Skip to main content
Loading video...

14 Board Games Ranked - Episode 19

Transcript 22:36

hey everybody and welcome to November's edition of month in review so in this series I take a look at all of the new games I played during the previous month and I rank them from my least favorite all the way up to my most favorite now I have 14 new games that I played during November with a big range of styles and of course a big range of my personal enjoyment now before I get started on the games I want to give a shout out to the show's sponsor keyienda dot Co dot UK for my go to online retailer when it comes to purchasing games here in the UK and if you use my link in the show notes or the QR code then you can get five percent off your first order now before I get started on these games I want to make it clear that this list is recorded after my top 100 so you will not be seeing these games on my top 100 list even if they do break into the top 100 just because of the chronological order that I've recorded these things so hopefully that makes sense to you but let's get started on the games at number 14 I have city of the big shoulders now this is a heavy complex economic simulation Style game as you are trying to take control of these companies you're investing in other players companies increasing the production of these companies in order to get your share of the dividends now there's a lot going on here way more than I can summarize in a short clip like this but why is this at the bottom considering it has so many things I tend to enjoy in board games that is because it is way way too long this took us over five hours to play with a teach and yeah

that's for me is completely unforgivable I've lost any interest in playing this game again because you can easily get a you know a two-hour game played with just as much depth just as much going on but of course it's going to take you half the time so yeah completely um debilitated by the fact that it takes way too long for me and I would not recommend it to anybody for that reason at number 13 I have Toledo now Toledo is an older Martin in Wallace game is definitely one of his lighter games as you are going up this road and you're placing tiles on this road as you go and basically when you land on these spots you are going to be collecting resources and building these swords and the more lavish the swords are the more points you're going to get but you have to make sure that you get some of your points to the top otherwise those scored swords aren't going to be eligible for scoring for me this was a very paint by numbers Style game it felt dated in the way it played um and it I think it might have been one of the pioneers of those games where you actually build up the spots as the game went on and I think maybe at the time that was a new and exciting thing but now so many games do that that this one felt Ultra generic and I can certainly see why it's faded Into Obscurity nobody talks about this one anymore and I think for good reason now I didn't hate it but there was nothing and I mean nothing to excite me about it at all either at number 12 I have psychic pizza delivery service now this is certainly a family way almost deduction Style game I should try to make your way around this town pick up a pizza and then deliver it to a certain

house however you'd know nothing at what's going on on this map at the beginning of the game and as you go through your turns you are learning and you know unraveling the map as you go and all the mean time there is going to be someone who's the games master who's going to be telling you what you're walking into so bear in mind that somebody when you play this game is going to have to be the game master and not actually get involved in the in the actual game itself now I think that itself is probably the Twist on the game it can be quite funny at times if you know that somebody's going in the wrong direction and their pizzas on the other side of the map it's also quite cool that you have you're playing on the same map as everybody else or your opponents so if you end up piecing your knowledge together you get a bigger understanding of what's going on now I also thought there was some imbalance here there's some Power Cards that come into play some of them are very very good and some of them are pretty terrible so that felt a bit swingy at times and ultimately it just felt a little bit lackluster the decision space was pretty much negligible so therefore I couldn't really recommend it at number 11 I have Autobarn which might be one of my biggest disappointments of this year this is a Fabio lupiano design along with Nestor mangoni who are two brilliant designers or at least they've had some great games come out in the past this one for me was a convoluted mess of a game as you are playing these color-coded cards you're building the Autobahn you've got this pickup and delivery mechanism going on where you're collecting goods and trying to drop them off to a certain cities You're Building service stations to get income as other people pass your service stations and so on all of it on paper sounds fantastic

to me but it was so restrictive by the to the point where if you wanted to do an action with a certain card you could not do it again unless you wasted your whole time picking all your cards back up um and that for me it felt too slow it felt plodding and it took a long time to get anything done I also thought The pacing and Tempo with this game was a little bit off because you would never get those dopamine hits in terms of getting points here and there it was all end game scoring and that was a fluctuating thing because you need to have people on these matching councils in order to be eligible for scoring certain things at any time so it was a yeah a bit fiddly for me there were some rules that could have easily been streamlined and ironed out of the design process but hey I seem to be in a minority with this one I think it's generally been well received but I certainly think it would have benefited from having things removed from the game now check out my review if you are interested in this one because I do go into a lot more detail as to why I did not get on with this one but hey for now Autobahn is at number 11. at number 10 I have Airlines Europe so this is like a step above a game like Ticket to Ride as you are building these routes out this one you're doing with these with airplanes of course and when you build these routes up by spending money you are going to be able to take a share in one of the airlines now when it gets to certain points in this deck of cards there's going to be a scoring phase and depending on Whose Airlines or what islands are the strongest they are are going to pay out points depending on who's got the most shares in those companies that's pretty much the extent

