Top 10 Elegant Board Games - Chairman of the Board
Transcript
hey everybody today I'm counting down my top ten elegant board games now when I say elegant board games what I mean is games with a low ruler overhead in comparison to the depth of the game and the kind of weight of the decisions throughout the game for me elegance is one of the top traits I look for in in my board games because I really don't like kind of you know overall it's in convoluted games just for the sake of it I don't get me wrong I some of the games I do like do have that element to them but you know that's a said one of the foremost traits that I look for because I think the quicker you can get into a game the better and you don't want to be sat there for ages and ages just learning how to play it and before you actually get stuck in so I've got a big kind of variance of games here I think I've got a good diversity loads of different genres of games and they're all rock-solid at that so at number 10 I have cryptid now cryptid is actually a pretty simple game in its um in its essence and it's a deduction game where you're trying to pinpoint somewhere on this map where this monster could be and every single player involved has a unique rule assigned to them and when you combine all those rules together it's got a pinpoint one particular location but where the elegance comes into this game is basically on your turn you're going to ask one player one question or by asking them if it could be on a particular hex or map on that board and they're going to simply say yes or no and put a marker on it and
then in return you have to do the same so you either have to put a if they said yes it could be here you also have to put one of your yes tokens on someone on the board where it could be according to your rule but and that's simply it so the decision wise it's you know well it's simple in what it what it is you know you do actually have to think about where you're gonna choose carefully and when you do actually have to do something in return by responding to that question you've got to be very you can be very clever and savvy about where you put your marker to try and mislead the other players on where this cryptid could be extremely clever one of the best deduction games out there for me and the algorithm about how all those rules comes together to UM to pinpoint it's absolutely genius Oh a really great game that is cryptid number 9 I have a pretty ferocious little card game called Arboretum now from the face of Arboretum you might not think you know this doesn't look fierce it doesn't look cutthroat and but I assure you it is so this game is based on making your own tableau of cards or Arboretum and just on your turn you're going to simply have a where you going to have a hand of seven cards and every time you're going to draw two cards you're going to play one of them into your Arboretum and you're going to discard the other one on to your discard pile now it's important that you each player has their own discard pile and not like kind of a central discard pile where cards will never be seen again what's important about that is because when it's other players turns they can either draw cards from the facedown stack or can draw pot or draw cards from
each player's discard pile so you've got to be very careful at which cards you discard because other players might want them but the the point of what you're doing is you're trying to build this and I said this tableau of cards by formulating these different paths as trees trying to get points by making the longer paths you can cross the road with different tree types and stuff like that but where the real weight of the game comes in is the management of your hand because you've got to be very careful about what cards you discard as I said because other players want the cars that you're getting rid of but what's really tricky about this game is that you've got to keep cards in your hand of a certain tree types based on the cards you have in front of you because you're only going to score score points in relation to cards you have left in your hand being higher than the other players of that tree type because only the players with the highest amount of cards of a tree type in the hand we're going to score that type and that can be extremely tricky because you know you want to get these trees down so that you got you're going to get the points in the first place if you don't keep anything back in your hand you're gonna score nothing and just knowing what other players have in their hands as you know it's gonna be impossible to tell but you can kind of keep a track of what they're discarding and stuff like that but yeah the weight of the decisions in this game is absolutely agonizing you know sometimes at the end of the game you'll think you've done extremely well by having a huge kind of path of cards and having behind number cards in your hand but then somebody Trump's you've just buy one and you end up scoring nothing a great game extremely clever and yeah elegant to a tee that is Arboretum at number eight I have
a game by Alexander Pfister this is Isle of Skye now Isle of Skye it is a tower placement game and when you're trying to basically you're building the same kind of region in Scotland and you're basically trying to place these toilet in order to fulfill these different kind of scoring criteria at the end of each round but the gamepad should flow itself is extremely simple in this game but they'll again the weight of the decisions is um is pretty tricky because every time you're going to draw three cards from a from a bag and you're going to hide them behind a screen and then out those three tiles you're going to choose one two three so you get rid of and the other two you're going to set prices to based on your you know your current bank of money and the importance of this is is fundamental because the the price in your setting is what the you're basically saying that you know I'm willing to part with this tile if another player player pays me this amount of money but then again if nobody chooses to buy those tiles off you you have to pay that cost yourself and that is absolutely genius for me because you know you can try and be greedy and hope song plays it but if they don't pair you're stuck yourself so that nuance of balancing how much each tile costs is really where the depth of the game comes in for me and you can be strategic in this game because you've got to plan ahead because you know what the what the kind of future scoring rounds are going to are going to kind of require yeah extremely clever but again very simple went I just thought in terms of its rules overhead and it's actually pretty easy to teach us to you know to kind of
