Skip to main content
Loading video...

My 2025 Best Board Game Nominations | 2025 Punchies

Transcript 21:56

2025 is almost done and it is time for the inaugural a nomination for the punchies. You might ask, what are the punchies? Well, I honestly just made them up. They're essentially the cardboard's people's choice awards. And we have a variety of categories that we're going to start to nominate some games for. Discord has already gotten a head start here, so some games are nominated. But what I would need you to do right this second or actually right after you watch this video and feed the algorithmic gods, go on over to crdbbrd.ap if you haven't already, sign up and nominate games. We're going to do this for a couple weeks, week and a half probably by the time you see this and then we're going to go into final voting and that final voting will crown 2025's best. Some things to note here are some of these games are technically published in 24 or 26. board game industry is very very odd in how games actually get published and distributed. A lot of games come out in essence sort of near the end of the year or too late in the year to actually arrive to the normal folk. So in this case, you can nominate whatever you'd like. We're going to let the votes land where they may be and just let the people speak on the absolute best games of 2025 asterisk when you got the game. So once you do uh navigate to the 2025 punchies and you can start to nominate stuff. Pretty easy to do. Uh if you want to nominate a fresh game, go ahead and do it right

here. Um this is for best expansion. You can also second nominations and also share your thoughts because they get posted over here on this live feed. And I'm going to go over what you have to say about these games when ultimately we crown winners at the end of the year. So, first off, my nomination for best expansion. I really don't have one. I haven't really played enough Valenwood, but I'm going to go ahead and stick with that nomination. We'll get to why a little bit later. It'll be uh apparent, I think. Most anticipated for me. This is sort of a 2026 award because what are you excited for going out of the year or coming out of 2025? For me, if I can remember what I nominated here. Oh. Oh, it's right here. Aquaria. I nominated Aquaria mostly because of this. Tomas, I think it's Tomas. I think that's how you say that. Hol is becoming one of my absolute favorite designers. Si at the tiptop of my absolute favorite games.

Galileo Galilee, a really solid interesting action selection mechanism. and Tea Garden, which will come up later, so I won't say anything about Tea Garden, but a fun deck building game. Um, I'm also I have not played The Asylum. I don't even know what that is, but Pawnscape is one that was on my anticipated list for Packs Unplugged, so I'm excited about that. So then when I saw Aquaria was coming out. So the TLDDR on this thing is action selection tableau building where placing aquarium cards managing oxygen and timing filter triggers generate income and endgame victory points. Aquaria is where people step into the shoes of a dedicated members of the aquarist aquarist society. Each striving to create the most impressive aquarium. So we are building an aquarium right now. Key mechanics here, hand management, set collection. I have been really interested in the way that Tomas Holk has integrated action selection into a pretty unique mechanism in basically every single game that I've played. So, I'm excited here. I think the theme is pretty darn cool. So, that's my nomination. We have best crowdfunding campaigns, and I'm actually going to abstain. I've done nothing but build this app over the last year and I have not been paying attention at all to crowdfunding until right now. And as you can see, I have a new feature around crowdfunding campaigns and um I think

you all are going to really like that. So stay tuned for that. But I don't really have a great pick here. Agricula special edition is probably something I will upvote. I'm a fan of Castles of Burgundy Special Edition. So I'm guessing that this one should be pretty incredible. I will say in terms of the campaign and it's running, I don't really have a perspective, but I'm going to vote either way. Hidden gym. My hidden gym is Tea Garden, and I had mentioned Tea Garden, Tomas Hol. This is a deck building area expansion game. I really enjoy the deck building. I think there's some really interesting things around aging uh tea leaves on your board and playing cards and the timing around that. This is a game that I actually probably should make a video on. I don't know how many people will watch it. This game kind of came and went pretty fast.

