Skip to main content
Loading video...

2024 People's Choice Top 200 Solo Games, Pt. 3: 1-50

Transcript 57:00

just to with you all right Perfect all right hey Gamers this is listen Ser you can't start talking while I got this going on I absolutely can and I will he look at my an idiot what else is new how many videos have we been idiots all together Mike um so welcome to thir it of our of our People's Choice top 200 solo commentary uh this is games one through 50 so we're in we're in the tippy top of the list now and I again here with my three amazing panelists um so we have Derek Dereck want you to introduce your Stu really quick sure in case if any no one has well you should go and watch the previous videos but anyway I'm Derek from solo podcast uh and yeah you can check for the podcast if you would like solo games and Cooperative games like we all do all right uh and then Marceline uh if you're skipping the previous two episodes to this one you're probably me you're probably asleep tuckered in in your bed and I'm telling you wake up wake up it's time to wake up because we got a top 50 to go on and do let's go okay uh I am a freelance game designer uh and I'm most known for the game oceans uh the solo design for oceans as well as um most recently my

solo designs for trkking the world uh Second Edition and trkking the national parks's Third Edition which just came out in Target so you should go buy it in Target and play my solo mode Hell yeah and then Mike hey I'm Mike uh I am most known in the fan variant solo Community for Designing the most popular fan solo variants 4 tyrants of the underd dark seed fighting game system radlands and what's another one that's actually popular I don't know that's oh uh undaunted Normandy there you go I designed some pretty good fan variants for those I I do nothing else I'm not I'm not from any other medium you have never seen you're just the radlands guy I am the radlands guy yeah I wish any company would pay me ever once to decide an official solo for one of the things is do it all for the fun of it and you're just you're you're just a fan of some game called Flame and Fang that's right hey number 484 on the ranking this year we're gonna talk about the top 50 so it's almost there baby just a few more spots just a few hundreds and hundreds of spots flame and 484 here we go I am gonna say I actually like flame and I think it's a good game so I I like I really appreciate since we're since this is now flame and fame time I just wanted to say I really appreciate like the key Forge style like Mana system I think that's super super cool

thank you that that was pet Peter was the lead designer on that one and that was the first mechanical idea that popped into his head he's like dragons but it's key Forge and I was like all right we we'll figure that out somehow all right so um this is probably the least exciting part of the list so let's just go ahead and talk about the first couple I'm super excited yeah what could number one be in a shocking upset number one is Spirit Island wait wait hold on hold on yeah that's what I want hold on I got a fun idea okay we're going to name the top 10 and for each one I want a thumbs up you know diagonal okay we all ready here we go all right it's gonna be count of three okay so number one is Spirit Island one two three wait I thought you said boo Marceline no that was a joke that was a joke that was a joke it's okay I I don't hate it but I don't Boos were mostly like number one to be here you hate it I think you you're I don't hate it I just don't love it all right number two island is in fact amazing it's just we hate to see it always at number one we want to see some shakeup that might be it I'm I'm bit I don't disagree with that all right number two is Mage Knight one two three oh jeeez I'm the most negative here sorry it's just hard I haven't played it but I just love the idea of wait what do you think you haven't played it you can't give a th you're telling me to rate things that I've

never played or I'm assuming moving on I I have to I have to say that I'm excited to give this game a try and therefore it's a thumbs up from me yeah that's coming soon time yeah Apocalypse Dragon let's go I want to play that although know it's great you know well but hold on Derek the one thing I'm not sure about yet Mage night campaign Mage night is already like a two to thre hour game for me campaign M night I don't know what it's gonna be man absolutely where's there for it no matter what you're like 50 hours of age night let's do it I don't care it's because you're also going to come to the question like if you're in an island you know like like lost for many years in that island and you can take three games with you which ones will be like it's a classic question right like so if you're going to if I'm going to be stred on island for three years and I need to play games because there's nothing else to do well Mage Knight campaign will do it fantastically for me so I wonder how many calories are in within Mage Knight like how could how long can you subsist on M no no you both are wrong you both think are the wrong thing I'm bringing the biggest chip Theory game I can because of the waterproof near PR going to staple together a boat and escape the island on my like Cloud SP Bo all right all right so let's have a look at we're going off the rails number

three number three Marvel Champions one two three oh oh Derek whoa okay talk us through it talk us through it where did where did the Marvel Champions hurt you here well hear me very deeply but when he came out I was like oh my God this is amazing and first couple expansion boom bo bo bo bo boom and then it went like this and that was just like that for a while and then suddenly I mean it's just I found it somewhat repetitive I know people are gonna kill me for this I know there's gonna get a lot of haters but and to be fair the bias is like I'm not a fan at all of the Marvel IP so that really you know put it aside for me um and yeah I mean if you put I know you're going to mention another game very soon that I'm going to say double thumbs up that I prefer way more mechanically speaking and theat and theme and immersion and everything versus Marvel Champions I'm not saying it's a bad game it's just me personally I would put it I wouldn't put it on the top 10 you you put a thumbs down I think you did say it's a bad game by the way Derek I'll note you know what else goes do do a roller coaster and those are exciting yeah well I mean but come on but then you can we're here those you can go again like this you know that's a good point I guess you do need to go back up at some point yeah right oh my God oh my

