Skip to main content
Loading video...

The games every designer MUST play | Pam Walls

Transcript 1:22:00

it was one of those like on the border is it gonna be number 10 or not and yeah so for the same reason I'm not a huge fan of the game but it is a Monumental feat of game design yes I think I was at origins or something around the time it came out and that's all people could talk about it's like have you seen this game it wasn't like oh this game is amazing I love it they were just like have you seen this have you seen what this dude did like game design you know or the fun or the enjoyment but what do I worry about that right now a lot of people love it it's still a great great game but just the ability to put something like that together and it works but to your point it does have some interesting downsides foreign really excited to have you here excited to dive into an episode I've never done before I've never done a a show like this where we're just chatting about all sorts of games we're talking about games that people should be playing that they should be analyzing that they should like be taking notes with like I think that's another thing as a game designer you kind of Nev you never play a game again because it's deeper now like as you're playing you're looking at the choices that the designer made and the choices that the graphic designer and the artists made and the production value like you're looking at a zillion different things and in some ways maybe it kind of ruins gaming like I've talked to designers they're like yeah I used to enjoy playing games a lot more than I do now because now I can't turn the design brain off so I think that's interesting challenge but not necessarily a bad thing it's kind of like watching film you know if you're trying to get better at anything you go find the people doing it the best whether it's comedians or or

speech writers or whatever and you just see how they do it and you break it down and I think that's what we're going to be doing here just talking about some of not necessarily our favorite game games because I've got a bunch of games on my list that I don't really like necessarily that I'm not going to pull off the shelf I'll play somebody but these are games that I feel like people should play even if you only play it once and so before we get into that these lists tell me your process like how did you come up with your games what were you thinking about as far as like categorizing different things just to give people context because this is not like a top ten it's not like oh we're gonna go from number 10 down to number one it's a little different so tell me about your process so I actually made a video of the 21 games I think every boy board game designer should play and my process for that was trying to hit every single major mechanic so trying to expose designers to every single major mechanic that I could think of so for this I did take some from that list but then I added some some new ones as well and so I'm just trying to have a good breadth of games where if I were to meet a new designer I would give them this list of 10 games and be like go play these 10 games and you will learn so much from these different types of themes mechanics being exposed to different designers that they should know about so it's just a broad range of games that I think new designers should definitely check out yeah one thing I always advise designers is don't only look at or watch reviews or play games based on the specific thing you're designing if you're working on a work replacement game don't just do work replacement stuff go do some party games

go do some deck building like see some other mechanisms and experiences because that's going to inform everything as well and so if you're listening to this and you're like ah you know I'm not I'm not designing that kind of game understood play play these anyway because you're going to learn some things and even if you don't learn anything like you're saying from the mechanism you're going to learn from the designer like why do they make this choice right and so and tell me tell me about that what are some things that maybe you learned from these games like I'm assuming these are games that you've played that you've you've figured out and all that what are some of just the general concepts you've kind of learned overall and then let's get more specific when we get into the actual kind of nitty-gritty sure so one of the biggest things you know as being a a good game of good designers you want to give players interesting choices so that's one of the most interesting thing is does a game offer interesting choices and a lot of the games on my list do that in really interesting ways how do players interact with each other that's always very interesting to me as well so then also um maybe what not to do um trying to cram in too much into a game sometimes um yeah those are the sort of General things and also when you're looking at theme trying to be different and unique not always doing the same overdone themes different things like that I wanna I don't want to give too much away before getting into the list yeah yeah absolutely to your point though another thing to think about is bad games now none of the games on our list I I don't think at least my list are are bad by

any stress the imagination a lot of them are very well loved they're in the top 200 500 or so on Board Game Geek they've made a lot of money selling a lot of copies but there's so much value in playing terrible games right it's kind of like when rain is scarce you pray for it you know I mean like when you when you don't have the balance of the good and the bad it's kind of hard to understand the context the full context and so yeah if you if you play a game and even if it is an awful experience there's value in that right and so yeah I don't know that I'll ever do a don't play these games I'm not trying to start any kind of Internet drama with with some game design yeah good good things to think about but anyway let's get into our list and I'll let you go first guess first and um technically number 10 but like this is just kind of you know it's not like a ranked thing so what's the first thing that comes to mind so yeah the first game on my list is Imhotep and this is the game by Phil Walker Harding and so every designer should know about Phil Walker Harding he is probably my favorite designer he has a great catalog of games any game that he comes out with him like I want to play that and they're all so different it's like he's done Sushi go silver and gold gizmos he just came out with one called Spellbook I played at Gen Con so he's just a great designer for other designers to know about first of all secondly this is just a really fun game so the idea is you're all ancient Egyptian Architects and you're building pyramids and obelisks and different things like that and so you're all trying to gather resources and then load

them on ships but the interesting thing one of the interesting most interesting interactions between players is that any player can launch the ship and decide which action space it goes to so you could send a ship that doesn't even have any of your resources on it has all other player resources on it and you can send it to an action space that you think will not benefit your your the other players as much as possible so there's a little bit of take that in that and I don't love take that but the way that he does it is so interesting because you will still get something out of it you'll still get something good out of it just might not be your ideal plan A and so I think that's just really interesting I've never seen that in a game before where you have like a plan you're loading up a ship but then someone else can send it send it to a different action space so yeah it's just a very interesting game the player interaction is very interesting it deals with the sort of take that mechanic in an interesting way and just an introduction to Phil Walker Harding yeah I love Phil he's been on the show in the past one of my favorite games of all time is Baron Park which he did it's a polyamino game about building a park for for Bears that's kind of literally on the bear part but uh it's a great game but to your point completely different than Imhotep that you're talking about like he is his brain is phenomenal because like yeah I'm the kind of designer I know a lot of other designers you kind of get in your lane you're like this is what I do yes I'm good at it I've play tested these types of systems a million times I'm just going to stay right here this is where I

block and where I tackle right if it was like I'm gonna go do something that I've never done before and it's still going to be one of the best games in the world yes exactly every game you play by his yeah is completely different I played Spellbook and it was the only game I played at Gen Con and I was just because I saw it I was like I'm playing that and because it was so busy at Gen Con you couldn't demo any games but I waited around to like finally play it and it's just so different from any of his other games but just like all his other games is so much sound and is so interesting and different so he's definitely a desire a designer that inspires me for sure yeah 100 all right so the first I'm gonna cheat on a few of these just to let you know where I've got like some either ORS or I've got like this sure so the first one that I really thought about is really based on you know I've interviewed over 300 designers at this point and the same four games come up over and over and over again especially as far as like games that got people into the hobby you got people into designing and so my first one is is those four which we I'm and these are all well known it's Katan it's Dungeons and Dragons It's chess and it's magic the Gathering those four games seem to be I would I would say that those four games have brought 90 plus percent of game designers into game design uh with me it was Dungeons and Dragons I know Rob davio was Dungeons and Dragons I've talked about other people it was Katan uh chess you know a lot of people grow up playing chess and kind of gets their their wheels turning at least into this not necessarily the space of game design exactly but at least in the space of like playing games and just kind of

normalizing in their lives and so anyone listen to this one you've probably played all of them if not most of them but to go back and study why these four games in particular change the world because they all did in different ways right yeah people still play these games you know and a lot of times Gamers they they'll come in with Katan they're like oh what Katana doesn't have this or that and they'll kind of like throw shade at it once they get into the wider world of gaming but I still have friends that Katan is the only game they play they get together once a week with their Catan gaming group not their gaming group their Katan gaming group yes and they play that and they you know they'll throw in the expansions and they'll play The Game of Thrones version like they you know they change things up but it's still Katan why why do people keep coming back to that game same with uh measure the Gathering just the ability to construct a deck and like have all these different Combos and all these different things you can do I mean that game's been around since the early 90s I think late like it's been around a long long time made billions of dollars so it's easy to look at some of these games that kind of everybody likes and we're like uh well you know I like this thing you've never heard of that there's only like 42 copies on the market like cool fine but there's a lot of value in looking at why did these games make such an impact so Pam with you what game got you into the hobby or got you into gaming or Game Zone yeah and I was asked this actually just the other the other day and I I don't remember like a certain specific like aha moment or anything like that what I

