Episode 92 - Is Theme Essential In Board Games?
Transcript
you're listening to the broken meeple show a podcast that speaks passionately about board games for the benefit of those who play them my name's Luke Hector best known for the broken meeple YouTube channel and I'm an everyday gamer just like you and I'll be talking about reviews top 10 and just about anything that connects me to board games as long as I have a tea or coffee in hand that is so grab a cup relax and enjoy and remember it's only a game hi folks welcome to another broken meeple episode the 28th of April 2024 this is episode 92 I believe we're slowly creeping towards the 100 Mark I wonder what I'm going to do for the 100 episode I have no idea I'm not usually a massive fan of these whole like it's our 50th episode it's our 100th episode Bonanza special thing I don't know but maybe I'll think of something to do around there but uh you would' have to decide or maybe you can give me some ideas on that front so yeah generally things are fine I mean work is tedious and mediocre as it typically always is but uh you know Soldier on everything you know you got to get a pay check from somewhere in order to make sure this happens uh but healthwise generally fine no acid reflux issues um you know the pills do their job the lack of caffeine does their job although I did have a caffeinated coffee yesterday that's the first one I have had since November you know since then I have been on decaf all the time along with herble te's but yesterday I just felt too tired I was in
a game of a gmany and I had to teach the game as well more than that in a minute um and it was you know I kind of just needed that little pickme up but it was one one you know travel cup full of coffee that was it and then I didn't have any more for the rest of the day and it didn't really affect me that much you know in terms of like you know acid reflux or anything so I think that I think my body has now got to the stage where it's like it can handle some of the stuff that was causing the reflux before providing I just don't indulge on it and to be honest coffee was the thing I indulged on the most I still drink a lot of coffee but it's always decaf or at least 99 now 99.9% now decaf but it you know I used to have like five six cups of coffee a day at work I mean it could be I don't think it was over more it could be less but you know that was a daily thing I would drink it throughout the day and it would be full on caffeine and so I think that was the biggest thing that contributed to the acid reflux issues so the fact that now that that has been curbed and moderated along with stuff like drinking plant-based milk and not having Tomatoes as often as normal uh not having citrus stuff as often as I used to you know just curbing those sort of things I think it's doing a decent enough job and I do eat a lot of things like bananas and almonds and you know other little foods and like yogurt you know stuff that's actually designed to soothe acid reflux so yeah I think it's combating it pretty well and at least it's made my throat a bit better I mean I still can't I I think it's kind of a permanent thing that I can only talk for so long before my throat dries out
that's just normal hence I always have a you know a tea or you know a drink or something at hand mint tea today but I I think that's just a permanent thing but at least it's not like scorched Earth you know I think I'm getting a lot better on that front so yeah it's just nice that that is progressing the way it is other than that uh you know wrists not too bad a little bit of a repetitive strain from you know typing on keyboards and stuff like that for work but that seems to be slowly but surely healing um it manifests a lot more the top muscles of your hand I think they're called the flexor muscles or something you know you you feel them when you you know put your if you put your palm down on the table and then try and lift each finger like one by one those muscles that you feel in the back of your hand that's kind of I think what's a problem with my left left hand at the moment but you know it is healing I'm seeing physio so that should that will mitigate in time it's just it takes a good few months for wrist injuries and like you know muscular injuries to heal properly it's just you know not just the fact of getting past 40 years old which I've you know had that been there done that and you know Moving on but also I think just uh the older you get the more your body just wants to give out uh so gaming wise what have we got well you know the channel itself not too bad although you know 23234 so it's climbing but lately not a lot of content I admit there just hasn't been a huge amount to do and I've been quite busy I've had like handy con recently uh which I thought I was actually going to do this podcast on hand con but uh guess not I mean like I
say I talk about it a lot anyway so I don't think there was much else to say other than I had fun it was good saw lots of nice people some people said hi uh very kind uh gentleman gave me a copy of nette um after buying one of my games because he listened to the podcast so John thank you very much for that I am so so grateful that he's going to sit on my shelf for some time uh but yeah it was a good conventional route um but yeah video wise there just hasn't mean much I mean I still have to do the Moonraker videos so that's you know I've played the game enough to do the reviews I just need to now actually record and edit them um the patrons have voted on top 10 um design issues or was it I forget what I called it but basically irritating design choices you know so to sort of put it in another way it's like top 10 top 10 things I wish designers would stop doing in games you know so they voted on that list so that will be the next top 10 that I look at as well but then I also do have some uh other games that I need to look at soon I mean the uh main one to look at is canvas uh canvas uh is a very light game looks very pretty I know very little about how it plays I know it's super light I'm fine with a light game but I've always never had the chance to play it not many people I know own it and every time it's been offered I've always been doing something else so I've now thanks to Kender you know so you know Kender games who sponsors the channel they have sent me canvas along with Reflections and whatever the second expansion is I
forget what it's called uh what's it called let's say canvas finishing touches yeah so Reflections and finishing touches and normal canvas so I've got the entire game series to review so that's probably going to have to be similar to Moon Breakers where I do a kind of like a review of the base game and then a review of a beyond the base game review of the expansions that will take a little bit of time CU I still got to do the moon rakers one but I think that's my focus for the next few like few weeks you know for for at least the first bit of May I need to do the Moonraker videos I need to do the canvas videos and I need to do that top 10 I think that is priority right now although I was supposed to be getting the prototype for Earth um abundance you know the expansion uh so that's been going pretty strong on Kickstarter and of course I'm definitely interested in uh you know grabbing that but the problem was was that I was supposed to get a prototype copy to do a review for uh before you know the kickstarter aired or before at least it finished but you know I chased them up and apparently it had been shipped but still in transit like it's kind of lost to the a of time so I'm hoping um oh actually no I think it was something that they didn't ship it I think that I think I was told it shipped but then they didn't ship it and you know for various reasons because I said that I was busy on my 40th birthday holiday and stuff and I think they were going to ship it after but they forgot to so I think it's going to be one of those things where where I'm not going to be able to tell you my thoughts on the expansion before the kickstarter
finishes I just don't think there'll be enough time by the time it arrives I mean it's the 28th of April and it still hasn't it's still not in my house but I guarantee you when it does I will give my thoughts on it you know I will give honest thoughts on the expansion because I've got people who are literally tearing my shirt off in order to get this played like they want me to tell them what this is like and they want to be involved in the play so yeah getting this one giving this one the beans is not going to take very long at all I mean solo and multiplayer people will rush to my game to play this so I will give my thoughts just you might have to accept the kickstarter might have ended by the time it does that's just the way it is I mean it's a shame I would have liked to have got it earlier but can't always help it yeah that's just the way it is so what else I forgot to mention on the channel front where's my ah I've lost the page where's it going page come back here we go so we've got what content did have so I've done a small review on the niku dice which was a trick- taking dice game that I absolutely adore I mean I gave this you know spoiler alert I gave it a 10 out of 10 this is a probably the best trick-taking game I've ever played and you can check out that video to know why I'm actually kind of surprised it's doing as well as it is 2,300 views I mean it's been a while it's been since it's been over 10 days but I was expecting nobody to really give a monkeys about this game but apparently people did so I'm kind of surprised by that especially as fractured sky from Ivy Studios which I reviewed shortly
