Top 10 Games We Dislike But Respect w/ Chairman of the Board
Transcript
thank you thank you howdy everybody and my guest there because he was still on mute uh but yes thanks for joining us all today Sunday three o'clock in the afternoon with a chance for two people from the UK to get together and chat so time zones aren't as massive a problem for us um the only thing will be just internet connection I just get that's the only thing um but yep I just had to come over from like a different live stream I was watching it was like Paul grogan's assembling an insert on his channel and it's just like oh let's watch that for a bit oh yeah I gotta set this one up now so not too bad but all in all a good weekend of trying out some gains getting stuff prepared for reviews and probably one of the most well not the best of Christmas dudes I've been to either I guess I should be slightly careful but cheers for everybody who has turned up this is another top 10 collaboration list and the idea comes solely from a returning guest to for some reason wasn't put off by the first time so this is Dan from chairman of the board all right and before we get started talking about the list this is where you can get like I say his internet is uh hit and
miss so hopefully he'll be able to stick around but we'll see how much is internet last while he plugs himself for 30 seconds that's your cue Dan you're talking yeah yeah so I'm done yeah sorry I can hear me apologies for the internet yeah apologies for the internet today um yeah so I'm Dan I'm chairman of the board um much like Luke um I am a one-man Channel I'm obviously from the UK and most of my content is based around kind of eurocentric games and but I also cover other stuff I like a lot of fillers and kind of card driven games as well and uh yeah glad to be back I'm really enjoyed working with Luke last time and um yeah I think our Styles complement each other quite well because we are pretty much on the put her opposite end of this spectrum and what we enjoy so hopefully enjoy what we talk about today we do have that I mean that was interesting there so yep lots of different games a lot of them that I would never play to save my life I'm pretty certain there's a good few there that I would yep nope nope not one I would play but the top 100 certainly an interesting one and still waiting for that to finish but as I know from first hand it takes a long time to get top 100s done so I sympathize with anybody who gets uh helped back with that um but at least you've got the chance to actually do things like the monthly things which I wish I had more time for I really do need to do a bit of a stock of what content I put out once I get past Christmas you know kind of like to start the new season for 2023 so we'll
see but uh that's all well and good so the the top 10 we got this one normally the patreons I give them a list and they vote on the favorite ones and I do those that was why the overrated games one came up last time and we had fun with that one with me and Brandon um this one is not one that was on the patreon list because there were a couple that we were thinking of doing the like games we thought should be in the BGG top 10 but then down at this idea for games that we dislike but respect which actually turned out to be a pretty interesting topic especially when I was having difficulty coming up with 10 because a lot of games that I dislike I don't tend to respect so I was trying to find 10 games that I can actually give some props to as opposed to just rant and say how bad they are so it's like okay that was tricky in itself but as you say because we are Polar Opposites in terms of tastes you know like your games that you love are far different from mine I'm as much as we'll probably get the same polar opposite with like games like presumably games that I like will be ones that you dislike in that but it'd be interesting to see which ones you actually turn around and say oh you know I can still respect this one despite it it's like hmm that's going to be tricky yeah absolutely and as you said um like a lot of the times I I can differentiate what I like to what's good or not and then maybe maybe you're a bit more harsh in that respect like there's a lot of things where I I don't I don't know yeah yeah that's fine absolutely nothing nothing with that but a lot of these
games I think are objectively solid designs they're just away from my my preferences um and I would even recommend these to the right person you know under the right circumstances even though I don't like them myself so I thought it was a nice blend of being you know negative in a way but putting a positive spin on the negative to give a more you know well-rounded balanced opinion yeah this is basically like going down in stages so we've had the overrated one which is basically like the upper echelon of yeah like negative ones I mean short of saying games I actively hate but then this one's kind of the next step down saying I still don't like these games but I can kind of go in a different world I would like him and stuff like that or you know and then as and then maybe the next one I do will have to be a positive one at that point you know it was like it'll get better it'll get better yeah I think yeah you do some positivity after that and I said I know one of the topics we're going to discuss was like top 10 game 10 games that should be in the top 10 on Board Game Geek but I think ultimately I probably would have lent towards games that you'd probably expect me to say so I thought this might be a bit of a quick careless it may be somewhat different and don't worry Jeffrey we'll catch you later um but the I mean with that one that would have been a half positive half negative because I would have been saying that these games are awesome and should be up there but then I'd also be rounding as to why certain games are up there so and I'd have to be careful as to sort of think well you know I love Arc Nova the bits it's in the top ten but does it really need to be in the top ten probably not quite yet but but then I get to say that about
everything else that's in that top 10 frankly um I don't quite see how endless winter would make this list I gave it an 8 out of ten that's a good that's a great game on my score so I don't see how that fits the dislike list um yeah so yes I well yes I think the mega lifts are a bit of a waste of space in it but still that's a that's a flaw with the game that's nothing else uh but yeah so I mean did you actually struggle to make the list like I did um top half of the list I did not struggle at all um bottom half the list a little bit more um particularly the bottom spots because I could have shuffled a few things up and you know honorable mentions up into the list and vice versa but I'm quite happy I'm quite content with the 10 games I've got here and I think there's a bunch of different reasons as well why you know why I do you know respect them yeah I'm hoping that even if I do hit on some uh sacred cows from some people I'll be able to redeem myself we're going it's like yes but I do respect you for liking it granted there's going to be a few games that I dislike that it's like yeah there's no chance I'll appear on this list but to be honest I think all of those you would have seen in the last top 10 I did so that would have been there and sorry look those they're spoiler alert we're not getting Concordia on this list okay I've never respected that game that's a given something would have had to although one game on my list I have ranted a bit about before in the past and it has warmed up a bit more so I mean that one might shock a few people but we'll see and yeah yeah Scout ain't appearing either it's like no respect for that little
game not happening what was that ah that works with it anyway oh I said yeah some some of the things you say I'm like how can you not like these games laughs I'm sorry Scout just really rubbing the wrong way that one it's like Grogan tried his best to teach me as soon and then I tried my best to get into it afterwards so it's just like yeah why I'm not getting it's like it's not working for me but as I say Different Strokes different folks all right let's get a move on foreign
my number 10 is one that certainly a lot of people's favorite game of all time you know is quite commonly actually um my number 10 is it's Twilight Imperium um fourth edition I suppose um and the reason I don't like this one is a lot of the kind of low-hanging fruit um too long it's way too long for me I mean you're talking six hours maybe a bit longer than that if you have the full you know range of players there um yeah absolutely and also um I'm not a theme guy you know you know there's some I'm definitely a mechanical Guy theme means next to nothing for me but there is kind of one exception to that and when it comes to sci-fi games sci-fi for me is a huge turn off I don't know what it is something the way I'm wired I've always never been interested in uh in sci-fi at all anything to do with sci-fi so no absolutely not the one exception is Pulsar but that's obviously um you know that's true but then a mechanical yeah calling that sci-fi is uh stretching it exactly um and also this obviously the um one of the main features in terms of the combat in this game is is dice rolling roll to resolve I I despise role to resolve games um I don't understand it um but hey I can understand that a lot of people do like that excitement of it that random random nature of it so again a lot of the a lot of the reasons I don't like it are pretty obvious reasons but I have to sit back and think you know what this is this game really did pull off the whole scope and the epicness of what this game should be so
it does what it says on the tin you know it delivers what it promises and it does have that true epic feel to it and that big kind of micro you know macro perspective um I also think it's um the main mechanism of the action selection system is is fantastic you know I love it in games like Puerto Rico I like it in games like um I can't think about oh race for the Galaxy that kind of thing um so yeah like really cool mechanical wise it works and it does it does well and I have to think you know if I if I stepped away from what this was and say there was a game that was slightly tweaked for someone like me where maybe the combat system was was changed to something a bit more deterministic and maybe there was a different setting um if you've made this medieval and it was a bunch of castles you were trying to invade and you were you know I I would we've seen that so many times but it's never done as well as this it's never done as well as this and I one thing I really loved about this game is um and this is what I remember about it because I've only paid it like two or three times and this was many years ago but I had you know strong distinct memories in my mind when you do this kind of like political phase and you can do like this voting system where something's come into play I think that's so that's so clever and it can really can make those standout moments but yeah it's just one of those games where I can completely understand if you love if you love sci-fi um and this is your cup of tea then what more could you ask for you know you'd be absolutely reveling in this if this is your you know if this is your taste so for that I give it full respect and I never questioned anybody who thinks this
is their favorite game to think you know bless you you've got you've got a game that's tailor-made for you and you can enjoy it so everybody needs that definitely needs that time commitment yeah that's the crazy thing I know somebody mentioned about that I don't miss uh was it UK internet connections my internet is Flawless thank you very much if anything I thought the Americans had more problems with Internet sometimes I forget who you have as a provider TF and I or something I don't know something something with initials and they're always a bit mad but uh I mean you could say you've seen some of the dice tower streams with their internet but no usually we're all right in the UK it just depends on region but now the toilet Imperium is a good one it's it's huge it's epic I love sci-fi but my God yeah does this thing need to be six plus hours it's just it's just mainly a length thing all right number ten well funny enough amusingly I've also got Twilight in the struggle of um sorry I've just literally just spoil it fight there you go Twilight Struggle I was literally trying to say I've got Twilight in the name and then I just said the entire thing oh well that's ruined let's start the stream again all right now this one is kind of it's a slight catch all this world because it's not just Twilight Struggle it's kind of a lot of GMT games and stuff as well like I mean I am not a fan of this game at all but I really know that I'm not the target audience for this thing it's it I get that if you're willing to put the time and effort into learning this thing it can be a really good two-player back and forth I just don't have any interest in the politics and that's cold war theme
it's just you know you know my connection with the cold war is literally James Bond movies I literally I'm not a historian fan and yeah and so this little back and forth thing was fine I didn't like the the dice rolling for Space Race and it's one of those things where you kind of have to know the cards ahead of time like we've got somebody's done some weird pay stubs on this one here but but yeah like if I'm playing just new and if I'm new and somebody else who's teaching me knows this game inside out they will wreck me because I won't know what kind of retaliations and things can come out so it I get I get why it's I guess get why it's popular I still don't get why it's so high in the board game geek ranking since this is kind of lower on my list down to number 10 but GMT games in general are a bit like this they're all these political themes they're two players three maybe if you're lucky they're very sort of thinky very strategic and they're thematic if you're into this kind of thing it's just they tend to not with the exception of I think dominant species Marine the GMT games have just not generally sat well with me but yeah I'd be hard-pressed to call them like oh yeah these are terrible games or anything but just a different genre are these on your shelf GMT stuff no absolutely not actually I'm I've not played this one I have played a couple of other GMT games which I have not enjoyed at all um but yeah this one I don't know what it is I think a bit like you I'm not willing to go down the rabbit hole and
get really familiar with it commit to the game with one other player because you know you from what I understand it's this one you don't really want to be playing with a bunch of different players because you're going to have that experience imbalance and it's just not going to be fun so I'll give it a go but I can imagine myself giving it a go and not liking it but um but yeah obviously extremely respected game but I can't testify because I've not paid it myself yeah just one of those things like you've got to be on equal measure you can play these cards and they'll have the events on them and a photograph and I won't know the first thing about what it's talking about so I'm not like going oh this this card reflects this part of history is like no I'm literally just playing a card titled something Liberation and I have no idea what it's on about you know it's it doesn't work as well now I mean if if there's an app for this game I don't know if an AI is a good opponent whether they I mean they know obviously everything inside out so it'll be an uphill struggle I guess but I guess that's in the name but nah it's like I say I get it but I think GMT games in general because I played a couple others like Churchill and uh I can't remember the other ones but Churchill was definitely one to remember and it was kind of like I get it but yeah this is they're just it's different different or was it different audience and it just clearly is not for me all right nines thank you okay so my number nine is one that I