goodness all right let's look at number four so everybody Arkham Horror the card game one two three yeah we don't like I have not played this one but clearly I need to play it it's it's my it's my it fights for my number one game of all time with h exceed so yeah it's it's it's awesome I just I just played it I got the new campaign so I played it like 14 times in the last week it's been it's on my mind fantastic all right so number five too many bones one two three y'all are making me feel like such a uh a like a like a faker like I haven't played a lot actually we're not making you feel like Faker the top 200 voters are making you feel like a faker that's nothing to do with us this is a community problem yeah I love love love too many bones although I have to tell you I can't wait to see where Elder Scrolls lands in this list next year because it's freaking amazing I like Elder SRS better than T many bones that's that's a definite I think I might too and Bon is lovely for Elder squirrels because I I actually really love the Elder squirrels series uh definitely felt like extremely deep into Skyrim just as I was getting into college so I'm really really excited to give that one a try I have not yet seen or or played it I just know that I'm

gonna love it you will love it L I have a question so does it is it basically just a reimplementation of too many bones or is different enough it's very different it has a lot of the same DNA like you can tell that they came from the same Studio okay and there's some borrowed Concepts but I would say that the character building the way skills are done feels very very different to me I I would disagree I think it's like 80% the same game except for like the adventuring and I think it's just mostly better the the big thing Derek I will say too many bones wins out for two things the gear locks are more unique and varied and if you just want to sit down and play a game in like 90 minutes and be done too many bones offers that and Elder Scrolls does not besides that I think Elder Scrolls is better in basically every way for me it's to many B is defined by the gear loocks which I think why Elder scrs feel so different to me because in Elder Scrolls you build your character out in a manner you're Ching whereas in too many bones you're figuring out the build you like the best within the confines of a gearlock uh I would say that that's the big the big thing yeah all right what's next all right we got Lord of the Rings the card game all right yeah all right three two one go oh Derk loves see Derek I I thought you were going to double thumbs Arkham with me but I didn't realize you were talking about Lord of the Rings Lord of the Rings is a game that made me a solo gamer so wax point about it Derek like like when we talk about you know why I

didn't like Marvel Champions which I know they're different enough but whatever uh and you if you put them side by side with low of the Rings and especially right now with what they did very smart about releasing the trilogy of the movies that we all grew up watching you know and that they're very well done it's one of those few uh cinematography experience where you know you compare to the books and of course always the books are going to be better right but it's one of those few at least that's my perception that they're very good both of them and the movies are very well done and the soundtrack and the everything the cast The everything everything you and you translate into the car game which is already a very good solid system in a very fantastic system where you can develop your characters in your own unique way um I think it's great and plus the narrative the I mean everything everything is perfect a masterpiece so if you if you going to P me to compare that versus uh Marvel Champion I'm sorry Marvel Champions like you're going through the trash you know because this bad boy comes and takes everything so I'm so happy to see it in top 10 for sure everyone rewinded five minutes of time where Derrick's like I'm not saying Marvel Champions is bad I'm just throwing it in the trash I mean if you put me side by side we lower ring by way I do rank uh Derek I'm with you I rank Marvel Champions as maybe well actually I don't know I I might put Lord of the Rings as lowest of the three like Cooperative ones for me but

yeah I'm I'm a Lord of the Rings than Arkham than Marvel person so I like them all but yeah if I could only have one I have a take that I think is worth sharing so I haven't played any of these games but I don't generally like playing deck building games because of the deck building part uh I prefer to have like a pregenerated deck or to have like here's a couple things shuffle them together yeah yeah um which of these three games would you recommend for somebody like me I think the easiest one for precons is Marvel by a pretty wide margin and then Arkham and I would say Lord of the Rings requires deck building for Success probably the most heavily of the three yeah like I actually bought it because I was trying to recover from my magic the Gathering addiction and I wanted deck construction without having to hunt through a bunch of booster packs and like that was the attraction of Lord of the Rings for me so yeah that's yeah Marvel except for Marvel except for like a few like Thor and Hulk and a few Heroes that are like known to be kind of terrible out of the de out of the box most of them you can just like take a hero with their starting deck play most scenarios on the regular difficulty and have a good time yeah one thing I'll say is with earthborne Rangers being a deck building game I think that kind of thing might work more for a player like me because you're crafting your character through play right yes uh something more like Dominion where you don't have to know