think it was was a Board Game Cafe opened up near me when I was in Toronto snakes and lattes one of the first board game cafes ever and it was teeny tiny now it's huge um and so I I think it was that just being exposed to a Board Game Cafe with a million different kinds of games and just started playing a million different kinds of games I think that was really the door kind of opened a little bit and then it got flung open as soon as I joined the Design Group in Toronto at snakes and lattes meeting other designers them talking about different games so I would check it out mentioning different things so I would try that out so just be exposed getting more into the community I then learned about all the all these of the games that exist that I didn't know about yeah is that something you did on your own or were you invited uh to go to the Design Group well to go to snakes and lattes at the beginning um I just I heard that this Board Game Cafe was opening down the street for me and I just went and checked it out and then they were on Twitter and I saw that they posted they have a design Meetup and I saw that and I was like oh my God that's a thing it was happening that night I ran down the street to go do it and then like Christopher Chung who designed lanterns was one of the play testers who play tested my game the very first time I went to one of these things and I was just like completely hooked after that yeah oh that's awesome and I had a similar experience of like wait what is this like this this exists like what is this world that I did not know of that apparently there's a whole bunch of opportunities so yeah that's that's really cool but uh all right so moving

on what's your next one um but just another thought about that too is that um I do remember playing Ticket to Ride and that was my first exposure to like a modern board game I'm pretty sure um and I just remember feeling completely overwhelmed and not having fun at all too complicated yeah I was just like what is that only been used to you know yeah like party games trivia games very simple role in Move games and this was like a gamer friend of mine like friend of a friend he played Ticket to Ride and I was just like yeah I was just completely overwhelmed by it so that did not hook me in so I can't remember what other game it was but now I play take a try and I love it but when you're first exposed to these games they can be overwhelming absolutely if you're used to just sort of the standard rolling move yeah um absolutely but yeah so moving on to number two which is definitely not an intro game definitely not begin two beginner beginner friendly super heavy game is called Robinson cruso and I don't know if you've played this game um oh yeah I almost put it on my list I almost did that was really close but it was like coming down to like the final slot and it was one that was up there so anyway great game go ahead so yeah so as a designer I always want to continue to push myself and to yeah like you said play games outside my comfort zone but also play games that are heavier than what I might be comfortable with or used to so there's a

lot going on in this game be prepared to watch an hour-long how to play video and then struggling through it for three to four hours um so yeah it's on my list because it is a great game um but it's a very heavy game so just me exposed to that but I would also challenge designers to play it and maybe while you're playing it think about one thing that could have been cut because I do think there is a lot going on and I think the publisher was very nice to the designer just let them do whatever they wanted I mean it all makes sense everything there that's in the game has a purpose they everything works together very well but some of the rules are a bit finicky some of the things you forget are there some of the things you're like oh wait when I do this then I can do that but it doesn't happen all the time it just happens this one specific time it can be a little bit finicky sometimes it but it is a fantastic game but from a designer point of view I would maybe look at it and think if this is my game what would I maybe streamline a little bit from it yeah that's a really good good idea with any game in general right how could you change a mechanism cut a mechanism how would that affect the game you know Rob succuso has those dice which a lot of people loathe because they do all these things they build up these strategies they get everything in place and then the dice just wreck you and there's nothing you know about it because Lady Luck was like not today and so like what would it what would it do to the game to make that a card based system where there's still the luck of the draw but you you can count the cards like you know what your odds are you know you know the percentage is a little bit better sure like how would that change the game you could maybe stack it you

could add more good things into the deck to maybe potentially help you so you know there's a less of a chance of to something terrible happening because so many terrible things happen in this game exactly which yeah is one of my favorite things though I love the system in that game of you you have the card and you read it and then it's got like it's going to come back later you know you have to put it back in the deck you're like oh man now you know it's in there you're like oh the tiger the Tiger's coming back to eat me it's gonna happen yeah or like you eat something and then it comes back later and you get sick like I I there's so many clever things in this game so in case anyone doesn't know so you basically you stranded on an island and you there are different scenarios the basic one is you're trying to build a fire to alert a ship that's going by uh in time or you all die so it's a cooperative strategy game with all different kinds of scenarios and you're all trying to work together to not die but you definitely probably will die um but there's so many different smart things going on I love how if two people go do something it's a guaranteed success but if you decide as a group one of you is going to go do it then you have to roll dice I think that is just that alone is just such a cool cool thing there's so many cool things happening in this game and I don't even know if you have to cut anything but it's just an interesting exercise to think if I wanted to streamline this game what could maybe be cut or what could maybe be clarified or maybe not so Edge case kind of finicky situations yeah definitely okay excellent choice my next one is a game called Kemet you ever

play kimet I've heard of it haven't played it phenomenal game it's kind of this like Egyptian adjacent thing going on where it's like pyramids and Pharaohs and all the like Egyptian mythology Mythos mythological creatures and stuff like that but it's kind of it's basically a war game so if you like Risk then Kim it is like the way better version of it right one thing I love about Kim it so let me back up one of the problems with risk is somebody can turtle they can go down there in Australia and it's like hard to get at them and you know there's other people up here and they're going at it and but it's not balanced like the map is not balanced right Kim it changed that in that pretty much every space can reach almost every other space and when you start the game you have equal access to everyone else on the board the way the map is arranged like the areas and you can also teleport and like you can do different things so like nobody is safe you can't just Turtle somewhere like if you're if you're doing really well Airbus is going to come get you and there's nothing you can do about it and it's great because it kind of self-balances in that way but players can also go totally different paths to Victory it's all sorts of different strategies that you can take different types of creatures that do different types of things the combat system is phenomenal it's not dice based it's card based and it's kind of you've got these cards in your hand and you're going to play one and it's going to do different things and you're going to you know look at the numbers stuff like that but it's not just winning and losing it's also basically how many casualties you take right so you could you could win the

battle but end up losing more men on the board than your opponent it's it's this really interesting thing and different cars do different things and so and it's you especially early on the game you know what your opponent has and so then you're like oh do I do I go all out do I play this like do I play my best card and then you know basically because if you play it then you lose it for a little while anyway phenomenal system if anyone is creating a game that has combat that has any kind of skirmish has any kind of bored movement as well I highly highly recommend very cool very cool who designed that one I do not know I will look that up and I'll tell you in a second you go ahead what's your next one okay

fruits by Roberta Taylor um it is a a dice work replacement game and I just I love worker placement games in general because again it comes down to choices you have so many different things you could do on your turn and I love how it's a bit of a race to see if you can get to that space first this one is slightly different um but the main reason is on my list is because of the theme so I mentioned this earlier that a lot of themes in my opinion are overdone and this game has one of the most interesting and different themes that I've seen in any game so so the the theme is you're all different animals and you're all getting ready for winter and you're trying to make your dens as cozy as possible and I just love that it's so different it's just I'm so kind of tired of seeing the same theme over and over and over especially at play testing meetups which is oh here's another one of those kinds of games so it's just we're so refreshing and so as a designer it's good to see different kinds of themes different interesting uh worlds you can create different themes you can have and this does that really really well the art is amazing you really feel like you're building up your little den and you have your little soup and you have your socks and you have your like blanket and it's just fantastic so it's a great game mechanically but theme wise it's different and interesting so it hits those both of those two points very well yeah I love that I love anytime a game can have some interesting things thematically going on