after um is only on 2,000 views and that's since April 23rd I mean you know I was expecting that one to get more of a following than the other game but the thing that makes me a little bit sad is that I know I'm a bit late to this party but I finally finished pandemic Legacy season zero with a group of friends we have finally done it it is over I can now move on from everything that is to do with pandemic Legacy and I have my thoughts on what Zero season zero is like compared to season 1 and two and I've done a spoiler and a non-spoiler overview video of my thoughts neither of which has managed to even top a thousand views in fact one of them isn't the spoiler thoughts aren't even aren't even topping 500 that's pretty poor I mean and there are some people that dislike the videos as well I mean you know again and I say I don't get too fussed about the dislikes but still it's like what's there to dislike but yeah those two I was hoping would be a bit more popular because I know they're a bit more rushed than other videos I've done like they don't have a lot of video clips in them they don't have the full editing like a normal review it was basically a quick review it was just like look I've played it I just want to give my thoughts and move on to stuff that I need to get going because you know this is quite late to the party but yeah if you can check out the pandemic Legacy season uh zero videos that would be appreciated but yeah I'm kind of surprised that not a lot of people are I mean maybe just because everyone's played it to death so there's not much to review uh but yeah I would have thought pandemic Legacy season zero would have been a much more popular game and me certainly compared to something like the kosu dice uh maybe
it's one of those Flash in a pan effects you know you I mean this is the way of the board game industry a game that is popular at the time it comes out has a very short halflife and for the most part by the time it's a year later will just be quickly forgotten like nobody will give a monkeys about it anymore and with Legacy games that's kind of a big deal I mean you know Ticket to Ride Legacy everybody was going on about that uh first you like oh yeah this is going to be fantastic I gave it a below average rating I was really disappointed by ticket toide Legacy but even when you've got some people who love it to death is anybody talking about it right now I've not seen photos on social media nobody's really done any extra reviews of it it just seems to have faded out of everybody's Consciousness that came out at Essen last year it's less than half a year old and it's like nobody cares anymore so I think Legacy games have that problem anyway maybe there should be a video maybe I should do a podcast topic on those sort of games but it's you just one of those it just happens yeah nobody's kind of watching it so yeah not a lot of content I admit it's been an April I've been very busy but may should be able to get back on track because May is full of bank holidays which is always good and I don't have any plans until UK games Expo so yes I'll be at the UK games Expo I need to actually see if I can do some volunteer he in at the Expo as well not for the gamees Expo itself but I want to help out a publisher but I haven't really had the time to go out and like extend my
hand to a few I mean I I mean Flat River group might take me back if they want to but I kind of want to vary things up a bit I mean I don't know maybe the guys at hedg monic project games are they going to be there if you're watching this you know if you've got room for somebody who who's going to give you a hand teaching hemony or setting up the stall and stuff like that maybe on the Wednesday before the Press event and things you know uh talk to me I might be interested you know I would certainly like to do a few hours volunteering to mitigate the cost of going to the Expo because as much as I do a enjoy going to the games Expo it's not the most cost efficient of the conventions you know Essen costs a lot of money you know to stay there for nearly a week and go to Germany but you get a lot done there you get a lot of games you get a lot of stuff played you get you know like demos at the convention and that but you also meet a ton of the Publishers everybody in my world like the the content creator world is there whereas the game's Expo is a much more secluded comparison and yet it still seems to cost about as much to do so so there is that and I mean I go to the games Expo mainly to socialize play a few games with people who watch the channel and uh you know who Publishers and content creators but I don't really go there to buy or Test new games because not a lot of new hotness Games come out at UK games Expo it's usually Indie Publishers and I don't tend to play a ton of those games so I have limited scope to do anything around the trade show itself hence I've got some time to do some volunteering if need be but yeah I mean the games Expo is a good time if you want to catch me
for you know just a chat or play games or something you know because I do I do tend to take it easy at the games Expo it's there there's only so much to report on and so it's a very compared to Essen where I've got to make appointments and rush around all over the place and it's like a you know 10 miles 10 m square miles or whatever of stuff to walk around games Expo is a lot smaller by comparison it doesn't take to get from A to B and so it's a lot easier to kind of just meet you guys there that's has been a mint tea right anyway that being said let's move on with some uh extra bits so uh I want to talk about the game I play literally on Friday night um this is a very D and certainly given the topic I'm going to talk about this podcast is kind of a bit of a a weird 180 but this is Forenza uh friend of mine has this so specifically the anniversary Edition the 2020 version is what we played uh my friend has this he likes pretty much any game that is set in Renaissance Italy that has Latin names that is dry as a bone that is beige as all get out it's his style of games and surprisingly I actually figured you know what I'll give this one a try I like to try new games outside my comfort zone every now and again and I was told that this one had you know worker placement spots that other players created that you could go to and it's like that sounded pretty cool I mean you know whistle Mountain one of my favorite Euro games has a similar thing you know players create spaces on the board that other players want to go to unfortunately I think I misinterpreted
what he was saying because I got the impression this was going to be something a bit like whistle Mountain where you have these massive great great spaces on the board for you to go for worker placement and stuff though that aspect is pretty dialed down here when he says players create worker placement spots for you to go to we're literally just talking about three or four buildings that are on their board most of which literally just say get a resource that's it that is all it is and to go there you have to sacrifice VP that you give to the opponent to do so so there's not even that much incentive to do it unless you're really desperate for the resource so yeah that dream was kind of dashed rather quickly but that aside was the game fun we played four players and it does say 60 to 180 minutes on here we did take a good 2 and 1 half hours I think to play this maybe even three maybe not 3 hours I mean maybe two and a half to three something like that bear in mind we had to have a full teach two of us had not played it before but yeah the game feels really long for what it is essentially what you are doing is that it's it is dry as a bone you have a player board with these different spaces and all the and the main board has a bunch of these spaces as well where you're commissioning art and the like patronage basically and all the spaces have got these resource costs here with you know like marble and uh we think metal we're not entirely sure if it's metal or not but you know metal
gold which we kept calling lemons for the entire time because the icon for gold looks very much like a lemon so we basically just assumed that it was lemons which does inject more amusement and theme in the game than the game has trust me on that but the and wood and various other resources the basically is is that you've got your buildings that can generate these resources for you you have these little workers these little head dudes that you can place on the buildings to get the resources and it's a very tight Resource Management worker placement game where you get the resources uh put the art pieces down on the spaces and these spaces will get you bonuses you know in in the income phase and obviously victory points the game production is fine I mean you've got wooden pieces for all the resources and you know like wooden tiles and that but yeah I mean as you can see from the picture here is beiges all get out you know you've got some colored buildings that you put on your board and that and the resources are colored and that's pretty much it you look at the main board there that is just one big collage of beige with a few pictures thrown on it I mean I have seen much much worse this game at least does try to inject a little bit of uh color into it but it is still pretty beige but you know that's essentially all the game is you're just basically getting the resources and then putting tiles on these various spaces which are some are more lucrative than others and they just have different requirements for resources uh there is a small card system where you can get a painter to help you with the art pieces and you have to pay money to hire them and they basically depending on how much you're willing to pay uh they they get
