Top 10 Board Games for 5 players
Transcript
Hello everyone, this is Senada. And this is Johannes.
And you are watching Board Gaming Rambling. And today we are taking a look at the top 10 games for five players. Yes, the horrible amount of people that is five players. You know, if you are two players, you have so many games to play. If you are three players, you have almost all the games to play because all of the great Euro games are stuff and usually best with two. So actually four players is bit harder, but then you can just play the games that are good with three players. They just take a bit more time. Then you come to five.
Dread is [clears throat] is creeping up and you're like, "Oh, but 95% of my games only go up to four players." And when we come up to five, do we have to play Flip Seven for a whole evening? I like Flip Seven. I don't want to play it for hours at a time. So today, we are taking a look at 10 games that are great with five players. They might also be good at all your player counts. It's not like the games that are best at five.
They only play at five. But games that are yes, that's not too many games.
No. I don't think I know any. I know a couple of plays on that tree. But this is 10 great games to play when you are making a game night and the fifth player is like, "I want to come as well." And now you can be happy instead of sad. Yeah, and we need these games in like this category as I said because sometimes you yeah, there's The fifth person comes along.
Shows up.
But then the sixth person comes along and you have to either split it up to two.
could play you could split with five also, but that's not the same Yeah.
And this is a bit unusual because usually when we make top 10 list, we make each list we make that's not a sentence. We make our own list. And this time somebody else made a list. It's someone It's Bob. Bob made a list. No, we have a joint top 10 this time. The reason is because we wanted to. Yeah, just because it we did it was fun this time to do it. Usually we think it's fun because we don't know each other's list. For this one it wasn't that important, so we thought let's just crack our heads together like boom and make one big list of the 10 games." And our like meanings and thoughts and taste in board games are usually pretty aligned, so we figured it out we were going to have a lot of crossovers. We might do like separate lists with more crossovers than Yeah, like but this time we wanted to do it this way.
But the thing also is I feel like the pool of games I would put into this list is way smaller than for example if we did top 10 heavy games or top 10 worker placement games. So those kind of things. With that said, should we begin? Let's jump into it.
Do you want to begin? Yeah. Our our number 10 is a co-op game. It is Bomb Buster. And this is a game that shines with I've heard all player counts. We haven't played it with like two players, so I can't attest to that, but we played it with the higher player counts and it works really well. This is a non-communication game. Yes. Um where
Limited communication.
Limited. Yeah, very very limited communication game where you are deducing what wires the other players have that are hidden from the other players and you're trying to basically disarm a bomb. There's many many different scenarios and you want to cut the right wires so that you don't lose and it's super tense and really hard and there's yeah many many varieties of like rule sets to each scenario, but the core concept is really solid and we really like this game. And this is one that is best if you have the same group. So if you are like a group that is usually five players, this is a great little campaign co-op game that you can play with the same group because it's not that great if you have to play with different people and then you start over and over and over. Next up is another one that is actually also very good with other player accounts. I feel like the more we come to the top of the list, there are games that we would rather play with five players.
Uh number nine is spectacular. And this could also have been like many other simultaneous action games. Like for example, Seven Wonders is great with five. So, this is kind of like that spot. Spectacular is from a few years back now. It is a a tile and dice drafting game where you are building up your own little zoo or sanctuary. You are sending these tiles. You have some tiles and dice that only you can choose from. And you have like a little tile that is moving around with tiles and dice on it that you can choose from as well. It doesn't have that much interaction, but it is a game that has a great It's one of my favorite spatial puzzle games. And we do love spatial puzzle games. What I really like about this with a higher player count is because you're doing things simultaneously, it's still takes a short amount of time. You can get this played in like 20 minutes, no matter the player count. And it's super easy and simple to like teach and understand, so it's easy to get to the table.
And number eight is Cosmic Encounter.
What?
And this is a game that hasn't been in like any top list for a long time. Do we still even have it?
I hope so.
we do.
think we have Cosmic Encounter. And I also think that it it was in my top 50 years and years back.
Yes, it was.
But it's not anymore. This is a game for us that we have played since like the early days of our board gaming experience. And it is a very different game from the other games that we usually enjoy.
This is a chaotic one. This has negotiation. It has like kind of war where you want to have like the majority. It's basically majority, but you you have these when you're the lead player and this goes around from round to round, you are like challenging for to take over a planet, basically. And then the defender is trying to defend that and the other players are active in that part. So, you can decide which side you want to be on. You one player cannot invite one player to because they reside because they would don't want them to gain the advantage from from that victory. And you play these like cards to get things to favor your outcome, basically.