but at the same time it still makes sense with the mechanisms like things still intersect and you go oh that makes sense like it's still intuitive yeah that's really cool so the designers of kimmit I'm going to totally butcher these names but I think it's Jacques Barrio and kyukiyame Monte hey French it's in French I don't know what it is my Alabama accent does not let me say those letters next to each other but uh okay it's from madigo it's from 2012. like a lot of games on my list are ogs like they've been around a long time and I think I think that kind of is another thing to think about it's like if people are still playing this game they're still buying it I mean chess has been around a zillion years you know Katan d d match the Gathering Kim several more on my list are from like 10 plus years ago and they're still selling copies it's like yes he tells you something for sure and there's a lot of cult of the new in the board game community so no I think it's great to there's so many great games that are 10 20 30 years old for sure absolutely absolutely and there's not the flash in the pan stuff right now it's a game that comes out you're like yeah you know that's fine but it's no it's not a favorite game it's a three out of five yeah you know I I think I would rather have a game that a certain group of people are like this is my favorite game of all time and then a lot of other people are like I hate this I never want to see it again I would rather have that than just a game where people are in general are like yeah that's fine um you know something to think about as a designer you know you want a strong reaction one way or the other yeah absolutely absolutely and find your people you know right yeah not

every games aren't for everybody like you can't if you create a game for everybody it's a game for nobody so how can you really lean into your target audience so that it's their favorite game it's one of their top 10 games of all time yeah knowing that in doing that you're gonna have a whole bunch of other people are like I hate this this is nothing I want to see at all and and that's okay if you go to Amazon and you look at the best books ever written those books have a bunch of one star reviews it's just this is what it is so something to think about all right my next one Speaking of Games been around a long time uh Twilight Imperium which is now in its fourth edition or or if you're not quite into that Dune which has been around uh a zillion years as well and these are the kind of games that take forever to play Dune is like a three plus hour experience Twilight Imperium four plus five plus depending on how many players are at the table and so why would I tell you to sit down and play these one of these games even if you have no desire because I want a designer to understand what it takes for a game to last that long and still be good yes because I've I don't know about you I've made 20 minute games that lasted too long we're Paris away this is too long this needs to be five minutes I'm like okay I'm sorry um but you've got these games that these are these are two games that like people say are their favorites of all time I can't tell you how many people I've met they say oh I love Twilight Imperium one of my top three favorites of all times that's crazy and they they will they will devote a weekend bringing friends over planning out the meals for the day because it's gonna take all day because they're playing a six player game or something crazy and they'll do it all

day and they love it they'll get to the end and they just feel satisfied so as a designer how can you design a game that takes up a long time but it's still good the whole way and one thing you learn about these games is it's different systems players aren't just thinking about one thing they're thinking about a whole bunch of stuff in in chunks and bytes right in trial Imperium there's combat there's the voting where you can you know bring new laws and they're gonna change the game in some way there's there's just so many different little phases that kind of keep your brain working and none of the phases in and of themselves are big they're all pretty small there's just a bunch of them and they can stack on top of each other and so and also with anytime you see a new addition like is a fourth edition what do they change why why do they why do they take that out why do they add that in and just analyzing that so let me toss that back to you have you seen any games that you enjoy that have come out with a later Edition or an expansion that changed the game in certain ways you're like oh and you kind of saw something new that was really cool nothing is jumping to mind where they like fix the major error and then updated Edition yeah it could be or change a mechanism like I'm working on a game right now that came out a couple years ago it's hunted Kobayashi Tower and it's very dice based and I I made that game because I wanted it to have a lot of luck and a lot of just like swingy I wanted that but then the more people played it they're like it's just too much it's like oh okay and so going back in and changing d6s to d8s adding some cards in that had just a little bit extra mitigation where you can go plus one or minus one or just a few tweaks have drastically changed the swinginess of the game still out of luck

and so it doesn't have to be a massive change uh it could also just be the rule book A lot of times second editions just fix the rule book and help yeah trash they were first down around so yeah for sure I mean one of my games is the second edition but it's just like a re-theme I don't think they really change anything or updated anything so what what theme to what theme um what's actually should I just talk about it now oh heck yeah if it's on your list um so yeah it's Century spice Road Golem Edition um so the first one is just yeah I guess you're collecting spaces on a spice road now this one you're collecting crystals and then forming them into Golems I don't even know what a Golem was until I played this game um the theme is almost unnecessary in this game um but I was I did actually looked at that up this morning about what's different between the first edition and the Golem Edition and from what I saw they didn't change any tweak any rules or anything like that so I guess it was pretty solid from the from the jump um but the reason it's on my list is that it's a very interesting engine builder and it seems like engine builders have a tough time of finding themes that actually you know are intuitive makes sense help learn the game more are immersive Splendor Sentry spice Road I didn't even really know what the theme was I had like I didn't remember what the theme was I had to look it up this morning like wait what's the theme I just remember enjoying it

but the theme didn't stick with me um but it is a great engine builder um and also there's open drafting or collecting cars there's deck building you're building up a strong deck you're playing them um so there's a lot going on in this game um but they all work really well together and it is fairly simple but I just found it so satisfying to build up my crystals and you're restricted with how many you can hold at one time so it's all about timing as well and it's also with the open drafting there's that race element again too of you're trying to get a card before someone else but you can see what everyone else might be going for so there's just so many things that work really well together and I just love engine builders where as the game goes on you're doing more and better things it's just so satisfying especially when you have a deck builder element where you can have that hand management where you can decide when to play your different actions so yeah it's a fantastic game and then with the gollum Edition the major difference I guess is upgrading the components so instead of the little cubes for the spices now you have these really cool shiny crystals and different beautiful colors and then the art is really nice as well but that's secondary to the mechanics the mechanics those are so satisfying I only played this game one time but I was like I love this game so if you want to put like play an engine builder I would definitely suggest playing that because it's not just engine building it's also deck building open drafting things like that yeah definitely so the designer of that one Emerson matsuchi matsuchi anyway

phenomenal phenomenal guy I've hung out with him at conventions he's just a great dude to be around but his brain is just kind of feel like a Harding it's okay they're on different level like they just see things differently and yeah that game is definitely a a great example of that and to your point about the theme yeah that game is so themeless you could literally slap on anything and it would still be fun yeah like it's just it's an engineering game it's not a thematic deal it doesn't even need a theme no not at all but you're right though in the the satisfaction something about our little lizard brains that love taking blue and turning it into purple and then turning it into green I don't know why like there's so many games that do that and it's Wonder was the one it so that's something I'm all in for this Golem card that gives you points and yeah and getting it before someone else so I love that where you have to be aware of what your the other players are are doing because they might get what you want first because a lot of a lot of games you can be you know in your own little Silo but in games like that where you have the open drafting you have to be a lot more aware about what your other players are doing yeah so follow up to that my next game uh I'll do is called lahav your play lahave no okay these games to my list list of 2008 all right yeah a while back still holds up today same concept though with what you're talking about with uh spice Road in that you're taking this turning it into that turning it into this other thing scoring points this is how I'm

gonna build up this thing and win the game it's not quite as engine building as Century but it's still there's all these buildings out and all these cards cards of the building so the cards change every game so it's always different right and you've got these special buildings that come out and do interesting things you have a ton ton of resources trying to think there's fish there's wheat there's cows there's like all sorts of different like Iron and Metals and different things like that um and you're constantly like and the tiles are all these tokens that are double-sided and so wheat is you know wheat on one side and then on the other side it's bread and yes fish or fried fish cows are meat and then you can also turn cattle into hides and then turn the hides into clothing and then trade you know so the closing for points and so it's such a cool game but on your turn you're not doing very much nothing I think that's another thing a lot of these great games have they're not overwhelming the players with too many choices at a time but in general there are lots of choices right and one thing I love about Ohio is like there's no oh that's the best choice and then there's nothing else like okay there's these other choices I could do but that's the obvious it's like do I want this really good choice or that other really good choice or I could do this other really cool thing that sets me up for amazing Choice next time right there's so many cool things you could do and I would only play it with two or three players though that's the one I will say one negative four player is not great just because the way this turn structure is is broken down it just doesn't work as well before but two or three phenomenal game and it's got a little little fun Easter egg things like

