Top 10 Disappointing Board Games - Chairman of the Board
Transcript
hi everyone today i'm talking about my top 10 most disappointing board games now before i get started i do want to make it clear that this is all my personal opinion and to be honest a lot of the time i don't actually dislike these games they just weren't as good as i thought they were going to be and again a lot of the times that's on me because my expectation is something different than what the publisher or the designer intended but nonetheless i'll explain i'll talk through my reasons why they didn't quite live up to my own expectations as i go through them so let's get started at number 10. so at number 10 i have a game by one of my favorite designers ever this a stefan feld game and this is the castles of tuscany now the castle of tuscany as you can probably tell by the name is a kind of a sister game of the castles of burgundy which is a game that i absolutely adore this one is however a slightly string back and a bit simpler version that's more card driven as your drafting cards based on top decking basically and then um cashing them in to take actions building a bit of an engine placing tiles on the board and getting bonuses etc um but for me when i first saw the castle of tuscany being advertised there wasn't really much information about it before it actually hit the market my expectations were that this was going to be a similar game to burgundy but with perhaps different building abilities and things like that and when in in actuality it was um something quite a bit different with some you know loose comparisons and for me the reason why this didn't quite live up to my expectation was because it was quite light it was a lot more luck based than
the castle's burgundy and ultimately i thought that the the rules overhead of castles and castles of tuscany wasn't that much different in comparison to burgundy whereas the richness and depth of gameplay in burgundy was drastically bigger than tuscany in my opinion so for me it was much more worth just giving that extra bit of effort to learn burgundy and get a lot more satisfying game out of it than just being content with tuscany and for that reason um you know it never would have hit the table for me and it didn't really have its own niche and spot in my collection because it was just a bit too light and the gameplay just wasn't quite up to scratch and not what i was looking for so again a solid game i enjoyed my play of it but um not one that was um strong enough to stay in my collection and certainly not one of feld's best games for me next up i have uh between two castles of mad king ludwig now i'm a big fan of the castles of mad king ludwig where you are you know building your own your castle trying to please the king by fulfilling different criteria that he wants this one however was a game where you're placing towels from a different perspective really trying to get bonuses in different ways and um using drafting tiles and picking one and negotiating with your neighbors about where you're going to place them because you don't actually have your own cast on this one you actually share castles with each of your neighbors and then you kind of work out who's got the best overall building you know building ability at the end of the game um but for me uh i found that a lot of
the scoring in this game was quite um convoluted it was a bit fiddly i didn't quite like the look of the game it was very small you know very small tiles with very small iconography that was hard to decipher and look at um again the gameplay was fine it was just a bit lackluster and it didn't leave me wanting to go back to it um which was a shame because you know i was expecting a game that was as strong as the original i love the idea of having to work your neighbours because this was actually uh i suppose a a hybrid a comparison or a mix of not only the castles of mike and ludwig but also um between two cities and that was a game that also really appealed to me but i think ultimately it didn't come together as well as i would have wanted it to and it didn't kind of hold its own place in my collection for that reason um but again it was fine just a bit a bit average and it didn't really um it didn't really do it for me next up at number eight i have a dominant species now this is a game i haven't played in quite some time however i very i remember quite distinctly my feelings at the end of the game so this is a highly regarded area control game you know very euro-esque as you are um basically using one portion of a game to place your workers down to line up your ability to place things onto the map and manipulate the board to fit your own species so you can thrive and try and hinder other people but for me i found the game uh not only long and a bit dull and boring um i
found that the housekeeping in the game was so tedious where the variables by just making one change on the board would just have a whole cascading effect which i think a lot of people would like but for me that was almost impossible to take any autonomy over and to manage your game efficiently and it just didn't it just didn't have that fun fact for me which is a shame because i think when a game you know is is so highly spoken of this was considered one of the great euro uh interactive games um you know an area control star game we have the map and things like that um game doesn't look great which doesn't overly bother me but um yeah that ultimately i found it too fiddly i find it a bit too convoluted well i did have some things i did like you know in terms of the way that the work placement spots were resolved and the the core gameplay i just didn't find fun which is a shame but um you know i think everyone else i played it with enjoyed it but again it didn't do it for me personally and it just isn't a game that i'll be looking to play again next up at number seven i have another immensely popular game this one is five tribes now five tribes is a game i do not dislike i wanna make that clear i think it's a solid design um this is a mancala style game which i really enjoy as you have this bunch of tiles down on the board and you have meeples on these boards and you're picking up a stack of nipples dropping them off one at a time and wherever you land you um you have a potential to claim that tile for victory points you have abilities depending on the color of the meeples you picked up
and you can buy gods an investment investment to get certain powers and things like that lots going on that i really like the thing i didn't like about this game was the fact that again another another element of being too many variables and being a bit too tactical for me so you look at the board state and it is not your turn and somebody will take an action and they'll obviously take the strongest action which i think is normally quite apparent but from then on you know you have to completely look at it from a new set of eyes from round to round and i don't really find that very satisfying when you go start start and stop and that much of a strong tactical gameplay doesn't quite do it for me and that's that's pretty much what the feeling that you know i left with this game it was too too many variables at all times and just impossible to map out turns because of you know the mercy you're at of the other players which is fine more of a personal opinion um again it has a lot of things i really do like about this game i particularly loved the um the turn order process where you could bid on going forward going before your other opponents do so that's that's a really good way of kind of balancing out that mercy of the other players because you'd actually have to spend money to go first but money is going to be your victory points at the end so that was really nice but ultimately for me i said i just liked some a bit of something a bit more opaque maybe um just slightly more and it was just way too i said way to tactile and too many variables to keep me interested and that's why five tribes is at number seven uh at number
six i have azul now azul again immensely popular by a great designer who i tend to love their games you know michael kiesling this one is a more abstract style um tile game if you are picking up tiles uh placing on your playable trying to get like you know line up different combos and things like that it has this element of when you draft things go into the middle and then at the end everyone's drafting from the middle and you can potentially shaft your opponents with a bunch of tiles that they don't want and can't place which is going to score them negative points um i can see why people like this game but for me i think maybe this was a matter of being over hyped i didn't play this as quickly as a lot of other people did um you know the game was already really hyped by the time i played it and i think because of that and because of you know all the massive praise i got i was left underwhelmed and a bit deflated because of it because it you know it's a pretty family-friendly simple game which is not necessarily a bad thing you know sometimes you can have these games that are just mechanically sound but still be accessible but for me it just felt a bit flat it didn't have any real peaks on any moments of excitement i've always found the decisions quite apparent and obvious to take at least to be optimal um but again a pleasant game but one that i was expecting more from um and a lot of that isn't the game's fault it's because of the um you know the massive praise that it got from a lot of reviewers and players and things like that so again number six azul and number five i have a gizia shifting sands now igesia is a game by
some of my favorite designers actually and the kind of italian conglomerate of board game designers to make euro games and egysia is a re-implementation of um of a game of its namesake um but it wasn't uh it was so it was it was very much out of print for a long time and i think because of that there is somewhat of a rose tinted glasses looked upon it where um you know people think this game is hard to get hold of therefore it's going to be it's great you know it's brilliant it's one of the original euro games um one that really implemented that time track mechanism where you can go as far as you want down the river and collect things but you can never go back on yourself mechanisms i love it has a bit of area control a bit of set collection and game bonuses a lot of things i really liked and when i got to the table i enjoyed it it was perfectly pleasant but i must admit i thought what was all the hype about this is very much a game that a thousand other games do very similar things you know basic area control um and things like that so it was a game for me that didn't really have its own identity it didn't really raise its head above the parapet in terms of being different than anything else just a bit a bit bland a bit uh a bit beige for me um and i don't mean that literally i mean in terms of its um its identity and while it's solid it did nothing wrong it just didn't excite me um which is a shame because i was expecting so much of it because of the um you know because of that grail game aspect it had to it and ultimately i think it was just a victim of time and became a bit outdated
and the gameplay wasn't as strong as more modern designs in my opinion at number four i have uh reavers of midgard now reason of midgard the reavers of midgard is on this list probably not through its own fault um probably because of the uh the speculation of the gaming community um you know champions midgard was an immensely popular game one that i wasn't for me but i could see why people like it it's a hybrid of american mechanisms and euro mechanisms but while i could see that game was solid but again not for me um the reeves of midgard was kind of being touted as the the euro version of the game you know the the more deterministic game the one where you can map out your turns more um you know with more clarity and accuracy and when i when i got this game to the table again a lot of things i liked about it it had this great car system where you can use cars for different things um you know work a placement where with diminishing returns if you were to share a spot with someone else but for me all the euro trappings of the game were very much just a casing it was just uh it was shallow and the the gameplay itself was wasn't as deep and rich of a euro experience as you might first expect there's a lot of going to spaces just collecting cards for in-game bonuses lots of top decking and basically pretty again pretty shallow scoring mechanisms without without any deep connected mechanisms and while i said
well i like the casing of it a lot more than champion midgard in terms of you know the actual mechanisms of much more euro but the way you gain points weren't very satisfying and um i thought i was expecting a lot more of a rich experience and um something that would be more satisfying to your your more kind of euro minded player and um ultimately it was a bit too much like champions for me but with a different user interface um but again i don't think the actual publishers themselves um really spouted about how euro this was going to be it was pretty much just the speculation and um for that reason it fell a bit flat for me personally but next up i have yamatai at number three so this is um another bruno cathala game who designed um five tribes and i think for me personally i think uh maybe this was the game that broke the straw or the straw that broke the camel's back in terms of cathartic games not being for me um while i really liked abyss when that came out and these games have some similarities and i thought you know these games i like abyss these games are even highly higher regarded than abyssas so i'm bound to like these ones and a bit like um five tribes this one for me had way too many variables i thought the gameplay wasn't very fun um a game where you are drafting these towels and placing boats on the board trying to surround islands and collecting these tokens to get um to get bonuses and powers trying to control the regions and things a lot of things that i really like but for me it didn't have any