wasn't too sure to put on the list or not but I'm quite happy it's here now this is uh Magic the Gathering um so I think with a lot of board games you you go through uh almost like a a state or an evolution where you normally touch base with magic along the way um I did that I played magic for a few years before I did go down the rabbit hole of board gaming um and the things I don't like about it you get quite simple stuff I don't like the business model of having to keep on buying these packs yeah I I don't like the idea of um basically paying to win you know you're paying to get the better cards I suppose and just the whole General I suppose the culture of the game I suppose the you know that power creeping trying to squeeze every you know every power level you can a Min maxing absolutely everything and I don't like deck building in its entirety you know I I'm not one to you know play like lcgs for example and then spend an hour tinkering with my deck before I play a scenario that that for me is a big turn off I got no interest in doing that but I can understand that people who like or have that stuck style of mindset um do enjoy that you know just take this card out get this one in keep on you know these minor improvements so again I completely appreciate that but I think the thing I I appreciate most about this game is well number one it's longevity you know this has clearly stood the test of time is yes and I think a big part of that is because of how flexible and how simple the actual core framework of the game is you know the actual mechanisms themselves are as
easy as it gets but all the keywords and things that's that's what was obviously the spice to the game and I generally don't like a ton of keywords and things in my games anyway um but but yeah I could can see like this is uh you know it's a lifestyle game you know if you want to invest in Magic you can be set for life playing Magic with with the group but yeah it's not for me I mean I I would happy playing this game if I've got someone in the same mindset as me who wants to go in for a bit of fun to maybe preset Decks that we know are balanced because you know the designers said so they used to do the Dual decks and I don't think they do any more and that would have been if I was going to keep playing Magic I'd just stick to them because they're balanced against each other I used to be a magic player back at University and yeah time sync money sync a few disgruntled people who I remember beating in tournaments who took it somewhat uh harshly and it's just like yeah it's a very you can be very unlucky with who you end up playing Magic against you know they're either going to wipe the floor of you and blow about it or they're going to give you a death threats as a response I'm not kidding I had one before it's you know some people do take this a little bit too far um I don't know what the Challenger one is I know the commander decks I quite like they were like pre-constructed hundred card decks they're quite cool uh I I must have been like I mean I don't like this model either anymore this I mean when did this come out 1997 is that 1997 I think this came out 90 or three yeah no no yeah
no it says 1993 a year I mean now we've been the first one so which means that next year is the 30th Anniversary that's going to be uh an interesting then they if they don't do some big event to celebrate 30 years they'll be surprised but yeah I mean lcgs I still enjoyed playing but yeah I must admit the deck building bits my least favorite part of the lcg stuff I tend to go online onto the net deck sites and just grab a deck and then build that and then stick with it because at the end of the day you can bake the best deck in the world but if you can't pilot it it doesn't make any difference so I'd rather at least cut the bit about making a decent deck in the first place and then just try and do well at piloting the thing you come if you give someone you give someone a nuke or something they still need to know how to fire the thing it's it's not gonna just wipe the floor of the enemy in no time at all so yeah I totally get this one but if I I would happily just grab a deck and play it now but that's literally the only way you're going to get me to play Magic yeah or any ccg model I'm gonna say no for me yeah exactly the same all right I'm a nine I I I'll be surprised that this isn't on your shelf or somewhere because I swear I've heard you like this one or at least the one before it it came out as a fantasy version but originally and I did play it and I did like it for a bit but sort of burnt out a bit and got a little bit frustrated with it then a sequel came out in sci-fi mode which is ranked somewhat too highly on Board Game Geek I gotta admit it but I do got to give some
perhaps that I do find guy a project to be overall a better game than its predecessor of Terra mystica overall I just wish that this one was just a bit easier to kind of in a sense get to the table and not quite be so punishing and why are all the pictures just lame bits of those things so there we go that's better this one is an improvement of a deal because I do like the tech tracks and I do I do like the fact that there's a variety of races I wish they were more balanced but yeah this whole idea that you would bid but to get specific races I mean if you have to do that before a game starts that's kind of proof that the razors aren't balanced but it is very thinky I do like the variety of pasta Victory and you know uncovering stuff off your board and having to decide right I've got to put stuff back on take stuff off you know get it in sequence it's a good efficiency puzzle I still don't quite get how the uh distance rules work in this game we're going to different planets I do find that a bit fiddly but it's as you say it's it's generally a game that I think is like it's fine it's you know I don't think it should be as high as it is on BGG but I have enjoyed plays of it preferably with just maybe one or two other opponents and preferably not ones who are experts at the game so I don't get the floor white with me because you know winning this game is not something that's a common place but you know I get it but yeah I mean your faves are coming bro I am a big fan of Terry Mr scratchley but as you said I don't think I would I would jump into terrorists and
knowing that a bunch of other players are way better than me um because I would be as enjoyable but I I have it I do have it on my shelf and I play it with people who are rubbished it like I am and I've always had a good time with it and I actually think that Terra mystica sorry I'm talking about Terminator because I've only played that one and not not this is the same game actually okay okay yeah I can't I can't even tell the differences um but yeah I've actually I actually think that terrorist gets a bit of a bad rep and saying it's so it's so gamey it's really you know it's like um a difficult game to grock and things I actually think it's relatively streamlined and quite easy to play um it's not the rules it's how to do well because you can easily paint yourself into a corner and then you're kind of wiped out for the rest of the game and pseudo knockout's not something I'm a fan of generally hence I wouldn't want to play this with people who knew exactly what they were doing because it's just like well I might as well just give you the game straight away the the one thing I was I can't remember of guard project does it as well but I was never a fan of the rule where you've got cheaper buildings if you built next to someone else because particularly in a free player game it usually meant that one two players were doing all right and one player got left by themselves and were basically on the back foot it's right there's like some little niggle rules that I would certainly want to change and like shorten it a bit more I don't know what I would think of Terra Nova the um the normal the one that came out I haven't really heard that many people go mad for it no it seemed it seemed to me like there wasn't that much of a step down from Terra
mystica like the extra effort and Terra mystica seemed minor in order to release the whole new game seemed a bit strange yeah from what I heard about it I thought if you're trying to make this like my first terrorist degree you're not doing a very good job of doing it um I did try it I did try it solo but I mean I I liked it fine solo if anything actually I probably preferred it so low to multiplayer in a sense but it was just then it was just trying to understand the the rules and like all the different factions I mean I've got like what like 10 12 in in the Box and I can barely figure out the first couple that I'm playing let alone try out all the rest it's it it got to a point where it was just a little bit unwieldy for me and you know me I'm a big theme person so I want theme to uh you know I want theme in my games and terabithic project never tried to introduce any kind of theme in their games I mean they changed it from fantasy to sci-fi I don't see what the point of that was you might as well have just kept it in there but I think at least they're trying to make some effort but that I like advice yeah that's what I mean it's doing well and I see I I played it and saw the appeal of it it just was like oh yeah this is not one that I'm going to continue playing for much more but when people get it out I'm like ah cool I remember a time when that was fine okay and it's
okay so my number eight is a feast for Odin um this one for me one you don't like okay yeah this one I'm not saying I I know this is we dislike I mean this one it just I got no desire to play it anymore um for me because there's so much going on here I feel like a lot of the extra stuff wasn't ultimately necessary I think you'd cut 30 from this game and it wouldn't be a worse game for it um yes yeah but at the same at the same time I understand that's why people like this one because you can try different things each time it's almost like a a sandboxy style Euro because again you can do something completely different this time and ignore a whole part of the game that you did last time it's but for me because there are so many worker placement spots and you know things you can do it did lose some of that kind of pure turn angst that you get from a lot of the great worker placement games in in my opinion um but again I understand if if you are uh maybe have a smaller collection and you have something like this in that it does have a lot of mechanisms in one game so it is a bit of a kitchen sink Style game you've got the you know you've got the polyominos you've got obviously the worker placement um you've even got some like you know role to resolve style collecting resources and things so it is a lot you know a lot in one box but yeah for me it just it just lost a bit of focus I felt like once I
discovered everything the game had to offer the appeal for me to come back to it wasn't there so like for me the fun was like pressing buttons to see what happens but once I pressed everything it was like well it takes a while to press every button in this game though that's true that is true but still I I thought like once I'd groked it and I didn't have the desire to go back and explore any any further and I also really didn't like the card play in this one maybe I was missing a trick with it but it was really tacked on I agree actually because I mean I've still got this in the collection but it is lower down in my rosenbergs then I mean out of the ones I like it is low down in that set because I do I mean I like the polyamino phone even though the theme makes no sense I do like having a lot of the worker placement spots although to be honest if I do play this it's generally solo only because the time it takes to teach and play a three or four player gamer this is just ridiculous but right and the solo mode seems to work quite well actually I quite like the way it happens but I like having a lot of options it's a open that appeals to me but there were some parts of this that were a bit of a pain you Norwegians is like the essential expansion to this game otherwise it just fundamentally is not balanced I haven't heard that yeah you've got to get that expansion which is already a knockout effect and yeah I agree the card system I was a bit let down by because not the weapons stuff but those occupations they just didn't feel worth going for you didn't get a lot of points from them they didn't give you a ton of great bonuses and of course you've drawn from a giant deck you've no idea if you're gonna get anything remotely useful so I've I tend the
problem is I I know I should avoid them because I know they're not very good but I want to collect them because it's thematically more interesting to say I'm the baker all right but I know I'm just shooting myself in the foot every time I try it yeah I mean again I appreciate it I mean there is but for me I'd rather play something a bit a bit tighter where you're stepping on each other's toes a bit more I think um but but yeah uh it's just it's just one that didn't it didn't click with me to be honest and and one side yeah once I got out my system I didn't really feel the desire to go back to it but but hey I know it's a very popular game and two honest I feel that way about most Rosenberg games I've not really found the one for me yet and the ones I do like are the ones really light like games like Nova Luna I think are fantastic but um no more is abstracts then I suppose yeah I suppose I I wasn't a huge fan of because that's the way I would have expected you to sort of like the half I know you probably wouldn't have liked converter because you'd have probably found that too open and I love caverna um coffee maker mentioned fields of art that's my favorite Rosenberg but then you might find that that's way too open because that's basically the kitchen sink of Point salads it's like you know crazy amount of options you've got in there but then that's one thing I love about it and I don't find that there's one thing in fields of R where I'm playing it and going oh yeah this strategy will suck no it's like this strategy will work I mean everything's getting your points it's just a case of beer fishing with it whereas here it's like yeah there's a few things to try but you need the expansion to make animals even worth going for and even then it's possible to just make
immigration kind of spiral out of control so it's it's like I say it's this one is still on my top 100 because I still enjoy it but I don't know if it's going to last much longer at this rate because I can't remember the last time I got this out every time I'm thinking right I fancy playing a solo UE Rosenberg game I look at this and then I go yep I got fields of all it's just that what drags me there so much quicker than this one does you know so this this was one oh yeah I definitely respect this game but it's I don't dislike it I think it's just a case that when a lot of his heavy games kind of feel the same now they're just blending together and now you've suddenly got to decide well which one's your favorite yeah yeah do you need them all that's the thing no not gotta catch them all when it comes to URI Rosenberg games okay so oh yeah speaking of a giant games in fact I don't know is this an early Rosenberg game I need to check as I look it up I don't think it was a ray Rosenberg it is a giant epic um nope Tim poles or something did this one but it is from Lookout games as well another fan of it it's regarded as an epic strategy game and yeah it certainly is epic because if you want to play the full game you've got to play it in four separate eras which is a little bit ridiculous the colonists though does have some good stuff going for it you know I uh there was some stuff about this that did intrigue me to it I mean one that's this style of game you know farming Resource Management you know build up