you more victory points for doing it now you might notice there's a die symbolism here we played with the no die variant um because when I read the rules to the normal game and I read about how the dice system works I could not believe that a designer would put such a stupid mechanic in a three-hour Euro I mean maybe this would be one for the top 10 later but yeah you basically roll randomly and it sort of dictates victory points on whether the artist stays or goes why would you put that in a freour euro that makes no sense you maybe it was a product of its time but I don't know that's no excuse because this would have come out in you know I mean this was a 10th anniversary so this thing must have come out in 2010 it's not like games were ancient in 2010 right you know certain design decisions could have been avoided but we played with a no di variant which means you start at a fixed level and spend money to increase it much better you should always use that variant I would never want to play this otherwise but you know you essentially are just putting Tils out on these buildings using the artists and it's a tight Resource Management game and that's kind of it there's not really a lot that brings me back to want to play it more I mean there are a couple of things that do put me off slightly the fact that you've got this reference chart that you know has the costs of everything in the game on it it's two-sided and it basically is quite overwhelming when you look at this thing but it is quite useful to have so I can't knock it too much but you remember how Coliseum gives you that giant player Aid with a ton of stuff you're supposed to forward plan for well you've got an
element of that in this and it's just like ah God I hate it when you've got a forward plan pretty much the whole like spectrum of what you want to build but uh it's not quite as bad as Coliseum and certainly not maybe as bad as the TR Caron tricks that you have to do where you have to kind of forward plan exactly what tricks you're going to use in traron so yeah it's not too bad on that but the problem is is that the game is just a bit too dry for my liking and it kind of links into what I'm going to talk about later but you know there's nothing new in this and I get that this is a 2010 game that's just an anniversary edition so yes it's going to be fairly old school but all you do is collect the resources put a few workers down to get resource you know I'll put it here and I'll get a lemon put it here and I'll get a wood uh I generate a a a marble each round I can go to this space and sell a wood for 200 money fine now I can go onto this space this will give me a victory Point income every turn on the purple banner and more stuff happens and you've got a church track because every game set in Renaissance Italy has to have a church track and honestly the church track doesn't seem worth the cardboard it's printed on you can go out of your way to bump on it but it doesn't get you very many points and the benefits are really minor I mean you're much better on your main board trying to fill out this bottom bit here because you can do that quick enough you'll get Victory Point income every term and given that the person who won only beat me because he had several of these Victory Point generating income Things Early in the game otherwise we play pretty much the same I mean this game
does not have pretty much any variety whatsoever it is entirely one note you know there's not really a strategy you can formulate it's just do what you got to do but the church track the person who focused on the church track got very little reward out of it and came off I'm I'm never going to look at this track these These are basically a waste of space in fact the only reason I even built on one of these spaces is because you suffer a negative victory points at the end of the game if you don't so it's forcing you to do it again games that force you to do this to avoid negative points that always irks me a bit you know probably another design decision to think of the top 10 I really should start taking notes but you know the game wasn't bad I still enjoyed the time although I think some of that was because we were calling things lemons and uh the fact that we were I was a game with mates but the game itself is fine it's average maybe above average I'd probably give it a five or a six um I don't know there's I think a six is probably I'd probably say a five a five out of 10 it's average it's not a bad game but there's just nothing really unique in it there's nothing that's in that that engaging apart from the fact that it's quite tight resource management but each round plays out pretty much exactly the same it's just except that it escalates a little bit in terms of how much you can get done but all you're doing is just you know working your way through higher spots on here to get a tile and shove it out there's nothing nothing kind of cool happens in between rounds uh these characters that you can go to at the top of the like card row where you can spend
money to get a little bonus and you know they have they're so inefficient that nobody visits them at all it's just a waste this whole mechanic where you can be the captain of the people by being ahead in the point scoring order but then your points reset back to zero you cash them in effectively and then you go again isn't that interesting either I mean it's cool but everybody gets to be the captain of the person at some point because everybody resets to zero so at some point you're going to be the captain of the people it's just a case of when it happens so it doesn't really feel like much of an achievement it's just a it's an average Euro it does the job but that's about as much as it does it it it's not going to grip me to want to play it again if I play it again I'll you know if it's the voed game and there's not much else available I'll play it but for a game that takes two and a half to three hours to play with a big group of players it's a bit too one note and linear and just far too dry you know there is no theme in this at all I mean it could have been pasted with any setting and it would still work so you know it just it doesn't have enough to want to draw me back I mean it's that quote I used to use before that good mechanics will make me enjoy a game a good theme will p pull me back for the second play this game has mechanics that work fine there's nothing particularly new or innov Innovative about them but they work so I'll play the game and have a reasonable time but there is nothing to draw me back for a second play if I play it again it's because there wasn't any other better Alternatives and so I
would say it's an average game but nothing particularly to shout about nice bit of tea so hopefully that hasn't uh offended a ton of you beige Euros out there but sorry it's just it's a generic Euro you know that's kind of the problem we have okay so why don't we talk about quick bit of news first um uh let's see um let's see here we go uh quick bit of news Ticket to Ride This is the game I love so not going to lie I'm certainly excited for this but Ticket to Ride has kind of had a bit of a slump lately you I didn't like Ticket to Ride Legacy it felt like it was just cashing in on a fad and the small ticket to rides are fine but you literally only have to pick one and that's it I have London that is the best of the lot so far and that's the one I'm going to stick with I don't care about having all five or six of them there's just no need what I want is more big map packs and some good ones well they've answered my call because they've announced for later in the year somewhere in the summer I believe uh Iberia and South Korea as a map pack for the main game this is what I want I don't need little spin-offs anymore and I don't need some weird weird big Legacy like cash in spin-off what I want is just more maps for the main game now this is going to make things interesting because I have got a crate of uh Ticket to Ride in the other room I bought a custom crate and this was during my time when I realized when I before I realized that buying giant
wooden crates for games is a complete waste of money um I was a bit of a sucker for them and I wish I could get the money well I got the money back on some of them I mean I not necessarily the games themselves certainly the crates so you'll notice in the background the legendary crate and the eldrich horror and Arkham Horror crate are gone they are entirely gone they have been sold I have retained Aden legendary I put it back in its original box with the dividers and stuff so I should still be able to play that but Predator legendary is gone uh the Firefly legendary is gone uh Arkham Horror second edition is all gone elich horror is all gone all of it's gone cuz it just wasn't getting played and frankly as I said Mansions of Madness and Arkham Horror lcg Does It Better even the thirded of Arkham Horror I'm not sure I'm going to hang on to for too much longer at this rate but you know they digress but I have a giant wooden crate of ticket to write and it holds all the Ticket to Ride stuff in it but it also weighs a metric ton when am I going to take that to a game night it's just not going to happen so it stores all neatly at home but again I can't just easily take bits out of it and play it and I don't play tickets to ride at my own house I play it at other pees and usually they have a copy of a normal ticket to write there so I kind of made the mistake of buying The Wretched thing at some point I need to dismantle it and put things in some boxes the only problem is I don't have a lot of Ticket to Ride boxes so I'm a little bit questionable as to how I'm going to be able to store this um so yeah ouch whoops so I'm going to have to kind of figure that out at some point but it may be that this one has to be a separate
box but then I've got a separate box to a big crate H why did I buy the stupid crate top tip for me if you see a giant big wooden custom crate for your game unless it is something that is going to take you a day to play like something like the uh the Firefly crate I've seen that in action and it's like that's a massive metric tongue thing but when you play Firefly you're playing it for half a day because it takes way too long but at least that makes the crate worth it and that is a pretty decent looking crate but big giant wooden crates for games like this where you're only going to play it every now and again unless you're going to play it a ton at home they're not worth the money anyway I digress supposed to be talking about this expansion well there's only so much information on it I mean Iberia we've you know Iberia so a bit of Spain and South Korea South Korea is going to be interesting because I don't know much about the landscape of Korea so that would be a cool map to try but essentially there's not a lot of information it mentions here on this page so uh what have we got you will go to the festive squares of Seville collect and maximize sets of Festival cards as your network expands but plan your travel carefully as other players will offer a fierce competition to reach cities and claim the rewards before you do sounds like a set collection game okay sounds nothing major there it also includes the South Korea map which offers a unique twist in how routs are organized be quick and efficient using your high-speed train bonuses to claim the most valuable routs and secure the highest positions on the province chart that's interesting and it doesn't mention it here but in some of the Facebook media it's mentioned the word drafting
