Skip to main content
Loading video...

10 Reasons Your Rule Book Isn't Working and How to Fix It!

Transcript 21:16

hello and welcome to guacalope thank you for being here today I am joined with Jonathan bobel uh who that's me is a rulebook you're a you're a board game rulebook I think I am a rule book yes yeah you uh are you right now uh freelance uh and as a passion on your own hobby time use your history as a special ed teacher uh you said you have a master's degree education and you've been applying that to the world of rule books and we first got in contact with you or you got in contact with us yeah around Horseless Carriage from Slaughter games coming out because you've worked alongside some of the designers over there to produce a second alternative version of the rule book that's a little bit more thematic has more art assets and might make some people uh able to table the game slightly easier than others and you've also worked with quite a few companies in the industry at this point right how many uh like what are some of the different companies you've done on projects for awaken Realms I actually worked with them to revamp their Great Wall book okay Lucky Duck have many Capstone games sure I mean worked with Fantasia games yeah there's so many we've been pulling games off the shelf downstairs to find uh your name in the you know the book editor there's a few like just a second no you have not been the lead on everything but one of them is not working to get to the point where you could actually be a lead rulebook uh rules editor or lead rulebook uh kind of writer and designer yeah and some of those projects I was the full lead and graphic design too some of these I do the full layout there as well very cool so I thought today we would have a conversation from two

different perspectives around five elements that we each think every single rulebook all the way down to code names all the way up to aeon's trespass Odyssey please rewrite that rulebook for me all right you do that you do not want to go I do want that oh my God no one else I don't know either way but it's a whole conversation for another time we thought it'd be fun to talk about five different elements that we believe every board game rulebook should have yes elements of design elements of instruction uh whether you know I have some things that are about the formatting of them but we'll see leave a comment down below I want to know two important things first off I want to know what is the worst rulebook you have ever read and I might be working another list of video and two I would like to know what are essential for you when you're looking through a rulebook what what are the elements of a rulebook that either make it table for you or you'll put it down to the side and you'll say I'm gonna let someone else in my game group read that because I'm still excited about the game but my my mind's not working on this stuff and I'm going to read those comments as well so if you if you put those there I will read them and I will you might literally make Rule books better you will I'm gonna let you start this time because you made me start last time what's your number one what's the first element of rulebook design or principle of rulebook design that people should be following well I think I I want to play a game okay I'm here to play games so I want a rule book you saw on me do you want to play a game

yeah so this blue Maven jaws of the line because the element is like let me play quick so this is essentially the rule book Element is how fast can I open this rule book and start playing it can that happen do I have to read a whole rule book before now I know that's not going to be possible for every game I mean I guess technically it could be if you put a lot of time into every game you could make a tutorial but so the challenge would be something like a heavy Euro like something like Horseless Carriage how do you get back to the table and allow you to play quick while at the same time being able to facilitate the next stage well that that's an interesting thing I like I like that concept though I like the the question of how quick does your game table right in some and honestly for some games to learn and play in 40 minutes is okay for some games to learn and play in five minutes it's okay it's not a conversation about playing in five minutes every time it's a conversation about how long does it take always double checking what's the what's the time someone's doing invest before getting something to payable yeah like dungeon Lords if anyone knows they have tutorial little missions so you could start playing the game before you know the full rules and you're not really playing the full game but you're playing little mini games essentially or something like uh vampire masquerade chapters yeah it gave us the opportunity to learn the rules by playing through solo missions with each one of the base characters nine total solo missions taught you all the core mechanics you're looking for so I was actually playing the game and learning at the same time I love the concept I think for some euros it might be hard to integrate but I

