Our Sister Kaitlyn’s Top Games of All Time (2025) | #10-1
Transcript
Hey, I'm Ryan. This is my brother Daniel. And this is Rolls in the Family. And we've got a special guest back. Definitely, you know, a week in the future from the even set aside the same clothes. Yeah. To make sure for consistency on the channel. That's right. Um, we are talking about our sister Caitlyn's top 10 board games of all time. Best of the best according to Caitlyn. Will we agree? Absolutely. Absolutely not. Probably not. But I'm intrigued. I will say there's I know there's some new games that I haven't heard yet that I will either be impressed how high they are or surprised that they missed cuz maybe they didn't make Well, I will say I always appreciate Caitlyn's list cuz you know Ryan, you know, we have some variants but we're pretty similar similar. Oh, Caitlyn's an absolute wild card. Who knows what's going to show up here. Who knows? So, buckle up, folks.
Yeah, we will have links to all these games down below if they sound intriguing to you and you would like to check them out. But without further ado, let's kick it off with number 10. Number 10, it's a new game this year. I've played it once and it's based off a video game. Number 10 goes to Clank Catacombs. Oh, Clank Catacombs. That's actually not based off a video game, is it not? I think you're thinking you're thinking of a a you're probably thinking of a different game that Ryan got this last year that's based off a video game. But I that's but she hasn't played that one. But she doesn't play that one. So you're absolutely not thinking of that one. Clank Catacombs. Is it really not? It's not. Uh Clank is actually an original game by the same company that does uh Dune Imperium in fact. And Catacombs is a newer version of it. Um great to hear this is so high on the list. Number 10 new. Yeah. This is so high because the game she played, she got to watch her boyfriend just be completely left behind to die in the depths of the uh Yes. Catacombs. That game I went for the strategy of versus staying in longer. I was close to the first relic that came out. I went I got it and then I got out right away. I would have been out a turn or two turn sooner if there wasn't like a 180° flip of the tiles, which you got to love those. something comes up and changes the map. And I that's why I think you were able to get out is cuz that that happened. But that kind of ruined my
boyfriend and yes, he died in the rubble of with the dragon. Yeah. Made for an overall very positive experience. Well, it's it is a I mean, it's an interesting just kind of feel to the game that I feel like you don't see very often of this whole kind of exploring out and then needing to kind of run back and the timing. Like in some ways, Ryan, it kind of almost just like from a timing perspective reminds me of almost Great Western Trail of a game where you're really trying to feel out the pace and your pace can change depending on what other people are doing will need to change. Yeah. like if somebody goes really fast, you need to figure out, you know, how you're going to deal with that. Um Yeah. And so out of the three of us, Dingo, you're the only one actually that can speak to Clank Catacombs versus other versions of Clank because you've played Clank in Space.
Yeah. Um, briefly, briefly, but I think all of us having played catacombs feel that the dynamic map element, which that's unique to Catacombs, the other ones just have a static board, is a huge part of the fun of the experience. Absolutely. Absolutely. Yeah. I I mean, again, it's everyone has their preferences. Some people might like the predictability of being able to like look at a whole map and see their path. I could I couldn't go back to playing with. It's just that is such an incredible benefit to be able to have this exploration feel. The tiles are so fun and interesting. I mean, there's so many times where we pull a tile and you're just like, "Oh, especially cuz you can orient it." Well, that's what I was going to say is you it rewards you for exploring cuz you get to decide and you have this decision of like how do I want to, you know, orient this? Yeah. And like what benefits me most? But then if you somehow land on that one and you get the 180 flip from the thing, you're like, "Well, now it's not how I want this piece to be at all."
