Introducing Expansion Month - TCbH Podcast
Transcript
Hello and welcome to the Cardboard Herald podcast. I am Eric joined this week by my two dynamic duo of co-hosts Jack and Christina. Hey guys. Hello. Welcome in. It's been a little bit since we've had a podcast, but we felt this was a great occasion to do so because we're going to be doing an expansion month this month, which is April 2026, depending on when you're watching this video, I hope. With the Gregorian calendar, it is April 2026.
Uh so yeah, we wanted to kind of talk about what this month is going to look like for the channel, what you can expect to see. Uh also just kind of start off the month by giving our uh how we approach expansions. We've done a podcast episode on expansions, but that was a little bit more uh mechanical level versus uh vibe-space, which is I think a good point to start with. Um so yeah, this month we're doing expansion month. Jack, do you want to talk about what we have coming up on the pipeline for expansion month? Yeah, so this was a project that was kind of born out of convenience in that we had a bunch of expansions to review, and then it was like, well, why not just dive into kind of the goods, bads, and uglies of expansions, and that kind of snowballed as I'm sure Christina and Eric are now used to, like, I get kind of a hairbrained idea, and then I just kind of lean in without really thinking about the consequences, the amount of work involved, and the I guess bystanders who are impacted by that. Um and so with expansion month, we now have several reviews that we're going to be doing covering expansions of all different types and kind of diving a little bit
deeper into what those types of expansions are. And then we also have a lot of really great interviews that we've scheduled with various publishers and designers, as well as retailers to talk about kind of the weird nature of board games as it is right now with the expectation that there's continued streams of content coming out for your favorite games. Um and then other top 10s, discussion podcasts, I don't know, just kind of whatever we feel, but we already have a lot already done in the works, and some of those half-brained ideas that might come about. Yeah? Yeah. Yeah.
And Christina's here. You may have seen Christina on the channel certainly in B-roll over the years, but she's done some top 10 stuff with us, and then she comes to conventions largely she's behind the scenes, but you are covering at least one expansion, right? Yeah, I'm going to do Wingspan Americas for you. Yes. Yeah, so she's going to take over guest work on Wingspan, which Christina loves birds and Wingspan, and then that made sense. And also she's one of the people that I most often inflict expansions upon, where, you know, like I It's not an injury that I
I know, I know, but like sometimes you're like, oh man, we should play Wingspan, and I'm like, yeah, that sounds great, but I have this whole other expansion for this game that we haven't touched in 2 years that I got to review an expansion for, and let's go ahead and get that to the table instead of the game that you really want to play. And she is like, okay, yeah, I'm game. So she has a lot of insight on expansions in team Cardboard Herald. Um how about you, Eric? Like what sorts of stuff have you been working on for this? Yeah, so I have interviewed two board game designers so far who are both, I mean, you'll see as they come out this month. Uh Both of them are have quite a bit expansion experience.
We have another interview with the designer coming up that I'll be doing shortly. Um But yeah, interviews with designers uh do you have any questions?
shout-out here? I mean, we have a bunch of big names, but like Eric interviewed Cole Wehrle, Donald X. Vaccarino, the designer of a million expansions known as Dominion, you know, like
17. Only 17.
Just for Just for Dominion, then there's Kingdom Builder and all of his other games, but those two alone make up like 30% of all the expansion like materials on the planet right now. So uh yeah, yeah. It's It was a lot of fun talking to both of them. We're also going to be talking to Justin Gary of Ascension uh and other games, but Ascension being the one that is as as I feel like Jack knows is my wife's favorite board game or the game she's played the most at least, where she is uh Yeah, we've We've played a lot of Ascension, so we have a lot of experience with those expansions, so I think it's be really fun to talk to him about that. Um yeah, so we have those. I have a few different games that I am going to be getting to the uh review section of my life soon, which means I'll just be playing them a lot.
Um we have Four Shuffle and uh Furnace are going to be the two games that I for sure I'm doing. And then a couple other games that might might pop up here and there. Um So yeah, I think that it's going to be a fun month for kind of revisiting some older games, and one of the reasons why I like expansions so much and why I do like where they are in the board game space right now is because of how much it feels like I am able to revisit old games and discover new things. Hm. Um You know, his Four Shuffle expansions are not in German, so they're like at least 15% not as cool as ours.
up the language skills in addition to playing He has to play with bats, not fledermaus. So I'm so sorry that I'm What about Schmugler Hole though?
