Won't Play Certain Games With Newbies? | TableScraps #61
Transcript
today's topic is well actually if you were part of the group and you'd already know what today's Topic's going to be welcome to table scraps short discussions about board card and tabletop gaming submitted by the viewing audience and discussed with the viewing audience hey there everyone I'm Chaz maror from par of di paradise and welcome back to another episode of table scraps the live stream chat show where we discuss with the audience a topic about board card and tabletop gaming and not only is the discussion done with the people in this chat window but the topics themselves are suggested by the chat as well today's topic of discussion comes from viewer Patrick Doss who wants to ask about newbies in your game group Patrick says Are there games that you refuse to play with new players or are there games that lend themselves towards a quote unquote Niche group only to be exclusively played when those members are present for example I own all the expansions and figures for Star Wars Imperial assault and my group holds an exclusive game night to play through the various campaigns with no Outsiders allowed to participate likewise I own Cosmic Encounter and all of its expansions making it difficult to teach to new Gamers without taking out of all the added materials like the hazard Deck The Defender reward the Technologies the
satellite add-ons and more complex races and all all that stuff that adds flare to the game stripping away these elements makes the game feel well empty and defeats the purpose of buying the expansions in the first place so are there other examples of games that people refuse to play with newbies for one reason or another the main problem that I ran into when starting to think about this topic was that I kept coming back to the point that well in one form or another we were all newbies at one point when I discovered gaming um again I found all of these gaming groups that I had no idea were right under my nose uh you know groups of between 10 to 60 people that get together in my area and in fact um I discovered that there was a convention that takes place every march called GameStorm um in Vancouver Washington so this was like the first actual gaming convention that I went to I didn't know anybody there I went Alone um so I I I had no idea what to expect it was my first multi-day gaming event like this and I was the Newbie I had been collecting games for not even a year yet I had no local game group of my own and I went in there and the first thing I did when they first opened the doors is I walked into the gaming Hall and I stood in the middle of the gaming Hall I watched the people I had no idea what to do I I I had no idea how to get into those groups and someone came up to me
tapped me on the shoulder and said hey you want to join us in a game of dacker and I was like sure let's go so I went I joined him now for anyone who doesn't know dacker is a big huge massive three plus hour game about manipulating the German political um environment it's it's fun and it's cool but it is a big Hefty game that is if of any game out there if you're going to say oh we don't want newbies for this game this would be the game not to introduce a newbie to and this guy came up saw me standing there looking looking lost and invited me to play Die mocker just because someone might be inexperienced with someone so something a game a genre of games might be a newbie um it's no reason really to exclude them just because of the precon that we may have that their lack of experience may lead to a lack of playability the other side of of the coin here is are there let's get back to Patrick's question are there certain groups and games and stuff oh absolutely certainly I have at least three different game groups that I play with um and one of them really likes Euro games one of them is uh friends from high school that we really enjoy some co-ops and every now and then you know some good backstabby type of games and you know then there's my wife and daughter and when we play there's you
know still for some reason backstabby stuff going on but that happens even when we play non-b backstabby games like even Uno or Katan it just happens I don't understand why but that's besides the point the point I am making is that the reason why there are certain groups that I have established and I know I play certain games with them and these can be closed groups that I know I want to play with these certain players isn't necessarily to exclude others but it is because I've learned what these groups like the kind of games that they enjoy and the kind of experiences that we want to have together so Patrick I think to me I do kind of fall into that realm of yes I do set up certain gaming events that are that are set for just certain people but it's not because uh I think noobs are disqualified from participating if that makes any sense starting with our first statement here by Steven who says some games are heavy and just don't serve new Gamers well I love teaching new Gamers but brought out EX librus for new players and one of the players was just lost and you know it was a bad feeling you have to know your group I guess and there you go absolutely reinforces uh my own thinking on this you got to know you got to know the group and sometimes you know getting to know the group means introducing games that aren't going to be the best fit and um you know even