for instance the church building will take um bread and like turn it into more it's like it it turns certain number of loaves into more loaves I see what you did there biblically uh yeah it's got little fun things but it's just a great great game it's one of the things that you play it and you get done you're like I want to play it again and it didn't take that long to play uh and you can you see where if if you lose you're like ah I should I should have done this or that like you have a pretty good sense of why you lost or why you won and then you but again you could set it up play again and have a totally different experience because the the buildings that come out this time are going to be different going to change your strategy so definitely recommend Laha that's l e space h-a-v-r-e yes it's on my list it's not Library which is what I called it anyway well I called Golem's Gollum so I don't know well if you're familiar with Lord of the Rings that's all I knew Golem Gollum Edition um yeah I was gonna say similar oh yeah so yeah I remember there's something about upgrading things there's something about crafting things and upgrading things that I just love like I want to yeah get all these resources to pay them to craft this thing and then I want to do something to flip it over to its better side and now I get like I don't know why that's so satisfying as humans but I definitely get that for sure and there is a lot of that in um Creature Comforts as well yeah something about going from nothing to something right and same this in the real world like if you're if you're doing Mission work or you're building a house or anything like you start off and there's like a plot of land and okay and then

you know a certain amount of time later we have a structure that people can live in and it's just like so satisfying to your to your soul and and there's a lot of games that really lean into that and do well and I think that's part of it engine builders especially maybe it's because it and maybe with Ninja build let me get your thoughts on this one thing I found I can't remember who told me this in an interview but anyway they said Gamers or people in general they want to feel one of three things if not more at the same time they want to feel rich they want to feel powerful they want to feel smart so anytime your game can get them to feel that way yeah it's going to do well and I feel like there's something with engine builders you feel smart because you're the one that came up with I'm gonna put a next to B next to C and we're going to run this thing and I'm gonna win the game right so has that been something you've noticed as well oh for sure 100 and I think yeah you just want to feel like you maybe you built something at the end you did something like look how much I did I started with nothing and now I'm here like absolutely no I I agree with that 100 um yeah so letting your players feel like that's another thing too even with party games they want to feel funny but not have to come up with the funny content you know so it's like look at this funny card that I picked to put in this scenario look how funny I am but all they did was pick the card that you created with the actual funny content but you are helping people enabling people to feel like they're the funny ones so these other things you're helping people feel like they're the Smart Ones because they combined these two cards that you made but then they are are doing that so you're

facilitating yeah people either feeling funny or smart or powerful all these types of things those situations all right what's your next one okay so my next one is is an or it's not four ores but it's a vast or root so these are extreme asymmetrical games if you haven't heard of them I'll take fast as an example so uh the scenario is there's this cave there's a dragon inside the cave and you can play one of I think five different characters so if you play the Knight your goal is to kill the dragon if you play the dragon you're trying to get out from the cave you play the goblin you're trying to kill the Knight you can even play the cave and you're trying to collapse onto the other players which I find hilarious um so it's an asymmetric game and extreme asymmetric game meaning where each player has their own different set of rules and own different win condition so it's almost like everyone is playing a different game but you're all playing together so yeah I don't know if I'm the biggest fan of this mechanic but I definitely thought this game out to play it because I wanted to be exposed to that type of game that style of game it is very interesting one of the things I don't love about it is that you don't really know what other players are doing because you have to remember four sets of rules at a time this especially is true with root which is another asymmetric game where each player has a very usually somewhat complicated rule

system and win condition and so you're doing your own thing you don't really know what everyone else is doing but all of a sudden someone else won so yeah it's a very interesting system to play as a designer be exposed to it and maybe you find that you love it and I just find it so interesting I'm just thinking so great that one designer I just appreciate the effort that it took to design essentially four or five for root 10 plus games in one I just think that's a feat of Designing Engineering in itself which I can appreciate I might not enjoy necessarily but I appreciate it yeah I'm right there with you root was was again it was one of those like on the border is it gonna be number 10 or not and yeah it was that same so for the same reason I'm not a huge fan of the game but it is a Monumental feat of game design yes and exactly I remember when vast came out and I think I was at origins or something around the time it came out and that's all people could talk about it's like have you seen this game it wasn't like oh this game is amazing I love it they're just like have you seen this have you seen what this dude did exactly game design you know or the fun or the enjoyment what do I worry about that right now a lot of people love it it's still a great great game but just the ability to put something like that together and it works but to your point it does have some interesting downsides right um when someone wins you're like I really hope you played that correctly like I hope you did the rules I don't know what the rules for your faction are so hopefully you got it right yeah and you kind of have to play the game a bunch of times even as one faction to

really grasp yes what you're doing and different factions are different levels of complexity and difficulty and that's something about but you kind of have to play it as all of them to really yes get the full experience and so just something to think about but yeah that might be one of those points like you were saying that yeah when people love it they love it like I've met some real root fans but like you said like they've played every single faction multiple times so for them they do know what everyone else is doing so if you find your people who like really really love it and then they invest the time to learn every single mini game within the game then I'm sure it can be a fantastic experience but for the average gamer you know it's a very long learning time it takes a long time to learn because they're learning multiple games at once and then yeah not really knowing what other people are doing right also as a game designer now you have to write five rule books which yeah at least like I hate just the thought of that makes me want to go get back in the bed and just try again tomorrow I can't even imagine the play testing for that like let's play with these four factions now let's take one out and replace the other one and now take one out like you would have to play test so many different combinations to make sure that they all work together because it could be broken in so many different ways oh well my thing won't work because you blocked this and yeah oh my God I can't even imagine the play testing they had to do for those games especially for root right all right so very different game but one of my favorites a game that I believe is perfection like I don't know of a single

thing about it that's not just like exactly what it needs to be and it's called Concordia you ever play Concordia no idea yeah again came out a long time ago has a ton of expansions at this point all sorts of different maps and different ways to play it's from a designer named Matt Gertz and Mac's a great guy he's another one that just kind of sees things on a different level but Concordia it's it's got a boring thing it's trading in the Mediterranean I mean it's it's but it was one of the ones from a long time ago so at least they were there weren't quite as many games back then as there are now but the idea is that you you have your little board you're basically move around the board building cities and collecting resources trying to get victory points and what I love about it is the card system and it's a system where you start off with a certain number of cards and each card lets you do a different thing right it might be move on the board it might be collect resources it might be build a city it might be copy someone else's Last Action all these different things um collect money but then there's also a card that you have to play to be able to pick all the other cards you've played back up right and so the game is all about timing because that that's a wasted turn and so when am I going to waste the turn and do I do I want to do two actions in a row well if I do that that means I have to play the action play the card to pick that action back up and then play that card except three turns and so like oh man it's just the tension of that and then there's this open market of other carts and these cards are like more powerful versions so like these other cards might let you get more resources or might let you uh buy

something without having to spend as much right so you're trying to balance out do I want to get these new cars to add to my hand but if I'm doing that then I'm not building cities I'm not collecting rights you know different resources so I'm not necessarily getting closer to winning and so it's such a good tension and another thing I love about it there's no rounds there's no phases it's not like step one we do it's you play a card and then the next player plays a card and and we're gonna do that until the game ends and the game ends either when you run out of all the auction cards like the deck empties or somebody builds their last City then the game ends and so there's no I don't know I just love that idea is a big fan of this too and I think it's something he tries to do with all his games like there aren't all right in round one this that and the other and we're gonna have a beginning and middle and an end that we do round two like no we're just gonna play and when the game ends it ends and oh it's so phenomenal and now there's like 10 or 15 different maps and all the maps are different some are big wide open spaces some are like a lot smaller and so you're kind of having to fight over different resources and everything's more so anyway Concordia is there area control in that as well not really air control it's but there there's a bonus there's a benefit if you get to a place first and build a city anyone else who wants to build a city there has to pay more so there is a benefit teamwork they don't pay you they just they don't pay you it just costs them more right and so there's benefits to getting your stuff out there yeah but at the same time you got to do this and you got to do that over there you gotta do this other thing and you kind of have