Yeah. Right. So, I think that's a fun aspect. And then the dragon, I think that's a fun aspect whenever. Yeah. I mean, even once you're out, you get the fun of playing the I'm going to keep hitting everybody to try to Yeah. Yeah. This one I think has been a a winner so far with with both of you and other people I've played it with. Um, and is nice because it is sitting more in that like 60inute game. Um, and not overly complicated. Another deck builder though. Caitlyn. Oh, the deck builder. Changing the narrative on Caitlyn and the deck builder. The narrative. Yeah, maybe it's it's only deck builders designed by Paul Denen. Yes, it's the same designer. It's the same designer. Junior narrative. Juniper and Clint are the same. There you have it. There you have it. There you have it. Has he made any others? Uh, that's a good question. I think he's got a new game coming out that's going to have like bag building kind of like Quacks. I don't know much about that. Well, Kaitlin needs to check that out. Check it out.
Number nine. Number nine. New to the list this year and I I actually bought the game myself and I was telling Ryan I need to play it again with you. So, I'm just reminded how to play. I was surprised when I sent you the list that this wasn't I didn't realize you hadn't played it. It was a while since I played it. So, I was like, I need a better opinion on it. But number nine goes to Cascadia. Wow. Okay. I you know it's funny. I did see that you bought Cascadia and didn't realize how much you liked it. Yeah. I think it's a like pairing like the animal with the tile and making your terrain, trying to build up the terrain to be bigger and that kind of stuff. I just kind of enjoy that. I think with the puzzle, it's a little bit of a puzzle for me. like Tetrisy type thing. Putting that together cuz I want my terrain to be all nice looking. Not just have like a random mountain and this there, that there. Yeah. I I do care about it being bigger, which does give you points in the end. Your biggest It incentivizes you to to do that. Exactly.
Um, but also I just like the different aspects of like, oh, I want this tile, but that has a hawk with it and I can't put hawks next to each other because they're Yeah, the paired drafting adds a lot of just interesting decisions. Yeah, it's a game It's a game that allows a as you know, we've said a lot like as much thinking as you want. Like I I think that's what I like about it is I can we've play I've played this with people who aren't super, you know, gamery and the rule set's very simple and yet I'm over here like crunching how to like optimize this. Every hawk get the maximum number of points. I've done it. Yes. Yes. Yeah. I think it's it is interesting because I think oftent times we peg you Caitlyn with like oh Caitlyn likes these really interactive games and like but there are certain games that are more in that like work on your puzzle genre that you do enjoy quite a bit. So, Cascadia is one example. It is.
And I feel like Cascadia since it's a little bit of work on one of those your own things where I could just like pull it out with one other person, just a two-player game. Cuz like there's other games that I own that I'm like, "Okay, it's fine with two people." But you prefer a bigger group with it. And Cascadia, I would say, can fit well with kind of any number that not pulling out Cosmic with uh two people. Not pulling out Cosmic. Not pulling out uh What was the other game? Killer Bunnies. I got Killer Bunnies again recently. Oh, which I can only presume is coming up in this video. It's true. Number one still for the take. It's true. But I made a joke about Killer Bunnies in the last year's video being in my top 10. But then my boyfriend got it for me for Christmas and he said it was super hard to find.
So I taught it to him again recently. Like it was fun with two, but like that's definitely like a game where I'm like I want to choose who you're at least. For those who don't know at home, Killer Bunnies was kind of our whole Yeah. started it all. You're watching this channel today because of Killer Bunny. You better go pick up a copy. 17 years ago. Is it really that long? Yeah. And No, it's true. There's no uh there's no spite if there's only one other person to attack. So Caitlyn doesn't get to But enough about killer bunnies. That's right. Cascadia. A nice a nice relaxing p. Honestly, couldn't be more different than killer. Yeah. Have it. It's true. Okay. What are we at? Eight. My number eight. It dropped.
But still, it dropped. It's still warms my heart in the top 10. It's um a card game where you want to play like full houses. There's a bomb. You could play some special cards. Number eight goes to teach you. M still firmly in the top 10. Still firmly in the top 10. There's just a lot of good memories surrounding it. And unfortunately, the core group I now play it with isn't really all together. It it's less frequent that we have the opportunity. There was a stretch there. We had like a group of four with two of my two my friends and Caitlyn and I would actually normally partners in this game. Yeah. For a while. So, man, I thought we were a good team. I had an incredible game at Tichu like I don't know a month or two ago and it just like we've I if you've watched this channel we rave about this little card game.
