How to Introduce the Board Game Hobby – Board Games & Coffee Ep. 4
Transcript
hello good morning good morning today I'm with a friend this is Jay hi so to give a little introduction to who Jay is I became a high school teacher uh when I moved to New York in 2008 and he was one of the first friends that I met 2007 we met in 2007 we've been friends for 14 year for we've been friends for 14 no that's wrong I said that wrong how many years has it been math 14 this is 14 all right wait are we both bad at math yes we're Math teachers together that's how we met cuz we can't add and subtract 24 - 7 is 17 17 outstanding um yeah I cut I cut my board game teeth with you that's right like starting with Scrabble and we uh we started with Scrabble actually you know what we're going to save it for this for today's topic okay because today's topic is how to introduce people to board games all right so to kick things off we're going to look at the oh no to kick things off we're going to start with a definition so I asked this question how do you introduce people to board games and I think it's important we Define those terms what what is it that we're introducing people to what do you think the board game hobby is what is it what is the board game hobby
like what what are we introducing people to when we introduce them to board games I mean I like I like the social aspect of board games that's the whole reason I was hanging out with you and Luke right like I wanted a space where we could sit around and do stuff like to fill in the conversation kind of almost like it was a way for us to communicate and bond and and and become new friends in this new city that was new to me to both of us um but in general I mean it's like finding out that you've got something new in common with somebody like hey we both like playing this oh I'm glad you're here today I love it I love it okay cool I'm so I mean it worked it did it's exactly right like yeah um I I might smile too much this is so cool all right so I I see it like I often talk about well I've talk about one thing all the time as board game Dad I'm always talking about introducing my kids to board games and in fact I did a video about how to introduce children to board games especially like how to scaffold the teaching of rules so if you are interested in that I will put a link to that video in the description after this stream is over but I also see two two elements one with we have a board game group here in okanawa and when people are arriving to the group one is like
how do I set them up to make connections in the group and have a good time in the group and that's a different set than introducing people to the Hobby so of three things introducing Kids introducing people to like an existing club or group and then introducing mostly friends to the Hobby the thing that you love that's what we're talking about today so I asked this question to oh my subscribers which is up there what aspects of the hobby game first hooked you so fascinated by the depth of strategy drawn by the social and competitive aspects transfixed by game's Aesthetics or cap captivated by the variety and creativity of game mechanics uh now most people said they were captivated by the variety and creativity of game mechanics oops take that down uh if you would like to respond you can also respond in the comments or in the live chat right now so going back to us oh we started off by playing Scrabble and then from there uh I I there were two games that I I can't remember which one I played first it was either Cosmic Encounter or k Cosmic was real early on yeah Cosmic was really early on on and Kanan was early on but they were in different settings for me Kanan was at my church and Kanan was with my friends and they
sort of overlapped but the real hook for me was actually uh Agricola because I got into the hobby because of depth of strategy playing agrica for the first time losing by like 15 or 20 points or well that would be abysmal in in agrica in agrica the scores are like 20 points so 14 17 yeah 14 three uh it set me up to wanting to play again all right I really liked there were a couple of quotes on here that were really cool so uh Jacob Ramirez he wrote more than just Roland move that just blew my mind and that I think really speaks to this variety captivated by the variety and creativity of game mechanics because that's true in the in the 90s the games that I had were either party games or they were they were like Monopoly and sorry and all that yeah yes I was going to say that um captivated by the variety and creativity of game mechanics is what kept me hooked I like I didn't go hang out with with um that circle of friends from grad school because you said hey check out these game mechanics it was was hey let's hang out and do the shared experience together right like um and then the mechanics like the int I did
not know that there was a world Beyond sorry and Monopoly and um you know playing Jin Ry and stuff like there's still a special place in my heart for that but I didn't know there was a new world until you sat me down you said hey check this out I remember distinctly thinking hold on a second if I played Cosmic and I've played Katan and I like a gria and there's more than that we had a common friend C David who had a closet full of games I couldn't even imagine a closet full of games he had like that amount and it was yeah had like and it was like whoa whoa uh let's go to oh the next question the next question question was boom uh what type of game do you think is best to introduce new players to the Hobby party games Cooperative games light strategy games or classic games like Monopoly Scrabble Etc Jay what do you think away with me um yeah do you need to look at that I was just looking at the uh options party I mean it's all nuanced right it's all it's all about like I imagine that the kinds of games that you would have brought me um that you would have brought to the table with me would have
