Skip to main content
Loading video...

Top 10 Board Games That Lived Up To The Hype - Chairman of the Board

Transcript 23:03

before i get started on today's video i just want to say a massive thank you to alexander lindqvist for um choosing to back me on patreon i thank alexander um that means a lot to me and um i hope you enjoyed today's video hey everybody today i'm talking about my top 10 games that lived up to the hype so these are the games where i was generally late to the party i'm playing and by the time i did get to play them they were already tremendously successful you know had a lot of praise i'm really highly rated and people generally telling me you know you've got to play this game because it's the it's the best thing since sliced bread um and when that happens i think naturally as as people uh kind of defenders go up and think you know what these can't be as good as you think they are and it just puts even more pressure on the game to live up to your expectations and if anything that that's a huge praise on these games to overcome that hurdle and still impress me so these are ten really great games and another thing as well these games have a a big scope in terms of being really light to pretty involved in heavy games so let's get started at number 10. so at number 10 i have that's pretty clever organ sean clever so a couple years ago this game um took off massively everybody's saying it's a great filler game one of these first roll and write games where you are drafting dice and writing numbers on your little board and getting combinations and trying to basically puzzle out to get as many points as you can um and when i got to play this one i thought you know it's not gonna be all that it's just another role and write game by god is this game fun this game is probably one of the most addictive and

satisfying games that i've played in my whole board gaming career um really good fun now quick engaging decisions a great solo mode um just yes that that status uh faction you get on playing this game and com combining your different um abilities to trigger one another and things um and people will say you know this this is a game that i played you know 200 times just trying to beat my own score and i think you know what i i've not got any i'm not that interested give i gave it a go not thinking much of it and then before i knew i played the game you know 70 times absolutely uh great fun and um one i think still one of the best roll and write games and um just just because of that synergies and the combinations and the the the kind of domino effect of one thing triggering another gunshot clever by wolfgang wash fantastic little filler game and next up at number nine i have the quacks of quevenberg so this one is a bit of a strange game because when it first came out i think in germany it was starting to get a bit of buzz before it got to everywhere else and people think you know what is this game it's it seems to be getting popular over there um and then it started kind of um gaining momentum and cascading into you know into england and such and um you know people saying this game is fantastic it's such good fun it's a pushy luck game and with an element of bag building and funny enough another game by wolfgang wash so he's got the 10 and nine space here um and i was thinking you know what i'll give it a go i managed to go to a to a games club but by this time you know the game had

already had a lot of window under its sails really popular people singing from the rooftops about it give it a go and thinking okay very simple rule set i like bag building i like pushy like let's give it a go and by round two i think i was absolutely hooked just enjoying myself like i hadn't been in a long time um and just yeah loving what this game was delivering really fast-paced really satisfying pushy luck um gameplay where you're drawing stuff from a bag trying not to make your potion explode that incentive of just pushing more and more and more was really visceral with this one because you got abilities not only for um you know for getting points but you've got the ability to invest in getting new ingredients for your bag as well and i thought it was just a perfect storm of these simple mechanisms that build your bag building and pushing up that came together wonderfully and um yeah before the night was through i think we ordered a copy and um probably one of the most popular games of the last two years just in general a family weighted game not much to it but what it does it just does wonderfully and there's just an element of magic about it that i can't quite put my finger on that is uh quacks of quedlinberg at number nine at number eight i have awkward guests so this was a game actually um it was the dice tower that got this onto my radar tom vassell was saying that this is uh the best deduction game he's ever played you know he's uh he's a big fan of deduction as i am and so is my brother who we play a lot of games together um and you know deduction games have been out for a while there's not really much new that goes on

