Board Of It's Top 10 Board Games of 2023!
Transcript
hi everyone I'm tally this is farl and we are bard of it and Welcome to our top 10 games of 2023 video hello Sven so this is also Sven senson senson and for our top 10 games of 2023 we're going to rank them individually so you see my top 10 T's top 10 we're going to reveal them to each other so we don't know each other's top 10 so it'll be a surprise for both of us and you and we for our top 10 list we're not uh only considering games which came out in 2023 yeah just because sometimes you know it's hard to get a copy of a game in one country or another sometimes game might come out in German and then it doesn't come out in English till the next year sometimes there's stock issues and all these kind of things so we're just picking the games we discovered this year that we want to rank in our top 10 so we're going to start out with some honorable mentions and then we'll take turns you know we'll both share our number 10 and the number nine but let's jump to the honorable
mentions coming on to the honorable mentions T has stated that I have to I have a lot of honorable mentions even though I told you you could only have Max four yeah but I can't so I'm letting you go first because then if some of my what I just I just don't think that you should have so many there was a lot of good games this year what can I say and I just feel like they maybe don't deserve to be in the top 10 but I just want to give them a little shout out and that's fair so T's going to list every game she played this year yeah but I'm going to keep it to honorable mentions yeah so I'll let you go first in case mine overlap and then like I can just agree and then take the ones so I have three and one which would never make it on top 10 but I think deserves recognition is so Clover which is if you've watched our videos on our most played games you know code names is always number one just because our families love it it's easy to get out easy to replay but last Christmas time well kind of going into January I guess that we discovered so Clover and we've played so much this year mhm uh that I wouldn't be surprised especially after this Christmas if it makes it on to our like most played games list and I just really enjoy it I think it's really I love these little word games it's a real novel twist so I've Lov so Clover and we've played it so much so I think it just you know it's an horrible mention I wouldn't put in my
top 10 but yeah I think it's a terrific little party word game so if you like Coden name but you're a bit tired then look for a so clever it's Cooperative as well Co a slight difference in those other types of games where maybe it's teams right so that's that's quite nice yeah have a lot of fun with that does not overlap with one of my mentions so the next one for me is solar 175 mhm which is a euro Legacy game it's kind of based very strongly on or or oron so get it right well just in case people don't know how to pronounce it so now I know both sides of it so this is where you bag build and you pull out little worker discs and then you put them on the slots and each action needs a number of like different makeup of workers so you might need like a Tradesman a merchant and a boatsmith and then you can do that action and solo 175 kind of takes us to space does similar things but makes it into a legacy game so for your first couple of games you're introducing new mechanisms and the Galaxy expands and I had a lot of fun playing it I think we both love all on so it was nice to kind of go back to that in a different format you could say I like some of the what it added but I also we did a review of it so you can check that out but I had some negatives mhm which is why I didn't make the top 10 but I I really enjoyed my time with it I think you didn't enjoy it so much I think it's a good game but you kept
winning and it just gets a bit tiring after a little while so that's a little negative for me um yeah there was another little negative for me which I actually can't remember what it is now it's been a while since we played it but I think I just felt like it kept being the same over and over again even though it was a campaign game you were just doing like kind of the same like the work has never change and there's like not so many choice in workers so it's kind of the same over and over again plus coup with the fact I just couldn't win it yeah no but there was a problem where you kind of are unlocking stuff pretty regularly and then you get to a certain point and it's like you probably have to play a couple of games before the next unlock and they start like really spreading them out and nobody wants to play this game like 25 times to see all the content they should have just had a 12 game like sharp campaign and I think they really overestimated how much people are going to play it yeah basically so my last honorable mention and this when I was designing the list it was kind of one of these ones that was on it it was number 10 and then it went to like number nine and then it went off so this one you could consider the honorary number 11 mhm M and that is that's cheating but yeah sure that is uh Ticket to Ride Legacy okay and we got sent this to review so we're going to have a review coming out we're just waiting to complete it because it's kind of I think important to see the whole campaign before reviewing it and we're
most of the way through I think we have three games left but probably the main reason it did not make it onto my list and slight spoilers but I think everyone knows this if you're interested in getting it it that you start out very small and the map gets bigger and what happens is the games get longer and at a certain point there are the mechanisms added in slash that you kind of use up other mechanisms which run out so you end up getting Ticket to Ride or or close enough that is kind of similar to the base game but it goes on for hours and hours cuz the map's so big yeah and that got a little frustrating to me MH uh that now it takes like two and a half hours to play a game of Ticket to Ride and you you're just playing Ticket to Ride right yeah but the discovery in the first like six to eight games is incredible we loved everything we had so much fun the the new mechanisms that adds of fun but we'll talk about it in our review but but that's the main reason I don't like that now it's taking like 3 hours two and a half hours to play again we have got five players to be fair but still yeah but you would want it to be five players considering I think yeah okay that one did overlap with one of mine so I can take that off mine I think it just didn't make the top 10 or I felt like I didn't want to put it on there because like you said we haven't completed it but we played enough to like you said have fun with it and we've had some good times but obviously maybe it goes completely downhill in the last games who knows so
