Skip to main content
Loading video...

Responding to HOT Takes from You: 6-Sided Dice are the WORST

Transcript 1:25:21

Good morning everybody. I'm Tom Bessel.

I'm Z Garcia.

I'm Camila.

I'm Chris. Yay.

Welcome to Hot Takes,

the Christmas edition. Besides the Christmas edition, there's nothing about Christmas in any of these hot takes.

Why, Tom? That's a missed opportunity.

Who thinks Christmas is overrated? [clears throat]

Nope. [snorts] Yeah, we're watch Charlie Brown.

We're going to eat ham for the 90th time again.

Enough with the ham already. My Christmas is

Let the pigs rebel.

Shrimp all the time.

Really? I had cereal.

That's a hot take apparently in your in your Q&A. I saw that somebody was like chipper. Oh,

how dare you eat shrimp in during Christmas. Like, what a weird thing to be upset about Tom having shrimp.

All righty. Well, welcome to Hot Takes. Um, this is Hot Takes at You Email me um at tomdar.com and you still can realize that we have a lot. We're not going to get to all of them today. Um, there's many. I'm not going to do all of them. And also, as a side note, if you do a hot take, send me your hot takes. Don't say, "Here's a quote I found on the internet. What do you think about it?" judging pieces.

Um, so yeah, and this is meant to be not too serious at these. I I hope.

Um, so let's get we're just going to jump right into these.

Go, man. Let's wreck some rules online from Jason L. And he says, "Bard games are board games and video games are video games." To clarify, he says,

"Yeah, that's a statement.

This is going to be unpopular. Um, but if a video game crosses over to a board game and it's good, it lifts the board game community. If a board game becomes a video game, it's just lost in a sea of video games. He's saying, "If I want to play a video game, I'd rather play Borderlands than Wingspan digitally." He thinks it's a waste of time for board games to be in the video game arena.

Have we had a board game that becomes I don't I want to say, have we had a board game that becomes an actual video game, not a digital implementation of the board game? So, because the Wingspan one, I would call that a digital version of the board game, but it's not like they took Osworn and made it a big video game where you're open world and you're going and doing this stuff. Like, have we had a cross like that?

Didn't Wasn't there a Gloom Haven version? That was No, I don't think we ever had anything that isn't just I The closest thing is uh the closest thing is Elder S had a video game that wasn't Elder Sign really. It was sort of Elder Sign. Oh, I forgot about that.

Zombide had a video game that wasn't really Zombicide. It was some trash version of Zombicide.

Uh, they're saying Tainted Grail. That's right. That's a good one.

Tainted Grail has a video game.

Yeah, that's right. Okay.

It's kind of like a bad version of Oblivion or something.

So, I [clears throat] think good from all of these.

So, I think that's the thing is we haven't had a good one yet.

What I disagree with is I think board games put in a video game form are fantastic. Yeah. I I would probably prefer to play a video game over a board game on a video game,

but sometimes I don't mind playing them and also lots of people like it. It's got more people in the hobby, I think.

And again, there's that idea. I definitely thought that when we first started, we say when the hobby started making board game adaptations into video games, I thought, "Oh, they're going to kill their own thing. This is bad. This I can get this board game that cost $60 for $3.99." And the opposite has pro proven to be true. This actually helps sell more of that board game, not less. So,

yeah.

Right. Yeah. I mean, board game arena drives sales. People play, they click it on the computer with low stakes and they're like, "Oh, fantastic." I was just reading an article on on Super Nintendo games. Like, what Super Nintendo game should I look into? Kind of delve back into the past. And someone put on there the Monopoly port for the Super Nintendo and called it one of the best ways to play Monopoly. So, this is not a new thing. This goes back to the '9s, if not earlier.

Huh. I would I would put a lot of other Super Nintendo games over that.

Like, WHY?

But it was still interesting to see that on this like retrospective article of like this has worked for a long time.

Yeah.

Yeah.

I played the Monopoly game at Dave and Busters where you see how far you can get and you get tickets.

Really? Okay.

Interesting. That's probably the closest that Yeah. Like Monopoly branded stuff has become

I forgot what the hot take it was.

Saying it's not good that this is happening. It's wrong. It's wrong.

Okay, whatever. Yeah.

All right. Santi B says, "Oh,

Parlor, Yard, and vintage games are too quickly dismissed or underrepresented in the gaming community.

This goes back. This is very similar to that dexterity game one that we had last time where it said dexterity games are not board games." This is very similar.

A sidebar to show. Yeah, it's very similar and and what it's saying is like these games are not actually it's the opposite of that to say it's under reppresented I guess which I think is true. I think they are still games but it goes back to what is a board game.

I agree with this. I think those games are very quickly dismissed. So are honestly mass market games sometimes. We very quickly go this isn't a game. This

it's not Oh, it's still an overhead from the last one.

Yeah,

we'll fix the mics. Give us a second. This is not a hot take. Um, no, I agree with this. I think this is yard games, vintage games, parlor games probably are the ones that stand out the most.

They are very quickly dismissed as not being a real game. But

look, you don't need that many things for it to count as a board game. It needs to have rules. It needs to have the ability for somebody to win or lose. Done.

I think that comes back. I mean, I think what I like about this statement is they say in the gaming community because it's not segregating video games. It's not segregating board games, card games, whatever. It's just saying in the gaming community in general. And I absolutely agree with that. It reminds me of uh that convention we did in France when that was a whole part of it is they had lawn games happening all day long. Everything from botchi ball to um that animal quacking one, whatever.

But I will disagree with vintage games. Vintage games are vintage for a reason. They're not particularly great. There's not a lot of great vintage games that we play today, the old timey games, because they just weren't

stick or what? Like what are vintage games?

Like the old games from the 30s and 40s, you know? That's what vintage means. It's basically that old stuff. I don't think that's worth Yeah. They're dismissed because they're not that great. There's like You asked me to do my top 10 games before 1970 and that's a

big That takes some work.

Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. No, I lawn game, yard game, all that type of stuff. I remember there's this

there's this I guess it's a bar in Vegas [clears throat] downtown where you could they have various things set up. They have giant connect four, you know, that type of stuff. The most popular thing they have there are 20 garbage cans arranged 10 in a triangle, 10 in a triangle, and a basketball and it's just giant beer bomb.

Yes.

I will say I am a little tired of on Facebook or wherever I get these ads. Every once while someone reinvents beer pong, some new way to throw something from one end to the other.

Your mic. Your mic.

My mic is on. Oh,

just cuz I turned it off to go fix that.

Oh, okay. Not for the batteries.

All right, next [clears throat] one. Sean S says, "You should try to play games with the worst gamers because if you still enjoy the game despite the bad company, you know it's really good and transcends. I don't care for a game that no is this Sean Stewart perhaps.

What?

I don't think so.

Yeah. Right. Yeah. He will get a strongly worded text message.

That's like say that only makes sense if your pursuit is to find a game that will withstand anything. It's not.

Is your pursuit

The pursuit is to have fun,

right? Yeah.

Is the pursuit do I like this game as much as I think I like it? That doesn't matter. Do you enjoy playing the game? that that's what you should be pursuing, pursuing positive opportunities.

You should find you should find a movie that you love so much you would watch it in the worst movie theater with the stickiest seats and the most broken chairs possible.

Yes.

And then see if you still like it.

If you still like the movie, it's worth paying for.

Now, I will say if you're play testing games, I might try to find people who try to break games and things like that.

Yeah, that's different.

But that's different.

That's when you play with the worst people. Matt D says, "We think, this is very similar, we think we're reviewing games, but we are more so reviewing experience." He says, "This distinction matters because when reviewing, we establish a casual relationship between the game and variable factors that are outside the game's control or design. These relationships impact a review way more than people acknowledge."

That is true of everything that has ever been reviewed. I'm sorry. You think when I watch a movie, if I'm comfortable or not, if I'm hungry or not, if I have a stomach ache or not, doesn't affect my viewing experience? Of course it does.

Just like a meal at a restaurant that's is slightly too warm for my comfort.

Just like literally anything else is great, but the waiter is terrible.

Yeah. Like

there's no way to distinguish those things. That is that is simply impossible. You can try, you can put things into place to attempt to take yourself mentally to a place where you separate that, but you're extrapolating.

Yeah. Again, this is a repeat from before. And you know, what we talked about is that's the difference is if you're reviewing it for your home collection versus what we do, you know, reviewing it, actually looking at the games, but also that fun factor, that fun factor piece is always going to be included in the review. And that's why we have personal uh ratings on it.

Sure. But yesterday I played two games that I thought were really terrible in a row and we had a hilarious great time playing them.

I'm still ranking them a two and a four respectively.

That doesn't matter. We had a good time. But I'm I'm hopefully able to transcend that a bit. You can never do it 100%.

And a lot of people don't.

But again, that's because you're a professional. You're doing it hundreds of times a year, you know. Um I think that's the difference here. Think I think this is absolutely true for people who don't do it professionally, but even as professionals, it still happens.

Well, like just like when you if you play games with a kid and the kid is like, "This is dumb. This doesn't make a lot of sense, but I laughed a lot." Nine out of 10.

Right. Yeah.

Well,

stop talking about Jimmy.

All right.

Yes, I was talking about Jimmy, my daughter.

Jimmy.

Zeon comes in with a spicy take. Zog.

Many people want solo modes as a coping mechanism to deal with their overspending and their wall of shame.

Oh, that is strong.

That that might be

revvelatory.

Yeah, that that could that could very well be true.

It's a joke.

I do think people use the solo experience of a game as an excuse to buy it.

Sure. They'll be like, "I'm I'm never gonna play that game. I'll play it by myself." And and maybe they will, but it does give you that incentive to get more and you'll be like, "Well, I'll get around to that game. I'll play it by myself."

Right.

I don't think this is a hot take. I think this is a hurtful take.

That's That would be our next video. Hurtful takes.

Personal attacks.

Yeah.

Um I could I could definitely see this being a thing. It's certainly subconscious. I don't think anybody's obviously thinking this, but yeah, absolutely. But it's like anything if you are if in your mind before you purchase a thing you can imagine yourself doing more with it fitting more situations or you being able to adapt to it in more different ways. It'll be easier for you to purchase that thing. Sure.

Right. And you could put that wording with almost anything. Includes fifth player expansion. Like yeah I have a five player game group.

Are you going to play that game with that or with them or not? Doesn't matter if you kind of if you feel justified in purchasing game.

Yeah. And going back to those experiences, last week on game night, we had five people and all we got to play is party games. Oh, cool. You know, I mean,

yeah,

right. It's that self-justification.

Maybe it'll happen, maybe it won't.

Brett B says, "Small board game content creators often can't be fully objective in their reviews

because they're too small. One overly negative take, he says, can mean losing publisher support or future review copies. And that pressure inevitably shapes their opinions.

I think

first of all, you're extrapolating there.

I I think more often what we see is rather than them not being fully objective is maybe they lean towards I only review ones I like.

Sure.

You know what I mean? Like it's more of a shift in what they cover more so than I'm not being fully objective. And maybe that's just because I'm definitely trying to give the benefit of the doubt there. You know,

I would also argue that a lot of people review games positively because

they when you first start out, you haven't played a ton of games, so every game you're like, "Wow, I've never seen this before."

Yeah, I think so.

Yeah.

But is this happen? Probably.

Maybe. Yeah. Does this happen? Sure. Does it also happen with large ones? Yes.

No.

Yeah.

Yeah. I I'm very hesitant to attribute motivation behind things, right? Uh when I don't know that person, I don't know all that stuff. But

I I get what they're saying. There's like a bigger I don't know potential. But like having run a small YouTube channel before working here, it's I mean I don't know if I didn't get a review copy of a game in the future that I didn't like from that company when they make bad games to begin with.

Right. Right. like, "Oh, I better review this positively so they can send more bad games."