Not a ton of hype, but I think it was a blast to play. It's still in my collection. It's going to continue to be in my collection. You are expanding your tea territories and acquiring better cards. It's a nice kind of economic game and deck building in a format that I hadn't really expected at all. In fact, I ordered this before I even knew it was a deck building game. And there was just a I don't know, more depth to the deck building than I had expected. Not the deepest deck building, but in the format and theme, I thought it was surprising and super fun. Best rule book by far is Galactic Cruise. And one of the reasons is actually the player aid. I guess it's technically a rule book, and this is a game that has a lot of layers to it. I had some critiques on it around the level of depth compared to the rules or the the the ROI of depth in a part in the game relative to the rules if that makes sense. But it becomes much easier to understand and just to figure it out when you're using this player aid. And I think it's an eight-page player aid. So that kind of shows you how many layers there are to this game from like a rules perspective. One of the things I really liked about this is this how do I get area and that is a thing I am constantly asking myself in games is it talks about certain terms but I have no idea how to go get those things especially in a multi-resource game where we're talking about reputation money ads and three different resources there's a lot going

on here and I thought the actual rulebook setup or layout was really really good and most importantly I really enjoyed this player aid and I hope more games do it. You know, I hope more games use this as a model because I thought it was uh really helpful. Best heavyweight game. I didn't play a ton of super heavyweight games. I think Speak Easy is probably one of the main draws here. Um I have Luier, which I think is closer to a midweight. Let me check. Luier's Complexity is at a 6.2. Rules overhead 6.2. But my pick, which might be a pick a little bit later on, is Elder Scrolls. It was, you know, it's not the heaviest game in the world. I think there's a lot of layers to rules specifically. The enemy skills are kind of just tough to comprehend and keep track of. It becomes a relatively heavy mental load. If you're used to chip theory games, it's nothing. It's not a big deal, but if you're new to them, it's probably relatively heavy. And I I had sort of a tough time in figuring out how this thing plays. In fact, I originally had built a flowchart, which gave me an idea to build this flowchart, which you can see here. This is a flowchart of how the game plays and all of the different branches to this game and it's one of the more complex um that uh we did analysis on so far.

Regardless, it was absolutely one of if not the my favorite games of the year and you know it would make sense to live in this category for me. Best lightweight game. This is really tough and I can't remember which one I originally had nominated here but I've upvoted both. Soda Jerk and Flip Tunes. I love Flip Tunes. It's deck building and drafting. You're trying to get to 30 fame. You do so by building a deck that's more and more efficient. The great part about this game, it's the only decisions you have or what cards you're building or what cards you're buying and trying to create synergies like any other deck building game with everything else kind of stripped out from the game. Because when you actually play cards, you flip them and place them on a schedule essentially. two rows of three. All kinds of zany things happen, but they tell you on the cards, this is the perfect entrylevel light deck building game that I will, I don't know, until I find something better, consistently recommend. Soda Jerk, on the other hand, has been something that has really surprised me. super basic, I don't know, card hand management game that you're playing different soda flavors down in front of different fountain fountains trying to increase or decrease their value. And depending on what you have left in your hand, you earn points based upon the net value of the particular card. I've already talked about it before. I thought it was really, really good. In our household at least, this really fun kind of meta game

around trickery and I don't know, hidden intentions is happening and it's been really really fun and it is definitely worth a look at for best light game of 2025. Best party game. This one's easy for me. Magical athlete. Um, I don't know. One of the thing I Bombbusters was one that I was thinking of, but I think it essentially was delivered last year and didn't have one of those crossover years. I just got it late and I absolutely love it. So that technically could live here. At least best party game I found by far was Bomb Busters. But of the games released this year, Magical Athlete was an absolute blast. I've also talked about this one, so I won't go incredibly deep into it. It is a basic roll and move, but every single one of these characters have crazy abilities and it's certainly more of an activity than a game because you have very little agency. You're just rolling dice. The only agency you have are which racers you pick and which race you have them race in because there's four races.

