11 Board Game Reviews in 21 minutes - Keep or Cull
Transcript
Hello everyone, this is Johannes and this is Irma and you are watching board gaming rambling. And welcome back to keep or cull where we play all the games and tell you if you want to keep them or cull them. Yes, if they're in the staying collection or if they're going to go somewhere else out in space. Yeah, or a new home. We always send the games out in space like we have our own space shuttle that we send all the games and just go out in the atmosphere. They don't, but today we have around another round. We have exactly 11 games. I don't know how you could have like a round 11 games like 10 and a half. I have an empty box without any contents. That's true. That's going to be a keeper for sure. Are you ready? Let's start with one game. It's Rocket Punch. Rocket Punch, this was a review copy. Are you ready? 1 2 3 boom. It's a double keep.
This one was really fun. This is a trick taking game. Oh, we like those. But if you win a trick you kind of keep like the token for that color in front of you and then if another player later in the round wins that same color, you will give that to the other players. You want to win with the color lost. The last trick of the color is the best. The count. And that don't think it's your points. It's a pretty pretty quick one, but it also it's like a different kind of feeling and I really like it. And you feel really clever when you It's going on my side. That's why nothing happened. I was thinking like why is he not moving it to your side? Next up we have another review copy Red North. This is a new version of a game we played a couple years ago from Llama Games called Sad with a weird Norwegian letter. It's also it's Sad is also kind of weird in it's it's kind of like what is this word in English? Sad. You're kind of like not it's not awkward. It's quirky maybe.
That was a nice word for it. That might be be a good word for it. Are you ready? Let's go. 1 2 3 boom. It's a double keep. I think this is really good. Yeah. I really like sad. This is the same game it just looks better. Yeah. Because sad didn't look really good and also it's very much like made in like by by one person. I don't know if it's one person but by very small company and actually it was mighty boards who made you buy sad. So thank you for that and also thank you for this new version. This is a It's a real majority. It's a majority game not a real majority. A majority game. You're playing cards face down and at the beginning of the round and to be able to play more cards you have to flip some of your cards face up basically saying this is kind of my plan or am I bluffing?
This is not really my plan and I'm just flipping this blue card while I actually am playing a lot of green cards to win the green outpost. And then you're going to score points for the outpost that you win at the end of the round or keep if you already have them. And they're going to also add to the value of that colors that will help you also give you a special ability and you will get special powers, gold powers depending on the round. Very quick game. Highly recommend this one. A small filler game that is really really good.
Yeah, very glad that mighty boards picked it up.
Yes. It makes it more available more available and also better looking. Propolis. Propolis. Another review copy. Are you ready? 1 2 3 boom. It's a double call.
Yes. In Propolis you are bees and you are basically collecting what do you call it? Pollen? No. Nectar? Nectar? From flowers and you buy cards with abilities and points. You build buildings. Yes. So it I felt like a little it reminded me a little about the I don't remember the name of the game. That's always good.
Splendor. okay. Because you're like collecting and and you buy it and then some of those cards give you like passive nectar use for later things and you're trying to get cards that work together well with your scoring space very simple game. It was meh. Yeah. It was not very interesting. Didn't give me a lot but I I did play it. Next up we have Point Galaxy the third game in the Point Universe. Yes. First we had a salad. That's like a cool name.
to the city. Yeah. I think it was Point City, wasn't it?
Yeah, yeah, yeah. It's not a good name, Point City. I don't like it. Point Galaxy. I like that name.
But how do you go further? It can't we go further?
Well, you can't
with a salad, then you go to the city.
They've kind of broken the rules. Yes, but it's
did like the word play in the first game. Point Salad. Yeah, it haven't you heard about the Point Galaxy? It's a very normal thing. Okay, are you ready? Well, two, three, boom. It's a double camel.
Yes, I don't know if I said it was review copy, it is review copy. It was fine. It is It's I feel like Point Salad is really good because it is so simple. Yeah. I don't know if we played Point City. I don't remember we did. Okay.