think I think even little like modules where you have the game fully set up and then as you're reading the rule book it's saying like hey take this little sequence of actions look at how this puzzle resolves yeah it's like giving little puzzles exactly that's like what dungeon learned stuff interesting I almost think there could be a whole separate genre of rule books that do something like that like solo puzzles or something for to facilitate the learning environment that's funny that you mentioned that I did something like that for um Kingdom Rush like it's literally separate scenarios to teach the game interesting been released yet but they might be cool cool moving on to my number one everyone is going to agree with me on this every single rulebook should have aggressive and dedicated well-written flavor text oh no say that so the sheriff of Eureka Springs has been murdered with no one guarding his Gates Ruffians are coming in droves to take advantage of the defenseless town is this the end for Eureka Springs of course not that makes me excited to play the game I love having theme I love having story I love having artwork I love having flavor text that supports the rules that I'm reading now here's the other element of this you might be saying what I'm gonna say and I'm gonna take credit for this as well when you put in flavor text the theme and uh environment into the rule book itself it helps refine the rules you the game should operate and in my opinion a good game should operate in ways that make sense to the theming of the game and so it helps not only the player attach themselves to the mechanics of your game

but it helps you as a designer and a writer of the rulebook understand why these mechanics actually work within the context of the game environment yeah I learn a lot of things through experiential the one thing I'll pick up on a board game majorly is when some mechanic does not integrate accurately into a theme if I'm if I'm spending a research if I'm feeding people by spending wood and lumber and there's not a good justification for that yeah I suddenly have this disconnect in my mind now what were you going to say um well before that you brought up a good point I haven't talked about dungeon Lords again your your link of thematics so their rules for the ghosts in that game it's thematically sound they're like they can go through walls because they're ghosts so that's the rationale for them being able to move through walls like stuff like that you're not going to forget that yeah why would a ghost not be able to go through 100 and if a ghost can't go through a wall I suddenly as a player I'm sitting here going like ah yeah but they but they can I mean like you don't your rulebook doesn't get to Define what ghosts are ghosts are you know visages of past life that can totally transport through walls yeah and but I was gonna go go along with so thematic is good but please make sure that it is clear what is thematic and what these rules and also if you're gonna try to claim something systematic as a technical editor uh as well um I want to know what is actually the rules and just me but this is good this is clear this is thematic type sure um when I'm going through here it's it's separated out yeah like sometimes

there's blocks here you can see like in the yeah that section what doesn't kill you probably won't make you stronger I don't necessarily need all this page to be themed but even little blips like this all of these Chums are out for blood that ties me down to the game and lets me feel like I'm having fun while I read the book yeah but now if that was in the targeting section in this same font yeah so if that happens sometimes the target for an action can be a single townspoke a group of town spoke or none at all what doesn't kill you probably won't make you stronger yeah it might get in the way a little bit Yeah because at least for me I mean I'm trying to find the rules now yeah I I want to know where it is sure so that's that's my element which is kind of goes on along with you it's a good point uh what is your what's your next thing I don't know why I'm moving this off to the side it can stay right there what's your number two that was my number two keeping things yeah separated okay so that's what I was saying it kind of like goes with yours so the Thematic stuff is great but I don't want to have it in the rules like basically have an outline of the rules like this but don't don't mix so if somebody wants to find rules and essentially it makes it easier to find things I will argue and this doesn't work for everyone let's see though some I mean if I I want to see if I can find a good a good place that I would have to it might be a little well and I might um but there are absolutely some elements in here that are thematic and rules mixed together if they mix together and they and help and I so like you can only endure so much okay not dying is hard work over time your circumstances will grind you down and if you don't do something about it you'll

eventually die or as the game presents it become unendingly unconscious you and your team will increase into stress be affected with strange new behaviors and conditions and in time we'll simply be unable to go on support each other and mitigate your distress and complete your tasks before your endurance collapses if you don't it'll be the last thing you ever fail at so this that is a whole paragraph to basically say be very careful you might die but it's thematically integrated and so and so it is a conceptual yeah which is great that kind of stuff is I love that kind of overview so there is a there is a bit of blurring the line but I I will agree with you when you're when you're on the brass tax rules don't put Superfluous in when you're in the middle conceptual going towards rules add in some layers but make it clear what parts are indicating what you're looking out for like here I know that I'm going to be uh you know increasing distress distress is now a key word that I'm optimized for the language is going to be the same between the rules and the theme and then as we get back to the very front of this when you're talking about the uh the actual flavor text make that not uh you know not something that people are looking in for rules or keywords or cues yeah and I guess it's good to say too I was basically in the mindset of Euro games when I was saying all that too but in a thematic game it makes more sense to have more thematic text that's as well so um I was thinking like uh okay my next one I don't know that I'll have a good example at one of the best examples that I can think of is actually a game called Sniper Elite uh I I did a little bit on