And you get different different experience based on what kind of alien you are. So, there's a bunch of bunch of bunch of like special powers you can play with and stuff. And it's a very different one, but it's fun with a high player count. This is one of those games where I feel like the thing you said with the alien powers is what makes the game good because the game in itself is like a negotiation game which we usually don't like, but I like this one quite a bit. But the game-breaking powers is what makes the game fun. I think five is like a great sweet spot for the game because I think it plays up to seven. And I think if you play with seven players, there are a possibility that the game will be over before it's your turn.
Yeah. It's a very high possibility. think it's like a very high one, but it's like it has happened when we have played it. So, I think like five four to five is and I think five might be the best player count for this game. Number seven is Libertalia and there's two different versions of it. I feel like both of them fit here. It's Libertalia and then there's Libertalia The Winds of Galecrest.
Yes. I don't know why I was talking cuz I didn't I think that's correct.
Yes. Which is just like a new version of it with a bit nicer components and different theme, couple of nuances on the rules. I do think I like the rule changes better in the new version. I think we did a video on it way back. I think we only have the new version. We didn't keep the old one. The one I really like here, this is one of those kind of it has a blind bidding mechanism. You are pirates going out to try to to get treasures and you have a hand of cards. Everybody's going to start with the same hand of cards and you are going to be like, okay, I'm going to play this card. Everybody plays face down. You flip and then depending on the order of the cards, the numbers, you get to do things and some of them will be negative to other players, some of them will help you get the things you need and and a lot of these things is another one where like the powers and the variability of powers makes it great.
And then after the first round, you're going to get the same hand of cards again, but the cards you have left is going to be different. So, it's going to be I don't remember exactly did you play the monkey or did you not play the cook and all of those things? Um, it's one of those where we don't play it often, but when I talk about it now, I remember how much of a fun game it is.
Yeah, and it's really fun to play with a higher player count
you need five. because this it what I like about Libertalia is like the original theme was a pirate game. Yes.
Uh, and it's kind of that, but little yeah, a little away from the Caribbean Pirates of the Caribbean. Because the the artist for the first game basically painted or drew Pirates of the Caribbean.
Yeah, it's Barbossa on the cover. Yes. Um, but but what I do like is it being a chaotic game because that's where the fun moments come in because you're thinking you're sitting with your hand and like, okay, I really want this treasure. I'm just going to play a high card. Oh, wait, but if you I know you have this card on your hand. You counter with that, my card is going to be lost. So, that's going to be a like super bad. And there is moments where you really want to be the first one to pick because there's something really good and there's sometimes you just don't want to be lost because there's something really bad there as well. I love Libertalia. Uh, number six is Architects of the West Kingdom. Yes. And this is a worker placement game and it is great with a higher player count. Yeah. I like sometimes I think like worker placement games might not work very well with higher player counts, but this is a game where you you the spaces aren't blocked.
You just need more and more
to go there and you're essentially doing a lot of Euro stuff with the resources you get from placing people Mhm. in the action worker placement spaces. You can put people in jail and stuff to make it so that those action spaces are free again. But what I like about Architects of the West Kingdom, in addition to it being a great game, is that even though you can play it with a high player count, it doesn't take that much time. No, with five players I have played games in an hour, which I think is fantastic.
One of the highlights of the game is that you get a lot of crunch, a lot of game in a very short time and up to five players. We have an expansion I heard is good, but we haven't played it yet.
want to play that game.
back. We we have the trilogy. I want to go back and play all of them.
Yes. Next up is number five. Number five is recording we went from Cosmic Encounter to Libertalia, which is more like chaotic and not the Euro games and Architects, which is a newer, more nice, colorful, not that dry Euro game. So now we're going to go into the dry Euro game genre and we're going to start with Hansa Teutonica. Hansa Teutonica is a game I feel like I have played too little. Yeah. I would love to have played that game more, which means I would love to play it more, not just have it played it and not just oh, I like the feeling of having played. That's going to the gym. It's like
I really like having been to the gym. I don't really enjoy being there. So Hansa Teutonica is a very simple game. You are most of the time placing cubes on the board and then hoping that other people don't destroy your cubes or take over. It's a bunch of these different area majority things where you are placing cubes on these these trails and then when it fills this up you get to place in a builder in a city just to to score. You're trying to build build up these you have a player board. It might be one of the this is just like speculations. It might be one of the earlier games where you had like a player board with powers that you powered up. I don't know but I I feel like that is a big thing nowadays. It's like very like very often you have a player board you you upgrade things and stuff like that. That's very unique I felt like from Hansa Teutonica really enjoyed that there. There is an abundance of maps that you can play with and and it works with fewer players as well but I feel like this is one where you need four or five people to get the game to really shine and and also it has the best big box ever because it's like it's just a small box.
