Skip to main content
Loading video...

Top Ten Board Games of 2019

Transcript 25:36

welcome to allies enemies i'm jess and i am sean and this is our top 10 games of 2019. we did our top 10 games of 2021 and then we looked back at the top 10 games of 2020 and we thought we would just keep it up and look at our top games of 2019. yeah why stop there we're just gonna keep on going back like board game time travelers there's a lot of games that we really like from this year yeah and it was really tough to do this list because like our other ones we both rank them separately and then we are presenting our combined top 10 but i think this is the one so far we've had the most differences in we each had a couple that weren't even close we had like 19 places between some of these games and those are games we still both like yeah exactly so on that note we'll start with our honorable mention so these are ones that one liked a lot more than the other and didn't quite make the cut do you want to start so mine and this one was in my top ten but didn't make jessa's and this is paladins of the west kingdom and this is i go back and forth in the west kingdom series which one is my favorite and right now this one is probably my favorite it's uh it's it's the heaviest it's the thinkiest i'm really excited to get the expansion which i know has been up for a bit but we're a bit behind and we're looking forward to getting it soon but it's just it's just a great game and it is that like kind of solitaire but i like that i like just sitting and thinking and doing

my own little puzzle and this does it really well and my honorable mention is a very popular game i really really like this game this is one of my favorites actually and it is wingspan i have a zoology background i love animals so i really like the bird theme i love the production quality with the player mats it all looks really good i love the mechanics of it i really like games that have shared competing goals as well as secret goals so i really enjoy everything about this game um and it was really high for me uh and it is my honorable mention and don't get mad at me i like it i'm just not big on birds so it's just lower for me but i like it a lot no one yell at me uh all right and so let's let's get into our actual the nitty-gritty of our real top 10 and so starting out with we actually have a tie for a number 10 which we were happy about we both got an extra game in the list so the first number 10 is imperial settlers empires of the north and this is a this is a game that we like i think more all the time like when we got it it was even when we did our top 100 i think both of us said this would be higher if we did it again and it's it's just gone up and up and every time we get an expansion we like having more to choose from and we just find more depth in this game

it's just a terrific kind of a some very asymmetric engine builder slash card tableau there's a log kind of worker placement yeah and the cuteness of it i think threw me at first because there is a lot of depth to this that you wouldn't expect from the the kind of silly little art style that i love i love the art style to it but the the simple decisions of even just those five spots that you can put your your thing out to do your actions all of that makes a really big difference in it and the more expansions we get the more we like this game to see how differently each of the packs play yeah there's just there's just really hidden depth here yeah great game so empires of the north our other number 10 because it was a tie for 10 is cartographers we love rolling rights and this is one of my favorite ones because you flip your cards and then you choose what type of lands you want to draw in your kingdom and you each have your own sheets and you're just trying to accomplish various various goals across the seasons um but it's great we got pencil crayons and we do fun little trees and houses and so it ends up looking really great at the end and this is this is always going to be one of my favorite rolling rice i think almost every game that we play takes less time to play the more we play this is the only one that takes more time and it's only because we get more and more into the drawing all the time with the pencil crayons i've got very elaborate towns now and i really it's really fun it's

like being a kid and just coloring in your coloring book plus it's it really is an excellent game and just a good like polyamino slash roll and write um two of my favorite things mush together and it's yeah it's super fun but it's true we started with just simple colors and we have gone far beyond that now uh so that was our second number 10. our number nine is maracaibo and this is an alexander fister game and if you are familiar with alexander fister you are familiar with most of the things in this game he likes to use a lot of the same mechanisms and so he's got multi-use cards in this there's a rondelle system and there's a lot of really creative stuff in this as well he's got there's this this kind of at first you think it's going to be like a war system but it's not really you're like just kind of supporting all the different armies but like separately it's it's an interesting mechanism and then there's also like an adventure board at the bottom and i think when you first look at it it's like hard to figure out how would all of these things work together but they work together so well and it's so smooth for how much is kind of like smooshed in there it really does all the icons are really clear so all that helps you be able to pick it up and go with it really quickly and then it also introduces um a campaign mode and the story is the worst it is it's not good but the