that side maybe I can't talk about it we'll see we'll see so uh I love winning rule book understands how the players are going to be experiencing the game that is in front of them and takes the time to bold indicate graphic bubble or pop off to the side little hints uh or areas that are going to be hard for you to play even if they've spent even though they're spending ton of time hired hired a professional to go through and refine the rulebook there are still going to be elements of gameplay that do become confusing for players that they have to double check the rulebook for try to indicate that try to find that through play testing and once you think your rulebook is as good as it can be take the time to make little areas pop out uh with and I don't know if there's a good example in here but make little areas pop out uh so like here we have bold text for instance uh use bold text use different color text like in Frost Haven uh everything that is different from gloomhaven is actually in a in a blue or a second type thing and that's important because a lot of people are going to be coming with the preconceptions of gloomhaven in their mind and then something like Sniper Elite there's a whole run down the side column of that rule yes that says hey if you've already read this page this is what you need to know if you know this awesome if you don't know this you're in trouble that type of stuff that type of thought process to not only the intro walking into a game but then also the experience that's going to be happening as someone sitting at the table playing the game is really important yeah that sidebar is good yeah what's your number

three um player Aid okay lights come on oh man play right in the Roblox or play right out of the rulebook everybody needs something yeah I don't care like because we just make that a rule for Publishers I don't think everybody needs something text like there's there's going to be a structure to a game hopefully if you don't have a clear structure maybe that's kind of like two things mixed in one you need a clear structure everyone should have that structure so they could look at it like okay this does this we're going to go through these things so you're you're I mean as a teacher I'm thinking about ways to make teaching the game easier everyone has this play right they can look at it the teacher is the teacher teaching the game is uh referencing the things so they have something to like latch onto like it's an educational principle I guess maybe that's only obvious too because I've studied it for years but oh I mean you agree insanely frustrated by games that don't have a good play raid yeah or I mean forbid you go to BGG in the community like someone like you has taken the time good quality player age like uh I'm sorry uh looking at you uh what is it uh blood blood Black Rose Wars uh look at you black rose that doesn't have a play right why did the community have to develop and design your player aid for no very offensive that's a huge game massive game massive game you almost like it should have a play rate every game from code names up needs some type of reference material for the players at the table even if it's just a little card if we're talking code names sure

and Capstone did great with um their Siege of Vienna we got a whole player you know you could you could learn the game pretty much just from that okay my number four I believe that every publisher should spend some degree of time either taking educational classes or watching reviewers and producing their own version of how to play guides shut up sit down has a Incredible video on how to actually teach a board game and one of the things that I see Rule books Miss so often is they get bogged down into the details of rules structure and formatting based off of how they made their appendix or you know start with a heavy setup like five pages of setup before ever getting to the other elements of the game and it's just not how we as players learn a lot of experienced rulebook readers a lot of experienced board gamers will actually digest a rulebook based off of flipping beyond that how to like how to set up section all the way to the win loss conditions then the flow of play then the nuance and specific turn order then maybe the how like then maybe the how to set up area so I'm not advocating removing the how to set up section I am advocating for structure your rulebook in a way that is uh intuitively the way that you would approach teaching the game if you were sitting down at the table and trying to eat your friends up and running start off with a page of maybe a little bit of flavor text follow up with the win loss conditions the overview and the objective then get some of the basic components out onto the table so we're familiar with what we're seeing and then start walking us through start with the uh you know flow of the

game The Experience that's going to be had zoom in on a player board have them move some pieces around zoom out onto the major Tableau have them figure out how these systems work and then Loop it all back into the win loss conditions in the actual format of the game it's not going to be easy for every single game but I do think purposeful attention needs to be paid too how does my game not in a rulebook form but in a sitting across the table from other players format how does how do people actually teach it to other people yeah that's a great aspect because not everyone's a teacher yeah so your rulebooks should have that guidance there yeah I mean because you're trying to play a game not trying to