in that genre just slightly tweaks on the existing games um and but again by the end of the first game i was like i couldn't agree more this is by far the best deduction game i've ever played um just a most satisfying puzzle as you were trying to um deduce who the murderer is for this particular case who is a have they got an accomplice what weapon did they use what you know where did they do it and why did they do it but what was their motive etc and um this game just took it to the next level in terms of having a physical blueprint of the building and you've got to map out where the murder has been you know who they've spoken to who've seen them etc just an absolutely wonderful puzzle um that has this brilliant deck building system or cut kind of um scenario building system where you take lots of budget uh different cards from uh and mesh them all together and that will give you a unique scenario about who's you know who's going to be the murderer what weapon they've used etc so infinite replayability based on this deck system and um you know since i've got this one almost every other deduction game is just being knocked down a peg because nothing can chin up to this one it's just so good um it's still quick but still being really involved just the the drama of it the satisfaction of working out who it's going to be it's mind-boggling you've got to think outside the box sometimes um and there's a great scalability as well in terms of its difficulty you know you want a really easy scenario then go for it or do you want a really hard mystery that you've got to solve

then you can do that too i think it's just a one-stop shop for deduction games just absolutely phenomenal and certainly lived up to the hype um my initial impression was of this game next up at number seven i have maracaibo now by alexander fister who at this time is um one of my favorite designers ever but when maracaibo came out i was a fan of fista but only played a couple of his games i think i played mombasa and some of his lighter games and people were saying um you know maracaibo is just the his magnus opus it's the best game he's ever had it's a mix of all the different games he's built before then and it's just that you get another a meshing of all his previous designs that was just a perfect example of what he can do um and i i i don't know what stopped me from playing this one as quickly as i probably should have you know i probably played this about a year after it came out and again as soon as i played it wow that game has everything i like about euro games it's got hand management it's got um kind of stocks and shares it's got uh engine building it's got like a rondelle it's got tracks it's got everything um a bit it's just a feast for all in terms of euro games while still not being i don't think it's as intimidating as the rule book would suggest i mean there are a lot of rules in this game i said it is pretty much everything but the kitchen sink in this game but it manages that in a wonderful kind of um casing that's not too overwhelming i think once you've played it

it's not one of those games you've got to keep relearning again and again because it's pretty intuitive um and still i think i played almost every alexander vista game now and this one is quite noticeably above the rest of his designs at least in my eyes i know a lot of people like great western trail but for me um maracaibo is just uh the best of the best it's one of the best games i've ever played i think it's in my top 10 at this point and um yeah i don't see it moving from there any time soon just just absolutely wonderful one of the best euro games i've ever played one of the best kind of heavier games i've ever played and um yeah just cannot say a bad word about this one would play this one anytime and that incentive to go back to it as well as there because the game does actually have a a very uh interesting but slight uh narrative to it which um just just adds that extra wrinkle of enjoyment for me personally wonderful game maracaibo at number six i have hansa to tonica now this is a game that is really much a staple the backbone of the kind of euro designs this one's by andrea steading and has been out since 2009 so this one still spoke about really highly today people say it's one of the classic euro designs uh one that's not scared to get in your face and interact with your opponents in almost a nasty way um people saying you know this is one of the best games out there that you need to have in your collection i was skeptical to play it not only because um i'm a little bit of a care bear player but

when i got this to the table finally the big box version because it was out of print for a long time um i just sat back and i can look objectively out and think you know what this is a phenomenal design clean crisp mechanisms you know just putting cubes down on the board trying to build routes but blocking other players making them not invested get you out the way so you can get bonuses um trying to control these different cities investing in your playable to get upgrades and do more actions and get get into the more valuable spaces in those cities this game is just so well put together it's streamlined to a t uh just a a great stripped back clean euro game with no blokes whatsoever and i think when games can stand the test of time and just be praised for you know ten plus years um there aren't many games that do that and hands into tonight is just a perfect example of that and now i've got to play it i think you know what yeah this is everything people were saying it was just a true classic design and uh one that certainly lived up to the hype for me that one is handed to tonica at number six at number five i have a game it's kind of a similar vibe to hazard to tonic not not in its gameplay but in the sense that it's stood the test of time people spoke about it for a long time a real a real kind of cult classic and um one that's remained high in the board board game geek rankings for a significant period this one is power grid by friedman freeze this one is an economic game

