Top 10 Board Games of 2024 (so far)
Transcript
hello everyone and welcome back to the board gaming doctor my name is Phil and I'll be your board gameing doctor today so this is the video about my favorite and best games of 2024 thus far I obviously have not played every single game that I've wanted to out of this year due to those games not being released where I live yet and so notable games such as setti and a handful of others the SE is the only one that comes to mind right now but hopefully I will get a chance to play those and try those in the year to come and will update you next year around this time about what I think about those games so uh just laying down some uh house rules I guess for what might or might not be on this video I'm not going to include any expansions uh I'm not going to include news fur The Big Box Edition that will receive its own separate video um if you're new to this channel I enjoy my rosenbergs very much and so newf will be very high up obviously would be very high up on my list uh but that it will receive it's a separate video so and then before I get started here uh thank you everyone for uh your support uh this channel has been out for about a year the podcast about one to two years longer than that and so I appreciate everyone subscribing and commenting interacting with me it's been a lot of fun I won't ask for any subscriptions but I appre appreciate any support and
uh thank you for joining me along in this journey almost 400 of you have subscribed and that's awesome so thank you so I ranked all the games that I played in 2024 from this year and I got to about 48 of those games and so uh I'm just going to go through these are like the honorable mentions right of games that I will that are lower on my list and and so yeah so I'm just going to go over a couple of the honorable mentions I suppose and why some of these games aren't higher I think gome Hollow would be a little bit higher on my list if you know I didn't have the chance to move things around here so I I think gome Hollow is a fine game but it wasn't one of my favorites but probably is higher than 45 out of 48 uh moving along some of these games were really fun botanicus was a Spiel uh nominee for I think kers Spiel and that was a fun game I was really surprised and and pleased with games like in eternum hopefully I'm saying that right uh that one was fun Middle Ages was great too um as I get into some of these games I really really enjoyed it this is a pretty good year and so I I I had a really hard time compared to like last year uh ranking some of these games for maage I enjoy I didn't like it as much as the majority of people so this might be a hot take from me I think the worker
placement is unique but not as interesting for my tastes but that's okay verage is still a really good good game rat Jack is a game that I just recently played that I found really fun this was mentioned on the dice tower not too long ago and uh yeah a great uh iteration on the Black Jack system so that was pretty cool rats of wiar Millennia a a new Juma Al guju game that was really some Kickstarter earlier this year naishi is a small card game that I really enjoyed here's windmill Valley Lord of the Rings duel for middlee just barely missed the top 10 I I feel like this game oops I guess you'll see what number 10 is but uh this it was a really fun game I would probably enjoy playing it more uh I I like it just about the same as Seven Wonders tool I think it's different enough I like the theme more but it's it's not something that I would come back to over and over again but I have been playing a lot more Seven Wonders duel lately so we'll see if this changes and then Harvest comes in at my official number 11 very fun farming game lightweight I I think I would rather play a gria but if I couldn't Harvest is a great plan B for me so let's transition into the top 10 so as you might have saw my number 10 is castle combo this was a surprise to me how much I enjoyed this game but I think it's a game that receives and has received a lot of good praise I
really enjoyed and and first of all don't mind my rating I'm going to be reating everything some games might have a lower rank that that is higher up the kind of criteria that I based these rankings off of at this time were you know what games would I rather try to pull out if I either could play a game right now on a week like a week night you know so a shorter game or a filler game such as castle combo as well as like if I had unlimited time and could play any long game on a weekend you know so that's kind of what I'm going with right now rather than strictly by rating but anyway castle combo is a really quick and short Tableau building game where you are drafting cards uh purchasing them from a market and laying them down in front of you they each have a specific scoring condition and cost of course as well as icons that you try to match up based off of other cards Etc and the game ends after nine rounds and you know the best drafted Tableau wins and so it's a really quick game I generally enjoy games with a lot of different cards in them and different scoring abilities so this hearkens back to uh what's the game called uh uh it'll come to me but it you know there there are similar games out there that play in a similar Fashion Point city is one that came out last year so games that are very Point salad of course the the game that point City was the sequel of it it reminded me a lot of Point salad and I quite enjoyed that game and I think this one is another iteration of that style