to it's this holistic approach because you kind of have to do all the stuff you know you can't be like all right I'm only gonna buy Cards it's like well no or I'm only going to build cities like well somebody else is going to buy the cards that build cities faster and even though you're focused on cities by the end of the game they're going to do it better than you because they've built up this these combos right with these different cars and so anyway it's just a phenomenal game shut up and sit down did an amazing review a while back about it and that's one of the things that really turned me on to the game I was like okay if these guys have all these nice things to say about it I'll check it out and so it's just a great game yeah if there's something to say like about an incredibly streamlined game like that I I actually really like that's kind of the opposite of Robinson Crusoe um I don't know if you've played the game eight minute Empire is that from Ryan Lockett yeah yes I believe so um but uh yeah it's just a very streamlined area control game where yeah you're just drawing cars you're playing cards that's it yeah literally takes eight minutes to play um and there's just something to be said like even as a design experiment as a designer to try to make something as straightforward and streamlined as that but still have a fun uh engaging experience for the player I think that's really cool yeah absolutely and something just to take away from because that game accomplishes in eight minutes what other games accomplish in 60 and it's not say better or worse it's just preference you know or if you only have 10 minutes well we know which game we're playing so yeah

exactly you can play that when you're taking a break from uh Twilight Imperium exactly all right what's your next one yeah it's Ryan Locke I just wanted to confirm that um okay so yeah so that was your in your mind that was the most perfectly designed game a perfectly designed game in your opinion so my next one is actually a perf as close to Perfect Design game as you can get in my opinion I actually made a whole video about why I think that's true I put it up against yeah Jamie stegmeyer's 12 tenets of game design and I put it up against uh my framework that I work within when I design games and it hits almost all of them not all of them maybe one day I'll find a game that hits all of them but it's called Istanbul the dice game so it's not the pickup and deliver original Istanbul game is assembled the dice game um so there's just so many great things about this game one of the best things about it is I do think it's a fantastic Gateway game so if you're just new to this or you have friends or you want to bring into the hobby or someone's interested in modern board games have them play assemble the dice game and I can pretty much guarantee you they're gonna get hooked they're going to want to play again and they're going to want to play new and different games it'll open up them into this whole world of board games so the idea is you're rolling a handful of dice which is always fun and then you're deciding what to do with that dye result and there's a bunch of different fun things you can do and one of them is you can acquire mosque tiles which somehow give you abilities for the rest of the game so you can kind of build up you level up

your your player and you can do more and interesting things as the game goes on which I think is always a fantastic thing to have in a game um so yeah it just does a bunch of things really really well it's very fast paced doesn't go on too long lots of interesting choices and one thing that's cut might be a bit silly but that I like is that when you're rolling these dice they're not Pips they're not numbers on dice they have icons on them and so in a lot of games you have to be like oh it's a four and four means I get wood or like you know I don't know but if you have a little icon of the thing and you're like oh I get jewelry I get this I get that there's your swimming I just like about that where you're not counting Pips you're not adding one PIV losing one pip you're not doing that you're just you roll you look at the icons visually you connect you know what you got it makes sense it's not arbitrarily for equals brick or whatever um yeah so it's just a bunch of great things going on here the goal of the game to be the first to collect five rubies it's a bunch of different ways you can collect rubies a bunch of different strategy strategy you can try out and just so many different things you can do with the diet result so fantastic game Istanbul the dice game very cool is there a second edition called Constantinople

I would follow up with that if anyone is interested in games like that check out Nations the dice game okay similar vein where you've got these dice that have different icons and you're trying to upgrade the dice as you bring in new buildings you get different Dice and they have different uh you know two of this and one of that like they give different uh dispersions of of icons and things like that and so that's another one to check out but also just as a general like kind of higher level concept yeah what is someone doing when they take a game and then turn it into a dice version what does the translation look like what do they have to change or cut because Nations the dice game is very very different than just the regular Nations they cut 78 of the game and turning into this guy's version almost to the almost to the point where it could be a you just put a different title and it's a different game right and so what did the designers do and why is no thing just to kind of look at and so yeah go out there and find these kind of long work replacement games and then find their dice carapods counterparts uh Katan has a dice version check that out and see what's different uh just as a pandemic as a dice version I haven't played it but it looks very different and this is very different from the original Istanbul game very very different um yeah it definitely simplifies things makes it a lot faster um yeah speaking of dice my next one let's go with Sagrada if you're in if you're interested in kind of abstract games if you're interested

in dice manipulation dice mitigation Sagrada is a really cool and you're basically building stained glass windows and you've got all these really pretty translucent colorful Dice and you put them in different orders and you're trying to score points and do different things and move them around and change them it's really interesting it very similar to like Azul and I know a lot of people love Azul I I don't that's fine I'm good at it like I win the game stock I Lose I'm gonna hit this game like no I understand how it works I just don't like I think I don't like the the way you take tiles in Azul and I've seen too many people get screwed over and the game is really mean if you if you want it to be and I think it bothers me a little bit Serrano's a little a little nicer to each other and so I think that's part of it but I really I really like Sagrada also a game from a friend of mine David Abelson it's called Garden bow Garden bow Garden bow and it's got that similar you're moving around changing different things it's a flower theme this it's really great anyway it's one worth checking out if you're designing an abstract game yeah check out Sagrada check out Garden battle yes and just see the choices see the interesting options that players have on a turn and then try to figure out okay why did they do this and how did they mitigate that I don't know I just think they're both those games are really good case studies and how to do it effectively Garden ballot didn't get the reception I'd be if we ever did a list of like games that were underrated yes it would be on my list I really feel like it should have done a lot better but um it's worth checking out it's also beautiful it's also a game yeah production wise Instagram too right

we're not just talking about games we're talking about experiences right laid out on a table instagramable right where people could take a picture of it and it shows up and it looks good online with social media it's all part of this right Azul is a great example you take a picture of that people go oh that's a pretty pretty thing what is that tell me more versus another browned you know soulless Euro gameplay and they're like oh okay cool it's just different and so it's nothing to keep in mind from a product standpoint as a designer all right what's next so yeah talking about table presence my next one has great table presents it's called cult Express so in this game there's a 3D cardboard train in the middle of the table so that just will bring people over right away and that is something to think about as a designer you know how you attract you know people if you have great table presence you will automatically bring people over to your to your table whether you're play testing or if you're pitching you might grab the attention of a publisher who's walking by but yeah there's a 3D train and you're all like Bandits trying to rob on this train um but what's interesting is about about it is that it uses a programming mechanic so if you haven't been exposed to this it's basically where you're going to decide what actions your character will take in what order and you will lock them in and then everyone reveals their first action that those are resolved reveal the second action those are resolved so it's called programming because it's like writing code and then hitting run um so it's just an interesting mechanic I don't know if I love it um because you are trying to anticipate

you know what people are going to do and your third and fourth actions might be completely useless because the situation has completely changed by then so it's just an interesting mechanic as a designer to play and to try out maybe you'll find that you do like it but just to just to be exposed to somewhat of an of a mechanic that's not used as much in games that is kind of interesting yeah so Robo rally is another one that almost made my list have you played that one no okay very very same vein as cold Express where it's programming and I'm gonna program my robot and it's gonna move forward two spaces and it's gonna push and gonna turn right and gonna do this and then you let it run everybody's just bumping into each other and you know their robots are all you're pushing each other in the conveyor belts and into saws and like all sorts of stuff right it's old school that's game's been around a long long time cold Express took that idea and then made it much more thematic right how could we do that idea that concept on a train with a heist and a shootout and stuff like that and so that's another cool thought is how can you maybe take some ideas some Concepts some mechanisms from games that have been around long time have proven to be well liked they say well how do you take that core and then change it change the theme make it better add something to it yeah take something out put it on a train with a heist and a shootout like okay that's cool that's cool and the nice thing is the mechanism is already proven we know this works how can we do that mechanism in a different way see it from a different angle right I feel like a