meta knowledge by to in order to get into the game you sort of just can play in figuring out what is the what are the constraints of your deck as you're playing it and then kind of like building uh loosening the constraints given whatever the situation is well earthborne Rangers if you play through like the little Prelude they kind of like walk you through constructing your deck and then you you honestly only add like one or new cards to it every like couple of sessions like it's very you know for For Better or Worse it's like very slow progression of like upgrading and changing the cards in your deck all but hey number seven this is the only game that's new to the top 10 woo up five places what is it Liz all right we got final girl what do we think about it three two one go I should have done this just to see how people will hit me this is another one I've not played K but I I love I I I didn't put thumb up because I just haven't played it but I I do love how thematic this game is and it uses dice right oh yeah so I I usually I used to be really into like dice based solo games uh since like deep space D6 mhm uh that was like my first solo game I think um and there just came a point when I was just like tired of rolling dice I'm just sitting alone rolling dice

um so so yeah I think I think there's something about and this kind of goes back to my feelings about buttons and bugs too where um it feels like some times when things have and I I don't think that this is necessarily a problem for um final girl but when things have gated content when it's just like roll a die and something might happen it's just it just feels like I may as well rewind time back to the point when I did not fail the rooll um whereas I think what's going well for final girl is that it's meant to be this almost like Rog likee experience of like replaying the same event seeing what happens matching them up with different final girls I think that's super cool and and what makes it I think a really interesting experience for a DI a dice game I I love I love losing the game in final girl I think that's like the biggest compliment I can give it like final girl is a game where I'll I'll roll the dice I'll die horribly my boyfriend will get mangled by like Jason in like a Woodshed you know and then like I'll follow a cat by accident and I'll I'll get attacked and I'll die horribly and it's hilarious and it tells a great story and yeah and it always has a special place in my heart because Liz and I the first time I ever played it was a solo together game with Liz at was that Pax it was P yeah we did it we've done it twice now we had a great time both times yeah remember we had to sacrifice the cat to kill the alien hey man tough times we we uh we did we air we air locked him right yeah yeah it was

great but see like that's what that's the magic of final girl right like you have like a memory almost like you actually were there I think one one important thing about final girl though like I mean the game is just great you know and the theme definitely like right on my cup of tea like definitely a we all know like a nice reimplementation of hostage negotiator um but I think what is interesting at least for me for final girl is not something about the game self mechanic wise or theme it also has that nostalgic um feeling of like I don't know you know during which years everyone grow up but I grew up in the late 80s 90s and one of my dearest memories is going to Blockbuster or you know rental stores and and get those VHS and you know that was for the nights when my parents were going out or something with a pizza or um you know on the weekends or whatever uh so this game brings me back to those times in a way where like I can go to the game store if I didn't uh you know did the crowdfunding with the whole thing which funny enough came I think with a VCR kind of like art on the box but anyway if you didn't purchase you know through the crowdfunding you can go to a game store and get like sort of like a VHS little box and it will be of course based on the most uh famous slasher uh Slash horror pop culture films like you will have alien you will have uh you know Friday nightmare Elvis Street Friday 13 and so on and so forth at least it's you know unfinished but um that's one aspect that I really like the

nostalgic aspect of like okay I'm gonna go and buy my little movie if you want to call it like the box and then you lay it out and then you have a fun uh very thematic immersive Horror Story right so that's my favorite part and from all the ones that I have played um definitely the one that I like I don't know if the most but I found it the most interesting because of the puzzling which is weirdly enough because I'm not a very puzzling solo gamer but the one about nightmare the nightmare Elm Street I don't if you remember that you have I believe you have four cards laid down or something Freddy starts to pop in so I think it was very cool and very clever how they designed that so anyway I wanted to put out there that is very interesting to me how some aspect that is not necessarily about the game also is very attractive to to me as a solo gamer so I'm curious what you guys think about the form factor so I think it's super cool that like pretty much the when you buy like the VHS tape like everything in the VHS tape becomes part of the game that's a super like cool like economic solution but at the same time when you want to like buy more of this you know system it suddenly takes up like multiple Ikea shelves and that's a problem for me and I and I think it's really cool and I think maybe final girl from what I've seen with with this kind of solution um has probably had the best go of it like um paperback adventures

also tried to do it and I don't think it's as like strong of a but a of a of a release through that method but something about final girl makes it work uh although for me it's quite daunting to like get into the system after seeing like so many like Seasons worth of boxes that are now available and having to comb through what are the best ones now I know that the uh nightmare Elm Street one is really good to me it's like I would love to just hear people talk about what are the ones worth having get these ones these ones are really good um obviously I think also your own personal Nostalgia is going to be a factor in that like for me I would absolutely want to grab the alien one the alien yeah but I will say so final girl so actually this is an issue that I have with a lot of games these days um I love final girl but I get overwhelmed sometimes with how much there is of a game and actually that's been true for me with anent as well like it used to be like tops for me and it's actually dropped off in terms of games that I'm interested in games I want to play because it's like there's so many huge box expansions that I just can't take it anymore and I feel like I'm so spoiled for choice that I no longer know what to do yeah I I I think a lot of games suffer from this problem I I I have avoided it because the game I own the most content of of any game is root and so I'm really glad that like I could still fit like everything of root in one box plus or minus some like roll like