It was It was like a little step up. I like Point Salad more but I like that too. Same as I like Point Galaxy. I do like it. I think it does exactly what I expected from it and I think it's supposed to do. I think it's I I think it's like the the the main mechanism of the game where you have like these stacks of face down cards that have something on the back and then you flip it over and then it turns out to something else in your like the tableau and you draw from there. That's been the same in this one and Point Salad and And that's a great system and I think the things that you do in this game to score points was interesting, but ultimately, I I I found it just like I have I have better games that I'm more excited to play. That's the bottom line. But I think that it was fun. I'd rather play Point Salad. I don't know if you have that I don't think we have that. But like if I had to have to choose to play one of them, I would choose Point Salad.
It's the simplest one. It just does that system very well. I feel like they added It's not that it's so much more complicated, but it's just like it doesn't of a system that works really well in Point Salad. For me, it's Point Salad, Point Galaxy, and then Point City.
don't even remember Point City, so I'm guessing I agree. I didn't I don't recommend it. I don't think it was that much fun. Next up is Silo. Yes, this is not a review copy. It's something I backed on Kickstarter. Cool. Are you ready?
Yes. One, two, three, boom.
It's a double kill.
Yes.
This game has a really cool theme.
Uh-huh. Uh you basically are abducting humans.
Yes. As aliens and also cows, which is cool. So, uh you have like a board with many different like areas or yeah. Um that's basically it. Yeah. And uh the game is going to trigger these different locations, and you want to have control over the locations at the right time. So, you will collect the humans from there or cows and also be able to do the action of that space. So, it's a little set collection with the humans and cows, and it's it I it's a little mean. You can like try to destroy other people's plans,
Yes. but it was like silly fun. bother me. It's It's a fine game. It's another one of those where I played and I like that was a fun. Never need to do that again. Uh but it was fun. But it's not something that I would go out and and and and run out and buy. Next up is Paddy. It's another review copy uh from two tomatoes. That's the name. I like that name. But the tomatoes are like dice, they're square tomatoes. I don't think that exists in the world. Are you ready? 1 2 3 boom. It's a keep for me, a call from you. I I really like this game in the beginning and I felt like in the end it was kind of dragging a bit. I felt that was so weird because I liked it more and more the more we played.
Okay. I felt it might have been the way we played it ended up like in a kind of for me stagnated way where I couldn't change too much that was better. And it's basically a game where you are building a tableau, building up a 3D terrain. Yeah, like a shared one, yes. Yes, and you will be placing animals on there that is your own animals and trying to control areas on different levels. And the higher the level, the more points that area is going to give you. And I actually I enjoyed it. I'm happy keeping it because I would be happy to play it again. Mhm. I'm happy calling it. I was very on the edge of with this one because when you explained the rules to me, I was just like I don't know how this will be fun because it seems like so random where you want to place it because just like every time you place a new the tile, you can move one of your animals there. It's like why do I want to do that because somebody can just like ruin that a moment later.
But it ended up feeling very like meaningful for in tactical when you started playing and just like oh, but I saw this opportunity. Uh the thing that I didn't wrap my head around was the waterfall.
Yeah. I still don't know how to score those. Still you know how to score them. Like I didn't teach you the rules. Like rules, I know. But how I will get those points and not the other players, I kind of don't know.
So, should we keep it to play once more? What do you think? Yeah.
keep it for now. I'll let you know. Yes. Next up on your side, we have Ego.
Yes, another one from this is Canitsia as well, right? Yes. And I backed it in the same batch of games. Are you ready? Was it Orbits, the last one, or what was it called?
Yeah, Orbits we did a while ago. Are you ready? 1 2 3 Boom!
It's a double cow. Yes. I thought this was just okay. This is mainly just like um auctions. Yes, a string of auctions. Your favorite mechanism. Well, I thought it was done in an interesting way because just like now it's a blind bid, now it's like a a different color you have to bid with a card. And you're trying to sometimes just avoid the negative stuff. Uh sometimes just like I don't care about winning this auction, but I really don't want to lose. So, I want to stay in and be a number two if I can do that. And like trying to see when to back back out of a auction.
Yeah.
