Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 34:37

hello everyone and welcome back to the board gaming doctor my name is Phil and I'll be your board game doctor today in this episode I'm going to go over my long to plays of July 2024 and talk about some of the games that I haven't had the chance to dive into deeper and throughout the month and this includes games that I've played before and Revisited some games that I've been able to play a few times in review and a few first impressions as well so let's talk about first a spirit Island this is a very popular game of course and a game that I've had the chance to play a few times recently with my brother and cousin they really enjoy this game and have graciously invited me to play with them with the app you know we are using the subscription based version to be able to play all the content including the new expansions and that's something that I've never had the chance to do whereas I've played this game I don't know if I've mentioned it before i' I've played it uh I first played it a long time ago this was maybe about 7 years ago or so and it was pretty complicated for me back then I wasn't really into board games as heavily as I was or as I am now and then I played it again when the app came out a couple of years ago and I was deterred based off of the price at first because I didn't enjoy my first play with this but now that I've played it a few more times and had the chance to kind of

forcibly learn and understand this game at a higher level to play with real people I do really respect this game I think that the opportunities to play as many different Spirits if you include everything that the expansion has offered is really fantastic and really Alters the game in a different way to make each game feel different and the expansion material also adds modular things that affect the board other than your asymmetric player power to do so and so I really like that the ramping difficulty is really nice as well at first our first couple of games this month were at a lower or even lowest difficulty if I recall correctly and so at least it felt better to make mistakes and actually win and understand how to win this game while moving on to harder difficulties in the future it felt like the ease in that you get in with like Legacy games and so I really enjoyed that I will say that I'm still not a complete fan of Cooperative games I do prefer more competitive games more so for the fact that I tend to When approaching uh Cooperative games I think I've shied away from them because I used to be much more of an alpha gamer than perhaps I am now I think I've backed off a little bit and I'm more conscientious of how I

approach Cooperative games and how boss I am granted in spirit Island it is hard to do so because we each have a certain it's almost like a self Tableau that you're managing in this game with your cards and your powers and it it's really hard to be aware of what other people are doing with their own boards but there are really cool times when we ask each other how we can help each other with our powers since we're not completely aware of what each other um are doing and so if you are a big fan of this game of course you you probably will have that knowledge base to be able to Alpha Game potentially but as a newer gamer uh in this game I feel less constricted or less impelled to do so and I don't mind being told what to do because they offer my my uh you know my brother and my my cousin offer a potential problem that we have to solve and that forces me to come up with a solution that I can put forth that only I can do rather than telling them what to do with their own powers and so I really enjoy that and then there are other times especially earlier on in the game where I feel like I don't know what I'm doing and so I do rely more on other you know players to be able to tell me what to do that that happens in a lot of Cooperative games where I'm not

at you know not at par with my uh Cooperative uh folks you know the people that I'm playing with and so it makes me feel less I I feel less enjoyment when I play that because I don't feel like I'm contributing a lot and that I'm letting the team down essentially and I think that is mitigated in a sense in this game as well because of that forced understanding that you need to have to be able to play your asymmetric Spirit at its capacity to be able to contribute well to the game State and so I will continue to play it I think I enjoy playing it more so to be with family and to you know hang out and talk to my my brother and cousin but I think this game will continue to grow on me as I continue to dive deeper into how this game works and so yeah I've really enjoyed my plays of spirit Island thus far more so than I did in the past next I got to play distilled a few times on board game arena I'm going to show a demonstration of that game here on screen which I soundly lost and so distilled is a game that a lot of people now know especially with luier on board you can check out my past video on that from a week ago but dis still you are essentially creating a Tau of a brewery and creating new and different types of

beers utilizing the cards in this market to uh be able to do so to upgrade your uh brewery as well using premium ingredientss Etc all the while trying to fulfill uh public objectives to gain as many points as possible so I I've mentioned this before I really enjoy the mechanisms behind this game as well as the Thematic integration the push your luck mechanism of brewing your beers feels what I imagine to be very thematic in the sense that you don't know what's going to come out of that casket you can put as many good ingredients in as you can but there is still random chance for it to be as good or perhaps better or even worse than you were hoping it to be now I do really respect and appreciate this game as well because I was wasn't able to winc I I realized that I was able to brew some of these higher uh scoring beers during my game here but I failed to really pay attention to some of the objectives that uh were available during this game and so to me that denotes a lot more of a depth to this game than perhaps meets the eye it's not as simple as hoping for the best cards in the market to be able to play play you know to your characters strengths as well as the Tableau that you slowly build throughout the game that is something

that I really enjoy in games is when you can build your asymmetry throughout the game to create efficiencies that you craft rather than having all of that taken care of at the beginning of the game and so this is a game that I do enjoy I think once again this might spoil the last video but I think I prefer luier a little bit more compared to this game but I I still really enjoy it and would happily pick this up and play if someone recommended it next on the list is age of innovation so I've been able to play this game twice now and of course that's probably not enough to really dive The Depths that this game has to offer and pardon if this is a little janky this was still in Alpha on board game arena when I recorded this or played this game but essentially this is Terra mystica that is a standalone sequel to Tera mystica particularly that I feel incorporates some of the modularity that is offered with Gaia project but having its own identity as well you have a map that is static like Terra mystica you have four tracks that you're advancing on as well you've got all the bonuses and uh you know tiles that are seen in in all the systems of games that these come from uh your Tableau is a little bit different because you get to draft or randomize the faction and power that they start with and so there's added modularity there there's also this board

in addition to the uh City benefits that you can gain similar to Terra mystica you can have a you have a new resource in books where you can spend them to gain some of these Innovation tiles which offer some additional asymmetry similar to the tech tiles that you see in Gaia project in my opinion so I feel like this game combines the competitive feeling that teram mystica provides with the static map and knowledge of these factions with the added flexibility that comes from Gia project not in the sense of a modular board but modular player powers and Technology tiles essentially and so I I feel like it is a marriage between I in my opinion The Best of Both Worlds I had bounced off of Terra mystica it was one of the earliest games that I ever played in the more heavier uh realm of board games and I bounced off of it pretty hard as soon as I started to play other games because I felt like it was a little bit too competitive and too tight and to in a sense quote unquote scripted and what I mean by that is it's very uh well established what the best factions are where you can play on the map to gain the best benefits as well there was a lot to take in strategically when I first played this game that I wasn't really willing to dive into and still I

have issues with myself devoting so much time to this game that I don't feel as or you know terisa in particular as inclined to do so however I think age of innovation is that solution for me where I do get that Competitive Edge that this game can provide that is mirrored with games like Terror mystica but it also offers the added flexibility for me to still feel clever to feel like I'm still exploring this game and in a sense that I can explore this game on perhaps a similar level to other players as well who don't have the extensive knowledge and background from teram mytica now I I believe that players who are very good at teram mystica would be able to play this game a lot better than I can but for some reason I feel like knowing that there is a little bit of a uh learning curve for everyone in the sense of the modularity of how this game is set up with your factions and tiles makes this game feel a little bit more approachable to me in the sense of strategy and so I'm really excited to continue to play this game uh if I were to choose a game now in the system of teram mytica diet project Etc may I I might go with cl uh clans of Caledonia actually but that's beside the point out of the games from the same designers I think this one takes the

cake for me this is the one that I'm most interested in pursuing and I am grateful that it's on board game Marina to be able to do so at uh at a more repetitive uh notion rather than you know not having a physical group that I can meet with to play so I'm I'm really excited to dive deeper into this one all right next is path of civilization so this is a game that I covered on tabletop simulator a couple of months ago when it was not as widely uh shared and distributed but now it is on board game arena and at the time of this recording this one is uh I think officially free or available for everyone to play development is done so in this game I I feel like it is a competitor to a sense to um seven wonders in terms of theme and gameplay you have a market of cards that you're purchasing throughout the game instead of drafting them by you know giving up a hand to another player and you're using these to collect icons uh as resources to buy wonders and leaders Advance on tracks the military track the philosophy track Etc and so this game now that I've been able to play it a couple more times I do admit as I approached this game again uh from a few months back the rules I I'd forgotten you know most of how this game played like especially with these public objectives and things like that and so I found myself mostly uh just clicking buttons and trying to