been different from other people if it's a party setting and you bust out Monopoly it's going to you know bring the mood down but um you knew that I was into math you knew that I was into thinking logically and that I would like a strategy sort of situation um it's fun to see kittens explode but it's more fun like hey you'll like um you'll like the mechanics in this like check out give you gave me room because you knew me to explore like the logician side of me and that was that got me I have there is actually an awesome what you said reminds me of a great comment it's this one this is from from aravis hear oh I I shouldn't read YouTube handles I'm I'm at it I guess it depends if someone who wants to know what the hype is all about I think a light strategy would be good but if they just want to have a good time party games are the best option even with the lightest strategy games can turn into a hostage situation real quick if other people weren't ready for it
a hostage situ yes I mean even like yeah we've I cannot think of a game where I especially early on when I was learning all of these where I didn't feel like a hostage at some point like it's AG gria I'm 15 points behind you know it's 3 to 18 o i uh I'm at their board game club on kadina uh we've had a few people show up because they heard that it was a good time and they like total complete lack of experience and in those situations I I have seen the looks on the hostages faces they look so ter what did I walk into like it's it's pretty scary to be on the I've made that face yeah yeah it's it's kind of sad so this is why as I Was preparing for this video I decided I'm going to delete lineate between getting people into a game group and getting people into the hobby because if someone walks into the room and they're not ready like they needed access they needed an anchor uh there is a distinction to be made there yes yeah yes so I'm going to jump back to another response that someone gave into one of the polls I like this one though I think party games are mechanically not typical for board games therefore I prefer Cooperative games as intro they allow
deep mechanics but don't let newbies lose because of lack of experience yes here here and then this other one from chillionaire uh for a night where my wife and I invite a few couples over for drinks I'm going to be introducing a few new people to games I'm going to try to get a mix of very light strategy and party games in the same night because I'm working with a range of POS personalities I usually start with a few rounds of for sale then love letter or sushi go have you played these before yeah um Sushi go yeah we were going to play draftosaurus last night yeah let's do it and then uh wrap up the night with wavelength or code names or Dixit those are all party games depending on the current Vibe goal is to move fast games where side conversations won't drag out the game and everyone has a chance of winning if introducing one or two new people to games because they expressed interest in the hobby I'm leaning towards King Domino downforce pandemic Azo and summer camp first then I'm branching out from there with them based on how it goes my sister and I um when we were when when I'd met you and then I'd gone home to see my sister uh Barry we played um oh no where did it go it was um uh Cooperative game Island you got the the tiles and you're trying to rebuild a spaceship and the island is like sinking around you uh it's like there are three
of these yes those guys um that that was like one of our first like hey I want you to see this new thing that I've been working on in New York with you and it was a Cooperative game and it was like an opportunity for us to be equals I think that that was a really good point about like Cooperative games for people who you think have a reasonable chance at enjoying the hobby but they might be nervous because it's all new and novel give them a Cooperative game and um you know Usher them in we're all on the same side here you're going to love this with me that was very yeah very wow it was one of the first games we played that's really cool I really liked um I'm really finding identifying the games that I can play while talking at the same time so for us like mountain goats has been like that our CH Society has been like that but I'm also thinking about what the other comment was about um you know party games and mechanically not typical for board games so while I see the the fun in some of those accessible games if I'm trying to get them into the hobby I want something that like invit some in a little bit but I what I liked about that response was this idea of a sequence like first get their attention second get them hooked third okay now that you this is our third time let me show you something that I really like right
um yeah yeah I don't think I like I only had one lived experience but I know that I was at a party with um Rita and Rob and all those folks from from grad school and at the party early on that was my first exposure to Dixit we played like several rounds of Dixit in a party setting and I know that that was other people's first experience of the game and I remember having a great time and I didn't know what was going on that's that Dixit isn't normally like my way of expressing my creativity um it felt nice and safe and fun um and yeah I hadn't thought about that that was that was some people's first experience in like the new age of of games and I wonder what that was like for them yeah you know what was cool about di Dixit is it was also a gorgeous game like that made it real easy to like it was beautiful and it still is that was before components themselves were you know people were still playing with wooden cubes for sheep and and cows and everything but Dixit had like artwork it was just wow so what a pretty game how do you play this all those board games the generation of um cubes with friends cubes and cards with friends cubes and cards with friends all right all right so next one one more
poll here and then I'll share with you my recommendations for this sequence of games but I'm going to do that at the end all right back to polls screen all right so what's the ideal player count for introducing someone new to gaming and I'm going to go into straight into two comments that came from this so spqr K Leo depending on the game but I think three or four so there's more interaction but not so many that the new person feels like everyone else is barreling ahead of them or carrying them along and I'm going to put this alongside this one I'm in the 3 to four Camp depending on others what pending as others have said one thing we try to focus on is the number of teachers if two or three of us already know a game then introducing one or two new individuals we always make sure that there is one primary teacher especially for the initiative or rules overview the other people know that the games are there to help set up examples and provide some extra clarification if they think it'll help but I find it has itself to have one teacher's primary voice uh once we are into the game everyone can chip in if they see an opportunity to help but even if we find two people trying to explain a rule we defer to the primary te uh the primary teacher so what I liked about that those two well
actually you ever yeah I mean what I liked is especially that last one from chillionaire was how I feel like you've got your primary teacher um but when you have multiple people thinking of the same thing you're going to have multiple people thinking of multiple different examples and if I'm at a table with people who are trying to introduce me to the craft they probably know who I am what my personality is what appeals to me so if somebody's thinking about what they needed to hear when they were learning how to play their game it gives the it gives the opportunity for somebody else to go no no no wait um what you want to hear is this like the the possibility of augmenting um the instruction process when you've got multiple people instead of it just being oneon-one like then you just either they're getting it right or they're not like either they're explain like we've all been in that situation where uh General appeal where um you know somebody's just explaining the game to you and it is falling flat if you've got more people at the table if you're really concerned with bringing somebody into the fold and you have more people at the table you have a greater chance at mitigating that which I have seen it's been I've seen it enough where like that doesn't seem like it should be a concern at all in until it is um but in general yeah a one to two person setup would be great if you're really like if you're really familiar
with that person but otherwise more people somebody can be focused just naturally just like it's not a conscious thing like somebody could be focused on I'm the explainer I will be doing the explaining and then somebody else has the role of just doing a temperature check like hey he's getting tired here like oh that's not really important those rules like that's big game end of you know that's big scoring end of game stuff we'll get there when we get there I you I'm distracted by the fact that we are now talking about instruction and as teachers this is what we nerd out about most like how how far down this Rabbit Hole can we do go about in terms of effective instruction this is this is a this is definitely kind of getting meta there yeah at our grad school we met learning how to be teachers yes yes that was um what did I write oh yeah I I do think that there is something about starting with a big group and going small from there because there are some party games like even though I recognize the validity of that comment part of the games don't capture the the nature of the hobby as well as light strategy games do um there are some party games that are more strategic than others and with games like that you can
still get that strategy in there but with more people I think you you ignite that social Dynamic yeah get people excited not because they're playing games cuz the games they don't know how to do but they do know how to connect with people so connect with as many people as possible wow I'm having a really fun time and I'm doing something that I'm not confident with and then break out we did this last week like we him and I did this last week because we had eight people 10 people eventually but we started with eight we did De crypto two teams of four then we split up into um two more people showed up so then we had 10 and we split up into two tables of five and at that night there were three brand new people um and I think that works even when you know you're not at a a a group night but like just within your family um and I like that idea of stages but big to small but not so small that it's only one-on-one instruction all right uh now at this point if you have questions that you want to get ready ready you can go ahead and write them in the live chat I will share some of my recommendations for those two stages from Big to small and party to strategy I don't know if you've got any like you could think of yours if if you can but um all right so I wrote down decrypto that's what we played last night that one plays up to
eight at least it's recommended Avalon plays up to 10 um was that what they were playing at the other end when we were doing Cosmic they were playing um the resistance um it was it was those yeah it was it was a related game um the crew that plays up to five that's what we played yep uh trap Words which have you played trap wordss trap words is a is a really nice one it's a it's a word guessing game like taboo but it still has this like strategic Dynamic to it um I don't know if I've done a review for that but maybe I will anyway um you know I I would say like our chaos Society has a really nice addictive nature to it which is a good hook it does yes my six-year-old wanted to play it behind your back after you introduced it to him yeah it yeah it's true it it has good appeal um if you're not familiar with ar Society it's the retheming of ethnos and then um I got two other games that are that are like social but very strategic so obviously Cosmic Encounter then the other one is Imperial have we played Imperial together I have not played it with you know okay all right Imperial is one of my favorite games because it involves a lot of negotiation and it's a heavier strategy game but then go to the next step so almost there's so many good games these days but one thing that I identified that new people are very comfortable with is cards they like
physically holding them holding like what are the rules of this game the rules of this game are in my hand I can do these things I have three cards I have three things I can do which of the three like it out I can read them whenever I'm looking I like yeah yeah and it also has this like element of strategic like these are my secret things no one knows what they are but like I get this game because my three cards are my four cards whatever they tell me what to do and almost all of my games that I've recommended are card games so for example Concordia like awesome not only because it's a card game but because you're adding cards to your deck and it or to your hand it's getting bigger and bigger Ark Nova is another one where you've got five cards the five cards spell out the rules for you and at every turn in arar noova gets your cards get stronger and then when you use them they get weaker so you've got always got like this bias towards whatever the strongest card is um brass which is also a very popular game within the hobby brass uh Birmingham so that's a that's got cards revive amazing game and uh Roco I'm not going to go into the other ones they're a little bit more complicated but but awesome the only one that's not a card game on my list is the White Castle which we played last night yes and that's dice worker placement but there's I mean essentially you've got about three main important things so very limited focus and yet so much unfolds
from that there was a lot of you do this and then this causes this and then this causes that and then that causes that and along the way you can choose it it kind of felt like um in a really weird abstract way like we were playing Plinko but I had like the ability like as it was falling through the options like I could nudge it one way or the other that's a good yeah not cards though but it was fun it was it wasn't it wasn't that heavy it was light it was nice medium medium medium do you have any other recommendations for card games no for introduction games um I really liked pandemic and I don't I mean I just wanted to go back to that I've introduced pandemic to people as a Cooperative game in a social setting it was also like I mean it was it was pandemic it was appropri it was thematically appropriate like my mom that was the first game that we played and it was during pandemic times like my mom was brought up playing uh back gamon and you know classic stuff so I was like you will like this new kind of game and uh that's cool we this is this is like a weird I don't even know if what I'm about to say is outdated but there were games during the pandemic that became um my friends and I during the pandemic were looking for games that we could play remotely and we made Katan work where we all set up I there was a
lot of front loading beforehand we set up a deck a certain way and then we shuffled it a certain way and we all agreed on the rules of like so we all had the same decks and the all everything and I think that that some consideration can be given to a kind of game that could work through Zoom which is like its own like weird little category like I don't I don't know um what kinds of games would work I haven't really thought that much like what are good examples of games that would work through um like remote video I I think the the principle of accessibility like here's a game that we can play in so many different ways that that hooks we did a lot of Gam online with with pandemic as well uh carcassone would be another one cuz that that one's just you know tile placement and it's friendly I introduced Lauren to um takenoko that was her that was one of her first games and she just the theme brought her in and kept her wanting to keep playing it yeah you know it's interesting we didn't really talk about theme today but it is a very powerful tool all right so at this time I am going to look at the questions in the live chat and if anyone is working on those questions I do have one that's loaded and ready to go so the question is what about simultaneous gameplay games that
have everyone doing something at the same time roll and rights for an example do you have any examples of games with simultaneous gameplay you mean like other than Cosmic where you have to find out like did two people act in good faith and they're negotiating or is somebody attacking somebody else like no like everyone's doing their main action at the same time why am I struggling here have you played a rle in right before no really a Rolland right yeah no oh we got to try that genre out okay so a roll I think a rolling right is worth experiencing sure personally I have some games with simultaneous game that I love I've done a whole video about my favorite games with simultaneous gameplay the nice thing about them is that they keep the games moving like there's no downtime it's always your turn but you're doing things to interact with people at the same time um oo speaking of simultaneous gameplay I want to show you Daybreak because Daybreak is pandemic with everyone taking their turn at the same time that sounds a little Calvin ball is I mean like like it's a it's and you're not fighting a disease you're preventing global warming it's by in part Matt Leo the same designer like it's it's worth trying anyway to the question simultaneous gameplay the advantage there is that when you're playing games with simultaneous turns uh keep there's no downtime it can be extremely engaging the problem I've
always had and why actually often avoid them is because uh it's very hard to monitor if everyone is playing by the rules oh yeah if everyone's getting the help they need with people who have more experience they are more equipped to like oh these are the rules yeah I can play that but if someone's like a little uncomfortable it can be a little bit more uh difficult for them to get that play successfully they need that help of being able to watch somebody else's example my friends Bridget and Jeff introduced me to a game whose name I don't remember so if you remember it get in the comments uh the idea of all right so it's like a maze it takes place in a mall and it's it's modular so you put down like little chunks of them all um there are everyone gets to sign like a piece a color and everyone gets one roll like you have to take this piece in the mall and you have to move it around the mall to complete objectives but there there are multiple pieces they all have to do their objectives you are limited uh to only being allowed to move the piece north or south or east or west like you can only move pieces North I can only move pieces East the mall is set up kind of like a labyrinth and we need this piece to get over there so if you can only move the piece North you can drag it all the way to a wall but then somebody has to move the piece East to get around the wall to keep going up the hallway or something so everyone at
all times is looking at this map and you just have to remember okay I can only move this way and there's uh it's a silent game which is also an added level of complexity you can't just say like Ben that piece move it um oh my goodness it's called Magic maze is it called Magic maze I don't know I haven't heard magic maze but but I feel like that's it isn't that piece that has like the do something yeah the do something now piece just such a great mechanic like that but there's an actual piece for that is that called Magic maze so we I can't remember I haven't played it yet uh i' I've looked up the rules and stuff but I I maybe that's it you know what if if people are watching now they'll know we have people watching but oh man not the most active chat we've ever seen no one knows no one knows I'm not blaming my audience they're um they're like they're like my uh Lifeline you know what I mean yeah they help me before I forget designer names I stare at the camera I look like an idiot for like 3 seconds and then someone drops the name and it's awesome it's bacon um uh yeah maybe it was magic maze I feel so bad um Bridget and Jeff are in a time zone where they are asleep they are asleep right now no no no no it's it's evening should be like 5:00 p.m. right are they in a different time zone they're traveling Oh okay um yeah that was that was the thing that was frustrating about me was or about that to me was it was a new experience
for me and it was a confusing game and I just had there was a lot of stuff to watch and we're like 2/3 the way through and it turns out that somebody else at the table didn't understand what they were and weren't allowed to do and so while we were all playing simultaneously someone was kind of I don't know how to put this in a polite way but like the victory was kind of asterisked right like it was robbed and I was like I just put in so much like mental effort and and and strain to like make sure I was doing it right and pulling my weight and we get all the way here and it turns out that we maybe shouldn't even have gotten to this game State because you were just you know moving pieces around like you shouldn't have been and it kind of cheapened the victory in that like little thing like oh do we have to start over like okay I guess this was another good practice round even though it took 40 minutes actually I don't think magic I'm calling it magic maze without yeah knowing what else to call it but like a situation like that where you get all the way to the end and you go oh that did that that didn't even count that I mean it was a fun experience with people right like that was a fun experience the game yeah it was magic maze okay all right there we go that's it resolved all right um like if the point of the oh I feel torn because I don't I have never played a one player tabletop like as a one player I've never
done that that's a horrible way to introduce people to games it is here's your have fun here's your box bye but like as someone who likes playing board games like like going on a campaign mode I've never actually sat down and done it but um so to me like clearly that's evidence that part of the reason that I like playing board games is for the social aspect of it so who cares if the victory was cheapened because somebody was over there just being weird yeah but on the other hand I'm like oh we were building something I don't know I really even now and this happened months ago even now I'm still thinking about it like it's so silly but like we had fun the table had fun we all laughed the um The Scofflaw if you are if you are in the game the game hobby if you're in this hobby then caring about rules and doing it right is part of how you begin to think yeah you to adopt that thinking and so yeah it makes sense that you're like oh man I had so much fun but the fact that we played it wrong still bothers me like that like congratulations you are now a gamer you did it you have been effectively introduced to games yeah it was it was it was fun with my friends at the table it was a good time and because it was fun and and we like there was some light ribbing but we kept going uh we played that game again we played other games afterwards no one became sour right like and that's the
whole thing like keep it keep it keep it light keep it moving it ended up like you just kind of say Okay that was a practice round reset to zero yeah all right uh we will end on that today thank you again for watching