I also I also think there's an element to it where games you like are more fun to review. And so if you are small and you're not doing 40 reviews a week like we do, you know, then you know, as a as a whole channel, not individually, but then you want to you want to cover the ones that are fun to cover. You want if you have to play it two or three times, you want to play a game you like two or three times, three or four times, five or six times, depending on how however many times you need to do that. You don't want to like, "Wow, I hate this game.

Let me keep playing it. Let me keep shoving it on my small game group, you know, you want it's it's easier to do. It's easier. It's more fulfilling. It's fun. It's rewarding. And it's positive, you know, to to do the positive reviews.

Yeah. That's the thing we don't see is the the the the videos they're choosing to not make,

right?

We don't see that.

They might have a bunch of games they hate it that maybe they got sent and they're choosing not to cover them because this is a hobby, maybe, right? They're like, I don't really want to like spend a few hours crapping on this game that I I really like this one. I want to talk about that.

Right?

And I think maybe even the worst victims are the mediocre okay games that inspire nothing, right? Yeah,

it's fun every once in a while to just kind of go off on a game and it's fun to to just rant and rave about how great a game is, but that stuff that's like a six. It's like a 5.5, right?

You're like, I'm going to dedicate

hours of my like I work a normal job. I come home. I'm going to set up the cameras, set up the lighting, I'm going to do all of this to talk about

a game that's like a six. It's okay. Like

doesn't inspire either thing. So, you have to just

Yeah. You have to make yourself talk about it. Yeah.

It's the monotony of the work that you're choosing to do on your own time. No.

All right. Alexi says, "Ra and Nitto are not an auction are not auction games." He says, "An auction is when I have a pile of money and I can throw as much as it as I want in your face. If it kills me, so be it. If I can only use one card token with a number on it, like playing war, it's bidding and boring. All hail modern art." So this is just

so any of the games where you have set bids or you have cards that you use or a tile

and it's not like I have I can spend 17. He's saying those are not auction games.

I guess I guess he's comparing it to real life.

But I guess also like okay are we getting stuck in this is this is this and not this. Well actually I don't just play the game if you like it.

It's a bidding game instead. You saying it's a bidding game instead of an auction game? Yes,

sure.

You win.

You can consider that. You mean if you want to introduce it to your friend. We're going to play a bidding game. This is Let me tell you why this is different from an auction game.

Yeah. [clears throat] Like if you if I show up at your house and you give me like a whole breakdown of how this is not an auction game, but a bidding game before we start playing. It's the last auction/bidding game we're playing together.

Well, the great thing about

So pedantic. That is so pedantic.

Isn't that a great thing about board games that we can create new types of auctions that don't work in real life? Right.

Okay. Here is uh here's Al Capone's car.

Everyone put a wad of cash in your hand. We're going to reveal it at the same time. No.

But we could do that in a game because it's fun.

Yeah.

I want to play an eBay sniper game. All right.

I like that. You just have people bidding and then one person's a sniper.

You're trying to shoot out the winning bit. All right, Ronald R uh says, "The hobby has become all about quantity. The number of games coming out causes people to play shorter games in order to get the next new release to the table. It has caused people to play a never-ending turn style of shorter games in favor of games that are 90 to 120 minutes long."

No.

Ronald, are you in a different hobby than I am?

Have you seen the length of games that are coming out now?

Yeah. What were the hottest games this year? Right. We just did the top 10 people's choice. Galactic Cruise was number one.

Galactic Cruise was number one.

Then Hot Streak, which is a shorter game.

There's Vantage, which is big on long sessions, right? I mean, like 20 minutes. Yeah.

No, I will agree that I think there is a lot of quantity in the hobby and often that quantity is

not utilized. You go and back a game on Kickstarter or Gamefound, you get that thing, it's 12 boxes. You play one and a half of those and then the next giant 20 box thing you back shows up and you go, "Oh yeah, but that doesn't mean the games are becoming shorter so we can play more." There's a correlation there between money and acquisition and and playing that you're dismissing. I do think that there I I I will agree with this slightly and I do think that those shorter more I don't want to say entry level those comfort games kind of kind of ones are on a rise like if we look at some of the most played at conventions yes it is the the Galactic Cruises the Vantage that stuff but it is also harmonies and Cascadia and more of

Sure but that's nothing new that's always shorter games have always got played a ton

it has seemed like it has been an increase

it has felt like an increase to me.

Okay. Well, I really disagree with that. I don't

Wrong Ronald.

I I feel like I have seen a rise in the amount that those are getting played. Um, yeah.

But also like small card games and stuff are becoming just kind of bigger or whatever. But like

I don't know. Yeah, there's always been like good quick midweight games. The 30 minutes and under.

I just don't think it has anything to do with the quantity of games. There the correlation isn't there at all. There's a ton of games that

it sounds more like they're talking about just that constantly seeking like let me play this one cuz then I can get to the next hotness. I think it that's more of what it's referring to. Is that

But the people I see who are like that are playing the bigger games. The people who are like, I need to play the newest hotness aren't people who want to play Hot Streak. Those people just want to play Hot Streak because it's fun.

Yeah.

All right. Matt D. More Spice says the paid game preview YouTube genre exists so people who are doing YouTube as a hobby can attempt to make it a job while also making their channel worse, but maybe also making it economically viable, but certainly worse because these videos are extended commercials. He then says playthroughs are fine. Thanks, Matt. Um,

no, I mean, look, previews need to exist. They're helpful for people when you're buying up a Kickstarter you or a game found. You need to look at the preview and see how it is. Um, is it people trying to make money? Yes. Does it make your channel better? I don't think so. But you got to find the balance and do previews and reviews. If you're just previews, that's fine. But I'll never go to your channel. I'll only use it

if I'm on the page for the game.

It's valuable content for that game, not necessarily for your channel.

That content also has a very specific shelf life. You know, it it does die faster. Um but it does help with the Yeah, it helps with the money part. Absolutely. I think I think the trick is finding that balance which is very tricky of Yeah. doing content that has a longer shelf life that is not that doesn't feel like an advertisement or an extended ad like you were saying, but also when you do those extended ads, try to be discerning and pick a game you actually think is pretty good. And don't you're going to do yourself a disservice if you are shilling something you don't really think is that good. that will come out that that will be obvious after a couple of years that that you are just shilling. I think it'll it'll the truth will out it'll it'll be obvious.