tickets that does fill me with a little bit of um Intrigue because you know the formula of Ticket to Ride has been set in stone for ages but when games like the UK version throw a bit of a spanner in works as to how it work how the game plays I really like it this one introducing the idea of drafting tickets could be really cool and I want to see that in action so I'm looking forward to that in play but you know this also is quite an interesting word from the author so alanar Moon uh for many years Switzerland has been my favorite Ticket to Ride map wow that's usually low down on the scale for most people and I mean Switzerland's a fine map but tunnels are a bad mechanic in ticket to ride so yeah I'm not going to agreee with you on that one but I mean come on United Kingdom is the best one you got to say it uh but without any any real complexity to the rules uh Iberia or South Korea changes the game completely makes the choice between claiming roots and drawing cards tense on almost every turn of the game the career map is my second attempt at grouping Roots by color and it also changes the game without lot without adding complexity okay cool the express train cards do add a little complexity but allow players to follow different strategies uh expansion pack 8 is now my favorite so far I mean to be honest you're the designer of the game so isn't that kind of inherent that you got to say that the next one is your favorite but like guess you are the designer and you have said that Switzerland is your favorite so I guess you'll be honest on that one but yeah you know some High Praise there but that's about as much as I know there's not much as as I can see in the picture doesn't really go into a
lot of you know I can't really show much on that picture there but I'm I'm intrigued I you know I want to grab this I want to review it I want to do a b beyond the Bas game video for it and I like ticket I love Ticket to Ride so it will be good to play this with the parents if I see them at the time but if not I'm certain I'll get it played if I take it to board game clubs so I guess that's the you know the way it shall go but yeah looking forward to it more mint tea keep the throat going keep the throat going right let's talk about uh the topic of the day so again you know it's been suggested to me by commentators on this one I talk heavily about theme in games and I've just talked about Forenza which is like the antithesis of theme but you know and actually only just this morning um uh you know someone I know on Facebook was doing a solo review of Mara Kaio well solo review he was basically saying how much he loves the solo mode and marra Kaio and you know he tagged me in the post as as a when I was because he remembered that when I talked about maraio I said that the camp the solo campaign was a let down because it was a pasted theme that didn't make any sense but and I still stand by that you know the game itself Myra Kaio is fine I used to own it but I did sell it because really the bit that was drawing me in was the card system which is easily the best part of it but it has no theme it is just basically a race around a Rondell um you know there's mechanics like the expiration being just a track you move up and the game is variable in
the fleet mechanic with the English Fleet the French Fleet and whatever the other one was you know is really really clunky and didn't really work that well and on top of that the game was variable length which means the game could end before you realize it because somebody rushes around the Rondell too fast it it's got problems and so I did sell it eventually but you know he was talking a lot about how you know he was he loved the fact that it was a rich story driven campaign and you know with Legacy aspects and it's like yes it's got Legacy aspects but for crying out loud it's Mara Kaio there is no theme in that story the story doesn't even make sense if you read the rule book carefully it mentions that there's a duration of time that each lap of the board represents and it's something like I can't remember a year 5 years 10 years it's certainly a number of years okay you could go on one lap and get a story aspect that says you're going to go meet this woman on this island you know okay cool well I've just passed that Island okay I'll get it on the next lap round that means you don't technically visit this person for another 5 to 10 years how does that make any sense you know it literally is it's such a weird plot hole that you could literally just see the meme from the ah what is that me called oh what's that Disney movie oh that's going to drive me nuts now I can't remember what it is uh the the one with the grank the one with grank where the meme where he goes you know they they get the enemy gets to the bit before the good guys and they ask how in Earth did you beat us and he goes well you got me you know he puts down the Char for all accounts it doesn't make any sense like the film pokes fun at its own plot holes love it oh
Emperor's New Groove that's it ah now I remembered but I think it's Emperor's New Groove whatever the one the guy turns into a camel for half of it or something but it's a it's a good funny movie and I love the grank character along with the uh you know the other lady the other sort of um antagonist but that Meme I love I love to use it in my videos and it's just such a cool one but that's basically summarizes the plot holes in maraio but they digress a little bit here what I'm getting at is that people sort of go like all right you like theme in games and all that and so the question is when is theme essential in a game for me and I'm not saying this has got to apply for everybody there are people out there who will play the driest you know driest lump of sand for 5 hours you know and they'll be fine you know they'll play an 18xx game for 6 hours and they won't mind you know how dry as a bone it is okay you know that's fine you want to play a dry game for four hours and you enjoy it then do so but for me when is the theme essential in a game because it's not that every single game on my shelf is richly thematic I mean you know know some games certainly do have a good formatic flare I mean Pursuit of Happiness for a euro is pretty formatic the Vitalis serers I own behind my head are pretty well fmatic um but then you know you could argue that Earth you know is mostly an engine builder Tableau game the theme is only there in so many ways in that one uh obviously something like Marvel Champions is uh pretty formatic with the superhero stuff and Manion of Madness but then below that is Twilight
inscription the roll and right TI game yeah are you really going to tell me that that is ftic you know it's not the most ftic game in the world either so it's not that every single game on my shelf is a ftic masterpiece but there are some games I can forgive it more than others and even then some of my favorite games are going to be F Matic whereas some of my games that you know struggle a little bit more to get played more often are going to be the dry ones a good example would be Newton uh let's see if I can uh bring that up on the screen here because I have right here we go let's go back to the Forenza video a second so Newton this is a game from I think crano Creations it's uh you know it's a liked game it's from Simone Yani um and to be on to be honest it's probably one of the few Luciani games I actually enjoy cuz I'm not a big fan of this designer games but it's a it's a fun game and it's got some cool mechanics in it but my God it d as a bone like this thing is just super super dry it is just moving along tracks and getting tiles and doing weird little bonus things but it's got a cool fun system in it but it is dry as a bone and so as much as it is on my shelf and I do enjoy it I haven't got this out in ages and there's a couple of reasons for it firstly the lack of a theme struggles to draw me back in because I'd rather play something that I can immerse myself into and escape from reality in some way but also the rules to the game will be something I'll forget over time for not playing it and if you don't play a dry game for that long it's very tough to
get back into the rule set because the theme the strong theme of A game can help you learn the game I mean that's we'll talk about it in more detail in a minute but you know hegemony for example is really rich and phatic but you know the fact that it is a really heavy game is offset by the fact that the theme is so strong that a lot of the rules make sense and some of the valital assurers are the same stuff I mean kban is you know chalk full of rules but it's very easy to teach kban because the the rules make sense you understand the fmatic applications of making a car designing one and dodging your boss at works so those mechanics make sense and so they stick in your mind the mechanics in Newton do not stick in your mind I mean if you forget if you don't play this game for a good six months to a year or something you're going to forget every mechanic that's in it you'd have to read through the entire rule book and go so how does that bit work oh yeah it flips over if you do this aspect and then on the end of the turn the shuffle along and then uh if you cover these in a row or column you get more bonuses I think that's something down there it's you know it's not easy to relearn the game when you take out the theme but you know when is it essential because I'm going to say when it's essential and in times when it's not you know sort of throughout but let's talk about story driven games so you know my friend on Facebook was talking about Mara Kaio and how he you know likes the solo campaign he didn't I think he whether he used the word f Matic I don't know but he did he did call it rich and I think he actually did mention the words theme like you know he want he liked the good formatic
solo campaign I'm sorry but the solo campaign of marai but it's just not formatic but ah digress here's a here's a fmatic solo game though story driven game tainted Grail you know I'm still playing through Kings of Ruin at the moment although I haven't played it in a while I need to hurry up and get back to that because it is sucking up my table space but you know you can't beat games like tainted grail for solid theme in a game I mean the rich law of this gritty ariran Legend Universe uh you know with the the the story book the expiration journal and the artwork and all the stuff you do I mean you don't even have to listen to music when you play this but if you do it just adds to the atmosphere it is such a great Rich formatic game now this is a game that you're going to play for multiple hours multiple campaigns and it's going to be something you're going to need to get immersed in well something like this then needs to be rich and formatted because if this was a dry tail that didn't really make any sense you know then what would I care Legacy games have done this occasionally like you get a um as much as I like the pandemic Legacy games particularly with season zero you find that the story just isn't that interesting and not immersive at all and so you don't get immersed in that area and so you're basically just playing a mechanical game that changes itself each game and you know when you've seen Legacy games the Legacy format thrown onto such dryness you know I know Cosmos I think did a couple like my city and stuff you know then why are we caring about the fact that we're replaying this all the time just because a little bit
the game changes what you want is all that story and richness and that is what tainted grail for example does in Spades it just gives you that world for you to have you know all the time I mean you don't have to read these extra law bits where it talks about the monsters that come out but you're tempted to just because of how cool they are when you play the actual game you know you don't need the Miniatures you know the Miniatures are fantastic but I've said that this has got some of the best writing in a in a campaign game to date it is such good writing you know I love reading every single word when I play the solo you know the descriptions of the locations the interactions you have with player NPCs and it's just it's such a glorious like formatic experience so if this was dry I would hate it probably I just I don't think I would get into this at all and so certainly from a you know you got to have the theme strong in a story driven game because the whole point of a theme is that it immerses you more in the game so a story should be immersive you know you can't just have a a dry story book is basically a textbook that's what it is the rule books are textbooks effectively they are the dry story bit that you're reading um you know if I read a tax manual to do my like job at work that's not an immersive experience I'm reading and learning stuff it's a dry textbook you know so you know there is a difference between the two so let's talk about um like another like heavy game as I mentioned hegemony so yeah we
had a fun game of it yesterday I didn't like the fact that I had to teach the game to somebody who uh didn't quite tell the truth about whether he played the game before when I asked for experienced players I was a bit mythed about that but I taught it anyway and we still had fun and at least it did make that we could have a four-player game rather than a three-player game but hemony um we we had a weird one with the game actually sort of as a side point we had a position where the state basically had no workers on it it had is open but no workers because some of them got privatized and the workers kind of went elsewhere to work for the capitalist um so the public sector just wasn't producing anything it was kind of weird how it was just like basically scorched Earth on his side of the board it was quite amusing but you know still was state was still getting enough points from just generally doing his legitimacy tracks but was quite amusing that he couldn't get any resources for the middle class uh myself and the working class to buy so we were having fun with the capitalist but then the capitalist was new to the game so it's not like that they were suddenly dominating the game as a result but I digress this is like one of my favorite games of all time it is heavy you have got asymmetric factions that play differently but the theme in this is so strong on how it takes into account social class politics workingclass middle class capitalist in the state how they interact what their agendas are how they you know how their companies work what their needs are it's
just so rich in theme and some of that is brought out by you know the interaction with the players as well because this is a heavy game that you interact with players therefore the fact that it takes a long time is offset by two things the fact that you are interacting with players and the fact that the theme is Rich and immersive you get into this setting you get into this world you you you almost roleplaying the factions that you are I mean the capitalist scum the workingclass peasant the middle class avocado eaters you know this the corrupt government you know there's definitely some banter that goes back and forth with this but I get a kick out of this game every time I play it and even the way the voting system works you know and you know how you know how taxation effects like labor how the taxation Works in general like the fact that corporate tax is based on the revenue of the capitalist uh not its capital amount so you they thought hard about how these things work and just how the the feeling of of the gameplay changes with these policies like we had a game at hycom where we had low wages fairly High tax but we managed to get into a situation where four and five were on A's so Healthcare and education for a long time was free I think I was playing the working class at that time it was was I playing the working class feel like it was yes I was I was playing working class because the wages were low but I didn't care because everything was free it was kind of funny and you know the setting kind of like you could compare it like so this is basically the NHS on crack is it you know so where the
NHS if the NHS actually worked you know and was funded properly well could digress a million years about that but you know with this one it just kind of made for a really fun setting and you remember it you know we were chatting for an hour after the game finished about what happened in the game and how this like changes from other games and only a formatic game can help you do that I'm not talking about what I did in forens for an hour afterwards I mean it's like you know I did some I did some tile placement and I did some resource Gathering and there you go it's like what am I supposed to talk about same with Newton and a few of these others you know it's not going to generate a story but this does this generates a story Pursuit of Happiness generates a story when you're playing it and you know that is all done from interaction as well as a strong theme the other thing is is that this game takes a good 4 hours to play a typical game of this if this game was dry as a bone I'd be bored out of my brain within like an hour an hour and a half cuz I'd be like oh my God we got to sit in this for another 3 hours oh God it's going to take forever time flies when I'm playing this game though because I'm immersed greatly but you couldn't sell this to me and make it a dry experience and expect me to play it for 4 hours it just wouldn't work and so there's the point I'm trying to make if it's a very long game I think theme is essential there are people who love Twilight Imperium 4 and you know the Twilight Imperium series and fine I don't mind Twilight Imperium but to be honest it doesn't
matter how formatic you make a game there is no way you are going to convince me that any game is worth playing for a good six to eight hours that is just ridiculous I mean we I taught hegemony to a player from scratch I set it up we started a good hour and a half two hours after a Twilight Imperium six player game took place and started and we still finished ages before before the ti4 game ended in fact we finished I packed it away I hunt around for a bit and I eventually left and they were still playing you know and our game took a good four plus hours because I had to teach it and it was a slower game but man there are limits to how much the theme carries and honestly is the theme that strong strong in Twilight Imperium I mean that's probably heresy to some people I mean it's certainly got you know cool look and it's got the alen races and you certainly do feel like you're engaged in Space Battles and stuff so yeah I mean I'll I'll give it credit it's definitely got some theme there but any expiration that's in this game is literally Bare Bones at best you know the game plays out pretty much the same every time I mean everybody sort of congregates in the middle into a massive cluster battle and then somebody comes out on top but then you've also got the Euro game mechanics in it which kind of feel very Euro as opposed to the Amera fry style that you kind of want for a space battle game but I mean I don't mind game Twilight Imperium is fine but I mean look at this I mean this is just unwieldy as anything can you tell what is going on in this picture with all