No Schmugler Holes. I'm so sorry that I'm not doing my Duolingo as part of my board game playing. The bird is disappointed.
So sorry. Uh Well, you mentioned that it gives you a reason to look back at games. When when we talk about expansions in general, like, what's your vibe? Like, do you look forward to expandable content? Is it something that you're kind of hesitant towards? Or Or either of you guys, is it something that you know, you're always excited about? Yeah, I think for me there are some games that I just know right away an expansion would do a lot for. So Mhm. Like [clears throat] just as part of the conversation with Donald X. Uh Dominion is a game where the base game is really solid, but just adding one or two expansions really heightens the game to a lot higher highs than it could be. So I think there are a lot of games where I can see where an expansion would really help make the game feel a bit beefier or make the game feel a little bit more complete. Uh even small things, like uh I played Cascadia today, and I I at PAX had gotten like this little small thing that is just new scoring goals for the animals, and uh playing with some like a couple of those tonight was really refreshing because, you know, I had seen all the other scoring ways so much.
So even just like one extra scoring option for each animal made it feel a lot fresher. Yeah. I would say I'm not I wouldn't say I look forward to expansion content, but I'm usually happy when it's announced for a game that's in my collection. How about you? What's What's the the gut instinct what it's like a new expansion came out, and it's a game you like, but just your your immediate reaction. If it's a game I really like, I'm excited cuz I I get excited when there's more of something that I love. There are some games, like Eric said, where I'm like, this could do with another scoring or another option to help me navigate my strategy.
And I don't want to give too much away, but I kind of get into that when I'm reviewing Wingspan in the Americas is I think like there's this this want for more, but when more feels like a chore and not an addition to the game, then I'm less excited by my expansion experience.
Right. Right.
sometimes is hard to know like, was that good until I've gotten several plays in and can really see how that's manipulating my own strategy as well as my opponent's strategies. So Several plays before reviewing a game? Wrong biz. Get out of board game content. No, uh Um you know, you know,
[clears throat]
Do you I mean, I guess do To throw it back to you, like, do you have similar feelings? Are you excited for an expansion? Well, I mean, you've known me literally since I was a child. Like we we were in high school when we met. We started dating right afterwards. And it plays into my worst like basement dweller comic book nerd instincts, which I say lovingly and proudly, but there's a part of me that's a completionist and a collector. And I know those are the instincts that are being preyed upon with mediocrity. You know, like this is an expansion where we know that there's going to be some of you SOBs out there who are going to buy it whether or not it's good because if it exists, you need to have it in that box.
I think doing the cardboard herald for a decade now has tempered my resolve. So, I now don't need every single expansion. I don't need every single upgrade, those kinds of things. Um but there still is this like oh boy, here we go again. You know, Dune Imperium is releasing an expansion. It might make the game actually worse, but I kind of need to check it out. I need to know. Do you think that is a Venn diagram though because as somebody who has known you this long, a Venn diagram of the things you love that aren't board games when they're brought into a board game sphere, it becomes even more of a completionist. Like, oh my god, I love Dune so much that I get more Dune if I have this expansion. For good or bad? Yeah, I mean, that's that's that's part of it. Like, I can't imagine a spirit for Spirit Island that would be so bad that I would not want to own it. You know what I mean? You know, like if in content where there is a lot of enjoyment that comes out of the like variety in which you intersect with the game.
Then I'm always going to love it. And it does make me feel like I'm getting more out of it. But I'm also really cognizant of anytime that the weight, both the literal and metaphorical weight of the game is getting so much that it impedes the usability of the game. You know, like there there are games on the shelf where I know the core game through and through. However, because I know there are like three expansions layered on top of that game in that box that it actually makes me hesitate to take out that game because it's like, God, you know, like do I have to unsort some things? Do I have to relearn some things? Is there nuance for different player counts and all this kind of stuff? They they greatly complicate the game and then complicate the experience of playing the game. So, like yes, I want more expansions because it's going to give me more of the toys that I love playing with, which board games are toys. Um great toys. Uh but at the same time, I I know that they can undermine the aspect of actually playing them.
Yeah, I I think that there are times where board games just get so a a game gets so inundated with so many expansions that one there's no way you're coherently getting everything to the table. So, you have to pick and choose which expansions you want to play with. Right. And then there are also ones where it feels like nothing nothing of note or value is actually getting added to the game other than just more rules. And those are definitely, I mean, I think that big swings of like we're going to make changes to the fundamental rules in this expansion sometimes hit great. But then also occasionally it is it is just, oh, this is more rules for as much if not less fun.
Um yeah, case in point, we were having dinner moments before this and I was talking about how over dinner with our son, I was like, hey, um I need to get some more footage of King of Tokyo. So, like, can we play that later? And our son was like, do we have to play with that new expansion? I was like, no. Actually, I I kind of need footage without that expansion because I don't have a lot in the the B-roll library. And he was like, oh, thank goodness. Um
so, there there are some stinkers as part of expansion month that we're covering too. And I think that's one of the cool things about this project is by codifying it as, you know, like an effort to meditate on the nature of expansions. Um I think we're taking a critical eye to both our reviews and also those interviews. Like, uh one of the folks I interviewed was Jamie Stegmaier to talk about like the nature of publishing expansions. And while I wouldn't say that it ever gets like antagonistic, there there are definitely moments where I'm asking him questions about like, why would you do this? Why didn't you do this? You know, like, what are the significant challenges do you think that an expansion can ever, you know, dilute a game?
Talking about the the lack of factions in the original Scythe, but then hinting towards future expansions. Was that a mistake? You know, like and kind of reflecting on the past. Um and I know that you did some of that as well with the designers kind of talking about not just the promotion of the work that they do, but talking with them as gamers, as people who have looked back at their work over the years. Have they made mistakes or are there things that they've contributed to that they would have done differently now with hindsight? Which I think is really cool about this project in general. Yeah, and I mean, I think that giving ourselves a constraint to just like really focus on expansions because expansions are, I mean, with with all of the people we're talking to and all of the, I mean, I mentioned here the conversation you have with the retailers of you know, expansions take up a lot of space in this hobby, but especially in like the review space, I feel like they are much under appreciated and under represented where expansions are, you know, wildly popular for a lot of games.
And a lot of expansions are not given the same treatment that a base game is given. And I think that makes sense with just, you know, how the analytics treat expansion content. And also, you obviously people aren't probably going to be watching a review for an expansion for base game they don't own. Some people are. Some people just Some people are going to do it. Eric, Jack, and Christina, you know, they're just going to show up for it. But I think that with with the review space being what it is and the fact that you are like discouraged from taking a look at expansions in the way that we would be doing it. I think the constraint is going to be fun to like help push some content out there in the world about expansions and kind of just, you know, looking at them with more of a more of a reviewer eye than we normally would. Right. Right.
Um I think we may be seeing some additional stuff. Like I said, beyond what we've already planned. Um there there are some other board game content creator types who have reached out regarding this project because we've been talking about it on socials and that kind of stuff. And you know, some folks have been like, oh, I might I might be able to to join in on some of that. Um and I'm already thinking about like, man, is April just expansion month from now on? You know, like is this going to be expansion month 2027 next year? You know, like are we going to have an even bigger, [clears throat] better thing? Um we we have a lot of things that could come out of this. I don't know that it's going to be necessarily like the um biggest like content delivery that we have as far as like numbers or anything, but I do feel like this is a really interesting cohesive way of looking at something like you said that's kind of under explored in the hobby, both in the micro, individual games, but macro, the the general discussion. Like, I'm looking forward to wrapping up expansion month and the three of us just kind of like talking about like highlights and lowlights and, you know, did it change any of our views and that kind of stuff.
Yeah, absolutely. And I think I'm excited for this project. I think that we're we're going to have a fun time with it. I also think that it gave us a really great chance to talk with people about it. I think on top of board game reviewers not really discussing it, I feel like board game designers don't typically get interviewed for the purpose of talking about their their approach to just expansions. Uh so, yeah, I think that it'll be fun. It'll be really fun time.
