13 Board Games that Didn't Survive The Purge
Transcript
hi it's Ryan from knights around a table and friends the day is finally here I'm so excited that the huge secret that I've been trying to keep under wraps for the past couple months is now out what is that secret you asked well there's gonna be a link up there or in the description below that you can follow and you can watch a video to find out and the video is only three hours long split into two parts but you know a secret that big reveal has to be just as epically insane it's pretty darn cool and in anticipation of revealing that secret last Friday I did a video of the games that didn't quite make it on to my top 10 list and the link you're gonna be clicking to take you to another video is going to be talking about my top 10 games that I love and would love to have with me on a deserted island or in a bunker or shelter situation and would be happy with playing for the rest of my life so then in order to have a video to hook to that today I thought you know what's left I've done the best so let's cover now I'm not gonna say the W word because I'm gonna try to be as kind as possible here because I am a creator on the game designer I make stuff I make arts I make lovely things to hopefully entertain and please people and I know how hard it is to make a thing and to especially get it to market and get a skew on it offer in its stores and just put yourself out there for the criticism of the world I don't want to be punching
down on people you know maybe some of the things that are on this list I'm about to share with you didn't do so well in the marketplace and so you know it's no wonder they didn't get a lot of uptake some though are very ripe for being pilloried because they're hugely popular and I can't understand why but let me talk about this list this is a list of games that's aren't the worst games of my collection they're the games that I couldn't even bear to keep in my collection and now you have to understand I'm a bit of a hoarder when it comes to fun stuff if I buy toys and I do buy toys I keep the boxes and I haven't thrown out any of my expansion board game boxes either so for me to get rid of a game out of my collection I've got to dislike it pretty hard and I only mention this list for this reason some of these games you might enjoy I might be listing your favorite game I mean as possible hopefully unlikely but I mentioned this list because obviously there are a hosts on YouTube who talk about board games and you watch the videos and they say I like this and I don't like that and you come to understand what their tastes and preferences are and maybe you identify them with them or maybe you say oh that guy is crazy like he anything that he recommends I know I'll hate but at least that's useful information that you can take away with you so if you watch somebody like me and you align with the
stuff that I like then you know that if I say this game is really really cool it might be something that you find interesting too or if you're diametrically opposed to me and you don't like anything that I like the same token I can say something's good and you know it's not worth your time checking out so in that spirit let me talk to you about the games that didn't survive the purge list of 13 of them and they're in no particular order except alphabetical number 13 is escape the curse of the temple this is the game that I think helped me understand that I don't really like real-time games all that much a bunch of you are in a temple you got little ponds there you're rolling dice frantically in order to move from room to room and get out of the temple it's a time-limited thing and really all it is is just chuck and dice check and - did I get the right symbol that I get right symbol that I get very simple if you didn't you get don't get to do anything and another reason I don't like it I don't like the pressure of the real-time thing so much and I didn't enjoy the price of it I think I paid eighty Canadian buckaroos which is astronomical and I'm not too sure where all that money went to be honest a couple of dice and some tiles and I have come to realize that I don't really like games where with a few exceptions the rule for the galaxy is one of them but in generally I don't like games where people can't be he please so they can be rolling dice or taking actions or doing something over here and you're doing it something over here frantically and you can't make sure that people are you know following the rules
and these games they're all about rules if you're not following the rules what the heck I even do and just go out and play soccer or something and the real-time aspect adds pressure to that so you can't even be sure that you're following all the rules when you're frantically throwing dice around the table or whatever the game has you doing so let's get Kirsten temple escaped my collection now we're 12 flower fall this is game with different patterns of flowers on the cards and you just throw them on the floor and wherever they land you score differently and there are a bunch of different games where they tried to put rules and parameters around just making a mess and throwing stuff everywhere so it's like the imagine you know dungeon drop is like the diced our unboxing drop of components and then like depending on where they land at points yes so it's it's not my favorite kind of thing and there are a few games out there that do it but it wasn't for me number 11 the immensely inexplicably popular and almost universally reviled flux so there's an interesting category of we see there's you know niche board games and there's mass-market board games and never the twain shall meet but there is a category of niche mass-market board games so these are games that you can only find in like a friendly local specialized game store yet they've got they try to have such broad appeal that anyone can walk in and pick it up off the shelf and flux is one of those and for some I mmm I know I talk about