I didn't want to commit to putting it in the top 10 okay so my honorable mentions I've got four of them that I'm going to pick out they're all I would say very lightweight games do that include TI ride Legacy excluding that because you covered that one that is also on there um and it's not even that I don't think lightweight games deserve to like not be on the top 10 because I have actually got some on my top 10 it's just they're kind of games where I don't know maybe it's not particularly novel or something isn't new or fresh so maybe it doesn't quite deserve to be on like a top 10 but as we've talked about in our video last year I rank all of my games based on how much fun I have with it like gut feeling whereas you're a little bit more scientific over it so they're games that we I really enjoy um but maybe not as much as the other ones but they're pretty much all lightweight so we've got sale even really I'm very surprised even though you shouted at me you keep shouting at me because sometimes I like forget the rules but it's a little small boox uh two-player Cooperative trick-taking game about getting a little ship across the board but the way that you take the tricks means the the Ship Sails in certain directions I just think that's really cute cool novel uh good concept I have perspectives which is a how' you describe that um deduction game a way like shock holes
Consulting detectives if it was much shorter cleaner and all like image based yeah so it's uh cooperative and trying to solve some cases but very simple you have some cards your uh teammate has some cards all kind of depicting a scenario but from different perspectives and you can't see each other's cards so you have to describe what's there and solve the case and I think that was a really nice little box that we got very cool had a lot of fun with it so deserves to be there um and then I'm going to pick spots Spots I'm surprised surprised that's not in your top 10 to be honest I mean maybe it would be if we I don't know not even played it more because we played quite a few games in the week that we've had it already but it's a new addition yeah so I didn't think it was maybe fair to put it on the top 10 but that's a very cute little dice rolling game uh based on dogs so I mean great can't really complain with that but it's just so cute the drawings and the art is just so funny and really tense little game for just some like Dice and cards yep and then then my last one I'm going to pick way points um so that is a print and play roll and right from what's the publisher postmart games we have a few of theirs now and they're just really nice cheap things that you can um download print and lemonade like we do and they're just really well done well implemented fun games that we like
to play with a cup of tea so just wanted to give that a shout out I think they are solid honorable mentions surprised by sales but uh sale yeah I think it's really cool Co concept they're good um good little mentions so I guess we will now go to our top 10 mhm and very exciting um interested to see because uh yeah I haven't thought really about yours but I'll think about it now
mhm we've got our Christmas wine so we'll begin the top 10 cheers and I'm interested so my number 10's going to be easy to explain because you already just explained it and it is perspectives okay nice yeah I thought that might make your top 10 as we said it's a little Co-op game you kind of and it's two to six players so cooperative and you're going to deal out all of these cards which have images on them it could be screenshot of a cell phone could be security camera could be a document and it's going to give you information and you're kind of given these questions to answer and then or like an overarching question who did the crime and then once you think you know that you have to put all the cards down you flip a sheet over and it gives you like four questions you have to answer each one gets you a point and then you answer them and then you know you can look at the ANW see if you got it right or wrong and I really really enjoyed this uh I like the deductive element what I thought is because you only get half the cards it's very dependent on the players communicating yeah and it's one of these games where something will mean nothing to you and you'll be like oh yeah there's this red line on it then the other play like oh my God that's this and then you connect and you talk and I really liked uh how you know there's like no quarterbacking because you have different information it opens up discussion around the table
and the answers were logical like you could work them out it's not oh I didn't think this weird thing that the designer thought is completely logical had no problems with the answers and it was just very clever and really enjoyed it it was like a really nice concise yeah little game so the one thing we'll say is that we were sent a review copy by as Nordic so know that obviously it being in my top 10 it's important you know but I really enjoyed it okay so my number 10 is so Clover which was on your honorable mentions of course so yeah I just think this for me deserves to be in my top 10 because like I said I rank on fun and gut feeling and I just think we have a lot of fun with that game we play a lot with our families have good memories of it but I think what makes it is even though it's cooperative and we don't particularly lean towards co-op games we prefer to be a bit competitive there's still an element there of slight savagery at least when we play it with our families because even though you obviously working together we still rag each other if you're giving rubbish Clues basically so there's still a bit of competition what were you thinking yeah as to who can make the best Clues oh God we're we're so bad um if someone Nails it and the teammates get it first round you're like yeah I made the best
Clues uh so it's not two you know nicey nice goody to shoes for us so yeah just really like it it's a classic now in our house and really nice one for the upcoming festive period if you're interested yeah so if you I mean if you like Coden names to crypto and you just I guess something like just one which we haven't played but if you're looking for something like that so Clover just felt a bit like a a breath of fresh air yeah and just really enjoyed it so y uh it's been yeah one of our games of the year in terms of plays and impact for sure in this year and we're definitely going to be getting out cuz your mom is obsessed with it they're coming over for Christmas so shall we go to number nine number
nine my number nine is barade uhhuh what's so funny about that nothing nothing go on carry on so beade is a game by Ryan Courtney you might know for pipelines and he's also designed Trails which has been big this year which we haven't actually played beade is one that he did that kind of slipped under the radar and it's this stons game so it's like stalks and shares basically and it is like it has a bunch of parody companies like banana instead of apple and Nile instead of Amazon very good slow clap really good and it's it basically this game about manipulating the stock market to make the most money and I just find it so hilarious and I enjoy playing it so much and I'm really upset I haven't got to play it more so we only played it a handful of times this year but I always it's always the game I look at and I'm like some like a lot of times something has to come for the channel right so we have to play this when people come around because we need more players or and it's the game that I always wish we were playing if that makes sense so I I just find it really funny because the way it works is you get a random bunch of stocks and basically if you make the company share price go up it will double so you get double that amount of stock