introductory gamers because I said it's not a lot to take in but the the trick is about just putting things or being as cost effective as possible and I'm you're balancing your funds in the in the best way you can so that is I love sky at number eight number seven probably the most complex game to this point in fact it definitely is this is now bigger door by mcgirt's now this is a rondelle game so by that what I means you've kind of got this wheel of different action you can take and every turn you can either move one two or three spaces around that rondelle in a clockwise fashion and take the corresponding action and that's where the elegance comes in for me you're never overwhelmed by decisions because you can only ever make one of those three decisions but out of those three decisions it's going to be extremely difficult to choose which one because you want to you're going to want to do each one and the objective of the game so you're basically trying to travel the world by not only sailing but trying to build factory set up colonies and stuff like this and ultimately the way you score is you score and you basically pick up these privileges which can amplify your multipliers for doing a number of different things but as I said the the real depth of this game is that there's this real tension that you want to be the first to do everything at all times you know not only do you want to be the first to get the privileges because you you know you want to score those multipliers but there's only one of each top you know one of each type available you want to be the first to go to the
market while while the market is hot and make as much money as possible you want to buy the buildings because the buildings and get more and more expensive as the game goes on so you're going to be quicker at doing everything it's extremely clever game and I absolutely love it and it just for me is just elegance personified because as I said you're never overwhelmed by so many things just one of three decisions but each one is going to be absolutely excruciating on which one you're gonna which one you're going to choose so that is naviga door and absolutely phenomenal elegant game at number six I have Hana Mukherjee now Hana Mukherjee is a two player only card game it's a tug of war style game where you have I believe it's six different geisha girls or it might be seven and you are trying to basically win their favor by having the most cards of their suits on your side of the table but this game is very very nuanced very tricky and probably the more than the most delicately balanced games that I've ever played and when you first play this game originally the kind of strategies and nuances and depths might not be apparent to you but the more and when you play it the more you can kind of understand and appreciate how well this game is designed because every year basically your turn is or a round of the game consists of taking four actions in any order you want and once you've used that action you can't use it again until the next round one of those actions is to basically reserve a card from your hand until until the end
of the round and play it in front of you one of them is to simply delete a card from the from the set basically and the other ones are have this very clever but but absolutely a Skoosh excruciatingly kind of ice split or I split you choose mechanism where you will pick either three or four cards and basically present them to your opponent your opponent will either pick a pair of them or a single card if it's the three one and you'll get the remaining cards and place them on your side the the way that you can manipulate the game in the most kind of intriguing manner is absolutely fascinating with this one and I think if anybody's played Hanuman code you'd they'll completely testify about how this game you know has so much hidden layers to it and while still being extremely simple there's Hannah Mukherjee one of the best two-player games out there at number five I have the palaces of Carrara this is a very clever euro style game by Michael Kiessling and Wolfgang Kramer and the objective of the game is you're trying to collect marble to build buildings in in a number of different cities now all the marble have different different kind of qualities to them and they're more kind of refined the marble is that means you can build in the more expensive cities and get better rewards but the game is ball down into three very simple actions first action is to simply buy marble by paying the cost associated on this really cool basically resource
wheel where you can either pay the costs that they are or you can rotate the wheel making each brick cheaper and as it rotates around but I'll see if you do so you're making it cheaper for your opponents as well the second actually you can do is to buy a building and associates it by boss or by cashing in the marble type and then putting on your player board and a third action is to score a city and when you score a city you're going to score multipliers based on the buildings in them they can be points or money but the trick is that it has this real kind of tricking mechanism to it where when you score a city your opponent can no longer score that city so not only do you want to make powerful you know powerful cities you've got to be careful because your opponent could score it before you completely shutting out doing so a really cool game very clean very simple and just elegant that is the palaces of Carrara at number four I have the second game by Wolfgang Kramer this is El Grande now if you're a fan of like my channel out brandy is currently my number one board game of all time I love this game it is a game that dates back to the mid 90s so it's quite old but for me it is just absolutely phenomenal and it's an area control game where the objective is very simple and score as many points as you can by controlling regions by having the most kind of cubes or meeples in them depending on which version you have and the way you put those cubes in or meeples in is by the use of these action
cards these action cards are going to let you kind of manipulate the you know the board state by you know moving cubes around and stuff but they're also going to determine how many workers you can place on the board as well and there's a really cool central mechanism as well where you can only place meeples on the board corresponding to where the king is which is this huge kind of porn and you can only place them in kind of adjacent regions to the king and the way you get the action cards that you want is by bidding on them by playing these power cards and this is the higher the power card you play the first dibs you're going to get on the action cards but you can't always play the higher cards because you know not only because you can you only pay them once so you've got to be careful but when and where you're going to use them and but also you want to pay the lower cards because if we if you only pay higher cards you're not going to have a kind of income of meeples to keep placing onto the board this is a game that's so simple is tactical strategic it's got everything you want is constantly engaging the board is constantly shifting but the rules overhead is very easy to digest and it is an absolute classic game and just a testament to the genius of Wolfgang Kramer at number three I have raw by Rhino Knut SIA now rah is an auction style game I think it's probably his most its most famous auction style game and again this game I think it dates back to the 90s as well and the idea of the game is basically to collect
