Skip to main content
Loading video...

Jack & Eric's Top 10 Greatest Solo Board Games

Transcript 37:43

hey everyone sometimes us Gamers do not have the opportunity to hang out with friends like I'm doing right now with Eric who recently made his vocal debut on the channel yeah I think vocal yeah okay vocal debut on the channel uh with our Iliad and iore review which you can check that out um however I needed to talk to everyone about solo games because it had been a while since I'd had a chance to go over our top 10 list of solo games and I know that Eric is also a big solo gamer yeah all the time I love solo games it's kind of how I got into board gaming in the first place so for me solo games always have like a really big place in my life uh they still do to this day did you get into solo games when the pandemic was in full lockdown or had you already been kind of dipping your toes into the solo water uh definitely during the lockdown uh my first solo game that I played was Gloom Haven which uh was a lot to do in terms of upkeep as a firsttime solo board gamer but uh I still loved it I had a really great time and it made me want to do it more and then I looked for I think a lot lighter easier to access games it may have influenced your decisions from that point forward yeah I think it uh it scared me a little bit but I've definitely gotten back into heavier solo games and I have so many that I've play played and I agreed with you Jack that

now is a great time to share our top 10 solo games yeah so this is going to be our individual top 10s that may have some overlap and is representing the cardboard Herald's top 10 or more like 18 uh best solo experiences that we have uh right now because sometimes it's fun to talk about the things that we do alone together yeah so with that said my number 10 is a new game one that I have had such an energized time with and that is leviathan wild now the reason why this made it onto the list is because it overcomes one of the limitations I think of solo gaming which is where you play a big epic sort of dungeon crawly game and it doesn't feel like a full robust experience because you don't have have multiple people to run the multiple characters and have that synergistic time well this just says you know what we're going to have one class two characters combine it all into one deck that's one of the core mechanisms of how you build characters in the game and it preserves the experience of having to climb these enormous Titans or leviathans in this game but nonetheless you are managing one hand one pool of uh grip as it's described in the game and

it still feels like a a fluid uh experience that is is every bit as challenging and immersive as the full game my number 10 is set a watch it's not a new game but it's new to me uh I have only started playing it recently and I love it there's so much depth in terms of all the different characters you can play as there's so much math that you can go through and try and find the perfect line which takes the least amount of damage takes the least amount of resources and gets through the line as quickly as possible with as few risks as possible uh I think that I prefer playing this game solo which is one of the reasons I put it on my solo list I think being able to see all the options in front of you at once instead of having to kind of Juggle back and forth between two different or three different players is just the ideal way to play this game for me I nearly put this game on my list and in some ways I'm still struggling with the idea of not including it on my list but when you had it on your list I was like okay it's going to be represented I I can let it go because I do want to highlight some new games and in case you don't know all this like board game or anything top 10 on the the internet there's a bit of horse trading going on behind the scenes so I'm glad set of watch is getting its due it is such a great game do you have a favorite character yet I really like the Cavalier oh so good I I I love the uh Barbarian orc so

good yeah so my number nine is another new game uh that I had a chance to play and maybe it's a little bit of uh The Cult of the new or the hype train or whatever but I just had such a great time with the solo implementation that I wanted to put Stone spine Architects not Stone Spire Architects as I constantly want to call this game uh but uh Stone spine Architects on this list which is the follow-up game by the uh design and publisher combo that make cartographers which in itself is a great solo game uh but it's just such a nice Euro tile Lang dungeon buildy uh implementation that uh allows you to have essentially the same core experience of playing the uh multiplayer game but giving you enough opposition through an automated player that simulates the experience of having to play against someone but you're not having to perform everything for them which I've talked about endlessly is one of the things uh about solo games that I I really look for I don't want to have to fully manage an AI that is essentially me just playing two-handed against myself yeah I really love solo games that have kind of very little to no upkeep um which is one of the reasons why my number nine is micro macro Crime City it is that's a doozy of a name it

is it is awesome it's where as Waldo but with murder and you don't know what's happening I mean I've seen some of those where Waldo spreads they they definitely have some dubious things happening in them they do but this one you are playing as an investigator you get a GI map of a city and you draw a deck of cards and just says hey this person was murdered figure out what happened and you look through this map that is both the past and also the future and you follow along and try and solve the crimes present and it is so easy to set up all you do is you take a map out lay it down grab a random case and then go at it uh I love it for its Simplicity I love it for how quick it is to actually just get onto the table and get through a case pretty quickly uh I think the longest I've taken on a case is like 30 minutes so it's very easy for me to just if I have a little bit of time between things it it's very easy to break out uh which I really appreciate and I think that it is a super solid game the one limiting factor is you can only play it as many cases as there are they're not going to be able to put in new cases you get like 10 cases in the boxes but but at this point I think they have three different versions so all three are great you got a lot of content to work with yeah yeah I think for for the price it's a great game well my number eight

