Skip to main content
Loading video...

Being the ODD One Out in Board Gaming

Transcript 17:31

I feel like the odd one out when it comes to playing board games uh yeah I totally do because I think I'm the most obsessed out of everyone I know but recently I went to a board game Meetup where I was the fifth player there were two couples and my hubby couldn't attend because he was at home working and so it made me think and ponder about the idea of playing board games at the three player and five player count I know that player count is really crucial for determining what sort of games get to hit the table and I know that a lot of Euros are CED for four players and if you're playing a party game you can usually play that with a bigger group of people or if you're playing head-to-head you're usually going to play with your partner and so in this video I want to talk about what it feels like to be the third wheel what are the pros and cons of playing board games at the odd player number hi my name's Danny I'm an modern board gamer from Australia who lovees sharing my passion for this hobby with you my friends and my family come and join me I've got my cup of green tea and let's get this video started hey Danny are you ready for our two-player game night I'm super pumped I even brought a friend

hi when I usually play board games it's usually as a couple or as a group of four I'm either usually playing with my husband or I'm playing with our couple friends and often we we play games at even numbers so there's often a rare chance that comes along where we do sometimes play at odd numbers and one of the positives of playing a game with three plays is that it reduces the head-to-head direct conflict effect that you often see in some competitive board games if you're playing a game where you're literally just playing against one other player that direct interaction can be quite intimidating and if the other player is more skilled and more experienced at a particular game and think of an example like chess where if the other person has played chess every day and you've only played it once in a blue moon you're going to really feel intimidated when that uh other play versus you and sometimes I'll often avoid a two-play game if I know that I haven't had EXP experien um in a particular game before going against someone who is more experienced so I feel like that uh level of tension is reduced when you have three plays when you have three plays now the conflict has been split you can either go against one player and use the support of the third player or the other two players can kind of go against you that kind of split interaction means you're you feel less like the target essentially and I

kind of liking it to like a triangular effect uh basically you know player a can kind of Target player b b can Target c c can Target player a and vice versa there's a whole range of different Dynamics and interactions that are opened up when you play a game with three players and I think this is what makes it cool at an odd Play account the fact that there is a different uh social Dynamic and a different level of strategy that you might engaging when you play a game at three plays for example in the game ank uh at a certain point in the game uh the two weakest players in that game will merge together to become one team and they will uh I guess resolve the rest of the game as a single unit that idea of banding the two weakest players or weakest teams together means that the dynamic of the game shifts the power of the game shifts and how you evolve and develop your strategy becomes very different cuz not only you paying attention to one player you're also paying attention to the other player as well and and this brings me to the point about teaming up the fact that if you're playing a three-player game and two of the weaker players can kind of form an alliance to try and Target the stronger player can make that stronger player feel like oh I've done all this work I've succeeded this far now I'm going to have to battle two plays instead of one just kind of feels a little bit deflating for that player conversely you can have the other effect where two of the strongest plays

Target the weaker player just because it's an easy option and therefore pushing that weaker player further and further behind and I have been that weaker player quite often when I've played certain games that have that political dynamic or that social Dynamic and sometimes just picking on the weaker player is just an easy option but when you are the weaker player it feels awful feels terrible and so often we might talk about look I'm really far behind in this game maybe I could ban with the stronger player and we can even the playing field out there's a whole lot of like weird dynamics that are kind of uh evoked when you're playing with three players and that strength of power and how it shifts actually does become interesting a unique situation that I've encountered when playing a five player game especially when we played a team game where we have to split into two even teams team uh the dynamic of setting up the teams can be incredibly awkward the other day I think I was playing Blockbuster and we had an even number of players playing this trivia game and because Blockbuster is a party game that's centered around who knows films the best we had to decide which team would have the extra player and it came down to a discussion of how well do you think you know movies and some people thought they didn't really have a good breadth of knowledge of movies but they did did and some people who thought they had a really good depth of knowledge but