lot of times as game designers we we get maybe two preoccupied with coming up with something too new it's got to be super unique and now you've never seen anything like this like there's value in that for sure but there's also value in leaning into something people are familiar with they especially like with deck building you know everybody understands I I draw five cards I'm gonna play them I'm gonna discard them I'm gonna like we understand that concept now okay how can you change it just a little bit right but also at the same time it's okay to make a debt Builder that you just draw five cards what if you what if you do that but now you add a board this is what Ascension did right it's a deck building game but now we've got a board over here that I'm moving around and so I'm doing the cards here but then also moving my pieces and having combat over there okay so now that's different even though those Concepts have showed up in a million other games debt building or Combat on a board like okay that's not particularly original but the combination was super unique yeah so some of those things exactly 100 100 yeah I always say like yeah one of the reasons to play as many games as possible is to be inspired by all these games that exist and think like I like this one element of this game and I like this element of this game what happens if I combine them and smoosh them together but maybe then added a little extra in there myself yeah I think that's one of the best things about playing as many games as possible for sure and just as you were talking there just had a couple thoughts about cult Express is that Robo rally makes a lot of sense for the programming mechanic makes a lot of sense because they're robots they have been programmed and then they're doing that that's why it makes sense then cult Express I don't know why I'm shooting if there's no one

there anymore you know it's all happening so fast you know oh I'm just reacting yeah we'll play it almost like that yeah I know that that is true yeah I guess if you pretend like it's so high speed that you when you took the shot they were there but then they dropped down to the bottom level now they're not there anymore um but if they're maybe robot people that would make a bit more sense um but uh one other thing that'd be called Bolt Express yeah I love it um but I wrote I was gonna say robot express it uh it plays really well on a board game arena um obviously because the programming mechanic takes a very long time to go okay resolve okay what's this card resolve and like but board game Arenas boom boom boom boom boom it's one of the games that plays better on board game arena than in person um for sure yeah it's very interesting uh definitely yeah all right so next one on my list we're gonna go kind of to the opposite end of the spectrum we've been talking about a lot of complicated games games that take a while kind of heavier whatever I'm gonna go to a game that's barely a game basically an activity and it's called silly Street and it's a game for families it's getting that my kids have have loved especially when they were a little bit younger and it's it is silly it is a silly game of going down this silly Street and it's kind of this roll and move type deal and every time you land on a space you you draw a card from different places it's almost like a

like a Trivial Pursuit thing where you draw a card and you're gonna have a cranium where you're gonna have to do different things right you might have to draw you might have to act something out you might have to you know you've got 30 seconds to run to your room and grab something red and bring it back you might have a vote one of them is in there it's like who has the worst Bed Head in the mornings and I obviously always got voted that as the person and so all my kids laughed at me but I also because I got voted that person I got to move forward two spaces I was like well you know it works out you can laugh at me but I'm I'm now winning the game and so there's a lot of games on the market like this that as Gamers as game designers especially we have a tendency to look down our nose at and we go oh this is barely a game where are the choices where are the interesting decisions that's a valid criticism however silly Street has probably sold more copies than all my games put together for the rest of my life right yeah and so it's something to be aware of again what's your target audience what's the market you're aiming at and and be okay with a game being a little lighter because one thing I've found especially in play testing the more I play test the game the easier I think it is but that's because I've played it a hundred times when someone plays it for the first time they're like wow this is too complicated what are you talking about this is so simple it's simple for me because I made the thing and I've done it a billion yes so always remember that someone coming in is gonna feel like kind of like your experience will take it to ride like that's not a complicated game but when you don't have experience with it it's overwhelming because although it's so brand new and so that's something to think about also

there's something to be said for a game that is just simple you put it on the table you don't have to think you just grow some dice see what happens another couple games I wrote down shut the box which is a game where you're literally just rolling two dice and then you're hoping to get certain numbers that's kind of it there's like two decisions in the whole game there's can't stop which is another game from you know the 80s I think and you're rolling dice you're trying to move it's a pusher luck game but you're really just rolling Dice and hoping for the best people love those games and they take 10 minutes to play and it's easy right after dinner before kids have to get ready for bed just throw it out on the table have some fun laugh for a minute have a nice little moment and then move on about your day there's so much value in those games so I just wanted to Highlights yeah 100 I mean as someone who loves party games and loves designing party games yeah creating those experiences that are easy to learn easy to get into easy to understand but they create those memories and those experiences that you want to create for for people and their friends and family and if you can do it in a clever way like designing very streamlined simple games I put simple and quotation marks is difficult you know a lot of people can't do it especially want to do something different that hasn't really been done before but if it if it takes if it does something in a clever way but in a simple clever way I think that's I think that's fantastic and that's what I try to do with my party games not have a

million different things going on but have some sort of clever interesting thing that makes it have that ooh moment when you read the back of the box and then that creates those moments between players I think is great yeah and to your point it's it's much harder to cut than it is to add exactly exactly yeah all right what's next yeah um well my next one is definitely not simple um it's tyrants of the underdark um so this is a deck building game with area control set in the Dungeons and Dragons fantasy world so I was also going to put Dungeons and Dragons but I'm glad that you said it um to have like a role-playing game so this isn't role-playing but it's set within the dungeons of Dragons World so if you enjoy this then you might get hooked into sort want to explore the dungeons Dragons World a bit more um but it uses deck building with area control and I don't think I've played a game that does that before um but it does a really interesting way two really solid mechanics that work well together just feels like you're playing two really good games in one because you have the deck building going on any of the area control so in case anybody doesn't know area control is just if you have the majority of a region then you have uh you control that region you get points or resource or whatever so yeah and then the theme just the art the feel of it you feel like you're in this world um you're building up your your army and you're trying to Vie for control over the underdark so yeah I I thought this

was a fantastic game it took a little bit to get into but once you I mean if you already know the deck building mechanic you already know the area control you get into it fairly fairly easily but the mechanics wise and theme wise all worked really really well together yeah very cool and so piggybacking on that my next one also a building game legendary and I think these games have some interesting things to to think about in how they implement something but do it in interesting ways right it's not just a clone of dominion right it was it was yes designers figuring out a way to take the concepts of dominion but then turn it on its head and offer something brand new that really appeals to people whether it's in theme because minions kind of like you know again we're trading in the Mediterranean basically but with tyrants of the underdark okay dungeon dragons sales right and people love fantasy right to put into there yeah or legendary has like 10 different themes now and all the games are a little bit different you have the Marvel you have 007 you have X-Files you have Firefly alien The Matrix which I think just came out and every game is different it's the same core it's the same concept but it's it's different and the changes that they make it they make sense you're like okay it you know because we're doing this whole different Universe now it makes sense that the cards work this way still the same you know I spend these resources to gain these cards cards are moving around this little board and whatever but it kind of makes sense more intuitive and so something I want desires to be thinking about is can you create a game that's also a system that

leans itself into being able to be re-themed yes to make more money and to make more games I mean pandemic has had like 20 different versions at this point there's Cthulhu there's all sorts of different like time periods I think like ancient Rome is one yes and they just keep printing money with this right so if you can create a system right tires are dark similar kind of thing like you could set that in space you could set that in the wild west like you could take those Core Concepts of deck building and area control and the way things are moving around on the board and put a new spin on it and have a very very different game that appeals to either the same audience that wants more of the same or a new audience that's more interested they don't like fantasy but they'll play Space they'll play Wild West right because they have a cool core system and I don't know you can just you can productize things in a really cool way if you create like a really nice core yeah 100 and to build on that so I've been working on this game for the past two years it's finally coming out next year so I can't talk about it like in such detail but it was a game I had to create a system that wasn't couldn't necessarily be I mean it could be re-themed but with the idea of of scaling it of being able to add in expansions to add it to slot in different characters or add different characters to the world to build it out so I had to think of how can I make that work where this game you can play it with two you can play it with three four or possibly five six with the expansions how would they fit in with that so each player has their own land tiles and then depending on which players are are