It's only big because there's more maps in it. It's there's like it's it's a normal rectangular box. Yeah, I like that. It's we have the new edition and it's really nice.
box.
box which is a normal box size but Hansa Teutonica I feel it is like an old classic but it still feels so fresh because of its smooth design and this is a game that feels tense almost throughout the whole game because you're always have like the next step on your plan and be like I need to get this working and these spots in the cities get filled up so you really need to like set your plan and go for it and be but also be able to pivot because if I'm starting on a road and I see like oh but if you get that over there then you get a lot of points. Okay, I need to go up there and stop you. Yeah, really solid one for sure.
Absolutely. And next up is another old classic and it is Power Grid. And in Power Grid you have a lot of paper money.
That's my favorite thing about the game, you know, that you are using in auctions to bid on different power plants that uses different kind of energy or resources to make energy. But you also need to buy the actual resources you need unless you're going for like the green energy like wind energy and stuff like that. And then that means that you need to save money to do that and depending on where you are in the player order, the prices will go up if it is a high demand on that kind of resource. So, this is and also you have the board where you're trying to build the houses and cities that need the electricity that you want to Yeah, so there's a lot you spend money on.
Mhm.
Um which means that I should be really bad at it But you're not. My math is Yeah, I'm actually the best.
It is mathing in your brain somehow. This is one of the few games where I think it's a possibility that you can use a calculator on your phone to be able to play the game because you are kind of Okay, how much can I bid for these power plants because I need that that that that. It is one of those games. It's very very like it makes like this is a game that feels very old school because it is, but one of the thing that makes it feel that way is that the rule set is so simple. You can teach this to almost anyone and I think this game really shines at the higher player count. I'm one of those weird people who really like it with six, but it's not often that you get to play it with six and it takes three and a half hours with six. So, I think five is like a great sweet spot. There are different ways to like play it with fewer. I think you need four through six people to make this game really shine because again, the interaction is high all the way, the tension is really really high and I just think it's a plain fun game even though you win every single time we play it.
Recently we played like the outpost version and that was fun as well. Yeah.
But we didn't keep it because the original Bargain is just a classic and really lovely. Number three is another game that I often think about. Like when we made this list, whenever I we started with the games that when we say, "Oh, we're five people." There's like four or five games that just comes into my mind. This is one of them.
And those are the ones that are on the top basically. And this one is The Princes of Florence. The Princes of Florence is another old-school Eurogame with simple rules, a lot of interaction, and a lot of fun. You are basically building up your estate to make it so that people want to come and work there. So, you're going to have cards in your hand with people who want to come and work there. And they have different like Oh, I want to have this. I want to have this building. I want to have a religious freedom. I want to have this thing or that thing. And how do you get those things? Yes, by auctions. And the beginning of each round there is an auction. Every player gets to choose a thing they want to auction off. But when one thing is auctioned off, you cannot auction off that thing again. So, it's all about okay, this is getting very high. I really want that, but I also want that. So, maybe I'm going to wait and hope that the joker tile for example or jester tile is going to be more affordable. So, when it comes to that one or maybe I'm going to start an auction for that if I'm last player. And all of these things is a great interaction, a great like auction.
And then another thing I really love about this game is when you finish a work, like a piece of work, somebody's doing the work, you get money from that depending on how well you did it. And then you have to choose how much of that money do you want as actual cash because that's what you bid on and make the rest of the game continue to work. And how much of it do you want to convert into points? And that is usually the only thing you get points and coins from. So, the balance of that is very interesting from the beginning. It's one of those games of course. In the beginning you're probably going to take most money. And at the end you're going to take mostly points. But that balance and also when to start pivoting is a thing I really love about this game.
Yeah, this is a great game and it has in as we've highlighted in many of these games, it has a high tension throughout the game because this guy, for him to come work for me, I really need that tile, but you're also wanting that tile. Should I wait? Should I try to like push you out in this auction now? And also it's a little bit of set collection also in this game because you want like professions that work well together. This is absolutely a really, really good game. Uh number two Two. is in the year of the dragon. This is a Stefan Feld game about trying to not be miserable Try not to die. and dying. The game. Uh this has a like at the beginning of the game you see all the disasters that are going or like the bad things that are going to happen throughout the game and those are the same for everybody.
Yeah. But you're trying to prepare for the disasters. So when the time comes that it is famine Yeah. you have enough food to feed your people and they will not all of them die. But problem is that it is a really hard time getting all that stuff. So you're going to get negative stuff come your way. So you're trying to just mitigate that as much as possible and try to fight the really important battles really and you're all playing cards to get different like people and you're trying to build also houses for the people that you have in your I don't know, village.
Yeah. And how how that works is that if you are the first player, you might get what you want.
Mhm. And then the lower you are in player count, the harder your life will be. Yeah. Essentially. There is like that's what I like about five because like it's a lot of tension again and interaction is very important and very interesting with two, three, four. Four is good.
is good.
But two and three is too little of that. Like, there is this track of the military that chooses like the turn order and you have so many things you want to to focus on, but you can only choose one new person each round to help you get where you want to be. There's only one more game left and it's the game we always think about first when somebody says we're five people and that is Medici. I know it's called Medici, I think, but I'm going to go with Medici because it's one of those things where I've just decided that's what it's called for me. This is an auction game from Reiner Knizia where you are trying to fill up your ships with different resources and you want the resources to be of high quality because that's going to give you points. You want to have the same resource to move on tracks that you will get most points for, like a majority of that and even if you get to the top of the tracks, you will get bonuses. And all the points in the game is the coins you are bidding with to do everything. So, it's one of those where the balance of how many points do I spend to get the things I need to hopefully score more points is super good. It plays up to six. I think it's great with four, five and six and it's one of those where you can teach it super quickly and it has a lot of great depth and I I love it. Yeah, that's one of the games that you said that instantly comes to mind when we're [clears throat] five players and it's one of my favorite auction games also.
What I like about this is that the player that is the player's turn that are holding the auction kind of is flipping the cards that will be in the auction and they can stop on one, two or three cards.
Not four or five.
Maximum of three per auction and you can be like, is this something that I want to win? And if you are really keen on the cards on your auction, you will be basically the one that bids last.
Yeah, cuz it's a one-round auction. So, yeah, it's a one-round auction. So, you are kind of like safe to get those if you really need those.
issues with that.
But, people might drive up the price if they notice that you really need want that.
Mhm. Um yeah, I I love Medici and I'm trying to pronounce it right as well.
Medici and Medici Medici Medici Medici Medici.
Well, but anyways.
very good game. I think one thing that's interesting to see in this list is that, of course, what is important for me or us in a five-player game is interaction.
Yeah. Cuz I feel like I think except for spectacular, all of these games have a lot of interaction. And I think that that is something that the more players you have, I feel like it's more important because if we play three players, I don't care if it's a multiplayer solitaire game. But if you're five people, I need to be also more engaged in when the other players have their turn, which then interaction is a big part of that.
Yeah, because if you're adding I don't know, people are not like us in this part, but if we're adding more time to play that game, if I'm going to sit a long time between my turn
Yeah. cuz four other people playing the game, that might take a little while, I'm going to be maybe a little bored. And I would rather have a game where I'm yeah, engaged in what the other players do. I also another thing with this list is that there's a lot of auctions. And there's a lot of games with quick turns. So, you don't There's no combo turns, nothing like that. So, you don't get those long drawn-out turns. Another thing that's interesting to see is that half of this list are pretty old games.
Yeah. And and there is like a tendency from newer Eurogames to have less interaction than older Eurogames. That that be a topic that would be interesting to talk about in the future. But, this topic
like could you argue We don't know this, but if per No, per way, but for example, from Princes of Florence or in the year of the Dragon was made today, would they put a cap on Like maybe other games would be also playable with five, but they put a cap on it because they I don't know. I don't know. And also I don't think that Like the the interaction part is is what was Yes, because you also have like the opposite that I It's a game that I should have I think that it should have a cap at four players that doesn't.
is true. But, that is going to be the end of this video because that might be another video. Well, this Speaking of this, was top 10 games that we think you should play with five players and that's going to be the end. Thank you so much for watching. I'm Johannes.
I'm Sarah. And you've been watching Board Gaming Ramblings and bye-bye.