they actually didn't and so it wasn't until we started playing the game we realized where people strengths lied uh in their trivia knowledge of film and it just was a bit weird because it's like well I don't think I know much about film so I'm just going to join the team to make this side bigger but then this team all of a sudden halfway through becomes overpowered because there's more people with more knowledge compared to the other side and so you have this kind of weird situation where playing Team based games at an odd player number can feel a little bit off balance and I know it's not the intention of the game to make the the game feel off balance but just simply having that extra number that extra player that extra wealth of information brought to the game experience shifts the fairness of the game um or skewes it in a particular way and also even the discussion of saying oh look you don't really know much about film you should go on that team like it's it's just obviously it's a all ingest but it's kind of like a funny thought to have about like okay we're going to play this party game how are we going to form these teams and even that's usually an interesting conversation itself should we keep the couples together should we split up the couples how should everyone sit I really love middleweight and complex euros and I try and get them played as much as I can but whilst the frequency of getting them played isn't quite often as I'd like uh I have noticed that a lot of them max out at the four play Mark and that's because a lot of Euros are non-confrontational there's not as much

play to-play interaction you're kind of just working on your own Tableau your own engine and racing against the other players so it makes sense on that Mark and if you obviously have um too many plays playing a complex euru then you're going to be waiting a long time for your turn to come around which is a disadvantage but what I have notice is that when you have five players and you want to play a game like that um because a lot of Euros only play maximum four players being the fifth player I've often acted as like the game master the rules reference Guru the person who kind of oversees the rules to make sure the game is facilitated and the game flows smoothly and I love doing that like I love seeing other people play a game that You' just really wanted to get to the table I love being that person where you know people can just ask oh is this the right thing how does this resolve I absolutely love doing that role and just being that kind of person that infuses knowledge to make sure the game experience is a fun one for everyone but the downside of that that is that you don't actually get to play I get to miss out I just kind of watch I get to ref the game kind of like in soccer basically I guess that is a downside when you have odd numbers and you do want to play that game that you've wanted to get tabled for such a long time I know one of the workarounds that I've used uh before is that I've often partnered with one of the other players so that we play as a team so it might be three players playing on their own and I'll partner with someone else as the fourth player and that kind of at least

allows me to feel invested in some of the decisions and the gameplay moments which I absolutely love doing and no one has ever had a problem of coupling up and obviously if you do want to play like that it's actually a really great solution the idea that you can play like a four-player game but with couples and that just kind of adds a new social element to the game where you're like oh you have someone to talk to about what you should do next positive when it comes to playing with three players is in particular when it comes to games that have asymmetric powers or abilities or factions where each faction plays differently each uh person plays differently and those factions combined together create for an interesting Dynamic I often find games like Spirit Island where everyone's controlling an asymmetric Spirit has an equal contribution to the discussion of how things should be solved and how things should be completed and so I feel like that is a very positive in the favor of the odd number player count the freedom to be able to own your own uh moves uh contribute to the discussion equally and to be able to contribute in your own way just makes those sorts of games far more fun when you do have an uneven number of players there's an interesting social Dynamic uh when it comes to making decisions in Cooperative games when you've got three or five players you can have this really interesting interaction where because you've got odd numbers there's always going to be at least one player who might disagree against the

majority um sometimes you might all collectively agree and that's great but it's more fun when someone goes you know what I think we should do it this way and the other two players go you know what we disagree with you we should do it the other way and then trying to have that discussion where you find that middle ground is such uh it's actually quite fun I I don't know for some reason I just like having debates but anyway uh a game like betrayal at house on the hill however can feel really really interesting at the odd playay count because in betrayal house on the hill uh when a haunt is triggered one player leaves the room and becomes like the betrayer and so I've often been in multiple games where I've played at the five play or three Play account and I've always been the betray and I've had to leave the group betray often feels really left out feels very isolating I mean it fits dramatically but I've often was like oh please don't let the betrayer be please don't let it me and then I'm chosen I'm have to you know sit in you know the toilet while everyone else is like sitting in the loung room having their long discussions about how they're going to be able to beat me game like Katan where if you only played it at two plays because the board doesn't really change in terms of its size the freedom to be able to build your things wherever they want becomes quite easy and so the tension becomes quite low the game kind of feels a little bit more like a race and games like Ticket to Ride kind of have that effect where the board feels Freer you don't get blocked as much and you can kind of do and Max