playing that's what would create the board so you could play with six because they all come with their own reason their own tiles their own yeah get like say I want to like talk about this game so bad when this game comes out we get to talk again but yeah just the idea of like yeah creating a system that can be scalable or like you said can be re-themed to different things this is very important yeah very cool and just from a again from a business standpoint anytime you can make a game with a long tail right that you build up an audience and that you can keep giving them new factions new characters new expansions exactly right that and again you're not just making stuff you're making it because they want it it's got to be good you know just oh I made a system and here's a million different ways it still has to be fun and enjoying a good experience yes yes but if you make a game that is so specific then there's nothing wrong with that but it's going to be hard to change it it's gonna be hard to like add more to it um and again there's no wrong answer it's just a matter of just kind of thinking what do you want to do and how do you want to carry it out yeah all right what's your next one so was Legend legendary was yours legendary was mine yep okay cool are your games seem to be like magically kind of aligning to each other well I'm doing I didn't have them listed like in a number oh yeah oh okay we're doing it organically yeah uh okay so my next one is King of Tokyo nice um by Richard Garfield designer of Magic the Gathering you can't see it but it's like right over my shoulder right over here oh there you go literally it was like again another one of those

borderline ones you I'm glad that you chose almost all of my borderline ones this is working out yeah yeah this is great yeah no matches yet so we have one more um okay so yeah in this game you're trying to be the most powerful monster in Tokyo and it does a great job of two of the tough toughest mechanics you can work with as a designer in my opinion uh that's take that and player elimination so in general players don't love these they can generate bad feelings among players uh people are waiting around possibly for a long time before they can play again if they've been eliminated um but it does it really well in my opinion because first of all uh eliminating the other monsters is not the only way to win you can just build up your own power high enough that you are the strongest so you win so you don't have to go after other players if you don't want to um and then player elimination is such a fast game that if you get eliminated you're waiting around Max 10 maybe 15 minutes before you can join back in for another game it's not like Monopoly where you're waiting around for a couple hours before you can get back in so it takes two yeah two tough mechanics and does a fairly a pretty good job with them I would say but then just in general it's a fun game you're again rolling a handful of dice and it's a yahtzee roll so you can re-roll a couple times try to get what you want and you can buy cards to power up your character you can decide what direction you want to go do you want to try to yeah build

up resources to buy Cards so you want it you have to increase your health and there's also a bit of a push your luck aspect to it where if you're in Tokyo um you can't heal but then you get more points the longer you stay in there maybe stay in there too long and your health goes gets down too low you have the potential of dying and that does happen quite often but the you they so like you want to stay in there as long as possible so interesting so there's a lot going on but it is a fairly simple game and it's one of my favorites for sure yeah this is one of the one ones that anytime I was playing with new Gamers right people who are only familiar with Monopoly and clue and stuff like that this is one of my go-to's because it's like okay you ever played Yahtzee pretty much everybody's played Yahtzee it's Yahtzee but we're gonna add a couple more things and we'll explain them as we go and there's only a few cards out at a time so you don't have to explain every card just have to explain the few that are out there to say hey well this one does this gives you more energy very simple to understand and I was playing most of it with high school kids down at Honduras and they all just picked it up real quick and then they just they loved it they especially younger people they love take that they love destroying you you know yeah yeah that's part of it too but also I love how anytime I got eliminated for a while it was my fault because I was trying to do too much I was trying to push it I was trying to max out I was trying to stay in Tokyo and max out on damage everybody else and that was really what was more important I wasn't even trying to win I was trying to do something cool and it gives you the ability to do that it makes sense that that's possible because Richard Garfield designed it and he also did Magic the Gathering which is another thing it's like you have players that want to win you have players that want do cool Combos and both are cool like it's yeah

either strategy is fun and so that makes a lot of sense yeah I love I love that game but like you were saying earlier how do you how can you take a games mechanism from a long time ago in this case Yahtzee and then right do it totally differently and make it something special mm-hmm all right yeah 100 on the opposite end of that these these two are not related at all my next one is sleeping got which ah I just looked this up the other day look cool phenomenal I'm excited for the next one the sleeping Gods part two basically distance guys which is somewhere in the shipping process right now like it's about to get on people's tables and because sleeping gods for oh it's amazing this it did have some issues which I think the next iteration is fixing a lot of that well so there's another example of fixing some things in the next Edition all right it is a massive adventure game kinda open world in nature you still have these like Euro mechanisms that are controlling like how far you can move and there's like some resource management and stuff like that but it is just going back like like root a phenomenal feat of game design even if you don't like it even if you don't like adventure games and it's not your style just to take a step back as designer and appreciate the amount of work and effort that went into bringing it to life even just the book of The Narrative I saw the size of that book I was like oh my goodness a lot of people's favorite game a lot of people hate it but a lot of people it's the thing that they love most about the Hobby and so just something else to take

away from that but it's got story it's got puzzles it's got combat it's got all these different things that make up this really big epic adventure yeah it also it doesn't hold your hand necessarily like it doesn't say go to space F5 and do this it'll say oh you need to go find the the jagged rocks so now you're looking at the map you're like okay what which rocks okay that one could be a jagged rock that one that's probably that's probably this let's go over there let's see what that is and let's continue the story and so you kind of have to figure some things out on your own uh it does have one issue where it kind of resets where as you go throughout the game you kind of get to different points and like it resets your abilities it resets your cards that's kind of an unfun thing that they're fixing in the next one but I don't love that no but I understand I'm designing an open world Adventure game in a lot of ways inspired by sleeping Gods so my game's called robomon it's kind of like Pokemon the board game and okay sleeping Gods is not just a great game I think in general it's a great game for me as a designer personally because I saw that game and I was like oh there's so much more we can do with board games and then that inspired me to do some other cool stuff so from a personal standpoint but yeah one thing I've learned this goes back to when I was talking about Twilight Imperium in Dune how do you make a game that lasts a long time in this case like 30 hours of gameplay but you still keep it interesting and different and fun and I think what happened was Ryan Lockett ran into the situation was with like if you just continue to gain cards and abilities like by the end of the game you're gonna have a hundred of these things and so how do we fix that well we need some resets we need to do some

things that cause that not to happen because that's just too much going on and that was his answer there are better answers and I think he kind of figured that out in distance guys I'm really excited to see how he's doing it differently but to keep players engaged for a 30 plus hour campaign that's a challenge you know and there's games like tainted Grill and a lot of the week and realm stuff they're doing this they have so much narrative and story and content or content to get through how do you make it fun for a long time something to uh to think about but it's hard it's a big it's a big challenge it takes forever that's another thing I was talking I did I did an episode with Ryan and I was like man how many games could you have designed in the time it took you to do sleeping Gods it's like 10 yeah you know you could have done 10 other products for the time to do that one so something yeah it's a big investment it really is it has to be a labor of love if you don't love it it's not worth the time the effort the money everything that goes into it we don't have a publisher who's interested who's who has signed the contract to make it I don't know if I could like this game that I've been working on for two years that is all I've done for like two years it's also like open World um quests and all that um yeah it was with a publisher who was I signed the contract at the start of the development process so it's not like I don't know if I could have the motivation to do something that big without a commitment from a publisher yeah I would honestly warn a designer against it if you're not gonna do it