that looks pretty bland i think from the face of it a bit like handsome tonic does really where this one you are basically um doing auctions for these power plants and then buying the resources on this kind of fluctuating market and trying to power as many power stations as you possibly can um by the end of the game you know whoever powers the most power stations is going to be the winner uh this one i i i it has a brilliant market where you are you know where you're choosing to bid on these things it it just is so clean as well a bit like how to do tonic again where there is nothing here that doesn't need to be there it flows really nicely probably on the on the upper end of the time scale you know maybe 90 to 120 minutes to play this one um but it works extremely well it has uh that i said that economical feel to it where you're trying to get as much money as you can and reinvest that money to um to pay dividends really and considering this one is not uh it's not the license of games there's quite a lot of involvement in this one quite mathy as you are choosing to span out and build new power stations paying the cost etc but i managed to teach you something to my mum actually my mom is not uh you know not a gamer really we played the odd game with her and she absolutely had a great time with this one which i think just does a great job of saying how versatile this game is because me is a pretty salty dry euro gamer and you know my mom who casually plays games i've all enjoyed this one equally brilliant brilliant design and again one that i think is going to stay

steadfast in the board game geek rankings for a long time to come because i think when you have the pedigree um and the just the design prowess of this that this game shows then i think it again transcends time and it will just stay in those rankings and um just just stay strong because it's just that good that is power grid at number five uh next up at number four i have rococo by matthias kramer rococo is was one of those games that was so hard to get hold of for a really long period of time it was out of print became that holy grail game you know everybody wanted it because it was so scarce or so difficult to get hold of and um this year i'll throw last year 2020 um eagle griffin games reprinted this one in the deluxe version and um i managed to get to the table was very quickly in line to buy this one and i was so impressed with the way this one played on the on the face of it is a simple area control game as you are and as per set collection game as you are getting resources and building um trading them in to build these dresses for these nobles and putting these dance halls um to get majorities of those halls to get victory points are you also investing in different decorations and things um which yeah how many games do that loads that's fine that was decent but on top of that you had this really interesting hand management system where you would have different kind of apprentices and journeymen and

master designers really that would not only allow you to take certain worker placement spots but they would also allow you to um do certain actions based on those cards as well and you really have to weigh up about what cards you are taking into your hand and what you're going to do on your turn by by managing those card systems you know what knowing when to get rid of them knowing when to buy new ones and so on and that meshed with the area control aspect and the kind of gather resources aspect all came together in such a classic design in my opinion um and it just comes together a lot stronger than a lot of these generic um euros do and i think a lot of people would say you know this game is one of those games that had maybe unnecessary hype built behind it um because just simply because it was so hard to get hold of you know that almost um rose tinted glasses but for me the gameplay really did stand on its own and um i was left really impressed by this one not only because the beautiful visual aspect of it but that gameplay in itself was really strong razor sharp and just interesting decisions throughout and for me that's what i want in my games and rococo certainly did that and left me massively impressed despite the years and years of hype um or pressure put on this one so at number four i have rococo at number three i probably have one of the most prolific board games of all time this one is uh puerto rico by andreas

safarth uh this one was uh the number one ranked board game of all time for a long time uh it's a kind of a role selection game if you're choosing um one of these tiles which will give you a bonus um but not only do you get that bonus everybody else gets to do that action as well but you get a slightly improved version of it and in this game you're essentially trying to gather workers and build different buildings on your special little plantation gather crops um ship them off for profit and all these different things but that role selection um it just is where this game really shines for me and also in the terms of how the uh the player interaction comes together because you've got to be really wary about the other players positions because if you choose a certain action you've got to bear in mind that you can't just take your own position into consideration think you know i want this action so i'm taking it you've got to really consider about the position of the other players because you can hugely benefit them if you um if you take a specific action and you've got to know when to sit back and think you know what i'm confident you're going to take that action because it's going to benefit you therefore i'm going to do something else and not play into your hands and that comes together in a really strong way and i think people often consider that as a negative for the game where you know people who are experienced with playing it are going to just rinse somebody who isn't experienced in playing it but i think that's just a testament to the design where the best players are going to win and being cognizant and weary about the positions of other players is actually um something to consider in this game which isn't so