roll mats that I like carry around with me um and so like I think the fact that you can stuff everything in the base box makes it a game that I'm not super overwhelmed by because I know that I could always make a decision of like what factions I want to play at game night I don't have to think about it like carrying multiple boxes with me somewhere um so for me I would prefer to have like a single box solution similar to the gamblers chest is that what it's called uh where it's like everything is just like contained in one thing where I can see everything and yeah it just seems to make more sense to me as somebody who like likes to own things but doesn't like to just feel like it's messy and just like kind of visually taking up a lot of clutter that's fair all right now the Mike's back let's talk about number eight sorry I had I had a nine-year-old out of bed you know what it's important all right so we got D Imperium so three two one go why do you hate it why you hate it um well I haven't played the new solo mode in whatever it was Uprising which is supposed to be better I've heard neither have I I've only played the older one yeah but the older one I found uh solo very like random things would just happen places would get blocked I found it pretty frustrating and also I thought the deck building was kind of anemic uh in the game so yeah like I was I covered

arnac and D Imperium around the same time and I would play lost runs of arnac nine out of 10 opportunities doe maybe once I I did not enjoy it that much I like doing multiplayer a lot yes yes I like it I talk back solo here I think multiplayer with like the backstabbing and like you know second guessing yourself and fighting over the uh the area control I think it's a lot more interesting well I think I think I Mike um I think I totally disagree with you I think you're totally wrong because you miss you're missing the appointment like you put that game you know you have the setle for your solo mode of doing it with all the expansions and you're ready to you know conquer Iraqis and then you play the hand simmer soundtrack in the background from the movie Dune And you Let Yourself Go and you're already in the movie Man and you're doing all this crazy stuff now um I have to say that I play this solo mode once again with all the expansions and it works fantastic one thing that I I would like to hear your opinions though and this is like a parenthesis when we talk about this game um it actually I don't I don't know if I should use the word bother but what they did with Dune it kind of like I don't know how to feel about it you know when you release a game like Dune Imperium you create expansions for it uh so you people buy the expansions and all that stuff you get invested on it and then a little bit after that hey guys here is do a rising which is very similar it's not the same very similar so you can own both But it includes the expansion that

you previously purchased for the first version that we did so I don't know how to feel about those things you know when some do that I don't know what what are you guys thoughts on that like because I know I'm not the only one here complaining about situations like this right which is like well I already invest all the money and time and everything on this product but now you're bringing this you know kind of like better version of the game and you said that it's different enough so in that way you can buy both of them so I don't know what are your thoughts on it as a hakus victorium lover I've just learned to accept that it is my fate it was very shortly after when it feels like very shortly after the previous release so I think that it was a strange lateral move especially because a lot of people seem to be like it's good it is better um and it it just feels like it maybe should have tried to release itself as like a a more distinct separate thing um but that's also the issue with like calling something a second edition or just like trying like trying to make a lateral move where you're trying to improve a thing but the problem is they already kind of sank themselves pretty deep with like the digital version like the direwolf version so I don't know if I would have if I was in their position made that move but they made their move and a lot of people think it's improved so I guess it was worth it you know hey they get to sell you the game again so they're certainly think it's a great uh business decision right I think that's what it all comes down to you

know you could get to like the design aspect and whether it's a better game whether it's Improvement or not but in the end they get to sell an entire new game with a very small amount of design time invested compared to making an entire actual new product with entirely new mechanics so they are very happy about it regardless of how you I think I think 20% Improvement is almost like not enough to have like bothered but I guess for them they just you know figured out that it is worth it for them and they know that Dune is really hot I don't know if it's still as hot as when originally had come out but you know I don't know uh it's it's interesting because Underdog also recently came out with their second edition game which is like totally different from trekking the world um and in that case I could totally understand why people might feel the same way where it's like a second edition uh but I have my first edition is that worse and it's like well it's just a different thing uh it's like basically a different game so it's I think it's just the problem of how you communicate a lateral move like what does it mean for the product for the original product um you're not going to sell that original product anymore or are you going to sell it um like I don't think Dune Imperium the original version is still being produced is that true I think it is it is it is being like there are two separate products that they're going to continue to move forward with well remember this is the company who

made Clank Clank in space Clank Legacy Clank catacombs all of which are different games that basically use the same mechanics but have slight differences and are sometimes cross- compatible but sometimes not cross-compatible and also have a Clank app now that you can play the game online with so I think they're quite happy having a lot of versions of the same game and making money by the way Clank catacombs by far my favorite version of Clank that's the latest one so I I did buy the one that is the latest and like it a lot but at the same time I could be like yeah I see what you're doing Dire Wolf I get it oh my God all right so in order to get out of the the sand before it turns into quick sand uh let's look at number nine Imperium classics all right what do we think about this one three two one go oh wow wow no big lovers here wow for me hly not I mean it's got great ideas I don't actually want to play it all the time let's how about that yeah I I'm very interested in the Star Trek version because what they have said about it is that it plays a little faster it plays a little smoother and scoring is drastically faster I don't know if any of that is true but all those things are things that I did not like at all about the Imperium series and I liked less as I played it more so if all those things