Um, you earn points based upon place. There's another side of the board where you actually earn points if you land on a space. But the fun part is to see how all of these characters interact with one another and just have fun with it. If you have the right group, this is a really fun party game. Best cooperative game. I haven't done a ton of cooperating. I play Elder Scrolls at one. Uh, well, I multi-handed by myself. Unmatched Adventures has not gotten here yet. I hope to play it before I do my final voting. Aridia, I play at one. And I have not played Lord of the Rings and I honestly can't think of a great callout game that I've played this year. I'm going to have to think hard. I'm going have to play Unmatched Adventures, but I don't actually have a nominee right now. But what I will do and I will commit to doing is playing Lord of the Rings. Um I think it's on BGG, you know, so that is super easy. I think it's kind of sold out everywhere else. So, I think by default, Elder Scrolls might win that for me. Once again, it's going to sweep a few different categories for me, but I haven't played it co-op. I just always play Chip Theory games by myself. Best two-player game. My pick is what is looked at as kind of a solo game, but it's Star Trek Captain's Chair. I played a little Imperium Horizons. I'm not a huge Imperium person, not because I don't like it, just because I haven't gotten into it, but I really liked it.

Star Trek and I believe the ship mechanic and the take that ability really had me thinking, is this just a better version of Imperiums that has better interaction between players? I really enjoyed Captain's Chair. I played it as I developed this app, so I never actually reviewed it. It is a top tier game for me, so that is why it is my um favorite two-player game of the year. My best solo game here I could call Elder Scrolls, but for the sake of a little diversity, I'm nominating Dragon Eclipse. I had a pretty robust video on Dragon Eclipse uh much earlier in the year. I played a bunch of it. I played through a whole campaign and I just really enjoyed my experience. And I actually don't think I would love it co-op just because the deck construction part can take a lot of time. the type of people I would ever play this in co-op with wouldn't really enjoy that part of the game, which is actually a really big part of the game. As you start a session, you're actually constructing your deck, which was great. You're opening packs, um, sort of like a TCG and creating your deck. You're acquiring dragons all throughout your adventure.

But the thing I really enjoyed was sitting back and um I don't know experiencing the narrative experience, which isn't something I put a ton of weight in when it in terms of games that I love. I typically would prefer something like Elder Scrolls that skips a lot of the story and gets right to the action. this game. I actually sat back and just enjoyed the ride, enjoyed the story, and the thing that I thought that I would like the most, which is the TCG dragon battling, which was fun, mind you, was actually took a little bit of a back seat. Um, so this is definitely probably my favorite solo experience. Um, it definitely it it at least deserves a mention and a nomination here. Best Euro game for me is Galactic Cruise. Galactic Cruise I have enjoyed immensely. And if you watch my video, I I think I might have come off a little bit more negative than I had meant to.

But with that said, I've actually played it like 30 times more since that review because I've played it on VGA. I've been able to really see more of the nuance there. I still think it's missing some dynamism or some depth that I typically like in games, but I've had a lot of fun and I keep starting a new game on BGA and it's just fun. It's fun trying to get more efficient in a puzzle that is almost the same each time. There's not a ton changing. There's certainly some variables there that have you play a little bit differently. U but for the most part, it's just been great. It's a relatively straightforward worker placement. Gain resources and spend them. The the hook is that you're building a ship. That ship can turn into an engine for yourself and getting more and more resources and you know spurring you forward to launch more and more ships. This is a thematically it's kind of a cool theme, but it doesn't come through really well to me at least. Um, but the mechanics are connected to a theme in that you are a galactic travel agency trying to sell cruises to customers and you do that through um, a resource which I I always forget what it's called. I don't know. It's a marketing resource. Anyways, you get what I'm talking about. Um, this is my favorite Euro game of the year for sure.

Best thematic game for me was Molly House. And the thing that I really appreciated about Molly House, and I haven't played it enough to give you a really great critique on the mechanics and the game, but it was the theme, and it was the boldness and choice of theme. Whly gig known for its historic board games certainly I think went out on a ledge here creating a game based upon the 18th century London mollies where there were men that were dressing as drag and hiding from the rest of society afraid of persecution and I thought I mean I haven't read the actual history but I assume that it's a accurate representation of kind of the turmoil of the time and the clandestine meetings that are happening in these Molly houses. And um I thought it was uh just a really unique and bold choice for a theme. And that's something that I really appreciate in modern board gaming, not having another farming sim, but really thinking outside of the box and trying to gify, especially a historical uh event or time period like this. um bringing awareness to it, something in which I had no idea about.