is a classic uh by terms of how fast the board game industry moves and that is wingspan it is still my favorite of the uh now famed otoma factories uh implementations of the multiplayer design design into a solo game a lot of people's first experience with uh solo gaming is via otoma Factory uh in seeing something uh being done with say Scythe or viticulture uh or tapestry but for me wingspan is still uh that beautiful engine building experience that is uh fairly minimalistic uh it's easy to dive into uh you're playing with all those great components uh but like I said with stonespine Architects you're not having to deal with the overhead of uh true opposition but there are smart things that are happening by the automated player that are giving you uh I guess prompts to play against and play around and in some ways opportunities that you wouldn't necessarily have in the multiplayer game uh but make for good puzzle uh decision making from birds to Bears my number eight is Cascadia ah Cascadia all right let's let's talk about Cascadia let's talk about Cascadia I enjoy it in terms of it being a super relaxing game which sometimes is

exactly what I need from a solo game I want to be able to sit down and just have a kind of peaceful time what's the difference between relaxing and boring that's you know I think that there's there are things to be said about both uh I I personally enjoy Cascade I can tell you do not uh I think that the solo mode is really neat uh you're basically just playing a two-player game uh but you have different goals or requirements you have to reach to consider uh a win consider having reached a win uh and that can be different kinds of animals reaching a certain point threshold uh and I know that that I don't actually usually Love solo games where the goal is just to score a higher score than the last time but I think it gives you just enough that you do have to really think about what you're doing um and I do enjoy the fact that you can kind of zone out for a little bit and come back to Cascadia and not much has changed you can pretty much Jump Right In and I know for some people that the fact that there isn't more mental load might mean that this this game is boring uh but I personally do enjoy it well my number seven is actually uh a game that's going to appear higher up on Eric's list so we're going to bypass the uh deliberation

until we get there uh so that way we can uh hash it out but uh what's your number seven my number seven is Sherlock Holmes Consulting detective in a similar way to micro macr Crime City I really enjoy solving crimes on my own uh I think that that's a niche that uh I realized when I was making this list I very much enjoy uh it's it's much smarter and it's much more indepth than micro macr Crime City you get like a whole bunch of random red herrings thrown in there I really am I think even in video games and in board games I'm an Explorer I like to go through every single detail that is presented to me and try and get as much out of it as possible and Sherlock Consulting detective is really great for that uh you just are rifling through this these two different booklets trying to solve what happened here and for me that's right up my alley in terms of what I want from a board game uh on a on just a cozy night yeah I I have always kind of viewed the sort of puzzle tail type games which I like quite a bit and have covered a considerable amount on the channel as more like social experiences uh you know like those are things I really like doing with my wife or like as a couple's night that kind of thing nonetheless uh they are fully completable as a solo game and uh that's really cool that that's something that

you've kind of gravitated to it's almost like reading a novel or something I think I prefer playing it solo just because of how many small details there are passing the booklet back and forth between multiple players would be the only way to play it Co-op and it just I feel like detracts from the experience of me just really hammering in with like a nice drink just this is my evening I'm going to solve this case by the end of the night spoken like someone who believes he's the smartest person in the room and doesn't want to have to deal with the inferior intellect my number six is yet another new game and I think part of this was I just wanted to highlight so many new great games coming out with uh brilliant uh solo implementation that would be worthwhile considering whether you're going to be playing multiplayer or you're picking up games just for solo and that is the White Castle which if you've been following this channel you know that I said the White Castle was my favorite game of last year and I stand by that I think it's an incredible game I think it is just a a beautiful balance of minimalistic design with only nine turns like you're taking across three rounds in a worker place game but everything that you do has so much important consequence and one of the problems or challenges of the game is that because everything has so much weight to it it's very easy to fall into

an analysis paralysis trap which you don't have to worry about other people being frustrated about you taking so long or you having to wait for someone else to take so long when you're playing a solo game and again this is uh simple card driven system that simulates some of the experience of playing against a good player like the board state is going to evolve in ways that represent the same sort of Evolutions that would happen in a multiplayer game but nonetheless it's a very minimalistic overhead and you are still having that that full robust puzzle uh and it it it's just absolute fire in fact I handed this off to Eric just the other day I was like you need to take this home you need to bask in its Glory my number six is a very minimalistic card game we were going to go from an actual board game to a card game that you can play with just one deck and a Joker um it's from the is saludo collection which I found on Reddit during the summer of 2021 where we were still kind of handling lock Downs in Los Angeles which is where I was living so I still had a ton of time indoors the game I have from the saludo collection is loot the loop uh it's a insane in crazy just wild card game uh