Gosh, it's I I almost feel like with how cheap it is, it's like how can you not buy it? I mean unless you hate trick taking games like you need this specific group. You need to be like I'm going to have exactly four people that are going to play that same group. But for the money they give you two decks. Yeah. You want to play with the red deck or the gold deck today? Exactly. I I think you know, and I don't know if you guys kind of agree with this, but Tu feels like the one kind of card game that has elevated to where it competes with board like bigger board games in our rankings and stuff like it feels like this big satisfying experience when you have a good teacher game. Exactly. Yeah. And I think the passing of the cards aspect is interesting too cuz obviously you'll give lower cards if possible to like the people on the other team, but then what you pass to your partner like you could pass them the dog like I have a really good hand. I hope they can take the trick once and I'm kind of hoping that's a teacher round for me and they can give me the trick.
But it's also then for that your partner knowing when to take the trick. Yeah. I love how you love how you're not only giving a card to them to use, but it's your one way to communicate anything with them. And so it's like sometimes I have things where it's like, okay, it's better for me if I give them this, but that's actually not like what are they going to think and that might not actually be what I want them to think if I give them this card. Um, so it's very interesting. Yeah, it's uh it is amazing, Ryan, because as you were saying that I mean when you're choosing to play Tichu, I mean I'm choosing that instead of I mean four people that's the best group number like you're talking about a a full game, you know, one of our bigger games. If you're playing a full game of Tu and yet and yet I feel like if we have if we ever have a group where they all like Tichu and there's four of us, it's like how can we not play Tichu? Yeah. Like you know what I mean? It's like we have the group. We got to make it happen.
Absolutely. We are pretty good about making it happen when we had our core four. Yeah. We're going to we're going to have to find the opportunities. I guess your boyfriend hasn't played Chich. He hasn't. And Toby's grown up. Yeah. Toby, you know, it's only matter of time. You don't need to know how to read to play. No. Didn't know what a number is. Yeah. Cool. Cool. Cool. Cool. Classic. Number seven. Another new game this year. Man, good year. Beating out Chichu. Beating out Chichu. I've played it twice and it's another like puzzly aspect of the game and I enjoy the four tracks on the side that you have to work on building up. This was one I was wondering about. This is pretty high. It's pretty high. But uh number seven goes to Planet Unknown. It's I don't know. It spoke to me when I played. I had no I had no Yeah, it spoke to Daniel, too. I looked around the table and this game was speaking to a lot of people. Um, this is one I did not know. I had like no prediction on whether you were going to like this game or not, but when we were playing I was like I was like Caitlyn's liking this. I could tell.
It's Yeah, I think it's one of those again. It's a little bit of your in your own world kind of after literally it's like lazy. That was a good pun. Lazy Susan uh Yeah. turns it that you have to pick a tile out. Then you have your four things on the side. you move up the track for depending on what terrain you get. But then like like as I was thinking about on the way here was like sure like if you move up on the water quickly great you're getting points faster but then in like the gray or the tech one you're not getting to look at the round cards as much and the other people are getting those and Mhm. I think I lacked how important those are cuz those are good. They're very civ cards. It is one of the hard things to teach on like a first because it's like and if you go up on the safe track, you'll get to draw from the mystery pile and it's like well how as a new player do you like quantify that? I really should like show an example from each to just be like here is kind of the level of impact these are. Um but yeah, it is one of those games where you you want to do everything. You're like I really want to go up on this track. Oh, but it's really good if I go up on this track.