that fun fact wasn't there i didn't really have anything to hook me or to keep me interested in playing the game it just it just didn't do it for me in terms of the fun factor and that's a shame really because the game looks absolutely stunning it's a you know gorgeous looking game i love the theme i love a lot of things that i thought it was going to do but for me the gameplay fell flat it was stagnant again way too many variables that i couldn't be bothered to wrap my brain around because the rest of it wasn't that interesting um probably an unpopular opinion because i know this is a popular game um but i'm just being honest it wasn't for me so um again because of the because of the praise and because of the the high regard it was in i was expecting a lot more from yamatai than what it delivered now at number two i have court of the dead mourners call now caught the dead this one is based on a kind of comic book um intellectual property as and it's very much in the vein of one of those eric lang dudes on the map style games we have a huge map of different regions you're placing um things onto the board to activate these regions and a real game of great table presence and it looks fantastic this game has some drafting where you're drafting these different characters to give you powers and to do different things you're trying to control these regions in order to again get abilities and bonuses at the end of the round um you're using currency to place things on the board you're trying not to be greedy because i had this um this this death script or dreadscript
i think it was called something like that where if you were if there are too many people in one spot then you'd have to roll dice uh and potentially lose the people on those spots um but you could go to certain spots which could kind of protect you from that uh it had a lot of things going on i think maybe it was a bit too um ambitious in what it was trying to create because i thought a lot of the mechanisms and the things that made it or tried to make it individual didn't really work in practice you know for example there was this tide you had to play at the beginning of every round but if you didn't get this particularly i didn't re meet a particular threshold then everybody would suffer a penalty and you had to divide up the different resources at the beginning of the round which there was no really real decision there as well um and for me the thing that really disappointed me about this one was because that with these with the different regions there was no lucrativeness or no incentive to go to a particular reason over another or at least not much of one so if somebody had gone for somewhere else gone for somewhere that you wanted you had a more than viable option of going somewhere else and getting not to you know not too much of a different reward for doing so and for me there wasn't that that competitiveness there of kind of rubbing shoulders with other people to try and get to the certain spots it was a bit too loosey-goosey and the card drafting was very much in the same vein where all the cards were just fine you know there was nothing that you really had to have and nothing you couldn't afford your opponents to have so there was no no no real incentive to hate draft there was no um tough decisions about which of
these am i going to have because you think you know i'll pick one it'll be fine and um that for me was why the game fell flat i was expecting more i wanted a more game of more intrigue some more meteor decisions and um for me it was just held in comparison to games of the same ilk ready such as eric lang games blood rages your rising suns this one just wasn't up to par with those and um it's sad to see because it would be nice to see a really solid court of the dead game um and finally at number one i have alma mater or alma mater this one is um one of my well by some of my favorite designers and was pretty much regarded as the second game in the series by i believe it was uh edgar spiel who published these games um it's a sequel to coimbra basically coinbase being one of my favorite games a current top 10 game for me a game that looks beautiful gorgeous artwork great components as you are kind of the headmaster of this university trying to um get the best students and make your knowledge more valuable than others um i was expecting a lot more than what this game delivered probably one of my most anticipated games of last year extremely hyped for it because i loved it again i love the previous games i love the designers i love the theme i love the artwork but the gameplay itself was so mediocre it was um another work replacement game um but that that was fine i mean i'm not the biggest fan of working in itself unless it does something tremendously different um but for me the thing i took away from
this game was how much of a slog it was to get resources it was very you know you'd have to jump through a lot of hoops to do basic actions to get basic um character abilities that didn't really do much there was a bit like court of the dead none of the powers you know you didn't really have to have you know you didn't feel like that was a really strong one it was juicy something that you know you could take ownership of and your opponents couldn't have there was none of that really everything was just fine again a very slow churning game that didn't really have that ramping up effect no excitement and ultimately no fun i just it was such a disappointment for me and probably one of the only games from these designers that have ever let me down and um it's sad because uh you know when you really do anticipate games as much as i did for this one and and it lets you down so much when the next one comes out you're thinking oh i hope this one doesn't let me down like the last one and once that kind of taint is in the you know in the waters you it's hard to forget that um again not a terrible game but one that i was expecting so much more from you know i was expecting this one to be you know an eight or nine out of ten and for me you know it was a six at best um and i i've not really heard a lot of people complain too much about this game but it's not really taken off either um but for me it was probably a lot of self implemented and self built up expectations um that the game had a hard time living up to so that concludes my list of my top 10 most disappointing board games i hope you enjoyed this list i'm sorry to be
negative i know i don't tend to be like overly negative about games but um sometimes it's good to get a bounce view so everything's not overly you know always rainbows and sunshine but if you have enjoyed the video please hit like and subscribe to my channel and check out my other videos too additionally you can support me on patreon um by visiting the link below and just unpledging a couple of pounds a month to keep the channel going for everyone else i'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye