Ranking Every Druid City Games Board Game (That I've Played)
Transcript
Hey, I'm Alex Radcliffe from Board Game Co, and today I'm going to be continuing a video series that I haven't done in quite some time, and that is my publisher ranking video series. Publisher ranking videos are where I take a look at the entire catalog that a publisher has, and then I took a look at the subcategory of that catalog, the ones that I've played within that, and then I rank those games from worst to best, going through them, telling you what I think overall, very quick notes. I'm not really going full reviews and all that. I'm just giving you the hierarchy of how I feel about a publisher's collection, publisher's catalog, catalog of games. And today we're going to be focusing on Druid City Games. Druid City Games has been around for quite some time. I have played most, not all of the games. I haven't played Guardians Call, I haven't played Barnyard Roundup. There's a few other games that I haven't tabled yet. I actually have not played the biggest one that I haven't tabled yet, and I never played the original Tidal Blades. I played Tidal Blades 2, I played Tidal Blades Banner Festival. I never played the original Tidal Blades game, like the the the kind of, I don't know, a dice placement one. I never played that one, so that's not going to be in this video, but I am going to be going through all the all all the games that I have played from there is, including unpublished or not yet available games, I guess, cuz I I also have played uh Bloodstone, as well as Wonderland's Wonderland's War Duel. So, I've played some of their unreleased games that will be in this video. Before we dive into them, though, a little note chart that our channel sponsor is All Play. If you go to allplay.com, you can find a variety of games, including you can find all of All Play's games, and I've actually filtered it to All Play, because you know what I realized about 5 minutes ago while I was thinking about how I'm going to do my little uh publisher segment, my uh sponsored All Play segment, whatever, uh is that I've never done a video for
this on All Play themselves. I've never done an All Play rankings, and I think the problem is I have played so many of All Play's games. I have I played I played a lot. I played like 95% of what they put out, but I haven't played everything, and there's a part of me that wants to play everything, and there's another part of me that realizes that if I wait till I play everything, more games will have come out since then, and I will not be able to do it. So, the next video I'm going to do in this series probably will be All Play, and it will probably be the longest one yet, because I think from any publisher out there, I have made I have played more all play games than any other publisher. The nature of them putting out small, easy to learn, easy to play games has as as killed it in that category. But with that, going back to going back to Juice City Games over here, uh starting off the ranking with our number 10 of it number 10 how many I played? 1 2 3 4 5 showing it 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10. I played 10 of their games. Coming in at number 10, it's not a top 10 list that happens to be 10. Coming in number 10, we have Title Blades Banner Festival.
Title Blades Banner Title Blade Title Blades Banner Festival is a trick-taking game that was the least interesting game for me personally that I've played from Juice City's catalog. This has you basically playing a trick where you want to come in high, low, or medium, which is a system that they put to better use in Off With Their Heads, but in the original Title Blades Banner Festival, there's nothing wrong with the game, but I did feel it was somewhat forgettable. I don't remember my my ranking of it my my actual numeric rating was at the time, but gut instinct is this would be a three out of five, maybe a 3.5. Their games aren't bad, even their worst games are still fine, but I'd probably give this a three out of five. This is like, you know, it was a fine game that wasn't super compelling. I never got super invested in trying to win, lose, or come in medium, which Off With Their Heads took that system and they much more compelling. We'll talk about that later.
Coming in number nine, we have The Grim Masquerade, a game that my daughter still has. I mean, technically I still have it, my daughter still has it cuz it's part of like the kids collection, but The Grim Masquerade is a kind of you know, hidden hidden hidden role game so to speak, not really hidden role like, you know, One Night Ultimate Werewolf or Resistance, more hidden role in the sense that you have a certain character that you are, and we are trying to go ahead we're going we're going to the dance, we're trying to figure out unmasking various characters along the way, uh getting points for a variety of things, being the last person standing, being part of the unmasking, and you have these characters and as you give them various artifacts, you have are you kind of artifacts you're trying to collect or avoid depending on your character. And you're slowly piecing together who each person is before you accuse and you are that character. It's light, it's simple, it's not my favorite game in this genre of game, but it's accessible, looks beautiful, and to this day my daughter still asks to play this game, so it gets played. She plays with her friends, she plays with me. It's fun, it's easy. I'd still give it a three out of five, but it's one that still manages to get tabled. Then we have The Grim Forest, well, in the same The Grim line of games. We have The Grim Forest over here from Druid City Games.
