Skip to main content
Loading video...

The Top Ten Most Complicated Games We Own! (According to BGG!)

Transcript 19:45

hi everybody hello I'm Ryan I'm Bethany and we are Ryan and Bethany board game reviews and today we have another top 10 for you this is a fun list actually I like all the top 10 we do I like all of them they're all fun lists for me talk about our collection and games we've played it's fun but this one is the top 10 heaviest games in our collection okay so first off to the bat let's define what heavy is um a few weeks ago depending on when you watch this when we post it we did a video called the lightest the 10 lightest games in our collection so game weight is basically has it's a very subjective category people can say it's a lot of different things but what it kind of boils down to overall is complexity in terms of rules and the difficulty of the decisions that you make those are kind of the two main things that that that filter into what makes a game heavy versus light so we talked about before our lightest games in our collection that light games are usually very easy to understand very quick to get to the table small setup easy to teach rules and and relatively quick gameplay and those games guess what are not bad they're really fun and silly and light and things that you can play a lot of times heavy and light does not equal good and bad it's not we found that trap I found that trap the where the g games are only good if they're heavy and I've since come back to where all games are good not all games but you know all weight of games can be good uh based off of what their circumstances when you're playing them and who you're playing them with all right so the

heavier games these are the games that we're talking about today these are the games that have bigger Longer rule sets maybe a little bit harder to learn a little bit harder to teach um they have a lot more going on a little bit more involved and the or the decisions that you make during the game are a little bit more involved you have to really think about think a couple lay layers ahead you can't just think about can't react what's happening to you you have to think a plan ahead in two turns I'll have enough resources just to buy that then I'll be able to do that to be able to do that to be able to do that so those are kind of things that are going on here on the very heavy end of the spectrum you have things like War Games very expansive games that last like a whole day or more and you have all these little stats and figures that you're moving around things like that um on a very light end it's this party games kids games and then everything in the middle this is based off of board game Geeks board game weight and it goes from one to five one being light five being the absolute heaviest I don't think there is any ones that are just a full true five because even just one four will bring a five down to 4.99 so anyways it goes one to five and today we're talking about the heavier end of the scale at least for our Personal Collection yes I do want to say that my sweet spot with games is probably um medium to light Euros those are the games I enjoy the most and play the most so I'm assuming and maybe I'm assuming wrong but I'm assuming this list is going to look a little bit lighter than You're Expecting well I think also based off what kind of a gamer you are you might think that this these are 10 very

very very heavy very complicated games or maybe if you are the person that likes those crazy heavy games maybe you're thinking you guys are this is the you're in the shallow end of the pool for death or maybe you're you're similar to us so because it's very subjective and tastes are subjective you might think um a variety of things about our our our collection and the heaviness of it um but in be sure in the comments below to let us know what you think of our top heaviest games and what your favorite heavy games are as well we'd love to hear from you guys know these are games that we should check out as well all right ladies first all right so we're going to count down to our very heaviest yes all right we're going to start with 10 and that is Amsterdam and that this is a reimplementation of maau it is weighted at 3.43 34 three it's just kind of like a fun that's a fun number um so in this it's it's um it's a Feld game so there's a lot of ways to do a lot of things by the way safan Feld is a very famous very popular designer and he tends to make things in those that yeah slightly heavier category yes so you might see a couple those on um and you're trying to gain area control on the The Village area of where you're trying to get all these um put these people there and you're just trying to get the most in certain areas and then you're also trying to ship people out to these islands out there um so if you've played maau this is just like a a streamlined updated version of that yeah I don't think I think it's the number one in the

in the city collection yes the first one and I do think I like this one more than you you do I know that you do but similarly I think that you like the one I'm going to talk about next more than I do and that is VI counts of the West Kingdom for the longest time I said viz counts someone corrected me and they were not kind about it they were not they were like really on top of it but there's this several games that from games that are like blah blah blah of the West Kingdom blah blah blah of the South Tigress blah blah blah of the North Sea uh so we've played a lot of those and we really enjoy a lot of them and more might show up later on this list but out of the West Kingdom line of Trilogy of games this is the heaviest one and therefore it's the one that made the list we it's weighted at 3.46 basically you have one Pawn which is your VI count that you're moving around on our board kind of generally speaking just kind of going around clockwise uh and you are it's kind of driven by cards a lot of things those cards can have you do they're multi-use cards uh which is brilliant and I don't know it's I can't even fathom how they designed that because it's so Al M these cards are so crazy but anyways lot different ways you can accumulate points you can try to uh get these Scrolls which have a set collection piece to them also give you special abilities you're managing all these resources there's a tower in the middle of the game's castle that has that's three tiered and you can kind try to put as many of your pawns into there as possible and the more you put up there the more they move around and go closer to the top they move around R go closer to the top gives you more special abilities more points uh but what kind of churns the whole game is this light

deck building element it's kind of like a a a tableau management system I guess you have cards that you're Drafting and gaining and then eventually they're going to go into this Tableau in front of you and three cards are going to be determining what actions you can take and the strength of them any special abilities you might have and every turn you kind kind of shift it down if a card falls off sometimes it might give you a special ability sometimes when a card gets added it gives you a special ability you're kind of just managing this this shifting Tableau of cards as you're kind of building this deck of cards and and going through it it's very very clever I know you like it a lot more than I do I think out of the West Kingdom series it's probably my third favorite out of the three and I think it's my favorite but it's still very very cool all right our number eight is Tren and this is rated at or weighted at 3.64 um trun is a game where all of the actions come from this manala so you're moving uh these things over wherever you land is where you get to take an action and it's really cool cuz you can put things in those places so you can do extra things I am so good at figuring this out getting the colors right because if you land with certain colors and certain places you can take extra actions until about uh 34s of the way through the game and then like I can't plan out any further like I'm just like I hope good things happen this this last quarter because this is as far as my mind went we have an ongoing joke that you always get second place in this game whether we're playing with two players or four players it's so true like I get there and then I just kind of like but

you always score really well but it's not always the most well exactly exactly so all of these that's how you determine your actions and you're going to different places on the board um you're yeah you're just doing that and so I it's just a fun one yeah it's one of my favorite games think of all time yeah um it's got like six little mini games they're all different they all come together they all merge Synergy wise together as well all right so the number seven heaviest game on our list is agrica this is weighted at 3.64 this is kind of the great granddaddy of all besides Kus but beyond that agrica uh is would be I would call the great granddaddy of all worker placement games you have these as the game goes on you're kind of accumulating more and more members of your family that you're able to send out to the action board to do more actions and then of course more actions are popping up each round as well um there's each it's kind of run by cards you have this big giant deck of improvements and a big giant deck of these occupations and you are trying to use those in a way that gives you all kinds of special abilities and synergies uh and there's lots and lots and lots of expansion Decks that you can use the game the base game that we came with I think there's a lot of editions and versions of this game but R came with three different decks of um of those different things and you can combine them or you can use just one use one deck or you can buy all these expansion decks as well and really ramp up the the different combinations of cards you might see and that's what really drives and makes this game special I know a lot of people compare this because they are very very similar um to um Fe free for

Odin but what's the one before that caverna and caverna I think is is very cool but lacks the cards and the cards is what makes agria so special and so much fun but also makes your decision decision level really high yeah I almost wish I had been introduced to this game now cuz when I was introduced to it I was a baby gamer and I was like no thank you no I don't you to feed your people that's a very stressful thing for a new game room yes yes like just that like you get punished you're like I want to have fun why am I being punished all right um because punishment is fun okay so our number s six is aquasphere and this is weighted at 3.6 so you are controlling 3.68 sorry my handwriting is bad 3.68 a little behind the scenes you are um you are managing these Rob and this underwater thing cuz you're mining for these gems essentially you're doing research and so you have to control these robots going apart going all over this underwater um facility yeah yeah so but the thing is there's all these octopi who are breaching into the facility and so you have to deal with them you have to go around and get rid of them and do all sorts of weird stuff with that um this is a fun one and I like that in this game like people are paying you to go re research this but they need proof and so you actually can't score higher until you pay them a gem like look I'm doing stuff give me more money so I I don't know that's kind of fun that you can't even score unless

you're actually getting the gems which is the point of the game all right so this is next one on our list this is number five this is yet again another Stefan Feld oh so was Aqua yeah this is I think the fourth Feld maybe the last Feld yes the last Feld on the list this is Bora Bora it has a weight of 3.7 seven so we're slowly cripping up on the the heaviness scale uh the actions in this game are few and far between you have very few actions that you can to use in this game how many do you take the entire game do you you're only guaranteed six rounds and each action is a dice you have three dice so 18 actions throughout the whole game throughout the whole game you're only guaranteed 18 actions the higher the dice value the stronger the action that you get to take but the lower the dice value the more flexible you are with where you to place it and what actions you can take so this is very cool thing going on where uh I think Fel does that in several games where dice are are both good at high and low values yeah cast of burgundy was one of the first games I played that was like all dice are the equal in value just what are the numbers and what Associated what part of the board is that associated with but yes so low numbers get you flexibility High numbers get you strength um and then you have you kind of drafting these these men and women tiles that you're able to use at the end of the round uh to give you extra actions so if you the more you draft those the more actions and strength of actions are going to get better and that's extremely important because again you're guaranteed so few actions this game and there's so much to accomplish you need the extra help of those men and women tiles here going off the side there it's not quite area

control but an area expansion part of the board trying to get as many resources and places as well as you're going fishing on this on the islands very involved very fun all right our number four is Starship Interstellar and the weight of this is 3.75 and this is game we are all different corporations but Earth is dying and you are trying to save Mankind and get them to um what is it Trappist you're trying to get them to the trapis solar system so that way we can continue um so you're competing for resources you're going to different planets to try and get stuff you're trying to um C cryogenically freeze people so we can transport civilization you're trying to help build the ship but you are still competing companies trying to do this it's a very expensive uh expans expensive game where you're traveling all over the the map and you're trying to upgrade your technology so you can do your actions better when you're mining for resources and all of that it is a very big table hog yeah this is this is not so much of a Euro no a lot of games on this list for us are Euros we like Euros this is more of like a almost almost like a 4X Style game so it's the first and only game that's like that on our list all right so the next one I want talk about is Ark Nova this is the number three heaviest game in our collection so our 11-year-old's like favorite game right now it's weight has a weight of 3.77 and the fact that our 11-year-old not only plays it but loves it um shows that to me it's not necessarily heavy in terms of rule set