So that's the main thing you want to be careful with, I think.

All right. Marcus L says, "Uh, bag building as a mechanism is just a worse version of a deck of cards, especially if the pieces don't have an enjoyable tactile nature feel to them, such as cardboard tokens or wooden cubes."

He's saying those feel good or they don't.

I'm confused because if he likes cardboard tokens and wooden cubes, I was like, "What?"

I think he's saying I think he's saying those are things that lack

texture as opposed to like, "Oh, the deluxe nice bits. The geek bits and all that stuff."

Yeah. I I disagree. I think bag building is is I think it's very similar to deck building, of course, but I I think that is completely valid and it's not a worse version in any way. There is something fun about putting your hand in there and pulling out. We were just playing uh aberration the other day, which has a similar thing where you're building your bag of actions and you randomly pull out your actions and that is so exciting and so fun. Um and in a way I I find that to be more fun than a deck of cards because you're like, "Oh man, it could be anything." Yes, that's an illusion. I realize that both are random any um they both have the same amount of randomness, but there's something about that you feel like you might have control. Oh, hope I pull the right one. You know,

that perceived factor, that excitement factor matters, right? The deck of cards is shuffled and it's set.

Yeah,

I want that seventh card down, but I have to draw the top four first. And I know that that's not a real mechanical nor mathematical factor, but sometimes feel is different.

Yeah.

Also, what are you doing with the rest of the game? If the rest of the game is draw five cards, play them out, grab five matching tokens that you then slot into places for different reasons. No, just put those pieces in a bag, pull out the five pieces, and slot them places.

I don't know if I think one is inherently better than the other. I like bag building a lot, but there are advantages. Bag building the advantage. You can throw a chip in. I'm say chips, right? You throw a chip in and it's immediately shuffled.

You don't have to like shuffle your deck. You throw it in, it's shuffled.

The the advantage cards have is they can hold a lot more information.

Tons. Yeah.

I played, for example, what was that game with

the minion?

No, the the guy who ripped the minion off and made the gem

poker chip puzzle crush puzzle.

Puzzle strike. Puzzle strike. Oh.

Um, so Puzzle Strike, when those chips first came out, I was like,

"All right, what does that mean? What does that mean? You look at that stuff to see what it meant." And it's like, that's because a chip can't hold as much information,

right? So,

they each have like their own inherent

Yeah.

better things they can handle, like setting a deck of cards. You can't do that with a bag.

Mhm.

Shuffle this card in the bottom half. You can't do that with a bag, right? Like at all.

But you also can throw something that feels different in a bag. And if we're doing a simultaneous reveal, I can always call that up. Can do that with a card,

right?

Yeah.

But also, they're the exact same mechanism. This is like, oh, this was worse. No, they are literally the same mechanism. You can take a bag, you can take a deck of cards, throw it in a bag, pull a random card. Ha. It's the same thing. It is literally the same mechanism. I think sometimes they are worse for a specific game or a specific, you know, you know, iteration. Yes. You know, but yes, it's like cool, this fits better because of this style of game. This fits better because this style of game, but they are 90% the same mechanism.

That'd be like saying worker placement is worse than dice placement. It's like, no, the die is a worker. It just has information that the worker maybe can't numbers. Yeah,

they are the same mechanism.

Yep. Yeah. If you stack discs under your worker mele and they are different numbered levels.

Same mechanism at that point. Yeah.

All right. Chris B.

Oh, close

says player elimination is fine. He says, "I would always rather be eliminated from a game rather than be stuck in a game I know I have little to no chance of winning. The possibility of getting eliminated also adds a great tension excitement to games when players are all fighting to avoid it. And it usually makes for a good laugh when it finally happens." So, I'm laughing at uh one of the comments. Z just invented bag deck building. You're welcome. Um

player elimination is fine. I player elimination is fine. I do think it's okay. I think a I think there's ways to have bad player elimination. I think there's ways to have good player elimination. Like anything,

I think the length of the game matters.

The length of the game, the time between someone being eliminated and the game ending. Like I love it when a game is you die, game ends next round.

That's fantastic. That is a great way to have a dramatic moment in a game that then quickly resolves.

That's great.

The idea that um it adds I don't I don't love the fact that usually one of the arguments I hear is well just eliminate me because I can tell I have mathematically no chance of winning. I feel like a lot of people don't know that. You like don't know that. You're You feel bad.

You got You got the feels and you're like, "I'd rather not even be sitting here. You guys suck it up. You're playing a game and you're sucking at it. Just sit there and take it. Try to do better."

When a game's like four hours and you're very far behind.

Shut your mouth and play four hours. You picked it.

But is that a is that a game issue or is that a player issue?

Sometimes it's a game issue. I think it go either way. I think it's I think it can go either way. If if food chain magnate for example had like just a you file for bankruptcy, you leave the table, everyone else plays for a few hours.

I don't know how that would feel, right? Because of factors like

I would do it.

But at the same but at the same time can't in food chain magnet isn't that like in the first one or two turns if you don't play well it's like you have no chance of winning. Isn't that like

philosophy says if you can't lose on turn one why have turn one

right? And so in that case, it's like, yes, just eliminate me, but I will probably eliminate myself at that point. Right.

I disagree with that so much.

I don't want to lose a turd. What?

Right. Right. There's no way you can come back from anything.

Right. I mean, this at at that point, it's like a mercy. Like, you haven't sold a single hamburger in three hours. This is I'm talking to my friend Steuart. I felt so bad for him the first time I played this game. We're like, you can just you I'm having fun hanging out with you guys.

I don't know. Wild philosophy, though. You can't lose on turn one. Why have a turn one? That is a wild philosophy.

Wild as philosophy, though.