This was a wasn't even worker placement. I'm trying to remember if this is worker placement. I played this so long ago, I don't remember the core mechanic. But I remember that the art was very appealing, the the the the presence very appealing, the the little miniatures. Everything was great from a visual production standpoint, which honestly Druid City Games does across the board. They always make their games incredibly high quality from the production standpoint. From a gameplay standpoint, this was totally fine. I liked it slightly better than The Grim Masquerade, although The Grim Forest we don't have because again The Grim Masquerade is being propped up by my daughter, but The Grim Forest was fine. It it felt like a I think it was worker placement, but it might have just been card play, I don't remember. But overall, it it was it was forgettable. It was it was a good game in the sense that it it's an enjoyable enough experience, but I'd still give it a three out of five. Then from there we get to Off With Their Heads. Off With Their Heads is actually a fun fact. A few of their games are actually not on the publisher website, so I can't pull up the publisher links, so we go to BGG.
Off With Their Heads, this one is a better version of Banner Festival. Title title title whatever title title based Banner Festival. But Off With Their Heads takes the same trick taking mechanism. This time we put it in the world of Wonderland's War, and it has you trying to play high, low, or medium in order to score on different zones of your your roll and write. It's a open write game which you flip cards, and then you're going to be utilizing those cards to again play tricks coming in high, low, or medium, which will affect which zone you write in. You're trying to get all the markings in a zone in order to try to get your maximum score depending on the strategy you go for. Overall, I really enjoyed this game. My biggest critique is that you're a little bit too incentivized to go heavily into certain strategies that after you've tried those strategies, you know, they're kind of like five or six core strategies you can go for in order to maximize your points, and after you play this game five or six times, I felt like I saw what the game was doing.
There's not enough room for diversification or branching off as there are in some other roll and writes, and that kind of forces a slightly more specific lanes. I really enjoyed this one. I'd give it a 3.5 out of 5. My initial plays were easily a 4 out of 5, but again, as it started as I played it more, I realized that there was less replayability for me personally. Coming up next, we have Sorcerer City. Sorcerer City was an excellent game. I still like I would I would happily sit down and play this game today. This is like a fun interesting game that has you laying down tiles in almost a real-time mode, which you're going to be trying to create these groupings of colors as you go through it. And then from there, you're going to be upgrading your bag, gathering more tiles as you try to lean into the different ways you try to move up the various tracks and build up a tableau and to get better and better around over around. It was a very unique tile-laying game. The real-time element worked really well for what the game is doing. Overall, all around a solid game.
This is a solid 3.5 out of 5. Really enjoyed Sorcerer City. Then we have Mancala. Mancala is kind of in a place where again, just to be mindful, I've only played Mancala one time. This one I played the prototype way back then, so I've actually never played the final game. I played the prototype one time, never even played the final game. I do plan on getting my hands on this one cuz I do want to try it more, but as a two-player game that utilizes a Mancala element as far as how you're trying to drop off your tokens along the way, being mindful of which side of the board they drop off on and which powers you're going to be activating, it give you a very interesting dual system set in the world of Wonderland's War utilizing Mancala as the kind of main mechanism, which I love seeing Mancala integrated in board games. It's usually very satisfying, and that was true in Mancala as well. To me, rating-wise, it's a little hard to say. It's for sure a 3.5 out of 5 based on my initial play. Whether that would bump up to a four would need more time, but ranking-wise, I I definitely enjoyed my play, single play, of Mancala. From there, we have Wonderland's War, an excellent game. An excellent game with some small caveats that hold it back. To me, this is a four out of five, and it almost feels like it should be better than that. Wonderland's War is one of the best area control bag I was going to say one of the best area control bag building games. It's the only area control bag building game that I know of currently. Well, I guess technically One Deck War War Duel is also. But in One Deck War, the biggest critique I had about it is it's just way too long of an experience. I feel that three players doesn't feel as good as four players. Four players feels better.