people who like or sorry who don't like randomness in their games I think that's crazy life is random ah they have a little bit of random your game is fine flux is way beyond beyond anything that I can handle is just like your play a car to be like it's the I win card we're done let's go home I don't like it but obviously tons of people do because there's zombie flux and there's Cthulhu flux and there's obscure 1984 sci-fi television show Automan flux or whatever so I mean obviously the thing is selling and people like it not one of those people dishonorable mention by the way goes to well he didn't play test this at all can't remember for the title is we didn't play test this or we didn't play that's this game at all I didn't research this video at all but imagine flux except not quite as good no.10 greedy greedy goblins which I picked up just because it had Richard Garfield's name on it now he's the guy who designed Magic the Gathering which I haven't actually played what I heard you're audible gasps so they're in audience land but I I do quite like king of Tokyo that he also designs so I thought I can't go wrong with the Richard Garfield game boy was I wrong you sure can it took me a while take me a few plays to understand that the title is a play are they even the mechanics the gameplay they're all a play on Hungry Hungry Hippos except it's Hungry Hungry Hippos in Reverse so instead of grabbing things from the middle like those white marbles with your big hippo mouth
you're a goblin and you're stuffing I can't remember what is caves or sacks or something with with tiles that are face down and it could be bombs that might not but just like escape curse to the temple it's one of these almost real-time things where everyone's doing something at the same time you can't really please people and it's just kind of a mess and things are being chucked all around the table and I don't enjoy it now we're dying is guillotine and guillotine is maybe the only one on this list where I had the teensiest little inkling of maybe it's just a grain of regret that it's not in my collection anymore because I do have fond memories of it my friend Carla introduced me to this game and she always say whenever they they play it and they line the people up in front of the guillotine there's a bunch of cards of nobles who were going to be beheaded and you are all competing executioner's which is already like hilarious and this is in like you know louis xiv era of france but one thing I read about this game is that the designer years later after people complained about this one card he admitted that it was a horrible idea and he should designed the card and put it in the game to begin with so I don't know maybe I don't feel so bad about offing guillotines head number eight hex hex next I might be the only channel on YouTube that has ever mentioned this game or the expansion to hex hacks because I brought it up in my board games 101 what's an expansion video where I talked about expansions that you
don't need the base game to play a really kind of a rare thing and the hex axe next with one of them I took it home not knowing that there was a hex axe so a busted-out hex hex next what I didn't realize is that it's a drinking game is really what hex hex is and I don't drink that yeah number 7 killer bunnies and the quest for the magic carrot I have extreme anxiety talking to you about this game because I feel like a real cat this was a gift to me for my dear friends Tim and Sarah I'm sure they asked around for a game that their board game loving friend would enjoy and somebody said ah yeah killer bunny is it's super cute me and my five year old really enjoy it oh yeah I know maybe if you're 4 I think I have mean the really little logically offensive thing is that this game comes down to yeah you're doing this I can't even remember there's bunnies and there's cards and cards of going around and ending up at a stack or in a bag or something anyway at the end it's like let's determine the winner there's a whole stack of cards now you just pick one and whoever's cars it is wins and the thing that I've read about killer bunnies is that the game designer designed it as an exercise to teach randomness I think he might have been a teacher so he's trying to teach randomness to his class and somehow that became a commercial game sorry Tim and Sarah I hocked it I got rid of it at a conference but I'm sure somebody out there it's gonna do a good home that somebody else is currently absolutely miserable playing it number 6 landlord this one's a bit of a cheat
because I actually didn't get rid of his game from my collection not for lack of trying every year at Christmastime we host a party at our house we have all our friends over and we have dirty Santa gift exchange which is where we encourage people to wrap essentially a hilarious piece of trash from their house that they don't want anymore and we bring it to the gift exchange and it's a huge letdown and super disappointing and everybody comes away with frowns on their faces I'm not too sure why we're still doing this but one of the things that I've tried to fall off at other people is this game landlord I can't even tell you what it's about I just remember it was really weird it's a German game but it came off like francophone for some reason where you play a sleazy scumbag landlord who is among other things bombing his apartment buildings to get rid of squatters it's really hard I leaves a bad taste in my mouth so I tried to give it to my friends at Christmas and I've tried now might be going on three years to get rid of this game and every single time somebody gets it and the dirty Santa gift exchange everybody leaves we say your good-byes and the hugs and everything and then I'll find it somewhere in my house somebody has stashed it because they don't even want to take it so I made and then a lot of them art board gamers so if they won't even take it and it's free I don't know number-5 much kid along the same lines
as flux right it's a mass-market game in the niche game store and again like flux super super popular there's all kinds of versions of it there's like Golden Girls munchkin and like 1977 issue of National Geographic munchkin yes Pete gets really weird so one of these games I think like apples to apples apples apples isn't on my list but it should be because that thing got turfed but maybe it's fun the first time you play and that's about the extent that it can go for me of course it's of course is massively popular tons of people love munchkin there's nothing particularly insightful I can add I just don't like it there before warriors which I mention I don't know why my voice just went up maybe the painful remembrance of playing quarters or maybe it's the fact that the third or fourth expansion decors which I for some reason bought has the worst board game name of any board game in history warriors quest for the Clady ater so couriers I tried to replace Dominion with something that was in cars warriors had dice I was cool at first but I didn't play very well and I found that the artwork I mean you're really like overwatch overwatch is like oh it's got ninjas and it's got zombies and it's got bears and gorillas and hamsters and and all this crazy stuff and it works somehow because it's got a great art direction the weird mix of stuff and
queriers never jailed for me I had no sense of place I had no idea what kind of universe I was in one of the monsters on the front is a clear ripoff of Alfred to Niels Jabberwock illustration from the Tennille tennyson from the house and wonderlad books I don't know where I am or what I'm doing or what the heck a courier is when I play that game and it committed one of the cardinal sins of board games which is where they released some expansions which I purchased and the expansions weren't compatible with each other which I hate don't do that I think it got rid of this at a conference too and I believe that the person who picked it up was extremely happy to have the base game and the expansion so good on you enjoy it number three is Stonehenge again I feel really bad because this one was a gift from a family member and the family member went to a niche board game store and asked the salesperson what will my family member who likes board games enjoy and the guy sold them on this thing which is a kind of thought exercise where a bunch of game designers who had other titles under their belt thought okay we're gonna put all the same components in a box and what will each do is will go off with the components and we can come up with whatever game we want based on those components and then you know put on the in the box and then based on the same components you can play five or six or ten or whatever it is games and then will encourage other people to come up with their own games based on the components in the box it's a neat idea I guess but kind of
like sounds like more fun for them than it is for me I would much rather have you know one designer two designers work on one game with components that are made specific before that game that they want me to play than just sort of this grab bag of game components and ideas and concepts and I mean I think the game was supposed to be sold on the strength of the names of the designers who worked on it but at the time that I received this as a Christmas present I couldn't name any board game designers so that didn't really have a lot of cachet with me now I will say that since I received the game and never played it and got rid of it out of my collection I have met a few designers who were involved in Stonehenge and one of them was very very mean to me so I'm happy to not have anything with his name on it in my collection number two sorrow I won this at a conference that I attended and just like escape the curse of the temple helped me figure out that I don't really like the real-time games Cyril helped me figure out that I don't really like tile placement games and then I started recognizing that tile placement was a genre and a very popular one Carcassonne is another game that uses tile placement and I don't much care for that either maybe the only tile placement game that I really got into was Scrabble it's weird right you might not think uh yeah scrabble is a tile placement game but it is it's a tile placement game but Ciro little too light little to family and much too tile placement II for me however if you need a game that you need
to pull down and play with with with grandpa or smaller children it's a pretty good pick to be honest and the number one game that I turned out of my collection was zombies not that it's number one like it's the worst one out there or anything but you know it's alphabetical but I mean there are a lot of great reasons to not have zombies in your collection it's tile placement it's like a roll and move mechanic so it's like playing clue with combat it comes with a huge baggie of zombies and somehow it's not enough zombies for what the game requires you to put on the different tiles it's got combat that comes down to dice rolls which isn't very exciting at all I don't know they managed to take sherlocky subject matter and build the really schlocky game out of it that feels like a zombie movie but it feels sort of slapdash like many zombie movies do I got quickly tired of it as I'm sure you've quickly tired of this video if you don't want to hear me harping on games that I didn't really enjoy who cares why don't you go watch the the video where I'm just oozing love for though that's a horrible why did I remember to edit that out later where I'm just exude Ingush or the stuff that I really really enjoy but I'll turn it back on you do have games that you just couldn't I'm sure you've got lots right that you just couldn't bring yourself to look at after a while and you've gotten rid of them out of your collection you pulled on Marie Kondo and
you thought this does not spark joy or are there any games that I mentioned where you say oh my gosh flux is a modern masterpiece it's a tour de force of game development hopefully not but we've got a comment section below let me know and I've been hyping the discord server and all the lovely people on it and since the last video so many of you have popped into that discord server just poke your heads in and say hi and check it out so I invite you to do that it's for my patreon supporters but you don't have to be one to join in but if you are one you do get access to a couple of special channels where I'll be doing exciting announcement and behind-the-scenes stuff including everything but the huge secret that dropped today if you go click that video and and find out what that's all about exciting things going forward thank you so much for being with me at this part of the journey and I hope that you'll continue with me on for the rest of it did you just watch that whole thing oh hey there 100% this video click the badge to subscribe and then click the bell to get notifications when I've got new stuff