Yeah, I know. I know. It's just interesting. I don't That's a hot take. It's in and of itself there. I don't I don't know, man. I don't know how I feel about that.

Yeah. I think player elimination has a very small window and that window is like about 10 minutes. 10 maybe 20 minutes. So, either the game is 10 to 20 minutes only or it happens in the last 10 to 20 minutes of the game. Like there's a very very limited window where player elimination is okay. Sure.

Well, Risk is the game that brought that, right? Or Monopoly. Like, I'm out. You guys are gonna play for two more hours. Okay.

Yeah.

I'll go watch TV.

Yeah.

All right. Whitney H.

Whitney Houston.

Oh,

could be.

Publishers should follow Dver's lead by making boxes just big enough for the components and rulebook. I'll let Wendy come in and smack you.

He says or she says consumers should not need to buy the contents in the box and the large amounts of air in it because they enlarged it for more shelf presence.

Those are you're taking one extreme and going to the other.

I agree with part two.

Yeah,

it's okay to have some air.

Yeah,

I like the Ver a lot. I think they make great games, but their boxes make me angry. You you I don't want to have to Tetris the game back in a box every time. I

and heaven forbid you come out with expansion, which Devere always does,

right? And then you've doubled the the box you need and doubled the shelf presence. I think it comes down to I would rather them air on the side of a smaller box that's a tighter fit than going up to a ticket to ride size box or something like that when there's something in the middle that would work. So I think I would rather them air on the side as smaller.

But again, they also need to have some foresight like give me a little flexibility to store it the way I want. um accommodate like if there's going to be an expansion in the future or something like that, especially if it comes out with an expansion available within six months. Absolutely. You already knew that. You don't develop and produce an expansion within six months. You had that in the pipeline already.

Give me some flexibility in the base box then.

Yeah,

I think I might prefer and lean like a little bit smaller than than bigger, but it's you're never going to appease everybody. There's some bad culprits of like you open up a game and you go, "Oh my, that's it."

Right. Absolutely.

That's That's not a great feel

and then you put it all back and you're like,

I guess I got to store this whole honken thing on the shelf for no good reason just cuz you wanted more shelf presents. I agree. And that sucks.

But if I ever have to put a game away and I'm like almost done putting it away and have to go h and start removing pieces to rearrange.

Yeah. No,

I'd rather I'd rather have the air. I don't love the air, but I'd rather have the air than have a game that doesn't fit. Right.

Right. Or that you have to finagle. That that increases the time to put it away because you have to and if I Oh, this bag has too much air in it.

But it also can ruin pieces. Sometimes I bent cards because the box was too full.

Yeah.

Yeah.

Yeah.

All right. Steve

says, "Phase 10 is not as bad as some people make it out to be."

Some people He says

capital S, capital P.

He says it has a built-in catchup mechanism and everything.

I I actually

That's a you argument right there.

I actually very much agree with this. I grew up playing Face 10. I have no problem still going home and playing with my family. I do not think I think that we are really quick to write off mass market games that have mass market appeals that yes, we know that mechanism can be done better, but we are also a niche hobby.

Don't care. So I think absolutely it's approachable and there is nothing wrong with phase 10. I to this day play it with my family.

I also grew up playing Phase 10. I got home my family were playing no thanks or myriad of other small easy card games that are good.

I think that is me pushing my current hobby on them and that is not my place to go. If they want it, they will ask for it. But I go home and they're excited to play phase 10. I will 100% play with that.

Once I've taught them the new games, they never want to play phase again. Also, I threw it away when no one was looking.

I think that is so elitist. I would never do that to my family.

I wouldn't throw their game away.

No, but I'm not going to force a new game on them when they have one they love. Why is it Why? Who am I to take that away from them? You are wrong in that, Chris. Blue does not look as good on you as you think it does. But I would argue bad color. Here's a red shirt, you know, like Yeah. That's like all

hide your filthy blue shame. But I would say I think it's just as wrong

that if you know someone doesn't like something to make them do it. I'm

I'm not making them do it.

No, they're making you do it. Like I liking it. So you willing to do that.

But if I don't like a game and someone says, "Hey, do you want to play this game?" I'm like, "I don't really like that game." They would say, "Okay, let's find one we both like." That's not being elitist. That's saying something we both enjoy.

I don't genuinely hate the game. Right. Yes. You can be like, "No, I don't." Right. And I think that's the point. My point is

some people in this case my point is I don't genuinely hate the game. I'm fine. And I don't love the game, but I do think it has a place. And it's like, okay, cool. I'll play a worse game for that experience with those people instead of pushing what I know to be a better game.

I do think we often discount, especially when it comes to playing with family, playing with folks that just get together for the holidays and want to do some game. We discount how thoroughly uninterested people generally are in learning new games.

Yes. And we forget games are like 80% comfort sometimes for people.

No, that I agree with

like so learning a new game it doesn't like there better be a massive massive jump in quality and they better have a lot of years left on this earth for that pay to be worth it because they'd rather just play the thing they know immediately jump into it. It's immediately comfortable. They're immediately laughing and having a good time. It's not, oh, we have to get through that really uncomfortable part where you teach me. I look like an idiot. I feel bad. I'm asking questions. I'm not comfortable or enjoying my time. Why am I spending time the little bit I have um

doing something fun,

not feeling great?

Sure. My argument here is I'm not that's not the case. You could teach someone apples to apples in 10 seconds.

Not everybody,

but most people here, come on. If they could play phase 10 has more rules than apples. Apples.

That's not even it. I think um I think people play games that have a lot of rules, but they know them already.

Sure. But I

Monopoly has a decent amount of rules.

I've never found and Well, yeah, but

but they know it already. That's the thing. And I feel like really smart people, people with serious degrees, you can sometimes try to teach them a little game and they go, I don't get it.

You're like, but you're a you're an engineer [clears throat] for goodness sake.

How do you not get this? But you can build rockets or something. It's a different part of the brain.

Sure. But I'm just I'm I'm saying though for these basic games and you're saying this but in my life and I'm not exaggerating here. I've never had anyone go I don't get apples apples to apples new game. It's such a simple easy game. And I'm saying that I would rather play one of those and teach that than play a game with people I don't like. It's I don't go home

when my mom was alive and she she didn't make me food I didn't like eat either.

Right. I think if they like it and you don't have a problem with it, that's fantastic. I'm saying if I don't like it, why should I play it with them?

Well, I think that's different. Yeah, you never have to do anything you don't want to. Yeah. If I genuinely don't like that, I'm not going to play it.

But I don't think that we should discount that game or that experience that those people are seeking um because we think there that it is a bad game or there's a better one out there.

I rip I'm throwing the trash and I did. I think it's like it's the idea of like I don't like it so I'm not gonna play. But the flip side of that which I think is what you're saying is

I'm also not gonna let you guys play.

Oh my word. Yeah. That's terrible.

I'm like no no no put it away. I have a better game. They're like but we like this game. You don't.

Yeah.

You only You only like that one cuz you're stupid. I don't know better yet. My kids play No Mercy all the time. And I'm like

all right have fun playing Uno No Mercy.

Yeah. And that's great. But if they like it

they do

then that's great. I don't. It's like somebody eats food I don't like. I'm like, that's disgusting. You seem to be enjoying yourself.

Especially if you take it to the extreme, you know, that where you're like, no, I'm not playing that because that's a bad game. Well, good luck with that. Enjoy your trash. You know, I mean, that's matters, you know. I mean, it absolutely is like, ah, you can h No, thank you. No, I'm good. You know, you guys have fun though. Yeah. Or I'll sit and watch it. I don't want to play. I do that all the time. I hate trick takers, but I'll sit there and play it with you guys and enjoy part of that experience. I genuinely have three times as much fun watching you play than actually playing,

right?

You know, um, and that's fine with me, you know. So,

as a side note, we got off on your thing, Steve, but phase 10 is that bad.

I could not disagree more.

Okay.

All right. Wayne W says the much maligned weight statistic. I think it's just me, but anyhow, on BG is actually okay if you round it to the nearest half and don't overthink it. So, he says flip seven's a 1.0. Lost Cities 1.5, Ticket to Ride 2.0, Wingspan 2.5, Castle Burgundy 3.0, Terraforming Mars 3.5.

What? What?

And then he he says he didn't go any further because he says we all know people that stop enjoying games somewhere along this scale. Um

well, that's a hot take there. So wait, so

he's saying it doesn't matter if it's like 1.1 compared to 1.7, just round it to 1.5 and they're all basically the [clears throat] same weight.

It's pretty much like what we do.

I don't I don't get this argument at all. He's like saying that's bad. It's like malign and it's crap. But if you round suddenly it's okay. Why?

I I think it's because people get caught up in the details of wow this game is rated more difficult than this one and that's clearly not the case.

And if it's by a factor of like 0.2 I don't know anyone who gets upset about that,

right? Like that. Yeah. The rounding part is I don't think the difficult thing

I do yell about it a lot but I do agree rounding it to 1.5 would be fine by me.

It's fine. Right. And the thing is that you have to look at this as a self- selection biased statistic, right?

Yeah. It's literally people vote if they choose to. I've never voted on the weight of a game ever in my life. I've been on BG like 15 years. I've never done it once. The people that do it might be a biased group that likes heavier games, i.e. love voting on this crap,

right? And therefore, tickets

might trend high. Then

tickets right to them is a one,

right? Right?

Because even a Lerta game like On Mars is really only a three when you think about it.

Right. Of course, then Ticket to Rides a one,

but a no human world is that actually the case because

because phase 10 exists and you're discounting it by voting that way. You know what I mean?

That's a zero.

That's crap. I hate that you are choosing a you're selecting a specific piece of the pie only

and setting the parameters within it.

Yeah. Yeah. Is it is the weight statistic sort of relevant? A little bit, right? It's it's not completely useless, though. You see something that's a 3.74. You have an idea of what that means. Right. Because enough people have been like kind of heavy.

Well, if you don't know what we're talking about, BG is board game geek and that's people go in there and rate games, but you can also rate them on how difficult heavy they are.

Yeah. One to five. To be clear,

I go weight them all 10 pounds, 15 pounds, but the system does not accept it.

Yeah. It's not a good like precision statistic. Yeah.

It's it's it's better as like a really vague kind of

it is a metric. Yeah. You know, I mean, if we're looking at a game to play, you know, in in the library here, I might pull it up real quick, be like three. Uh, okay, cool. I can handle that. You know, it's like, no, I'm looking for something light, you know, and so it's more of a general metric than it is because it is the average of scales, you know, my scale, average with yours, average with yours, average with yours, you know. Well, not yours. You don't rate them. I don't that should never happen. I mean, we can't trust the companies to do this for goodness sake. Some companies put it on their boxes.

You can't trust them. That company is comparing to their own other games. Any GMT game and they're like, "Oh, it's a two out of 10 complexity." That's a lie.

Like that. Or at least I should say that scale does not include phase 10,

right?

Right. That's that's two out of 10 out of the top four to five weight of the scale. But also those companies will also never put a 10 out of 10 in complexity.

You could have the biggest heaviest, you know, uh what was that one? Vermont or whatever it's called the 4hour fourplayer only German uh you know military peacekeeping uh treaty simulator like seven out of nine scale.

You're like what?

I love when companies put those scales in but out of fun it's always five out of five.

It's always everything on the right hand side right? It's always positively scary. Yeah.

Or solitaire suitability. I love those. It'll be 1 through 10 and it's at three. I'm like, what does that mean?

That's player count.

It's mostly solitire, but not necessarily.

A toggle, man. That's either yes or no. What?

All right. Whitney H is back.

She says, "House ruling should only happen if a question scenario is not addressed in the rule book or on Board Gamegeeek. House ruling because you don't like the rules in question." Um, only not only changes the gameplay, but also changes the designer's vision.

That's fine.

But good news, the designer's not in the room with you. Do what you want.

You will never know nor care what I do in my house with my game.

Did you buy my copy? Did you buy a copy of my game?