are true I'm really excited and I also like Star Trek a lot um not that I don't I also like historic civilizations and you know alien civilizations but I like Star Trek a lot I'm willing to find out I guess but yeah this one it's it's just not a game that I love it's something that I respect but not something that I feel excited to pull off the shelf I feel like to me it's like one of those things that feels like anytime I would want to play it I have to ask myself if I would rather play something that is like way lighter and I feel like I feel like the answer for me is usually that yeah and for me it's like amb Le like all right and then how about number 10 then on this list Ark Nova so three two one go whoa I think that the solo is not as good as the multiplayer I don't really oh c cry wait we're doing solo right never mind change change me to like that never mind I love I love multiplayer my fa this is a solo list we've been doing this for two hours we lots of things have happened Marceline we've been through a lot this evening okay but this is just one of those solo modes it's it's actually I dislike it for the same reason that I don't love the terraforming Mars solo mode it's just kind of there it's a way to kind of solo ify a game that's just really great multiplayer that people are going to

want to play solo because they want it in my opinion when also it was interesting yeah I think the the implementation I thought was really elegant for what is otherwise like a monstrous game and by the way Liz just mentioned the game that got kicked out of the top 10 by final girls Ascent which is terraforming Mars dropped six spots from number nine to number 15 and I'm 100% okay with that especially since the new version using all these AI art things and such ter terraforming Mars is a big down for me I think that the solo design is really smart but uh I just don't really like the Basse game I do like the base game but man there's at it inspired a lot of games that I like way more and there are like so many like Euro I mean AR NOA being what I would much rather play arova than terraforming Mars just as an example all right let's get out of the top 10 what do you want to talk about Liz yes okay so clearly we weren't all super enthusiastic about everything in the top 10 so what in the top 50 are you super enthusiastic to see I'm G to flag I freaking love PX Second Edition that's one of my top 10 games love it love it love it love it um I am super happy to see three different Theory games h four four because 20 strongs in here too although grouping them all together is a

little funny because they are quite different from each other 20 strongs but I'm super happy to see T many bones Hamas clouds fire and 20 strong all up here um I love spiropoulos and actually I'm just I'm delighted that it's a wonderful world isn't here because it's one of those games that like I don't know why I like it so much but oh God do I no it's fun to play Hey I like that as a tableau Builder better than terraforming Mars too shots fired but yeah I'd rather play I think um sleeping Gods is a game that I just love so so much it is I haven't yet played the sequel game because I've just been playing the first game so many times um I just think it's the kind of game that has and from what I hear it has like more replayability maybe in a single play through versus the sequel because the timer aspect um is different I I don't I don't I I don't I haven't played the sequel I don't you're rightless it if if you use uh the he they published veteran rules that are like ways to make it tougher and make the time pressure stronger if you don't use those and display rules as written you can explore almost the entire world because you just accelerate so much by the end it's kind of it's kind of a letdown I think the original one ended up being slightly better balanced than the rest yeah I I just think that um sleeping Gods is just easily in my top like five of all time games it there so

much content and and so much of it so that even if you repeat content you might not remember it um at least that has been the case for me I just think it's super fun it it it is like breath of the wild as a board game for me I love the exploration I feel like Liz wants to say how much she God I can't stand sleeping Gods but that's why right we have a community top yeah yeah I I just think that having a big exploration map that is fit you can fit it in your tiny New York City Apartment that's amazing um and yeah at least until the card sprawl starts to happen oh my God that that's one part that got a little better with the uh the new version you don't have nine characters and eight million I mean you do have eight million cards you don't have to have them all out with tokens on them you can just like have them in your hand I would highly recommend people play sleeping gods and if not you play uh primeval peril exactly one time Prim apparel is great I love that one yeah for a single oneoff play it's a really nice sleeping Gods hit I like that a lot you don't need to play a second time don't it'll just kill the magic just play one time and you'll have a great time probably you'll probably be like oh yeah there there's other things you could do just don't even worry about that you had an experience enjoy that it reminds me of the uh I don't know if yall play these but it reminds me of like the inherent lie and The Telltale video games like

