The Best and Worst of --- Uwe Rosenberg
Transcript
I'm hungry hello welcome I'm Luke Hector and this is the broken me a show where I Raven rant about board games but usually more the latter if you hear somebody kicking a football around outside sorry about that I'll be sending some angry Vikings over to those kids very soon tell them I hate them this is a continuation of what seems to have started off as a pretty popular series my best and worst of Series this was something I kind of suggested on the podcast and then people like the idea I came out with one for stonem games for a publisher and it took off really well I mean it's had a decent amount of views and it got a lot of Engagement of people discussing whether they agree or disagree or what their choices would be so I figured all right yeah this has got some legs and it's worth giving a few more episodes now ideally I want to focus this on Publishers and designers because I feel like mechanics are best done with a top 10 list although maybe I'll be able to throw the old mechanic one in there here or there it kind of really depends it varies from moment to moment so today we're going to focus on OU Rosenberg OU Rosenberg is a designer who I'm very curious to try out the game whenever I know he's involved but he has two very distinct paths for what games he's designing and occasionally they cross paths but for the most part he heads down to very distinct routs you either have the big farming Euro games
usually involving a heavy dose of resource management corn feeding your people because I swear this guy was starved as a child like didn't get enough food as a kid therefore he takes out on everybody else in his games I'm hungry all those ones where you got to build buildings get your Farms get your resources going feeding people that's one leg of what he does the other leg is typically abstract so we've got quite a lot of polyomino games that feat shirt with him stuff like Patchwork and College garden and Indian summer you know he tends to like a lot of these Tetris ones and as I say sometimes the genre was cross where we had Feast of Odin if you remember that one which was basically a mixture of building up farms and doing resource management but then also the insane abstract Tetris stuff so put them all together and you get Feast of Odin so yeah I've not played every single game by uie Rosenberg but then just like with the ston mar one I did before and of course any future lists I do with this series neither have you all right just accept it I can't play every single game that every designer and every publisher has done nor can anybody therefore this is going for my own experience it's subjective just like everything but I'm certainly not going to hold back now when I say worst honestly it's not really that bad most of a we Rosenberg stuff that I don't like as much tends to be below average maybe average but I can't think of a game off the top of my head for oie Rosenberg where I would consider it to be bad like we're talking 32 one out of 10 so he does tend to make a lot of games I'm still willing to play even if they're not going to be my favorites but
certainly there are quite a few that I've seen as I was looking through my board game gek rankings that I do put as five or six out of 10 so he has made a lot of average and above average games whereas there's not that many that have gone into the sevens eight nine and 10 so it's not so much they're worst they're just my least favorite get over it so my third least favorite is one of his bigger farming Eur games and it's a fairly recent one in the mix uh but it didn't get a huge amount of Buzz I know some people are fans of it but I don't think it it took off quite as much as the other so I don't reckon I'll be in a minority with this one but the biggest problem with Hal is that Halo had an interesting premise it had Progressive worker placement so you know the more that you went to a spot you know with all the other players the more expensive and workers it got okay that was something new and different the rest of it is pretty much everything you've seen in a Rosenberg game to date so there was nothing really new but the thing that held this one back particularly was the card system the card system in this on paper at first I thought I was going to like the problem is is that yes you can play these cards and they can get you really cool combos you know actions and scoring and such but the problem is that they are incredibly swingy because all the card drawer that you do in this game is essentially drawn at random so you could just have a game where you draw useless cards you could have a game where you draw the best cards you could ever need oh I can get points if I can
trade in you know six sheep and eight or this well I'll just draw a card oh look I just happened to get exactly what I need well that's good for me and you don't want a long Euro game to have that kind of swiny luck in it you know if they had like face up displays or some other mitigation and fine but this game has very little of any mitigation for those cards and it just kind of makes the game feel very random compared to a lot of other big euros add to the fact that it was also it came out at a time when we already had so many of these games it was kind of getting to the point where we needed something different and you know something a little bit new something with a little bit of a Twist that's different from the original formula and this one just didn't feel different enough it's like yeah I think when I reviewed it I might have given it a six out of 10 when I first reviewed it it's definitely gone down since but I think the words I would have used is this just feels like another Rosenberg game like nothing new nothing less just kind of exists so it's not one I can get too harped up about but yeah just not one I can get particularly excited about either see there's two sides to every schw so my second choice is down the other path of games that he tends to make which is the abstract games now most of the abstract games that he makes with the whole Tetris scene are fine they're nothing special but they're not bad either I kind of consider to be mostly above average I mean probably the best one he's done is Patchwork which Still Remains on my shelf mainly because because it's a good Gateway two-player game but honestly I can't remember the last time I played it and it's just like
