Skip to main content
Loading video...

Three Gateway Games- Catan, Carcassonne & Ticket to Ride board game- What do we think of them now?

Transcript 22:41

everyone has to begin their modern board-gaming hobbies somewhere and for a lot of us it's with one of the big three gateway games khatam ticket to ride or Carcassonne and now that we're well and deep in the Hobby we're going to have a look back at those three games and see what we think of them now coming up hi it's turned and Stella for me for your entity welcome back to our tabletop diary hopefully you've been enjoying our flock so far every Thursday evening in Australia or Thursday morning in the u.s. usually and thank you so much for commenting on our previous vlog as well I really enjoy looking forward to read your comments there this week we have a topic that town actually came up with and I sound so surprised because I haven't seen each other because it is a really good topic and that is right did you start with one of those three games did you not maybe you saw it nah Polly that so what I thought we'd do we go through each of those three games I don't know if they're actually called the big three gateway games but that's how I think of them from 1995 settlers of catan from 2001 Wow long time out

there from 2001 Caucus on and I think 2005 was know when was ticket to ride mm I think it was a little later but I can't remember now sorry about that that's something I'll probably like put a note in their screen somewhere at editing just make me look stupid no I have no idea you have better ideas with me anyways just continue sir yes I what I what we'll do we'll go through each of those we'll just recount our own personal experiences with them because we would each have played them before we met each other and what we think of them as games either then or now so all right can you start with guitar it was it was my gateway I forget who brought it to was when I was playing games with group of friends from work I forget who brought the game but don't know about this story by the way so this is news for me as well so yeah yeah but it was very eye opening and it was very you know it was the first modern game I'd seen and had these mechanisms I'd never seen before and it instantly made me want to go out and get it and I

played it a lot over that first year it was very much my gateway that was the basic attack yes yeah and I just like yeah it has it's so it's so simple but it has enough different pathways to victory it's not too long it has it still has a bit of randomness with the dice but then it's so much of the game as the negotiation over resources it's got just enough blocking on the board I mean you can see why it's been such a successful game over so long yeah there are so many different themes as well and extensions yeah I don't think that was sexually why one of my first game oh it's from me still in the early days but it wasn't the one that made me well board game I think it was um it was actually the red dragon in yeah finally it was that bad friend's birthday and it was like eight of us and I got in late and I was watching people playing games ourselves that looks so fun so I started and then they kind of like be a little bit gentle at me at the start because I they usually they play board games more than me at the time I started playing bat and they've gentle it didn't really attack me and I really enjoy it Freddy name and from then on I started to look up we went together then Sarika for public working meter and then the first game that I played there was

one of the forbidden I'm pretty sure this does it forbidden desert although we lost at the time I'm pretty sure we lost it's a tricky one yeah I look like Jaipur I remember that because I think the other two players are gone and then just the two of us and play type oh yeah and I kind of member the rest I think that's just the first three games that I play and then Catan came a little bit later and I said Wow and then I got the guitar I would yeah so what so what were your thoughts on guitar and that's a game I at the Sun I enjoyed back then I enjoy and I enjoy that but like learning the law at the time that McKenna those mechanics are new to me but I kind of like I'm I think I was already slightly frustrated on the dice roll because I always think you know this I always like this come nah I don't hate dice I think that dice is usually not on my side if it's really heavily based and I think in Catan it tends to be like that and I was like BIC teachings or negotiation at the time sounds like yeah okay but it was it was fun but it wasn't as I would probably prefer the other two gateways yep yeah it does it does have that flaw if there's one thing that came to bother me about those probably if there's two

things that came to bother me about guitar one was that you could set up your yeah you could set up with a whole lot of nines and tens and then 11 and sorry that's three point three you can set up with a lot of six and fives but then eight two nines and the ones that get rolled know why I suddenly thought it was a three dice game and not you know that that's like your best laid plans can fall apart but that's the nature of a game booth honest I still think the game flows quickly enough that that doesn't yeah I think if there's one thing that the does it's that we play a lot of four-player so it's got to play with you dollar you never interacted on the only four player 50% of games someone would get wedged in the corner and just have a bad time I remember that because we play with four players and one of our friends walked out of the game because basically they basically got blocked I can't really build anything is just completely blocked and that's it like I don't know if that's because of that I don't know because they really have something else to do and left the game at least they didn't flick the table so it's flip proof because it's seen a little I mean that that's yeah that's a peril of the game but the same time once you play it a few times you know how to avoid that situation that's right I will say that I haven't played all the expansions mmm because I know there's a lot of variety on expansions that won't bring surf