neat thing about it is it took us a number of games to play through and every single game the board just looked a little bit different which was neat because it changes your your choices of where to stop and what you're going to do a little bit yeah the story is every second card is a previously on so it's like it's like eight sentences and then like previously in those eight sentences um it's ridiculous you'll quickly find yourself ignoring the story i think but it does add the interesting things and the rondelle is really cool because it really allows you to push each other through because i i want to visit every single island um and jess wants to race her way to the end as fast as possible i just want to stop you from getting all of the points if you visit everywhere you're gonna get so many points so sometimes i see that and i think well i won't let you two at all i'm gonna i'm gonna race to the end and make you come along but uh yeah great we we love alexander fister this is one of our favorite fister games um and that is our number nine maracaibo our number eight is parks parks is a gorgeous game it's based off the artwork of the 59 park series and so all of the cards are beautiful renditions of of the national parks across the united states and a lot of these kind of remind me of home where we're from canada and the rocky mountains and all of that has that kind of look to it and so the look of this is great and the components look great and

you are hikers and you have to go down a a one-way street or a ratchet system i recently learned just how some people describe that that you can't turn back you can only move forward and then you take the action on those spaces and you collect your resources and trade them in for these park cards yeah it's it's a it's a simple game it's a great kind of gateway game really like game i actually like this one more than just us this was higher on my list it's just relaxing and and it is a little mean because it's again like our last game you are pushing the other people because once one person gets to the end the other person has to go to the end and you can definitely block spaces because somebody can't uh be on the same space as you unless they use their campfire and so you can just put someone there right away and keep them there basically the whole time and and not take them till the end and we have a lot of battling over the camera and the ability to take pictures so we are constantly trading it in which is a fun little mechanic too and this was our number eight our number seven is the isle of cats or the only way we ever say it i love cats um and isle of cats is uh it's a polyamino game that is a little bit heavier than most of them so you're putting down your shapes and you've got cats you're putting them on a boat it's got this ridiculous story where this guy vash is coming to this island to kill all the cats because he's horrible and

so you've got to get all the cats off the island but of course cats being cats um do not want to cooperate so you just have to get like the catch you can by putting them in baskets and forcing them onto your ship where they immediately like sprawl out um and so you've got to fit them in shapes and you've got to fit them in kind of color groups and then it's got this really cool scoring mechanic where you've got these cards called lessons i don't know why and i don't know why they're called lessons i mean in their public or private lessons and the lessons are little goal cards that you have to um for like you need this many of this color cats you need cats in this part of the ship or whatever it might be and so you've got these this scoring mechanism that's you're adding new scoring cards every single round so you're constantly kind of changing that it's kind of evolving which is a really interesting addition to the mechanic because that also those cards are also part of your decision for how many cards to keep for how many baskets you might need and you've got also the the fish that attract the cats and so the more cards you keep the less fish you have for your cats and so you really have to decide if it's worth that that card for the points or worth getting the the baskets to catch more and you can never fill your ship so you really do have to make some some tough decisions and only a few cats are out at a time uh and turn you can see which ones you might need and what colors might be beneficial for your boat yeah i didn't explain it's also a card drafting and a

cat drafting game um but this is maybe one of the heavier child placements not the heaviest but one of the heavier top placement games that we have and a terrific one and look how nice this looks it's a beautiful box yeah uh so that is our number seven our number six is res arcana and in res arcana it's by uh tom lehmann you start off with having one asymmetric power small little differences but it does make a difference for how you play and then you have eight cards and that's it you use those eight cards to collect your resources and you trade in those resources for different locations that are available each time and and different monuments and just try to maximize your turn using only those eight cards and we like this the first time we've played it but every single time we play it it goes higher and higher on our list yeah and it's helped too that we've picked up both expansions since um and i think both expansions add a little bit to it but it's it's beauty is its simplicity that like you said like you just you've got those eight cards plus your mage character with its power on it and that's it and then it's just how do i put that together and often times the thing that puts you over to that 10 points is just taking the first player token because if you pass first you get the first player token which gives you a point and getting to nine and then just making that decision of