it kind of just sits there to fill a niche for Gateway games but this one is one that I think was fairly recent and it covers a theme that I particularly like although the theme is kind of lost with this one it is very abstract not too long but New York Zoo just felt like a big dud for me it it didn't go as well as I would have hoped I thought oh yeah I'm building up a little zoo with animal pieces this is going to be great but what really hurts with this game is that I just found it fundamentally boring and fiddly as hell you the the actual gameplay of it where you just move around the track and decide whether you want animals or tiles and then just build up the tiles on your board again we've seen this so many times and I think this has the same problem that Halo did with the farming genre this one came out at a time when I think pretty much the entire gaming population got sick and tired of all of these you know polyomino Tetris shaped games I mean even to this day if you tell me that your game or if anybody here is that the game is a polyomino Tetris game then I think people just roll their eyes and go really another one and be honest in the last year how many of them have actually been released I haven't seen many I think the trend is starting to die out on Tetris shaped games and it's kind of about time really but this was definitely coming out at kind of like the end of that bubble and it's just like oh look another tety game but then okay you got the animal pieces and you have the different animals and they breed that seemed all right this is the life except that it's fidd or get out you've got a you've got these tiny
little tiles in this fairly small board not a big board and you've got all these cool little wooden meatles which I thought great component wise but then you have to balance all of these animals on your rotten board in big clustered groups of different types and shapes and sizes and they breed and then you try to get more in and I don't have the biggest hands ever but even these feel like you know inbred like Meander fall stumps like big good strong hands trying to get these animals to stop falling over or shuffling or anything if you remotely knock your board it's a nightmare and this just got very very frustrating from a component perspective but that alone wouldn't kill a game for me it would just be really annoying but here it just happened all the time and then it was on top of H this doesn't feel like an interesting abstract game I mean he's done several of them in the past and I just would rather play one of those really they probably got simpler rules CU even this New York Zoo did have a couple of weird Edge rules with how the placement worked and how the breeding worked and it's like I feel like we could have done this simpler it doesn't feel like you know it's meant to be a simple game but it is by no means Gateway it just kind of went too much with the whole fiddlin aspect that I couldn't really teach it to New Gamers it just fell outside of that that I that that kind of category and there are much better abstract games I could use for teaching new players I even iie Rosenberg ones I mean yes you can teach Patchwork but what about Alice's Garden that I've been raving about all the time
probably the best Gateway level polyomino game in existence and most people haven't even heard about it unless you check out my review or shop at Kender often so it's it's one of those things that it just it's not a bad game but it's just again another abstract game and you know as much as I like A revers and B's designs I feel that he does need to inate a little bit more with recent designs CU if he keeps rinse some repeating the same formula all the time it is going to get stale your mother and my worst R Rosenberg game again below average it's not that I consider this bad but every time I've played this game I just don't have a good enjoyable time with it and you know this is I think the reason this is also suffering worse than the other two is because the other two suffer more from the fact that they're just oh it's another one of these well this is one of R's older games I forget when it came out but quite a while ago and it's a small card game it's not even a big farming game it's not even well I suppose food is themed and it's certainly not an abstract tile laying game this is just a card game about collecting beans I'm sorry I just didn't really get into Bonanza bonanza's you know concept is fine you know you're drawing cards at random so again not really much in the way of mitigation but you can't reorder the cards in your hand okay cool and you're basically trying to plant beans the game play is fine it's nothing that I go particularly crazy for and it's just it kind of just functions and I don't find it that fun but the biggest hit that absolutely kills the game for me is it's way too long even at
