Skip to main content
Loading video...

19 Board Games Ranked - Episode 4

Transcript 30:30

hey everybody today i'm talking about all the new to me games i've played in the month of august in 2021 and i'm gonna rank them from my least favorite to my most favorite so this is a bump a month for me i played a lot of games mostly because it was the uk games expo where i obviously acquire a lot of games um so naturally i've played a lot more this time so i've got 19 games to talk about and i'll try to rattle through them as quickly as i can so let's get started at number 19. so my least favorite game i've played this month or news to me game i've played this month is saboteur now this is a pretty simple almost uh semi-cooperative but you've got the element of being a traitor where some people or this one team is going to be laying these cards out trying to build these tunnels to get to these cars are pre-laid out onto the table and you're basically trying to find the car that place face down that has the gold on the other side and the saboteur or saboteurs are trying to basically catch the other players off guard and try to start diverting those tracks off and prevent them getting to that gold that's pretty much the just the game uh if you're familiar with a game like bandido this one has a lot of similarities to that one however this one had a lot of take that and pretty much textbook as you'd expect it take that where you just smash a card in front of somebody to stop them from taking any actions i found that quite frustrating i found uh to take that element a bit a bit jarring i just don't enjoy that that kind of gameplay and ultimately i thought the game went on a

bit too long and it just isn't my style of game so unfortunately not a big fan of saboteur the next game at number 18 is fairy tale inn so this is actually a new game by i believe it's paolo mori who designed this one who is generally a designer i enjoy he's made a lot of great designs this one is a twist on the connect four game you know the classic game where you're dropping um tokens into this vertical board and trying to line things up however in this one instead of being so abstracted you are placing these different fairy tale characters and getting points in different ways you're blocking people off and i'm trying to get the most points um purely two player game i think it works okay um however i still think there's a twist on that connect4 mechanism that could be better this one i think maybe should be more tailored towards children and i think it probably is so uh not the kind of gameplay not the kind of weight that i'm looking for but really well produced looks great and um but yeah unfortunately the gameplay was a bit shallow for me personally at number 17 i have silver and gold so this is actually quite a revered flip and write style game as you are reviewing a card and then you actually have cards yourself which you are drawing on trying to fill in all the gap types by um filling out these tetra shapes and trying to fill these cards up and when you fill the cards up you get points there are different ways to score as well such as acquiring coins and different things like that um it was it

was okay i mean i was expecting a bit more from this one to be honest and i thought the decisions in this game were a bit too obvious and it almost played itself so i never really found myself um stressing over the decision i'm gonna make thinking of what i'm gonna do it was pretty much just going through the motions reveal the card and um taking the most optimal thing off so unfortunately just didn't quite do it with me and i think there's a lot better role than wright games out there and um this one was slightly subpar so i wouldn't really be looking forward to playing this one much more or all recommending it so uh at number 17 that's silver and gold and number 16 is a really strange game and i'd almost hesitate to call this a board game this is a game called maze scape so this is um a fairly new game i think this is from 2021 so new release and it's more of a puzzle more of a a solo puzzle as you have this book and this book has all these different tracks that you're trying to go down unless you flip this book over and you turn pages and overlap things that track's going to change and the idea is you're trying to fulfill these objectives by collecting different items and basically trying to get to the finish it's a really difficult thing to do i really struggled with this although although i enjoyed it there's a lot of fun um it's just my brain isn't quite wired to deal with this kind of thing and i know i was terrible at it but a really fresh and unique idea and you know what if i was alone and just had a bit of spare time then i would certainly consider just getting this this one out having a little play around and um and trying to solve the puzzle so at number 15 i have cluster now cluster

is a bit of a silly one this is a um this is a dexterity game that uses magnets so as simple as it gets you're just going to get this big rope all this basically this shoelace that's tied together on each end you're going to place it on the table and the objective is that you're going to have a number of magnets in your hand and these are really robust powerful magnets and you're going to place them inside this rope taking turns one after another and the idea is that you're trying to stop the magnets from kind of connecting together and attaching to one another because if you do you're going to get them into your hands and this is a shedding style game where you want to be the first person to get rid of all your magnets um you know before the other people do but there's some really cool little things you can do here by using the polarities by pushing magnets out the way trying to create a bit of space for yourself to get your magnets down and it's a bit of silly fun and it actually works a lot better than you think it would do a bit of a novelty factor and you know maybe the long term legs aren't there but i enjoyed my my plays of cluster at number 14 i have a pretty uh prolific game and quite a quite an iconic game i suppose with alien frontiers so alien frontiers was i believe one of the first kickstarter games out there and this was one of the first dice placement games as well i'm kind of leading the uh leading the charge on that style of game because there's a lot of dice placement games out there now this one is almost a gateway plus level game so it's not terribly complex but it does have some gamer systems in there where you are rolling a bunch of dyes you're allocating them in different spaces in a

worker placement style method trying to collect resources with the aim of trying to convert those resources into these colonies you place them onto the uh onto the planet to try and get area majority bonuses and things i like the fact that when you do control certain regions you'd get a unique benefit um and it had a quite a nice forward trajectory in this game as you're acquiring more and more dice spending more and more resources getting more things done in your turn is a pretty quick game you know you can get some done in about an hour um i think i think what kind of stopped us from getting a higher on the track was that i think this one is starting to age a bit there's a lot of things in this game that's been done a thousand times and i think this one didn't really have that extra something to make it stand out amongst the sea of dice placement games or work replacement games and i appreciate that at the time you know if i was looking at this game through um you know through the eyes of the time this game was released then i'd have a completely different perspective on this one but comparing it to games coming out in you know 2021 now i think this one's just a little bit lackluster however perfectly fine i've got certainly got no complaints about the gameplay it's got no issues um it's perfectly functional it works well it plays very smoothly but i said it just didn't have that extra something special and number 13 i have fiesta de la muerte so this is a pretty unknown party game you know i like my party games this one is almost a twist on the just one style um you know mechanism where you are gonna everyone's gonna be

allocated a person that normally they're they could be fictional they could be uh non-fictional uh people from history anything and you're going to be writing a word on these um dry erase boards to connect with that person and then you're going to be shifting your board from person to person they're going to keep on associating words with the previous word and to the point where everyone's exhausted and done done all their um done all their writing you got to place them into the center of the table and then you're going to try and match those words from the dry erase boards to the original people trying to think of the process that would have happened as the word association is going along the way um i think this one worked a lot better than i thought it would be it's simple good fun and i think if you're maybe exhausted of a game like just one i want to try something just a little bit different and have a slight um slight twist on that format then i would i would suggest giving a fiesta de la muerte a try uh really well produced as well and it's just again just simple wholesome fun at number 12 i have village green so this is by pier sylvester i believe who did the king is dead this one is uh one of those simple puzzling style game as you have you we're trying to build i believe it's a four by four grid of cards on the axes of the cards you're going to have different scoring criteria and then on the other squares you're basically trying to play these different trees and things um in order to score as many points as you can by trying to synergize the trees you're building with the scoring mechanisms or the scoring criteria on the vertical and horizontal

axis very simple there's a lot of games like this one i think this one get this one is slightly more restrictive than most of those games because when you play these cards you are restricted to either matching one of the symbols on them with with the um orthogonal cards to it or matching a color and that can be quite difficult at times you can find yourself backed into a bit of a corner where you can't get the cards you want played but i appreciate that that's what the fun is um no complaints about this one either a bit like um a bit like alien frontiers i think this one might lack something special that little something extra to make it stand out amongst the crowd but still perfectly pleasant for what it is and i think this one is a really nice game to play solo and um you know it's certainly gonna you're gonna get the full experience at any play account with village greens at number 11 i have meadow now meadow is kind of being popular this month and it's got a bit of buzz it's been in the hotness on bgg for quite a few weeks now i think mostly because this game is stunningly beautiful it's a wonderfully illustrated game where you are trying to acquire these cards with different wildlife on them different critters and insects and things and you are basically trying to play these cards in front of you and all these cards will have symbols on them and when you're building new cards you are going to have to kind of use the symbols of the ones you've already built in order to build that one so it's all about matching symbols getting prerequisites for cards getting as many points as you can and there's some racing to get some symbols down uh it flows really nicely i like the way that you actually draft the cards in the

first place because you have these little tokens and you're basically placing them onto this 4x4 grid which shows kind of the card that you can take by saying if i place this token down i'll place i click the card four in or or two in and then you would like count along how many cards you get and pick that one up and things there's some good competition in getting the cards that you want because everyone is drafting from the same pool so there's something you get some good tension and you've got to prioritize things to get the best cards but i liked it it plays very nicely again a kind of a gateway plus style game but i kind of worry about the replayability of this one i think it would have benefited more from an extra layer of strategy and something just something extra as well just to just to kind of uh give you something else to to to think about something else to a different direction to pull you in because you are pretty much doing the same thing from start to finish the arc of the game isn't tremendous although the cars do change halfway throughout the game um but it is good it's pleasant but again i'm looking forward to seeing maybe if there'll be an expansion or something for this one because i think it could benefit from an extra layer of complexity at number 10 i have can't stop so this is a pretty classic saxon design a push your luck style game as you're rolling a bunch of dice and then you are putting them in in pairs and then you are basically climbing these tracks um by the numbers that you've rolled but once you've locked into a certain number and you're going