see where the game would go um I obviously that is not the correct strategy and perhaps my opinion would be different if I uh sought to understand this game continually further uh compared to my attempts when I did learn the rules on my own and play a game with uh with or against the AI I suppose but I you know I am deterred mostly by the comments that were made recently you know right before I made this recording I've seen some strategy posts on Board Game Geek about this game from players who have started to dive into this game upon its release and denoting some of the better strategies of this game and if it seems like this game is somewhat solvable the the depth of strategy isn't quite there which is probably so it's probably at the same strategic level as Seven Wonders but perhaps it's not because with seven wonders you have the opportunity to really understand the cards know which cards aren't in play which ones aren't and has a lot of that interaction with other players as you are passing cards from One Direction or the other whereas in this game it's very much a solo uh m multiplayer solitary game with the small interactions of you know potentially building or bidding for wonders and leaders to purchase if you decide simultaneously to go for those

and so there there is some cool interaction there I really like that part of this game but I feel like that I mean you can look at the score right here we didn't finish this game all the way but I was just clicking buttons and I was only one point off and so to me that kind of says I can kind of mess around in this game and still do fine I think you can kind of play the cards that you have and kind of go for whatever opportunities are given you and be fairly okay or at least close to what others do now this this is probably not true at higher levels of play but I do wonder if that disparity between high level and regular level of play is very slim if it the differences are very minute in this game so it I don't think the skill ceiling is here for me that that would entice me to really learn and play this game but I do like the system that this game provides perhaps another expansion to add some complexity and additional strategic uh benefits and and opportunities this might make this game a little bit more appealing to me but at this time I think I'm I kind of rate at the same as as Seven Wonders I think they would be interchangeable to me and I feel like I would if I was at a physical table would enjoy Seven Wonders more since there is more inherent interaction in that game so that's where I'm at with path of civilization we'll see if that changes in the

future so next is links so this game is an interesting game that I was invited to play with my friend here and it's a it's very much an abstract game that honestly I'm surprised hasn't been created before so this game is a Lane game where you play a cross between Tic-tac-toe and rock paper scissors as you can see the goal is to get three in a row in the Tic Tac Toe sense of three in a row but the stipulation is that you can and you have to play one tile on top of another to have that flipped over and the stipulation is that is that you need to um or or at least you can do that but you can play on top of another tile if you play the corresponding Rock paper scissors icon on top of it and so that creates an additional puzzle to you know try to solve uh as you can uh yeah as you can see here you do need three tiles uh on top of each other flipped over to be able to score that round and so this game was surprisingly fun I do wonder about the you know the the luck that would that comes with this game with not having the right tiles to be able to place on top of certain ones to gain that Tic Tac Toe but it plays really quickly anyway and so it's really easy to you know just continue and play and so as far as abstract games go this is really fun and and once again really

surprising that this game came out so recently maybe I'm missing something there but I I really enjoyed this one I think I would play this with non-gamers you know casual gamers people who really enjoy abstract games kids even uh to create a you know just a an experience that is not as droll as tic tac toe is or rock paper scissors but something that is approachable and easy enough for people to understand while just being a fun forward game so next is botanicus so this is a game that was recommended for the Kenner Spiel this year if I'm not mistaken and this is I think still in Alpha on board game arena it might be in beta already for anyone to play but in this game essentially you're moving around uh your gardeners here around these uh this plot of land that you have I believe that these uh yeah these Maps can be different among players and you're essentially trying to advance along these tracks and align yourself to uh or at least try to achieve some of these objectives here by placing plants onto your your board uh place placing these animal tokens on there as well for added benefits as well as so moving along these tracks and that's all mediated by this action board where it's a very predictable sequence of actions that you can play in this two-player game you can play this neutral marker on

top of a one of the spaces and then you or your opponent have to choose one of the other three actions to perform which are usually a double action I don't know I think this is set in stone like in the physical version I don't think there is much of a difference between the these tracks and so it's kind of like a Rondell essentially uh and a very predictable Rondell system that you're you're playing as and so I thought this game was fine I obviously did not do as well in this game as I was learning it I think I picked up a few things along the way as far as how this Rondell works as well as you know major ways of scoring points you could look to my uh competitor here who really has uh yeah done really well this game and so so I think this game has a little bit of dep but it's not my cup of tea because there's a lot of track Management in this game that I typically am not not fond of but I do like the puzzle of this board the puzzle of the Rondell and choosing the actions and there's quite a bit of interaction here regarding what you can do based off of this uh rondelle system here so yeah you know I think this is a a fine enough game and it's great that it got the recommendation for kener Spiel and and it is available if you feel like this game based off of its mechanisms is something that you're interested in and would enjoy you can try it for free so moving on to Cole Baron this is an older game by Cromer and keing I believe if not just one of