so much the case in a lot of euro games now um yeah a game that's i think yeah again 10 plus years older maybe maybe even towards the 20 plus years old and one that still feels razor sharp um feels fresh just a clean bunch of rules um nothing in this game that doesn't need to be there and probably one of the most objectively well put together games i've ever played and i'm one that i can never ever see leaving my collection puerto rico just an absolute magnificent design at number two um ironically it's my favorite game of all time this is el grande now when i got into the hobby um look i kind of you know did you learn and get the information overload i'd always see people going back to work and saying you know this is the best area control game ever it's the forefather of the genre it's the best example of that um and i thought okay that's pretty peaked my interest look at the game looks pretty dry i'm pretty themeless which doesn't bother me but um you know something i take into consideration because i play with other players as well um and i i took a punt on this one you know before i knew the pedigree of walker and kramer and stuff like that played this one and thought wow is this a good game uh it's i and you know i played i don't know how many area control games are in majority games over the years and this one still is the by far the best design in my eyes it's a game where you've got to basically spread your different caviaros all these different regions to control to get

um to get points you know you have the most there you're gonna get the most points the second most there's gonna get the second most points etc that sounds pretty standard you know how many games do that but this game has a few extra wrinkles and a few extra layers that just take this game and transcend it to that upper echelon of just elite pedigree of games for example in order to take actions you need to bid on the priority of drafting the actions that are available and that's an interesting decision in itself because you have a limited hand of cards and if you spend up you if you spend your um most priority cards in order to get the action first then you are sacrificing bringing workers into your comment into your area to deploy so and likewise if you play the lower priority cards then you get loads of workers into your pool and having that is really important so you need to have this kind of cash flow or this worker flow of keeping people into your pool to be able to deploy them in the first place so that's really cool in itself another thing you have this um opaque tower on the board where you end up basically secretly putting people into this board which is another area control thing where you at the end of the round you're going to reveal them and whoever's got the most in there is going to get points but then you can secretly deploy them on different regions on the board which can affect the scoring which is another cool thing as well and on top of that you've got the you know all the different changing powers from time to turn you've got restrictions on the board because you can only ever deploy where

the king is or at least do adjacent regions to that king which again can be a really important factor to bear in mind knowing when to push and pull and lay back and know when to sacrifice a strong turn is so important in this game and to be honest i i generally prefer strategic games this one leans more towards that tactical side of things but because i'm so razor focused and engaged from start to finish throughout i just think you know for an hour and a half game this one just flies by just constantly fun from start to finish the constant flux of the board is just there and still the strongest example of an error control game that i've ever played and you know naturally my favorite game of all time um is going to be on this list um and again 20 i think 25 years old now and still feels as fresh as anything on the market that is el grande at number two and finally at number one i have barrage now barrage is a really heavy game about gathering water in dams as it trickles down this mountain and then converting that water into energy building building power stations building conduits managing your machinery to build new things lots of things going on in this game which i can't cover in a uh in a minute or two but needless to say i absolutely love it but the reason why this is number one um rather than el grande which is my number one game of all time is simply because my level of enjoyment was or the margin in between my level of

enjoyment and my expectations of the game was much bigger um i was expecting to enjoy it naturally but i enjoyed it way more than i thought i would i was expecting it to be good but it was magnificent and certainly one of the best games i've ever played one of the most interactive um unique and just a fresh um fresh idea and a fresh concept great player interaction just surprisingly easy to teach as well considering how heavy this game is um just ticks all the boxes for me and one of the games i just sat back and thought wow this is a phenomenal design um just one of the best games i've played in years um and i i couldn't believe that i waited as long as i did to get this game and i can't believe i actually sat there looking at the kickstarter page thinking you know what it doesn't look that good i'll pass on it and what a silly decision that was because this game is magnificent i unfortunately i think it came out a couple years ago now and i only played it this year and i i can't explain that why why i did that um but need to say i'm so happy i've got in my collection now and um certainly um not only lived up to the hype but way overshot that hype that i was thinking of it um and for me when the pressure is that much on a game and it still delivers that is just the highest praise you can give so um that concludes my top 10 games that lived up to the hype um check all these games out they're all absolutely fantastic and i think um it's quite a nice list because you've got something as light as ganshon clever

or that's pretty clever and something is involved as barrage on it so there's something for everyone here if you have enjoyed the review please hit like and subscribe my channel and check out my other videos too uh for everyone else i'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye

Progress saved