build up some little texts and that you know that all sounded good I particularly like the colony system in this I like the idea that you can go grab a different Colony there's different ones each game and they give you some special bonuses depending on which colony you go for and how far you leather up all that stuff was great production quality could be better there's way too many of these chits but oh my word is this game ridiculously long I didn't like the way it was split up into this four era system the idea that you needed to play like each era came out very like different the first era you basically built a shed and that was basically it you know I have I've gathered some wood a couple of Pebbles and I built a shed era one is over and yet it probably still took you the length of time to teach the game and probably a good 45 minutes to get through that era and then you go into era two and you build a little bit more but then the really interesting stuff doesn't come out until era three and four you could skip ahead to that bit but then you miss out on the build up beforehand so you don't really get a the best there's no Best of Both Worlds it's all compromised it's like one bit's gonna get on your nerves otherwise you've got to find yourself a good six seven hours to play all four racks of this game which is just kind of ridiculous but it was weird it's that theme that I do like this map thing I found good you know like I want to go to these different buildings and people are putting different ones down it's like oh I'll come use that now or go go grab this it's still the farming thing that I like in games
it just doesn't need to be quite this ridiculously epic um what kind of picture is that yeah I've not um I've not played this one I do have a friend who owns it but um yeah that I've heard it's really long that's a big you know a big obstacle for me my tolerance for longer games has gone down rapidly probably the last year or two okay but I'm sure yeah I'm sure I'm sure there's loads of you know mechanisms in here that I would enjoy personally but as you said if if you are jumping through a lot of Hoops in the first half of the game just going through the motions I could see myself getting frustrated with a game like that just wanting to just you know give a push um and not you know not dawdling behind waiting to get to the fun bit so yeah I think I'm kind of apprehensive I will give it I will give it a play I'm sure in the future but um I'm gonna have to be in the right mindset and prepare for the Long Haul I suppose and and the long teas I mean this thing's on internally on sale every time I see it's on sale because this is not a super popular game I mean somebody people who claim like oh yeah this is like one of their best games ever it's like yeah that's for them personally because they are in a minority because it doesn't it's not it wouldn't be on sale otherwise um although mechanics wise there is one thing I do actively not like in the game it's the storage mechanic I think like depending how big your shed is you can only store so many resources at once um and it's like oh I can only store two wood and a yeah around a stone or something and it's like seriously you can't just build a like a bigger like
storage unit in that you know it just feels like it's so tight like you're constrained so much by the storage mechanism not to mention it's wood and brick and stuff I'm sure you could leave it outside I don't need a storage shed bricks will survive in the rain I mean our houses are made out of rain trees are made out of wood they survive the raid I don't see why I can't just store it wherever the hell I like but this thing's adamant that it must be under shelter apparently yeah I generally do like um kind of games that have storage capacities but not for no reason like that just seems a bit Yeah necessary as you say it's kind of in there just to make it like oh yeah we just want to make it a you know tricky or yeah we want to make it tight for eurogamers it's like dude you've created like a seven eight hour epic Euro I'm sure you can afford to streamline it just a bit Yeah but some some people just want to throw everything they can into a game but let's say they do that alone I mean you could probably house rule that well no actually no it would fundamentally change the game but like I say that ruled aside a lot of the other stuff I like about it I'm ready
okay so my number seven is what I'm sure you're gonna disagree with me with I know we both don't like this game but I'm gonna show I'm sure you're not even gonna give it any respect and this is food no food chain I love Concordia our yeah food chain magnate um right yeah so yeah food chain magnet it's it's a very um you know it's overused this word but it's Cutthroat you know this is a very unforgiving and punishing cell game um much like we've alluded to before this is a game where if you are playing with somebody who knows the game they are going to absolutely trounce you and make sure that you never want to play again um so I think if I tell me about it yeah yeah if we if we let this all together then maybe it would be a different story and I'd have a different you know opinion of this game but right now I have no interest at all to play this one ever again um way too long that's right um yeah um it's it's way too long way too long for me um and especially as as you mentioned that pseudo player elimination you could be out of this game round one you're not making any ground up and um and yeah you're out for it but where I give it where I give it respect is the fact that um another board I like I like some of the mechanisms I liked the Milestones mechanism I thought that was quite cool if you're the first to do something you get an ability for the rest of the game I thought that was quite a cool little touch I did like that
um I actually do respect the fact that this game is so deterministic I'm pretty sure there's zero luck in the game um and if you have say four of you who are all of the same mindset you're all bloodthirsty players you know you're going for the jugular and you know you know what you're getting into and you get it all at that same level I can see you you guys having a lot of fun with this one because if you are of that particular type so yeah right group I think is a big um is a big part of this one um I also thought that some of the Thematic ties were you know they made sense you know and again I'm not I don't put a lot of you know weight behind theme but I think the advertising things you know all the different ways you can advertise to customers I thought it was really well done you know I think it's a good game I think it's an objectively good game but one that I got zero fun from so um yeah just not not my style and yeah just a bit too it just puts too much stock in people who've played it before they're gonna again they're gonna take you to the to the cleaners I feel like I could just take it the exact blurb you've just said trim out some of the sentences leave certain bits in like zero fun than that and you'd basically just get my thoughts on this side yeah I mean the stuff that you have problems with I totally wholeheartedly agree this is Cutthroat is all get out you can be out of the game from turn two it's kind of ridiculous um it somebody needs to tell splutter games to draw up some artwork go find some artists in there I'm sorry it's it looks horrendous but it does uh the the
stuff that the stuff that you respect it for I just can't respect it or I mean the Milestones even then I mean Milestones exist in other games but this thing off right if you're the first person to get the Milestone you get the ability but the problem is that now means that it's Rich get richer so you've already created a game where you can be knocked out really early and you're basically just saying well he's doing well and by the way he's doing even better now because we're giving him all this nice stuff it's like what you're right all right yeah yeah that last one thing I said sorry on paper yeah on paper I like that mechanism but in practice it worked different as you mentioned it was a rich get richer kind of thing and it made you somewhat paranoid about am I doing the right thing here should I be going for this this person's good at the game so they've got this Milestone and this Milestone before I've got any so yeah yeah completely agree it's no memory from there it's like I've got nothing nice to look at I've got the and then for four hours I'm just stuck there like going through the motions I know I can't catch up so why am I even bothering and sure just so much irks me with this it's like yeah getting respect from me for this game is going to be an impossibility it's just not one on there but I mean yep I mean that's the thing because I'd be surprised that you wouldn't like it I mean a bit and again I guess yeah the length and the cut throatness I guess are two things I know don't tend to no yeah it was your games yeah again big factor I generally don't like games when experience is a is a massive Factor like a huge Factor so
means that uh I mean I agree that it should be a pretty high rate weight not that I put too much stock in the weight rankings on BGG but you know it's it's a game that's got a decent amount of rules overhead and literally requires you to play correctly from turn one otherwise you lose I mean that deserves a pretty hefty weight rating and it's not just defeatist I just like fun games and this one was not one of them thankfully though I don't tend to see it on the table much anymore I know a couple of mates of mine that are sort of Die Hard fans but I still don't see them play it frankly so it's not like I have to be reminded of it on a regular basis but it does keep popping up yeah it doesn't give quite a ton of it it does seem to have quieted down a bit that game maybe he talks yeah yeah even with the ketchup expansion or whatever it was supposed to be I didn't suddenly see a Resurgence for it so it's just sort of like yeah there's a few Niche players that like love it to bits and it's like fine you've got four hours so I can squeeze you know at least two games of Art and over in that time so it's not a problem um it's big words I better not be on your list I like October few to deal with Brandon last time for that alrighty all right my one I mentioned earlier that there's a game that I did rant about a lot before and granted I still much prefer a certain game to this one in fact we've literally just mentioned it um but I have warmed up a little bit more to the game that it replaced which was the original terraforming Mars it I
had problems with this game for quite some time mainly with the fact of how long the game took especially if you didn't have Prelude in there that was like essential but also that you know even with the drafting you just ended up in situations where you know I'm the court that likes plants oh look there's no green cards what am I supposed to do and there was a little bit of that rich get richer style from it but as time has gone on I do like it a bit more you know to the point where I'm like okay fine if terraforming Mars is your thing I get it because there is some stuff I do like in it and I do like these card display like these card Tabo things of like oh I build up this nice little engine with options in front of me this one just takes it a bit too slow for my liking it takes a you know it this one could have been a 90 minute game but it ends up being like a three hour plus stretch you know art Nova can take a long time but I get why that one does take a bit longer this one I feel like if the stat markers just moved up a little bit quicker it wouldn't be so bad but you find you don't actually have that many rounds in the game by the time it's over yet it's still taken that time to do but and the communal map thing I just never really noticed any difference between the maps frankly it's like you can pay on hello Celestia or Mars but it's still just basically a bunch of Brown hexagons it's just changed where the river is that's kind of really it so I didn't I didn't get a huge amount from that despite some do but you know you you put me in a free player game of this with Prelude and I'll I'll play it and
then they'll still have a half decent time with it so this one has just built up over the years to say okay you know what cool I love my art and over you love your terraform me Mars that's cool not a problem as for all these other versions of it I mean Aries Aries is still not that sure the game you know I like the mechanic like the race for the Galaxy mechanic in it but I wanted that game to be like 45 minutes that game can still take 90 minutes plus with you know a decent amount of players it takes a while and the dice version I have no idea I mean just strapping the dice game although something doesn't instantly make it better so yeah um so this one I've actually not played telephone Master it's a bit of a kind of a guilty admission from me um again I've had to go it's really long get another big red flag for me um and you know you said you said that your game was over out of this one for me there's like a kind of a third pillar to that as well so I was like kind of a point where I thought you know what what type of Builder am I gonna get and I went to underwater cities and I think the water cities will do what I want this game to do and I'm really really happy with underwater city so I don't think I need this one as well but I'm sure sooner or later I will manage to go get misplayed but um yeah I don't like I don't like my games going along um but I don't like games going along if it could be sure sir what you said so enough for me from what I can be kind of cemented by you saying that is the case so I just never really had that massive itch to get this one played I don't know why despite all the buzz maybe it is the
Sci-Fi thing again but um but yeah considering how popular this was it just somehow managed to uh you know what I might manage to avoid it yeah I think your your mic's breaking up a tiny bit it might just be because your internet's having a site then we got the gist of what you said but there's definitely some bits there uh yeah there's quite a few comments that I sort of side in with it yeah I mean you can terraform Mars in the time it takes a terraform Mars yes definitely yeah if you are halfway through the game I can call the Victor and or at least the top two players and if you're not one of them then it's it's going to be like that but yeah a shorter game less players Prelude I'm cool I don't need colonies that just elongates the game and makes uh power plants ridiculously useful um Venus doesn't really add anything that interesting but the sideboard it's just more cards okay great but I'd rather just play normal terraform mods with Prelude shoved in and I'd be kind of cool with that really but again capping it for you players although I've played three player games of this where you get the one person who knew the game inside out but wants to a peer and min max it like crazy and it still takes three hours to play and I'm like seriously this should not be an hour per player get a freaking move on but as a it's it's cool and you can get me to enjoy it a bit more now which is a step up from previous where I was kind of hating on it quite a bit so maybe just because I was liking art and over more this watch you know this was before art Nova was a thing so I I guess I was just
warming up to it a little bit more much like when you're terrible in the planet and then as soon as art Nova came out I didn't really need to pay this any more attention so it just had that yeah that's all good with that all right so we're about six
okay yeah so my number six is root um so very popular game again um so the the reason I choose this one is pretty much for the style of game you know I've got no intro just in sitting through the game being taught to uh you know foreign