But you can't you can't do it all. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. And I think you mentioned this in one of your videos recently. We played with the uh special planets. Yeah. In one of our last videos. Yeah. You were in that game. I had the I think it was the fire planet. Oh yeah. Yours was like a lack of a planet. You had to like go around it. Had to go around it. Yeah. You ended the game too early. I was not happy about that. I wasn't trying. I could put a piece down. But um I enjoyed like I had to think about the ecosystem the green one because I couldn't go up on it unless I was making girl bigger. So the first green piece I play down corporation was really weird. It like had these double green spaces and you got to like choose the reward but you only like moved up if you were expanding an existing green area. Um, and we talked about this when we we I think it was in our top play video that we were talking about Planet Unknown that those corporations, I mean, the three that we had was putting us on wildly different feeling games and I'm not sure we were really that aware of what other people were doing. Absolutely no idea. Um, but talking about it afterwards and even when I just like explained them, I'm like, man, these are like really really different and that's super cool in that game.
Yeah, this was one of the best first impressions I've had of a board game playing it. Just saying something. I've seen I I just If this was a movie, I'd have a flashback to all Daniel's reactions within the first two minutes of Was this the earliest uh declaration? I don't think so. I don't think so. But we're like the first turn in the game. Totally positive. But man, it just mechanics. It has like so many things. I love simultaneous play. uh polyomino pieces tight you know fitting things together going up on tracks comboing like lazy susanss lazy susanss I will play any game with a lazy susan man and it's so great it is like I mean obviously they like need it to make the game work but the design is just perfect it is such a functional way of making that mechanic work so well and quick for everyone and that that simultaneous play you feel like you've done the equivalent of what you would do in like a 2hour or longer game. I feel like I've played terrible and then we look at the clock and we're like, "Oh, we were like just over an hour." And that's awesome. It is. Another thing I like about it is the only way you are kept accountable to like kind of the people around you is those uh objectives that are in between you and the people next to you. Yeah, I enjoy that aspect. It gives you a reason to still peek over. I do really like that. Yeah. though, not like completely in your own world cuz like yeah, you're scoring for stuff on your board, but it's like, oh, but if they beat you out on that, that's like five points you're missing out on. Yeah. And I like that
it's not just objective for every like that. I don't know. I for some reason the fact that it's just just you for this one and just you for this one. I like the narrow aspect of it. Well, and you're the only person that cares about those two because each of your neighbors has some other thing that they're trying to do in addition, right? And so it I like that uniqueness of it. Mhm. It was interesting thinking back to our last game. I think it was your wife uh Daniel that had the the Mars kind of like the red ones where she needed the biggest red. Oh yeah, her too. But also the least amount of red, the most different groups. She needed the biggest one. And we were like, "Oh, that's kind of unfortunate." But I think she did well in it because she just if you go really hard on it. Yeah. It's true. Yeah. I'm glad both of you had such positive experiences cuz this is one I was definitely excited about getting. I had such high hopes for this one going up to six players simultaneous playing just a lot of things going on and I think it's clearly clearly delivered. It's a winner. Winner. I mean it made my top 10. So I mean it didn't make the top five but that's right. Absolutely not.
Need a couple more plays for that. Yeah. All righty. We're at number six. Oh number six. I thought that was Ryan thought he was making a great transition, but number six. This is another fitting stuff together. Not physically pieces. You're drawing the pieces. They've got some seasons. Number six goes to ctographers. Nice. Another Polyomino puzzly one. Wow. Did not know you liked this one that much. Yeah, we um we played it again recently and I think it was with my boyfriend again. I just I don't I like the aspect of trying to figure out how you want to piece stuff together and the different terrains and like I think I mentioned this last year because I think it was in my top 20 somewhere last year of spring. You're scoring this like the first round, but then you don't sort of spring again until like the very last round. So like and you see it all up front. Yeah. I love that you know kind of what you're going after. Like even though spring scoring this round, I could prep a little bit for next round so I'm not scrambling, but I do like the aspect of scoring differently each round and Right. Yeah. Yeah. This one I I love cgraphers. It's it's one of my favorite in this genre. Um, I think the combination of the variable goals always making it feel different, but then it so does what I want in this type of polyomino game where it gets more and more constrained as you go and you get to play that end game where you're feeling pretty constrained. Like there's
some games that I feel like don't let you get that far like and we love that like that really trying to puzzle things in and like did I set myself up for this? I mean, all in a pretty short playing time. And, you know, it's so kind of functional with the actual drawing on it. We have laminated and used wet erase on them, which is great. Just go rinse it off at the end. Right. Um, but yeah, I'm I'm glad I can. It's always nice cuz Caitlyn lives here in in the same area. Not in that studio. Not in this studio. Yeah. We occasionally let her out. You never know. You never see her sleeping behind the camera. Yeah. So, keep quiet, Caitlyn. We're filming. Um, no, but Caitlyn ends up coming, you know, to more of my game days than I have opportunity to do with like Daniel. So, it's always nice to hear that she likes games that I also like. Yeah, it'll actually be more readily available now.