different sets of kind of artifacts or Egyptian things and they will score in different manners but the the nuances of this game are so so you know genius and you basically have a bunch of these bidding tokens and on a player's turn the either going to draw a tile from from the bag and kind of place them on the lot that's going to be bid for this turn or you can basically call rah and just basically start the auction for that round and sometimes you might be forced to do so by drawing a riot oaken that because you know what everybody has to bid you've got to be very careful about when and when to call what Rob because you know you could simply say I had a 3-2 bid and my opponent's lowest one is a 5-2 bid I've got to kind of get the most mileage I can out of those out of the tiles I have but at the same time I've got to be careful not to push too far because sometimes you know I could end up getting nothing from right for my tokens and because if you draw a certain amount of rar tokens the round is going to end instantaneously and you're not going to get anything at all so this is a very clever game again one of these games that I think the the depth might not be as apparent initially but the more and more you player is going to reveal itself and for me the best player always wins rah it's just so well balanced and just very clever and definitely one of the the kind of pillars of what's made Reineke it's you
the designer or they're kind of renowned designer their years today at number two I have another classic game with Puerto Rico now Puerto Rico was ranked the best board game in the world for many many years and I can definitely see why because of the depth and rules respondents to that depth it is a game about colonization you are trying to basically get us or produce these different resources in order to ship them off for points and the game uses one of my favorite mechanisms and board games which is kind of this role selection mechanism where you have a bunch of these role tokens or tiles and all you're gonna do in your turn is gonna pick one of those tiles and then you're going to get to do it but everybody else is gonna get to do as well but the person who's Tyler is gets a slightly improved version of that and they might be kind of to buy these buildings but you get a discount if you're the one to choose it or if you're selling you might get like a extra bonus to do so but the the depth of this game is it's a real different feel to a lot of other games because you've got to be very aware about the state of every other player involved in the game because when you choose certain actions you've got to be not only worried about how much you're gonna benefit yourself but how much you're gonna benefit other players and it's always that kind of discrepancy or gap in between how much you're going to benefit yourself and other players which is going to win you the game you've got to be aware that you're you're advancing yourself more than you are the other players I'm at all times and if you play this game in
the wrong way you're going to absolutely you know shoot yourself in the foot but I love the simplicity of those different actions you know some of them are just to take money some of them as I said to buy building some of them are to load your ships some of them are to produce goods and some of them are to buy new kind of plantations in order to produce more goods but as I said the the board state is everything in this game the the player interaction is just injected into this game that many other games just can't kind of compare with because it is fundamental on on everything you do in this one it is a classic it is so well renowned and so rightly so it holds up great to this day and it's just an amazing elegant example of board game designing and finally at number one I have the second game by Mac Gertz first being the Nvidia door this one is Concordia now for me when I think of elegance in in board gaming Concordia is the first game this brings to my mind it is just the most amazingly streamlined game with the most depth that I've ever played in my life the the premise of the game is you're basically trying to travel around I'm all these different regions of the world trying to set up trade houses and buy cars the score multipliers at the end of the game based on how many trade houses you're in all the different regions you're in all the different kind of goods you're producing but the system of the game is so simple because everybody's going to start with an identical set of cards and you're going to play one of those cards and do
what it says on them some of them it--be traveling around something might be to reap resources something might be to buy new cards in your hand which obviously give you new new abilities to do but they also give you what the the cards only aren't only important for what they do but they're also important by the way you score at the end of the game because they're going to amplify your multipliers based on the good type they're assigned to so say for example I think the Saturn cards you're going to score a point for each region your end times the amount of Saturn cards you have and the weight of the decision is so important because not only do you want the abilities themselves but you also want those endgame multipliers as well so streamlined and just agonizing agonizing decisions throughout because you want to be the first to do everything like you are in in the Riva door now you want to be the first to buy those cards when they come out you want to get the first into the cities because if you don't get in the cities first you're gonna have to pay more money to get in them and that can really ramp up yeah this game is a masterpiece it is one of the most I said most elegant designs out there it is streamlined is deep as anything and there's so many things to explore and yeah I cannot fault this game in terms of its design it's just absolutely incredible incredible game and I think everybody should play this one and appreciate how well it's been put together so I hope you've enjoyed this top 10 list of my most oh my favorite elegant games there are more that I could have put on this list but and it was quite hard to narrow it down as I said it's a real trait that
I looked for and I just really do appreciate it when designers are so you know intelligent to not only make a great game but to make it easy to play as well and so yeah I hope you've enjoyed the review if you have please hit like and subscribe to my channel check out my other videos too you can also support me by following me on Instagram or backing me on patreon and I put the links below for those but for everyone else I'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye