Skip to main content
Loading video...

Top 10 Hand Management Games - Chairman of the Board

Transcript 22:29

hi everyone today i'm going to be talking through my top 10 hand management games so these are generally card games or board games that use cards in them where you are trying to play through your cards as efficiently as you can by getting the most mileage out of them getting the most points out of them knowing when to discard things knowing when to you know sacrifice things for others knowing the order in which to play things and things like that i really like this mechanism on and kind of the way that it pulls you in different directions and you have to think about how you are going to play these cards to the maximum efficiency and maximum benefit so let's get started at number 10. so at number 10 i have the bloody inn so first off this is quite a strange game in terms of the theme personally i really like it where you are an innkeeper and you have constantly having patrons come into your into your hotel or motel i guess and you are essentially trying to kill them in order to rob them of their money but in order to do so you're going to have to kind of entice other people into helping you with your diabolical plan such as getting the gunman in order to kill them for you or getting people to build annexes or getting people to bury them for you and so on so it's it's quite a stranger macabre theme but the way that the car play in this game works is quite interesting because if you don't want to actually kill these residents i'm coming to your hotel then you are going to kind of bribe them in order to work for you

and by doing that you have to uh discard a certain amount of cards to do so and one of the kind of strengths of these cards is in order to make that cheaper one of them is to make it cheaper for you in order to actually kill the guests one of them is to make it cheaper in order for you to bury the guests i want to it makes it cheap in order to build these annexes which you need to bury the guests under and all these cards have different abilities and you essentially want them all and get this engine going where you can constantly do things for cheaper and cheaper but the problem is that if you don't bury people by certain points in the game when these cops show up then you're going to end up losing a lot of points and getting in trouble but additionally if you even if you have a successful turn you have a bunch of cards in your hand you need to pay every worker you've got working for you and that could be really expensive and it's just about knowing when to discard things in order to do certain actions knowing which cards to keep hold of and it really is quite a mind-bending puzzle to get your head around but it works pretty well once you get ahead around it it's not it's not the easiest game to explain to somebody i think but again once you once you know how it works and you know the systems it's a really good hand management game with a quite unique and strange theme that's well implemented so the number 10 we've got the bloody inn at number nine i have hana makoji which is a strictly two-player game and this is a tug-of-war style game where you're trying to win the favor of these geishas or what different points and you are trying to win their favor by having the most cars of a certain type corresponding to the geisha girl which

is going to give you these charm points and if you get a certain amount of charm points you're gonna be the winner but the way you take your actions is interesting because you have a hand of cards um i think you start with six or or even seven by drawing one in the first turn and you are taking one of four actions and those actions are gonna be things such as putting two pairs of these two cards two two cut two pairs of two cards down and your opponent is going to choose first and put them on their side and you're going to get the remaining cards on your side there's the same a similar mechanism where you're putting three cards down your opponent picks one you get the other two and other ones you can kind of choose to save a card backwards or delete two cards out of the game and knowing the order in which to play these actions is so so important not only because of the actions themselves but because the the actions that take four cards for example is just going to mean that you have fewer cards going forward in the game because regardless of how many cards you play from turn to turn you're only going to be drawing one card back into your hand meaning that your options are squeezed and squeezed and squeezed and this really is a game about knowing um knowing how to because the margins are so small and the the minutiae and nuance in this game in order to win it is so so important that you can't just do anything frivolously you can't just throw a caution to the wind and hope that it works out in your favor because actually it absolutely won't if you if you are playing against somebody who knows what they're doing and it's all about knowing which cards to keep hold of knowing which ones to let go of and so on and even knowing which ones to get out of the game

for example if you've if you've got one of these um say a guitar cards which there's only three of them in the game if you've already played one of them and you've got the other two in your hand then you know to get rid of the other two because you know your opponent can't beat you for example but this really is a game you need to try out for yourself it's a it's such a compelling and engaging game that uses a bit of kind of the poker face but it's all about how you play the cards and the order in which to do and keeping your cool and hoping your opponents don't pick the ones you don't want them to pick at number eight i have red seven now red seven i think is a bit of a funny game that i think it does something really well um but at the same time it's not the for a filler game it's probably not the most enticing for the games because of the way it plays so it really is a game of attrition so at the gate at every turn you were either going to play one or two cars and these cars have a number of different suits in represented by their colours the red being the most powerful and also in different numbers i think they go from one to seven so hence why the red seven is the most is the strongest card in the game um and you are basically either changing the rule of the game or you are placing a card down in order to be the winner by the end of each turn because if you are not winning the game or winning the round by the end of your time that you are eliminated from the from the game completely and these these cards are the rules you've put down as things such as you know who's got the highest card uh who's got the most of a certain number who's got the most consecutive numbers but the the way their mat the management

