Three Wargaming Rules Mechanics That Need to GO
Transcript
in this video I'll tell you about three different mechanics that pop up in many different War Games rules these days and I wish they didn't I like to talk about wargaming rule sets on this channel from time to time and it's for several different reasons number one the rules are are how you play the game it's not the lore it's not the art it's not even like the models or the terrain it's the rules that Drive the experience of the game play you may be really into the intellectual property of a certain game franchise I kind of referred to it as Vibes in a in a relatively recent video pcha but if you're going to be playing the game you know for that IP whether it's the attached rule set for that game or you're going to decide to move the lore you know that you like over to a different rule set that you like more either way rules are super important secondly I've been designing miniature games with my good friend Vince venturella for the last three years now he does the majority of the rules design of course and the writing and whatnot but we meet weekly and he bounces you know the new systems and rules that he's designed off you know off of me and then you know to get my feedback and stuff and then I do the same with the art and the layout and the visuals which is kind of my area right I bounce that stuff off of him you know it's because we're
collaborative but with all of the games that we've designed in the last 3 years it's kept gaming rules and what I like and don't like pretty front and center in my mind so I want to tell you about some things some mechanics and stuff like that that I don't personally like to see in wargaming Miniatures design again my opinion right not some of them are newer things that you start to see and some of them have have been around for like a long time probably too long in my opinion however I'm not doing this to like you know call out specific companies or designers or anything like that I'm doing it to help you maybe realize what it is about certain rule sets that bug or annoy you I want you to kind of start a discussion in your own mind or maybe even you know in your gaming group about what you like and dislike in wargaming rules my hope is to help you start to find games that you enjoy playing all right so the first thing that I don't enjoy in war games custom dice now I don't mean like fancy six Siders with like a cool logo printed on the six or whatever you know cuz honestly I have custom tabletop Minions d6s that I'll start selling eventually online you know through the website and what whatnot I I've been selling them at local conventions and things like that around here for years so it's not that those are fine you know if you're into
that kind of thing when I say custom dice I mean dice with specific symbols designed only for use with a specific game right you know they've got special symbols on there and all that kind of stuff and they're designed just for this particular game think Star Wars Legion uh Star Wars shatterpoint uh Marvel crisis protocol man like atomic mass and asmod love that custom dice life evidently and you know but there's certainly plenty others as well you excuse that I hear for making custom dice for your war game is that it gives the designer you know far more outcomes and resolution possibilities than just using regular like six-sided dice or whatever Um this can sort of be true right you know usually regular dice only give you kind of simple outcomes you need to roll a three up which is to say three or higher or four up which is four or higher you know or whatever but there's a lot that you can do with standard dice as you roll just like a few more of those dice you know if you if you even just throw 2d6 right the 2d6 gives you this really interesting bell curve in the results that can really sort of expand on the way that the rules can show and utilize Randomness here's an example of not needing custom dice right uh there was this game called Wrath of kings that I really enjoyed years ago it was made by coolman or not who loves to make Miniatures games and
then cancel them as far as I can tell that really is part of the business model I'm not sure how that all works but anyway they made really cool models it was a really cool game had cool lore all that kind of stuff and then they canceled it anyway uh in Wrath Of Kings every single unit that you'd have in the game no matter what it was you know a hero unit a regular unit a whatever they all had this little kind of bar next to them like in the book and stuff like that and it was a 1 through 10 bar so you would take a d10 10id a die and you would throw it and then it would give you a number a four let's say for an example then you would look for that creature and you'd see a little bar next to them and you'd look at the four and next to the four there would be a little symbol and that symbol would maybe mean miss or hit or crit or like lots of different possible States and things like that the trick was is that every single creature unit whatever in that game had a different little bar next to it so they could very easily make it so that well this creature rarely ever hits so they're misses until you get to the six but then when it does hit it does tons of damage or maybe this you know particular model hits a lot but never crits or whatever and then in that situation using a normal 10-sided die you can get a lot more possible outcomes for all the different units than making these like specific custom fancy schmancy dice that a person has to buy extra if they lose them and all that kind of stuff it just makes more sense if you want to have that kind of granularity and change things up so much to put it on the on the you know on the card or on the page or whatever as
opposed to putting it on the dice generally I believe that companies want to use custom dice for their games because then it's just another thing that you have to buy from them you know say what you will about games workshops overpriced fancy schmancy you know d6s they're not required to play the games they're just nice to have and you can take them or leave them you can also use white d sixes that you pull out of old yatsi games that you pick up at the thrift store too if you want GW don't care but try and play like Fallout Wasteland Warfare without their crazy custom like weird d12's that's a problem the next thing that I don't really like to see in war games rules I go Yugo activation which is basically the way that Warhammer 40K does it if you don't know what it was called it's called I go you go uh what is means is that when it's your turn you move your entire Army right then you shoot with your entire Army you charge and fight you know pretty much with your what your entire Army who's ever within arm you know hand toand combat range and all that kind of stuff and the only thing that your opponent does during most of your turn is you know roll some armor saves and maybe generally a little bit of hand-to-hand combat if you know if they're already engaged with an enemy then once you are finally done then it's your opponent turn to play and then you just sit there the turns alternate like this like I go and then you go you know
hence the name until the game is over that's it and I find it pretty boring at least in age of Sigmar you roll to see who goes first every turn and not just at the beginning of the game only once right therefore in age of Sigmar you could have a player who gets who goes at the end of let's say turn two and then goes again right away at the beginning of turn three and both players kind of have to plan for that possibility in 40K the order is picked at the very beginning and doesn't really change at all during the game but there are tons of other and I would say more interesting activation systems out there for tabletop War Games heck even you know Legions imperialis which is also from Games Workshop uses a better activation system than most of the rest of their bigger kind of army games in this game in Legions you basically it's alternating activation but it's phased so it's the movement phase I move a unit you move a unit I move a unit we go back and forth like that and then when it's like shooting then I shoot with a unit and then you shoot with a unit and all then we get to combat so it's alternating but it's still this happens in this phase and this happens in this phase and that kind of stuff right like and then there are other games out there that use alternating unit activations where you pick a unit and then you do all of the stuff that they can do moving attacking all the other special actions maybe that they have available to them and then your opponent does the same with one of their units but activation
can be based off of stats like in Star Wars X-Wing or by like pulling a die randomly from a bag like in bolt action there's tons of options why does it matter well because the rules are making the story happen in your games as you play them in bolt action as I mentioned there's like a serious fog of War going going on it's World War II and there's explosions and smoke in the air and you don't know what's going to happen next hence why you pick a die either in your color or your opponent's color like randomly out of the bag to see who goes next in IO youo it's more of a foregone conclusion but War doesn't happen in an orderly fashion you know also IO youo makes it really boring for the person who turned it isn't so there's that too and the last rules mechanic that I could do without uh bad list customization the worst offender amongst the games that I know is the 2021 version of kill team I loved kill team 2018 because you could like really build the type of list that you wanted to for your Force now sure you couldn't use like every model available in a faction from Warhammer 40K right like you couldn't be like I'm going to put in a land Raider that you know but you could use a lot of the foot troops especially when they released the elites add-on on kind of later on like 2019 I think then Along Came the new version of kill team in 2021 and then
your Force could only field between one and two types of units and only certain numbers in most games you're given a bunch of different types of units to choose from and then you know those units or maybe models if it's a skirmish game instead of an army game they all have a certain like value or they have points or something like that and you have a fixed number of points to spend on your force and then you just do the math sometimes there are like other requirements for the force as well besides just the maximum amount of points uh maybe you have to include a leader character or maybe you can only field a certain number of a specific unit so you don't spam too many of them or or whatever but you as the player have a certain amount of agency over your own force and that's important to making them feel like your own force in the new version of kill team 2021 if you use the compendium specifically then you can usually only take like two fire teams and that means only two different types of units now it could be two of the same unit which would be even kind of worse or you can use two different types of units that's mainly the long and short of it pretty much uh you might get to tweak some weapon choices on the units but not too much I don't think my old favorite uh nekron kill team was a combination of Immortals Warriors a single death Mark and then some flade
ones that I had made myself cuz the new ones weren't out yet there's like no way to make that list you know in the new version of kill team now I know some of you are typing in the comments right now but you like combat Patrol and spearhead Uncle Adam and there's no list building in those games and you're right but I look at those two different kind of games you know as easy beginner forces to get a player into 40K and age of Sigma respectively that's what they were built to do and a big problem that new players have is something called analysis paralysis when when trying to build a new list if you just give them the list up front right so that they don't have to worry about well how many of these should I take and did I take enough of those and do I have enough points and all that kind of stuff it just allows them to then focus on learning the game both of those formats no matter what GW says again are designed to get you into the bigger games so those are the three main things that I don't like to see in wargaming rule sets there are plenty of Runners up like like really massive giant thick Rule books with way too many rules and also you know games that require very specific models or terrain to play but these three things that I just mentioned are the biggest red flags that generally keep me away from from some war games these days do you agree with any of my choices what do you think about him do you disagree do you have other choices
that you don't like to see in wargaming rules these days let us all know down in the comments below if you like videos like this then it would be great if you'd hit the like button down there it really helps out the channel it helps out me more people get to see this kind of video if you'd like to see videos like this every single Friday there's also a subscribe button down there you can click on for free thanks for watching