Caitlyn graduated from nursing school and has a job as a nurse. I do. Thank you. Starting July. Let's go. Congratulate Caitlyn in the comments below. Big things ahead. Okay, we're to top five. Speaking of big things, my goodness. Oh my goodness. This is number five. Still in my top five, but it dropped. I think it was my number two last year. Oo. Number five. I didn't look at your western last year. It's got some more. It's got some conflict. Oh, yeah. Oh, yeah. Number five, Yellow and Yansy. Yeah. I I still just like the chaos that this game can cause. Mhm. I'm like, I'm losing, but we're going to cause chaos. I think you've gotten better though at like doing it to your own benefit and I think so there were some early games in Yang. It's like I don't think that helps you. Um but you recently I think won this right for the first time. I think I won the last time we played. Yeah, that had to that's a that's a big one to win. That's and it was a fourplayer game with like not solo with like heavyhitting participants. I'm not just talking about myself. Just saying this was a very competitive four-player game of Yellow of Yang and came out on top.
Yeah. No, it was good. I Yeah, I like the aspect of the game. I do think I'm better about not causing chaos. That hurts me. There was one time I think it was with friend Steve. We did it where I went I think it was to war against him. That the one where you just go one-on-one and not between all the leaders. Uh that would be a revolt, I think is the terminology. Um but I was convinced. I had like three of the color I needed to do the attack black tiles and I go for it and he was like, "Oh, I wouldn't do that if I were you." But I was like, "I'm confident with what I know. You can bluff." I'm like, "He's bluffing like." And so I went for it. I lost. And then he attacked me on his very next turn and he still had more of the stuff, the color to attack me. Yeah.
It was a It was a dark dark two turns for Caitlyn Caitlyn's uh positioning of the board. That game can have that. Yeah, things can happen and you can end up that you have all your leaders off the board and you're like, "How am I going to get back in this?" Um, but you've played this one quite a few times now. Um, yeah, it's it's really unique. I mean, there's not a lot of games I have like it. It rewards like creative play. I feel like, man, you're just looking at the map trying to figure out how in the world am I going to, you know, make a clever move. And man, when you pull something, there's so much opportunity for just, oh wow, that was a really interesting move that you It's brilliant that they give you two actions cuz that's what adds so much creativity is because you can do a first thing that like opens the door to then lock something in with your second action.
Absolutely. Yeah. Yeah. Good one. There you go. More conflict. Wait, we for a second there I was like, I don't know. Caitlin's had a change of heart. We've had Cascadia, Planet Unknown, Ctographers. Is it just the time for a new year? New year, new Kaitlin. Low conflict puzzly games, but Yo and Yang is pretty high conflict. The The next one's definitely not conflict among players, at least. We're a We're a team on this one. Okay. Team number four investigators. Yeah, number four. We're a team of investigators. It's been a while since I've played it, but it's just near and dear to my heart. Number four, Eldrich This feels like one that's going to be high on your list for a long time. Like, and it's been high on Dango, but it's like it isn't just a like new game that you're It's like we've been playing this for over a decade. Have had so many good games of it. Absolutely. Then just getting the different characters. Like one game you could be like, I'm the I'm the fighter. That's what I'm built for.
And then the next one you could be like, well, I'm gonna go into gates, I guess. Like that's what I'm useful for this game. So I like the different like uses you can be used for and just it's just a good game. I mean, between the locations and having to get to read different cards, even in like the wilderness, city or sea, when you flip those cards, you could read the sea for one location, but like the city's completely different. So, and I have all the expansions. So, the amount of event cards, like the possibilities, I mean, I know for a fact that I haven't seen a ton of them, and that's cool to go into the game and now there's the ones that somehow end up, you know, we we've said before, how many times do I have to wake up in the past and open the closet door and have my father almost kill me for some reason that card finds its way to the top of our deck on every shuffle? But, um, it is a sandbox. I was thinking about that just the how much of a sandbox that game is. It feels like a lot of newer games are leaning more into whether it's campaigns, story driven, but as a result more controlled environments. And I think that's one of like there's still variability and stuff, but I think that's one of the things we love about Eldrich is it's like it can who knows where this thing is going to go, right?
And there's a lot of things about like Eldrich and honestly a lot of the games in that era of Fantasy Flight games that I think in today's age is almost like labeled as kind of like slo less elegant game design and it's maybe not following best game design principles. But I think there's a lot of people and ourselves included that it's like yeah but it gives you something that you don't get like from some of these other games. And like, you know, sometimes that's what you want is kind of this little messier experience that has a lot more swinginess and what could happen and like maybe you're taking on more risk of a bad game. Well, we've had some games of Eldrich that are among some of our favorite gaming experiences. That's unbelievable.
So, don't be afraid, you know, of game designers out there. I think there's still people, you know, and there's probably examples of newer games that have come out, but I think you're right that we see less of this type of game design philosophy with most new games, right? Yeah. There you have it. Four. Eldrich number four. Mhm. Number three. I This did not make my top games last year, but playing it, I just in thinking about it, I was like, "What?" Okay, so just to clarify, this is not a new game. It was outside of your top 20 and it is now your number three. I'm pretty sure big time. Let's flash the alarms. This is big time. Here we go, folks. What happened? Number three.
Wonderland's War. Wonderland's War. Well, yeah. I think last time you had probably played it once and I think we've played it again since then. Wow. I did not realize how much you liked this game. Yeah. Yeah. I like the aspect of so you have the the the tea party phase and you go around the table and you get your cards and you do that for is it three rounds? You end up picking I think three or four cards and they give you all kinds of things like you might add chips to your bag and for the record Daniel has not played this yet. So Daniel does not Yeah, he's not as familiar with it. But you're you're doing a lot of bag building, right? things, but you might also be upgrading your character, getting these, you know, there's a or getting a Wonderland that you now have a unique kind of character that's all going to feed into that area control area.
And it's just I mean like that phase and then going and like pool of tears or red's keep and like those different areas you have to then battle for and like victory points. I think that's such an interesting aspect of the game. And then there's somebody you draw out of the bag. And yeah, I mean it kind of takes like the push your luck in a game like Quacks. That's now how you resolve the battles is everybody's going up the battle track and you have to decide like how far do you push and yeah, it is a very interesting just like yeah way that all does the area control the heroes and their powers. It's just there's a lot going on. I mean there's a lot with the character abilities and it's a very lavish production. It looks very good on the table. It does. Um, I will say I it it makes me happy to see this so high because it means that I still my predicting of what games you're going to like is still somewhat right cuz I I was like this game just feels like it has your taste written all over it cuz I know you like the bag building piece and then I know you like kind of the conflict area control piece. It's like this just feels like should be a hit.
True. And look at that. Number three. Big hit. Yeah, Daniel's got to play this one. I do need to play this one. There you go. Bring it. Bring it out with you. It's not mount. There you go. Yeah, it's always hard to bring on a vacation cuz it's a big box and it's got so many pieces and you need a huge table for it and Yeah, you got a minivan. You can fit it. Wow. Brand new. I mean, brand new to the list. I would say like last year it probably was just a little too early to say. Like I think it was like one recent. That's what I'm surprised to think Catacombs made my list cuz I've played that once. That's true. Damn it. I needed a little bit more of a taste of Wonderland. Man, I am intrigued by these top two though. Um, yeah. I feel like one of them has to be Well, let's just one of them, but we'll see. Yeah. Well, I think you know the one then the one you know is coming. It's been dethroned.
It's been dethroned. It's still number two. Still number two. Still in I'm still in shock. I've been shocked for a whole year after finding this out last time. But number two is Tournament at Avalon. I still just got that very teacher take which I like. Yeah. But then just the mind games of should I play the higher sword now or like is someone then going to play the higher card loses the round? Just got a nice twist on oh something about the game. It's like I mean you like tricktaking games or games like Tichu. It takes that type of game and like throws it through the cosmic encounter lens of let's just have wacky powers and things that happen and like you sacrifice a lot of the control and maybe some of the like how much your strategy is actually going to like lead to you winning to just fun situations and craziness and funny moments and It's a wild game. It's not for everybody, but it's for Caitlyn. Yeah.
Dana, what are your thoughts? Well, here's the I feel like I can't really speak to my thoughts because what I played it once once and it probably wasn't the best, but but easily I mean, probably of your the biggest discrepancy between your opinion of a game and of of a game you like and and me. Um, I can totally see why you like it honestly, like you know, talking about it more. Um it's it's definitely got elements of other games that you've talked about. Uh but man, number two, that is it's not number one at least that Yeah. Yeah. And I mean, we've I will say we've played it with probably the ideal like as far as the people like um and you haven't had the opportunity to play with quite that type of group. That's true. That said, this is way lower for me. I mean, I I like it, but it's not Yeah. I don't think it's in my top 50. I mean, this is her a gricula, Ryan. Yeah, almost. Almost. Yeah. Don't say a Gricola number two in the same sentence.
It makes me sick. I No matter what the answer is here, I'm going to be surprised on Yeah, cuz Yeah, just give me like I just need like a moment to like take a, you know, take a pause and think. I think I know what it is. You think you know what it is? Okay. But you'll be surprised. But if it's not it, I'm going to be surprised that what I'm thinking missed the whole top. Yeah, I know. Well, that's what's funny about when you get to a number one is it's either this or off the list. Surprise either way. So, Kaitlin, here we go. Here we go. Drum roll. I'm sure our mics pick that up really well. Number one, I won't leave you in suspense. Number one goes to Arcs.
Wow, that is a big Look at that. So, that's a new new to the list. That is new to the list. We have only to number one. Wow. How about that? That's pretty impressive. That's pretty crazy. Is that the game you were thinking? It was the game I was thinking. Well, I I just I'm terrible at guessing. Uh, but not surprising, honestly. Like, it's a game Caitlyn should like. Yeah, it's But number one. Yeah. Caitlyn, tell us about Tell us about art. Oh man. Yes. The first time I played I did awful. It was terrible. I think I scored like three points. The game can be But I gave it a chance again. Why you give it a chance? Favorite game. Did I? I think you won the second time. I think I won and then we played. It was us three and then Steve and it was back and forth between Steve and I and I just took second to him. But this is a game where I'm like I feel like I just do really well at this.
Actually, Dangga was in that game with with Steve as well. He must have been so far behind it felt like a three-player game. I don't even remember. No, that was you, Ryan. Yeah, remember I stole Yes. Oh, I I finally remember that. Excuse me, Ryan. Don't let It's the It's the It's gone down in legend seats here of how Ryan was able to double down on a ambition and then have everything ripped away. You have talked about how I ripped away your dreams on this channel. I had to try. Had to try. But um I just Yeah, I enjoyed that aspect. And then I'm in the campaign mode with you. Yeah. In fact, that's probably what's happening later today is continuing Bllighted Reach. You're going to play your number one game today, which it'll be very interesting to see once we finish that, being able to have the conversation of like what you think of the campaign versus just the standalone. I don't think we can really speak to the campaign too much right now based on our one play. It's true. The only thing I can speak to about the campaign is it starts out there's that like the empire or whatever that's like the neutral ground and you're not allowed to attack each other unless someone becomes an outlaw. Well, the race I got was like you want to become an outlaw basically as soon as you can.