these ships congregated in all these tiny hexes and that it's just oh it's just an absolute messy cluster that's what gets me with this but you know it has its fun moments but it's just too much you know 6 to8 hours the theme cannot be strong enough to keep me going for that long but again I digress so where do we have big heavy Euros that take too long that aren't thematic enough well um you know as much as some people might cry heresy void fall is a good example because void fall is you know popular amongst a bunch of Gamers fair play but let's be perfectly honest with ourselves people here is void full really a thematic game yes it may have nice looks you know with the orange pieces everywhere and yes you can play a different faction but is it really fmatic I mean the setting is essentially a madeup setting and when all said and done the mechanics of the the card system and how the corruption works and you know how you know how you go around the map and stuff it's like a lot of it doesn't feel like a big ftic space game does it it feels like you're basically playing a big heavy mechanical Euro with a space scene pasted on it and that's the thing that slly puts me off it you know the fact that when I play it I don't get immersed in this world of Space Battles and you know you know you know space alen civilizations and stuff like that feel like I'm just playing a bunch of mechanics which is plentiful to say the least and trying to deal with the fact that this game is going to take me four plus hours and it's literally
you get about you know a few things to do every now and again and you're kind of waiting endlessly for everyone else to take their turns oh God I don't like this game multiplayer but solo it was better but still it was just a lot of stuff to do and again the rules because the rules of this because this game is not particularly that fmatic learning the rules for this game wasn't absolute chore you know if I put this game down for more than half an hour I would forget half the game I had to rules reference a ton while playing this game because the rules just don't stick in my mind because there's a so many of them and B the theme isn't strong enough to gel it all together and make it flow hegemony has a lot of rules but they interact with other people some of them are repeated among classes you know some classes can do the same action as another but because you understand how the actions of one class affect the actions of another class the rules gel and stick this one doesn't have that it's you know I could I can play this entire game and forgo a good chunk of the rule but because I don't like playing warlike in these games so I tend to be the one that sits back and creates a really good economic civilization and every time I play void full I do that I pick a faction that isn't particularly War heavy sit at the back Turtle up get get victory points that way win the game and I barely had to attack anything apart from a couple of NPC things you know it kind of defeats the whole purpose of a big space battle game you when I can literally ignore half the rule book and still win it's kind of odd but you know that's you know you could
argue maybe this has a little theme but are you going to argue something like inventions has a theme um no I love fala games okay to to a point I hate Escape Plan and CO2 all right I like most of them weather machine was kind of above average all right I like most of them okay but you know gallerist Liz Boer Hanan Vinos now lizer theme wise is a little bit off it's historically accurate but what you're doing in the game is a little bit on the weird side from a fantic standpoint but again it's also the hardest one for me to learn because of that out of the four but vgos galleris particularly kban especially they have got such good themes that the mechanics just work they make sense you know you're promoting the artist and as you buy the art and you know you commission the art and as they get get better you know as they buy and sell art they get more popular and so you know their art is worth more and people come to your gallery to look at the art and collectors will walk off with it after you sell it it's a lot of the stuff is thematic and kban dodging your boss and building the cars assembling them and testing the parts out studying to get ahead of your boss it's like all that stuff's F Matic and the vgos V you know running a Vineyard wines submitting them to the fair having them be judged you know a lot of that stuff is again thematically Rich inventions ain't got a theme I mean hell weather machine was questionable about whether it either a theme and I get people have argued this to the cows come home about the uh you know the theme in weather machine but it's a very Niche theme when you think
about it come on at least give me that but inventions what theme is there in this this is pure Mechanics for the sake of mechanics you know the workpl system is just a well the action selection system is essentially a mechanical thing the fact that these Technologies level into each other is about as Bare Bones of theme as you can get and even though it's not it's not like oh I know how I know how to iron smelt therefore I can now make cool things out of iron no it's just the fact that the card links into this card it doesn't make you feel like you really invented iron smelting it's just oh I leveled up to this card you've got this bit around the map which doesn't make a huge amount of sense thematically but then it gets worse when you look at your player board I wonder if there's a more zoomed in version of a player board somewhere uh come on come on don't be shock I show off your player board come on show it here we go this thing so you know where you get these tiles and these tiles you put on this Grid in front of you and literally it's only put on that grid to put them in weird clusters or in certain sequences to score points for abstract reasons I mean this one here I think is literally saying you get free points if you can put like a tile next to a cluster of three or something I don't even know what that exactly means again your iconography is not 100% clear but you know there is a lot of iconography in this game and it is not intuitive but wow I mean this this whole grid system is completely abstract I've forgotten how it works for the most part already because it's just so like non
formatic it's unreal but inventions is not a short game you're playing this for a good three hours plus like getal Sera game and because it's bone dry I don't get I don't feel like I want to play it again I played it a few times uh sorry a couple of times and I just thought me not worth it you know and bear in mind this was at pre Kickstarter stage so somebody else had a copy and I've played it a couple of times but each time I just felt me it does the job but I'd much rather play one of these behind my head than this one you know this one I've already forgotten about for the most part but it's going to have some fans you know some fans of Lura who will literally eat everything that Lura releases but when thinking about it n this one has a few problems and theme is certainly one of them so okay so certainly from a long game perspective theme is important so do I need theme in every game for me to like it no there are some drier games that work I mean you know Arc NOA has a theme although you can you could argue that maybe the theme is not super super strong in it but the mechanics are so good in it that you know I can Overlook a little bit of that theme aspect because it is so much fun to do those mechanics you know there there's a decent amount of them but they feel smoother and a bit more not necessarily streamlined but they're not conky compared to a lot of mechanics but you know when is theme not essential I think game length is probably the big aspect here because I've just talked about some very long very heavy games right so why don't we have a look at some stuff that's light and fluffy yet still really dry I mean a game I played
yesterday in fact and I've reviewed it veil of Eternity okay this is a pretty cool very light engine builder game you know very simple very few rules the theme in this is completely non-existent I mean the title is literally just going to chase people away cuz people are going to say what in Earth is the veil of Eternity I don't know but there's no theme in this it's literally an engine builder card game where you draft a couple of creatures each round play them and score victory points in various ways there's no theme here it is bone dry but this is a 45-minute game it's a very quick experience I mean an hour tops but hopefully 45 minutes if people get on with it and it's just it's done and done usted really quick I don't need a theme to keep me super immersed if the mechanics are genuinely pretty cool and the game is short enough to compensate for the fact that you don't immerse yourself in the theme I like Puzzles as much as an next person and fre hour lerta games can be a giant puzzle but for example I like sodoku Puzzles okay I don't do them that often but if I go home and I'm at the parents they might do a cross word I might do a soku puzzle from their Times paper right I like doing a soku puzzle I can't do expert level ones they just confuse the hell out of me but I want to do a sodoku puzzle in the space of 30 to 45 minutes okay like let you know an hour absolute tops I don't want to be spending half the day doing the same sodoku puzzle crosswords are a similar thing it's good to do a cross word up to a point but once you get stuck and you really can't figure out some of those other answers