of the cards go is as i said it's it's very much a game of attrition where you want to stretch the card you have as far as you can hoping to draw cards when you can in order to outlast your opponents and it can be really um it can be quite stressful and quite straining in order to work out how you are going to play these cards in this order and not only by what's in your hand but by reacting to what your opponent's doing as well and often the margins are quite small in terms of just lasting one extra term in your opponent but you've and if you've done it just right you think yeah i did that i worked that out perfectly uh interesting game very unique and one that i definitely recommend checking out um designed by uh carl chadwick so at number seven i have battle line which is one of my kind of classic favorite games another strictly two-player game uh this one designed by reina kenitzia this one is essentially a game of poker played out over nine different hands but these these hands are only played over with three cards and the idea is you're trying to give the best formation of these warriors in order to win the flag and if you win i think it's five flags until two or three adjacent flags you're going to be the winner but at any one time you've only got seven cards in your hand and knowing how to play these cards um to to the maximum efficiency is quite puzzling because you want to be optimistic in order to try get the absolute best hands possible in order to definitely win the flags but in order to do so you're often backing yourself into a bit of a corner um meaning that you you are dependent on

drawing particular cards in order to complete those hands or you can kind of go for a bit more of a a relaxed feel and try to get decent hands but maybe not the best hands amongst several cards but a bit like um a bit like hanumakoji this one does have a bit of an attrition feel to it because the more cards are played you're limited your your options are getting limited and squeezed meaning that your options are getting becoming fewer and fewer and often you are ended up you know when you've built something quite carefully you'll end up just ruining it because you've got nowhere else to play this card and just knowing when to hold on cards for as long as you can in order to maybe make your opponents waste cards is so important and i i love that hand management feel in this game and you know not not to show your cards too early when you're confident winning a flag but at the same time not clogging up your hand with cars that don't need to be there a fantastic game very timeless in my opinion and uh just holds up so so well that is a battle line by reiner kenicia at number six i probably have one of the heavier games on this list this is mombasa so mombasa is this this pretty large area control game with stock markets and shares but this being a hand management list i want to talk about that part of the game so the the actions are played out using these cards of all these different fruits and all all these kind of explore cards but the way you you play these cards is interesting because you are playing them in different slots on your player board um and that when you play these three

different slots at least to start with you can you can potentially unlock more slots you are not only getting these actions on them which you can kind of pull together to get more powerful benefits but at the end of the turn those cards you've played are all slid up to the top of the board in their own separate discard piles and then you're going to take one of those discards back into your hand ready to play for the next round and that is such a strange mechanism and such an awesome and innovative mechanism because in order to play your best hands you're going to have to play them all together which means that you're diluting them down to further in you know into rounds going forward and i absolutely love that twist you know knowing when to um when to take certain hands back knowing when to put them all together but ultimately separate them out from each other meaning you can't play them all together at least immediately is absolutely fascinating and that's pretty much the crux of why this is high uh all my kind of hand management games because it just does what it does so so well and those kind of polarizing forces you know you want to have a great turn but in order to have a great turn you're probably not going to have a great turn next turn and that's just works fantastically and just a great mechanism that used by alexander fister next up i have rococo at number five so rococo is a game designed by matthias kramer and essentially it's an area control game with some pretty simple actions and the idea is you're trying to dress these noblemen and noble women up