Yeah. So my first turn I outlawed which meant I could be attacked but then it also meant I was the only one being attacked by the other two players. So it was like moment between I know I did what I needed to but it was getting frustrating. You were frustrated. Then we had to keep reminding you that you were doing quite well. And in fact did win the game. I did. I did. I I I did win the game. Yeah. And I think I'm somewhere off in space just by myself cuz I had some card that's like, "Oh, you can revive like two." Yeah. Right. At the end of our game cuz at the beginning of the campaign like twothirds of the map is all covered in this blight and you're kind of all in the non blight section. M um but right at the end Caitlyn made this like big move around and like got rid of blight. And so starting in this next game, she's got this like little outpost that's like way out by itself and I'm just chilling.
That is that's crazy. But on paper, this game again sounds like a game you should like. It's driven by a core tricktaking card mechanism. It's got some of those elements. You you definitely love those types of games. It is You are not going to find a more interactive game than this. My gosh, it it might be the most interactive me that I like. Um it is man the competition for those ambitions and just the ambitions but also needing to make sure you like have a card to be the ambition but if someone else is leading and they lead the card that like is the one you want to use the ambition for can't play out of suit. So it's just this whole interesting aspect of balancing when to play cards what you need to save for to try to claim ambition. It's just a good Yeah, I got I feel like the line here between people being frustrated with the hand management and like loving the puzzle of it is very like this narrow line. I think this is everything in it is hard.
It's just like hard to do what you want to do and and like you're either going to look at that and be like this is frustrating because it's hard or you're going to be like this is such a cool puzzle that's hard to solve. Well, that's what I think is so funny about this game getting so much just attention is it's incredibly divisive like in terms of whether you'll like it or not. I mean, and most people I would venture to say won't like it and like it's not the right game for them. Yeah. But it's one of those games and this is true of, you know, games like Root and and other ones by this designer where if you like it, it might be your favorite game of all time, right? like it's got that type of DNA that the people that do like it are going to love it, right? I do think maybe I mean compared to like a route which like teaching I mean even just learning the game is like this one has a little bit of an easier onboarding to the game um which might help with uh maybe a little bit of a wider appeal than than something like that. So I would argue that the tension and the scoring is almost more polarizing in art.
route. Yeah, it's just so I mean I think the big thing is the fact that the only things that score are those ambitions and it's all like zero some or like if I come and steal something from you, I knocked you down one for me to go up one. Yeah. I mean, and so that's so much of the game is constant paranoia of how are people going to come and steal things from me and also where can I, you know, position myself to go up? I know it's both trying to like make moves while also not leaving like leaving yourself vulnerable to like you know it's man it is just a fascinating fascinating tension. Yeah. Well that was with you when it happened to your game when you doubled up on the ambition cuz you had all the fuel and the material. I was like I kind of have a shot to go at him here. Oh and I knew I knew you had a shot. I knew our other friend had a shot. But like the thing is you don't it's not like you have lots of opportunities to declare the ambitions that you want. Oh no. Like if you get a lead and you have a card that you can declare the ambition. It's like I either do it or I'm not going to get this chance again. Yeah. Um Exactly. Yeah.
It's it's a wild game. There's really nothing like it. There really isn't. Um, I am so pleased that you like it so much because if you didn't, it would be hard for me to justify keeping it honestly cuz I don't have that many people that are going to play this type of game with me. But that said, instead it's Caitlyn's number one. And in fact, we're going to go play it here in a little bit. Well, it's just us now. They've left to go play arcs and it's just you and me. But hey, if you want to watch another video that I'm in, you can click right here. We'll see you in the next