of the game it was a very um quite quite a streamlined experience there wasn't too much going on here but I do generally like games that use stocks and share systems and this one I suppose was almost like a proxy to a to an area majority mechanism rather than the actual stocks and shares but it worked what it was I would play this one I played this one again with no issues at all relatively quick I thought there was a little bit of a um a speed bug when it came to the scoring phase and you had to go you know meticulously go through all the different airlines and dish out the points accordingly that took a bit long was a little bit tedious but the gameplay itself was absolutely fine I have no issue with it and I can see why family weight Gamers do enjoy this one at number nine I have Ready Set bet which is a real-time horse racing betting game as throughout the game you're going to be rolling dice rapidly when you roll pairs of dice you are going to give these horses a boost and those boosts are going to be a lot bigger if they are combinations of dice that aren't rolled very often so for example the twos and threes get a big push if you're on the back to back as do the 11s and twelves and just to counteract the odds of rolling you know the sevens more commonly for example um this one is quite exciting in this in the fact that you are doing things in real time of course uh the earlier you put bets in the better odds you're going to get but of course the risk factor is going to be a lot greater um and you know what when I first played this one I was pretty damn impressed by it because I hadn't seen anything quite like it before it's a very familiar theme and setting I suppose you can play this with pretty much anybody and

they're going to understand what you're doing with this one however if I'm honest I did feel like the novelty Factor did wear off pretty rapidly and my incentive to play it did no dwindle very quickly um I would play this one again no question about it but I'll probably save it for a family occasions big events that kind of thing and where you have a more party atmosphere and you have those higher player accounts because I do think that it's going to be an event Style game and probably you're going to get tired of it very quickly if you keep playing it in quick succession but hey it's fine it does what it says on the tin I suppose um but it's not my favorite of the racing genre I'd probably rather play something like a long shot the dice game at number eight I have Terracotta Army so this was a game I managed to play at a games Club recently and I'm glad I did because I was on the fence to buy this one for my own collection and I'm rather glad that I did not and that's not because I don't like the game I think the game was pretty solid um but I did have some issues with it now this is a worker placement Style game as you're placing your workers of course on this action wheel or around the action wheel and the action wheel is going to show three different actions you can take however that wheel is divided up into three sections meaning that you can actually spend money to rotate that wheel which will manipulate the actions you can take and that's useful because you cannot share the same spot as somebody else at least without a larger worker which you have to invest in so it gives you the freedom to do actions that you want to do even if you're blocked out of other regions but you of course have to pay for it and

then what you're essentially trying to do is you're trying to collect clay um clay is used to build statues in this big grid and when you build these statues in this grid you're going to be aiming towards the kind of end of round objectives so for example in the first round I might say that every uh who's got the majority of statues in the bottom left-hand corner of the grid is going to get the most points um then it's going to be who's got the most Archer statues who's going to get the most points that kind of thing and you can think ahead because of that it's all public information you can you think you know what I'm not going to do well in this category so therefore I'm going to start working on this category Etc I also like this mechanism that you have either clay being your main resource but when you collect it it's going to be wet but as the game develops and when it goes from round to round that Clay is going to dry up and be useless to you and you're going to have to spend a whole action in order to wet that clay to be able to use it to build stuff now I actually do like a lot of the concepts here but I think that when it came to the era majority there was way too much going on like for example you would have to score the objectives then you would score in the rows and columns where these kind of Inspector pieces were and then you would end up scoring for groups there'll be other statues that you'd put a new original score for rows and columns you'd do other ones which will score all around them and all of this is going on at once so when it came to actually cashing out the scoring it was a very meticulous very tedious process that went on way too long fiddly and convoluted like literally congested board

which became a bit of an issue for me personally and yeah I just thought it could have definitely benefited from taking a few of those majority rules out from the game now maybe you disagree me from that but just looking objectively I thought it was just too much going on with that part of the game the rest of it was absolutely fine but that part yeah just just too much going on at number seven I have loading so loading is a quirky little card game as in real time you are trying to skim through this deck of cards to pick out a number which is kind of the closest number to the one you've previously played and as soon as you pick out a card you're going to pass that deck onto another player because there's always going to be one player without a deck of cards and what you're trying to do is essentially do this as quick as you can to try and get as many points as you can by creating as few gaps as I can I suppose in those sequence of numbers but because those numbers are distributed so randomly you don't know what you're going to get in those decks but there's also another Twist on this game where you can actually play cards other people's stacks as long as you play the next card in sequence and if you do you get to snatch one of these kind of bonus cards which have quite a few points on them so there's this constant flow of cards flying around the table um it's very exciting it takes about five minutes to play and it's just a different Unique Style game it's kind of like the mind but competitively and definitely a lot more amped up and a lot more high energy um check this one out if you're not aware of it because I wasn't aware of it it was kindly passed on to me by

heshette and I'm glad they did because this is definitely a niche Style game I'll happily bring out in these larger groups and you know even plays at smaller groups but I'm really excited to see how it plays with those again that higher player count at number six I have vegetable stock now this is an ultra simple commodity speculation Style game with a touch of drafting to it as you have I think it's five or six different vegetable types all of which relates to this sliding scale stock market which means that at any time each of these Goods is worth a certain amount of money but that is going to fluctuate as the game goes on and the way that it's manipulated is done through a drafting system so there's going to be a number of cards out on the table each round equal to the players plus one and then in turn you're going to take these cards which are going to have a different combination of vegetables on them and the card remaining in the center is going to increase the value of the um of the vegetables of that card but when it gets right to the top it's going to sink back to the bottom again so it's got this timing exercise where you want to of course make sure that your vegetables are going to be worth the most money when it comes to the end of the game this is another game that takes 10 to 15 minutes to play it almost reminds me of a game like Botswana or Wildlife Wildlife Safari where again that Tempo in the pacing is a huge factor and you want to time it and just end the game at just the right time so that you get the most um you know the most money from what you've collected it's very Charming it's very cute and I like it quite a bit so that is vegetable stock at number six

okay so let's get into the top five games now and this is where my recommendations truly do begin so at number five I have heroba which is an area majority Style game based on Sudoku so you're gonna have this grid of tiles and each of these tiles is going to be divided further into two sections and on your turn you are going to be deploying one of your player pieces into one of these Gardens as long as that player piece is on a row or con where a previous piece of yours was already placed and then what you're trying to do is to have the majorities as in the highest total value of your numbers in those Gardens because then you'll score points equal to the size of those Gardens however there are several restrictions in this game where you cannot have the same number token in the same row column all the same Garden as yourself or another player so as the game develops the game becomes or the board becomes much tighter and your options do quickly Whittle away now I also like this factor that if you end up deploying low value tokens next to these koi fish and you can collect these tokens and deploy them in gardens as long as there's a space which will double the points output of those Gardens this is a very cool game it feels unlike anything else I've played before extremely sophisticated um again there's no nothing you could take away or add to this game to make it better in my opinion and I'd highly recommend you check out my review of this one because it's a strange game to rank because although it doesn't have

those extreme highs of a lot of my favorite games there's nothing I can really critique about it because it is you know perfect for what it does really and it left me very impressed at number four I have a photograph also known as wind the film now this is a small box card game a set collection style game which is pretty agonizing to play as you do again have a lot of restrictions in what you're trying to do here so essentially the objective of the game is to try and collect these sets of cards and play them in numerical order either from low to high or high to low but you want to have a small of gaps as possible in these sequences because if you end up having a gap more than three cards then you actually end up losing points but the way you acquire these cards is interesting because you draft them from this almost like a grid of cards and the way you acquire them you have to put them in your hand in a specific order so you cannot adjust things whilst it in your hands so everything remains in place so when you acquire cards you put them to the front of your hand but when you play cards you play them from the back of your hand but another Twist on this one is that if you end up say picking two cards up it means you have to play two cards so you can be a bit risky and take several cars and have to play Separate cards or you can play a bit more conservatively take one and play one but if you do that you're probably not going to win because you're not being as efficient as you can um it's definitely unlike anything else I've played it's definitely my style of card game I like these things with low rules overheads but I'm going to

constantly leave you in anguish from start to finish with this one I I think this game is great it's fantastic and I can see this one climbing further because it is really impressive at number three I have hamburg which is the re-implementation of the classic Stefan fell game Bruges now this this one though is a step and fall game of course it feels unlike any other of his designs it's a card driven engine building Style game that has a multi-use card system and everything in this game is color coded and when you end up drafting these cards you can use those cards to kind of fight off threats which can hurt you if you ignore them long enough you can use them to acquire money you can use them to build buildings you can use them to build these walls which will get you end game points to be really focus on them and you really do have to know how to kind of optimally utilize those cards in your hand and you'll often find yourself zigging and zagging at certain points based on different things that are happening in the game it's a very Dynamic game where you have to adjust on the Fly and if you are of a certain type of gamer where you like a lot of control and a lot of autonomy in your games that I think sometimes in this one you do have to roll with the punches and bear in mind that luck can be a factor in this one because there are a lot of cards in it and getting the cards you want is probably just not gonna happen again you're gonna have to work with what you have here now I think once you get in the mindset of that this game is extremely enjoyable I thought it was fantastic and each time I've played it I've enjoyed it more than the last one and that is because I've got into that

mindset of embracing the Carnage and again rolling with those punches but I'm so glad I finally managed to get this one played because I've been trying to head hunt Bruges for probably five years now and I've not been able to find the copy but now it is widely available in the form of Hamburg at number two I have Mara Kesh which is another step and fall game and this is a brand new design so no remake here now this is a sprawling game it's huge there's lots going on and it's essentially a bunch of mini games I think it's 12 in total which will synergize with each other and the way this game works is quite interesting as you are using these tokens you're putting them in this Cube Tower and depending on what filter was through is the actions that you you can take because some of those cubes will get caught in the cube Tower and then you are essentially drafting at these cashews which are the tokens putting them on your player board which will increase your engine to do certain things so the more you focus on a certain action it means the more you're going to start steamrolling and becoming more efficient and stronger more powerful at doing that specific thing and then what you're trying to do is you're trying to climb his tracks you are you know enhancing your ability to harvest resources you're getting these energy um engine building style um tiles from the main board which will let you break Rules and Things um you are trying to unlock end game scoring bonuses just a ton of you know eurocentric mechanisms all kind of mashed in to one game but I do like that core system of distracting what you want

to pick the actions you want I love that that forward progression of always feeling more powerful I do feel like I've almost kind of scratched the surface of this game and I'm very excited to see what else this game has to offer because at the moment I like it a lot and I think I could like it even more and finally at number one my favorite game of the month is Teleton so Teleton is the latest Game of the board and dice T-Series designed by Daniel itashini and this one has a co-design of Simone Luciani so those two for me are two of the absolute Godfathers when it comes to board game designs at least in modern day era this game is up there with their best designs so it's another dice drafting Style game and a Twist on this one is that when you draft these die the pit value is important because that is going to indicate the amount of resources you are going to get but the reverse side of that as in the accumulative value that adds up to seven is going to be the action strength you can take so for example if I was to take six resources I would get a one strength action if I was to take a three resources then I'd get a strength four action and so on and then what you're trying to do is that you are trying to travel around this map of Europe you're trying to set up these trade houses to be eligible for certain scoring during certain points in the game you are trying to set up these churches and donate to them to get more points as you go and you're fulfilling contracts you're building up your own player board to build up a bit of an engine as well so lots going on here I don't think it does anything terribly

new maybe apart from that die strapping mechanism but the way everything harmonizes is just fantastic this game has tremendous potential you string up string along these very powerful turns as whatever you do in this game you kind of have the option to pick up these bonus tokens which you can use at any time so even if you're doing a pretty basic action you can always bolster them or divert your strategy or tactics based on the tiles you pick up along the way um loads of fun a very satisfying game pretty easy to explain actually considering it is a mid to Mid heavyweight Euro and I was very impressed and I'm happy to say that because I think that over the last couple of years the Borden die Series has kind of gone off the rails a little bit it diverted away from the games that I really used to love and this one has got it right back on track to me and I'm now excited again to see what they have in the future so I have no doubt this game is going to be in my top five of the year maybe top three maybe even my favorite game so that is Teleton at number one so there we go that's another month gone hopefully you've enjoyed this video let me know what you think of these games and let me know what your game of the month is if you haven't joined the video please be sure to hit like and subscribe to the channel but for everybody else I'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye

Progress saved