the free player count this game seems to just drag on and on and on and if you play with four or five players or I think it was the German version or one other version that allowed you to play with up to seven players that is downright insane yeah you play this with too many players and the game just drags on and on a game that should be like a what 20 minute filler suddenly drags on to an hour plus and it's like that shouldn't happen with a game about collecting and planting beans why is this taking so long and so you know too much downtime in length for a small card game just kills any intention I would want to ever play it again unless you twist my wrist and you have only three of us maybe even then I would ask if you got like a kind of speed variant to play the game with it just takes far too long and with that in mind at least the other two that I've mentioned Hal is not the longest of all his big Euros but it's too long for the amount of Randomness it has and New York Zoo as much as I hate you know the fiddlin of it and don't really find a gameplay that interesting at least New York Zoo doesn't take that long to finish for what it is but this one being a small card game just has a habit of outstaying its welcome really really fast and just doesn't end up being good for me Bean B beans they're the beest okay we're done with the worst I'll talk more about about some of the close sces later let's talk about three positives though let's get on to three games that I adore from OU Rosenberg at the moment now I am going to make one caveat here you might be expecting me to
put Black Forest on this list I'm dis I'm disregarding that from the criteria for this list though because or whatever the words I'm disallowing it I'm you know whatever whatever the word you want to use but basically it's not allowable because I only played it once it's not long enough for me to gauge that it's a fantastic game overall until I actually get to play it it and all the like but I have only just played it once as a prototype it seems a little bit too soon to be calling it one of my favorite games even though it could possibly have made my top three favorites with the first play I've made I know I need to try out some more so that one will just have to wait so my third favorite game is something that takes well what I said earlier about him needing a bit of a twist with some of his mechanics you know so it's not just the same two all the time this one actually did that it still feels like one of his farming games but the mechanics aren't the same as with a lot of his stuff like a gular conver and a few of these other ones you know it does something a little bit different with tracks that the resources as you take them off the tracks then increase the production of other things on those tracks so it's a very heavy resource management system but the rules for this are very straightforward and it teaches you so much
as I was saying atwa this one is one of his newer games advanced level which apparently is less than expert level somehow but this one is kind of a mediumweight Euro game where you have fruit bats take that you way one of Satan yeah this one teaches you all about fruit bats and stuff which you never would have known before but it's a pretty nice solo mode in here it's a nice multiplayer system but the idea is is that you essentially have worker placement spots where you go and collect resources okay we've seen that before but you get to have a massive bag for the fruit bats you know all these bats can just be all over your boards but the idea is is that you have a personal board these tracks on and they've got the things like trees and the fruit on the trees and the goats for milking and population and the idea is is that they fill up this whole board but then you take them off and as you take them off you produce more of the other stuff so for example if I get you know four like wild animals off my board I produce two trees in the production phase okay well if I get four or five no if I get five trees off my board I get three fruit and if I get free fruit on my board I get a bat so these all sort of cascade into each other allowing you to produce some really good production combo turns but then you've also got these like Square grid cards with the different locations on and your resources go on those grid cards but you have to be careful not to pollute the area while you're trying to get gold which is another resource because it restricts the amount of space you use the thing I like about this one
is that it feels smooth and fast even though this game will take you about a 90minut time to finish I mean it is a pretty good 30 minutes per player system and honestly yeah 2 hours is the absolute Max time that should take you it is doable in 90 minutes though but it gives you a lot of really ansty decisions like trying to figure out right well hang on um if I've got a killer resource or maybe I should kill the tree but that means I don't produce one of those but if I produce more fruit that means I can get more bats I need the bats to fill that for next turn great but also just trying to position everything on your board because you've only got so much land space and the tiles that you can get I mean I say tiles they are cards but they look like them but those grid cards are ones where they they're very different so you might have one that can house a ton of trees a ton of fruit but can't have any animals on it and then you might have one with all the animals but no space to put fruit you might really need somewhere that can house bats you there are a couple of edge rules where you can put them in your houses that aren't occupied by families and families can train the bats like they did in this region but sometimes you just need to find a Haunted Cave to put a bunch of bats in there's a lot of spatial awareness that goes into this as well as a clever system of resource management and then top it up with a nice spring clean of very simple worker placement with action spaces some of which change as the round goes on the rest of them are pretty constant so there's not like anything particularly complex here and yes you might argue that variety is a little restricted cuz even even though you've got all the different location cards the board doesn't really change at all every