but if you make it go down it crashes and you lose all of your stock so what you want to do is make a company you have stock in be valuable and keep doubling in doubling it and the ones that you can basically sell a bunch of stock to get money to buy more stock but then you kind of owe stock so then you want that one to crash because it gets wiped away your deck gets wiped yeah but obviously other players have different ideas about which companies they're invested in and are going against you and you kind of manipulate Dice and you roll them so there's a bit of luck bit of manipulation but it's just really funny and interactive and smart and humorous and I've just had a great time playing it yeah it's really funny and Well Done isn't it because of the parody companies like you say also there's events is a bit strong but something different where the stock gets manipulated in a different way for each company every round and it's always something funny like a CEO puts foot in it or uh emails leaked or something like that right and it just is kind of chaotic funny fun game basically although yeah I always struggled to really wrap my head around it once I'm playing and I'm in it okay but if I had to explain how the like stocks part Works to someone I'm like I'm out I can't do it the first timeus we played this was after well not even after like during a night of drinking and we're like three games in maybe and you were let's say legless and I was explaining to you and you were like Starks and you ended up winning
then we CU you have a secret screen you reveal at the end of the game and tally had something like 40 stocks of whatever this company was and it was like fairly profitable and and we're just like it was pure like I did like you never even understood what's going on and you was like in your chair like St and shares works exactly I mean blind investment right yeah so yeah so my number nine is royal visit um which is a r canit a game right do we have like a like a deluxe version no I think it's just a reprint like it's been around for years and it's just we have the reprint yeah so this is a two playay a head-to-head game and it's you have some cards and some kind of characters let's say on a really beautiful like cloth uh mat and you're a king and you have a shadow at one end of the map and the other opponent is at the other end of the map and there's some other characters like guards there's a wizard there's a Joker um that all kind of have some different powers or do different things and the goal is to get the king piece to your Shadow basically is the goal and you do that by uh playing cards which have numbers on them that relate to the characters and that depicts how many times they can kind of move but there are rules like the king can never be in front of the two guards you had to be flanked either sides by the two guards so you have to move the guard forward so the king can move forward but then your opponent will kind of shoot them back um just think it's
beautiful production for one and just something that is so good to get out if you just have 20 30 minutes you want to play something fun super easy to explain so very easy to get to the table and it's just tense fun good quality game I think it's a strong Contender good game all of ran Kit's games always I think his kind of stamp is they always seem on the surface very simple but there is a lot of hidden depth once you start getting ility and available options yeah so like how you can use the kind of the Wizard and the Jo who have different powers and just kind of yeah making a little strategy there but we always tend to get it out when we have kind of friends over and one of us is kicking or taking the dogs out I'm like let's entertain the person while you're doing that with a game of rural visit but we also like to play it together as well I just think it's really good we' played it a lot this year to be fair we played it a lot when we first got it and started playing it so I I hope that continues cuz we haven't actually we've played more with other people like in the instances you say than we have the second half of the year with each other yeah but yeah I think it's great so let's go to number
eight my number eight is something you have already mentioned in your honorable mentions and that is way points and this is the game that moved around the most because I I knew I wanted it in my top 10 that was easy but I had it as number 10 and it was like this and Ticket to Ride Legacy that were jumping around like I couldn't quite figure and it actually went from 10 to 8 but I'm pretty happy with that uh so as tell briefly mentioned way points is a print andplay roll and right and this is from postmart games and they this is kind of the third in their series of these and the first one voyages we actually did a review of and we really just because we really enjoyed it and the concept and the thing is now I think almost probably because of the popularity of voyages you see a lot of print and play Rolling wres On Kickstarter but what they do is that they make their print and plays seem very high-end it actually feels like there's a lot of great art design in it a lot of great mechan mechanistic design so way points is basically another one of these where you roll some dice and you're using them to kind of hike across a landscape and you basically are going Waypoint to Waypoint so you draw a line and you kind of go through rings but the Rings it's like a topographical map so the Rings are like elevation contour lines yeah contour lines like elevation so it kind of represents elevation more or less and
you know the the dice is going to termine the weather and the weather determines how much you can move and so you have you know three movements and then if you need to move through more lines you have to drink water a lot of little things that you tick boxes and you get bonuses and but I just I was blown away by the art style by the mechanism I think at this point we've only played two maps cu the third one came out this week last week and I'm looking forward to playing that but I just had a great time it's one of my favorite rle and rights we've played and we've played a lot of them and I think why the core why it's on my list it cost £4 or $5 to download from the website you could get it by the end of the time and and be playing it by the time tally finishes her number eight and uh voyage's review was titled subtitled the best4 PS you can spend on a board game and now it's been taken by way points I it's a terrific role and right it cost you4 it looks beautiful yeah love it y agreed so my number eight is Obsession Obsession m m h i kind of so tough to really rank them eight maybe feels like I don't know harsh but there so many great games I had to put the others ahead of it but it's really really good game it is about