to be locked into three numbers at a time if you don't roll one of those numbers then you go bust and i like the fact that you can kind of keep crawling up and then just call it stop and try to lock in your place meaning it's easier or you've got to climb fewer steps in the future rounds to get to the top of these columns and i also like the race aspect of this game because i know a lot of a lot of pushy luck style games don't have a race element to the to them and uh camp stop has a really strong race element which i enjoy i think it suffers a little bit with down time as you are waiting for other people to take their turns but overall it's a fun experience and another one of those games i'd never really say no to playing because i enjoy pushing luck games it plays relatively quickly and you can teach this one to almost anybody because it's so familiar and really simple to get to the table at number nine i have four gardens so four gardens a beautiful game another very recently i think this one came out in 2020 but it's only hit um in the uk in 2021 this one is a pretty simple contract fulfillment style game as you are collecting resources and then you're building these cards which kind of depicts a panoramic painting so you are collecting these different cards matching them together and i like the scoring method in this game because whenever you build one of these cards you move us your one of your score tokens along a certain color track but when you build the next card in that panoramic not only do you score that card but you score all the ones previous to it as well so you can get these real cool um kind of

almost combining mechanism or these these kind of um compounding scoring where you climb up several tracks at once especially when you build those bigger cards and it's pretty good fun and i suppose the twist in this game is the way you're actually acquiring your cards or your resources in the first place because you have a very strict capacity on what you can hold in your storage and when you play one of these cards to collect resources you either get them from this pagoda which is broken up into four different sections um or depicting a different resources and you're collecting them either from top to bottom or bottom to top and obviously as soon as you hit that that capacity then you can't take any more which can be really restrictive but in a good way so you have to kind of manipulate this pagoda trying to make sure you get the best resources at the best time and keep that constant flow of keeping resources getting into your supply and on to your cards to get them built without any wastage works pretty well a bit like meadow i would have liked to have seen an extra layer of complexity of um of gaps to this game because it's pretty simple you know you're just collecting resources building cards collection resources building cards whereas if there was something else to consider i think it would give the games the game more legs but i appreciate this one is another game tailored towards towards gateway plus gamers at number eight i have blitzkrieg so this is another paolo mora game this one is a strictly two-player game based on world war ii so it's described as world war ii in 20 minutes

this one one player of course takes the control of the axes one is the the um the allies and you are taking turns playing these tokens which are drawn blindly from a bag unless you have three of them available any but you you know you are you're drawing from the back at least to put them into your common supply to be used so you've got some randomness there but still a little bit of autonomy in what you actually play and you're basically playing playing these tokens onto these different theaters and you've got your kind of land units you've got your your kind of nautical units and you've got your air units as well which are like wilds and you're using these to place them on the board and kind of shifting this token up or down on this track so it's basically multiple games of tug-of-war and the idea is you're trying to not only benefit from the token that you're playing because the more powerful ones move that spot further to your to your direction but also considering which area you're playing it in and which spot you're playing on because you get different bonuses such as you know boosting your power or i'm drawing more tokens from your bag or forcing your opponent to discard tokens and it works really well so simple so smooth has some good tension again like multiple games of tug-of-war which is quite interesting because normally you only play you know most tug of all games are based on one one operation and not several going on at once and this one is a good twist on that there's also good replayability in the fact that you've got the kind of real basic layer of the board but you can flip the board over and play a more ramped up complex level where you've got lots of different things going up at once and one kind of one battle is going to affect the other battles and that's really cool so yeah

happy with this one i was into minds whether to give it a shield of quality i think maybe longevity-wise it could sneak up into that shield of quality level but at the moment it's just on the cusp and um i'm just narrowly avoiding giving it a shield of quality but that is very much likely to change so let's get in to the top seven which starts with all the games with my shield of quality so at number seven the first game with my shield of quality for the month is a surprise of the uh certainly one of the biggest surprises of the month this is bastille so bastille is a uh a game by queen games which normally i actually might well my actual perception of queen games is extremely high i think i've never really had a dud with queen games i like the production i like the way they make the games accessible and digestible but still having some meat on the bones there and but still is a good example of that so this is a pretty standard worker placement style game which normally i shy away from however i think functionally this game just does everything really well as you're giving a bunch of these um these tokens you're placing on the board but these tokens also have different levels so you've got your level ones you've got your level twos and so on and one of the spots on the board is actually to upgrade them to the next level which means when you place them you're going to get better benefits such as getting discounts on cards or you know taking more powerful versions of actions and even trumping the uh initiative to get these certain spots done over the other players so not only are you trying to get everything done you also want to make sure you've