game apart from just the orientation of some of those action spaces but I don't know I just find this one quite a clever system and I think it's because it gives me a good resource management game but keeps it at midweight level because R Ros mode tends to make those games really heavy or like have a lot of rules in them and this one I just like for being nice and smooth and a little different again just something a little bit different is enough to you know potenti earn an extra point for me if it's still a fun game behind it because I don't have to feel like oh this just feels like another Rosenberg cuz it doesn't it really doesn't feel like another Rosenberg in fact honestly if you took out his name you might almost think this was actually from a different designer it really doesn't feel like his other stuff but yeah I know has surprised me this was a bigger hit for me than I thought it was going to be so my number two now we're getting into the big Euros for H Rosenberg the big chunky here's a box full of a million pieces and a ton of options almost sandbox like and this one has been one of my favorite games in my collection for a long time it's probably been my favorite Ur Rosenberg game for a long time although one has now eclipsed it but this one also killed another iie Rosenberg game which some people may argue didn't get killed by it there is a ongoing war between these two factions I mean you've seen House of the Dragon you know brackens versus the or whatever the other side was the ones who have been at
War for like centuries or something yeah think that but we're comparing agria with cavera now cavera is right there in this giant box yep so we've got the Forgotten fol expansion there we go nice big expansion there and cerer itself huge box sorry I respect agric okay I like the occupations in Agri I just think they're too sweet in random you know you could just get dealt a bunch of those really good ones at the start even with the draft phase you might just end up with a killer combo of cards that people can't match I also don't like the fact that it caps your points I hate the fact that it negatively affects your points if you just don't happen to grow one carrot here and one cow there that just seems really stupid and the fact that you must get children in a gria you cannot win a gria with your basic parents you have to get like new kids every now and again and it's so hard to get kids while still doing anything else that it feels just too restrictive and too punishing for my liking this one took that premise took out the occupations which is a bit of a shame but it gives you a bucket load of buildings you can make and makes it a lot more sandbox and like looser so that when I play this game got a few little summary sheets and that I get to decide what I want to do I don't have to grow a carrot while I'm trying to be the biggest grain farmer I don't have to get a donkey because I just choose to be king of the carrots or whatever you know I can choose what I like but M does have a lot of stuff in it I mean this scene has got you know boards Galore you know
different boards with different player accounts all these player boards all these building boards although I have deliberately removed from game I think I probably I might have to spare somewhere I might even put them in the bin the sixth and seventh player board because frankly if you are playing CNA with six or seven players you are insane and I'm probably going to commit you at some point are forite because Jesus Christ who the hell wants to play this with six or seven players but I got the folded space insert so everything's nice and organized and all these pieces I mean I've got the little piggies gold sheep donkey stone ruby gems all the player pieces take those Out Below we've got then you grating I think I've even like changed some of these cuz I'm not sure they look like pumpkins in the normal game but we'll see but I've got some upgraded Uh Wood pieces you know just like different shape actual look like logs R in the weird Twigs that they normally come with the game and let's see if I can get these two out here we go so yeah all the tiles nicely organized it makes getting this one out setup wise a doal compared to what it used to be before with the exception that you have to populate these building boards with a bucketload of buildings that gets a little bit monotonous but uh you can't have everything but I just like the fact that I can choose what I want to do in this game you know I can decide if I want to do nothing but sheep donkeys cows maybe I want to go adventuring maybe I just want to stay in my cave I have actually played an albino dwarf dwarf strategy where I've had six dwarfs in a cave never went outside you know the fact that I tend to win this
game a lot more than I lose it when I'm teaching players because obviously learning this for the first time you're at a pretty big disadvantage compared to someone who knows what they're doing I tried to do weird strategies and that happened to be one of my weirdest ones I tried I can't remember if I won or not I might have still done but man it was weird doing it now even when you have this in mind having forgotten folk now allows me to throw in these expansion races where where almost You could argue that it's good giving players this if it's their first game because it puts you off wanting to do certain aspects of the game and focuses you on a particular path which might you might argue is easier for new players I'm still on the fence about that it's there are pros and cons to both re to both ways of thinking but you know any chance that I get to use these expansion races including like some of the promo ones I've got I'll definitely take it and yes I did try to get it all in this box but it really doesn't work at least not easily so I'm happy enough to have the second backs don't however get the F the Frantic fiend expansion oh God check out my review video for that one but that one sucked that one threw in a weird mechanic about attacking Orcs where it felt like it was trying to go back to what a gri was like I don't want cerer to be more like a gri and by that I mean punishing and restrictive I like Cerna because you took that aspect away don't put it back in but yeah that expansion just felt like a waste I mean after so long gone waiting for another expansion you know like oh we got this expansion what else you going to do yes another expansion we've heard about this for ages let's hope it's really good and
none of us liked it nope all of us who played CER the out the people I know none of us liked the expansion and I sold it very fast after like reviewing it I was more than happy to get rid of it so yeah don't get frantic FES but by all means grab yourself Corona what are you waiting for a kiss goodbye now you're probably thinking where you're not going to get any bigger than that are you I mean there's maybe one or two options you could think of but surely CA is like your biggest game that you're going to love you know there's not anything bigger than that or with more options or more stuff to do because surely K's just got enough to do as it is oh my dear doctor you have been naive naive indeed wow um if you thought kerer was like the ultimate farming sandbox Euro you have not seen anything yet at least not until you play my favorite fields of all this game I love this one has climbed up the ranks of my top 100 now granted it's not easy for me to get to the table it's a table hog and it certainly does require me to have a bit of a rules refresher before I play it again because there's so many things you can do in it but if you want a Sandbox euro look no further this is the dictionary definition poster child whatever you want to call it for that thing I mean it's even got a couple of dents on the side which which saddens me but whatever I mean I would love to see fields of V's second edition just to streamline it a little bit maybe not in terms of options but maybe just some of the rule set but this thing allows you
to do so much and of course yes I folded space insert this and it's got a lot in here I mean this is just the boards which all these boards will take up a fair bit of space I mean this is a player board y on well this is sorry this is part of a player board this is just where you can build in terms of your player board where exactly can you take that even further well you could have this board as well you also have this board next to you so yeah you know the players have got quite a little bit on their their board in terms of table space but this thing has so much in it there is just a ridiculous amount of pieces and I feel sad that I'm going to have to try and put all these board back in in a minute but you know it may not look like much you know just that lot with stuff underneath it you know there's obviously a lot more resources underneath some of these uh trays but oh blind me caverna you could do like sheep farming you could do donkey farming mining you could go adventuring you could grow grain grow carrots you know excavate a cave you know go farming you know there's quite a decent amount of stuff you could do in caberna right deep breath okay here you can uh race sheep you can raise cows you can raise cattle you can build all sorts of different buildings you can you know manufacture three different types of clothes you can make leather you can make bricks you can go transport some of your goods to nearby Villages for extra bonuses you can build Vehicles would you like a a horse and car would you like a
plow would you like a you know a fishing boat to to go catch fish or you know find Pete do you want to dehydrate the Pete on your Moors well I mean you've got a bunch of soggy wet patches here you need to get rid of those well drain them and then you can get some Pete well you've got dkes on your board as well you know they normally restrict where you can build you might want to extend your dikes until the seafront so you can do stuff there uh maybe grow some reads you know reads is a good herb that's all fine you know what you need the right tools for the trade so I suggest that you find yourself uh where's the tools board here we go so I suggest that you look at your tools and think about upgrading them you know because it's one thing to say I can chop trees down which you can do in this game as well but maybe I want to make my ovens better my shovels better my slaughtering tables better my fish traps better you know I could also let's see what else I could do here well you know I could even upgrade the workbench itself I could go trade okay that's all good and then throw in the expansion well you know what maybe I'll export some stuff to uh England India you know get some tea bags that let me do more action oh no I've gone crosy Jesus Christ the amount of stuff in this game is insane and it's very overwhelming for a lot of people but man for someone like me who w way to get them into a game is to give me a ton of options all of which feel good and are rewarded is just heaven for me you know this is what I like you when I start