things when you don't really need to know it and you tell everyone else is capable of and that for me is just such um it's such a steep learning curve the point where it's just it's just too much for me again I apologize that is picking up um yeah my Wi-Fi uh kind of then um Carry On Carry On talking about root and then when I'm talking about mine see see if whether like twinkling with your mic or saying it makes any difference again in the UK I'm in heaven I mean I'm from the West country before I know the internet's not that bad down there it's kind of weird no yeah I apologize um okay okay I'll continue then but yeah please let me know if it is um it's really bad uh so yeah it's just that idea of letting all the different gigs at once too much front loading for me personally um I don't really have a group that this would work for or with um I just know it would be a massive um you know massive deterrent for somebody else to learn this or to learn it also group I'm going to lose the interest of everybody um uh yeah it's just there's too much um oh but there's some cars in the game that I won't prepare for when I paid this one and it left me feeling a little bit kind of disgruntled at times when something bad happened I was like well how was I supposed to know that and um so yeah for that reason I didn't enjoy my experience with it
um but obviously I have to respect the fact that he has or the design here has patched four separate games together into one cohesive thing so as a design feat I think it's absolutely brilliant like fantastic design you have to be very very clever to put a game at this together but for my from experience it wasn't really fun um and I didn't like again I didn't like that front loading and but the fact that he pulled it off you know pulled off those four different things into one game I thought was quite impressive so that's why root is my number six Fair dudes yeah their roots are root like I say I I gotta agree on that yeah the design is it's it's a decent game it's just not practical and the app has kind of killed it the app is such a good way to learn this game and play it that I'm almost like well when am I ever supposed to play it with four people randomly it's just not gonna hang on I don't know it's just not gonna work but that's all right all right while I talk about mine do you want to see what you can do with your mug I'm not sure what else you can do at your end but uh have a little Tinker around while I'm doing that um so on my six uh four letter word um if I still got root showing one sec take that off right there we go so with my I've played this recently and technically I've only played it once but then to be honest this is not a game that you can play a lot of times it's somewhat big it's somewhat grandiose uh
it definitely requires a a dedicated sort of group of people that are willing to learn it but and it's also based of an IP that I'm not a massive fan of certainly if uh the recent movie is anything to go by but I give respect that if you do have about seven eight hours to spend on a not quite a social deduction game but more like a negotiation Style game there are worse things you could do than play June June itself was an interesting experience when I played it but it is a long experience there is a lot of uh sort of swinginess in the game that can kind of take people out I do think the balance with these factions is not quite there uh because I mean if you play the benad jester it for example I think I was playing them you really do have a bit of a weird game compared to everybody else you can sort of get a lot of resources without even trying especially if you're the uh I think it was like the emperor and the spacing Guild just don't seem to have much of a problem and a couple of mates of mine were playing it and they and I'm yeah I'm talking about this version of do the gale force nine one but we got to a point about three quarters of the way through where two players literally could not stand a chance of winning so it's like why are they there but there were some fun things to be had it had some of the negotiation in it it had the bartering and some of the backstabbingness and I do enjoy that with a lot of games it's as somebody has mentioned it's showing a bit of its age though it's it's kind of dated
but despite the fact that they keep re-implementing it every now and again and you know would I play it again I don't know I don't know if I'd want to commit to it but it's it definitely does replicate Dune as in that Universe you know that IP and I must admit you know I'm not the massive fan of the IP I mean the recent movie was kind of supposed to be my entry into the lore or something and all it did was board a living Jesus out of me so uh you know that didn't help but yeah I can give this one a bit of credit there was some enjoyment I got from this but a bit like the Twilight Imperium one you mentioned before it's just like oh man how much time do I need to spend in this game you know could it be a bit shorter and I know they tried to release some like 30 minute version of this and as far as I can tell it's garbage because I've heard not one person talk highly of it or mention anything that great about it so it's I guess it was like a game of diplomacy and Intrigue or sorry but the fact that I've seen nobody mention it I think kind of speaks volumes as to how good that that uh re-implementation worked
um like typically how they desires no you're still chopping in correctly on that front um Charlie uh ah do you wanna try again
um can hear you but it still gets Dry still gets the crackling um yeah Lee yeah leave the string come back in I'll see you come back in and what I'll do is I'll talk about my five first and then we'll just swap the order around for that one right see you in a sec cool no worries yeah all over that so don't worry he will be back just hopefully with uh some internet that goes in there but yeah continuing on with the whole Dune front just I I give it some perhaps you know the game did give me some enjoyment but the whole guessing the turn thing I just thought was like okay seriously how are you supposed to make that work I don't know how you can possibly do it but like I've only played it once it you know I had to get a lot of the law explained to me um you know in terms of understanding who was who and what was going on but it was fine you know if people were fans of it and want to play it at conventions I can totally see why I think it's just one of those that needs a dedicated group who knows exactly what they're doing no randoms no casuals and you'll go pretty well so we'll have to we'll stick with that I guess right well while we wait for Dan to sort out his connection we're just going to move on to fives and we'll just change the order round for that number so hopefully we can keep track of what's going on foreign though he's only in Devon I mean well
they're saying that my parents are in Somerset and their internet connection is dodgy but then Paul Grogan usually doesn't have too much trouble and he's in Devon so I don't know but I guess I take my uh my internet for granted which I think is Sky and it was BT but I think in this new estate I just seem to have a Flawless internet connection for the most part all right let's oh God please yeah any better or not that was better yeah it will go with that for now you know people had suggested resetting the router and bits like that but yeah it sounded like you did need an off and on again moment there okay but you're in time because I've literally just moved on the five so you might as well just carry on with yours then okay because of my number five is inish um inish I thought was quite an interesting uh game actually um but the reasons I I didn't like it it was a little bit too abstract for me in the way it felt like it almost like chest like in a way and you'd find yourself in a lot of like stalemate style situations which felt a bit rigid for me at times um and you know it's one of those situations where you almost feel a bit paranoid at all times trying to spin all those plates and make sure nothing is going to work against you um and I also felt like some of the cards in terms of I think there was like two different decks of cards there's the normal cards you draft from and then this other stack you could get these special special cards from I thought those were quite inconsistent in their
power levels like some of them would be like whoa this is incredible and then something will be like well I got this card and it's quite circumstantial and not so great um so those are the reasons I didn't really like it is you know as as much as I probably could have and I also oh sorry I also didn't like the um I didn't like the combat system um particularly if you play well well when I play with people we wouldn't be quite stubborn players so we forget to a combat we're going to pretty much go through our whole deck of cards because no one wants to if our Penny you know no one wants to take the loss I suppose um it's deterministic in a way though isn't that more what you want it is it is but I I don't know I thought like it's just a matter of you bleeding all your cards and probably somebody else capitalizing because of that um I didn't I didn't hate that part but I just thought I would have liked it to be done in a different way but there were some certainly a lot of things I did like about it um I liked how all the pack cards was so you're drafting so it didn't take too long to get familiar with the actual cards in the deck and you could actually make some pretty Savvy plays because of that like you know if you know your opponent's going to go for something going to make a big move you can make sure you grab that veto card whatever to stop them doing it and I also actually really like this very minor rule in the game and you might be more familiar with this Luke than I remember because it's been quite a few years but I believe when you do the pass and draft thing you don't actually have to lock in the cards you've taken previously like correct is that right yeah you take your four cards
I think you take your four cards and then you choose one from those and you keep it Annie but what you do is that the three you get passed over you then add the card you just took to it and then you've got to take two cards and then you run into repeat and then take three cards so you could technically keep the card that you drafted first all the way through but uh you literally could decide to to draft bits later to say you know I don't need that anymore because I found a better combination that is pretty sweet I do admit um this one's this left a collection it it was in there but I I like a lot of the stuff to it I like the combat I love the card system I think it looks gorgeous and the expansion does shorten the game which is needed because it was it could drag on a bit without the expansion the expansion throws in a with the whole I I've got the crown I'm gonna win next turn thing the expansion introduces a variant which means that after that happens there's another cap on the game length so it can't just instantly go back and forth back and forth between loads of people and never finish um so that's always quite a good one but playing this with people who don't know what they're doing does drag this one out a bit and it was just another one of those deals where nobody wants to try the game I can't get a group of people who know what they're doing with it I can't keep it any longer which was a shame because ah it was enjoyable yeah what I like about this game as well is that it took a bit of a different approach to the whole area control thing where it's not like the traditional like you know blood rage Rising Sun smash
each other's face in it was a bit more of a sophisticated game and the way it it just I you know I appreciate that it's still different to anything else I love the artwork in the game as well I think it looks absolutely gorgeous I mean the card art is amazing um but but yeah okay now I game I totally respect that my player is is relatively low um that definitely has some redeeming features for sure and I can see why you know it is rated quite quite highly and a lot of people do enjoy it so yeah that's my number five inish I'm surprised it's rated highly because I mean I never see anyone play it because most people don't know how to play it or have never tried it um although eventually like number of people pronouncing I thought it was VI counts isn't it VI counts isn't the yes silent or whatever in that word but I don't know maybe I've been pronouncing it wrong for ages I know it's not viscounts or anything strange like that so but that seems to be the next part and and I thought it was it was inish isn't it what you almost sound like it's got a h on the end or how did you pronounce it yeah yeah yeah but I mean what are there people out there who seriously pronounce it you know in ISS or inis I mean hope not because that seems a little bit insane now that this one fits I mean I still like it but it was just it was another one of those impractical games that I just could not get played um and apparently I'm right on the vi counts sweet I mean why didn't they just pick a different rank frankly why did it have to be VI count just pick something else that's pronounceable
all right five oh boy me yeah um if you thought Dune was taking an IP and mate and making a game that's Cutthroat in your face nasty uh you know and wants to keep you there for multiple hours while you backstab everybody well then you've seen nothing yet when you've uh played this one and I have played it a couple of times and I did I did like the Thematic thing of this and I definitely played this when I was into the TV series a bit more this was long before the uh the series eight debacle for a Game of Thrones but the big second edition game as much as I'm not the biggest fan of it I can see why if people want to get this out at a convention they're gonna have a good time with it because it does do what it wants to do it wants you to have a you know a fairly lengthy negotiation style black stabby game much in the vein that Game of Thrones is is definitely representing the TV show in the books very well but uh the factions weren't entirely balanced there were a couple like Baratheon that I swear had too much of a good start uh Lannister I swear we're like not impossible to win with if you didn't know what you were doing but it had that problem again of being a long game that if you got if you got off to a bad start you were not going to win and particularly as Lannister I mean you are surrounded by everybody who hates you if you can't get your stuff out
the rich will get richer and you just won't be able to pull it back and it's not fun to be there with like only a few forces while everybody else is doing all sorts of crazy stuff and that puts me off it and that's why I dislike it but everything else it was doing with the cards and you know the I can't remember it was like a closed bidding system or something that you did for the uh like the turn order and that it was like you did with the crows I can't find a decent close-up picture of it unfortunately but maybe I can find one probably not but oh well but it's just basically you know there was a lot of stuff it did right sadly there was just a few things that it didn't do as well that I'm like yeah right I've not played this one it's actually on my on my shelf over there um I'm a huge Game of Thrones fan like massive um so I'm I want to get this out on an evening and just get make a whole night of it if it's a one-off play then so be it but I just want to say that I've played it but um but yeah I have heard quite a few complaints about um you know the positions of some factions being sandwiched in between others that kind of thing but I think if I go into the right mindset and think yeah this might go this might go completely you know Belly Up In It someone might get smashed but so be it it's Game of Thrones at the end of the day and how is the um how is the card play work then is it a matter of um kind of aha I've got this card therefore this happens um I wasn't quite sure how how that works uh to be honest it has been years
since I played it I can't fully remember but there were some cards that you could get that had your characters on there from your faction and they did certain things represent the character that they might be able to there they might be able to let you do some maneuvering on the board or swing a vote somewhere like I know there was a couple of cards I saw in pictures where you've got this Crow you've got the sword and you've got the iron throne and depending on the how high you were up these tracks allowed you to do certain things in turn order or do things better and so you know you might get Ned Stark or whatever and he's got a sword on his so you know if you play him at a time it'll help you in that respect but I can't fully remember exactly how they were but they were just a nice again a thematic Edition you know every faction did feel like it played differently like some wanted to just get out and Conquer from the get-go some wanted to hold back a little bit some were kind of more prone to alliances and that but being one of these style of games it was also fragile because if you get people who don't know what they're doing it will just unbalance things like crazy so it's another one of those deals where you know I respect it if you can get the right group I'm sure it's amazing but you're just not gonna commonly get that set up really and I certainly don't urge somebody to jump into a game where they've never played it with five people who have because who we You Are Gonna Get Wrecked and that's just not what I want yeah I'm really eager to play it yeah just have just have fun with your
first game I guess yeah yeah it's gonna be an interesting experience but ah well for us okay so my number four is a game that I know you like Luke because I've heard you talk about it a lot in the past this is five tribes um so five five for me is objectively a good game I cannot question that at all it is a good game I don't like it though for me okay it became look for me there was too many shifting variables all the time yeah so everything is changing because it has this my color system but it's a it's not like a linear mind color system it's a grid so yeah when you do something Everything Changes at once it's basically a kaleidoscope of options um at any time and for me it became a bit of work in order to make optimal moves you know if you really want to go down into the detail here and you know not just go with your gut reaction and just you know that looks good I'll go for that if you go beyond that there's just too many variables and the AP can be absolutely crazy because you could be leaving opportunities for other players so I think I think you do need to go into this for the mindset of just going with a gut reaction rather than stopping analyzing the board at every second which is going to change every second yes in order to you know in order to recalculate things and get again min max everything for me um yeah you and me is a very an analytical person it's hard for me to
switch that oftentimes so I think you know what I could end up spending five minutes analyzing the board but then it's going to feel like work so I'll just go oh my God reaction and if I go my gut reaction it feels like I'm not really invested so it kind of It kind of struck a bit of a weird balance there for me um and it became a matter of you know how long am I going to look at this board in order to get the maximum or the best move rather than getting just playing and having fun um I also tend to not like or enjoy the Bruno cathala element of his design where he always uses these kind of game breaking Powers a lot of his games have this where you have a simple system but you can invest in these player characters which will again mess with the game's rules for me I generally look at all the list of them and think you know what I can't be bothered I'm having a hard enough time trying to work out the game here I don't want to be talking about you're talking about the Gins then yeah the Gins yeah the Gins which yeah I couldn't really be bothered to think you know which one's the best me which ones should I go for what do they do again all that kind of stuff but I have to admit the game is very deterministic you know there is there's very little luck Factor here um and it's again a very well designed game and one of my favorite things about the game actually in fact it was my favorite thing is the um where it can bid you your points to go to go faster than the next round cool mechanism um I tend to like games that use a creative element when it comes to initiative and turn order and I think five tribes might be the one of the best examples of how to do it because you you know you're spending your money I think and your money is essentially your points yeah so
it's all about trying you know what's the what's the net gain here yes I'm gonna have to spend a fortune to go first but there's a really strong move there that I want therefore I'm willing to spend it so again I respect it in that in that way but personally I find it hard to get invested because if I want to get too invested then it's going to be too much work so yeah it was kind of a weird a weird kind of um sitting for me in my own personal enjoyment but yeah objectively very good game I forget you when we were at bacon earlier this year I did remember playing this two player with somebody um who like wanted to get it played it's like oh yeah I'm bought five tribes out in ages and uh I can't remember who won I think he won it but uh it was still like oh yeah five tribes you get two of you to play it it's such a joy because the the turns are quicker four player with this yes I got to admit you put anyone with ap anywhere near this and it's just like oh Christ it's not a long-term strategic game you've got to look at what's on the board but then you also need to not spend 20 minutes analyzing every single possibility because at the start of the game most of the points will be quite similar with the options it's just a case of what color you fancy when you get later on then yeah the points for a move become a bit more interesting but then there's also less options to think about so it's got that cool little Cadence there if anything actually my least favorite thing about it is actually the bidding of a turn order though because I find that most of the time people will just bid zero one or three or whatever which is not really a massive differential in points nobody in their right mind is bidding 15 or 20 or whatever the like
the higher values are because that's just such a crippling amount of points you will never earn that back with whatever move you do so if you exclude them out of the bidding range you're mainly just telling people whether they want to go for a second with like oh I'll be free I mean five is usually the max I see people bid if you're bidding eight you need to have a really good reason but most of the time I don't think my move is worthy enough to go that first so I usually just avoid it it's but one of those things I wouldn't have said no if they'd streamline that out a little bit particularly with four players worth but like I say it it works and it is cool that you are spending your VP to do it that you know that is something pretty sweet but yeah it got a bit bloated with expansions as well I wasn't a massive fan of the purple tribe been added um the second expansion to Sultans is not bad though because you get these little mini objectives you can kind of grab during the game which are quite cool for points but you want to say yeah you could just literally throw the base set of five tribes in front of me with two or three players Max and I'll have a good time I've yet to try it solo though I've heard there's a variant an official variant for it but not to try it out I'm not quite certain how that would work in the solo mode but it was starting to get it but yeah I've not played this in two player actually I've not made it two-player so um I think I played it three and four right three not so too bad but it can be a bit but two twos is the best one because as I say not too many people thinking about it but also you I mean you love the term bidding system in two
player you've got two each two of the pawns yes so you're having two turns each around so you can technically set yourself up for double turns as well which can be quite cool so yeah bidding turn order thing actually becomes a little bit more prevalent with two players I think then with three or four so it uh you know does a good really good job but yeah I mean that's the only thing that would tweak other than that you're still playing the same man color game so if that doesn't float your boat then it's not gonna suddenly change oh that makes sense four oh boy have I talked about this one recently on the various top tens and everyone's giving me absolute grief over it look I do like the game fine okay it's just not a favorite of mine particularly out of this Publisher's games you know I liked it more at first it showed some kinks in the armor and now I'm not now it's like a six out of ten for me I do think it's a little overrated but I still give props that paladins otherwise kingdom is still fun at times you know I still respect this game it's not like oh I only like Architects and VI counts and you know Raiders and Wayfarers and this one's garbage no it's just this one's it's like some of those sort of games you know I can only rank them so well this one is just one of my weaker links you know it's it does have some mechanisms I like I like grabbing the townsfolk for different abilities I like the options that you've got I just wish that the game just represented its theme a little bit better and wasn't just simply a case of spamming two actions over and over again with these color
meeples it just when it it goes so far down the dry almost failed like style gameplay that I'm like okay seriously what especially when I came from this after Architects which I really love but then this one was like um not quite as good but let's say still respect it I mean you could get me into a two-player game of this free MAX maybe but I know it's going to be a length free one I've yet to try it with the expansion I hear people say it fixes a few things it's like you know what I would happily play this with the expansion because if it can be improved I would gladly like to see if it can maybe it would bump me up but yeah I say I do still respect it you know I never sort of say oh you why'd you already why do you like paladins and not the rest it's like cool beans you like paladins that's all good you know put down your pitchforks yeah I've actually only played the first one of the West Kingdom trilogy The Architects yeah which I thought was quite nice but I thought of all of them this one would probably be the one that I would enjoy the most it almost gives me like the um the same Vibe of something like Olean um is that the case yeah um yeah well it's a different game to all the on but I mean they're both I mean they're both super dry but you know the bag Building compared with the meeple stuff in this is very different okay okay um yeah but I'll give it a go um how long are we talking of this one you said it's quite long it's how long is it I mean these games will easily fetch between two to three hours when you're playing it with like the most it
does drag on quite a bit because of just the sheer amount of stuff but going on in the sense it's definitely like one of the heavier ones there and I mean that works for some people uh not if you're colorblind certainly as to it says yeah if you're color blind this game will drive you up the wall but you know I I love Raiders I love Architects I love VI counts and I've even it's actually in the back downstairs I need to get it unboxed um I had some credit with what I say both of us we support Kinder or something and I've recently grabbed explorers of the North Sea from them because people had told me that that was actually a half decent game it's like you know what bye I want to try it so I figured solid let's just buy it and like give it a shot at some point so that's on my pile but yeah I you could get me to play paladins I'd just rather play the other ones that they've done but if somebody wants to throw city of crowns in front of me whichever the expansion was and just not make it like this picture the four player game which is ridiculous then by all means I'd gladly try it so yeah people think that I hate this game I don't I just don't like it as much as the others yeah I'll give this one I'll probably give it a go if I was pushed um but yeah the three hour thing doesn't sound overly appealing to me and I am quite badly colorblind so maybe that is a big No-No oh God don't don't even try it if you're colorblind this thing is like there is nothing in this game to alleviate color blindness you've got these different meeples they're different colors and this is your currency the meeples are not screen printed there's nothing on the board to
say the green has a line through it and the blue has spots or anything if you can't see colors and red if red green blue white and black you know if those are gonna cause you grief then you need to stay the hell away from this because it is just mad I'll take your advice I could say I I was kind of shocked that it really did nothing to help the color blindness but you know not every not every game has managed to do that but yeah if that's gonna say I don't think I've seen anybody who's colorblind try it but I wouldn't want to test the water shall we say I think that would just go a bit far all right top freeze
okay so yeah my number three is the king is dead um this for me this was the really difficult one for me to put on my list because and it's a difficult game for me to write actually because I think the game is so well done um but it became a bit too or I suppose the margins for error were so small and oh God yes it's yeah it's it's really is like a delicate Balancing Act in order to pull a victory off here and I'm not sure if that level of kind of uncomfortableness was something that I enjoyed you know it was just it's definitely probably the one of the purest examples of games that I I really appreciate it but my enjoyment of it isn't isn't quite there um yeah a little bit a little bit too stressful for me um and I think with each time I've played it I found it increasingly fun because I wanted to do better so it was it was a bit like you know something like chess again like I really appreciate the game but I I get no fun from it at all um but the actual concept of it I think is is so clever like the idea of literally puppeteering the three factions rather than actually you know taking ownership of one you're not a specific color you have a vested interest in all of them um and you need to making sure that you you've invested in the in the winning faction at the end I thought that was very cool and I think maybe more games could could use this there's a lot of I think there's a lot of potential to use that style of gameplay where you are again manipulating things on the board rather than trying to destroy the others I
suppose um like the heavy version of this in a sense because that's got a similar puppeteering thing to it what game's that Pax Premiere um oh okay that one has a similar thing of you've got three factions and a girl or something and you're not technically an ownership of any of them so but that's not the heavier version of something like this okay but I said one of my favorite things about this game is the fact that you have always like eight cards at the start of the game and you have to pace yourself with those cards from start to finish so every single one of those cards has to be used to the maximum benefit you cannot waste them um and I found pacing yourself is a really difficult thing to do because you could go you know you could spread them all in the first half of the game and they'd be completely at the mercy of everybody else to the second half oh yeah or vice versa so again every decision you make in this game is important and again make one mistake and if your opponent doesn't then that they're going to win so um you really do have to be on the ball and you know be very alert on this game so yeah it was one that when I played it the first few times I thought this is this is genius and then my desire to play it was just out the window I just never pulled off the shelf never even considered it so I'm quite yeah the kind of bell curve of me liking this one was steep you know a steep um you know decline so yeah but I completely understand why so many people like it I know a lot of people speak very highly of it and to be honest I don't have many I've never really heard many people