got a constant influx of upgrading your workers which reminds me of one of my favorite games actually called called lancaster this one as well you are doing a lot of basic things you know collecting collecting cards for set collection bonuses but also these cards have multiple uses such as giving you or having flags on them which which will give you powerful bonuses at the end of each round uh also you've got endgame bonuses that you're working towards you're trying to collect these cards and equip them with weapons you've got this kind of priority tracks as well there's a lot of tension in this game which i think is completely essential with a working placement game i don't really like it when games are when working placement games in particular are really loosely goosey and you have always have loads of options and you're not really worried about what your opponents are doing this one certainly doesn't have that it has a lot of tension you want to get to everywhere all at once um and you have to really prioritize things carefully so i'm really happy with this one i think it's a lot of fun it was way way better than i thought it was i'm i'm concerned about the replayability of it i think maybe the initial impressions might supersede the long-term enjoyment at number six i have watergate so watergate another strictly two player game this one is by matthias kramer who actually is one of my favorite designers this one of course is based on the watergate scandal one player is playing nixon one person is playing the the press or the editor and the idea is that we're trying to play these cars in order to move these different things up and down this track so it's another tug-of-war style game you are either trying to collect these momentum tokens

and which is a winning criteria for nixon or give bonuses to the to the editor player you also want to get this initiative token because it gives you more options to play on your turn but also you want to be collecting these evidence tokens which are going to be placed onto the center or into the main board and the idea is that the editor is trying to get these different informants um but to to nixon by building this chain of evidence but nixon is trying to block off all those paths by collecting that evidence and putting it face down a real tense game has some real nice thematic ties a lot of um you know a lot of great setting in this game a lot of good flavor text and good um just good history and uh i think this one plays extremely smoothly it's uh again it's really tense you can try and catch your opponent off guard by playing little things in the right order you've got to be careful about when to use these cards for their ability or for that or for the uh the value of the card in order to move those um move those tokens up or down that track because when you use the ability on them which is normally very powerful um it actually makes you discard the card from the game which is a big thing so uh in terms of a tug-of-war style game watergate is certainly up there with the best of them and um something that i'd certainly uh recommend to players who like that style of game are very very good and um i enjoyed this one a lot at number five another strictly two-player game so normally i don't play this many two-player games but um for some reason this month i have got a lot of the table this one is considered one of the greats this is seven wonders

jewel so believe it or not i wasn't the biggest fan of the standard seven wonders game i thought it was a bit a bit lackluster uh i'd much much preferred seven wonders duel so this one i love the drafting system as you have this almost a pyramid of cards some of them are face up some of them are face down and i like the fact when you draft one of these cards you can potentially reveal ones behind it giving your opponents more options so you've got to be careful about that kind of push and pull what you're going to reveal to your opponents what you're going to leave them this has got some good resource management as you're collecting resource cards to buy new cars to get more points you've got to try and compete militarily as well as you're collecting these military cards which again works in this push-up sorry a tug-of-war style system where you're trying to um pull the or push the uh the military token as far as you can to your opponent's side because it makes some cost it costs them money and it puts them under pressure to fight back uh you're also trying to compete in science because if you get the science victory by collecting these different cards then you can win instantly um but oh yeah this one flows so wonderfully i love the little tableau you get to build up it has a great game arc because it's broken up into three distinct phases the first one basically being uh you know your basic resources and then you start getting into the ways you're gonna get points in the later rounds so i i love the game arc of this game it plays so wonderfully smoothly i only takes about 20 to 30 minutes to play uh and a lot of depth here considering the the relative ease of the play

at number four i have miyabi so miyabi is a kind of a family plus style game um by haber so how about known for their family games this one is by michael keisling who is one of the the best designers of the modern age this is a tile placement game a very puzzly style one where you are placing these polyominos onto the board and you're trying to place certain symbols in certain rows because you have a very strict restriction on what you can place in certain in certain spots and as soon as you place these tokens all these tiles you're gonna get victory points but you've got to be careful to build a foundation because you can actually build vertically in this game as well uh and when you build these cards on higher levels you're gonna get those points multiplied by the level they're on and i love that mechanism it really does ring bells of a game called number nine which i enjoyed and this one for me is a much better version of number nine it has a lot of different modules you can try in this game to try different setups and different strategies and different things to try so many different things pulling you in different directions so each tile placement is very important and it's just so much fun a place in about 45 minutes uh stupidly simple to explain but still has a lot of decision space here and those kind of games are generally always two thumbs up from me and um you know the more i play this one the more i'm enjoying it it's just absolute blast to play and another hidden gem i suppose not too many people talk about this one but i think they