Cool.

Play Monopoly rules with it. I don't care.

Now, that being said, if you do a house rule, remember the first word of that is house.

Yeah.

You go somewhere else,

you can't force everyone. You're like, "This is how it's played." You're like, "Well, no, actually the rules aren't that way."

Sounds like her house rule is no house rules. I'm like, "Cool. In my house, I'll make the game fun if I want to, you know, like that's that's fine. You can play by the rules."

I will say, I think sometimes we use house rules as a crutch for bad design,

but but I also understand that you already invested money in that thing, and now that you're in the hole for $60, you're like,

"Well,

all right. I I'll change something if it's going to help me get some of this money back, right?" So, I get that. But I don't love house rules as generally because not because I care about somebody's vision, though ideally they know better. But more because I I I want the I want to buy the finished thing. I want I want it to be complete.

But sometimes there's a minor house rule. Like for example, in Carcasson, they had draw tow the beginning of your turn and most people say draw it at the end of your turn. And that's a simple thing or someone just mentioned in there they house rule where you reroll sevens in the first round with katan. That seems legit, right?

On the last round of the game.

I count it as a win.

I move on.

I very much do that.

Did I Did we win the game and there's three coins around me, right?

Guess I also looted for coins that maybe I'll give myself a little penalty because I fudged there. But I'm not replaying the scenario because I lost on a die roll on the last turn that I would have taken. You know what I mean? Like if we take each other out at the same time, I won.

Did I lose a solo game? I did not. I won a solo game.

I will never lose a solo game.

I tell you what, there's nothing worse when in a video game when you're fighting a big boss and you finally kill him and then at the end you kills you two and I'm like, are you are you kidding? Are you kidding?

Or you like fall off a cliff or something after you've killed him.

Got it. Got it.

All right. Jared L. All the famous people are sending in stuff today. He says, "It's not a hidden gem. It's just a bad game no one wants to play." That's it. He gave no other input.

My job.

This is true. Sometimes

true. Well, sometimes it's true. There I I've had a lot of people email me and be like, "How come no one's talking about this game? It's a hidden gem." I'm like, "Well, for you, but no one really liked the game."

Sure. Sure.

I think sometimes hidden gem is also accessibility. I mean, we just saw this with, you know, Magical Athlete, for example. that was this little hidden gem from this little Japanese game that no one could get and now it has a bigger reprint you know. So I mean I think sometimes accessibility is part of that hidden gem or it is um you know was limited limited run didn't get the advertising something like that. So I disagree that it's not a it's a bad game. There's a lot of factors that go into why a game didn't hit or make it big.

The term hidden gem does a lot of heavy lifting for different people I think is what it is.

Yeah. And that's true. It's it could easily be like, "Oh, this is a hidden gem for me. That means, okay, you like this weird, quirky game because it speaks to your sensibilities." Overall, nine out of 10 people might not like it, though.

And that's fine.

But I think there is also truth, and we've seen this over and over again, where a game is ahead of the curve. It's a good game

that hasn't yet been reprinted by AEG and B Love Letter, and everybody now loves it. That was a hidden gem before AEG printed it. And the the same is true, you know, multitude of times.

Here's what I would argue is I think the word hidden gem is used too often.

Yeah.

Everyone's like hidden gem. That just means I like a game that a lot of other people don't, right?

And maybe it is a hidden gem, but if if you then proclaim it and not a lot of people play it, it wasn't a hidden gem,

right? Also, a gem implies this is like a fantastic. There are a lot of games that are like, well, no one really gave that any buzz. I like it. It's like a seven for me. But, you know, maybe using that term hidden gem is like too strong.

This is like a hidden

It's like a diamond in the rough is a little bit better of a of a term

because it implies it's a little rough, but there's something in there that's really good. And if the rough edges

don't bother you, then that's great.

You know, it depends how forgiving you are with annoying setup, with an endgame that drags. Oh, I don't mind that. then maybe this is a diamond in the rough for you. For me, when the games, you know, I don't want that last three rounds where I'm not accomplishing anything. That might bother me or whatever. I'm just picking a thing. Yeah. Hidden gem does get tossed around a lot.

Yeah. Yeah.

Yeah. And I can see why someone who got taught a lot of hidden gems from friends that were kind of bummers would

like, you know what, that term sucks.

Yeah.

All right. The next one is more of a wish than a hot take. Andre P says, "If a game goes out of print with no plans to reprint it, it should automatically become free to print and play with files made available."

Good night.

Such as Arkham Horror Second Edition or At the Gates of Loy Yang, which actually did just get reprinted, so go figure. I think it's not possible because

it might get reprinted in the future. No one wants to

kill their sales by having it free on the internet.

Yeah. No. Talk about guaranteeing it won't get reprinted,

right? I I mean to be fair I think very few people would print and play

any seconded issue.

Oh my goodness. Right.

But like

I get what it's saying. It is a little bit weird that things fall into these like uh legal

development hell is the term or whatever it may be. Right. The the we were just talking before the stream about Glory to Rome. That's one of those games that's just kind of

it was a hot big thing for a long time. It's fading into obscurity. A lot of people don't have played it

and it's becoming a hidden gem.

I think that doesn't mean it wouldn't, you know, become

it's the idea that like any movie I cannot go and buy right now should be available for me to watch for free online,

right?

There's a lot

what you know like think about it in any other industry. It's just not going to work out. It's not

it it doesn't work. Sorry.

No, no, no. I was say you don't automatically have right to somebody's work just because no one is currently keeping it in stock or printing it. You know, it's like all that work, all that creativity, all that development now you can have for free because the company dropped it

or went out of print, right?

No, there's still work that went into that that has value regardless of if it's in print or not.

I agree. It's annoying when it happens for sure, but then you also run into all of those questions of like would it be a print and play file that has no artwork because that artist, you know, because those different things are licensed through different legal means.

Sure.

You know what I mean? Yeah. You can have fun printing Arkham Second Edition with no artwork and no uh licensed iconography,

right?

Yeah. Yeah.