those two but in this game you are oops uh looks like H suum in doesn't really help at all but uh what you're trying to do is on your own Tableau you are gathering these order cards and placing these these orders that you're trying to fulfill also uh using worker placement to and and Resource Management in the in the terms of money to placing Minds onto your Tableau and using an action point system very similar to games like to call where you have like 10 actions or six or eight to manage your mining here and so you can you know every step that you go down the the well or the the shaft is one action point Etc you know and so I yeah so this game was fairly straightforward to understand it was a lot of fun like I I I feel like this game was easy enough to Inuit it uh with the way that this game works on how you take actions as well as the Strategic you know uh objectives that you're trying to pursue it's pretty straightforward and so not a very hard game to to play and understand maybe it is harder to like really get a good sense of the strategy of this game if you're experienced but um it it's one game that I didn't have to work too hard to understand as I learned it straight from board game arena so it's got that going for itself and so if you want to try it out if you haven't already uh then you can try it there but if you

enjoy this this old classic game uh it is on board game arena so some quick thoughts on my little everdell this is a younger version younger in the sense of a younger audience of everdell uh in my opinion everdell is a pretty straightforward game to learn at least strategically it's it's probably a lot deeper than I'm giving it credit for but this this is more targeted towards children as you can see it's very highly rated since it was released two years ago I got to play the uh or demo at least the digital version of this uh last month and that was fun to see some of the little differences that this game has no pun intended but this game strips away some I think some of the complexity that comes from one the cards and the abilities that the cards offer to the amount of resource or worker placement spots that you have available there are some that are offered on the cards I'm pretty sure but it's not as extensive as the base game or with any of the expansions and in addition to that there are stripped down objectives that you're trying to pursue it's not as extensive as like the the objectives that you're trying to chase the Milestones that you're trying to get that are on the tree Etc you know from the base game and so yeah this game accomplishes what it's trying to do to making everdell a little bit more approachable for younger

audiences and yeah so it was fun everdell is not my favorite game to play I would rather play other uh you know Tableau Builders and work rep placement games but I really do appreciate the mechanisms here the overall sense of building out your Tableau to offer additional worker placement spots for you or others to take is really interactive and fun the market is fun to uh interact with as well of cards and the game scales and ramps really well and so you get that sense from this game as well and so yeah just a a nice little appreciation for what this game is trying to do so next on the list here is nextstation Paris this is a new iteration of nextstation London in line with the Paris Olympics which has been fun to watch shout out to the Turkish Hitman but this game offers a little bit of a an added variation in the game with the map being having having the central Hub that you're playing around and having extra ways to connect your routes in this game there are probably some different objectives that you're trying to uh really achieve I haven't you know I'm not a big player of next station in general and so I don't know for sure but but this was fun regardless you know the slight variations make this this really fun and popular game uh even better and you can play this I they they pushed this out really quick I I saw the development of this from alpha to Beta to to full release really quickly in

time for the Olympics and so I I think that was the the point of it but yeah really enjoyable if you like this system of games next I wanted to talk again about worms span so this game already reaching High status at rank 255 8.1 average rating very well-received game and I think it's rightly so so shout out to and congrats to Connie vogelman for for doing so now when I first played this this game and reviewed it on the Channel with my first impressions I did mention that I would rather play wingspan over worms spam and that was based off of one play against an AI bot very similar to how I started off with wingspan uh that that kind of changed when I played this in person with other people so I had the chance to play this you know at the beginning of the month last month and it was really cool to see how this game unfolded with the flexibility that all of these different cards have not only just the Dragon cards but the cave cards as well the guild that you're trying to advance on as well it really is a more more complex and more flexible version of wingspan now I don't get me wrong I really love wingspan and I think that the the identity of wingspan is set in stone based off of the expansions that are released in this game but this game feels and plays a lot differently and has its own identity as well and it's