agree with me on what I say here um I think people just find it fun but I just found it a bit too a bit too stressful so I mean I can certainly understand people stressful not enjoyed it because actually to be honest certain people kept talking highly at this like saying it was like best ever or best of year and I'm like okay come on seriously this tiny little game with a few cards and characters you've got to be slightly playing this up a bit and I still think that's the case but I played it and was generally surprised by how much I did enjoy it it's I think I read it in eight and it is still on my shelf on my Osprey Square because as I say everything you've mentioned that the game does in terms of this cleverness puppeteering thing the fact that every move is essential I can decide sort of part way through like okay am I trying to win by this faction in which case don't want their cubes or can I cause France to come in and take over in which case am I winning on that one it's like oh the tightness of some of these scores and ends I've had and with certain people I know who have got into this as well it's just been a an enjoyable experience on that sense my only slight grief is that for a game that should be relatively short it's still short but you put four people in this and any of them like AP like crazy it's like okay come on you know we need to get a move on with this I know each move is Paramount but stop analyzing it too much which is why you actually with four people I tend to only play that in team mode um which I don't remember if you have to or not but with that one it's like yeah I mean a two versus two thing helps a little with that one-on-one is
good little puppies I find this one with three is like fantastic though yeah three people you don't have to mess around with the team rules it's just short enough that it doesn't outstay it's welcome and that but you know it's not like one person takes a faction although sometimes that can happen but with free I don't know there just seems to be a there's enough interaction on the map without the game taking too long and it just enters that lovely little sweet spot but uh um somebody mentioned like Brian Boro which is the other game I quite like the trick taking area control version uh I'm curious what the solo fan made variant is for it though because I do like the game but it doesn't hit the table that much but I try to know fan made variants I'm a little wary of I know that Arc Nova had a really good one I would admit I've played the art the Arno variant it is brilliant but still fan made is usually a worrisome but I come across these sort of things but if it gets it to the table boy I guess I got to try a few of them but NADA if somebody doesn't like this game I totally get it because at first I was almost ready to hate it the first time I played it because I was so sick and tired of people saying it was their best game ever of the year and stuff but it's like I don't know actually I quite like this one and most stuff about them Karen so I was gonna say I was always in the reverse cap because on paper I should love this game I love I love streamline games where there's no fat or bloke on it whatsoever um so yeah I was expecting to really like it um but I actually I kind of ended up replacing this with um like condotia I think I prefer condottier in every
respect to oh that's probably what I wanted from the king is dead yeah concierge I don't know I don't know how it's meant to be pronounced but yeah I know that one um that one's that one's fine yeah I enjoyed that one takes a little bit longer this one on paper was guy like to say that on our Luke I mean you hated eight minute Empire this is basically you know that with some extra sort of cleverness thrown in also you're probably not going to like it either and it was just it surprised me that I played it and thought oh wow because a lot of people sort of play it and don't quite get what they're doing for the first few turns which is a bit of a problem like you end up in a situation where you know every turn is critical and then the but then the first couple of turns they don't know what they're doing with it but as soon as their minds click and they start twigging oh you know that's always quite fun to see and certainly that happened to me in my first game because I'm like I don't know if I'm doing this right but ooh and then you start don't seeing the little tricks you can pull yeah this definitely one of those Petty drop style games right not gonna talk very much about my number three because probably for the first time on any of these collaboration lists and certainly for the first time on any list that Dan and I are doing this actually crossover um with a game that you know I generally I'm not a fan of either but still got to give respect for mainly the same reasons yeah why does this massive sci-fi epic game have to be three hours I don't guess you know I I like the theme of it
the various factions and some of the stuff and it is good there is a lot of good elements to this I think that dice chucking is not one of its best features I wish the combat system was a a bit more deterministic particularly when a lot of the games basically just turn into this which is everybody guns for the middle Mecca tall Rex and then just has a massive cluster battle there and it's like I wish it was maybe a bit more decorum to the Sci-Fi epic than just simply everybody like demolition derby it's like what kind of weird but I usually am one of the people sitting at the back I mean yellow and blue here they're sitting on their back systems and just taking up and stuff that's me in this game you know I just want cool Technologies and cool Point stuff you know I'm playing the Euro version of this whereas everybody else is trying to kill each other in the middle but man I would enjoy it more if it was just shorter you know give me empires of the Void too and that gives me like two hours you know of good space fun with a bit of combat and a bit of ticking and stuff like that this one just doesn't need to be six hours but you know I give it respect it for the same reasons you said it gives you exactly what it set out to you do yeah absolutely and as you said well I remember playing this one and everybody was kind of going for the again just smashing each other and um you know me being the kind of Euro gamer I am I think I had like some kind of trading faction and I was getting all my points from you know just peacefully existing yeah the Lions yeah
the Lions yeah I was the lions and somebody just came in absolutely obliterated me and I you know I didn't provoke them at all and I was like okay well I've lost interest now that is the thing yeah somebody can just come along and be a child dick to you I mean you know playing space Aslan is you know fun for a bit until someone does that at least with the tech I mean I like playing your universities because then you just play Tech strategy for the whole thing if somebody does come near you and it's like well I got better guns than you I just need more ships you know so it's it's not too bad in that respect I don't know where where someone said three hours because yeah quickest I've seen this go is like five six or whatever it's like maybe there was a four hour once of the fourth edition but that was free people who do exactly no not free like four people who knew exactly what they were doing so yeah this is not something that is short in any respect but yeah some of the reasons to what you said there's a common error I just want to come across here though uh where's the where was it a second ago kina's dead did your dislikes have anything to do with yellow losing too often I never noticed anything with faction colors losing often because at the end of the day everybody's got the same cards and they start in three similar locations I've seen no real disparity no I don't think so maybe maybe I've mentioned on a video before that I always play Yellow I'm not sure well I mean you don't play a color in them no I know but I mean generally all right never noticed that no I mean the factions have done fine I mean at the
end of the day you want the spread of the factions depending on which win condition you get but no I don't think there's anything particular I think it's gonna be faction doing better maybe because yellow's England maybe that's what it is maybe but who knows I was like no I can't start over which I debate the most of his internet while it still lasts so we don't want to strain it too much uh but yeah some of the reasons just wish it was wish it was shorter but I still give it props because I've had some fun times with it foreign
a couple of years ago massively popular I think it's rated extremely highly on the BGG rankings uh this is the crew um Cooperative why is everyone hating not the crew I don't I don't hate it in that respect yeah yeah I get respect um so for me I I got very little satisfaction from winning these scenarios I I didn't really find compelling to go to the next one and try oh now now we've got this extra rules going on and I got we gotta try to beat this one and again one side one side understood the game and understand how it works I didn't really feel the need to progress through you know through the whole list of 30 scenarios whatever I kind of felt like I'd seen what it had to offer um and I don't we like the idea of um you know let's try this Mission oh we got it wrong let's try it again oh we got it wrong again but we did a little bit better let's try it again and we then we we've sussed it so I don't really like that kind of start and stop style gameplay of trying to beat the next the next mission and something whenever I've kind of never played I have not played 30 missions of this though good blimey I'm impressed
um and one of the things that most people say was when I um you know if I mentioned I don't like this game is that they think oh you know you just don't get it you know you don't get it it's like I do get it I just don't find any fun from it um I will say now I am sick and tired of people saying that okay that excuse because I got the same problems when I ragged on Scout the other day or something frankly though this if your excuse or counter argument is they don't get it your argument is invalidated at that point all right that is such a cheap get out clause to say so doesn't get it therefore they don't you know therefore they hate the game it's like you can hate a game and still understand its intricacies okay it just I hate that used as a cop-out right sorry right over no no I completely get it but I said I I understand how nuanced the game is I really do I think it's a very well designed game like some of the um like again like almost like limited communication methods you have to do which you have to think outside the box you can be very clever with it and stuff like that I completely understand that and I understand why people like excuse me why people like that element of the gameplay they're very small margins of um and very good very sophisticated plays you can make um and I also think the actual difficulty Arc is well paced you know you do start off very basic just a little bit extra in the next round I think it's very well spread out to keep you engaged but yeah ultimately that that kind of dopamine hit from
completing a mission wasn't really there for me I didn't really um can feel the need to to progress much further with it and get in I think this game came out in what 2019 2018 something like that something like that 2019 yeah to bring out to bring out a game that is truly a fresh concept and unique you know full props because this game did really it was groundbreaking you know there was nothing else that did this uh you know a Cooperative trick taking game and you know full respect for that and it pulled off to a very high standard but yeah I think for me in general trip taking is something that doesn't resonate with me um but yeah I can objectively objectively see that this game is brilliantly designed but it's just not one for me all right I'm quite impressed some of these do a remote play with this actually that's quite a good way of doing it um yeah as I say I still really enjoy this trick taking's just a mechanic that I've seen a Resurgence in with me playing it like I now want to try so many different trick taking games because I I don't know I always liked them but lately I've just played a bunch more and it's just like yeah there's maybe it's because I am trying to Veer away from the stupidly long games a bit like you are and there's something that I just appreciate now about just like a nice simple card game that I can just get out and still have some thinkiness with and this is kind of like one of those deals like you know five minutes we can buy at a game you know we'll rinse repeat if we to join up the difficulty or beat the current Mission but each decision I'm making isn't just guessing unlike the mind which I can't
stand this one at least has you know proper guessing you know there's a reason an educated reason why I'm picking a card for the most part sometimes you're just chucking a card in but if somebody plays a card I'm thinking about why they would play it and there are reasons why they would providing they understand what they're doing so it's yeah it went mad and what you said about the so I'm doing something new in this day and age somebody asked me the other day if uh I like gave extra points just because it was brand new or something like that for a review and it's like it's not that it gets extra points per se but it certainly does get more props or credit like or entry from me because as you say it's so hard to do something fresh and new that you could make a fresh idea and it it completely falls apart you know just look at pendulum snowmire for a kickoff but uh the oh come on Fresh idea that crashed and burned but the at least it was something different this one was something different and it just you know saying home would be really well but it could have crashed and burned as well it could have just been a complete failed thing but I was still giving it props for like you know what you tried something different but when but when a game succeeds while doing something different then yeah perhaps it does score a little bit extra because it took more risks you know give me a generic Point salad Euro beige trading in the meds you could make it passable but frankly it's like well yeah but then
so did half a million others before you you know you haven't you've made a credible game that stands on its own two feet but you haven't gone to the next level yeah yeah to break through yeah to break through to something new is very rare and this game certainly did it I mean I don't know how many copies this has sold now but and again it's a very nuanced game and for that to click with people and to people to to get it um it goes to show it is is a quality design it really is a quality design um where's that it does the job all right two again I'm not going to talk too much about this because we're actually at the second crossover or like you'd somehow we've managed to actually cross over on these lists I don't know how that's possible but uh yeah agreement root you know I still like the game sort of fine I mean it's you know six maybe it's closer to a five now or something it's an average game for me I certainly don't buzz about it as much as other people do and it's not necessarily the design of the game because I do agree with you I think this is a cool idea I think it's kind of in a way a fresh idea and the card I wish the card play was a bit more interesting it's more the difference in the factions that's more interesting I just wish I didn't have to have to teach four separate games every time I play the things you know people will bring it out and it's like oh Luke are you interested in this and it's like right well I've got to resume how I play this particular faction but then he knows exactly what he's doing with every faction these two