everyone's grateful for what you do if you do your job the best it can possibly be done yeah no one notices your thing like if your rulebook is well done everyone just plays the game if your rule looks horrible everyone's angry at you there's gonna be no praise yeah because they're gonna just say the game's great so a lot of times like gluehaven if they it didn't have these things this if this was a horrible rule book I don't think everybody would like Loom Haven yeah I mean it'd be hard it'd be hard-pressed but whatever work their way through yeah what's your number four my number four number nine number five I went first uh you went first what's your number five my number five is terms if you keep consistent terms make it easy to find what the terms are make it easy to find what they mean yeah consistency in terms is Major consistency yes so perhaps if you're going to use a term that is not normal like um breakthrough breakthrough could mean anything in any game but see here breakthrough is right here perhaps if there is a well that might be the full rules for it but having a page number just a like an index essentially or a table of contents one of those and even be there I feel like at this has it yeah right there this is wonderful uh so I I do have one question I I like some thematic keywords I think some thematic key like like oil canister instead of action Cube for me makes sense if we're in a post-apocalyptic you know driving game however I do find that sometimes

games get bogged down with their own inventive new words and others to using classic reference phrases yeah and so for me my preference would always be if there is a standard reference word that the industry kind of has consistent about around most games or comparable games in your genre use the standard reference word that is comparable in your genre and then explain through flavor text and story what that standard if I say action Cube that's okay I might thematically also learn that the action cube is one of your you know workers who's joining your army and going to forces against the goblin hordes that's fine when it comes to the actual like flow of play a Olga blog is much harder to remember than a action Cube yeah and for an example in Horseless Carriage they're called something's called a niche what's a niche no idea but if I told you with pretending another game a square sure do you know what a square is yeah notice if you look at that so sometimes if you use just a simple term especially for a heavy Euro that could be very beneficial yeah I understand the desire to make things somatic and I do like thematic references when it is important to know them when they add to the game but sometimes they do take away so so work your way through that double check with the community they have to make sense they have to be easy to remember or you should default to something that's more commonplace in the industry of your choice okay uh my last one is going to be uh separated books

now this kind of works with your uh but I think and I'm a big advocate for uh if we grab something like well we've talked about this yeah you've talked about that a few times already what do we got we've got a one of the biggest improvements in gaming history of the company let's talk about something like burn cycle here we have the floor plan book we have the rules reference book we have to learn to play book and the bathtub cards unless you're going to do something like Kingdom Death because of course Kingdom Death can do absolutely nothing wrong unless you're gonna do something like a luxury hardcover bound book full of beautiful artwork and the rules at the front and the reference guides at the back where this is what you want to have in your hand if you're doing soft cover if you're doing something like this that's going to be passed around and thrown around quite a lot and not be used for the entire duration of the game I don't want everything to be uh together in one I mean imagine if this was which some Publishers do this was one binding I'm just dreading thinking about that because learn to play guide gets me up and running rules reference is where I go after I already know the game but I need those specific Nuance details and the floor plan is my structure this is my setup this is the scenario by scenario yeah now for smaller rule books if you rule books within the 50 and under Pages range I'm okay with some things being being contained depending on the type of game it is but I I want to pay attention to what type of content is in the hands of my players yeah when my players are playing the game this is needed when you first start this is the needed when

you're figuring out the game after you've already figured it out I don't want those other components I don't want those other pages in my hand I don't have to sort through them this is so much easier to go through because it's designed for one specific thing it's designed to answer nuanced questions during game play yeah exactly and have that player yeah yeah I want I want I want that planet right thank you for watching thanks for being here let us know did we get it right did we get it wrong what are your thoughts around this conversation either way we uh are hoping to continue uh designing improving and uh working on Roblox yeah from uh from this time on uh and as always thanks for watching I don't think that's our catchphrase oh wait but I'll take it bye bye

Progress saved