I'm kind of done you know I don't want to spend the whole day trying to decipher whether this one word could be this or this it's like look we got to a point this is as much as we could figure out can we move on to the next one and I'm same with sodoku eventually I'll reach a point where it's like I can't be bothered to figure out the rest of this it's like this has taken forever can we do something else and maybe that's a you know it's not an attention span problem I mean I like playing I've just mentioned a bunch of heavy long games I love playing it's not that I can't focus for 4 hours it's just the fact that if the game is going to be worth my time and time is very precious at the moment I mean we're almost at the end of the weekend and I don't necessarily feel like I've achieved very much in the day and a half of the weekend and there's so much to do time is just precious and I don't want to spend 4 hours doing something that I feel could be done quicker or isn't going to justify the 4H hour game length but something like ve of Eternity 45 minutes bone dry doesn't matter it's quick and it's done I like trick- taking games so I already mentioned things like nokosu uh dice there's no F in niku dice it's literally you know a trick takey game with cards and dice it's a quick little card game it well quick about an hour but it's not meant to be fmatic it's not meant to be like immersive or anything like that it's just a cool set of mechanical systems that work really well get you thinking get you interacting with other players which I guess actually that's probably another thing that helps in dry games if you're interacting with other players that does help you know for example I mean you could play Newton you
don't really interact with players much it's pretty multiplayer Solita and you know a lot of these other dry Euros could just be multiplayer solitire in which case why on Earth am I playing this game for four hours when I could play something that's an hour long and more interactive um you know PE well funny enough on the screen here here we go yeah castles of burgundy the special edition I hate the castles of burgundy game I don't know why everybody loves it so much but twe each their own but you know and why it came out in the special edition I've no idea but you know this is a bone dry game and it's not the shortest game in the world I mean it's not terribly long but you are still talking a good 2 hours to play this game at time S I don't want to play a super dry game for two hours that's literally just dice and tiles and that's about it you know I mean I still don't get the appeal for this game in general you know I I digress h i don't maybe this is one I should add to the list for the um games that I didn't like in the past that I should try again now I did it with Great Western Trail and look how that turned out and you know but then there are ones that I tried again like you know you know hands to do toner and you know eclipse and stuff like that and those games are still garbage for me I don't like any of them you know even after this time what's the other one Brussels 1893 or something garbage when I played it still garbage now but maybe I would enjoy this a bit more now but I reckon that some of that would just come down for the fact of how good this new version looks but no way this game justifies the price point and space this someone takes up it's just too over the top but you know it's dry as a bone and
it's two hours and it just doesn't have that pull to bring me back in because the mechanics are going to have to be so solid to make me Focus for that long and in this one for me they're just not uh what other short game would work let's see short games aren't terribly ftic uh um trying to think I mean Seven Wonders and some I mean Seven Wonders is probably a good idea I mean Seven Wonders the drafting game yes you don't really feel like you're building up a civilization in Seven Wonders I mean you're drafting cards and different colors relate to different things like Commerce and culture and stuff but you're drafting cards and playing them to score victory points and chain combos I mean it's not like I feel that I'm building up a rich ftic civilization when I'm playing this game but the game's done in 45 minutes it's a quick drafting game what you know I don't need it to immerse me in a rich world for that Tim length and honestly most short games don't have strong themes I'm trying to look at my shelf and trying to think is there a short game that I have that I could consider truly ftic and honestly I'd kind of like your comments and the uh YouTube comments for this a short game and we're talking 45 minutes or less that is richly thematic and immersive I would like to kind of know that because I am struggling as hell to see anything on my shelf I could consider that I mean coffee roaster coffee roaster does a pretty good job of representing its theme pretty well that is a quick game so I mean that's my first um inan but I'm
looking at all sorts of me wingspan wingspan is not the longest game in the world although it can go to 90 minutes with a lot of players and you are men's I mean the theme setting is lovely way better than worms ban but the it's still an engine builder card game at the end of the day even though there are some formatic applications but you know that is another potential Contender I guess but I mean small Islands Reef uh raah you know Majesty for the realm Isle of Sky uh what else have we got Kina Tokyo get on board biblo Celestia Splendor Spellbook you know are any of these games ringing bells in terms of Rich themes I am not entirely convinced on that front uh but the last thing I want to mention is another time when I think the theme is essential because I've talked a lot about game length and you know and certainly I think that is the key time when theme is essential but here's another time when it's essential IP IP if you're going to put a theme on a game that is representive of an IP you had better make it thematically rich to it because otherwise you are doing a disservice to it so you will already remember that I you know gave a pretty damn good rating to Deep Rock Galactic Deep Rock Galactic a game that I still play on the PC every now and again can still wipe the floor with most settings but I don't mod my game but yeah Hazard 5 I can deal with it fine not necessarily solo it's pretty tricky to do some of them solo but as a group easy
but deep rock Galactic the board game so respects the IP that it's based on not just by its look and its miniatures stuff like that but the game playay and what you do is so rich and tied to what you know deep rock Galactic is if you have played the game now if they literally just pasted the theme on and didn't care I'd be a bit miffed about that you know you'd be doing a disservice to the game which is so rich in theme that you can't do an IP on it and just make it a dry Euro so something like this works and I think with an IP it's essential that you make a good fmatic game because you've paid extra money for the IP you're drawing in fans who love the IP if you then don't respect the IP and don't make a formatic game based on it then what was the point you're just annoying people who come to play the game and you're just wasting money at that point but you know another good example uh pretty rich in theme on how it plays is XCOM XCOM the born game uh I you know the app and how that works and how you're you know trying to fend off aliens from your base while doing missions and you know dealing with the UFOs that are flying down the tension the atmosphere the sound effects from the app you know the roles that you play you that they are again doing a good Ser going doing a good service to the original Ip and so if this was just a bone dry game that didn't give you the same tension as a normal XCOM game I'd be kind of bored and just would never
want to play it and it's still on my shelf now it you know definitely works in that respect so okay well why don't we take a really really rich IP you know a rich IP that has been in so many games like well you might be thinking Lord of the Rings I'm thinking Star Wars outter Rim anyone um you know and you could even argue Star Wars rebellion Imperial assault those sort of games but you know outter Rim this is a game of bounty hunters mercenaries and such as it says it is what it says on the tin and what are these these are some horrible looking Miniatures they're not in the game don't worry about that this one has a rich theme it does service to its IP you are going around doing bounties upgrading your ship trying to outrun the other bounty hunters deal with the Imperial and the rebels you can have your signature ships from the show I mean this is a rich fmatic game and yeah it does take a while this is another long game even if you're playing it solo but man is it good fun to play and man is it going to immerse you in that theme it does a really solid job and so back to the length thing I mentioned but also respecting its IP this sort of thing works now are there games that do not use the IP well and yet can you know take it well I mean I've heard slightly disturbing things about the new cyberpunk game uh gangs of night City I mean I'm playing cyberpunk at the moment on the PC and wow it is making my um Intel 12 900k processor basically heat up the room it is uh generating a very
hot processor I mean it scares me how hot it gets but apparently it's meant to do that apparently it doesn't do any harm that's what all the tech support people are telling me so you know I will basically trust to it and the game still runs smooth as butter on my system so fine but man the theme of cyber Punk that world in the game is so nice to walk around in and just Ure but when I've watched reviews of gangs of night City it doesn't really feel like cyber Punk um you know you know all the stuff about this area control with the different factions and stuff like that it's like that's not what I got from cyber punk you know where's all the cool like I mean yeah you've used characters in the games or I mean I recognize Johnny silver hand and I got to admit it's so great having me K reees like in that game it's just it's so great the voice acting but you know then you got you know characters I recognize like you know Judy Alvarez who I'm trying to get my um female character to uh um mate with at some point the Cyber Punk game does give you opportunities where you actually can basically have sex with uh various other characters depending on how the plots go and I've turned down several of them because I actually really like Judy she's really cute and I love a Tech quiz in game so I'm just kind of like try but best and it hasn't happened yet so I'm trying so much to deal with that it's insane but you know that's a fit that's a ver Matic story that's being told but this one from the reviews does not feel like cyber punk I mean I look at this game and I'm not even thinking cyber Punk this whole picture there is nothing in this game