the choose your adventure Telltale where you're like oh my gosh you could have gone a million different ways and you play it again you're like oh oh man they railroaded me like 89% of the chance time here didn't they right I think that's what it's it's like with sleeping Gods I just think it's crazy how there's just no guard rails there are just no guard rails you could just go in any literally any direction yeah it's like the classic Skyrim like see that mountain you can go there and I just love the game so much for that I haven't even touched the the expansion content and I've owned this game for years I've been playing this game for years I've had enough experience with the game that I could just not play the expansion content and then have a whole campaign that is just expansion content like that's amazing anyway play that game Liz is wrong play that game Derek what are some of your favorites from the top 50 we can't all be perfect my T is where to start but actually on the last video I spoil one sort of um number 50 these water mind the Bame I'm so happy to see it there because once again very immersive thematic way better than Frost punk I think maybe the idea of frost Punk even if it was based on a video game when it comes to the board game mechanic wise probably they took some inspiration from this water mine however this water mine is more like streamline it has this weird mechanic when you play it cooperatively like that you have a journal and you read the journal you do

some actions because we all manage the same survivors and then you pass the journal to the player on your left and so on and so forth but once you play solo of course you get rid of that aspect and you just go through your Journal by yourself basically is describing how around works and then once you play it a few rounds you get the you the feeli it and you don't have to re the journal again so I'm very happy to see it I'm actually I'm it's very dear to my heart to see one game that I just once again recently got the crowdfunding uh All In for it which is not a new game at all but it's Robinson cruo Adventures on the Cur Island it's still a game that I still play and I can play the same basic a scenario which you basically trying to get the fire going going on in that way the boat can see you in the last three rounds and they can save you and you can yell Wilson like in the movie um so this is a game that I still really really really really adore and and like a lot um what else I mean you have um there's another one that I saw that I was happy to see oh most recent uh let me see because I lost it here is slay SP the board game right I don't know if you guys had a chance to play it um it so expensive I didn't get it do I need to spend the money I think if you can I think you do I think you do I think you don't have to so my take on slay this bu the board game is if you're going to play solo just play the digital game if you're going to play multiplayer it is really fun m multiplayer well you could play it solo

too but you should play multiplayer if you're going to play it physically I I I I agree with you mer the aspect that if it's basically like a 150 I think 150 towards $200 game versus a $10 app yes for sure right and and you're right like the app is fantastic and it's going to give you that feeling of the deck building and you know fighting different monsters however that was my concept too I purchased the game at J con they had a bundle that you can get the kickstarter and everything was around 200 I think it was so I bought it and I had that similar thought where he's like you know like Cooperative is going to work great and it did work fantastic then I played it solo and I was concerned about well you know the collaboration between players and decks and like try to get that Synergy you know between different characters to defeat monsters how they're going to do it to mitigate that when you're playing solar right and they actually did a very elegant I guess system if you want to call it where they give you a card every round you're going to roll a die to see which enim which enemies we're going to activate but that same eight card that you get for the solo mode it's going to be based on the DI result that you roll also for the enemies and it's gonna kind of give you a boost so in that way you have that same rewarding feeling like if someone was collaborating with you as far as like ability goes so I think they did a good job on that to mitigate that loss of collaboration I guess if you want to call it that way so me personally I think it's worth it I think the product is fantastic I think it's

very well done also they thought about everything with the leaves and it's very satisfying as you go through the game to upgrade cards and just like un sleeve it flip it sleeve it and now you get an upgrade car right and then we you're going through treasures and stuff like you get new cards that once again you can they already sleep more than likely so just going to add it to your deck so I really like it I think from deck buildings in general in most recent times this is probably my top when you know taking a away over the rings of course but I mean they building like fun adventure like epic and nothing like crazy or chaotic to to start to play because literally that you just grab the decks and you're ready to play um I really like it I really like it it's it Marceline you're right like it's basically the exact same thing as the video game but there's a reason why we all play board games right like we like the tactic we like to feel on the table so answering your question l in my opinion yes you should spend the money uh but that's me I really I really love his latest pirate and I'm so happy to see it on top 50 I'm very happy to see it here too and I totally agree with Marceline Liz don't buy it the ad better for Sol play I I played the board game a few times I was like oh so in the time it took me to do one run I could have done like four runs on slay the spire and they would have had more cards available I wouldn't have been as limited as I am in the board game version and my relics would have worked better because I don't really like the way the relics work in the uh in the board game meditation but if you play it multiplayer it's the best my kids and I had so much freaking fun with slay thep cooperative and actually the one thing

I'll say if you want to play it solo that the board game let you do that's awesome is two-handing it's a little bit hectic but that gets really interesting because you get the kind of combos between characters but no Liz don't don't buy it it's too expensive I let Peter buy it and I play his copy go someone else to buy it that's you know it's the oldest trick in the book it works it works great um so I also want to say I'm super happy to see Obsession on here don't play Obsession solo that much but I have played over 200 two-player games of obsession on Arena so far I have like a couple play parties we just play and play and play WoW um if you want to play Obsession hit me up can we play can we play this game at at packs because I've never played obsession is great amazing never played this game this is definitely one I I like tried to read a little bit of and I'm like I just need someone else to teach me I'm usually really good at teaching myself but this was one of those that I'm like I feel like somebody else loves this game more than me and I would love to play from their teach I can gladly spread the gospel of obsession here I'll mention three favorites that no one else has mentioned yet uh for Northwood great solo trick taking game I mean it's it's not a like entirely a trick taker in the usual sense of the term but it's just an awesome card game I love it really cute art too um warps Edge my favorite bag building game so fun just for like a quick like combat hit with tons of variety in the ships and like bosses and stuff and then oh my gosh one of my top