High Society in what century 17th 18th maybe yeah something like that darbishire um there's a little bit of like light worker placement and some kind of like deck hand management so you have these these cards that represent prestigious members of society and you want them to come to your estate to mingle with you but you have to have the right staff so uh you have to have the right um prestigiousness You have to be prestigious prestig enough to have the right guest there um so you have kind of a card of hands which represent different characters and of cards I think the Wine's getting to you said the card of hands the card of hands hand of cards hand of cards take this away um and you kind of play them to get more money which allows you to buy rooms in your in your estate and also host different activities like high tea and the more rooms you have the more points you get and different members of society that you attract will get you more points uh just think it's really humorous thematic in a way like with all of the uh flavor text that goes along with the characters um just think it's a great game actually um kind of new to our collection actually got it in the last couple of months um but just yeah solid game doesn't take too long to play easy to set up and explain solid game yeah I think
obsession is terrific uh I think the theme does a lot of heavy listing but I think it is interesting mechanically I think the expansion The Upstairs Downstairs expansion which introduces the useful man makes it even better and I think now that you know I think if you have enjoyed the base game all get the expansion it makes it better it kind of uh Smooths out some edges that you not that there are negative edges necessarily but it gives you more like freedom and leeway and it the randomness of say needing a specific tile that kind of goes away because you can just spend the useful man create a collection for an objective but I I really enjoy yeah session as well mhm okay should we go to number seven number seven
yeah for my number seven it's a game you might have already heard of on this list because it is Obsession so as I said obsession is a great game uh tally explained it very well and I'll just add that yeah I mean the theme is just it really is one of the board games that I've played like of all time let alone this year that just facilitates a little bit of role play so well because you know it's like oh I'm inviting The Duchess of this and Mr Appleton and Mrs Willard to croquet on the lawn and you know it's just like um you have to speak out what you're doing cuz it's fun for the whole table and although it is a euro like kind of a little little bit heads down solo if you read out what you're doing it does make it that much more fun for the other players where you take your turn and yeah I mean I think the expansion is great it it adds depth to it uh and it's just a lot of fun to play like it's a good it has a really nice combination between constantly improving your lot versus having to plan ahead because you can see what's coming up you always got to be ready for that Village Fair always ready always ready for the I mean come on so we've had a lot of fun with it and it's actually one that we've like T said we've only just got a couple month or
two ago and I'm looking forward to continuing to explore it cuz I know I'm not done with it yet if that makes sense absolutely not not ready to take it off our intay yeah so yeah so we can just go to your number seven yeah okay so my number seven is nucleum oh yes so this is a dry Euro about producing energy Inc Saxony kept saying Germany when we talked about this game before and you kept correcting me yeah Saxony um just the sort of game that we love it's a little bit of a take some elements from brass Birmingham and also barrage it's about building tiles flipping them over when you've energized them essentially there's some tracks typical Euro things but the kind of Jewel in its Crown is the action selection system where you have these little tiles that have two actions on them which you can either use to do those actions but you also have to build railroads on the main map in order to connect up your power plants with the different buildings that you need to power so you have to decide whether you want to keep that action tile or place it on the board for a railway the nice little twist is that when you place it and they have different colors at the either end which match up with the colors of the uh cities and towns where you put them you get to do the action if the color matches so a lot of really nice decision making about
whether to keep it because then you can keep using it or kind of discard it but necessarily discarded to build Railway and where you place it when you place it and you can always build new tiles but yeah I think really solid game but maybe the thing that lets it down a little bit is the art style it looks very dated and when you have other games of similar theme which are much more sleek and elevated in their kind of production and style yeah maybe that's why I didn't put it quite so high but we really enjoyed playing it no I agree I think nucleum is a great game I agree with the art style the action selection system is is really great and I love the you have to give up your action tiles to build a network work but you can get more but obviously you're losing that action combination forever and that's a really interesting decision but and I also like how in in a lot of games say brass Birmingham building if you your entire turn is to build two links it's a boring turn right you just waited build a link build a link build a link that's it it's not that fun or interesting but here you build a link and oh now I get two actions because I set it up correctly so basically I have a full turn yeah so I really like that it's a nice little twist y okay cool shall we go to number six
six my number six is a very old game that got a lovely reprint this year mhm and it is raah MHM by ryania nice and I mean ra is RA it's known to be one of the greatest auction games bidding games of all time uh the 21st no 25th Century we're in the 21st century the 25th Century uh reprint that came out this year we I backed the normal version and then during the pledge manager I upgraded to the deluxe version which I think cost double but the game is so tactile in terms of the tiles that it was worth it so nice and it's just had a great time playing it and everyone we've introduced it to has had a great time and one of my Fondest Memories is my best friend came over with his girlfriend and introduced it to them they're not so much board gamers um and they got into it and we played like five or six games of it while they're here and they got very intense and very and they loved it and it's nice to show something to someone and I think ra just one of those games that you can show to anyone and they're going to be like this is really good because it is really good yeah uh so yeah I just had such a great time with ra and I I recommend getting a