should be that is me abbey at number three so my third best game of the month is smartphone inc so this is a wonderful design and you talk about being streamlined this one is streamlined to a t as you are basically trying to get as much money as you can by producing and selling smartphones so i really like economic style games and this one certainly is that and i like some of the mechanisms in this game as well particularly that core mechanism of you have these these tiles and you're basically trying to overlap them on one another to determine which actions you can take throughout the round such as you know producing phones or raising or lowering your lowering your prices or investing in new technology and i love the fact that you are trying to exploit the markets to your best ability to get the most points out of them you can try and undercut your opponents if you're competing for the same customers but if you have unique technology that nobody else has you can actually afford to ramp up your prices because nobody else is competing with you and the customers will flock to you has some really good decisions and i again i i really did appreciate the the functionality of this game and how well it was broken down into different segments which made it so digestible and considering the the amazing depth here lots of things to consider it was just it flowed like you know it flowed wonderfully and um i was really blown away with this one

actually i wasn't i wasn't quite sure what to expect it's not normally the style of theme i go for i tend to like my you know my dusty old euros this one has a much more modern much more slick design a slick theme and you know what once i got it to the table it worked for me so yeah very impressed by smartphone inc so the top two games this month actually are the only two games that got my shield or my or my elite shield so this is the best of the best games i thought were absolutely outstanding number two was terra mystica so terra mystica i know this one is another game that's massively revered this one is an amazing engine building game as you have your unique faction with the unique abilities and you're basically trying to terraform this map into your own territory which you can live in and you're building buildings you're trying to get victory points different ways you have a great degree of engine building here as the more buildings you place onto the map you're unlocking more and more income as the rounds progress you're climbing tracks you're kind of synergizing the current round with the tracks to get different bonuses this is pretty heavy in a pretty involved game however once you've got that rules over that steep rules curve that learning curve the game flowed really well the depth really did start to unravel and reveal itself as the game went on because initially i was thinking you know this is going to be a struggle you know in the first round i'm not getting much done but towards this later rounds the game ramps up wonderfully

so many great decisions uh a real tight game with careful resource management being careful when to upgrade things managing your funds carefully exploiting your player abilities and your own unique unique characters and um you know what this was almost a game that i can't really fault and it certainly deserves to be considered one of the best games of all time because in my opinion it is that good and my number one game of the month now this is going to be a shock it was a shock to me is mandala so mandala another strictly two player game and this one when i got to the table i didn't really know much about it i know it had some good uh word of mouth and some good um some good buzz amongst you know two player fanatics people who enjoy two-player games um and by god is this game clever so this is one of the slickest one of the smoothest and probably the best two-player game i've ever played so this is a strange game as you have these cards of different types and different colors and you're using these kinds of different things so first off you're using them in order to bid for other cards because when you acquire these cards they go into your scoring row and in the order in which you acquire these cards ramps up how much they're worth so the first cards you require are only worth one point and then two points and three points are four points and the other player is also doing the same thing with the same cards so even though i might have a car that's worth one to me uh it could be worth five points to my opponent so i've got to be really careful about not to allow my opponents

to have those and you're using your kind of your cars to bid for other cards you've got to be careful what you're giving away uh it's absolutely fantastic it has some great restrictions as you are you can only play a certain color in a certain kind of role each round and it's it's one of those games you really have to try and i recommend you check out my my review of this one and initially i gave this one my shield of quality um but since playing it more and more um i've just been blown away with it and it's instantly shot up to my elite shield you know i started off giving about eight out of ten now i happily give give this one about a nine out of ten um and maybe might even go up from there so i cannot stress enough how good this game is some good production maybe maybe not for everybody um artwork not the best but the gameplay is up there with the best it feels like a classic game and um i think this one is really going to stand the test of time and it's gonna you know if there's ever a game that i thought would be a lifestyle game for me one that i would play for the rest of my life it might just be mandala because this one is just incredible and um i don't know how this one isn't being talked about more often because it is simply incredible so that concludes uh this this month roundup so hopefully there's something on here that's caught your attention a really good month in general uh if you have enjoyed this video please hit like and subscribe to my channel if you haven't done so already additionally if you want to support the channel i do have a patreon page which i'll leave the

link in the show notes and for everyone else i'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye

Progress saved