something that I I just really enjoyed I really enjoyed the puzzle that this game provided and loved to see like you know I I really needed to maximize the amount of points that I had to get and oh you know I could do it with this these cave cards or I could potentially try to go for the guild or play this Dragon what can I do right now to achieve that and so it offered the same kind of strategy that I pursue in wingspan but at a more complex level which I did really appreciate and I think only appreciated as I played it again the action system with the the coins as well made it very interesting to really build uh an engine and only be able to you know ignite it like once per round or something like that until you got to the end game where you were able to ignite it a couple of times because you had built up an another engine so you know to be able to gather more coins and to afford to do so and so that was really rewarding to be able to build out an engine and even though it was it felt restricted at first and it felt kind of complex and and uh kind of I don't know fiddly if that's the right word to build out these dragons along this I I felt like it was really achievable by the end of the game and fun tidbit as well with our game I think we were all within like two or three points of each other and so it was a really close game really fun and

everyone kind of got to that same level by doing drastically different things and so it was it was just a really fun game I really enjoyed worm span and would happily play this again it's it's probably you know I give it an eight right now but I I probably if I play this more would give it a nine very similar to how i rate wingspan I think they're you know essentially up in the same echelons for me with games that often are reiterations of another game or use kind of the same system it's it's harder to differentiate them sometimes and it's easier for me sometimes to give a higher score or a higher preference to one game from another but in this in this case I feel like they are very separate games and they both one utilize A system that I really enjoy but two feel different enough that I can pull this out with different groups and really enjoy myself and so yeah really enjoyed worm span really looking forward to playing this game more so the second to last game that I want to talk about is galactic ERA this game I I played on board game arena but I am not able to access my replay of it because I believe it's still an alpha but this game is a very ambitious game where you have a 4X type of experience space you know space 4X experience and you I the the unique Factor about this game is that your faction has like a light side and a dark side a more peaceful side and a more war

mongering type of side as well and so there's plenty of interaction in this game let's see if we can get a little bit closer and so you're moving around a map you know they different rules for how this how you move you're building out cities and your own Federation what have you but uh there are different rounds and eras in this game where it behooves you to be more peaceful with your competitors versus more competitive and uh more combative I I suppose and so I think this game is very much a hit and I think it it's got the complexity that I think you know space 4X enjoyers would really like I know this game has been out for a while and I do wonder you know if um let me try to get back to the main page here I think you know if there was I don't know why this game isn't as highly rated as it could have been maybe it just kind of miss the mark for some people but I I gave it a six because it's not my cup of tea I think it's it's too complex for me for my Euro brain to really wrap my head around or or to pursue to enjoy but I really respect the design that this game has it's it's a longer game and so it's harder for me to really enjoy the implementation is fantastic on board game arena so if you do like this game there is a community out there and so I

I guess this is more of a plug to those who enjoy this game to check it out on board game arena to give the plays that it needs to be fully developed and so more people can research and find out about this game because I think it does deserve a little bit more credit than perhaps it has gotten since it's been released so the last game for this video is red Cathedral so this I've mentioned before that this game is now on uh Yukata another like a similar site to board game arena and I'm not sure how this this uh replay would work but anyway in this game it you know I I'm coming off of this after having played the White Castle and so it it came in a very timely in in a very timely manner for me to try this game now uh from the same designers but you're moving around a Rondell based off of the number that is located on these dice to collect resources and claim parts of the red Cathedral that you use those resources to to finish its completion to gain points money and so there's a lot of interaction in what resources you can draft from the Rondell uh bonus actions that you can take as well there's a in the expansion is included so there's a contractor map that you can uh utilize as well in case the uh you know building out the cathedral is not a part of your plan immediately so you can get a lot of points by doing this as well and that's

essentially a a broad overview of this game it's uh I'm I'm assuming a lot of people know and have played this game and so once again more of a plug to say that this game is available online to play for free and I really enjoyed this game as well like I I think I still prefer the puzzle that White Castle offers but I really like the interaction that this game provides it's it's not too weighty of a game it's more of a medium style game in the sense of complexity for rules as well as strategy but the level of interaction is is fairly High based off of this rondelle and what you're trying to do with this modular map of the red Cathedral and so I really enjoyed the puzzle that this game provides and would happily play this again so there you have it it's a longer video to kind of go over some of these games I I'm not going to rank which games I liked more than others but you have some of my thoughts and Impressions after playing these mostly on digital formats and so thank you for listening and and sticking around to the end hope you consult with me further and hope to catch you on the next video take care

Progress saved