copy yeah I just I really enjoyed it so raah was on my b list of honorable mentions be list I had so many yeah really great game that I think will again keep in our collection forever because it's just something so easy to to crack out yeah okay so my number six I feel like you might be a bit surprised this even like made my top term it is Thunder Road I'm not surprised at all okay I this was the one game that I looked at when I was looking at the list of all the games we played and I was like I know T's going to have it on a list yeah absolutely so it's a car racing game um you have three vehicles small medium and large and basically you roll some dice and that dictates how many movements you can kind of take with each so you assign the dice to the vehicle and then you also have a fourth dice which lets you do kind of some special power round to round but it is really for me invoking you always say Mad Max uh but like Fast and Furious is very chaotic you have a chopper you can blow people up with a chopper you can shoot out people in at the end of every turn with your car if they're kind of in front of you and the idea is just to get to the end of the the race course but I just think it is so much fun the theme really comes through for me and I just feel like I
really am in some kind of like desert racing situation where it's like completely chaotic and it's it really feels like playing a movie to me and I just think it's really novel quite unique to me we've introduced this to to a few people again who don't necessarily play board games and they were just saying this is so fun yeah uh and I just yeah I think the kind of novess for me means that it goes into my top 10 I always have a great time playing it and I don't necessarily like games that are so aggressive aggressive in a way or like combative but because it's just so fun and I don't know it doesn't go on for too long either it's not short and it can go on for a long time if everyone kind of surviving but because it's more in the fun not party game is the wrong word but you know you have a lot of people around and you're all just like chucking dice uh yeah more like fun party style that it doesn't really matter if you go out it's like eh whatever yeah well somebody going out triggers the end of the game as well so it's not very long that you have to wait but yeah it's not great either but uh yeah I mean it's it's a lot of fun I think for me I do enjoy it it wouldn't be in my top 10 like it wasn't close but I'd be really interested because there's a bunch of expansions uh and I'd love to to throw those in and see what happens because I do really like it as a fun dice chucking beer and pretzels game yeah uh and maybe
with those expansions it would rise up M but they're very hard to get and I think there's maybe rumors of the reprint of the kind of Ultimate Edition we'll see but yeah I think yeah I knew I knew it I love it I love it not that I knew you'd put it in but I expected it to show up because I I just thought you would right because you've always really been buzzed about it yeah totally okay then we'll move into the top five o my number five is grow West and TR mhm Argentina yes and it could be either Argentina or New Zealand cuz we've played both this year for the first time H I mean you could really pick EO but I've put Argentina here just because I'm only going to have one of my top 10 right I'm not going to like chunk it up with two great won Trails although it very much could because they're brilliant games uh it's just because Argentina has been described and I agree with this as great w and Trail for people who love Great West and Trail there like more of everything it's more complex it's probably a little bit more difficult there's more mechanisms and so we both had great withs and Trail in our top 10 of all time y so we love that and I love playing Argentina so I I thought the changes were quite interesting and I can see
some people maybe not liking them because it does kind of put like another layer between things so rather than just delivering when you get to the end now you can put them on a boat and then when they they get to the port you then have to also spend the secondary currency to get them to get points rather than just getting points so it's more convoluted but I just really enjoyed how it did it I enjoy the new type of workers which are farmers uh that you can help out there's some interesting mechanisms that play uh and it also introduced us to C Moos yeah exactly which is a combination of red wine and Coke which is surprisingly delicious yeah very popular in Spain and South America so we're here yeah and uh don't knock it until you've tried it it's actually very delicious so our friend who we played with he introduced us to it and yeah so that was another benefit of why gry won Trail is number five yeah I think we did a video before where we did our favorite drinks and games pairings so for the original Great West and Trail we did a bourbon and then that would be the updated version for Argentina Cacho yes okay so my number five is void for which is a big box Euro game it has tracks it has Euro combat by that we mean uh mathematical dry combat um very dry yes but it is quite unique because it is it's scenario based so the
voidborn are kind of like a non-player enemy in the game they're an infectious what is it parasite wow they're like an other dimensionally like a faction yeah that infect the Galaxy I yeah it's out in space so you have some kind of Technology upgrades politics tracks economic track things like this to go up but the action selection system again is very cool and unique because it's a set of cards and you can only play maybe four or five every round and it's variable depending on kind of the event that happens every round so you have to be very careful as to what you select as part of that five and also the order that you play them because you need to optimize on the combinations you need to make sure you have some resources in play Maybe in that turn to enable you to do something else in a following turn so it's really about kind of action order optimization I would say to kind of get points um but like I said scenario based so the kind of events and things will change every round the map setup changes um I think the reason maybe why I didn't put it higher because I think when we both first played it we were like yes clap clap it was amazing um it's it is a bit of a chore to set up and you would know that more than me because you're mostly on setup but it's not something that you could just be like oh should we have a quick game of void fall it's a slug to get it out it
has to be on the table for a while we usually play like one or two games and kind of leave it on the table because the time investment of getting it out is is so high and that's quite annoying because it actually especially if you know what you're doing it doesn't take that long to play It's like a standard heavy Euro like you know it's 2 hours maybe less if depending on the scenario and how many like you said cars you can play per round MH but it just the setup is it's it would be my top three most brutal setups for sure yeah of but yeah and you don't even gain anything because because it's base like you say and this is really clever because it it changes the challenges and you can have a scenario that makes it so that players can kind of fight each other or you can make it so that they'll basically never be able to fight each other and only fight the voidborn and you have these different considerations with the scenarios and obviously if you enjoy the game you want to see all the scenarios yeah but then if you do a different scenario you have to completely set up from scratch almost because the board's going to be completely different cuz it's tile based yeah so that adds a lot of time right yeah so but it's a brilliant game yeah yeah fantastic well number four number