Um but yeah, I I but it was fine. Yeah, I I enjoyed my time with it, but again, it's not something I would seek out to play again.
Yeah. Next up, we have another review copy. This is Knitting Circle, a Calico game.
Mhm. This is a Calico game. It's kind of in the the same way as Calico, but different. But it looks similar. Yes. Are you ready? Yep. 1 2 3 Boom! It's a double cow.
This was um I like Calico. I think it's a fun game. We did We had Calico. Uh I felt like the randomness in it made it like it's a super tight puzzle, but it's kind of random if you get what you need or not.
Yeah, in the original Calico, yes. This has less randomness, I felt like, but also less fun. Uh like you are doing mostly the same thing. You are placing these You have some buttons which shows you goals, and you are placing these tiles that can be like either one side or the other. I don't know what's called like in the knitting One, the two different kind of patterns Uh or kind of ways to knit. And you are placing those on cards that you get by discarding some of these pieces. And the buttons tell you which goals you want to go for like, "Oh, you want to build symmetrical, for example." I'm saying build knit symmetrical theme. Or you want to do it this way or that way. And for me, I felt like it was fine, but it was nothing where I was like, "Oh, it's super interesting which choice I have to take.
Oh, do I I need this, so I guess I'm going to take it." And I guess I'm going to place it there to score points. It Of course, that sentence can be used to describe a quite a bunch of board games, but I felt for me it didn't give me that, "Ooh, now I get to do this." or "Ah, I get to do that." or "I'm trying my strategy is going to be this. I'm going to have two of these, which is two of these things I want to knit at the same time, which is the maximum. I'm going to try to complete them. And I'm going to get new ones, and I'll just rinse repeat that in a way that was meh. Yeah, I agree. I think that in terms of luck and randomness, I felt my my options were more free than in Calico. I like that. But also, the things that I'm trying to achieve was a little like looser, Yes. which also is better for the randomness. But then again, also I didn't feel like, "I really need this, or it won't work." and it like you lost some tension there. Also, that made it a little less interesting. You have some like when you're drafting the the knits, the the fabric, the wool, I Yeah. Yeah.
You you move your cats around this knitting table or whatever it's called, knitting circle. And Um and if there's another cat where you want to be, you can't grab from there. But you can attack them, and you will roll dice. And the cat that chaotic game. Well, no. you don't. [clears throat] But so then I was just like, okay, I can't do anything about this that you want where I want to go and I couldn't really do anything about it because I couldn't go there before because it was too far away. So I was just like, okay. And as you said, you're basically re-repeating what you're doing. It was it was fine. It's a game. I It was fun to play it, but again, next up is is Watson and Holmes. Yes, are you ready? Yeah. One, two, three, boom. It's a double cow.
Yes. We played this a little while ago and this is one that I've been eager to play for a long time because it's been standing on the shelf and just like always, it's deduction. And I'm very keen on trying that. When we tried it, I thought it was I thought it was okay. You have this co- What do you call it? Competitive deduction in this instead of the cooperative ones you have in the other Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective games. But in this genre, I like the Search for Planet X more. I like Cryptic more. I like the Awkward Guests. Yes. This was not up to those No. I mean, I know some people really liked it, but for us it just fell flat. Next up, which is the last one on my side, which means you have one more on your side, I think. And that is a box. I will I probably look pretty stupid while trying to get that out there. A box is a new review copy and it's a big one. Are you ready? Yeah.
One, two, three, boom. It's a double cow. Yes. Um civilization games Yeah. aren't usually our bread and butter. 4X games, special especially. I would say this is kind of a 4X game. It does, I think it says it is. I don't care. Doesn't matter. It's a board game. It actually does matter. But
It is kind of a 4X game. I still really want to play this. One of the reasons was the designer. Yeah. Uh which is the same designer who did Age of Galaxy. Oh yeah, we loved it.
were big fans of. And so when we got the chance to play it, I was very happy. And I enjoyed it. I enjoyed it, too.
I had a lot of fun while I played it. It is long. You will attack people or get attacked. Yeah. I attacked many people.