in these fine garments to go to a ball are you buying different buying different ornamentations and fireworks for this grand ball and so on but the hand management side of things is so interesting because you have a handful of action cards and from rounds around i think you're playing three of these cards and these three these cards are they have three different kind of categories so you've got your journeyman you've got your apprentices and you've got your masters represented by kind of bronze silver and gold banners on them and only certain actions can be taken by certain ranks of these um of these cards so for the basic actions such as gathering resources can be taken by your by your bronze workers or bronze cards and yeah only certain real powerful actions such as drawing new cards or bringing new cards into your hand can be taken by those mastercards and additionally you get other bonuses by using those mastercards but the the fact that some of these actions have um have oh so cards have actions on them themselves which you can kind of use to follow up your main action is important but it's all about knowing how to how to space them out and knowing what you're going to do from time to turn um and just playing them in the in the right order is just brilliant and it just works so so well for a relatively simple game in terms of its mechanisms i said just a just a pretty straightforward area control game but that extra wrinkle about managing your hand is so so important and there are additional actions you can use as well to kind of thin out your hand it will stand out the cards you're using in order to get

points and obviously make it better to not having to cycle through your whole deck in order to draw them back again so yeah i love the way the cards are used in this game just a pretty simple use of them but it just works well with those different tiered systems and next up at number four i have another alexander fister game with maracaibo so maracaibo a bit like mombasa this one is an involved game with lots and lots going on in it but the the main kind of driving force in this game is the card system and these cards are really interesting because they they have your normal things such as having a cost in order to buy them but they have um multiple uses you've got things such as quest items or you've actually got abilities of the cars themselves you can use and often to play cards you need to sacrifice other cards again you've got a hand limit so you can't carry loads of cards through from from round to round you can choose to allocate cards to certain spots to reserve them to build later but once you do that you can't take them back and use them for their other benefits and it's one of those cars about knowing what when to sacrifice one thing for another because you might have a really powerful card that you you want that benefit for but right now you don't have the the kind of the funds to pay for it but there's a juicy quest coming up and you you've just sailed your boat there and you have the item to use on that card and you think you know what let's just get rid of that item which is gonna lose me that cool power but um it's gonna help me get points in other ways and i love multiple used cars and i think fister is probably the best guy

at doing it and yeah maracaibo is probably the prime example of that the fact that it has i said i think it's three different criteria on each card one for quests one for um missions i think and one for um sorry once one for the towns where you can trade in things for other things and one for the ability themselves and those abilities are also super cool so yeah all about the cards in this one and um and just managing those cards is just a huge part of this huge game now at number three i have the king is dead now this is a pretty cut-throat area control game set you know on this map of um all this map of britain and you are basically trying to win majorities or at least trying to kind of invest in the different nation you've got your three nations you've got your whales welsh yeah english and you're scottish and you're trying to invest in these uh in these nations by taking cubes of them and hoping they win battles because whoever's won the most battles who you have the most cubes of at the end of the game is is going to be the winner but the the fact that the hand management in this game is so good is because of the fact that you only start with eight cards and these eight cards are at least in the core game you are identical to each other player and the game is going to play out over eight different rounds although i think at eight different regions all reserved all kind of resolved in a certain order but these cars that you have at the start of your start of your um at the game are all you've got for the entire game you're

never going to draw these cars back once you've played then you've played them you can end up using them all in the first half of the game having nothing in the second half of the game or you could do you know vice versa in terms of kind of really um you know weathering the storm until the second half of the game and start to use those cars to your advantage but the the fact that you really want to use these cards to the maximum of efficiency is just an absolutely painful decision because your people are doing things which you know you're not going to benefit from but you end up reacting to them and spending another card and then you're quickly running out of options you keep reacting to other people just not knowing when to uh knowing when to give up and let someone have have a small win in order to win the war and not the battle and i just love that pacing of this game where you do have to be really patient and know when is the time to use that card and not only for its ability which can be things such as adding cubes of a certain color onto the board or moving cubes around or moving even moving the locations around in order to change the order they're resolved but when you play them you're also taking a cube off the board in order to add to your investment in those in those nations so you know if you want to play those cards early and completely stock up on a different nation then other players are going to naturally move against that and make sure you don't win but you can't just let other people run away with things as well so sl it's all about the pacing in this game and knowing when and where to play those cards because they are such a scarce resource in this game and every move and every card is pivotal to winning this game with a very small