four my number four already been mentioned by T on her list do you want to guess what it is Bo no it is nucleum okay and I mean everything she said I think uh brass birmingh and BR are in our top 10 it has a lot of elements of both I mean one of the designers is the same as brass uh sorry barrage so obviously you can see that influence and as you said the action selection system I think is really clever uh I really enjoy it and it gives it its own kind of like Little Twist on what's come before but the reasons that is probably not higher as you say I think the the art Direction and the component style is I mean it does have dual layer boards and stuff but the the component and art direction is very uninteresting tired and I think that docks it a lot of points because if you look at Brass Birmingham barrage they're very beautiful games and I don't think bras firmingham would be anywhere near as highly rated if it looked like nucleum looks yeah I think a lot of it's a claim has also come from the fact that it made kind of something so dry so beautiful yeah there's no there's just no excuse really for it in like this day age is there you know it's very easy to make a board game be very mechanically good but also look nice on the table to just elevate it above you know looking tired and dated and then for me I think
the the other thing that we said in our review of nucleum is because it kind of splits his Focus among all these different things you kind of have the energy system of uh garage and you have the flipping of tiles from brass it it kind of doesn't do those two games are very focused and they do one thing exceptionally well was this is a bit split so it doesn't do anything as well but it's still by far one of the best Euros we played this year it was terrific I mean we love playing it you wanted to play it over and over uh I have you know it's kind of the only criticisms for it are that better games exists but it's still a terrific game and one of the best games I've played this year certainly one of the best Euros I've played this year totally and obviously number four I pretty love playing it yeah and I think like you said this action selection system it it is kind of its own thing so it does do something special and I love the way it works and the way you have to decide as we said with putting it down to create links or keeping it to do the actions I think it's interesting because whil it obv obviously takes influence from brass and barrage I'm not mad at having like all of them in the collection I think they each do something a little bit different enough to have all of them they're not really they're influencing but they're not overlapping in my opinion y okay so my number four is John company wow uh I'm
surprised I made your list okay why are you surprised I don't know I just didn't no just had a lot of fun with this game it's a Cole worldly game and it's a satire on the east Indian Trading Company it's um every player represents a family who's part of the company so you all have to kind of work together to make the company succeed because if it fails then everyone loses but of course you want to be the family with the most money at the end of the game so kind of uh interesting concept about working together so that it doesn't fail but of course you want to win if it doesn't so you there's a lot of steps in the game you do a lot of actions but it's essentially about making sure that the company is profitable but you have to make the most money for your family by doing various things do you want to add something about the way that it plays no I think just just add it's it's not who has the most money though it's the most victory points oh that's true but you need a lot of money to keep your retirees in the lifestyle they're accustomed to that's it yeah exactly so you have kind of workers from your family and you appoint them into different positions but you have to kind of agree on it you can't have too much nepotism so that's the part where the kind of interaction between the players comes and about working together but then you kind of want your your family
employees to retire because that's how you kind of get points amongst other ways but you have to have money to send them to better retirement homes basically so the better their retirement home the more points you get but you go through a lot of different phases you're kind of doing trading you're doing military Affairs and each person sorry each family has kind of different positions in the company who gets to decide who does what but a lot of table talk actually about who does what yeah and that's for me where a lot of the fun comes from and maybe this is just because the the people that we've been playing with but we really get into the role play um about giving the little characters names like it's kind of funny to call a what 15th 16th century uh 17th century it's not 15th what is it then it's like 17 no 18th or 19th century really 15th would be the 1400s yeah yeah yeah yeah no you're right yeah it's the why I'm talking um giving them I don't know funny modern names like Oh Mr Dave he's going to be the uh head of shipping so that's where a lot of the fun comes into it for me and you know kind of saying Okay who wants to be director of trade who wants to be the ambassador here so I just think it's really a lot of fun and yes it's very complex it's a cwy game but I think it's probably one of the maybe easiest to teach in a way
because you go through like a cycle every time uh it's not asymmetric though like route we always strugle yes yes and I would say we always struggle to kind of get people on board with rot because of how asymmetric it is so you have to kind of play as the factions to understand how they work understand how to stop them so maybe higher time investment there whereas yes yes it's like high barrier to teach but then it's like the same every game right yeah so yeah just had a lot of fun playing that yeah I mean going on to the the difficulty I guess it's from on your individual turn or an individual action it's generally very simple what you're doing it's very understandable it's very approachable but it's more about what that actually means in a wider context of the game that there's so much mental load and that's where this huge amount of difficulty comes from is how does this impact everything basically why would I do this why should I do this yeah and able to for foresee what everything means for the future like you say yeah exactly but yeah just had a lot of fun that's fair let's go to top three
then top three now interesting times and my what interesting times interesting times so my number three is probably oh I know it is the first game we played in 2023 and it has made it straight to the very almost top and that is undaunted stalling grat and this is obviously a game in the undaunted series uh kind of deckbuilding World War II game uh very popular and Stalingrad was the campaign game in this series so you play something like 15 games one person plays as the Germans the other as the Russians during the Battle of Stalingrad and it kind of introduces a lot of Novel mechanisms where the terrain will change depending how you act in the mission it has a branching narrative so different missions will be played depending who's won and it was so addictive we I think played all of those 15 games in something like three to five sessions right yeah something like that we just played at one point things got a bit stressful because it was a very tense game and we're like okay let's pack it away and we packed it away and literally first thing next morning we just put it back on the table and played some more so it was one of the best gaming experiences if not the best of the year I absolutely loved it we love in daunted
we've played an insane amount of undaunted this year uh and Stalingrad was a highlight basically for me of all of that and it was just so fun yeah agree moving on to my number three yeah that is undaunted styling grad we did a crossover yeah so agree with that you said like I said I rank mine on fun and of course this is fun but it's stress fun stress stress fular yeah exactly um but I guess it has to go up there because of how addictive it is and that just says what a great game it is like if you want to keep getting it out Time After Time game after game and saying oh maybe we should put it away and go to bed one more game then I think it deserves to be in the top three and like you said we really love the undaunted card building deck building system but they're kind of layering that onto a campaign style and moving it on um every scenario and really really felt like you are directing the battle in a way and that's the same with all of the undaunted games but the campaign elevated it even more because you're getting soldiers kind of permanently out of your deck um if you if they're kind of yeah dying or out of the game um so yeah we just absolutely loved it UPS the stakes right UPS the stakes because you
can get improved soldiers you can get worse soldiers and a lot of tension and just very interesting ideas and just unlocking new things all the time different like vehicles and planes and things like this just obviously elevates it over and above the kind of undaunted games that aren't campaign yeah and importantly it's a replayable campaign which is great right so we could go again next year yeah okay let's move on to number
two number two now the penultimate game o excited there's a lot of decision about if this was going to be number one or if something else was going to be number one and this landed on number two and it might be something that I regret in future not having number one but we'll see that's exciting what do you think my number two is void for wrong it is John company second edition okay so I obviously rate it a little bit higher than you uh but for all the reasons you said uh some board games they just give a novel experience and John company is one of those there's nothing quite like it yeah I mean shut up and sit down just did a 50-minute video all about John company and obviously it was worth the amount of time yeah that was spent on that for them and for us uh it's incredible and we love Co worly games and it's another great great reimplementation of you know an earlier game he did second edition like pack Premier and yeah it's like you say the table talk the theme the mechanisms negotiation the fact that it's a little bit luck based as well yeah uh it's just it's just epic isn't it yeah it's just this Beast right and the fact that it also comes with these different scenarios so I think
there are three or four kind of different variations you can play that alter the setup and some people will just play the first one over and over and you'll still get an incredible amount out of that it it's probably number two because you do need a group of players it's you can't we didn't find a two player work that well yeah uh I mean I'm sure some people could make it work a bit better but to us it was like you really need I feel an intricate knowledge of the game for the two- player to really shine because it's a specific mode whereas it's really 3 to six yeah and we just rather play it because we do have people like willing to play it right with more so that's just a preferable way to play for us yeah but I think it's just harder to get to the table which is why it's number two to me we couldn't just get it out you need people and not everyone's going to like it a lot of people aren't going to like it a lot of people will hate it uh for a variety of reasons so that toughness is probably what keeps it number two but uh the Brilliance of design on show blew me away I just love the experience of playing John company and you know if I had kind of free reign to get something on the table with a group of people and you know they would just do it and there wouldn't be any complaints it' probably be John company every time if it was like super easy to teach and everyone could just absorb like how to play yeah yeah okay so yeah you my number two my number two is Great Western Trail New
Zealand actually New Zealand so this is the most recent one um that we have in the collection so it's Great Western Trail based in New Zealand so instead of cows you have sheep same sort of thing we going around in a loop stopping at different buildings doing actions ultimately to kind of sell the Sheep at the end of the game deck hand management improving the uh value of the sheet that you have and the kind of new layering on here with New Zealand is that you can also um sell the sheep for their wool value which is slightly different to their kind of monetary value in order to get money so that's the kind of twist here versus the other games I just think Great Western Trail even though I'm not alwayss very good at it although I have been improving and I think we went through I don't know 20 or 30 games of maybe Argentina and the original without me winning a single one I just always have fun playing it and I don't care if I don't win just trying to improve your own scores is enough for me and I think it's the fact that you go around in this Loop you always want to try and improve on your own stance let's say always trying to get better hand of sheep or cows uh at the end of the loop and you can just keep going with the loop so that's why it's number two for me I would never turn down a game of Great Western Trail New Zealand so other games
even games on this top 10 you might have to be in a certain mood but that for me I would never ever turn it down so that's why it's my number two yeah I mean I agree like I think like I said I did Argentina because because it's more and I wouldn't have had both of them but grey Western Trail New Zealand deserves to be on the list as well so I'm glad you put it mhm and I think it's terrific Edition it's one that's more for if you want to incorporate the deck building element because there's like new cards that you get into your deck that aren't sheep or cows that do special things there's kind of different setup every time you play with different cards that can come into that deck yeah so it kind of leans more towards that aspect yeah and and yeah the new sheep shearing element is also really interesting that you can get money and you can also make wool deliveries yeah as well as kind of sheep deliveries yeah it's really interesting choice especially if the Sheep sharing building tile is near to the end of the loop do you want to get rid of that entire hand to get more money or save it for the market so I think that's a very interesting decision that's kind of thrown in there yeah I mean the last game we played of this actually it was very interesting because the sheep shearing one was right before the market it was the last tile so if you went all in for sheep sharing you basically had random chance of what comes into your hand for the market which is quite dangerous so that made it like a little interesting element as well say yep all right well let's let's
go to number one now one we're here with Sven for the number one hello Sven he's excited he's he wants to find out he's excited and I think tally is not going to be a surprise to you because you definitely know it in your head it must be this game I'm thinking of it must be well you can reveal my number one then okay faroh's number one must be void fall it is indeed void fall uh we obviously already talked about it at length I just think it's absolutely brilliant I love these big Epic big heavy Euros uh the components the game playay The Action System the scenario design I thought it was incredible it's some of Masterpiece one might say yeah you know when the action of playing it is really fulfilling for me I'm really engaged I love it I love the picking through the actions in the right order as you said I love that the different scenarios feel so different and give different problems uh and you know the the big negative as we said the setup right and also it's not a game I would ever want to play with someone who doesn't know how to play yeah if you're going to teach it to someone you want to know that they're going to be playing multiple games otherwise is a waste of everyone's time so those are some big negatives but
obviously I have you you had it in your top 10 MH you're going to play it so and if you play at two or four there's not much of a difference because some scenarios it's almost impossible to even fight another player yeah if that's what you want right so it is a very solo game in in many aspects you probably just fighting someone just for the sake of fighting someone else right it's not like necessary to win the game you get a lot of rewards from taking over void warn spaces so so I just I yeah in terms of what it does and the scale and the scope I just really really enjoyed it you know and like I said I think John company could have been number one it's just that it's that much harder to get to the table although this isn't easiest but at least I can always play it yeah yeah yeah we can always play it together right think something we didn't maybe mention when we talked about vo for From Me Maybe we did can't remember but like the production value as well and the artwork you know tool we have and the B- roll will be the uh kind of I think it's called the galactic Edition which is like the upgraded so it won't be the retail but yeah the production is terrific yeah okay so my number one yeah see I'm not sure cuz a lot of the one side I would have thought maybe maybe you'll say it and then I will be like of course I feel like based on some of your comments earlier maybe it's going to be a little bit of a disappointing one oh no but
it's it's great w TR Argentina oh no you put both of them in you like I would never put both of them in I was like uh oh wow I don't care I stand by it no wonder I couldn't guess what it was exactly I mean I did think about it a lot whether they should both be in there because obviously they're I mean I'm very glad that we have all three of the trilogy in the collection I don't think we would probably get rid of any one we play all three all the time get we switch them up um they will have their own kind of unique uh value let's say so I did really you know think about it a lot as to whether to put both but in the end I just had to because of the reasons all I said about New Zealand just the fact that I just find it so much fun all of them would never turn a game down and there are a lot of games I would turn down even though I love them and great w TR is just not one of them so for me I felt like they both deserve to be in there and kind of have their own spots I think Argentina had to go first just because you mean oh Argent sorry Argentina's first um number one spot yeah um just because I think the ship mechanism is very interesting like you said it adds another layer of you have to deliver the cows but you also have to make sure you have enough of the wheat to make sure that you can um put the discs that were delivered in the right spots to get the
most points I just think that element it's almost like a risky element of uh delivering the cows but yeah making sure you have enough week I just think it's like a really like fun Challenge in a way and adds another layer on top of original great Great Western Trail the New Zealand I think the Sheep sharing is is really cool and really fun but that kind of ship part for me and Argentina just takes the top spot well no wonder you had to have so many honorable mentions if you chunked your list up with variations of the same game yeah no comment to that uh just yeah I just love them both and didn't want to leave one out n to be fair I mean they are separate games I think for me it's just that they are so similar in so many ways that I wouldn't have both but like that spot could have been taken by either of them yeah yeah it's not that I wouldn't have New Zealand on the list it should be on the list I'm just not going to as a personal kind of thing right I thought about maybe cheating a bit and adding them together in one spot but I feel like they're different enough where that would be doing like either one a little bit of a disservice and that's why they take up two spots okay sorry if that's boring everyone but that's how I feel well so that was our top 10 and please let us know what you think always let us know whose list is better more accurate it's mine and Well
yeah if there are massive Great Western Trail fans uh and please if you have any questions let us know uh it it obviously we're happy to answer them if you haven't subscribed and you found this fun please consider subscribing and we just really appreciate you watching we hope this gives you some nice recommendations and shows a little and maybe you're surprised that there's not some of the bigger games from this year on our list but actually in the first half of the year we we didn't play so many new games we didn't we haven't bought this year so many new games in except for ones that have really attracted our attention like we been a little bit more selective yeah we've got a lot more review copies as well of different things so we haven't necessarily been buying like one that comes to mind is like Earth we've never played that's I think people are pretty hot on there's like a few kind of games like that where we just haven't got around to playing basically so if a game that you think is like was wild good this year it's probably just cuz we haven't played it let us know if we should play it obviously we're always looking for new stuff uh but yeah I hope you enjoyed it and we'll see you next time thanks a lot for watching bye bye