yourself if you're not going to do your own crowdfunding campaign and because the potential for it's hard to find a publisher no matter what but it's really hard to find a publisher for big games that are expensive you know and the amount of time and everything and yeah that you maybe just came up yourself and they don't know anything about it and they might have IPS that they would rather work with and they might ask you to completely change the narrative to one of their IPs they have to redo everything yep yeah yeah it's a tough one if you're not gonna do it if you're not gonna publish it yourself I would warn somebody away from from diving into because it's epics because I got started working on this game in April of 2020. so yeah where are we at now it's like September 2023 you know hopefully it's going to come out spring-ish next year like that's the plan that's a long time so yes all right yeah 100 what's your next one okay so this is my last one um it's Charter Stone so yeah Jamie stegmeyer's Legacy game um I feel like it yeah it would probably be on my list of maybe yeah underrated a lot of people I feel like don't talk about it um but it's a great legacy game um you know pandemic Legacy tickets right Legacy they get kind of all the attention but charterstone is very cool so you're basically um and it's a competitive Legacy game which is interesting um but you're all trying to build up this Village and yeah you're unlocking

crates so there's all these little boxes in the game and you're you're opening them up and you're adding new cards you're adding stickers to the board you're changing the board over time you're building up this land and just the art super cute opening up the crates is so satisfying it's so cool to to discover new things and add it to the board and make you the board unique and different from anyone else's board yeah it's a fantastic game there's a lot lot going on like Jamie stigma I don't know how he designs these we were just talking about that like scythe and Charter Stone how much effort goes into these massive games that he makes and I don't know how he he probably has a big team helping him and lots of play testers and stuff but it's a lot it's a big Endeavor for sure especially with Legacy games I don't know how you play test that that's a tough that's tough to do but yeah it's a great legacy game I definitely recommend it to check that out especially if you haven't played a legacy game before and you don't really know what that genre is it's a very cool concept yeah charterstone Taps into one of the things that people love in general which is surprise what's in the box right what what new little goodie are we going to find in this box especially if it's based on like your own choices you know it's nothing yeah some Legacy games it's okay we're gonna open box number five because the game told us right versus I'm gonna open box number five because I did a thing and I traveled over here and I've explored this or that and now I get to open box five like it's on it's my

decision like that's a cool thing to lean into and yeah tarstone just a great example of that yeah to your point like a little underrated but people don't really talk about it now yeah um there's been so many other Legacy games come out so many not that many like 10. we're not talking about 30 minutes it's very weird that it doesn't get the the attention that they take forever to design the same reason there's not a whole bunch of these like really massive open world games um yeah I had a really good conversation with Rob davio just a few days ago where we're chatting about play testing and I asked him how do you play test a legacy game and he's like oh like you could just see the the weight the burden of this and because you have to get groups that are going to go through the entire campaign but you have to but they're also iterating and you're making changes but you can't necessarily get the same group to do it again because they already they've already seen stuff right so you're constantly having to find new people and yeah it's a challenge yeah that's one I don't think I'll be doing anytime soon all right my last one is Arkham Horror the card game so is another example of a really popular game that was then turned into a different version but in this regard I think a better version Arkham Horror is an amazing game it's been around a long long time had some issues right it could take way longer than it should it's like a game that shouldn't last that long kind of it's a lot of luck life swinginess a lot of dice and so they turned it into a card game and you still get the adventure even though you're not moving around the board and going you still feel like you're exploring you're investigating you're moving from card to card room to room but the systems are just so tight like

they're just so good you know and you're building your deck based on you know your select a character and you have certain cards that are just generic cards but then each character has different cards specifically for them some are really good some not so good so you get some kind of flaws it's flaw cards in there and that's kind of interesting which gives you more replayability so even though like each box doesn't come with a bunch of scenarios and my honestly is a little overpriced for what you get but you can play each scenario with different characters and play it out in different ways and so cool just replayability there um there's a big campaign so it's like this overarching story if you're into that like you can kind of go from you know the beginning middle and end and kind of see how the story is going to change and evolve it can change depending on your choices it's just a cool game and then also organ horror had Dice and you had to get like a five or a six for success and you're trying to roll as many dice as possible but it's still swingy well they replaced that with this bag building kind of system where you're reaching in a bag and you're drawing a token you're playing cards to get let's say you need five five resources or five five is your your target number well I might play cards and now I have four so I need to draw a token out of the bag and hopefully I get a plus one or higher but there's also negatives there's also instant fails there's also tokens in the bag that do different things based on the scenario based on the chapter of the you know story you're in so that changes you can make the the bag easier or Harder by changing the token distribution in there so that's kind of cool um anyway so they took that idea that

system of okay we still want some luck we still you don't know yeah if you're gonna kill them the monster but we're gonna make it a little less lucky a little less swingy uh and I think it was really cool systems anyway Arkham Horror the card game and are you able to add better tokens into the bag as the game goes on if you do good things are you rewarded with that no I don't think so um okay you just said it's like the beginning at the beginning and you change it depending on the scenario right so some scenarios you're gonna add different tokens and the a lot of tokens are generic and they might mean different things for this scenario so this icon in scenario a means this the icon and scenario b means that and so yeah that can change but but there's also that freedom where if you wanted to as a games are you could go in and kind of like mess with the bag and make things a little bit different yeah and so I think that's what I really want to do yeah like if you succeed at this thing you can add one more good token to the bag yeah and that might be that might happen there's so many scenarios at this point like so many different versions uh they might have added that the ones I played I don't think that was part of it so it very well could be I don't know why they wouldn't do that you know change the distribution um during the still luck based yeah during the game you could also make it harder you know as as Hulu comes out and then all of a sudden he adds these really negative tokens in the back so now you're more you're more likely right to have bad things happen um right mid game as opposed to from you know from the beginning where you're just kind of getting started I like getting one games level when they scale you know we go from not a lot going on to at the end it's like

oh my gosh there's so many things happening and um yes it's just really tense and stuff like that definitely you want that Arc for sure yeah well Pam there's a good list you had I really appreciate we didn't have any crossover which no not one cool yeah I thought I didn't think we would but that was cool that was really fun yeah I mean I need to do this again I need to like find other like top 10 topic kind of things I mean the dice tower has made a living off of doing top ten yeah for years you do top 10 insert whatever you've got a viral video yeah absolutely and just but I love breaking it down from a design standpoint because you know exactly 99 of those videos are this game is fun because of X Y and Z reason whereas it's kind of cool to look at it this game is that ain't necessarily good it's just like this is a game to be aware of or a game to play because of these cool things it has going on I think this is that's cool thank you for suggesting it I really appreciate you uh offering up this as a topic yeah that was super fun well Pam where can people find you I know you've got a really great YouTube channel that's how I discovered you you've been putting out some really cool game design Focus videos for a while now so tell people about that and any other place they can find you online yeah thanks so much for having me Gabe this is super super fun um yeah so my YouTube channel is pamel's Game design so I try to put a video out every week um I'm also on Instagram Twitter Facebook my website Pamela's game design as well so that's where you can find me yeah you got any games you can wanna plug or where people can find yourself yeah so my uh last so I have three

published games one is hold that face with Hasbro act fast with outset media a Blog party with Whiz Kids and that's the one that just came out at Gen Con so it is slowly filtering out into stores hopefully gets into a few more um it's definitely available online um it sold out at Gen Con it's been really get really it's been getting really good uh feedback um so I'm really really happy with that game it's my favorite party game that I've made so far it's a Cooperative game where you're trying to all become one Big Blob and you have Play-Doh you can smush together with googly eyes so it's super fun um so that one for sure and then hopefully I'll be able to talk about my adventure game coming out next year um it's with Robin's burger and that's all I can really say right now but hopefully can announce it pretty soon awesome yeah I'd love to have you back and we can dive deep into that game and hopefully my adventure game is out by then too and maybe we can just kind of compare notes Adventure Party yeah definitely Fam thank you so much for being here really appreciate your time yeah thanks for having me appreciate it foreign

Progress saved