Skip to main content
Loading video...

Top Ten Spiel des Jahres Board Game award winners.

Transcript 25:29

I'm Adam in Wales and today we're going to be looking at my top 10 games which have won the spiela yarz award now in July 2016 the new spieler yarz award is going to be announced and it's going to be either emot or code names or karuba that wins the award So today we're looking back at other games that have won the award over the years and specifically my favorite 10 of those games so let's make a start

Kingdom Builder was uh the first game by Donald X Vino to follow uh dominion and as such it had a big great degree of expectation because his previous game Dominion was such a big hit and in fact you're going to see that later on in this list so Kingdom Builder came out with this big Fanfare and it really divided opinion because it was a very very different game this game if anything it it it feels like it's inspired by something like Rina kitzia through the desert that game where you lay out camels in sort of trails around the board um but this game mixes in a whole load of sort of variants really there's different scoring conditions in every game the map is different in every game there's different um powers and abilities available in every game and yet the game play itself is fairly dry it's essentially a puzzle sometimes you get another players way um and it's a game that has health just Hefty dose of of Randomness in it um and so sometimes you can be a bit messed up by the card draw no more so than in a classic game like kazon or something like that but I think some of those games knocked it for a lot of players uh they weren't entirely happy with that stuff personally I've found I I've got a lot of enjoyment out of this game I I've enjoyed adding in the expansions and um I found it has stood the test of time um I don't think it's up there with the the the the top tier of spiers yarz winners um and it's perhaps a little bit too

complex for a a first time sort of Gateway game it's not as simple as something like carcasson but it it there is a place for it it's a sort of next step to those Gateway games um it looks lovely when it's laid out it's it's only a short game um and and there is a lot of variety in this box in Kingdom Builder each player begins their turn by drawing a card this card dictates the terrain type the player can utilize that turn either grass flowers Forest Canyons or desert the player must Place three of their settlements onto the board strictly placing adjacent to their own existing settlements and sticking to the terrain type shown on the card only if there is no adjacent location on the specified terrain type May a player Place their settlement in another part of the board placing next to special locations gives players Special Rule breaking abilities which are different in every game even more variety is provided by the variable scoring conditions which change from game to game in one game for example players May score by building next to water in another they're going to be building the largest clusters of adjacent settlements or alternatively they might be attempting to join various locations with chains of settlements when one player runs out of settlements in their supply the game ends and the player with the highest score wins

Quirk is a uh it takes Scrabble and it does away with the letters let's put it that way the rules are exactly the same as Scrabble really you're laying down tiles and trying to score rows and you can add to existing rows but instead of using letters and trying to make words we're matching colors and we're matching shapes it's it's an ingenious idea very very simple this really is a family game this you could imagine this having been around for generations and sitting on the shelves and Toys R Us alongside all those Mass Market board games but that's not to do it down because it it is fun it is strategic um and uh you know there's nothing there's nothing foolish or simple or old or old oldfashioned about this game or outdated about it it it plays well as a classic accessible abstract game in quir each player has six tiles which are kept secret from the other players on their turn they add one or more more blocks to the communal grid and draw new tiles from a bag the tiles which are added to the grid must match the same characteristic as the tiles already present either creating a line consisting of a single color or of a single shape the player scores one point for each tile in the line including the tiles already in play this is reminiscent of the scoring and Scrabble with clever placement players can even score two lines at once an identical tile can never featuring a line more than once so the maximum line length is

six tiles and completing a line of six tiles is called a quirk it scores double points the game ends when all the tiles are used and the highest scorer wins celup was the surprise winner in 2014 I say surprise because it was up against Splendor which is a uh an obvious sort of it felt like a shoe in for the award Ward really Splender has has just been this Mega hit but what's where Splendor is a fairly dry sort of exercise it's good it's a good solid game uh and it would have been a worthy winner in itself but what it doesn't have is the excitement of the races that you get in camel up camel up had that sort of toy factor that cardboard pyramid so people looked at it as a little bit frivolous it kind of it it wasn't a well-known game and it it it felt like a sort of child's game but once you start Play playing and you watch those racing camels and you back one of them and you see it make this miraculous comeback as it crosses the finish line and Nets you all the points those moments are are rare in gaming and it is one of those games where you'll stand up and shout yeah yes you know your your your camels just won the race um and and netted you all the points um I think it's a a fantastic game it's accessible it's easy to teach it's essentially a gambling game but uh but who cares it's it's it's great fun um family game that the the theme is funny those P those pyramids of of um of

camels they're stacking on top of each other as they as they go around the track uh fantastic game uh celup it's making me laugh just thinking about it in celup players bet on the results of a weird Egyptian camel race the race comprises of several legs at the end of each leg of the race play as score points based on the accuracy of their predictions when a camel crosses the Finish Line the game ends and a final scoring round occurs and the highest points wins on a player's turn they may do one of four things the first option is to bet on a camel to win the current leg the second option is to bet on the overall winner or loser of the entire race the third option is to move a camel by tipping a colored Dice from the pyramid Contraption the final choice is to manipulate the race using a desert tile which changes the camel's progress when camels move onto the same space face as camels which are already present they climb on top and if a camel lower in the stack moves again they will take the camel stacked above them along for the ride thus even the camels in last place have scope for exciting last minute bursts towards the Finish

Line number seven on my list goes back to 1983 uh now this is a game that I played a lot as a child and I didn't realize at the time that I was playing anything other than a mass Market game to sit alongside Monopoly and all the rest but what I was actually playing is a a sophisticated Euro this is the original um deduction game the the the all the players against one many against one sort of game where you've got one spy hidden ident not hidden identity but hidden location traveling around this map of London and you can only see what forms of Transport he's used and you have to kind of track him using that it's fantastic really simple really easy to teach um like I said with camel up exciting moments where if you're Mr X you're the guy hiding in the shadows those moments where you just sneak through and run away uh and the other guys they could have got you but they didn't there sort of you know heart stopping moments in this game it's been later developed into all sort I mean to be fair it's created a genre really so you've got games like Fury of Dracula and letters from White Chapel which in my view um bloat the system they they take what is lovely and pure and Brilliant about Scotland Yard and they make it into this big convoluted extra long thing I don't need any of that I need a map of London I need an underground a train a bus and just see the tickets and and and try as Mr X I'm

trying to get away or as the detectives I'm trying to catch him I think it's a fantastic game Scotland Yard stands up amongst today's modern spers Yara winners in Scotland Yard one player takes on the role of Mr X and the other players hunt him playing detectives Mr X moves around the map of London writing his location secretly each turn on his own log book he doesn't give his location but he does indicate his mode of Transport so other players can deduce his approximate whereabouts particularly because every five turns Mr X has to reveal his current whereabouts if any other player ever lands on the current location of Mr X the game ends and the detectives win if the detectives run out of movement options or after 22 complete turns without catching Mr X the game also ends in this case Mr X

wins 2006 turn and taxis wins the award now this is two years after Ticket to Ride and it's a similar sort of game and I think ultimately turn and tax this loses out because Ticket to Ride does a lot of what turn and taxes does and it does it in a slightly simpler slightly more accessible and slightly more attractive way that's not to say turn and tax is a bad game I think it's a brilliant game and actually I think if you're interested in that sort of game this is a good Next Step from Ticket to Ride um but the theme is dry it's about developing post offices a system of post offices around uh around Germany um and essentially you're laying houses on the board and trying to create a network of these houses to gather points the the the the rule set is is simple but it's it's there's a couple more bits to it than there is in something like Ticket to Ride um it's had a couple of expansions as most of the spiers yaras have the first expansion was excellent um I think it's power and Glory the second expansion all roads load all roads lead to Rome not so good um and it's it's kind of been forgotten um which is a shame uh I I think it's a great game I think it's well worth looking at again in turn and taxes players are each attempting to build a postal system in Germany in doing so they collect bonus tiles and valuable carriages which will all translate into points at the end of the game on a player's turn they must add a city card to their hand relating to a location on

the board they must also play a city card adding to a so-called route a network of adjoining cities in addition they may choose to take a second City card or play a second card or clear the selection of cards on display if the player wishes they may score the route they've been building and in this case the player May Place one post office onto all cities in their route of a single color or place one post office onto a single city of each color in their route bonus tiles are awarded for completely filling certain regions of the board with post offices and carriages are awarded for creating long routes when one player completes a route of Seven Cities or when one player runs out of post offices in their supply the game ends and the highest points

wins number five tial oh this is a good one this uh this is one of a Trilogy of games The Mask Trilogy along with a game called Java and a game called mexic um actually I I I I prefer Java to tcal um but Java didn't win the SP as yarz so I'm talking about tcal today and it is a fantastic game it won in 1999 wolf Gan Kramer and Michael keyling the brilliant team and and this is you know a Euro game that was around before Euro games really existed 1999 it's just starting and what a start this is a beautiful game a game that really evokes that sense of exploration As We Lay out tiles as we explore um a jungle and we find these little temples and and and it's an area contr game really we're trying to claim dominance over these temples and and then and then score them later um stunning to look at uh really sort of uh interactive game getting in each other's way um nice sense of as I say of that explation lovely lovely game tcal in tcal players excavate the jungles of Guatemala receiving points for recovering treasures and controlling Temple sites on their turn the player places a new hex tile on the board covering a selection of the Jungle and then uses 10 action points to explore action points can be used to move to uncover temples to create camps and to

recover Treasures uncovering temples makes them more valuable and players score for these temples if they have more workers in that tile than the other players sets of matching Treasures also score points after four scoring rounds the player with the most points wins

number four and what is there to say about kazon that hasn't already being said this is the ti laying game this is the entry point into the modern board gaming um world for many many people it was certainly my first entry point into the into the hobby um the this this old this this box it's been reworked recently but it still looks very similar and it's starting to even look a little bit old hat but the game itself self I mean this is the game that introduced meeples it really is Iconic in our board gaming world it's simple enough to teach to practically anybody there's a kids version if people are too young to play the current the this version there's in fact there's a load of different genre versions of kazon Star Wars carason basically there's a version for anybody there's two player kazon in kazon the castle um there's there's the South Seas version the Gold Rush version all manner of different games this has become an industry in itself and it's not overrated it's a it's a fantastic game um and you know it it deserves its place in the history of board gaming in kazon players build a communal map of the French region by placing tiles on the table representing cities roads and Fields on a player's turn they add a single tile to the map lining up matching terrain types they may also place a wooden person onto the tile they've just placed this game introduced the term meeple to describe these tokens if the meeple is placed

onto a road it will score points for the player when the road is completed I.E blocked by a junction at each end if the mle's placed on a city it's going to score points when all the city walls are joined up if placed on a Cloister it scores for being completely surrounded with tiles finally if placed on a field it scores at the end of the game for being close to cities players can manipulate the growing ball throughout the game to muscle in on other players scoring opportunities and when all tiles have been placed the player with the most points

wins you can't really talk about carason without thinking about Ticket to Ride because really these are the two most significant games as Gateway Games into our hobby along with perhaps Settlers of Katan these three have introduced more people to gaming than any other game uh and and they're well I'm not a big fan of settlers I've got to admit but caraz on and Ticket to Ride stunning stunning games this game is that it's it's the in it's so ingenious the fact that you can explain the rules on a single rule sheet and yeah this is a meaty game it takes an hour or so to play maybe that's slightly overdoing it but we've got a nice big board it looks like a board game it looks like a board game in the eyes of people who don't play Modern board games this is what they think a board game is it's a worthy successor to those old-fashioned outdated Classics like Monopoly and cludo and all that sort of thing I forget them move on to Ticket to Ride This Is Where It Starts okay Ticket to Ride mine is the uh 20th uh no not 10 10th anniversary edition 10 years of Ticket to Ride is a beautiful production this particular version very expensive but you can get many different versions of ticket r a bit like I said with kazon you've got two player Maps You' got three player Maps you've got really sort of tight nasty mean little Maps you've got ones that are much easier going you've got ones with nice little rules variants there's so many different ways to play Ticket to Ride I haven't explored hardly any of them um

and I love it and I'm looking forward to playing more of it and and you know that's that's 10 years on in Ticket to Ride players Place chains of plastic trains onto a board to connect cities and score objective cards held secret from other players on a player's turn they may take two cards from the supply or play a set of matching cards from their hand allowing them to place trains onto the board and scoring points for the length of that route the third option is to draw further secret objectives from the deck when a player has played a set number of trains then the game ends and players score points for secret objectives they fulfilled and they lose points for unfulfilled objectives the highest score wins