you're the the theme of the game is you're playing as a temple Raider going through a deck of cards and trying to get the gems out which are the Aces and you're trying to avoid the traps which are the face cards and there's a ton here with very simple rules I think that the depth of it is kind of one of the things that I enjoy just in terms of navigating through a deck of cards that slowly is becoming more and more trap filled and just trying to get out with all the gyms is really fun it's a really core cool core gameplay Loop and I think that the minimalism of it where I just need a deck of cards and I can play a game that is very simple all you need to do is just remove one of the Jokers Shuffle the deck and you are ready to go um I really enjoy the fact that I can kind of bring it wherever I am like if I'm just waiting for friends at a bar and have a deck of cards for various reasons as one as one does just carry it in your pocket in my pocket my deck of cards uh I can play a really satisfying game that doesn't take that long it can definitely be played multiple times in a row my number five is surprise surprise yet another new game but it's kind of a standin for a concept uh this is earthborne Rangers it is that kind of investigative uh semi Comba but you know not really uh expansive story driven game where you can Level Up characters

you can um discover key uh moments and items but what earthborne Rangers brings to the fold is uh one uh the characters uh are reliant on the synergies between them that is a cool aspect but I feel completely good about uh one handing it whereas say Arkham Horror lcg which uh has a lot of design inspiration to earthborne Rangers you really get the most out of the game in seeing different investigators make up for their weaknesses uh the other thing is is that it has this very Innovative open world system that you can uh effectively stop a session at any time that may bear consequences but you can camp out and uh save uh so it feels if anything more like an old school jrpg that I was playing as a kid uh and there's a sprawling world there's emergent story moments that happen in a very smart system the way the decks uh just Shuffle together to create the different terrain types and the different possibilities and uh the key wordss that intersect impacting the world is just it's brilliant it's a sweeping game it's uh very polished it's interesting uh and it's very strategic uh in spite of the Ambitions making it sound like how how uh challenging and real really

mechanical could that be from my six to five I'm going from a very simple minimalistic card game to a very convoluted upkeep heavy card game which is Imperium Legends and Classics I have a lot of mixed feelings about this game when it comes to the co-op version which is I don't ever want to teach this game it it does have a little bit of insanity to it like it there's a lot going on it's it's maybe far too much going on for Co-Op one of my worst fears is teaching somebody this it's one of my greatest fears but as a solo game I really enjoy it I think there's a lot of depth there I mean you have so many different factions to play with and really try to hone in on uh I really love the Chin Dynasty so that's a deck that I play a lot and it's not just the Decks that you play you also choose different factions to go against and there's tables to tell you how they operate that make them mimic how a normal player would play them but in a way that still feels like you're not just substituting in a normal player player like there is a strategy that you can go into it with of I know that this faction is always going to get rid of this land that I want so I have to do something about it now and I kind of like the fact that there is a bit of predictability in what the uh other faction is going to do and and the the

the different uh factions what I found Most Fascinating about a game that ultimately I just found wasn't for me uh but like it it's not just your strategy for getting to the same point I mean I I guess it is in the sense that you're getting to the point of winning uh but like fundamentally uh the asymmetry feels like the entire Vibe of different factions like what they construct how they interact uh how they get points feels like you you are having very different concepts at work there yeah I really enjoy the fact that the asymmetry feels like this is how the game has to be and I actually met you because you were getting rid of this game because you definitely did not like it as much as I do that's true that's true and yeah I think that I noticed Robinson Caruso isn't on your list though yeah Robinson Caruso did not make my list my number four is a game that's not typically a solo game or at least out of box it's not a solo game and so I feel kind of dirty putting it on the list uh but it's that good uh and that is undaunted which there was the original undaunted release in Normandy and then shortly after you had North Africa and reinforcements which reinforcements not only gave you more toys to play with in

either of those two releases but came out with uh like a an official adaptation of the brilliant solo design that uh happened by uh professional designers uh but on the BGG forums as just like fan implementations of uh solo driven uh work that is scripted to each individual campaign of uh undaunted Normandy uh North Africa and reinforcements like every scenario has uh a a unique pool of the cards that you're going to have for the uh solo uh functioning OTA and you have the complete compliment uh covered in this whether you want to play as the Allies or you want to play as the Nazis I mean that feels weird feels weird want to play as the Nazis uh but nonetheless whether you want to play as the good guys or the bad guys um you have the ability to automate the opposing faction um it is a little bit bananas in how expansive it is it is one of those things where you're you're dedicating a full gaming night to this if you're playing it solo it's one of those types of games that I wouldn't expect to function really well as a solo game and yet it does so we're getting to the part of my list that uh has start starts including more print andplay games uh I

