Shelf of Shame Update | 10 Must Play Games
Transcript
looks like I have that butterfly thing you've got it looks like you've got what I thought it's probably wind burn but why wouldn't you get the rest of my face it's covered yeah hello everyone and welcome back to Foster the meepola Channel all about four games and or gamey things exactly we are here today to give you an update on our Shelf of Shame we're both wearing gray we're both wearing Gray gray outside gray outside Jamie's feeling great it's gray inside that's for sure in April we focus the month on playing games from our Shelf of Shame you may remember we put out a video about it it was called spring cleaning doesn't feel like spring four degrees next week so when we started with this little journey at the beginning of April we had a total of 160 board games on our Shelf of Shame 21 of those were expansions and 10 were Campaign games so we kind of took those off the docket so we were left with 129 games on our Shelf ocean now to end off on our Shelf of Shame if I look at our list because I think keep everything in my collection on my air table we have 153 games on our Shelf of Shame 21 of those are expansions nine are Campaign games
because we did play one of our Campaign games leaving us with 123 and I know what you're thinking that's terrible that's only six games but let me throw this curveball at you we played 28 games off of our Shelf of Shame we have a net of six yeah six played so so now you know why it's so difficult for us to get ahead that basically means we had that many games new games come in which we didn't even realize because they come in like one at a time we get game sent from Publishers we buy games Jeff went to Lancelot games and bought some games which is the first time we've bought games in a while we we're not like actively buying them they just appear here and so it's impossible for us to knock our Shelf of Shame down I told Jamie we need to redefine what shelf of Shame means we need to redefine what shelf of Shame means I say three months yeah if it's been on the shelf for three months but then it's be can can is part of the shelf of Shame totally so I'm gonna have to add a new layer to my spreadsheet which I'm fine to do I love adding layers to the spreadsheet anyways as part of our Shelf of Shame month as part of our spring cleaning we had our patreons vote on games from the shelf that they wanted us to play and we were challenged to play 10 games and I'm happy to say we played all 10 of those games right down to the wire right
down to the wire literally the last day of April we played one of these games yep but we did it so that's what this video is about we're gonna talk specifically about those 10 games if you want to hear more about the other games that we play from our Shelf of Shame you can go and watch our wrap up we just did that not that long ago we ate some snacks so the first one on the list we have talked about a couple of times now and that is the adventures of Robin Hood from Cosmos this I believe was the campaign game that we knocked off yeah it's not really a campaign but I think I had it marked as that because I didn't know we yeah I think a lot of the times we'll throw in those scenario based because like forgotten Waters technically isn't really I guess it is kind of a campaign game but like it's hard to Define The Adventures of Robin Hood we actually covered this in a board game snapshot so we did a full review of IT an overview so we're probably not going to dive too much into that one but this is kind of like an advent calendar scenario based Adventure type of game where you're playing as Robin Hood and the merry men and married married Marin made Marion and you're doing scenarios in a storybook and you're uncovering things and it's so exciting and this has been sitting on our Shelf of shame since December of 2021 and it has actually been a game that for some reason we were pushing off because maybe we thought it was more intensive I was do you think that is a big part of
it I thought it was a way more campaigny yeah but it wasn't it's actually the easiest and I thought there was going to be a ton of rules overhead and there was basically enough we covered it in the snapshot but like this game is so good at literally you get a storybook and it'll be like go here do this when this happens this is what it means and read this page and it just teaches you as you go in such like a beautiful way that you don't need to be stressed about learning rules if you're afraid of teaching games but you want to get into like a campaign scenario based game this could be a great one to introduce to people I think you could play it with a lot of different ages and different types of people and the theme connects with people I am very very happy that this ended up on our list agreed but what I will say though is this was the first one one of the first ones that we played from The Challenge and immediately we were like let's play it again let's play it again and then we're like oh no we have to play more new games but it was a game that we both were like let's just set it up and play it again let's just leave it set up and play it again so it definitely made us want to play it more and more the next game that we were challenged to play was decorum this is a game that I've been super excited to play for a long time have you been super excited I was a difference um we did end up playing this live on Twitch so you can watch the video on
demand on our second Channel if you're interested but basically this is a game about passive aggressively decorating your home so I'll have certain objectives Jeff will have certain objectives and you can't tell each other what those are except for at certain points of the game and that's just that you're just trying to fulfill your objectives yeah I really liked it I'm not sure how you felt I don't know how I feel yet we've only played two or three we did two on stream and then one before stream Okay so we've only played three of the scenarios yeah I do think it plays well into our dynamic because we are both very passive aggressive with each other and sassy and stuff I enjoyed it but it's just not my type of thing yeah like I enjoy that game as much as I possibly could for the type of game it is right is that fair yeah I think yeah I think that's fair I think one of the things that we struggled with is that you can't really ask questions because you'll you'll give away your objectives and some things maybe you might interpret different than somebody else and so Jeff and I got to like a standstill in the first game that we played we were very frustrated because I was like what do you like no I but I read my card wrong so anyway so it eventually will get to those moments it'll eventually get to a point where it just feels broken yeah and then it's like I feel like someone's interpreting a card wrong yes but then we played it again that didn't happen I
was like oh okay and it gets more challenging as you progress so I'm excited to continue playing it I really liked it I don't think I loved it as much as I want it to love it though I feel like you got a little bit overhyped for us too yeah because a lot of people love that game and we're telling us how much they loved it yeah and then I expected to love it and I was like that's fine totally next up on the list was Mosaic a story of civilization civilization Mosaic we have the big box bigger heart version yeah um Mosaic is a civilization game that takes up too much table do you have a mansion in my opinion it's not not big enough but your Mansion massive but where it's massive it is also super simplistic there is a lot of iconography and that sort of thing but the board and the actions are all very easily laid out on the board for you you're just doing actions on your turn like it might be to build a city it might be to move some troops all of these things in typical civilization-esque game fair like it's very typical civilization game it felt like playing Civ the video game the PC game whatever you want to call it yeah I didn't love it you didn't love it no
I really liked it but I didn't love it it was too long it went that's the key that's it that was the only I loved it for about the first hour and a half and then I was like we have how much longer it just kept going it just kept going and yes caveat we played it a two-player but I've talked to Zach who always played it at three or four and he had the same a similar problem basically the end game is triggered by like one of two things happening it's like end scoring cards that will come up in the deck but one stack of cards is like this big in the card somewhere within the bottom side one of the other ones is like there is uh kind of like Victory Point conditions that you're chasing after like the first person to have for military troops out in these areas will get this thing for example it's not exactly that but you know what I mean and those Stacks are like this big and you have to get rid of two of The Three Stacks it just it gets to a point where like all your you have all the resources you need and then you're just like all right I need one more card in order to get this you're just like kind of going through the motions to get the cards and I wish it had ended before that happened yes because it it dragged it out so long that we ended up getting kind of bored of what we were doing and I'm like I'm just doing the same things and then it was we were just trying to be like all right how do we get to the end of the game funny because I was one away from clearing one of those piles so I was
just filtering through the technology I'm like every turn I'm just gonna get this technology because I'm gonna try and find this thing and yeah so I really liked it I very much enjoyed the mechanics uh and the gameplay of it yeah I think if we were to play it again I'd maybe like host rule something and be like all right if we get through like I don't even know like one stack or I put the end scoring cards yeah a little bit higher or make the card Stacks smaller or something I don't know but it went on for too long but with that being said like we were in the game being like this is great yeah that game was simple that game was fantastic for like again for about an hour hour and a half yeah it was great and then it just went on too long and then it was three hours later and I was like what the f why are we still playing this game and uh but again like super simplistic very easy to kind of get in and played but the setup I mean Jamie set it up I literally as I said like this gameplay better be worth this setup because it was but again we we don't have we have the big box one so big box but yeah I mean enjoyable experience I definitely want to try it again and see if maybe it's quicker but yeah it just went on a little bit too next one on the list was bad company and this one was one of the first ones that we played in the month and it was really really fun I really liked it I actually knew nothing about it did you know anything about it yeah I did oh yeah I knew I knew that it used a similar uh mechanism to space space so
basically in Bad Company you have a gang but it's similar to space space so you're rolling Dice and you have 12 gang members in front of you and depending on the combination of dice you're able to activate those different gang members there's a secondary board that has a car chase mechanic to it so you're moving a car around this track to get bonuses and and that sort of thing but it's a little bit more beefier space with a uh Heist theme to it yeah it's super for fun super silly and I feel like it would play best with more players like I'd love to play this at four yeah I feel like four would probably be good but I had a great time playing it because it was so silly yeah I just I love a good silly game the artwork was great yeah space space Sports Bad Company really I think I'm Bad Company Sir John declare is can beat him yeah I mean like yeah fair enough but I think the added little elements of like the the car chase and stuff gave that game a little bit of an extra it's definitely like a beefier type of game the theme is really fun it's like I said it's silly fun I don't know there's something about space space that I just there's something about it that it's such a tight game I love it yeah then we played fall of the Mountain King which we also covered in a board game snapshot so you can go watch that for a full um review we picked this one up at Pax on the club this past year it is an area control game now I also think this game
will play better with more players most areas most area control games do but I really enjoyed the theme I really enjoyed the artwork another thing another game that has like some silly elements added to it because the trolls all have like funny names and like everything like that we very much enjoyed the uh action selection mechanics in that game too um yes that's the last part of the game you're kind of building out this little Tableau in front of you ancestry the Tableau is actually how you take actions there's like placement rules in order to where you can place these plaque cards out basically they have to cover one at least one quadrant and there's like certain quadrants that you can't cover sixth grade yeah there's certain quadrants you can't cover and then you can have a maximum of a six by six grid and this grid is allowing you to take your actions which is um really cool yeah very much enjoyed it very fun I'm excited to try it with more players for sure then we played fog of Love which was a very interesting experience I actually like I really like the game we did something that I we definitely should have done and that was we played the tutorial we should not have done that because I think Jeff's brain drifted off yeah into the sky so the tutorial is great it really is like if you're able to kind of sit and slowly go through everything the problem was I had already watched like a how to play video anyways it doesn't matter the point is in this game you are acting out a relationship you are building your characters their features their traits
their occupation and you're making decisions based on the character that you have built and you are trying to make your relationship survive it is such a unique game we've never played anything like it I really enjoyed it I once again just wish that we hadn't played the tutorial version because it kind of pulls you out of the game and there's too many it's it's too many stops way too many it's very good to teach you the game 100 very very very good if that's what you're looking for yeah but you are stopping every turn it's like now read this card and then you're just reading it and in and when you're doing an rpg-esque experience I was just out a little bit so I want to play again we just played like the intro tutorial scenario so I'd like to play a full-on scenario but I thought it was such a cool and unique we played one scenario after that didn't we no we didn't I would like to play it more and just kind of see how the game plays just on its own with a tutorial but I thought it was really cool I enjoyed it for what it was and I am excited to try it again without the the constant stopping to really like kind of get into the character and stuff yeah it was funny Jeff played as his character was an actor I think it was like an insecure a nerdy actor and I was a wedding planner and I kept making references to JLo and Jeff like why you gave Taco yeah I didn't get it because Jennifer Lopez The Wedding Planner I didn't get it at all we didn't get it but then we played too many bones this was one that we knew
would be on like our patrons would chooses we have an entire channel in our Discord dedicated to this game we call them the Bones crew called basically definitely cold too many bones number one to learn it the rule book wasn't so great but luckily luckily bones cult in the Discord people were sending me videos of how to play Jeff and I sat down and played and lost so miserably so horrible that almost was it was terrible that we were like I don't like this game okay then we realized oops we were playing on like expert mode and we're not experts at like anything so we should never have done that so with some encouragement from the Discord and they told us kind of things we were doing wrong we're like whatever let's just go for it and yellow it and play it on stream uh we did and we won and it was amazing and now I love the game let me set the scene for you set the scene we had progressed all the way to the final battle against our friend knob no no no no I don't want to spoil it yeah basically basically I went into a room and died immediately and then Jamie came Walton in so give me some backstory my character was the tanky shieldy one uh and Jamie was a bit of a glass Cannon Boomer so I died immediately Jamie Waltz
is into this room and she's like some bombs and so she's like walks over to Nam and just says you're dead well Jeff was like roll everything and I was like everything shouldn't I roll some she was going to die regardless on her next turn yeah she needed to kill Nam on her turn otherwise we lost all of my dice she needed a 11. she needed to roll an 11 with all of her stuff what did you roll a 12. and we defeated novel it was an epic moment the replay is on our second Channel you can go and watch it it was amazing and we fell in love with the game so much so that we just desperately want more characters I want to play this game all the time it was great I understand the cult I have drank the Kool-Aid I have also I have also drank the Kool-Aid I'm not giving myself into the cultiness of that channel yeah I just can't do it I will say to Echo Jamie two things one there's times when you play games that are just become a core memory yeah that is now will be a core memory yeah 100 I will always remember that moment and two we are hoping to do some more too many bones specific content primarily over on Twitch uh to be determined we're still working some of those things out but um hopefully that will happen in the future the next game that we were challenged to play was at the gates of loyang which is
an uve Rosenberg you know I love love to see it and this game shocked me see here's the deal I think Jamie likes uve games but she's got this bit now because she loved hallertau and she's a lot she loved Gates of Liang and glass Road and glass Road and Patchwork New York Zoo we'll talk about another one too in a minute this is my new favorite uvae game there I said it over all the other ones yes I don't know what it was about this game so essentially in at the gates of laying you are like sewing Fields collecting your produce and fulfilling orders for customers you got casual customers and you got regular customers and it is just like a resource production machine that's what you're doing you're building out your engine to optimize how many things you can bring in to make sure you have happy customers because if they're not happy then you're gonna lose money you also have helpers that can come and help you do things all of this stuff it just made there's something about all the little bits of vegetables that just made my brain happen the veggie meeples are very nice in that game so colorful and it is very sewing Fields putting those crops on the fields in order to produce more stuff for your customers that's basic premise it's optimization yeah it's one of those games that when you get it go in it just makes your brain feel really good if you like math puzzly stuff puzzling yeah I
loved it yeah it's an old game too I don't know if you can find it I very much enjoyed I I love uvae and every time I play one of his games I'm like yup I love his stuff and this was just another example yeah I don't I don't think I've liked it quite as much as you did I think that's because like you definitely enjoy more of that comboy like optimization stuff than I do I like there to be a little bit more substance to it it's very it's very just resource uh it's just very much resource optimization with not another a lot of gameplay outside of that really yes then we played Galaxy tracker we have defeated I'm sorry if you can hear that Juno is chomping her nails because that's what Huskies do beans it's probably enough for that she just keeps going she's she might be one of the loudest dogs ever she's always licking stuff and chomping her toes very like I didn't even notice it until you mentioned it I am hyper sensitive it is hypersensitive to stuff lately yeah sounds specific I think I think you need to like I'm in like sensory overload you need to like go on a vacation it's only 140 some days until we go to Disney World can't wait boys I talk about Galaxy tracker we defeated Galaxy trucker Jeff had learned Galaxy tracker about a year ago and then for some reason for some unknown reason we just didn't play unknown reason nobody even knows what
the reason was Galaxy trucker is a real-time game that you are basically building a spaceship in order to truck stuff through the Galaxy your Galaxy Goods you're a Galaxy trucker so the real-time element of this game is you have a timer and you are going to flip that timer and then you're going to start grabbing tiles from the middle of the table in order to build out your ship so you have a little framework that you are allowed to build out within so each tile will have different ship components on it so it might be an engine it might be blasters gun like Blaster gun it might be battery chargers to charge your Shields it might be Shields you're building this entire ship in order to hopefully successfully navigate through space to deliver your goods so after you do that you then proceed to basically the rest of the game which is to pull event cards and those event cards are going to tell you things to do so it might be a meteor attack so meteors might be hitting your ship and if you have shields you can deflect if you don't have shields pieces of your ship are just going to get destroyed that just happens in this game by the end of it you might only have one little tile left sad ultimately it's impossible to avoid really having damage to your ship you get pirate raids you can see you can dock at space stations to pick up Goods all of these things happen it's silly nonsense fun and it's one of those games that you're just probably not going to do good at but it
doesn't matter because it's just fun it's just silly nonsense one thing I want to say quickly about Gauss trucker is a really really good navigation through playing your first game so it removes it removes the real-time element it literally gets you to play step by step we didn't use the timer in our first game so in the first game the book will walk you through everything you did need to do it's super accessible way more accessible than I remember it being the first time I learned it yeah because I think I skipped through that initial like thing and I was like ah we can just jump into the real time we didn't play with the timer the first time which was a luxury the second time we played with the timer and it just like it's over and I had gaps in my ship and I was like my ship was literally like maybe five tiles and Jeff had like 13 or 15 tiles and I was like what have I done yeah what have I done because you have to pull a tile and then you have to bring it in front of you and decide don't want it or you do want it you put it back there is a reserve you can put tiles in your reserve and your Canon it's got to be pointing one way and your Rocket's got to be pointing another way and then everything's got to be connected but there's connection rules and anyways then last but not least we were challenged to play another uvae game a classic in fact uvey's first ever game and that is Bonanza do you like beans good play Bonanza we have the 25th anniversary edition just FYI because it is a bit different it is a bit different we have the 25th
anniversary edition which includes a bunch of different variants including the Dual version of the game for two players so it has a few different rules there's not really any trading within that version that we played um but I thought it was really fun so bonanza's basically just set collection it has a little element of like scope where like you can't move the cards in your hand and you have to plant whatever is first and new beans have to go in the back and a bunch of stuff there's a lot of placement rules but it is one where you need to make like some tough decisions Visions for such a simple game do I want to sacrifice my green beans in order to get this black eyed Bean but this being there's less of them in the stack so what if they don't come up or you know all of these different things or if what what if Jeff steals my beans I really really liked it however I one thousand percent just want to play this with a bunch of people because I do think the trading element is like a huge part of this game that you miss in a two-player version yeah I think a lot of the games on this list um we've mentioned I think multiple times it would play at a better player count which I think is probably why we put some of them off for so long yeah I mean that might be part of the reason for sure but Bonanza is definitely one that I want to play at higher player account not to keep saying that but I do think that's accurate because I think the fun in Bonanza and I think anyone that's played it would probably agree is the trading of the cards and having that debate at the table because um ultimately what you're trying to do is negotiate
so that you don't have to prematurely get rid of your being Fields yeah you want to make money you want to make money and you do that by having a larger set of beans but I definitely want to try it with the the trading piece in it same Seas which is weird because we don't really like negotiation games that is true I don't know so I don't know how I don't know no honestly like I'm I agree like yeah I it might be something like we think in theory we're like oh that trading should be cool but yeah Jamie and I are not the only thing though is that this game is simple enough like I feel like a lot of times in negotiation and trading I never know if I'm getting a good deal yeah whereas this one might be like hey I'll trade you this green bean if you have a chili bean you know yeah you're just looking for something very specific it's not like what you need yeah it's not like they need it's not like oh is it worth five coins yeah I don't know yeah it's a little bit different but yeah those are the 10 games that we were challenged to play from our Shelf of Shame so 28 games off at the shelf of Shame um and then a bunch more added to it because you know that's just how it would be sometimes but I think we did pretty good this is a good indicator of why like people are like how do you have so many selfishing games like because like we add like 20 of them each month and that's okay it's okay those those are all of the games that we were that we're going to talk about today that's it that's all I said so if you're interested in buying games like any of the many that we mentioned today you should first start by checking your friendly local gaming store and for us that is boardroom Game Cafe heck yeah
it is you want snacks who doesn't are you waiting for me nope where should they go though lunch pack lunch pack thank you so much for watching if you like what you see Please Subscribe we hope to see you again soon and now we say goodbye bye later days now to end off uh did I do math from I don't think so no you're good okay so we played this all right I wish I could do that God that felt good I bet it did why can't you do it because when I touch my eye at all my vision just goes it's gone sometimes my uh it just feels like you need like that foreign