I absolutely want to recognize Molly House, and I'm gonna probably tell you right now, it was my favorite theme in all of board games in 2025. Next up, best art and presentation. This was sort of a tough one for me. I nominated Shallow Sea and I did this because just the bright and vibrant incredible production that I think Bad Comet is beginning to become known for, especially the mele quality, the cute fish. It's just a really nice implementation in a mediumsiz box. I could have picked Galactic Cruise here. I certainly could have picked Elder Scrolls here, but I want to recognize one of my favorite games of the year um for what was just a really great um experience that is that is really enhanced by the quality of this production. Um I think there's a lot of really great games to make an argument for here and I have like Old King's Crown for example, I haven't been able to get my hands on. I'm still waiting for a Wild Venture to arrive from the Kickstarter. Core Discovery also uh was really cool. So, I mean there's a lot of great games here in this category. Best game mechanic, Ember Leaf. Emberleaf, I was blown away that I have not seen this. And maybe it exists. Maybe the play a card, slide a card mechanic is out there, but I was blown away by the crunchiness of the puzzle that this game presents, which kind of presents as a

hand management game. Play cards for actions. However, there's a new to me at least mechanic on the block that I think will be reimplemented somewhere else. In fact, I've thought about how to design a game using this in a totally different manner. But play a card, you get the onplay abilities, but then some of the cards have slide abilities. And when you choose a slide turn, you slide everything and you activate it from left to right. So, not only are you trying to think about playing cards down for their abilities or what they will slide for, but you can play them anywhere on your board, and that matters because the order in which you slide a card and activate it actually matters. And it is a crunchy resource management game. You have a finite number of spaces to manage your resources within. So, timing around when you're spending those resources or getting those resources is super important. I realize I'm talking about all of this without showing you. Right here is a really great example. This is a full board right here, but cuz you have to slide at this point. And you see all of these left arrows that are saying this is what you get or get to do whenever you slide that particular card.

I thought this was as much as this isn't a deck builder. You are buying new cards. I could see this as being an incredible mechanism paired with true deck building. In this particular instance, it's a means to an end, which is going out around the board and building these uh different towns out. I believe with u your people. There's so many different layers to this game, but I want to recognize the mechanism of play a card or slide a card uh because I thought it was really really fun and created a lot of unexpected crunch. And best in show is Elder Scrolls. I mean, this is best in show is the allaround best board game of the year. here. And when I say all around, I'm talking about art, production, um, quality.

The rule book as well is in there. As much as I didn't necessarily love the rule book here, I had to kind of do my own thing, but I think there's been some changes to the rule book as compared to the the version that I had looked at. But this game takes, and this has already been said, but takes too many bones and I think creates a better system. So, if you like the Too Many Bone system, this system is just better. I played it for over a hundred hours this year. I definitely played this game longer than absolutely anything. The building, the characters with all of these different combinations has been a blast. the spatial puzzle by expanding the battle for field from the tiny grid that Too Many Bones gives you to an epic dungeon that you have to crawl through and presents you with an incredible mental puzzle that is also spiced up with the luck of the role that still has plenty of mitigation. It's this perfect meld of board game for people that like that mental almost euro puzzle, which this has nothing to do with a Euro game, but there's there's this aspect of chip theory games in particular that are just more cerebral than a normal dice chucker. And part of that is kind of building your character in the RPG elements and but it's just a really smart battle system that I will enjoy the rest of my life and is probably one

of my favorite games of all time. Does it beat out Too many Bones? That is a different video. But for this year, it definitely deserves a spot. And with that said, that is it. That is the 2025 punches. Go right now to crd.ap and nominate those games. And in a couple weeks, I'll come back and let you know when it's time to vote. said, "Have yourself a great day.

Progress saved