kind of got into solo gaming through print and play games cuz after BL Haven I started looking for the the least amount of components that I could very easily acquire and just get gaming uh so post-traumatic GL Haven syndrome tgd uh I have under Falling Skies as my number four it is sci-fi themed which is my favorite theme in board games I love science fiction I always have so when I saw this game I was really stoked to play it and it is smart it is really really the decisions matter so much in what you do and it just feels very right like all of the rules make sense it's a very clear oh well because I did this clearly this thing is going to happen and that's exactly how the rules work and it it's a game that just makes sense and it's solo only which I think maybe bumped it up my list a little bit in that this is how this game was meant to be I think that there's so much depth here cuz there's a whole campaign you can play I nearly put Nemos war on this list as a representative of the like solo first design philosophy uh and I've played a few games at this point where uh even if they have multiplayer versions uh as part of a retail list to make it more appealing to the masses uh

or at least to the Publishers um where that it was very clear that the design itself uh was um to be a solo game and there is something to be said about something that kind of adopts the mindset that one person is going to be examining all this yeah and I just think that underf Falling Skies is it it definitely has a bit of nostalgia for me like when I don't have somebody to play and I really need to scratch a board game Edge underf Falling Skies is really simple just get out done I have it laminated I still am playing the print andplay version yeah uh and it's great yeah and then you're in a better mood for the rest of the day my number three is uh well you know like I I had to have some C worldly uh representation on here so I went with Pack's Premiere second edition which I think is the best solo uh implementation of any of Kohl's games is so fluid and smart and interesting it doesn't necessarily feel like you're playing against a a big robust set of players uh because the politic is so much of most of Cole's games but nonetheless the new puzzle that is presented through the won I hope I'm pronouncing that uh deck is so brilliant and conniving and and presents uh some really fascinating gambits that you can

do that you actually have personal Stakes you are you are like dedicated to taking down this deck of cards uh and seeing how uh you can uh really exploit the systems uh that are so rich in that game in the first place yeah I mean I think that I'm very glad Cole World got it represented here because I think he is one of both of our more played designers I think we both played a lot of his games uh and arcs is awesome I can't wait to see what solo mode either the Community comes up with or comes up with I just I would love to play Arc solo my sci-fi love is definitely interest is peaked could not be more peaked my top three uh was actually your number seven and it stays in the Sci-Fi realm for me which is terraforming Mars Aries Expedition uh so good it is such an awesome game both multiplayer and solo and and I feel like the solo really does pretty well to represent playing other players without having them there and it is fluid your turns are really quick and I think that what I like most about the solo version of terraforming Mars Aries Expedition is just how fluid the game feels like from one turn to the next it you're your brain doesn't have to lose its train of thought right uh the entire time you are I be focused and on

without having to really do too much upkeep AR's Expedition just has a constant dopamine hit of turn after turn after turn whether you're playing the multiplayer game or not um what I really like about the solo game is that it gives you uh a uh a reliable set of other players uh activation you know that they're going to run through five cards and it's in a random order and you can bounce off of that strategically in interesting ways kind of accounting for well I know they've already gone through their you know like uh their red and blue action their green action so I I knew I'm going to get a production here in the next three um and you can minimize the instances in which uh you are having kind of a dud turn because you both picked to the same thing yeah and I think that there's a depth that you don't get in the multiplayer game which elevates it to such a high spot for me my number two um I uh think that uh I'm still having some remorse on putting this so high but I couldn't think of something else uh that I wanted higher than this and I can't believe it uh because it's one of those games where it's like yo just get as many points as you can uh but I've ref fallen in love with Agricola uh in the last three four years uh having

played it way back in the day when it was such a Monumental and impactful release and everyone adored agrica and then everyone kind of moved on from it the solo game of agrica especially in the revised Edition where there's a campaign which sounds ridiculous to have a campaign for your little like farming game but nonetheless uh having the ability to carry over one of of the uh the jobs that you have the professions into the next session but then the point threshold uh in which to win gets all that much higher uh it means that you're having to exploit things in uh that much more micromanage of a way each time uh it plays really fast uh it looks great at the table and it's it's allowed me to refall in love with a game that was already uh really impactful and while we've had a lot of socalled evolution in worker placement from then going through this has allowed me to kind of reassess that yeah it's still just one of the best and it's I mean it's it's a great game I think there you should not be ashamed at having it that high so much shame so much shame but it just it is such an awesome game and I yeah no no shame with having it that high uh my number two is also a worker placement but it's a little bit of a