that trial and error experience can still be an enjoyable experience so don't let that fear prevent you from trying new games and introducing people to a variety of games next comment comes from Trevon who says any game with a strong meta game is hard for newbies from the unspoken rules of certain social deduction or the flow of Magic the Gathering some things aren't explained in the rule book trevan continues to say any game that benefits knowing the cards inside and out is hard for newbies if all players know all the cards except one player well they at a huge disadvantage well that that's absolutely true and I I think that goes back to kind of getting in that Groove and learning which games to introduce to which people um because if there's a strong meta there uh it definitely can be a hindrance and when you first mentioned meta I was thinking more just how the people know each other you know I I might know that Bob um is a real backstabber or I might know that um Randy over here loves to earn your trust and then backstab you because he does it every single game and every single game it tricks you but now I'm introducing my own baggage into the conversation so let me move on you're also talking about how The Meta can um you know be a hindrance to to newbies um that's that's
absolutely uh that's absolutely true and you know how do we how do we handle that do we have to break off and have certain games that we play like just one-on-one with those newbies to bring them up to speed do we have all of the newbies play together to get them up to speed or do we just um you know do baptism of fire and just throw them in the game head first and see what Happ happens I'm you know not sure what the best solution is I assume actually that the best solution varies from from person to person from group to group the next statement comes from Richard who says I feel like I've lost some newbies from my game group because the games were just too heavy one fellow in particular I think I overwhelmed and he just hasn't come back the word there in particular the games were too heavy you know what I I I I totally see that happening but I want to back up and say any game doesn't have to be heavy if the game is not the right fit it can make them disappear um I've had uh game clubs that I've hosted and I've had people show up that um some they just they show up for the first time on the wrong day where just a game they don't like is the main game I'm introducing to people and if they had come the week before or week after they would have loved that game and just the timing the bad luck they didn't like it and so you never see him again so I I think it's not necessarily too heavy some people will dislike you know every
genre of games so keep that in mind too that you know everybody is going to come into this with something different that they they they want to play Trevon also mentions that poker is an example for why noobs can be bad they don't know enough to actually play they're just moving pieces there's a meta to the betting that they don't understand and it can ruin things all right Trevon as a very poor poker player I have a follow-up question then for you I am such a poor poker player that I don't realize how bad I am and I think I'm pretty good so is there a level of nubin where the Newbie can still actually be enjoying the game um just as much as the people who understand the meta because they are basically happy with the level they are playing at and they don't realize there's a whole another level up here that they could be playing at that they're missing they're per perfectly fine just moving their pieces around down here does that have any effect on your argument at all let me know either in the chat or in the comments below Tren follows up to his previous statement about poker and my uh challenge to him to follow up on it with his followup and says oh the new poker player has a great time they just ruin everyone else's time fair enough fair enough
Trevon touche Omar joins us to say our board Gaming Community caters for noobs by having a table or two dedicated for newcomers along with guides while the rest of the tables play their favorite heavier games I know that I've mentioned in previous videos that um I believe that it is the job of the host of the event to play the part of host or guide for these people um and whether or not um it's the host doing it the fact that your gaming Community actually has you know dedicated guides for each each game day to play that part to F facilitate that type of learning experience that is fantastic uh I I hope that that um I hope that that becomes a trend that many more game gaming events and gaming clubs can follow because that's a very inviting environment Toyota wolf joins us to say that Arkham Horror second edition with multiple expansions can be a nightmare to introduce to new players most games with lots of expansions are this way that's a really good point there Toyota because we've been talking about the games themselves like heavy games or whatever but yeah let's talk about expansions for a minute real quick boy I don't know about you guys but how many times I cannot count because I don't have that many fingers and toes but I I have trouble counting how many games I have purchased expansions for that I have still in like
a separate bag or in their box still segregated away from the core game because I haven't every time I play that core game I'm introducing it to someone new or I just it hasn't hit the table enough for us to feel like we've mastered the core game and so these expansions just sit waiting to be played because if we were to introduce them all at once yeah it would be way too overwhelming how does that compare to your experience let me know um and let's compare some notes Toyota also mentions I also find that games with take that mechanics can cause newbies to run away too definitely that definitely can be one of the genres that seems to um lend itself to scaring way people if a game with a lot of hot take that that where someone can feel like they're being picked on um definitely someplace to To Tread cautiously let's continue on to another statement from Richard who says no the games were physically too heavy oh talking about heavy games that were hard to introduce but he's talking about they were physically heavy we made the Newbie move the Gloom Haven box oh well right there that that you can strain a muscle doing that uh Gloom Haven has got to be 18 pounds or so it's insane but he says no your point is well taken we just had the wrong games for him oh you fooled me you gave me a bit of a opposer there what what with your question with your your you tricked me Richard you I fell for it I you tricked me and I fell for it and I don't think I'll ever forgive you
but we I'll work on it I might work on it our next statement coming from Omar again who follows up to say but do a lot of games actually have a meta associated with them oh very good question uh the only one I've come across uh with a particular group is secret Hitler where it's always goes to the last chance vote before everyone says yes do a lot of games actually have meta associated with them poker was mentioned and Magic the Gathering was mentioned you know any collectible card game would fit into this I believe any game with lots of lots of various uh rules that can be introduced into it but do a lot of games H that's really good question and you know what I'm not going to spout out my thought on it quite yet that's when I'm going to turn over to the community do you think that there are more games that have a meta that that prohibit can be prohibitive to newbies than not or do you think that modern board games in general have come to the point where they're sophisticated enough that they can get their point across without too much trouble for newbies let me know what you think and that might actually Branch off into another episode in the future but in the meantime let's continue on to the next next comment from mm who says for me it depends a lot on the size of the group for a small group that might have noobs the heavier Gamers can just have to deal with it if they want to play for bigger groups they can split off fair enough in
your experience could this lend to kind of uh niches uh groups of people basically can this lead to the newbies all getting crowed together by themselves to figure things out while the established groups of friends go off and play where you always end up having kind of the same you might have 60 people show up for your gaming event but you end up with the same 10 groups of six sitting at each table never to mix or mingle um I I have to admit I run into this myself I'm guilty of this all the time um and I when I do it I hide behind the justification that I'm just being shy and I you know am more comfortable playing with the people I know but a lot of the game groups I go to I see that you know you'll go and week after week month after month it's the same clusters of people sitting at all these tables so even if you have a large group it can feel to a newbie like a small group that can be uninviting um again everyone let me know how your experience compares to my own let's wrap up this episode from uh with a comment from axon troll who says I am always hesitant to teach nuclear war to new people people and I believe that nuclear war is one of those games that basically can just it never ends well um and it just ends in total player Annihilation and such uh the the ultimate in player
elimination I would suppose if I'm thinking of the correct game I'm thinking of a game from the late 70s early 80s I think um but it might have been a different one anyway it doesn't matter the point is it underscores how important it is for us as game guides um to borrow a from Omar uh for us as game guides to really help bring when we're bringing in newbies into the hobby to go out of our way to not only create an environment where they can play games but to actually find out what interests them and what they're going to be comfortable playing and you know help facilitate that as well I think that you know as ambassadors to the Hobby it's really important for us to remember however if there's any other comments on this we're going to have to also keep that in our memory banks because we've run out of time for this episode so I want to thank everybody in the live chat who has taken the time to uh contribute and participate in this uh today's episode and for more board game videos about news questions commentary that's not what the videos are about the videos are actually about um board games and stuff watch a video you'll figure it out but in the meantime I've been Chaz marer from Paradise paradise Who along with the live streaming chat have been serving up some table scraps thanks talk to you again soon hold on let me make my mind completely blank well that was
easy actually that's pretty much the norm all right we're good to go excuse me I'll edit that out hopefully the heater turned on and in the last 3 minutes the temperature has raised about 10° so uh my apologies if I die from heat stroke I think it's gone up another 12 degre which is fantastic it keeps the blood pumping all right let's continue on to some more questions before we runs out of the times or melt