maybe five games of all time bullet I'm so happy to see this stay in it actually went up from 50 to 49 uh yeah and they just uh they just released I kickstarted it Paul and pallet eight new characters they're so freaking good like just the creative crazy ideas they have and every character is also a boss you can play against in Solo so it's just like insane variety and like asymmetry and things to try out man I love bullet yeah bullet is genuinely such a good so it's crazy I'm saying this about a game in the top you know uh what are we at top 50 but I think this game is underrated yes it's like really good it's really really good um it's one of the few games I feel like that has a timer element that is just like you don't even think about the timer it's just it just feels like Tetris it just feels like puzzle League it feels like or um uh Tetris what what is the whatever I'm thinking about like Pokemon Puzzle League um but it's just like it's such such a good system and has all of the things that you love about Spirit Island and Route where you have these asymmetric factions but built into the system where you can just like I and where youve one side of the guy is you know a good guy he plays and the other side is the boss and I think that is so so smart that is so smart yeah all right so it sounds like we're all very thrilled about this list but in the interest of time I want to ask a

couple of kind of concluding questions so first uh do you feel that this is a worthy top 50 that is representative of the solo Community I'm gonna say yeah like it's this is a bangers I I'll say I'll say yeah except I'll agree with you Liz that as someone who loves historical and war games they seem pretty pretty absent from this list and I think some of the greatest solo games of all time should maybe be on here yes besides that yes fabulous top 50 list if you're not playing historical you're missing out and I will point out that if you enjoy Nemo's War dawn of the Zeds or PX from your second edition you are secretly a historical gamer and you don't know it yet and you need to go explore that part of yourself further because you're going to like what you find I'll say the same but for like pure puzzle games uh like turing machine not being in the top 50 I think is so sad I think turning machine is genuinely such a clever puzzle um but yeah it's you know I'm just noticing there's not really a lot of like deduction or puzzle um Centric games in the top 50 so that is something maybe bullet is like the one leading charge of like what a puzzle game is maybe cartographer okay okay they exist but I I feel like um you know I would like to see like to

see more games that are more like puzzly I guess we have Orchard as well you know there are games here but what about turning machine I feel it Derek what do you think I think I think it represents great like what the solo Community you know he been playing the most and what they like like you have fantastic games too they're like heat right like we didn't talk about heat but when it comes to racing games uh with the solo mode either official or a fan variant I don't think there's anything better than heat like heat is by far in my opinion the best solo fast uh racing with a elegant automa that works great that almost takes no time between your turns that it's out there you also have epic games like aulu that may die right like they keep releasing seasons and more crowfunding and you know now there's a famous Godzilla somewhere that is crazy expensive to get so H but everyone loves cthulu that may die know I call like it's like almost like rock and roll like you start to play the game and you either die or kill him and you know it's it's it's it's just great um you know you get games like hop M Victor as you were mentioning classic games like eldrid horror that they're still there um you know so I think this represents very well whether whether I like some games or not this represents very well what solo community you know likes and is playing like you have from you know from chief3 20 strongs which is in my opinion also very fun to play Tower Defense the production is fantastic small box it's great you

have site which is one of my favorite games you have Friday of course which is the small box fantastic solo game as well uh so I think I think yes I'm very happy with this list actually yeah although this Bittersweet for me to see Friday fall so far like I understand why but this is another one of those ones that was like originally a top 10er and so it's uh it's very interesting I guess year on year like it feels like not much changes year to year right but that if you look over like a wider span of time so much has changed oh we didn't mention but I think it's a fabulous design too big for me to get to my table often but uh void fall fall jumped 87 spots to 24th which is pretty crazy void fall solo void fall solo is really well done and I'll probably never play it again I think that's the problem it's like I A A good solo game is one that gets played and one that gets played like a lot like that's what's great about solo playing like um you know I was hearing about someone who played uh one of my designs 10 times in a week and I was like that's amazing that you get to play that game 10 times in a week you know that's time that you would have other not played a game yeah so that's why solo gaming is super important for games and and also why people who play solo games tend to be like the most hardcore uh players of games we play

