 73. my number 72 is on Bond and this is a game that I like almost despite the theme because I'm not really that big into cars and in kanban you are running this car factory but it's a Vettel asserta game so his games are all very interconnected and I think this is the one that I connect with most because I think the part seem a little bit more visible there's you know there's car parts and car designs and you bring the

cars out and then you can like get those cars into the garage so as some of the other ones I find are maybe a few longer steps and how things connect and just like increase the the brain capacity a little bit more whereas this one still you really have to like focus on the game but there is something about I think it feels a little bit more approachable than some of the other heavier Lasorda games yeah it's it's a heavy game no doubt but it's just it's smooth it's like a really smooth it's like a welcoming heavy game and we've got the driver's Edition and I got to tell you I love it because it's half the price of the new version and honestly it's got everything that I want in it and I like it's kind of clunky colored clutteredness and like the look of the board and everything uh and this is it's just it's such a great lasserta game and I like Lasorda I like the idea of playing all assorted games sometimes they feel a little bit like work and this one never does it's just so smooth and it has so much going on but it just it makes so much sense because there is a lot going on but it seems I don't know it seems to all be almost displayed you can tell where you can get seats and you can tell what like half the goals are and all of it is enough that that spoiler alert this is my highest uh lesser Day game and it's my number 72.

my number 72 is gloomhaven and gloomhaven has fallen a little bit because it's it's been a while since we had the big gloomhaven experience but when we did gloomhaven was terrific it was really cool opening those boxes it was really cool playing through the whole campaign it was we were in it the tricky with it is I just have not been able to rekindle that at all the expansion honestly it's just straight up terrible the sequel Frost Haven is terrific and if you want more stuff it's got more stuff but it's just it's more stuff than what I wanted and I find that when we're doing The Outpost phase it just slows it down I don't I don't like crafting in games and I just feel like you know what I just I want to be in the dungeon and I want to play with the characters in the dungeon and I want to open up more characters and I want to fight some bad guys that's that's what I want in my Gloom Haven so I've even mulled over we've talked about it just taking the frost Haven characters and replaying through the gloomhaven campaign with them just playing original Gloom Haven and maybe we'll do that yeah because I think there's also cause of the lion which we both liked um but the tricky with that is you don't get the experience of retiring your characters and starting a new one and that was one of our favorite parts of gloomhaven was becoming an expert on a type of character and then having to learn a completely different character and because you don't get that with jaws even though you get to do a lot of the

fighting and it's kind of a smoothed out system that part was missing so maybe we do maybe we do take our Frost Haven characters and play through Blue Haven or we just keep mulling through Frost Haven I don't know I think if you're the sort of person though who sees that like a video game has 600 hours of gameplay and you see that as a positive you'll really like that I see that and I think I'm not touching that video game with anything just give me NHL 94 again so I think that's kind of where I'm coming from with it but I loved the experience of glue of gloomhaven and I would love to be able to recreate that experience again but it's still my 78 my number 71 is gingerbread house which is by Phil Walker Harding who is so great at making easy to learn and fun to play light Medium games and gingerbread house there's something about it that has become one of our Staples for we're not too sure what to play we're looking for one more quick game at the end of the night and I think it's when we played it so many times and it's so simple you are trying to get these fairy tale creatures by covering your board with Gingerbread whatever you cover is the gingerbread that you get and that can trap the fairy tale creatures but I don't know I I don't know what about it Stan makes it stand up from other ones as our go-to but it has just become that that game that we turn to yeah it's one of the it's one of the few it's like that in Ganymede in between two castles I feel like are the three that kind of

fill that and it's just I think it says something about us being board game addicts that we've got games that we play one more done playing board games but we're like oh we got we just we ain't one more just one more and then I'll go home but this is sold out one more and then I'll go home just easy Comfort game that I love it and the theme is so funny too that you're trying to capture and presumably murder fairy tale characters yeah it it does it does the winter list because of gingerbread and winter yeah but we play it all year round and it's my number 71. my number 71 is Suburbia and I I love city building games I love tile placement games and this is one of the best of both of those things mushed together and in Suburbia you're building a city you're building a little I guess Suburban City and you're building out residential and Industrial and Commercial and you're aiming for goals and it's got this really cool system where you're building up your population but as you do you kind of drop your income so you're trying to build both your population and your income but if your population grows too fast your income starts to decline because of how the scoring track works and you pass across these houses that drop your stats which kind of it's it's a really cool like ketchup mechanic for the game and just kind of slowing you down a little bit but we also we got the big collector's edition so so we've got all

of the expansions with that too in the expansions add a ton and I highly recommend doing the double Market variant but it's just do do a line of the of the original tiles and then you've got a line of all of the expansion tiles mushed together and then when you take one you just discard the other so you've always got two choices in every slot it's just so much fun that way you have so many choices and options and it it loosens it up a little bit but it's really fun and it is nice to always have the special tiles as an option because those add some like interesting different things so it's great that there's always one of those available as well as the base ones which you might want and it does a really great job of having to pick tiles and some of those tiles will activate based on what's your city but some of them also activate based on what's in other people's City so again you could be like really hoping that the other person collects a whole bunch of this thing because you'll end up with a lot of coins or or income or something as well so you're right it does city building and tile placement just so well yeah and those expansion tells some of them are kind of situational so it's nice having that double Market because then you can still have those situational tiles and they don't feel punishing but you still have the fun of having like a vampire Den or like some of the nightlife ones are really fun so you can still have those when it fits what you're doing and it doesn't hurt the rest of the game so it's great and it is my 71. and that is it that brings us to the end of the 70s

and next time we'll be counting down the 60s I've always wanted to say that counting down the 60s come back for all rock all day interestingly about our list none of the games we picked were the same for that chunk no that's we barely had any over this whole 30 but none in this ten not one I was so sure we would have at least an imperfect crossover but absolutely no crossover whatsoever I do think it might get a little bit similar as we go along but we'll find out as usual thank you so much for watching please let us know in the comments if you've played the games you liked any of the games that we've talked about and please like subscribe and hopefully we'll see you next time for another game foreign

Progress saved