At five players, I will never do again. Four players is probably the best player count, but even at four players, it's slightly longer than I want. A three player game is right about the right length, but not enough player interaction. And a four player game is the right amount of player interaction and not and and too much length. This is a game that is incredible as far as the gaming experience it gives you. It just runs a little long for that gaming experience, which is a challenge, but it's still an excellent game that I highly recommend. Just go into it knowing that you have to have the tolerance for longer games. For me, my biggest complaint about One Deck War is most of the time there was another game that would give me the same level of enjoyment in less time. And that was the biggest hold up against it. But still, it's fantastic and it's also very unique. And games do get points for being unique in a crowded spaces. And we very much live in a crowded tabletop space. One Deck War Duel on the other hand, again, this is very much in that asterisk. Yes, right now in this video, I'm putting it ahead of One Deck War.
Further plays could change that. I've only played half of a play of One Deck War Duel because I played the prototype. But it did seem to do the exact same thing that One Deck War does, but in a much shorter play time because it's focusing specifically on a two player element. Focusing a bit less on general general area control and a bit more on the tug of war that you can get out of a two player experience. So again, many many asterisks. Half a play it does not a review make. A full play does not a review make. This is just where I am with it currently given that half a play. I'm very excited to play this one more and see whether it flushes out and becomes a truly excellent two player game. And and Antique Duel 'em as a word. Like Antique Duel 'em was always a better game than Antique. And and that might be the case here. Although in this case, I think it's more of a play time than better experience. But either way, more plays wanted, but excited for them. Coming in number two, we have Bloodstone. Bloodstone, which I am very excited about. This does come with the the asterisk that the only time I played this was the prototype. I played it several times with the prototype. But the problem is they actually made changes. I had last time I talked about this was actually fairly recently in a 10 upcoming crowdfunding campaigns I'm excited for and I found out the hard way through the comments that the cooperative mode was axed and I liked the cooperative mode. I liked both modes of the game, but I liked the fact that the game gave you both. It gave you like this cool story and this cooperative adventure and this like new arena combat experience that felt if anything I might prefer the cooperative mode which puts me in a weird place in this one, but I still did enjoy the competitive mode. So we will see, maybe it'll be an expansion one day. I am I hold hope for it. I thought it was the to me was the better way to play the game.
But Bloodstone gave you arena combat that character abilities. Overall a fun system of basically trying to hack and slash each other while feeling cool doing it either in competitive or cooperative is the one I played, but apparently just full cooperative full competitive right now. But this one definitely enjoyed it a lot. That is the world of Bloodstone. Great miniatures, great art, great gameplay. That is Bloodstone. And then we have Tidal Blades. Tidal Blades 2 Rise of the Unfolders. I have not done a full review on this one. I covered the prototype way back in the day, loved it. Then dove into a gameplay with a few friends and then unfortunately the gameplay stalled. We were really enjoying ourselves. We were having a lot of fun and the gameplay stalled which means I need to either make that happen or alternatively go back to the drawing board with a new group that will actually get a table or even just a two-player game or even a single-player game because I really enjoy Tidal Blades 2 Rise of the Unfolders. It gave you great deck building, a fun little grid system over here like this little grid the way you activate this grid gives you kind of vibes and elements of Monumental but in a faster game that overall is a very enjoyable campaign system. I loved my game plays of Tidal Blades I can't play multiple games there. I played the prototype like five times and I think I'm four or five missions deep into the my subsequent plays. I loved my game plays of Tidal Blades 2 Tidal Blades 2 Rise of the Unfolders. I am excited to dive into it and complete it. Obviously when it comes to campaign games my opinion can change as I go through it.
Sometimes I love the first five games and then the more you play it the more you're like, "Okay, I've seen it all. I don't need to keep going." It does take a lot for a game to really be just as encouraging and incentivizing you to play the whole way through as opposed to just when it's all fresh and new and exciting. But that is Tidal Blades 2 Rise of the Unfolders the The I am most excited about from this list. Rating is not being given on this or Bloodstone or One Night's War duel because they all need significantly more time with them before I would give them a rating. Anyways, that has been my ranking of Jue City Games. Let me know in the comments down below what is your favorite Jue City Games and why and you know, that's basically it. Let me know in the comments down below. Until next time, I'm Alex Radcliffe from Board Game Co. I hope you enjoyed this video and as always, I hope you have a good one.