games so much um and and I do think that this list is is representative of like the whole gamut it seems like really really um really really well um crafted by the community here and I will say even though it's lame to see Spirit Island stay there for years I think that it is genuinely such an amazing game uh I think it is in my top two games personally of all time so I it's not a surprise at all to see it be first again this year all right and then sort of on a closing note I see a lot of people say what is my first solo game what should it be I want to try a solo game and then people direct them to this list if someone asks you that question what game on this list would you direct them to play because I got to tell you I would not tell a new solo gamer to immediately go purchase Mage KN even though I think it's the best so what what would what would we recommend I think officially as ambassadors of this part of the hobby should we all agree to something to one no no just because that would be a blood bath no no no no everybody say suggest one sure I guess my answer will be based also in the type of bir right like if you like sports or something I will go with he if you like horror I mean ELD horror it's a classic but it's a very you know easy to learn system that is g to take you hours but you know like playr wise but it will be fun now if

it's someone that I know that you know they're like look man like I have played board games like here and there I don't know like king of tokens that type of things but I'm trying to jump into the next level and I want a solo experience where I can have a lot of fun I can think about it I can be I immerse in the game and have just a very epic experience I think I will go you know going to the basics and Classics I probably will go with Robinson cruso I think that I'm going to take this question as if I'm talking to somebody who is not yet a hardcore gamer but has played some games like Azul uh Cascadia I'm I'm not going to suggest Cascadia because I don't like that it's a beat your own score solo um so I'm going to suggest to that kind of player um to play that's pretty clever or which is also beat your own score uh or um a gentle rain would probably be my number one to suggest it is super lightweight in terms of rules um you could literally just give it to somebody and they can really just figure out the rules through play in a sense um it's a very chill game calm game and if someone the way I like to um convert people into the realm of solo gaming is to convince them that they are already a solo gamer um by being like hey you play apps on your phone right you do sodoku puzzles right

well gentle rain is kind of like doing a soku and they might bite it you know so I think that uh my pick for this question would be a gentle reain even though it's not in the top 50 I do think that a gentle Reign would fulfill the goat like share this solo game with somebody and see if they like playing a game alone yeah actually on that being so actually I think dererk your answer is great like when people ask me what solo game should I play I'm like well what do you already have that has a solo mode and like let me tell you which of those has a good one um or like what Cooperative game do you have already like you could just play it by yourself like that's usually the best answer but I think if it's somebody who's like kind of feeling feeling their way and they're not sure if they have the attention span or the desire to play by themselves yet maybe what I recommend is something like either Orchard for somebody who I think wants something very light and quick or sprawlopolis for somebody who wants to sit there and crunch for a while just to test out do I have the patience to sit here and do this by myself or do I need human interaction because I think that you know a lot of people will play any of these chuner games with like their friends but that doesn't mean that want to do it by themselves and you have to see if you have the appetite for that spops is definitely a good call out for that it's it can be played as casually or as competitively as you'd like um and I think that's one of the one of the reasons why it is such a strong solo

game uh for me this is sort of a one that's based on personal experience and this would be like if I was talking to more of a thematic but like quick fun solo thing I might say warps Edge uh specifically because when I was getting my uh 11-year-old at the time or maybe he was 10 at actually the time um like we had played a lot of Cooperative games together we played a lot of competitive games I sat him down with warps Edge I played through a first game where we kind of like discuss the moves together and then I was like all right go ahead and I just left him and he played it like three more times on his own just like trying out different like ships and things and was like good to go so I think it's it's a quick enough like exciting Dynamic enough game that for some types of people like again not every gamer is gonna jive with it but for some type of people I think it's like a nice one to just kind of play once with them and then be like all right have fun and they'll you know have probably have a good time just kind of experimenting with it I always felt like warp's Edge has the same appeal as like I mentioned earlier um uh deep space D6 was my first solo game I ever tried and I think warps Edge actually has a very similar kind of vibe except a little less random um and so I would I think that's a really good call out yeah nice all right so this brings us to the close of a commentary year another one a good one I really appreciate y'all were here to do this with me do y'all have any final thoughts before we kind of clear out uh what number is flame and fagg

again 484 let's keep going and and let's get ocean solo up there too yeah play Ocean solo and and night is whenever that comes out from Liz and David Thompson yes we're waiting on youo tool you can't R genius Derek any lasts uh no just it was a blast you know and he was U sorry for all the Marvel Champions U lovers out there I'm so sorry uh but uh you know I hope you guys enjoy uh you know this and and it was very it was very fun and I like like I said enjoy reviewing all this fantastic games with you know amazing people like like all of you and and yeah super happy and hopefully we'll do it again I very much hope so um I guess my closing thought is always that like it's just so much fun to touch base about solo games with y'all and like have this panel and like you know look at what our our part of the hobby is up to and I I want to emphasize I really think that the solo gaming corner of board gaming is really the best um like we do things like this because we it thanks to Kevin ersin who turned like a labor of love into something that's just been so enduring for so long and that it's you know it's taken on a new life but it's still here um and uh I just really appreciate that we all get to be part of this even if I have to look at sleeping Gods being so high up this list okay

God no seriously though um y'all are great uh both y'all in the video and y'all out there so please you know like uh comment uh participate vote in this next year um and uh Happy gaming everybody m

Progress saved