things out quite easily but when you introduce that third player or even fourth or fifth player all of a sudden everything becomes constricted the board becomes limited the choices become far more tense and the tension points all accumulate and makes the game feel a lot more decisive in board games like parks where you're moving your worker down a trail at the five player count the whole Trail becomes so cluttered with lots of different people and so you've only got one or two options on your turn when you're moving along the trail but when you're playing parks at two players or three players the trail becomes a lot Freer you can kind of do more and have access to more resources that you need to claim cards so games feel vastly different sometimes depending on how many people are playing so whilst we've had this really fruitful discussion I thought I'd share with you some of my favorite games to play at the three player count inish is a pretty cool game to play at three player cards you get to play epic tail cards you trying to VI for dominance with your Clans in certain territories you get Advantage cards based on which territory you're in and you're trying to literally viy for three Victory conditions so there's no points in this game it's about satisfying uh conditions like owning six centuries across the territory map or having dominance in certain areas the fact that in inish uh that social Dynamic of spreading across the territories and trying to uh impact and have control over certain

territories means that this odd number player Dynamic becomes such a pivotal mode in inish if you play this at two it feels very very relaxed it's probably less tense and maybe a bit too fast and cutthoat is but at three players you can kind of divert your attention between two other players br Birmingham is an interesting route connection game where you'll be pigging backing off the other players uh Connections in order to uh get coal use iron and even um manufacture be from breweries the idea that you're trying to connect routes together but also utilize what other players have built on to build a cool functioning economic system and this game plays a lot better at three or four plays and because you use more of the map there are more options for different connections and decisions and ways to score points small world is an area control game where you'll be acquiring different combos of factions and abilities in order to disperse different races throughout this small tiny land the idea that you're finding cool Combos and paying for combos that are more synergistic and then the fact that if you skip over other combos you're adding money so other players can potentially earn uh points means that there's a lot of dynamic to the market that you're uh kind of engaging with as well as the map itself the idea that if you have three or four or five players uh games like this means that the area control mechanism becomes far more Dynamic far

more interesting and where you choose to spread your different races is going to be quite pivotally important because as you spread across small world you're going to kind of flow into other people's territories and they're going to flow into your territories apiary is a b worker placement B bumping game where as players take different actions they knock other bees out of the spaces that they're in so players are going to have options for wherever they like to go however when they take that space a bee is going to get bumped from that position and increase in its value and when a bee reaches a value of four and then has to um be bumped up then they go into hibernation mode AP feels a lot more Dynamic at the three and five player count mainly because um the competition for the the different spaces and the bumping of bees really creates for like a flow on uh consequential interactive effect in the game the fact that you're acquiring these technology tiles to build out kind of like your hive and cover up and explore different space the dynamic between plays becomes a far more interesting one when you've at least got three four or five players so have you experienced some of the things that I've spoken about in this video what are your experiences of playing board games at three plays five plays seven plays or maybe 11 plays don't know if that exists maybe um yeah odd playing number games are kind of strange and it often makes me wonder

like why they design certain games for five players or seven players or three plays because that's such a niche number to have and it really just uh you know has opened this can of worms of what makes these games um designed the way that they are now if you really found this uh video topic super helpful and fruitful please consider sharing your thoughts and experiences in the comment section below if you really like my video don't forget to like subscribe and if you want to see some exclusive board game sanct video content head over to my patreon page and support me there you also get to say over the future direction of the videos on this channel otherwise this is Danny sunia I hope your next board game experience is a beautiful one see you

later

Progress saved