Skip to main content
Loading video...

The Games I got rid of in 2021

Transcript 22:51

welcome to the games i got rid of in 2021 now the purpose of these videos is to talk through the games that are leaving my collection and why they're leaving their collection why they aren't keepers why they're not going on the permanent shelf and why i'm just kind of moving them on and the reason i do these videos is it's a sort of exorcism for those games banishing them for my presence so they can move on to a better and hopefully more peaceful existence somewhere else now that doesn't mean every game i get rid of i think is a bad game i get rid of plenty of good games a couple of great games even but there's only so much space i have on my shelves and there's only so much and there's only so much space i can have for each type of game and it really is about keeping my collection at a manageable size where i can actually play the damn things because because even though i'm a professional board game reviewer i like to actually play games i'm not currently reviewing and when you've got too many it's really hard to get through them all so so if i'm not playing a game and it's not what i'm really really that emotionally invested in i gladly move it on to someone who will have a lot more fun with it and i think that's just a good thing for us to normalize in the hobby there's no point holding on to stacks and stacks of boxes of games you're just never gonna play again so anyway here are the games and we're doing them in alphabetical order first up on the list is chai an incredibly good looking game that just didn't have the gameplay i wanted in it now it's pretty safe to say that i'm probably not chai's target demographic i like my games a little bit meatier and if i am going to play something smaller like that i don't necessarily want a box you know this big uh for a game that's

really a light small box kind of game i'm sure there are plenty people out there who love chive but after playing it two or three times i was like i've seen what this game has to offer and i don't think i'm going to get any more challenges out of it and that's really worrying like after the first time you play a game you shouldn't necessarily be going i know how this game works i know how to maximize my points already i don't see this game throwing me any more surprises all i have to do is this set sort of way of playing and i should get a very high score each time i still think china's a reasonable game i just think it's doesn't really do anything that hasn't been done before in another game and many games have done it better plus it takes up way too much shelf presence for what it is next up is dinosaur island a game i really really wanted to love i love the whole dinosaur theme jurassic park making dinosaurs putting them in pins all that kind of stuff i also really like the art style in dinosaur island and when i looked at it i looked at the rules for the game i looked at everything about the game i was like i'm going to absolutely love this game and dinosaur island is a pretty good game it's just over engineered for what it is and there's these four phases and all this stuff happening in it but ultimately it's a run-of-the-mill worker placement game with a few fiddly bits here and there and no amount of cool production values kind of disguises the fact that it is just this pretty ordinary worker placement game

beneath this really cool concept and really stylish veneer like i really like the amber dice as an idea but in game they just add resources to a pool that you then take to put in something and then place a workout to turn that into a dinosaur it's a lot of flash and not enough substance and worker placement really is a pretty crowded genre i've got a lot of worker placement games i would rather play than dinosaur island i'm still eagerly waiting to hear back from the dinogenics guys because a lot of people told me that that's a better game than dinosaur islanders and i am very interested in trying it next up we have june a game of conquest and treachery i can't remember the time i just call it june light it's the light version of june that came out late last year now in the review i said this is the perfect version of june for people new to the hobby or who are fans of the film and want to try something because it's got a fair bit to it for a game like it is it's not monopoly like there is plenty happening in june but i'm an old-school june player so i looked and i was like oh this is missing so much of what made june special for me i'm not the target audience for this new game i'm not the target backer for it at all so while i reviewed it i put those words in my review that i knew this wasn't going to be a game i was going to keep because it wasn't made for me and you know what that's fine not every game needs to cater to my very peculiar wants and needs and i already have june

so you know more than happy to move june light out the door and let someone else have a crack at it i know a lot of people are fans of dinosaur island so there's already probably a few people angry at me in this video already but there's a lot more people who are fans of the next game and that's dude imperium i wanted to like june imperium i like june i like worker placement games that allow you to do other stuff i think june imperium is a reasonably clever design and i can see why it's popular but i found it like just so dumb just it was just a dull game a dull bloodless lifeless game it was general sort of work replacement stuff with some deck building in it and a confrontation phase which is like ah for for someone who's a war gamer at heart it's like the most bloodless engagement i've seen in any game to simulate a conflict it's just so unsatisfying that you're okay to love june imperium that's that's perfectly fine you can also think i'm terrible for not liking your favorite game but ah just pulled the pants off me and there's this thing in a game where people talk about theme and how it works and for me that's all about ludo narrative consistency that doing stuff makes sense and there's a lot of this happens because game in um due imperium like you could honestly strip arrakis out of it uh make it about four colonial powers colonizing the new world and you wouldn't notice a beta difference aside

from the card out would be different and card art is not game theming that's just that's just art like the game itself and its mechanics have to sort of reinforce that and june is just not a setting where you're like i place a worker and get a thing and i place another worker and get a thing and oh look i've collected the set of fremen and everyone else is collecting sets of freeman too it's just yeah um solid reasonable game but i just found it dull and not really a dune game like that's it i think it's a solid kind of dull game but it's a just not a good june game and that's the sort of thing that really matters to me is how much a game really grabs onto that theme and makes me feel like i'm living in that universe and in june imperium i felt like i was just june the accounting uh this one probably won't surprise anyone evil corp uh it was a game i did a review of because you know i like the idea of it i it seemed like a novelty but it's basically a glorified munching game and it had a really weird sort of pile on the leader a second person tends to win because the first person gets blitzed kind of vibe to it it was a little busy for what it was and really chaotic and random like there's a certain baron pretzels crowd who love munchkin and love that sort of game where you like screw each other over left and right and for those people this would be a good game but my group's just they're they're already into that um we do like a bit of

birth and we do like a bit of back and forth but we don't like it being really sort of arbitrary and weird like oh this dice happened in this thing so you lose that like um so yeah evil call um pass that one on next up is fun fair and fun fair i got rid of not because it is a bad game and you've probably heard me say this a few times it's fine it's perfectly fine the thing is there's also unfair which is like the evil version of fun fair and which one you like is it's kind of interesting because unfair is a better game unfair has a lot more going on but as the title says it's unfair it's an unfair game mean things happen and that's fine if you go in knowing that it's that's kind of brutal unfair mean kind of game which you probably should because it's called unfair now funfair downplays all that and gets rid of it and keeps the funfair elements of the game but takes away the nastiness and it kind of takes out the the special sauce it's like there's a signature burger out there that has this really tangy sauce that you either either love or you hate and the people who love it are like ah give me this tangy sauce burger and everyone else was like oh my god this is revolting that's unfair fun fair is the same burger with no sauce so you bite into it you're like tastes like nothing and ultimately that's why funfair moved on it's just a bit of a nothing game

it's a downtuned dollar kind of version of a polarizing game the funny thing is i gave this one to the person i borrowed unfair of because because i borrowed unfair of them just before the covert lockdown and we didn't see them for months and months and months so i actually held on to that game we moved house with their copy of unfair so i held onto the game for nearly a year um so i thought the least i could do would be to give the game back and give them funfair as a sorry for keeping your game because of the pandemic for over a year my bad and kobet's bad next up is fall gardens a game i legitimately enjoyed and thought was incredibly clever the main reason i got rid of this one is not because i disliked it or thought it was bad or anything but because one of my play testers absolutely loved it and begged me to give him the copy and you know what that's a perfectly good reason to give away a game i get a lot of people who come around and test games with me and they do it you know they give me their labor for free mostly because i like playing new games and i assume slightly because i like playing games with me i hope so but it's unpaid labor it's unpaid labor for the channel they're coming here they're giving their time to help me test the games and sometimes i just go hey you love that game so much you've been around here a bunch here you can take it now if i'd absolutely loved full