this game and I've got the board set out and all these pieces that and I'm like right what am I going to do this game I might take 15 minutes to on a solo game to start thinking about where I even want to begin because there's so much choice so many different strategies and it's a point salad so everything's rewarded even just upgrading your basic wood to Timber is worth points you know I've got a bunch of leather well I can turn it into some boots they're worth points build myself a plow that's worth points uh I get negative points if I don't dehydrate my Moors soon as I do it's worth less negative points great it's just so much you can do now it is only a one to two player game unless you get the te and trade expansion which of course I do which let you play it with free players not to say that I tend to play this with multiplayer that often I mean two player is great to play this with three player depends on the players you're with but the game is shortened slightly for free players so it does feel a little bit different like you don't necessarily feel like you achieve as much in a free player game compared to a one or two but there are quick start rules in this in the Tre and trade expansion that allow you to kind of accelerate the beginning of the game to make up for that fact and this works in two and especially free player so it work works at all those free counts providing you've got a table big enough to have the boards cuz wow this thing takes up space but I get a blast every time I can sit down with this and yes it's an investment to sit down with this
and get used to it certainly I have to learn a few of the rules again even though a lot of the stuff when you've played a bunch of these Rosenberg games is quite intuitive but I cannot I cannot stress enough how I just love the choice in this I mean it's I played the um Pulsar 2849 on Monday when I was showing it to people one of the things I like about that game is the fact that you have so many options so much choice of what you want to do and you can get points for everything I I guess I just like Point salads you know Point salads feel rewarding because every time you do something you get points now that's not to say I like all Point salads I need to be doing something interesting while getting the points poar is kind of like an exception to the rule but the mechanics just working it here I'm doing all sorts of farming and trading and you know buildings and stuff like that which all you know because I love farming themes works for me but then compare that to something like Barcelona for example which is just a bone dry as hell Euro game that's a point salad that doesn't interest me as much in terms of how you gain points compared to something like this it's a game I absolutely adore it's being threatening to go into my top 10 of all time I'm not sure if it will quite go that high but it was kind of neck and neck with cerer it's now fields of Al without a shadow of a doubt I just love this one it may not get played often but I want to play it that desire is there and that's the sort of thing that makes me you know rate these ones higher trust me if you want a pure heavy sandbox Euro and you
like the farming theme this is the game you hunt down shut up and take my money so there you go three best of three worst of when it comes to OU Rosenberg and you know whenever he makes a game I'm still interested to check it out now granted lately I haven't found a lot stuff he's done that I would kind of get behind I mean I played Apple Jacks at Essen didn't really think that much of it and I feel like he just needs to kind of you know innovate a little bit more with some designs but that being said I did play Black Forest and I thought black forest was amazing so you know there is still potential there and I'm certainly at least interested whenever he designs something but he's got a lot under his belt and you know even though some of them I find kind of more average there're still games I want to play and I still give them respect a 6 out of 10 I respect the game and you could twist my arm to play it but you know I wouldn't want to play it for players I wouldn't want to play it with people who really knew the game CU I know I'm just going to get creamed and I I would just always want to play caverna more now people are probably going to hang me uh from the from the Gallows for not putting Feast of Odin or newsford on here now Feast of Odin is one that I actually have on the Shelf down there I do like it but the rating has gone down over time and the biggest problem problem Feast of Odin has is one the theme is completely lost because all the Viking stuff is irrelevant when you are basically putting Tetris pieces on your board in order to get points by some measure now I do like the fact it has a million actions that you can pick from
even though it's a nightmare to teach this game teaching this game is such a chore again another reason it doesn't come out very often so you might say why don't you just play it solo it does have a good solo mode in it I'll give it that it really does but uh there's a lot of rules to learn there's a lot of spaces to do there's quite a bit going on and it just doesn't hit the table of mat and it's just as big a table hog as field ofal but I still like it I would probably probably rated it an eight when I first played it it's probably a seven now but I do like the game it just wouldn't be top three probably top 10 of an Ur Rosenberg La maybe even top five you never know but probably more like maybe top five who knows but it's certainly a good game it's just not one that I think is like the best ever like some people do there's just a few problems I have with it mostly from the fact that it's just a bit of a nightmare to get to the table in terms of space teaching ruls a lot that it just has kind of just sat there and not done a lot it also needs a Norwegian expansion to even function properly it's very imbalanced if you don't have Norwegians in there uh then news for this one actually was a bit closer to my worst off list I actually considered it instead of the Halo Halo just felt more boring felt more random new for is it's okay but I just found this one kind of underwhelming like nothing about it really stood out as oh this mechanic's really good again it just felt like another Rosenberg game you know nothing particularly different with the one exception that you had