[cough]
Not to uh distract us from uh or I guess not to take away from the content that uh we'll eventually have with some like top 10s or any of that kind of stuff, but do you guys have any gut instincts for expansions that are favorites of yours that you uh like that come to mind as maybe it's the best or it's the most notable or something that like really stuck with you as oh, you can expand board games now, you know, something that kind of opened your eyes to what this could be? For this month like specifically no, but I think probably in like the long vernacular playing games, Lords of Waterdeep when um Skullport was added was this like oh, you took a base favorite game of mine and added this competitive piece that I simultaneously want to engage with and also very much do not want to end up the most corrupted player. And so, it was that first kind of where I'm both interacting with the game and my opponents in a not so much a push your luck kind of way, but almost goading my opponent of like you need more because I already have four and you should have five and that keeps the score even.
Um which is kind of like a you know, the way back machine because after so many years like past Lords of Waterdeep and games have grown so much, but I think that's the first time where I looked at a game and could see the potential to adding just a little bit more to that that isn't necessarily like here's a new rule book, just here's a new way to interact with this. Which is kind of crazy that that was such a successful expansion and I think Lords of Waterdeep was a very successful game, but it's Wizards of the Coast and Hasbro and so, I don't think that it's as successful as say Dungeons and Dragons and Magic the Gathering or My Little Pony [clears throat] or any of the other properties that they own under their belt and so, you know, like they didn't go back and explore, but you know, like talk about a game where so many nerds in the board game space would pick up every single expansion had they come out with more. Like dual classing units in Lords of Waterdeep, why did we never get that? Why did I not get a month?
like man, you could have added now you could add My Little Ponies to it. I mean Yeah, exactly. I thought they did. Hasbro has so many so many licenses under it it's felt it's bananas. How about you, Eric? Uh I mean immediately coming to mind is Prelude I I just as one of the best. I think one of the just one of one of the expansions though that got me like when I was first getting into board games and was like I didn't realize that like I loved Spirit Island so much and then to be introduced to like oh, there I already thought this game was like as good as it can be and then getting Jagged Earth and it's like oh, the challenges like getting it better, different adversaries, uh and obviously just throwing in more more spirits and more complex spirits gives you so much more to play with and I think that uh yeah, I I have puppets to make. So many
More puppets to make. Yeah. Yeah. Um you know, uh with uh Spirit Island, I feel like one or the both of you are going to like make [snorts] a custom design for the worst possible spirit in Spirit Island to be like if I were to make one Excuse me. If I were to make one that Jack uh would not own an expansion on account of this crappy spirit. This is the one.
it. Yeah, we'll go head to head. At the end of design at the end of expansion month, we'll both share our our spirit design that is the worst spirit to ever exist.
Must be turned in on 8 and 1/2 by 11 hand drawn. Uh it's got to be perfect. It must be turned in on four different index cards taped together.
Um text front and back. Uh you got to get ready for the test. Cool. Well, anything else to uh to discuss in uh Prelude and Preempt for our expansion month? Um I don't think I have anything on my end. I mean, I guess with this uh if there's anything that our audience or our listeners want to hear uh feel free to send it our way. I mean, you can find us here on YouTube uh or uh cardboardherald@gmail.com uh whatever you want to get in touch with us, just let us know cuz I think that there is time for us to make some more uh make some more videos if there is like a a piece of content that you would like to see or if you want to have any discussions with uh or if you wanted to see any specific discussions on what expansions can be or what they can do.
Uh I think that we would love to hear from y'all and you know, what are your favorite expansions? Probably. Mhm, nah, I don't want to hear about anyone else's. Only the people on this call. If you were here. Now, uh I think that's definitely something that we want to know about what everyone's favorite expansions are and also, you know, like if you've had bad experiences, you know, like that's important too, you know, like I I want this to be as useful of a tool as people can have in thinking about their own purchasing habits, you know, like in their own design habits, you know, like I'm hopeful with us talking with uh very experienced publishers and designers that they can think about how they want to uh work on their own games and you know, like how they would like to see um the future of their games as well.
Yeah. Uh yeah, I think I'm looking forward to it. I think it's going to be really fun month for for the Cardboard Herald and hopefully for our audience. Uh just to see what we got coming down the pipeline. I know it's going to be great for the audience. That's the confidence we need. She knows it's going to be great. The Cardboard Herald
not not Seal of Approval, that's a different channel. Um the Cardboard Herald guarantee. Yeah, the the cardboard cutout uh something. We'll we'll give a
Yeah, we're definitely going to workshop it. Cool. Great. Well, thank you to everybody for tuning in to this introduction video and uh we hope to see you at the end of the month. Later, guys. Bye.