gardens i probably would have kept it but it was it was on the cusp like it was close to being a keeper and if i was gonna sell it or move it on in another way i probably would have held it for quite a bit longer but you know you've got someone who's there they've contributed their time to you you might as well you know give them the odd free game oh yeah and if you're unfamiliar with four gardens it's like really clever it has a central tower thingy and you spin it around make moves to spin it around to collect different resources it's a little bit different and it's an innovative game and now i'm actually slightly going why did i give him that like it wasn't that bad it wasn't that bad like it was a good game i think he just begged he just begged so much that i had to give it to him i may be completely misremembering things but that's my story and i'm sticking to it next up is kitchen rush a game that has been on my top 100 before now i've talked about a concept called space before and that's where you have multiple games that do something very similar and there's no point necessarily having you know a half dozen games that do much the same thing unless that thing is something that you really really really like like do you actually need 10 different dungeon crawlers do you need 46 worker placement games maybe maybe that works out for you but sometimes there's a specific game space where you're like do i need an extra game of the exact same type in this category and i got rush md which is the medical you know reimagining of kitchen rush and it's same sort of gameplay same designers

it's just it's a hospital instead of a kitchen and i vastly prefer rush md to kitchen rush kitchen rush is perfectly fine but rush md is just i love hospital games like i am a sucker for hospital management stuff and i just i love the whole picking up organs with tweezers and you know patients coming in and someone screaming out ah we need like four cc's of the stat it's it's ridiculous it is a fantastic fantastic game i love playing i backed it on kickstarter i got all the expansions and stuff for it so you know i've got this big stack of rush md stuff kitchen rush well do i really need to keep that game am i going to go who wants to play like real-time madness and then you got to choose between these two things i'm probably only going to play russian d you know once or twice a year which means kitchen rush is probably going to get played you know once every three years or something do i need it no i don't so that one's going on because game space having multiple games in the same conversation when you're going hey we want to play this type of game and if there's a second game that you just you just won't get to well maybe move that one on because you're always going to play the other one instead oh boy now we're up to on mars a game that i had so many issues with i did like a 10 12 15 minute long video about it with a song at the end on mars

is a game that i have a lot of issues with mostly because it just doesn't feel like it needed to be on mars like you go to mars and you're mining crystals like what like i don't get why it's a mars game for me it felt like a game that was designed to be an old world new world colonization game that then just got rethemed because you've got the space station this orbital and when you're up there you can only make decisions and acquire stuff but you can't communicate back to the planet and i can't figure out on with mars how that would work how you would have a station above mars that can't communicate with mars that seems impossible to me it does make sense if it's going back to the old world and the mining of crystals well that's just classic new world exploitation of gold or silver and the more i looked at it the more i played it the less marsy it felt and it just it got under my skin and i'm sure it is you the people out there who absolutely love the game who think it's like the bee's knees but again for me thematic consistency lunar narrative consistency that the game makes sense that things are happening in game because they make sense to the game's world instead of this happens because it's a game like i i can put up with that in some games but when a game is sort of

marketing itself as a thematic experience and it's got these dissonances in it yeah it really gets under my skin and on mars got under my skin like very few games ever have before or since last year was a funny year a lot of the games that people really raved about i just didn't get um you know lost ruins of arnach it's okay june imperium yeah and then meadow ahmedo was quite popular with a lot of people and i played it and i thought it was absolutely forgettable like nice looking game but yeah not much to it um i just really played it kind of went oh that that's that game done and i honestly i'm sitting here now trying to remember the mechanics of the game and i am struggling but i did a three minute video on this uh where i little book i compressed it down to three minutes and right now i can't tell you anything about meadow other than it involves moving north and south and collecting cards one of the most bland uninspiring sort of game experiences i had last year now i had a lot of pretty average game experiences last year but meadow just stands out because i saw all the hype beforehand i see or seen all the hype afterwards and yet for the life of me i can't tell you much about the game at all because it just went in one year and out the other and that doesn't happen to me i am a you know mentat i am a person