yes she's able to understand the rules that you're basically just building a zoo which thematically is a great tie in for any age group you're building a zoo and then you're trying to do two things you're trying to support these various conservation efforts while simultaneously providing a great experience for the people who visit your zoo so you want to have a wide variety of different animals and and rare animals but uh the complexity comes in the fact that this is massive deck of cards this huge deck of cards each one represents a different conservation effort or a different ability you can learn or a different um animal that you're going to be putting into your zoo um they all have different costs and abilities and benefits they give you and uh it has this cool thing where there's actually two different score tracks you have conservation and then you have ticket sales and what's going to happen is the game is it's going to be triggered once they meet up somewhere so you can do very little conservation a whole ticket sales or you can do a whole bunch of conservation in very little ticket sales doesn't matter wherever they meet up that is when the game end is going to be triggered you're going to finish that round out uh it's a very cute game lots of these great Wildlife pictures on these animals on these animal cards uh ton of fun lots and lots of cards so many cards all right our number two is Scholars of the South Tigress thank you and uh the weight of this is 4.06 we've crossed over the 4.01 Yes we finally did it we do have some of those in our collection okay so this game this is the first game I I want I don't there probably are other games like this it's

just the first one that I've played that's like this where you take actions based on your D color but you can mix and match those to create different colors in order to do different actions on the board so the more lucrative actions of course are going to be a mixed color and the more plain actions are going to be the primary colors but it's really interesting in the beginning of the game you don't feel like you have enough die to do anything and at the end of the game you're like I don't I can't even use all of these like I'm done with all of that so in this game you are trying to translate texts into Arabic and it's not as simple as translating you have this text in Chinese and you want to get it into Arabic you have to translate it to Hebrew and then from Hebrew to Arabic so you're hiring all these translators and sometimes you have to hire multiple translators in order to get this text theme is really fun gameplay using those dice in such an interesting way was really fun and unique and it's probably the of the game that we're getting the most play in right now yeah I I was surprised at how heavy it was cu the first time we played it it was very biger involved but I feel like I clicked really well yes yes I felt the same way the second time I played it I had to teach someone who wasn't as familiar with heavy games and I was like oh okay this is why it's heavier because it's a teach is a it's a big teach it's a big understanding of how all the little systems in work together okay so we have now arrived at our the number one heaviest game in our collection uh this is kbon EV and has a

weight of 4.3 this is based off of another game that came out called kbon which I really enjoyed but kbon EV is the newer updated version it's about electronic Vehicles basically you have this board which represents the electronic vehicle Factory all different actions you can take involve uh designing a vehicle U you have to gather parts for that vehicle then you're going to kind of build the vehicle together then you're going to test that vehicle out in the track and there's all these trading seminars you can go to which sounds really boring and by the way my J job is as a car parts professional so like this job this board game is actually my career you have to go do all these trainings you have to assemble all these car parts you have to stock all these car parts you have to do all this stuff that's what's happening in the game here too uh the action selection is really really fun and kind the way it resolves is very very smooth but what the funniest part of this whole game is as big as an involved and as crazy as it is and there's also just this supervisor named Sandra who's running around the board and every time she goes to a new section of the board she's basically inspected to see who's not doing their training and then she penalizes you based off of whatever the parameter is oh you're not you don't have enough car parts or you're not doing enough training or you not you know whatever the case is I think it's such a funny thing it is so funny that she's just this mean supervisor running on the board scolding everyone for not doing their training and I love that a lot um it's a nice little moment of comedy and it's a way to kind of feed your people in a sense you know you have to keep keep the managing of that all that stuff

keep all the different balls in the air in this game uh it's a funny little com comedic element in this very involved game yeah I really really like this one it's it's a it's a fun one and it's finally one where I've played it enough now to where it's it's just going to click like I'm Ryan will have to retach it to me every single time we get it out but since I'm so familiar with it I'm going to be able to lay these pleas um lay them in my brain to make it work that is our list but we want to hear from you what's the heaviest game in your collection does our list does it seem like those aren't my games or is our list like oh You Weep babies babies nice beginning G boarding collection yes we want to hear from you make sure to leave a comment below until then thank you for subscribing and thank you for watching our video you can find us in all of these places you guys thanks for watching we will see you next time bye bye you guys thanks for watching our Shenanigans as always we appreciate it over here if you follow this link you're going to find a playlist we've hand selected handcrafted just for you uh because you watch this video and if you check over here this is a video that YouTube thinks you might like so you can check that out if you want as well all right we appreciate it guys thanks so much for watching and we will see you next time bye

Progress saved