righty I haven't actually played a lot of expansion as well that's probably why maybe the expansions make it a little bit more complex for us more gamers I mean look at us you feel like we such a snob we Gomez no not really yeah I played seafarers yeah my experience on seafarers was sad a little bit because the seafarers book has scenarios in it and they give you like specific islands to set up and we played a scenario where I think there was just an island of gold in the middle and it was gold with a number eight on it so it was a really valuable place and the game was just get there and whoever got there first yeah just got everything they needed and that was kind of it was like there was one way to win instead of lots of ways to win and it did sound me a little bit on seafarers but overall I think it was a I think if you took that scenario away and didn't use the gold okay yeah I don't remember much about it sorry I still think it stands up i we haven't played it for a long time we have a lot of games but I would still play it i won I was still enjoy that game knowing that yes there's some dice but I'll play it again yeah yeah yeah yeah there's the ice but at the same time you know what you're getting into it's not that long yeah you can mitigate your dice risk you

can negotiate go and get a port and negotiate with me I've been playing it wrong maybe I should play it again and then try to encourage you yeah okay yes yeah okay next one is Carcassonne yes

phone I had that a lot of expansions I have a while yeah and it's the first time I was playing this it wasn't my early days as well wasn't one of the first one but still in the early days I was like it was a nice fight what is this you put the tile what there's some randomness and I did find it enjoyable but I did not actually win a lot and then couldn't figure out things so quick and later on on the Hobby then I figure out that I'm not good at spatial rotation thing so whenever I do special because Pakistan said relying a lot on that as well yeah you have to confront imagine the the towels on the main common area and aggravates but I do enjoy it but that's the thing like so first we talk about dice in Japan and then now the rotation theme yeah so that's my kind of look at my weaknesses I guess mm-hmm you um for me I don't I don't actually remember when I first played Carcassonne it wasn't one of my early gateways right we may even have been together when I first like and I don't have a strong memory of first flying Carcassonne we want a board game weekend or something however we I'll come to that story yeah I would have played basic yeah

once or twice maybe I'd have made up I don't know but it was it was definitely never a game that grabbed mm-hmm certainly in the physical form yeah you took a tile there weren't that many things to do with it it was never one that grabbed me oh god such that's like it's a game that brought us the meatball but I do like actually I do like the meatball bit and I do like the the fact that you can difference really for a different strategy on there you know what you will not focus on that sort of thing I think that's like a maybe first and I think it's more different strategy than Catan yeah yeah yeah have a lot of memory yeah we played we played it on iPad a couple of times when we were on holidays oh yes yeah yeah and I remember the game made more sense to me at that point and there are a couple of things about it one was that the game would tell you when there was no longer a tile that could go in a space which was a straighting but basically the game would look at all game looked at all the tiles that were left and if it knew there was nothing that fit that space anymore it put an X there that makes it easier for me actually that's why I think I like it a little bit more it helps me with my rotation themself wasn't that this meal and when we're waiting for the joy of queues yeah but I think that also meant you knew that if there was a space there

and it looked really specific but it wasn't X doubt it was like all right if I get that next tile it has to go there and it was I think because that was all like small and on the iPad that was when it clicked to me that's like all right well the point of this game is not to make long roads or make big cities the point is to get in on somebody else's city and score as many points on tiles that you didn't place as possible which actually made it a bit of a mean game at two players so yeah it was okay but it was never a game that grabbed me you know we did once play big box with everything and with like eight players yeah and craziness bad too many tiles too many rules too many people too much downtime between turns its I wouldn't say it's add me on Carcassonne because I never loved it that much but that was a bad way let's play caucus on right now last one last one ticket to ride that is my favorite out of the three and I don't remember when I play this again I think it was a bit later on but I would say that kind of like it might be the first game that introduced me to route building yeah I

know it's a bit blocky as well but I was like wow it's just really good and then and head management yeah Road building hand management I feel like wow really you'd you built it from here from here and then not only what's not another one goal yeah the goal fulfillments with them yeah cards yeah I think that would be my favorite out of it pre so because this may be less truckers push all mark but this not really irritation and it's not really a rolling dice yeah I do like the game I think it still stands up as as a good game and a good gateway my first experience of it was a ticket to write Europe which was the second one mm-hmm and that was with a was a five player game and I think I'd played that one a few times before I played bass US version and the Europe one is a lot more forgiving because you can't really block someone by taking all of the routes area because you can yeah yeah cuz you've got the railway station that you can put to use someone else's track at a loss of points yeah and so that that was kind of more forgiving and I remember that that one had tunnels which are interesting and I had one that was worth eight that was really valuable that everyone who won the game