number two and number one on this list are among my very favorite games of all time Dominion was an absolute turning point in the hobby this was the creation of deck building games by Donald X Vino who also made Kingdom Builder this was the precursor to Kingdom Builder and it was so successful that that's why Kingdom Builder I think upset so many people because they were expecting another dominion and what we've had instead of just having another Dominion we've had hundreds hundreds more dominions and they've never been quite as good in my view I know that's controversial I think Dominion is essentially themeless we've got this sort of medieval sort of look to it um but really this is a simple card game uh and yet there's so much Variety in this box what other deck builders have done is taken dominion and added a whole load of theme into it constantly trying to make a story out of something which is essentially an abstract sort of mechanism um I it works for a lot of players so uh I'm very very happy for them but personally I I can just appreciate the the Ingenuity of the the different card interactions and that sort of thing and the fact that they're still producing expansions now when there's already so much content for it just shows the endless imagination of Donald X Vino in creating these these different cards um it's a shame he's never quite managed to recreate the success of dominion with any of his other games but if this is all he ever created then he's done a service to the board game World um Dominion absolute

Masterpiece in Dominion each player starts with a small deck of cards which belongs only to them they're going to try and add Point scoring cards to this deck throughout the game The Player's initial deck has some coins in it and a few Victory Point cards the player draws five cards from their own deck and this will offer them income to spend on new cards to add to the deck they may choose to purchase more valuable money cards like s silver or gold or they might buy Victory Point cards or or special action cards which will give them better and better abilities throughout the game whatever happens all cards used are placed into a player's own personal discard pile and when their deck Runs Out The Player's discard pile is shuffled and it becomes their new deck hence cards never actually are spent you know not even the money cards the player's deck just gets bigger throughout the game and these abilities and their spending power just gets better and better each game has a completely different set of cards available to purchase so the strategy in the game is all about spotting card combinations to utilize ultimately when the last the so-called Province cards are taken the game ends and players count up all the points in their deck the highest scorer

wins number one Dixit my copy is Dixit Odyssey which is the 12 Player version uh but but I I've got the original Dixit I've got all the different expansions for Dixit oh my word this is this is my number two game of all time uh I I I absolutely love Dixit it is the Artistry that has gone into this game the beautiful images the beautiful artwork the fact the way it manages to to sort of gently encourage players to be creative and imaginative but it's not actually to taxing it's not like we have to tell stories it's not like we have to come up with anything ingenious but we do have to just just unlock our imaginations a little bit to get into this game I've seen it turn off some players who struggle with that um strategic players or players who are a little self-conscious um but it it when it works oh my word it's a Sublime experience it's a lovely insight into people's minds and yet everything in this box is so gentle you know the images are lovely there's a little bit of a just a delicious little dark Edge dark fairy tale sort of edge to to some of the cards but this is a game you can play with small children they'll get it you can play it with families you can play it as an after dinner game with adults um you can adapt the the the length of the game you know I've played this as a sort of 10-minute game everyone have a quick go or I've played it as a much longer game I've I've rarely met people who who who don't like the game outside of those those groups

I've mentioned previously the sort of strategy Gamers and the people who perhaps are a little shy or or or um you know lack the confidence with with this sort of uh this sort of creative stuff um but Dixit I think it's I think it's stunning I think it if this was as a Bo if I want to show people what the board game world is capable of uh and and why I love it so much and why it's worthy as an art form it's not just um some geeky little hobby that you know you can hide away and and play you know but but but not accessible for the masses Dixit is the game that's going to convert people Dixit is a creative party game using beautiful dreamlike images on a player's turn they give a title to one of the cards in their hand and they place it unseen to the other players onto the table announcing the title the other players then select a card from their own hand which could have the same title and they place that card face down onto the table too these cards are all shuffled and then they're revealed players then vote on which card they think belongs to the original title Giver the tricky bit here is that if everyone guesses the correct card the title Giver scores no points so they can't afford to make the title too obvious but if no one guesses the correct card the title Giver also scores no points so they can't afford to make their title too difficult to guess so

the title Giver each turn is actually trying to give a slightly vague title which some players might interpret and guess correctly but others will not so that's my top 10 winners of the spieles yarz award thank you very much for watching um if you liked my video please watch my others or subscribe to my YouTube channel or follow me on Twitter at boardgame Wales and on Board Game Geek I'm Adam 78 thank you very much for watching all the best

Progress saved