have never seen it before so I'm gonna have to wait while they teach four separate games again and it just becomes completely impractical hence the app for me has killed it because I could just bang you know I don't really play the app much anymore but I did have a couple of videos where I did try to solo stream those and they were it was good fun but they actually taught me how to play the game in a good way so honestly if if people want to learn this game before they're gonna play it with somebody I would almost just give them five bucks and tell them to buy the app because that's actually a better teaching tool than someone else doing it and then you add more factions in and that just makes it even worse in the sense but yeah it it does the job I mean it's the same reason I never bothered playing Merchants code did you ever try that one no same reason I I look for reasons not to pick up games now you know I look through something yeah it works and when I when I see that I'm like nope I can automatically bypass that without even looking at it yeah and that's the same way to go it's like look it may be a fun game but I'm not teaching four separate things to people every time I bring it out to the table it's not practical I I do have a regular group of four that I can play games with but they're not massive root fans themselves and that and even then we want to play different games we don't want to play the same thing all the time but I go to game clubs I have to play with different people fairly regularly you know there's some rinse repeat but never like the same dedicated group week after week games like root just don't
work and I do see it played every now and again at my Portsmouth group but again I noticed that when they're doing it it's like right they're probably gonna have a good time I'm already a third of the way through my game and it's like they haven't finished teaching yet it's like ah so this is going to get kind of ridiculous but yeah same reasons you said root just they're good I respect it does it need to be quite so high on BGG hell no but you know at least I can say look I'm just not the audience it's a I'd like to say it's a niche audience but it's still pretty popular but I just don't know where everybody else is getting these regular groups easily but I guess that's just me all right well unless you've unless you you've got the exact same number one I can tell you that we're not crossing over again so uh we're definitely going to have something different for the ones
yeah we've definitely not got the same number one because my number one is Spirit Island um oh boy yeah Spirit Island for me um first off I have to kind of put a caveat on this thing I've kind of noticed over the last maybe a couple of years that I've never really clicked with a co-op game it's quite obvious but when I come to look at my collection I don't think I've got any that's above a party game that's going to be fair I'm not surprised by that because when I think of the games that I know you tend to like and particular designers and that they're not known for co-ops no no that's true I just yeah even ones I have liked I've kind of gone off them pretty quickly yeah they seem to have a short shelf life for me but Spirit Island Emma much no actually maybe in a different dimension it's it's kind of what are the games where it's you can you can very meticulously plan things with this slow and fast-powered thing um it's a real true brain burner and one of those things where if you want to min max everything you are going to have to put work in and when games start venturing on feeling like work to me that is when I start to lose interest and again I lose that fun Factor um I also thought if you do want to again min max everything then the game can take quite long um yeah and but yeah just despite that I think that
the game is phenomenal I think the design here is unbelievably clever um I love the level of control you could have I love the Synergy between the different um spirits and the way they play off each other you know push things around the board you know playing it you know literally manipulating the board to utilize the strength of all these different things um yeah honestly I think the level of detail the level of attention and control you could have in this game is truly uh mind-blowing and it's you know it's a very Advanced game for pretty a pretty simple framework actually it's not terribly um you know it's not terribly complex in the rules but the gameplay is Rich and you know really dense um it's not the best right rule book but when you boil it down especially if you haven't thrown branch and chlorine or other ones in it there's not a huge amount of rules it's just a lot of stuff no yeah absolutely but that that fast and slow powered thing was really I don't know it messed with my head because when you have to bear in mind that I'm gonna do this but by the time this happens that's already happened but then your powers does this and when I when I have to kind of especially communicate with somebody else and mapping that out it's um you know it became too much and I was thinking you know what just do your thing I'll do my thing and that's not how you get the most from the game so I actually think I preferred playing this game solo than I did playing with somebody else like quite a big margin actually and and the the kind of um the spirits that suited my game style
the most and that I preferred were the ones where you could literally um you know just generally go and smash the bad guys the ones that are a bit more in your face I kind of got on with them a bit better so I think which ones necessarily those you certainly like the lightning Bird yeah because you get to ignore the fact that anything is slow and you are basically zapping everything so that's kind of yeah yeah so the game I enjoyed the most was that one but I played for that one but when I started introducing the other ones and particularly when playing with somebody else and they're throwing their two cents in as well I just thought it was way too much work for me so again probably one of the most difficult games I've ever had to put on a scale from one to ten because yeah taking myself out of the equation this is like 10. but with my own enjoyment into it it's you know definitely a significantly significantly lower than that and I have no desire to go and play anymore so yeah this was the game that's first sprung into my mind when I thought of this list um but yeah I mean I can completely understand if you like co-op games this one could easily be your best game of all time or your favorite game and I cannot throw any shade on that it certainly has been on my law but yeah I mean I would be the first to say that it's not for everybody if somebody comes away not liking this it's you know there are so many reasons where they could uh like have problems with this it is stupidly dense it definitely isn't is I must admit 90 of the time I will play the solo rather than with other players as well because yes I do love co-ops and
and I certainly had some really fun two-player games and some free players of this with people who know what they're doing I certainly don't like to throw in randoms in a multiplayer experience but yeah you get the right people or if I'm just bringing this out solo it's like man I can have so much fun with the thinkiness and the theme in this game and it took me so long to get back into it as well of one bad teach of a long three-hour free player game put me off it for years until finally I was determined to give it another shot and then played it with people that I knew locally who knew what they were doing I could teach it better it's like dang why did I leave this out for ages it's like I need to go back but I'd actually be really um really fascinated to play this with somebody who didn't know what they were doing because I think I'd be quite an awe and seeing them how they pulled this off because is way above my head I'm terrible at it yeah I mean I could I could do reasonable at it but even then there's a cap at the difficulty of those scenarios where I'm like oh cry yeah I can't beat this level you know it requires an entirely new level of style of play but you know then I play those harder ones with the people who I do know that I played this religiously and it's like yep so wait uh interesting that that promise to do a spirit ranking video I thought I did I have a feeling somewhere on my live stream videos if you look at my backlog there was a time when I did do a tier ranking list of all the spirits because one pit Wonder did it and I decided to follow suit so I'm pretty certain I've done that already have a look through
all my um live videos on my Channel or something I'm sure it's in there somewhere um it's got a big picture of one of the cards like with spirits on it it should be pretty easy to spot um but man yeah you know a lot of people were certainly in the chat do like it but uh Shane's on your side Shane really doesn't like this one by the sound of it although bear in mind we may not like him but we are still respecting them so we're not necessarily going down that route um yeah do we want to review on Dark Souls no because frankly well I played it once and it's rubbish I mean it's yeah those games are not designed that well but that way they look cool but their design is not great definitely have done the spirit ranking video pretty certain so it was quite a lengthy one I remember but by all means check that out already but yeah I I totally get this one and must admit uh I'm not surprised you've now actually now this doesn't surprise me yeah I mean you're not normally into the co-ops and that and I suppose like I say theme is not a massive deal so that one sort of bounces off so I'm not quite I'm not surprised that you bounced off this one yeah it works it's strange because when I played it the first time I was I was quite impressed I enjoyed it I think I've even rated it maybe seven and a half but again my desire is times why it's just sunk sunk sunk and I don't want to go back that's right up all right well I mean they say you you picked on the daddy there well I must admit I'm doing kind of similar actually because this one
I do Gotta Give it perhaps um I can still get enjoyment from this game quite a bit in fact there's only really two aspects of it that put me off wanting to play this and it's not even including the fact that some games have come out that have replaced this for me you know I liked it more when it first came out I you know probably turned off it a bit then but we've we owe Rosenberg a lot for a lot of his games but you have to give props to the mother of always Rosenberg farming games the original agricula most of my problems I have with this game is the fact that it's too punishing yeah I've got to do a bit of everything or lose a million points I have to get children otherwise I will lose this game flat out yeah that there's those sort of things irk me with this but it's still a resource management farming game it's still a type of Euro that I really enjoy and a theme that I really like I like farming themes I think they're I think it's a fun mechanic you know gravity you know granted I wish it looked a bit better than just tiles and discs and stuff but I like to have my farm full of animals and decide if I'm growing corn in that it's tight worker placement I do like that sort of thing you know it works works for me on that but much like you say feed your people the game fields of all need you to feed your people it's doable though you have to account for it but you shouldn't get killed for it this one on the other hand does kill you Stone dead the second that you try to not feed your people because you'll either lose points or you barely
manage to feed anybody I don't I don't get it um props uh I suppose what is the dictionary definition of problems I mean it's Etc I suppose it's exactly what this list is I give it respect yeah give it credit it's it's weird it's a weird slang word I don't think it's actually a shortened word I think it's just some kind of slang that some of us say oh I like this yeah I was gonna say that looks a bit more uh realistic but we when you mentioned Feast of Odin you mentioned the card system in that I like the card system in this for the most part I love the fact that the occupations are a bit more interesting than this and you grab a bunch at the start I just wish that they were more balanced and you know that I could get more of them it wasn't just the six or seven or something I have at the start and I have to make do with those so it it's like I said there was a few things with it that put me off liking it and most of it is down to that punishing nature I don't like the idea I need a bit of everything or I lose a ton of points caverna solved that problem for me which is why I like I love these different ways that people have pimped out this game but uh which is kind of crazy and it certainly is a bit of a table hog mess compared to even something like caberna and that but yeah converter just gives me it gives me the flexibility to have fun with the farming theme and decide how I want to build my farm and so just fields of all in that respect this one is forcing me down a particular path of how to do it and by the end of the game I'm like well I focused mostly on cheap
farming I've capped out on points because you can't add more than a certain amount of each thing to score and because I didn't grab a single pumpkin or a single Pig I lose you know four or five points and the game those things just irked me hence this one Gap replays but yeah if I didn't have a gricola I didn't I wouldn't have any of these other really good farming based Euros because this is what spawned them all yeah I mean this this game was certainly um uh you know influential on you know the landscape of Euro games um and another guilty admission I've never played it I've never played it I think maybe because I played this no I've never expected this to be one of your like love Childs or something no not at all because I actually played lahav you know quite a while ago and for me even the feeding the people in that one was way too much I was spending way too much of my attention of the game just filling a quota before I could actually do what I wanted to do and if that's it was even more intense in this game than my interest is very low and I think if I want to try one of them I will go straight to caverna rather than trying this one first so that's weird this one would be more up your street because it's more tight and restrictive in that I I like it to a point but when when you're debilitated by being so restrictive I don't really like that so none of the games I I really love are that punishing I mean there are the other odd exception but not when again when something you you