seem to always have but I think I enjoy having later gone back and played the US version I think I enjoy that one I think the fact the fear of being blocked is it's yeah it's really tight and it's a more powerful mechanic than always being able to just use a station and get past and so you can only do it I think it's a few stations per person or something in each subsequent one costs you more points it doesn't make giving you like you've put so much effort in building these or maybe your goal car and then it's gone I would probably like like the Europe better with non blocky one yeah you like the US better I think the US on is a more interesting game because it has that the decisions are hollow we need to play I like when the decisions are hard I'm not tied yeah and I think we haven't played the other versions yeah we haven't gone past us in Europe I know there's lots of different versions out there I don't know how many of them are just different Maps and this is how many have different mechanics yeah I think since then we've got a few other route building one like one on a recent one is only ambigram which is really good yeah I meant was that was originally 2005 yes and in this Imperial which is also a network building resource collection order fulfillment and this Airlines

which is probably I would say maybe a step up from tickets right it's really nice really elegant I think I would really recommend that if you like tickets right ideally like Airlines and I always do try to recommend Alliance Airlines Europe Oh once you're up story because I think there's another game called Airlines yeah I think she's wrong because it's the same designer Alan Ameen and Airlines whether it was Airlines Europe or an original version of Airlines was his first game it came out in 1990 Wow long way back and I had a little stock holding Macau not quite stock holding but it had the it had a similar mechanic but the same sort of map work and it's not to forget mini Express and mini rails mini rails has been out for a while one of my favorite games and also mini Express at the time of filming was on insan Kickstarter yep so I guess the eighteen XXY I've never been playing a lot of 18 X X Games so I did step up there and Irish stage as well that's a lot of train kind of like playing games here but those are the one that's that I can think of at the moment yeah I think I think tickets are ah I think I don't out of this four out of those big three maybe it's my own personal experience with Carcassonne but I think Ticket to

Ride and guitar and have a long future in holiday houses and you know the collections of all complexities because I think they do stand up as games alright I think that I wanna add I know wish we have three gateway games I only had at the fourth one or the half one is Wendell Splenda is kind of like still get away but wasn't our gateway yes maybe one of them it is one of my early games as well explained all that thought me it introduced me to the engine building mechanic mechanics which I really liked and Splendora and as some people say there's a lack base or Fault in the game but I enjoy because it's yeah it's building big no-no yeah that was one of my gateways as well I had the same reaction to Splenda as I did to guitar when I first played it you know it's so it's quick and it's thinkI and but it's got various paths of strategy it does have its issue as its top deck issue but it's a quick after so many games so many games have a top deck elements in there

that what does it make Elmen where if the right card comes off the top of the deck and I can just get it straight away yeah and go from the end I mean you say that's inertia pits so many games yeah and particularly on the lighter side to have that it's not really an issue about this it's not a huge issue because you should still be buying the you might get a couple of cards that way but you should still be buying low cards to fit a strategy to gain oh come on so anything else you wanna shout out mention um I guess if there's one if there's one game that should and maybe it's cuz it's too similar to Ticket to Ride but if there's one game that really should be among those and just never stayed caught on I think it's thrown in taxes oh yeah that was 2006 at one let's build this Yaris it's got the it is kind of tickets arrived in the way you pick up the cards and to get your roots but then you're building your roots out and scoring points in a different way I think yeah maybe because it relied so heavily on the tickets arrived mechanic it didn't take that same prevalence but it's yeah it's a really nice step up it's hard to get these days as well yeah it's a really nice step up from ticket to ride as well that's true so do any of those games are part of your get away games threat in the comment sections

below or any other games that you know it's that you discover versus you're you know that the game that got you into what gave me basically and if you are you know if you have graduated from those games to playing on Mars every other week James in the four to four point five difficulty yeah how do how do those old how do those old classics still stack up and you still pull out at the car guitar and play a good game look good point good questions so if you wouldn't mind hit the like button they'll help us and if you haven't already done so please subscribe to us you can also hit the nipple in the corner and hit the bell so you won't miss anything from us when we publish new exciting videos I also am on social media Twitter Instagram so hopefully all will see you there treat until next time

Progress saved