margin ferrera and that's why the king is dead is at number three at number two i have concordia by matt gertz and this is one of my favorite euro games because it is such a pure and clean game as you are collecting resources and buying new cards to get end game points but the the cards are interesting in so many ways because number one is that the cards themselves not only have action abilities on them which you're going to use to either move around the map or collect resources or buy new cards for example but each card is assigned to a certain scoring criteria on them meaning that for example if i i might get a point for every uh region i'm in for every saturn card i've got and obviously i'm trying to collect saturn cars if i've spread the map that way but at the same time those satin cards abilities might not be so great so it's not only weighing up the abilities themselves but also the scoring or the way they're going to score points at the end of the game but in addition to that you are actually rewarded by playing through as many cards as you can and you are when you when you collect these cards you can really map out your turns quite carefully and dictate the order you're going to pay them in order to have these or string up several actions in a row and i think that level of strategy is absolutely fantastic so for example you might say i'm going to collect some money with this card and then i'm gonna buy uh buy and sell some goods with this card using the money i've got and then i'm going to travel and then i'm gonna build a couple of warehouses and so on you keep playing these things down but

as other people are going around things they might be going around the map they might be making things more expensive but it's all about as stretching those cards as you can and trying to place through as many as you can because there's a another card that you use called the tribune when you play it you pick up all your other cards back into your hand ready for use again you think oh well that's no issue why don't i just keep playing a couple of cards and pick it back up again because you are rewarded by playing through more of them because every card in excess of three you're going to get an additional coin for so by the end of the game if you're playing 10 11 cards in a row you're getting quite a big chunk of money in order to do that and naturally if you keep just playing cards and picking them back up you're not being very efficient because you're wasting a whole turn just to pick those cards back up but i love that level of hand management the planning and forecasting in this game is just brilliant uh in addition to the um into the abilities on the cards with the scoring on the cards as well just a great use of cards and hand management in concordia and finally at number one um this is the game that really just made me think of hand management straight up this is arboretum now arboretum from the from the looks of it it looks like a very simple pleasant card game and in a way it is but in another way it's absolutely the most cut-throat and nasty game you'll you'll play um the the limitations on the game is is absolutely uh crippling because you are basically drawing two cards each each turn

and you can either do that from a central pile which are kind of a face down pile or you can actually draw from a discard pile from the other players that have accumulated throughout the game so that's quite cool first off so you've got to be careful about what you're discarding because other players might capitalize on that but you're also trying to play these cars in order to create these different routes and tracks of these trees in order to get lots of points in different ways but the hand management is so good in this game because every tree you lay on your board isn't worth anything unless you have the most or equal and most or equal amount of those cards or at least the value of those cards in your hand at the end of the game so in order to score something and try to get a lot of points you need to have some cards left in your hand and that itself is is contrasting because you know you want to get loads of points but you can't get those points if you don't have some in your hand and knowing what other people are having as well is so important because if somebody's got loads of say white trees down and you've got the the white seven in your hand you think well he's not going to score any points for those because i've got that white tree on my hand which is absolutely brilliant so you can be really nasty and just completely throw other people under the bus by collecting the cards that you know that they want um but all this time you're considering you only have a hand limit of seven cards so those seven cards are gonna be the ones that you're trying to play out they're gonna be the ones that you're trying to collect and keep before end game scoring and by the end of it you just you can't afford to give up certain amount of cards or certain types of cards because you know you need to score them so

meaning you're gonna have to discard certain other cards which you know that other players want so every single card in this game is is of paramount importance not only for your own scoring but from stopping other people from scoring as well knowing what to discard and and so on so an absolute great example of being restrictive but in a in a fun and compelling way and ultimately in an extremely cut-throat way because you can end up scoring this or winning this game by a landslide just because you stopped other players from scoring a certain thing and yeah and alternatively you can end up scoring all your cards by not holding any of those cards just because nobody else has got them in their hand so yeah the hand management in this game is probably the best example that i've ever seen that is arboretum at number one so i hope you've enjoyed this uh video of my top 10 hand management games i hope there's something on here that's kind of piqued your interest or kind of at least you know turned your head and watched once you want to check out if you have enjoyed the videos please hit like and subscribe to my channel and check out my other videos too additionally you can support me by backing me on patreon or following me on instagram and i'll leave the links in the show notes for those okay so uh for everyone else i'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye

Progress saved