have to do you know you're forced to do something um otherwise you're going to be punished so badly I don't really yeah I don't really see the appeal of that when there's so much else you want to do and you just haven't got the you know the bandwidth to do it so yeah I already am trying to say that but yeah yeah absolutely um but yeah I'm surprised actually because I thought this would have been something that would have been on your shelf somewhere and like you would have been one of the ones that goes oh a gricola For the Win not caverna or something but uh I mean the day fields of all is still my favorite because of that it's even more open with what choices you have it's just kind of ridiculous and it's kind of weird I come from the West country I'm not a farmer but the farming theme is just a bit more because I mean whoopee Industrial Revolution coal iron make make metal steel or whatever and make engines I don't care you know that that sort of stuff doesn't interest me at all but then nor does the trading in the med silken gold and and a lot of these other hash rehashed themes are used with Resource Management even like medieval as much as I like architects of the West Kingdom at the end of the day it's getting stone brick or whatever and building the cathedral that's not an interesting theme but I just think the farming is a fun theme you know but who doesn't like animals and you know who doesn't want he doesn't sort of get a good feeling when they're just building paddocks of sheep and cows and stuff I don't know it's just something about it especially when it's you creating your own board it's just a bit more appealing
in that sense but as I say it it's not you know if we didn't have a curricular I wouldn't have caverna or fields of all I much prefer those two and to another extent Feast of Odin somebody mentioned haloto earlier I not the big fan of that one actually halito was incredibly Swinney with those cards and they did mention that a similar thing now you've got that house that you move along or saying it all the score points you have to do that like that's the be-all or end all of the game so that one didn't work with me as much on there there was a question earlier that I was trying to find oh no yeah somebody mentioned um the governor of frantic fiends I've got it over there and I have played it including with some people who are big caverna fans and we weren't they they didn't dislike it as much as I did but I wasn't the fan it literally does what he just said there it gives caverna the Agricola viciousness which I don't want I play converter to not have the Agricola viciousness the Frantic themes expansion Frozen like Orcs who gotta defend them and stuff like that but it basically tightens the game and makes it harder to feed people and do what you want it's like well yeah but that's not what I wanted by converter for so your expansion has literally you know taking the game I love for this reason and tried to make it more like the game I didn't want and on top of that it says you can't play it with the first expansion forgotten folk which is the brilliant expansion for it so you're like you're not only making it like a game I don't want it to make it like but you're also disregarding the best
expansions it was like fail it's like social fail yeah so it's a matter of time I'm sure before I get to try um caverna but yeah I think agricular is one that I'm just gonna accept that it's not gonna be for me but I could be wrong it could be one of those ones that I'm going expecting not to like and end up liking it but I've yet to I feel that way about any Rosenberg game sadly at least the heavier ones over that is that farming probably is my blood whatever I like cider and I'm from the West country I wouldn't be surprised if it's in there somewhere but I don't recall anyone in my family tree being a herd of farmers so I think it's just that I would find it more interesting if I was going to do anything like that I've never played Ascension tactics I didn't even realize it was a tactics version of it I thought it was just a card deck builder but it you know it's a new one on that uh right honorable mentions before we wrap on them there did you have any others that didn't make your list I did I dropped a few down there was there was some more um I mentioned I wrote down champions of midgard um I thought that was I gave it respect because it does kind of give that hybrid effect of the Euro nature with the dice rolling but for me again it's more role to resolve which I tend not to like preferred it's a slightly more yeah Valhalla and something else I've not played it with the expansions at some point I would like to okay yeah I thought that was okay um Lord of the Rings the confrontation I don't know if you've played that one Luke it's heaven but I know a very intense almost like streaming yeah
yeah I thought the game was really well done but again the the margins for error were just a bit too a bit too small for me one mistake you're done for um Gloom Haven I thought the card system was good but the rest of it was just a bit generic for me um very Innovative brush design yeah I know player and they like it but I'm just I'm not a real-time fan and it just it devolves into just I don't know it's one of those chaos games that I just can't really bring myself to that level especially when out of the four stations that you've got I only want to play one cartographer if I'm not playing a cartographer I won't get any enjoyment out of sonar yeah exactly yeah a bit too chaotic as you said some parts of the game more interesting than others um unmatched was another one and also um Sobek the new two-player one really you didn't like that one there's that one it's a little bit too um a little bit too abstract for me I thought it was quite nicely done you can't seem to spot it maybe it's downstairs but yeah I remember reviewing that one recently I quite enjoyed that one that was a I mean saying that though I must admit I'm certainly more of a brunette father fan and that terms up uh Talisman uh no I'm I mean it's dated it's it's a roller move game that's way way way too long I'm sure it was a good laugh back in 1975 or whenever it first came out or something
but you know it's not something that I can respect anymore because I would never want to play it now um say thanks to you Agave uh with us to have online so I'm looking at a different list that's right uh coffee Trader yeah the one that I played recently at um gridcon uh wasn't this fat I wasn't a big fan of that one uh my two mates really liked it I wanted more theme out of my coffee game and it doesn't really have a lot of that it's mostly just leveling up tracks and spending off those tracks one of the tracks I don't even know what it's called it's literally just on the right side of your player board and you level it up in some weird arbitrary mechanical way that doesn't make any formatic sense whatsoever so I don't even know what they called the track that's how sort of dry it was um but it almost made my 10 but I was just like yeah but at the end of the day the more I think about it the less I respect it so it's kind of like especially for that 90 pound price point because I think that's a little bit ridiculous uh lahav we did mention that one briefly earlier I do like I didn't want to put that on though because I don't think I dislike lahaf I do like lahav the problem is there came a point where somebody I knew uh played We we played the half and he showed me like how well the way he played it and how he won it revealed the exploit in the game which now puts me off wanting to ever play it unless you house ruled it out he basically does the classic
thing of I don't care what loans I get because at the end of the day the acceleration you get from those loans just propels you into the the points and you just buy them off at the end you know nice and easy because interest and debt doesn't work properly in the in the game from a phonak standpoint as soon as that happened it put me off the game from that point forward but I would play it again if somebody house ruled it to say that interest charged per loan and not all together because well a that's how debt works and B it kills that exploit Stone dead but yeah it almost made the list as a on that result you already mentioned Captain sonar cult Express I thought that was being a bit too harsh I mean it's it's a luck Fest it's light it's for younger people I thought that'd be a bit harsh putting on Galaxy trucker I don't think I respect that one enough it's it's okay but it's just a bit like I say the time stuff I'm not a massive fan of I thought I suppose the most the only other semi-serious one was probably smartphone Inc um okay you know I've I have played both of those and mobile markets I think mobile markets are slightly better but I don't know I just I wanted again more theme out of it and I just didn't get any theme from it it just like all right this is a simple economic game through and through you know beat someone at the markets turn order is a big deal which I'm never as big a fan when turn order plays such a huge part over everything else but I did at least so you know what it's simple it plays five players which is
not easily doable it's not a complicated game it's just a genre that I'm not massively into and I just wanted a bit more theme out of it but you know the thing with the little puzzle thing is odd but it's a cool little puzzle to do so there was enough props I could give it to let's go huh I was contemplating that for the list um I like that one as I said we're not going any others in there the Serta games huh yeah I can see that you know the the giant they're heavy and I mean I've got some people I know who are raving about weather machine at the moment and I've played it it's fine but I mean all those are the surges I prefer you know to where the machine it but these ones have actually got theme whether the machine has no theme in it whatsoever and it just feels like another laserder game in a sense again it's like this thing that I want something fresh so I can give weather machine respect but yeah I just can't see the amazement Factor of it as much uh can't see any others nobody else uh destinies uh I did review destinies I suppose that could have maybe made the list because I can kind of respect it in a sense it does a story based game it's does app the app Integrations good the rules are straightforward I just wish the story was a bit more interesting and the whole they didn't do competitive the whole like oh we're going to make this a competitive story based game just doesn't work I'm obviously guessing you've never even wanted to go near it
but no no I didn't didn't pick my interest at all again anything campaign or story based I tend to just automatically dismiss yeah I mean this one doesn't have so much a campaign I think they were scenario based right but they were technically story based and I didn't mind the story the story thing but it's just like nah just I couldn't um the idea that you were racing each other to get through your story quicker doesn't make much dramatic sense but it also was just incredibly luck based you know did I go in the right direction from the start no well that sucks oh you went to the exact Church you need to go to well great I mean even solo I just didn't solo puts you on a time trial that forces you to get everything right otherwise you lose and it's just like no time stories had problems when it did that I don't need this Destinies as well uh Tony's been trying to okay well first leaner I already mentioned Game of Thrones earlier so yep that's definitely a thing Caesar I Can Only Imagine you have to verify you know because this is on right do you mean this Caesar oh well there's a lot of them hang on where's the one that I rated oh that one it'll be the palomori one probably yeah because I only gave that a five uh yeah this one I don't know could I I mean I don't like it I certainly didn't like it and I got a lot of flack for it
um yeah again because the amount of people on Disney doesn't get it it's like ah come on um at which point delete comment because I'm just getting sick of her but the I don't know do I respect it it's not bad I guess I guess I like this I would never make it it would never make a top 10 I guess I mean it it could be a top 20 maybe because I can see the push and pull two player aspect of it I didn't like playing it solo I think it worked better as a two player but the problem is the game was just so forgettable for me like literally it was like a whole it was the epitome of a whole bunch of nothing you know I couldn't get welled up over it but I also couldn't get excited about it either it just left no impact so it's hard to tell if I respect it or not because I can't generate enough emotion for it it just exists and it's there whatever if you like it great but it just didn't work for it fair enough I really like that one I think it's very clever that that doesn't surprise me on that one Perhaps Perhaps it could be perhaps it could be a top 20 I just I don't think it would be quite top 10 worthy but uh yeah I didn't think it was a bad design per se it was just not for me so yeah that could work um during was already mentioned yes I already did that one can't think of nope doesn't look there's many others okay just over two hours I think that's a good time to short things off so by means remember everybody supports all
creators so get on to Dan's Channel I think I think I'm still good on the screen there you go go find it lots of stuff and somebody mentioned earlier that it's good having Dusty one on the on the bases that we do have a very different tastes that's half the point because if it was just people who agreed with me all the time it wouldn't make sense but even I mean to be honest we've actually agreed more on this lesson than we had before because of a couple of Crossovers and the fact that even I think it's because of the nature of the list the idea of that is respected I could say Spirit island is one of my favorite games but I can totally understand people bouncing off it so it's not like oh you you you madman you know it's it kind of works on that but the fact that our tastes are very different I mean just that picture alone there I mean I've sold Coliseum I sold Kingsburg is that Castle's a burgundy is very old I need to update it because I've sold a lot of those games as well yeah like I don't like cars I mean like I say you've got failed which automatically is like you know I don't like those ones and uh castles are making like I think I've sold it when I kept Suburbia but I mean but even then you've got a lot of those fails and those like more typical sort of light to Mid base Euros or something which I don't tend to go for but it does make for two very different lists like the last one we did what was the what was the title of that one we did the games that aged well that was it yeah again like I say you do seem to pick some pretty good topics um but but that one there that was 20
very differently different audience and if we did like a top ten together like a top ten of a year or top 10 of all time thing I mean well to be fair we'll find out yours eventually when you get that far but um you know pretty good guarantee that if you go watches top 100 and then compare that to mine well yeah signori yep that's a promo come on um come on show me a game all right it seems to various to what it wants to tell me but I mean yeah signary I mean that's already a very different game to what's going to appear on on my list so you're probably it'd be interesting to see that you you watch both of our top 100s back to back also right you could probably find that you end up with a 195 different games yeah we do have some crossovers at points um so yeah you have that odd anomaly every now and then like you know we both like Arc Nova I like quite a lot so I don't you like it way more than I do but I still I still like it quite a lot um I wouldn't have expected no yeah so but yeah it's been it's been good fun talking about these games and it's good to again get the good balance of the positive and and the negatives and we can be constructive with negativity I suppose so how it works in there all right well take care everybody we'll see you soon so check out his channel check out the other stuff I've done including that Spirit ranking video I know it's on there somewhere so everyone else has mentioned it uh but yeah we'll catch you soon guys bye-bye take care enjoy your football or whatever it is you want to do tonight that's not for me but take
care see you soon foreign