shares right why are shares in my Rosenberg farming game people I mean this is a game about fishing I get to build harbors and catch fish and you have this weird as hell fiddly mechanic for feeding people it's kind of odd I don't quite get how it works but the whole idea that is that oh I need to raise money I can give you a share in my what I'm Rosenberg stay away from shares okay there are Publishers and designers out there who love making these boring economic games about shares all right you don't need to do that you are great at making farming games and resource management and stuff like that keep shares out of my farming game all right so that got annoying and then you had this little like trade like little disc thing to put your fish on and that just became a bit of a fiddly nightmare because you could never fit enough fish on it the piece was too small it it just kind of I don't know it it just felt underwhelming cuz a lot of people really love this game and some people go gooo Gaga for it but when I played it it probably just was overhyped too much but even when I tried it more I just never really got into it it just felt me whatever and I'd give this one a try you know I've been revisiting some older games to see if I'd like them again a bit more maybe maybe I would give this one another try but I don't know nothing really draws me to it I just feel like you know what there's enough farming Rosenberg games I already own some of the best ones I don't need to fill up with all the rest of them if they didn't win me over the first time uh any other ones I would have considered I mean I
already mentioned my thoughts on agria a laav laav is a game that I do like but it is ruined unless you play with a house rule that I have which I think some other people may use as well and if I don't play with this house rule I won't play the game it's the house rule that you make the loans work how loans are supposed to freaking work all right this one has the problem that you you can get all these loans and they give you such a massive acceleration if you get a bunch of them but you might think why hang on getting a bunch of loans is a Bad Thing surely not in this game because you only pay one Buck of interest for an entire wealth of loans that is not how loan Finance works okay okay you can't just take a million loans and take and pay the same amount of Interest no matter what you know I am an accountant I may not be a banker but I know loans don't work that way stupid it's stupid but the thing is all you have to do is just take out a bunch of loans not really care and then the amount of acceleration that gives you I just see people exploit that to high heaven and they completely cream everybody else because even by the end of the game even when paying off all these loans they still have so much in their possession that it doesn't feel like much of a chore and it's like debts are supposed to be bad it shouldn't be good to take debt that's not how it should work so the house rule is that you should pay one Buck per loan do that and the game is actually fixed for me and I would still like it the other
problem with theal is also its player count you have to play this at two or three players you can't play it with more because I forget how it works with two players but with three players which is probably the optimal amount two people get free access and I think one person gets two or it's the other way around you know it's two in three actions the problem with four players when you go to that level and then even worse with five is that players get two actions somebody only gets one in a round that doesn't feel great to have to sit for all this downtime of everybody doing all their cool stuff and then you only get one poxy action and it may be just to take fish it it drags on for ages it's way too long and way too much downtime you got to play it with two or three and again that hurts it for me now I do want to play some other his older stuff that I have not played so I have not played at the gates of yoang and I have not played Aura and labor however I would really like to try Aura and labor so Aura labora is actually high on my potential buy to try list because I know some stockists locally that have it it's about 35 odd pound to buy not that expensive and I would like to see what it's like see if it's any good for me or not so that's definitely on the list for potentially try to buy Gates of theang I would certainly try it I'm not sure I've been wanting to buy it to try it but certainly if somebody puts it in front of me I would certainly be Keen to give it a go this designer is one that I do enjoy their games I mean I've got Fields ofile ATA cerer Feast of odm Patchwork I think oh yeah agric all creatures big
and small it's fine just wouldn't be one that I would put on there and glass Road that's on the Shelf in the other room very good game I warmed up to it but it wouldn't be top three so I've got a lot of his games on on my shelves you know this is a designer I genuinely like and I'm looking forward to Black Forest later this year but I'm hoping that we'll start to see some new ideas from him and not just the same stuff all the time because like I mentioned with Halo and um New York Zoo rehashing the same and even news SW rehashing the same thing all the time can get a little problematic so until next time remember regardless of whether you were starved as a child just feed your people and remember it's only a game take care bye for now