apart from the occasional exclamation mark triangle and a couple of games that tells me that this is a cyberpunk game when I showed you the pictures of XCOM and Star Wars outter rim and that you could tell instantly what the IP was but if you showed me this without any other context I wouldn't know this was cyber Punk and that you know that doesn't work I mean I don't want to play this I don't feel like this will be a fun game because you're going to draw me into this game thinking oh yeah this will be be like cyber Punk and yet it just isn't and I know there's going to be you know other examples of when this is done I mean uh well I mean lord of the rings has done it for ages so when don't we just type in Lord of the Rings I'm sure we'll get a million games on the search front here so Lord of the Rings the card game very formatic that makes sense Lord of the Rings journeys of Middle Earth again a formatic story driven campaign makes sense okay the Lord of the Rings um as in the uh 2000 Rhino kitzia game where you literally move along the track and you put tiles down I think I can't remember exactly how it works it's been a long time but that's kind of all you're doing you're basically just putting tiles down and marking a route and that's it this game does not have theme okay sorry about that that was a big spider on the screen i i c up a picture of Shob um and I hate spiders I wasn't expecting it and so it just like bured me out in Fright on YouTube that would
make sense but on podcast that's going to sound really weird oh hopefully that gave you a bit of a laugh and didn't freak you out too much as much as me but yeah I mean this oh there it is in the background again well it's in the background I can kind of deal with it but yeah you're just putting tiles on the board and moving along and that's it I mean it's just that's it the theme in this game is non-existent so why on Earth would I want to you know go through it I'm going to be careful like going back through this yep I'm such a wor but you know all these other ones Lord of the Rings to confrontation foric question question mark risk the Lord of the Rings trilogy Edition okay what you know this is going a little bit too far um the the dice game I mean a lot of these are Lord of the Rings the card games but I mean there's a bunch of these Lord of the Rings games I've never even heard of this is how much it's been sort of just ripped apart Monopoly the Lord of the Rings Edition wow you know strong theme on that one you know so there's a lot of times that the IP is just literally pasted onto a game to sell more copies and Lord of the Rings I think is one of the worst contenders for how it literally has been just butchered by people and not represented well you know I mean let's face it we've already got that problem in the um uh TV industry with the rings of power seriously if you like the rings of power what the hell is wrong with you that show is utter garbage but um you know and the fact that they managed to get a second season oh great yeah I can't imagine what Miracle they've got to pull to try and fix that series but hey D you
so you know here most of this is just lcg packs so it's not really telling me much more but again there's a bunch of Lord of the Rings games that exist where there is just no theme at all like it does not represent the IP at all and you know that's a disservice you know you've got to respect the IP because otherwise you're just paying money for the sake of it you know maybe they're under I think they're the problem is when you have a license for a game you're under contract to produce so much content for that IP because otherwise you lose it um this is prevalent in in some of the board game stuff where like a board game has to come out with his IP every now and again otherwise you lose it but it's particularly prevalent in something like the movie industry uh remember the garbage fire earlier this month um earlier this year Madam web you know that that rubbish movie well basically Sony have the rights to some of the Marvel properties you know including some of the Spider-Man stuff and if you don't make a certain amount of content every now and again you lose the license so Sony are basically under this obligation to put out a movie of some sort on something remotely Marvel related in order to justify the fact it has a license this is why they are low effort I mean morbius and Madam web and even Craven looks bad you know I mean all these films are just generally mediocre or garbage at best and it's just the fact that they know they've just got to put out something to keep the license because they don't want to lose it and it just means that it's a mess each time I mean yes you occasionally get gold dust from them but
then that's more their Animation Studios and that's purely um into the spiderverse and across the spiderverse which are absolutely fantastic but that's Animation Studios clearly somebody knows what they're doing there but in terms of their film making horrible but you know that's kind of the way it is you know the IP is important and I'd be interested to know your thoughts in the comments as to um I couldn't think of that many off the top of my head but you know IP's IP board games where the theme is completely p it on you know and we're talking big bucks don't worry about small ones you know small ones I'm not too fussed about but cyber Punk 2077 games night city is a pretty big game with an IP to be that sort of dry to it I'd be interested to know some others and I'm sure I'm going to kick myself when you tell me some that I was oh yeah of course I should have thought of that but you know there's definitely some examples there where it does get misused and and so that's kind of the way to wrap it up when is theme essential I love theme in board games theme draws me back in and I love it when it's present and done well you know even if it's a theme I'm not that interested in i' still would at least respect it for representing the theme well and it may be enough to draw me in for a second play but two essential times for me the length of the game the longer the game is the more the theme needs to be strong because otherwise I can't justify the time length for the game I'm playing at least very rarely there are exceptions to the rule if the mechanics are just that good but even then the setting still needs to
be something I'm interested in I mean people will no doubt I'm sure bring up Arc NOA Arc NOA is a long game I wish it was shorter but even if it's not the most F matically Rich game in the world the setting is still something I really love because I love animals and so I still get immersed in that respect if Arc Nova was the same mechanics and it was literally brass you know basically Industrial Revolution building coal mines and stuff I wouldn't play it I'd be bored you cuz I wouldn't care the fact that I'm building a coal mine or some iron Railway or something like that but I do care that I put a giant panda in my Zoo there is a difference in settings uh same thing for wingspan versus worms span I don't care about dragons they're a Trope but birds are cool I like birds wingspan is better you know that kind of thing but the second essential part IP if you're going to have an IP in a game you got to get that theme right because it's a disservice to do it otherwise and it just tricks players and it puts me off a game really hard if you take the IP and just use it as a selling point like you know a misleading you know almost clickbait basically to say look at this big game we're making it's based on the Warhammer universe and you're putting tiles on a board and moving up tracks would you not Cass that as a betrayal to the license that you know when somebody has got the license to a property you really like and then they paste it on something does that not just feel like a betrayal to you from a board game publisher it feels very low effort
so yeah length and IP two most essential times I think a theme is necessary by all means let me know in the comments if you've got any other ideas as to why it should be essential I'm not interested in discussing the whole thing of whether theme whether you like theme in the game or not that's not the idea but you know we're talking you know is there a time that theme is essential in the game and if so when you know when is it for you and try and think of something different other than the length for the IP thing that I mentioned uh you know let's see if we can get some other things in the comments so yeah that's it for me I'm going to wrap this one up hope you enjoyed the episode uh you know I'm going to get on with uh the day I'm supposed to be playing some extended Stellaris with some friends in a minute although I still need to edit and submit this so that's going to be tight still want to go to the gym and I got valheim tonight so I've got a bit of a fun day later on but at some point I really do need to get recording on those moonbreaker videos so much time and just not enough time to do everything I want oh well that's the nature of the Beast for a content creator who has a full-time job it's just how it works I wish I could do this fulltime it's just never ever going to happen so anyway that's it for me I'll see you on the next broken meall video and remember as always regardless of whether the theme is essential part of a game for you or not it's still only a game so just play what you like and enjoy it bye for now everyone take care