if i pass now i can't do anything else can they squeeze by me and get to 11 on this turn because we've had games like that where somebody's like i've got ten they're only at eight i've got this and then the other person with the rest of their turn has managed to surpass that and get to 11. and the turns are really quick because each turn you can only do one thing that's it and then it's the next player's turn and so again you're competing for these locations sometimes you can see someone getting the same kind of resources as you are so trying to to jump in there first can be a whole another strategy as well yeah great game yep our number six res arcana our number five is draftosaurus or draftdosaurus if you want to say it correctly and drafted stars this one's higher on my list than jess's um because i love it this is the lightest game on this list and i don't care i i am such a fan of this game it's so simple it's exactly what it says you're drafting dinosaurs so you got a bag of dinosaurs every turn you take a dinosaur you put it on your player board and you've got different parts of your board that score different kinds of points for different dinosaurs so you're just taking a dinosaur you're putting it somewhere on your board and there's a dice that one player rolls each turn that gives you a little bit of parameters of where you're allowed to put it um but other than that it's really just taking a dinosaur putting it on the board it feels like a rolling right but like a rolling right

with the addition of having those actual dinosaurs that are you know fun to reach in and grab and put down and look great yeah the meeple dinosaurs are great and this is another one that also works really well at two because the i think most people tend to play it out more and it works great at more but at two there's such a kind of fun element of keeping an eye on your opponent and seeing what they need and purposely just throwing what they need in the box because that two player you put one in the one in your park and one like away for the rest of the game and so there is certainly that kind of you're not gonna get this one yeah i don't know another drafting game um oh i guess we just said about cats but i don't know another just strict like that's all it is is drafting game that works this well at just two players uh because that throwing away mechanic is so good if it feels so mean sometimes when it's like i need a t-rex and and i see her just like happily like look at me smiling and chuck it um it's it's really fun and yeah the dinosaurs are great and you can play this one with anyone this is a game you can teach to like your non-gamer friends in like three minutes um and have up and rolling and they'll love it so that was our number five our number four is this one here blank legacy acquisitions incorporated and so we spent forever trying to find a

really great legacy game after we finished gloomhaven because we loved that experience and we were just on the lookout for a campaign or a legacy that the two of us could play and we heard mixed things about how well this would work with two players but we decided to give it a go and we loved it it was super fun it was a great legacy in terms of the what you got to find out and the story and the narrative was was actually great it was well written it was a little bit funny uh it had like some jokes about middle management that was directing your movements as you're trying to go around and steal some things and one thing i loved about it is because there's certain goals that as a team you're trying to accomplish it was a little bit semi co-op of i won't run out of the dungeon and leave you high and dry if you're gonna go complete this quest but then as soon as you complete that quest then it's each person for themselves yeah it's co-op until it isn't which which was fun it was like it was like a negotiation kind of co-op of like come on we really need this and i'll give you one more turn before i sprint back or like that sort of thing um and you're right like the writing i'm i'm very critical of writing in board games and this it's short and snappy and often legitimately funny which is so rare in a board game and acquisitions incorporated we didn't know anything about it um i guess it's a it's like a dnd podcast slash youtube thing um wwe wrestler xavier woods is a part of it i guess we do like the new

day um so we like but we weren't drawn in by that part but it ended up even though we knew nothing about it i feel like adding to the experience even like just the world of it going in cold yeah was still interesting and fun and funny and this is the only legacy game that we have played where we legitimately play it after the game like people always say that like oh you still got a game but it doesn't um this one still this is probably my favorite clank game yeah it does play perfectly at the end and the nice thing too is that there's little bits that remind you of when you play through it as a legacy as well which is quite nice and so this is our number four number three is horrified and we love horrified this was like the second video we made on this channel um this is actually one of the games that we were like we need to tell more people about this game we love this game um and we just we got so into this because when we first got it i already i was a big fan of the universal studios monsters movies like the old ones um and jess hadn't seen a lot of them so it gave me a chance to rewatch them and i gave jess a chance to watch them um that was super fun yeah we went through watch watch all the old movies which was great and then played through the game as well and i love co-ops and this is really light this is definitely something that you could play with with new gamers for sure but it just works great and there are six different monsters

and so you pull out uh different amounts depending on how how hard you want it to be and so we usually do about three monsters which can sometimes still be a challenge to do and all the monsters you have to get rid of them in different ways so it always feels feels new and for an extra challenge you can bring out a fourth monster it's hard at four monsters like this is like we say it's a beginner game and at two monsters it really is it's a pretty simple game you're probably gonna win it but if four monsters it's tough and depending on who those monsters are it's really tough and it's just the little bits that they've got like they've got um abbott and costello in in the game they've got all of the all of the villagers or villagers from the different um movies and then it's it's a it's a solid like well-made simple game yeah yeah i i just love it and i think we're a really good team uh when we play so that's that's another reason why i really like it um and we're excited to try the american monsters we haven't tried that one yet it's not out here in the uk and america we're interested in your monsters please send us your monsters we want to know about them we will buy the game but that is our number three horrified all right our number two is tapestry so tapestry is by jamie uh stegmeier so it's by stone meyer games it has a beautiful production it's a civilization game that's very very asymmetric so each of you start has a

starting civilization and they all have various bonuses um and you go through the different tracks and you manage your resources trade them in to put buildings out on your on your little player boards and all kinds of different actions that you can do this is one that i would i would describe as a lot of multiplayer solitaire it's very heads down trying to work out the best combinations that you can do there is interaction in terms of who can get to certain buildings first and get the opportunity to put those out for sure but one of the things we love about this is we love the asymmetry so we have this like huge sheet that we use the most like excel spreadsheet of tapestry civilization which ones we were and who we were playing against and what our scores were because we do find it's a little bit unbalanced sometimes but that doesn't really bother us because if if sean beats me by like 100 points then later on down the line we'll switch civilizations but i'll see if i can if i'll beat him by 100 points when we're the opposite ones as well and so we looked at the number of games we've played of this and of our like decently weighted games this is one of the ones we've played the most and that's just because we want we each want to try all of the civilizations once and then again and we still haven't like even when we played it twice through that's tons of games and it's it's it's really pretty i know some people don't love the buildings but i love the buildings i think i think they look great i think they look great on the board and i think

this one probably plays best at two again just because you can have some long turns so and someone can actually finish the game before another player so with more players you might be kind of left out not playing for longer yeah so it does work really well at two and i think this game would go way up in my top 100 thanks to the arts and architecture expansion because i really like the maps that got included in that as well as the the fifth track there was a lot of great elements that um got us playing this even more and it just made us excited to keep keep playing it and trying everything new about it and so that was our number two our number one and this one wasn't on either of our top 100 lists because we bought it just before christmas and already have played it something like 40 times and uh well i'll bring it out on number one is marvel champions and marvel champions a few folks that actually text me in the comments uh or message me in the comments um over the time i've been doing this channel of like why didn't you do marvel champions how about marvel champions and i've always answered i don't want to do it because i'm scared that as soon as i buy the bass i will buy every single expansion and i was right we got this within a month we had everything and i just keep on buying everything but to our credit we have played with i think pretty much all of it we've played with all of the characters we've played through the red skull campaign um we're just going to

start the guardians campaign and we just can't get enough of this game and i love it because it's cooperative so we get to be on a team together trying to fight the bad guys and it's pretty hefty too like it's not a lightweight game it takes us about an hour each time we play and there's a lot you have to think about in terms of how quickly you go through your cards and everything that gets thrown at you and all of the characters that you get to be play so differently and in particular play differently against each of the different bad guys as well so there's just so many combinations and that asymmetry keeps bringing us back again and it's it's really interesting to try and see what heroes play well together because some of them really work well together and and some of them do not which we learn pretty quickly yeah and it works terrific at two players i think it um it probably shines at two players and you are invested in the other person's turn as one you can give them cards and you can help them out but even if you're not actively like giving them cards you you're invested because you have such a shared goal and you know the turns can go a little long but it's it's usually fairly quick um and the characters they just play so different and i love the universe i love comic books i wish they would do an x-men one um that would be that would be like my dream if i had an x-men champions game i'm sure it's coming i'm really excited for the spider-man stuff that's coming

out they got miles morales you know who i'm a huge fan of in in the next set and sinister six so it's just the gift that keeps giving or the gift that keeps spending all of our money but this is uh it's it's a heck of a game and it's it's worth it and the new characters are really really fun to try because they do an amazing job for just like the deck of cards and the kind then the one character that flip sides of of being very different yeah yeah ev every time it's super different experience um so that is our number one and that is it thank you so much for watching this it was really fun actually to revisit and i think as soon as our brains realize like hey we can just do other years we don't need to be in the year it really opened it up and so i would not be surprised to see a few more of these yep exactly and we weren't able to put all of the games of 2019 that we love um so if there are any particular ones that you love from 2019 do post those in the comments we would love to see what you play please like subscribe and hopefully we'll see you for the next one

Progress saved