Top 10 (non-Rosenberg) Farming Board Games (part 3 Rosenblog March 2024)
Transcript
go into the top 10 non- Rosenberg farming games so when you mention U Rosenberg many people will think Farming Simulator from his earliest board game hits such as Bonanza and Agricola to his latest designs of holler toow and adwa there seems to be an element of farming or agriculture to most of his games from raising crops and caring for animals to managing a homestead or a ranch these farming games played a big role in hooking me to not only his games but into the board game Hobby in general and they are a nostalgic part of me as well especially reminding me of the video games that I played a lot in my youth such as harvest moon and so there's an element of coziness to the farming theme that I really enjoy every time I play to these games having nice bluegrass music in the background with you know just a like the feeling you're sitting on your porch overlooking a prairie or your Farmstead you know it it just it does something right for me that makes me want to come back and and be in this environment when it comes to board games now Rosenberg isn't the only person obviously who has designed a farming game so this list is going to be the top 10 farming games rated by players over time on Board Game Geek filtering out any of the Rosenberg games along the way and there were quite a lot Board Game Geek defines a farming game as quote games that encourage players to build and manage farmland for the purposes of growing crops and or attending to livestock often to be sold or traded later on and so as I go
through this list I'll react to each of these games in you know descending order from 10 to 1 with my thoughts on them if I played them or what people have to say about them if I have not played the game yet of not there are 1,250 games at the time of recording with the categorization of farming according to Bor and geek the highest ranked game with farming in this entire list is rosenberg's a feast for Odin by the way uh which I consider to be less of a farming game and more of well a thematic Viking game I suppose but I I do see the tie-ins with farming and and crops and Agriculture and things like that so anyway another note is as I was making this list there were highly rated games that had a small or insignificant amount of farming to it in my opinion so I decided to skip them and place them on an honorable mention type of list and so I won't go into these with any detail but anyway these games include Zulan Village above and below Goa Santa Maria madaa Boon Lake aizia caca Cuba and meres uh once again skipping Rosenberg games and any repeats from his games as well as any of these other games that I've mentioned or different versions of them as well so let me know if you think I should have included these games in a top 10 farming game list I have played some of these games and some of that is based off my opinion as well as a quick overview of what the game is trying to accomplish a lot of these games in in my opinion are more trading and economic
based rather than focusing in on the actual farming or agriculture depicted in the game you know there there are resources that are featured that include wheat and things like that but I I felt like they did not Define the farming genres or category as well as I think some of these other games did and so if you disagree with me just let me know so number 10 for me is going to be beer and bread this is ranked 808 overall and this is a Scott alms game released in 2022 and this was one of my personal favorites from that year in this two-player only game you manage your side of uh an opposing Village brewing beer and making bread using multi-use card play to do so I like the resource management the card play and the quickness of this game and I think it represents the farming theme well by especially with the alternating years and rounds between good and not so good years of harvest altering the way that you draft cards to your hand as as well so this is a very fun game and I think it represents farming well number nine is Three Sisters this is a game designed in 2022 by Ben pinchback and Matt riddle overall ranked at 743 and this is a roll and right game where you roll the dice and cross out areas on your sheet mainly focus on growing the trio of pumpkin corn and beans and buy advancing on other tracks to help you do so and gain points in different ways it's a medium weight thinky Rolland right that I have had fun trying out a few years ago and I've reviewed it on the podcast but it's one
that I haven't returned to since I think the element of resource management is here as it is in some of my favorite role and rights and it does help the farming theme come through and I think if I were to try it again and pull it out I would enjoy the chance that I had to do so number eight is Venus this game is ranked 611 and is a Lera game from 2010 I've played this game only once and there's a huge comparison to another game that's coming up later on this list that you probably know about but I thought this game was really fun and it's a heavy cultivation simulator type of game where you're growing grapes in different areas of Portugal and using the wine that you make from these grapes in different ways utilizing an interesting gridlike action selection mechanism so it's not my favorite lasera but it's one that I would definitely return to and that farming theme cultivation theme right definitely helps number seven is takenoko this game is ranked 381 overall and it is designed by Antoine Baza back in 2011 in this game you are collectively controlling a farmer and a panda on a tile modular board growing bamboo and eating it respectively uh all while trying to fulfill contracts and score points it's a lightweight family game that has some Randomness to it with dice rolls which makes it fun and inclusive to those who aren't you know very competitive Gamers or deeper into the Hobby and as there are other family weight games that I would go to first