Yes, you were on the offensive. I really enjoy like there is a I don't remember exactly how many rounds there are, but each round you're going to play six actions. And half of them are going to play new kind of inventions. So you have a hand of inventions you're going to when you play a card from the last round you're going to get a new card from next round. So you can kind of already plan. So you know like kind of what options you have which I really like. It's not like at the beginning of an era you're not going to get like as your cards, good luck. You know the pool of cards that you have from the from from before which is really nice. And the balance of when I played on down those cards both for passive effects and instant effects. And when I do the actions on the board, it's very interesting. I enjoyed all of that. But there is like it is a longer game which we usually like and we do like. It's a big box so it's like harder to it is easier to keep. Like Red North.
It is. It because it it fits so easily into somewhere. This needs like a big shelf space and we need to put take something else that is a big the same size. So for me, I really enjoyed it. If you are into kind of like Euro-ish civilization games, I highly recommend checking it out. But for me, it ends up not being a keeper. Oh yeah, for me, too. I I absolutely agree with everything you're saying, especially like keeping this Yeah. is harder as you said. And also I looked at it before we started filming just like, "Oh, I'd love to play Epochs again." Because it was really fun. But also when am I going to choose to play it? Yeah. That's basically the bottom line for me.
I also want to say that if you are like it's one of those games kind of like in what's Through the Ages where you if you declare war against somebody it's going to take a little while until you can attack them.
Yes.
If you don't want to be a warmonger but that's going to be like a negative thing as well. So, we have one more game on the pile. I'm going to put this actually out on the screen.
I'm going to yes.
There we go. It is
Through Ice and Snow.
Snow. It's another review copy. Are you ready? 1 2 3 boom. It's a double cow.
Yes.
This is a game about leading an expedition. Through Ice and Snow.
Yes. And you I would say this is a painfully thematic game.
Yes. You feel so like when you're starting off you feel hopeful and you're just like this is going great and then everything goes like it's so bad. And also there's no way to get any resources.
It's so hard.
oh you want to get that one resource.
Mechanically it is a worker placement game and you have different kinds of workers that can interact with different kinds of actions.
And also you're are like together moving this fleet of boats and then like the person who are choosing to be the start player or has like the most dynamite will be the one choosing where to go and how fast to go and that will influence all players decision making later but bottom line I I didn't have too much fun with it. It was a little long. Mhm. It the box is lying that it could take 45 minutes. I didn't see that.
wasn't that for players. We played four players and it ended up being I think 1 hour 45 minutes which is not like maybe 2 hours which is not more than like half an hour first time you're playing I don't think it's too bad. So, I I length could be that when you play it multiple times. I thought it was a little too long and also I thought well, I want to have fun when I play board games and I didn't well, in the beginning I had fun and then it just like was horrible. I liked it more when it ended up being pretty tight that we understood that this is where the game was going and it's as I said very thematic because you're going further and further into the ice and you have like there's no way to just like I'm going to go there and get 60 food that's not possible. You can of course use all of your rifles to kill a a polar bear but then you get that opportunity and you get some health but if you go and get all the food at the same time you don't get enough health because you need health all the time and I enjoyed it. Yeah.
Like I enjoyed very much like what it did but it's one of those as well where I was like I'm happy that you have played it not going to go back to it. Cool. So those are the games.
Yes. We kept three small games. Paddy is the only one that we like is and it's also small so we culled so many big games which is good because
know if I can fit a box anywhere. No, you can't
the side here. So what was your favorite and least favorite of this bunch? Okay, my favorite is probably on this side.
Yes, I think actually that Rocket Punch was my favorite because I I won it was super fun. That is usually fun for you. My favorite is Red North. Cool. What is your least favorite?
My least favorite I think I liked Ego the least. I think I'm going to go with Propolis for my least favorite. And that is the end. That's the end of this video. You watched it. You did it. Congratulations. You get a point and if you want to give us a point you can do that by clicking the subscribe button. Do it now. It's free and we will see you next time. Thank you so much for watching. I'm Johannes.
I'm Zohra. And you've been watching Board Gaming Ramblings and bye-bye.