who remembers rules and crazy things and lots of stuff about games like i can pick most of the games off my shelf and tell you exactly how to play them but mido not a clue i got a really nice picture from them and they seem like lovely people but game just didn't hit and the hits continue as i pick on another one of the very popular games from last year and that's merchants cove first off i'll say i adore merchant cove's ambition i adore what it's set out to do its aims its ambitions and its overall presentation and style it's really clever like the design thought design process that went into it i think is is really really neat but it's not for me like for me the game was a whole bunch of people sitting around a table playing their own mini game and then we resolve it kind of in the middle like asymmetry is a really cool thing to explore and it was really neat for them to make these character boards and all the stuff on them and that's cool but it just felt like everyone was in their own world doing their own thing and you know if you don't know the other players boards you have no idea what they're doing but more importantly what they're doing doesn't actually matter what matters is the products they put out at the end and where they're putting the boats but all of the complexity in the game is in these player boards which is the definition of multiplayer solitaire you are literally playing your own game by yourself so yeah a game i thought was really

stunning um very clever and ambitious as all hell and my hat's off to them for designing it but it's just not a game that interests me after playing each of the boards once i was like okay that's cool i'm done oh this is going to make me seem really contrary because the next one up is marvel champions which is rocketing up the board game geek boards and it's really really another popular game and i kicked it to the curbside because i thought it was dulles dishwater oh this this is not an attempt to be edgy and controversial this is just you know i didn't like it um i like the akamhara lcg and i like the narrative aspect of that you know this is a sort of game i really like it brings you into the story things are making sense because you're you're playing clues and you're getting things and cool stuff is happening marvel on the other hand uses a similar system to just kind of throw numbers at things until they fall down like i'm not a big fan of the marvel comics or dc comics i've never actually read a marvel comic in my life and i suspect if you're a fan of marvel there's probably a lot more to marvel champions um than there is to someone who isn't to me though the character creation was kind of dull it was just stuck in the sort of halfway house between sentinels of the multiverse which i think is an expertly executed um superhero game uh which has a lot of cool stuff happening in it and the arkham horror lcg this is what i played with steve and she yeah she's got way stronger opinions on it

than i do she really hated it yeah like she'd just scream abuse at the screen of how little fun she had playing marvel champions so yeah marvel champions a game for me that was stuck between two things i really like on one hand you had akamhara lcg and on the other hand sentinels of the multiverse and these are two things i really like and and marvel champions was in the middle and it wasn't a peanut butter and jelly kind of combination it was more of an awkward teenager with a squeaky voice it's not quite a boy not quite a man just sort of stuck halfway in between being awkward and pimply and the last game on the list is star scrappers orbital this was touted as a new game from the designer of terraforming mars when in fact it's a really old game by the guy from terraforming mars and it shows it is it is definitely not a new game by the design of terraforming mars it feels old it feels dated it's not good it was not a fun experience and yeah this one left my collection pretty much as soon as i finished a review like it's interesting to see an earlier design by someone who would go on to make your favorite game and go okay i can see they learned lessons from this but getting sort of marketed as though it was something new and fresh and ended arriving would have been really disappointing to some people it was like finding out that this artist you know that has like one mega cool

album that you play over and over and over again actually had an earlier album but that album is like entirely kid rock covers and you put it on you're like oh oh well i'm i'm glad they got better and that's my takeaway with star scrappers orbital i'm glad they got better now that's the end of the list and remember just because i got rid of a game or i'm not particularly fond of a game or i have an opinion that a game is pretty mediocre that doesn't hurt your self-esteem you can have your own thoughts about games and that's fine don't you know swear and yell at me because i didn't like a thing you liked this is all part of the cathartic process of moving games on from my collection of exercising the demons and making this house a clean and pure place free of bad memories of terrible games or in other cases just filling the room with happy thoughts that someone else is enjoying the game more than i would and in some ways that catharsis of letting go of the game is a good thing and if your shelves are crammed to the broom and you're wondering where the hell am i going to put these next 30 kickstarters i ordered think about moving someone think about clearing some space look at the games you've got on your shop and go am i ever going to play this again probably not consider moving it on there's someone out there who will probably enjoy it a lot more than you are currently not playing it a reminder three minute board games does not do paid content keep us independent by supporting us on patreon and if you enjoyed this video hit the notification button like share and subscribe to the channel

Progress saved