when comparing it to takenoko maybe I think that's due to the randomness of the game but visually on the table it's a really goodlooking game it's one of the first games that I've ever played actually in The Wider board game space and so it still retains a fond memory for me it's not one that I return to often enough but I've had good success teaching the to non- Gamers and having a good time with them number six is heaven and Ale this game is ranked 342 overall and is a Michael keyling game from 2017 I haven't played this one but I think it is an interesting Rondell game where the timing of Brewing bear makes the difference according to the description of the game the overall mechanisms I'm not 100% familiar with but if the description is anywhere near accurate to the game play I think simulating the the timing aspect of brewing beer and making sure that it has had enough time to ferment and Etc is what I think represents thematically the the game well and perhaps mechanically it makes this game interesting so you know the jury is still out to see if this game in my opinion reflects the agricultural world as a whole uh but it does seem like to be a well-received mechanical game anyway and so I'm excited to try this one at some point number five is L granha this is a 2014 game from OD and Keller that is ranked red 239 overall and is one of my favorite non Rosenberg games Farm Tableau management mediated by
individualized multi-use cards and contract fulfillment makes this game very fun every time that I've played it and I've played it on board game arena as well which is available for free I've reviewed eluru the sequel to this game as well as the kickstarter version of L granha A few years back and so you can go and check out my thoughts there but there's a good following for this game I feel and love for the the over design which is another Testament of how great this game is probably out of all the games here it most closely on this list it closely resembles my favorite Rosenberg game of all time agria especially with the ident identity-driven cards that this game boasts number four is Glenmore 2 Chronicles this game was released in 2019 as and it is a sequel to Glen Moore designed by Matias Kramer ranked 169 overall and I've played the original Glenmore once on yucata.de another online version of ways to play the game and so I get the gist of this game where you're using Rondell uh and advancing as far as you would like to build out your tblo with tiles adding farming type resources like wheat and cattle and then using those to trade for goods and points and you know rinse and repeat the rondel I think makes this game feel unique and especially at the time of the original game which was way back way way back when and the sequel adds a campaign element introducing new mechanisms to the game I think there are seven or eight different modules that you can add
on to the game from this sequel so this is one that I need to try out for sure in its complete hole and especially if it ranks so high as a sequel game I think there is a lot of good gameplay here number three is clans of calonia this is a Juma alju game from 2017 that is ranked 64 overall and gameplay wise it resembles teram mytica and Gaia project the most I prefer Clans over those other games because of the interesting Market where prices rise and fall dynamically based off who sells or buys certain resources and the farming aspect of plac in resources like cattle sheep and wheat and upgraded resources from those like cheese and bread onto a shared board and turning them in for contracts or other ways to do well in this game this is definitely a deep game with resource management and tight interactive board play that that I really find enjoyable and as a whole in in the hobby people do enjoy it obviously because of its overall ranking and its similarity to very popular games in Gaia project and teram mysticum uh it does have a new expansion coming soon so that'll add some new mechanisms of play that I can't wait to try out at some point number two is Puerto Rico this game is ranked 44 overall and was once the number one game on Board Game Geek created in 2022 by Andreas Saar despite the controversial theme the gameplay is fun enough with a farming theme included in the plantation that you were managing and the mechanism of the leader or the
governor uh of the table you know choosing a action while everyone gets to play out a minor version of that action which I think was you know original at the time and really popularized further by games like Ray for the Galaxy and others afterward I think I prefer the quick card play of race to the G for the Galaxy more than Puerto Rico and something about the the overall strategic and very competitive aspect of Puerto Rico where if you do not play correctly you really mess up the Mojo of the other competitive players and so it's not beginner friendly which you know has paradoxically has turned me off of this game as agria is not a very beginner friendly game either but I do appreciate the fact that this game is getting new versions of it very recently in the past couple of years uh alternate versions of the base game as well as reiterations of Puerto Rico as well have been coming out recently another one is slated to come out either this year or next and so it deserves a a lot of love for the gameplay itself and it deserves a look from you if you haven't played it the number one ranked game behind A Feast for Odin of course in the farming category is viticulture the number one on this list anyway is VI culture so this is ranked 38 this is a Jamie STM game from 20 2013 originally but the essential edition the second edition essentially is was released back in 2015 including key expansions from previous
expansions into the essential version as well as adding the in my opinion adding the experience of bigger expansions like Tuscany and so this is a work replacement card driven cultivation game similar to Venus where you are cultivating grapes and making wine and delivering that wine via order contracts Etc I have said my piece about this game before I really do enjoy it as it approximates Agricola as well as you know how I feel lrha approximates agrica with the card play and the agricultural theme there is more of a random feel to the card play rather than the deterministic play style of Agricola in my opinion and this however in a positive note creates for play lines and routes to victory that feel different every time you play viticulture you don't have to go down the crate wine and deliver and fulfill contracts route to winning this game you can play based off of the cards or other different ways on your Tableau to score points and so I I really appreciate the fact and it's a testament to why this game is so highly ranked and is beloved by many so there you have it th those are the top 10 farming games that are not Rosenberg made and my reactions to them once again if you disagree with the the ones that I left out on this list just let me know or let me let me know if one of these games are your favorite and why you enjoy it as well in the comments below but that will do it and that is a wrap for the Ros and blog for March 2024 thank you for Consulting with me and
hope that you schedule an appointment with your board gaming doctor real soon take care