different style uh my number two is mck which I think is how it's pronounced uh it's French and I'm only on two years of French dualingo so I don't know how anything's pronounced uh it is a worker placement where you are trying to take down the Nazis by subversion uh this game has a ton of different campaigns to do the community is constantly putting forward new scenarios that you can play and it is just awesome it works so well you're trying to put your people in places that get you all of the things that you need cuz you need these bombs in the next three turns or else you have lost you got to balance that with it one bad role of where the Nazis end up and you have lost that person forever they are gone and you are down a worker for the rest of the game and it is such a good solo game it's one of those games where it is designed to be solo uh it's a print and play which again is how I learned to love it in the first place is it was really simple for me to just find it one day and then play it immediately I think the uh the dopamine hit of seeing something and then immediately wanting it and then being able to have it immediately is something that we kind of don't get in Juna right right yeah uh and I think that it is yeah it's just great it's one of the

best solo games I think I've played and I think the fact that there's such a dedicated community that has put out additional scenarios past what the developer originally made shows how much love there is for this game yeah the it really capitalizes on desperation and opportunity cost right you know like it's one of those games where you feel like there's no good circumstance other than maybe a hairs breath of a win at the end uh and it feels like every action that you're taking in the limited confines of the game is maybe not a total risk but you know that it is prohibiting you from also acting upon something else yeah and I think that it has a ton of great opening scenarios to teach a game so it's very easy to get into but then it has so much after those first few that I think really shows how good of a game it is which brings us to our number one which uh we built these lists independently and nonetheless uh it appears that our number one uh was unanimous so you want to tell the good people what our number one is our number one and I I knew it was going to be this as soon as we talked about this video is Spirit Island I mean how could it be anything island is just I think in My Mind by aze B margin the best solo game there is it

has so much to explore for a player like me but it's also very analytical that's kind of one of the things that I think solo allows us to do in a way that multiplayer games don't always because you know when you're playing a multiplayer game often you are either trying to do the the best that you can to overcome an opponent or you're trying to do the best you can so you don't disappoint uh you know your Cooperative partner whereas in a Solo game yes you are trying to win but there's less I guess meta considerations uh that would prohibit you from just going you know I wonder what would happen if I did this I personally like playing single board uh with one single spirit and I do love the game as a as a study on relationships between wildly asymmetric Powers MH but uh just having one single board and going like what can this Spirit ring out of their powers on their own without thinking about someone else being able to make up for it uh and sometimes that's wildly successful and sometimes it's disastrous uh but nonetheless it is always really interesting you feel satisfied in both that exploratory half of solo gaming and also the challenge side of uh gaming and general yeah and I

love playing Spirit Island as two Spirits two boards and seeing how they interact and I think that that's equally as valid totally totally I think that I maybe don't get as deep into one Spirit but I think that learning the different powers and how they balance off each other is part of what makes me have this so high on my list is what does what does hungry ocean and uh butterfly that changes Dimensions look like together how do they work is that good does that work well I love that that is that is for me what I find most impressive about Spirit island is how interesting those interactions are yeah totally and uh while I commented with Leviathan Wilds that I I love games where it kind of uh overcomes the need to twoand something and uh in spirit Island you don't really have the ability to do that but there is something about Spirit Island where uh because even in a multiplayer game players play their cards but then there's no turn order you just go like well what do you want to do I don't know what do you want to do and you can interact in any way that you want having two Spirits does separate your ability to utilize their board space but it still feels feel like you're operating one hand you know like you you have a bisected set of uh tools uh but uh you're still thinking about

them in concert with one another which is again uh such an amazing achievement in that game in general how how could it be anything else all of these games that we've listed here um with only two overlap uh but definitely there's a lot of games that uh could have gone onto any of these lists but uh Spirit Island uh was immediately a lock for both of us yeah well thank you so much for watching uh and uh as we mentioned in the Iliad and iore uh video Eric's going to be on the channel more uh let us know what you think of these games and uh also um what you want to see as far as uh some of these lists some additional content out there uh and maybe Eric uh being probably the more dedicated uh solo gamer out of the two of us can do some uh more focused solo content and reviews uh put it in the comments and uh thanks for watching thanks for watching thanks for joining us thanks for joining me here of course

Progress saved