of lightweight Tableau building car drafting that you could play over and over again but still have a lot of variety to keep it interesting so that's my number 10 Castle number nine for me is inventions evolution of ideas this was the game by lasera that was released this year I generally enjoy his designs albeit they are quite heavy this was one of his most complex games not by very much though and uh side note I have not had a chance to play Speak Easy which was the kickstarted game this year for a release next year so maybe I will by then but I did play inventions and I enjoyed the his thematic approach to a civilization style type of game you have your you know interesting move of pillar and take all the actions or part you know some of the actions uh on this board here to Cascade a combo of different effects on the shared board simulating the invention of ideas and sharing them across the globe uh reiterating the you know the history of what what might have happened if some of these inventions were created and shared in an alternate timeline of our own history so I like the theme of it it's not your average civilization Style game and not even your average Euro style adaptation of a Civ game it is very much a s a game full of cascading Combos and and actions and you know it is quite heavy and so that's probably why it's a little bit higher up on this list not
lower because of the complexity that it would take for me to relearn and play this game again it is quite long but I think it was a lot of fun and if I were to say at this point and rank my favorite lerta games Lisboa is my favorite of course but I think inventions would be in my top five for sure if not top three so this is one that I would love to try and get back into and play again despite the complexity and that's inventions evolution of ideas is my number nine number eight is going to be Miss Bor the deck building game this is the John declair release for this year and maybe some of this is recent bias you know I'm I'm a huge Brandon Sanderson fan I uh grew up pretty close to where Brandon Sanderson lives actually and and had grown up kind of or at least in my you know early adult life reading his books and so missb was among those first books that I read and it really sparked my interest in novels once again so fast forward to this year going to the release event for wind and Truth was just fantastic and I saw this game in person and so I saw this on the table I had played this game already on tabletop simulator just to demo it and it's a a really good uh deck builder it doesn't do I mean it's not on face value a lot different than your average good deck building games such as Star Realms Etc but there are some thematic unique uh features of this game when it comes to
mechanisms as far as using these metal tokens to burn or flare them to power your cards Etc you have a competitive but also co-op mode which is pictured here uh battling against the Lord ruler so it really puts you into what the first book of this series feels like I understand that didn't want to spoil too much there is material from the later books in the TR the first Trilogy uh you know in some of the card art and things like that but I I I believe there would be a lot of room for expansion for this game and in the eras Beyond uh you know beyond just what misor entails in the first book and so I think yes mechanically it's a very solid game thematically it felt like they they did draw on a lot of the mechanisms that make it feel unique to born as well as to deck building in general the way that you can purchase some of these cards and use them as a one-time effect and immediately discard them and not to your own pile but to give it up can entirely can really help keep your deck thin and so there are some unique things that are done really well it's gotten a lot of good praise and I you know I do have my worries that it might not feel as replayable in the long run but in the immediate uh time you know I I really enjoy enjoyed my play I could I could play it a few more times and if I were to purchase anything especially just for the Brandon Sanderson nerd inside of me I might try to get this game myself and
and play it with other folks who enjoy Miss born and anything in the cosmere as a kind of link between you know our fandom and the novels as well as board gaming and so very approachable very good deck building game that's mistborn the deck building game my number eight my number seven is unconscious mind so this game was available for demo back in 2003 23 and officially released this year and I really enjoyed this game not only just for the art but also the theme I think this was an interesting approach to representing you know early psychiatric medicine in a sense uh or psychological medicine and you know you're you have your own Tableau that you're trying to help out your own patients with and mechanically it's very interesting you have these cascading U tiles very akin to wingspan where you can modulate and activate certain effects in a you know in a variable uh row every time that you play this game right and so you've got that going on but it's a little bit more complex than uh wingspan in in terms of the other actions that you can do let's see if we can find a a good picture of the board but you're not only purchasing these cars but acquiring patience to try to treat them getting resources to do so tra around this Central board as well Gathering resources as you go so very much a Euro game in uh the way that it plays and the way that it looks but I think the mechanisms here really fit
well together it feels pretty streamlined and it I think it represents the theme in a really great way I enjoy games being a physician myself uh that represent anything medicine related or or adjacent or you know in parallel with what I do for work which does include mental you know includes mental health treatment as well and so I I think it did it justice in the way that you can treat patients and and do other you know academic things as well as You Follow the uh career of Freud and so yeah it it was a really fun game uh would love to see this game have a broader release in say a digital format or something like that it would be something that I would want to play again so that's my number seven unconscious mind all right my number six is worb span now from here on out that's this is where my list gets really difficult a lot of these games are very interchangeable when I looked back on my list as I ranked it on Pub meele and so these top six games were just you know immediate hits for me I didn't have to think very hard at all knowing that these games made it to this Echelon of ranking so worms span the sequel to wingspan made it uh more complex as well as Dragon themed I it's interesting I had an a somewhat lukewarm experience playing this solo on my own but then when playing this multiplayer in person as well I played it with someone else who owns the copy this game
really came alive to me I think I had difficulty understanding how actions were taken which is a little different than how it works in wingspan and so understanding that really opened up the possibilities that this game has I love the the added Nuance to this game of building caves down and then dragons on top of it to add a little bit more complexity in terms of what caves and Dragon cards you want to take and play you know you know specific times to gain benefits everything else you know worked really well I I really enjoyed how all these cards you know chained on top of each other like they do in wingspan so mechanically this game came to came together really well I still hold that think I would rather play wingspan at this time versus worms span but not by very much only because of my sentimental history with wingspan I think if it wasn't for that then I probably would gravitate more towards worms span it's at a complexity that is more at home for me and I really really enjoy this game it's probably only going to get better the more I play it and would love to continue exploring this game there's a lot to explore here with all the cards and whatnot and look forward to hopefully some expansions I I don't think there are any expansions yet for this game or that are announced but in anywh who I would love to see more content for this so that's my number six worms my number five is harmonies I really enjoyed this game a lot the
harmonies is a very it is a lightweight game but it's a very streamlined and fun and interesting game to me that is very akin to Cascadia and I like this game more than Cascadia because of the following right both are excellent games but I felt like the puzzle that you're solving in harmonies is more interesting to me where you are drafting cards that have different uh puzzles that you're trying to arrange with with these tokens that you place onto your board and not only are you trying to modulate your tiles to fit in your closed off Tableau to fit this but you're also in the end game getting points for like the longest river that you form the longest mountain range you know Etc right and so they're I can Cascadia two different ways to score in this this game you try to either balance both of those scoring types or try to go in heavy on one way or the other and so I really enjoyed that I felt like Cascadia in person goes the the other thing I like about harmonies is that it's a Cascadia everyone takes a turn you just go around and drafting tiles and animals whereas in harmonies it just felt quicker one because of this closed board and also with the limited amount of tiles it felt like there were Les tiles that you are drafting from in harmonies it just made it feel quicker for me which I appreciate in this you know in this realm of complexity it's a a light lighter weight game that I that I can play in a reasonable amount of time I
dare I say more reasonably than cascad of but that's only been my personal experience when playing it with other folks who are learning Cascadia as well but and so regardless of that I hold harmonies in high esteem I would totally play this game I've I I love that it's available on board game arena to play as well and I've enjoyed all of my uh plays thus far of it and will continue to do so so yeah that's my number five harmonies number four is ARS and it pains me that ARS is so high up this list even if it if it's just at number four this feels like totally a game that I would love to get into ARS is a game by Cole worly which utilizes the trick and take trick taking mechanisms in a unique way that makes this game a lot more complex than your average trick taker by introducing you know those mechanisms of how you play cards on top of a centralized board that you are doing space things on right you're traveling around Gathering planets for resources and doing combat there are lots of different cards that you can buy for um here's an example of the uh the trading card or the trick taking cards that you use they have different actions that you can take on on them and yeah this game also features a campaign mode where you can play like three games back toback with different factions that offer a lot of asymmetry akin to root another worldly game and the the thing about arcs for me
personally is that I while I enjoy root I get the same sense of like strategic exploration and wild asymmetry from arcs or else you know I would feel this way if I had the chance to play some of the you know the expansion material with the campaign as well as the additional factions Etc uh I think this game the way that it plays I think makes more sense to me and mechanically is more streamlined and easier to remember as well as teach compared to root and so so once again while I really enjoy root I think I would enjoy ARX better and I'm very excited to know that ARX will get a digital implementation very soon after it's uh release you know it took root a couple of years to do to get that quite a few years I think ARS will be slated for 2026 release for a digital format under direwolf so super excited for when that comes out at some point to really revisit this game if I don't do so earlier so arcs yeah very very highly rated game it's it's climbing very fast overall I I will definitely uh see this game I I think we will see this game in the top 100 very soon uh but yeah number four is ARS number three is civil lution it so this and my number two game were neck and neack I spend a lot of extra time thinking about where to rank these and I think civilan and I'll
explain why it's number three when I talk about my number two but civil ution I recently just released a video of my first impressions and boy were those first impressions very positive this is a Stefan Feld take on a civilization themed game where you're utilizing a lot of the mechanisms that you find in other games of his like castles of burgundy but with a centralized board that you travel around exploring uh taking resources and even with a little bit of combat-like interaction it's very mild when you compare it to other Civ games but of course you have track advancement you have a ton of different cards that you play onto your Tableau to give you as asymmetric ways to score and take actions there is a lot to explore in this game I compared it to games that I enjoy Like A Feast for Odin and I mentioned that I would play this game over A Feast for Odin I think there's a lot maybe it's a recency bias that there's more to explore in this game than a game that I have played over 50 times such as a feast for Odin but I I think this is a a fantastic marriage between mechanism and theme and you can check out my recent video if you'd like to dive into more of my thoughts of why I enjoy Civ olution and yeah it maybe it's so high up because of you know my recent play of it but I couldn't stop thinking about this game after I played it and I would just love to continue exploring this game so as it it pains me to say
the bronze medal of this year so far goes to civui which is crazy my number two is Black Forest now of course I put a Rosenberg game very high up on the list right now and why isn't this number one you'll see but black forest rosenberg's latest big box game that was released it's just a you know it's a fantastic game and it borrows or at least was developed you know and coincides with one of my favorite games of all time glass Road and so if you know glass Road this game is going to be very familiar to you utilizing the the resource wheels and Tableau building a lot of the same rules go into that as well but it introduces this work ER movement type of action taking rather than using cards and so this UPS the complexity a little bit and it's not to say that black forest doesn't have its own flaws like I I really did not enjoy the jobs I think they were fun but you know the the randomness of how those jobs come out didn't really sit as well for me and in addition to some other things as well but so black forest though is a game that you know I've already played it four times I which is a lot more than I usually get to play new games right I own a copy of this game and I'm glad that I own it and I will keep it and I think I put this game ahead of civil because I feel like well well one I own it but two you can you can play this game in 1 to two hours versus like the
two to three or two to four hours that cvoluion would take I think I can feasibly teach and play Black Forest more often than I would be able to do civui and so and the theme of this the mechanical similarities to Glass Forest one of or glass Road one of my favorite games of all time just really elevates this experience for me and this game for me oh the other thing that I you know was a little disappointed about was just how static some of these buildings are very akin to you know uh fields of ARL for example but despite those minor flaws I really I just really enjoy this game and will continue to enjoy it for many plays to come with but you know that that uh difference between civil is very small like those two games could easily be number two or number three we'll see what happens by this time next year where where these games sit I'm not afraid to bump out my Rosenberg games but let's see what number one is like I put new F big box as my number one now so sorry to lead you on but in the middle of making this video I realized that I put a 2025 five game on my list thinking it was I I played it this year it's a Kickstarter game for next year so I had to you know call it Audible and so I ended up just putting newf in the video so sorry sorry about that but I really do enjoy news so much I I like this game I genuinely like this game
more than black forest and so for me this really feels like my number one choice this year newsford had you know it came out 2017 or 2018 and I used to own the base game and one of the expansions I think the play Deck but so I I couldn't pass on the opportunity to purchase this game with some of the expansions that I had not been able to get because I hadn't been playing these types of games back when this game was released originally so I really love the opportunity to own all of the different expansions plus the new stuff I as as you might have saw I've played this game once with the uh biscon deck and that was I that was a lot of fun right I it's the maybe I I'm getting this wrong but it's the one with the guests designed by Tony Tony boell and I love something that I just took away from that play is just I love how quick this game is how tight this game is as well you only have 21 actions to seemingly do the impossible which Rosenberg games often make you feel like you're accomplishing a lot more than what meets the eye and I love the ability to really build out your Tableau in different ways to pick out the efficient buildings and combos that you initially see on the board and the expansions that are new and specific to this big box are just so far fantastic in my eyes they thematically make sense they add a lot of different variety and different pieces to the board and and game the guests themselves
add flexibility as sort of a wild resource that you can use in various ways and so I just yeah I I played this game again it reignited my love for it I will save more of my thoughts as I try to comprehensively break down the expansions and experience in this game but you know mistakes aside I I was going to leave this off but now that I'm you know put up to it yes newford is my favorite game from 2024 as you can see here I I yeah this is the best game that I played this year and probably will continue to be one of those best games I'm probably will leave this out next year but uh this is my channel I make the rules as I go and that is fine with me so thank you for Consulting with me thank you for checking out this list let me know what your favorite games were if it's some of these or other games that either I placed lower on my list or not at all and if you've had the chance to play some of the you know new hotness you know games that I haven't had a chance to play let me know as well hopefully I get toy to try those out in the future but once again thank you for all the support in the last year that this channel has been live uh you're very much appreciated by me and and once again thank you for Consulting with me and hope you schedule an appointment with your board gaming doctor real soon take care