I love Mike's comment. Mike Delacio uh 247 or whatever his number is. It's It says Andre is clearly a printer salesman.

Canon is going to have their day

or works for Dunder Dunder Mlin. I know.

Mark D says, "Bard game boards have gotten too ridiculously big." And he says, "If I have to stand up just to reach across the board to do actions, maybe the board should be shrunk down a bit."

I agree. With the exception of games that are epic in scope, like Twilight or a Civilization game, I'm 100% on board.

I think they've standardized them being too big. Now, I do not like boards that need to be bigger because of tokens, because of placement, because your iconography is too small, something like that. like it still needs to be legible and approachable, but it has gotten too big to where you should not have to have a game table to play a game unless it is that lifestyle game that you're getting into or that is like I will always have a game table probably because I like those big epic dungeon crawler kind of things, right? But that should not be a standard across games.

Are the boards that big? Because I often find myself thinking, not often, but sometimes I'm like, man, this board is too small for the bits on it. Is it is the is the problem that we've

I think boardread is too big.

Yeah, I guess

I'm not talking about just the board. I think the spread is often too Is it because we've turned up the scale on everything? Like a miniature that's this big didn't need to be a miniature that's that big. It could have been a miniature that's that big and then the board is this big and everything's normal.

I don't know that it's miniatures necessarily, but yes,

fits. You know what I mean? I feel like we've turned up the dial on just general production. Everything looks a little bigger. Everything's a little more bombastic. Boxes are bigger.

A lot of games have more big displays of cards. That's where I normally find it. Like there's 17 decks that all have five cards face up and sort of spread all over table and I'm like, I would like that card. Can you hand me those three?

Can you read me those?

So that I can see what they all say. And that's where I'm like, uh, it just would be easier if I didn't have to do that. Sure.

Or if there's a big board. And then I think we have seen a trend to bigger player areas as well.

Huge player board is my is my gripe right now,

which I love those. I love that intricate, you know, and and a lot of different things that you're personally doing on your board, but there does need to be that uh check and balances between if you have a main board that's regular board size and a player board, which is half a board size and a display of cards. I mean, you're

just um convoluting the the scope of the game, I feel like, you know, and really making it inaccessible.

And it's more of a trend. I don't again, I don't think that that's bad. it should never happen. But it's that trend that we're seeing that I think is not ideal.

And some of it is that things feel more deluxe, right? Speak Easy is a very deluxe game. It's gorgeous. Has a very large board. And on top of that, it also has a sideboard, which is the display of cards. And it's that stuff. I look at the board, I'm like, for a involved game like this.

There's also a sideboard. There's also the display of cards. There's also player boards this big that really logically could have been shrunken down to like what I consider more normal individual player board, but they [clears throat] wanted to be deluxe. They wanted a lot of room in between the tracks that you move up. There's like sometimes an inch between tracks. You don't need that much space. You just need to make sure you're not constantly toppling other things over, but it feels grand and deluxe when you have it. And it's even worse when there's

when a game goes to five players and someone's the fifth player and has to sit at the end of the table

and then you have these two sideboards and one of them they're like, "Well,

I can't even see that."

They're throwing pieces at it trying to make them land on it. You know, I don't know.

When it's too big when someone says, "I'm not going to engage with that mechanism of the game."

Right. Because I can't.

I can't.

I've done that before.

Absolutely.

Yeah.

Yeah.

All right. CARMEN COMES IN WITH A hot take. Six-sided dice are overrated and overused. Carmen says, and I think this matters, I dislike dice as randomizers as it is, but the d6 is the worst. If you're going to use dice, the d8 and d12 are much better dice as they provide more options.

Obviously, they do. They do mathematically.

A pair of 2d12 will roll better than 2d6, but they offer four times as much variability.

They do. Carmen might be a mathematician, you guys. If we decide to mimic 2d2, 2d3, 2d4, 2d6, or any combination thereof. Can we please let go of our obsession with 2d6?

Well,

how does he feel about double d6, though? I need to know this. 12sided die.

I think Carmen likes those. And I like rolling those, too. But there's a lot of games out there that require dice to be on the board and stay where they are. We just played one yesterday.

Yeah.

Where dice that were not d6s were moving more than the d6s. There's They're good for a reason. They They exist because people like them. I don't think they're overrated.

I think they're historically the cheapest to make because a cube is easier to to mold, right?

And they're historically been around because they were able to be made by hand. I can take a lump of coal and make a D6.

I can't make a D20

from hand. I can't like I can't make a D I I might be able to make a D8, but like you know what I mean? like give me an X-Acto knife and a little lump of coal and I can maybe make a D8 but that's it.

But D6, you can make that from bone, which they used to, right?

I think there's nothing wrong with D6s. They roll fine. You are overestimating how much randomness you need. If you're worried about them not being random enough, you should never play a card game ever in your life because I guarantee you that deck of cards is not as random as you think it is. You're not shuffling enough. They're not separating enough.

Don't even think about it. Don't worry about it. They're fine.

I also think they're they're instantly the most legible dice. Like you roll it, you know what's on top. Done.

Yes.

You know, I mean, they are for visibility purposes, what we just went back to, they are extremely visible. Um, that being said, I think there is satisfaction in like a double d6 or like a

Oh, D12 is my favorite. They're very satisfying. But for game play, any type of dice placement, quick visibility, hits or not hits, you know, in a dungeon crawler or something like that, they are so clear and so quick, um, that yeah, they're they're not underrated. I think there's a reason that they're the most used.

I think the one die I would love to see more used is a D4, but not a pyramid.

Yes,

correct. I want a stick right basically

like with four faces and it cannot land on the sides either because you round them off or the thing's too long and skinny. I don't care. That's the most underused die.

Yeah,

it's a nice variability of only four. It's a four spread. They're neat. They will stay put.

They're great.

They're pretty much a Yeah. D6 with only four sides, right? It just takes off the two ends. I mean, it's an iteration of a D6

football,

you know,

a football or whatever. Those are great and they don't get used very much.

Yeah.

Or a D6 with wings on two of the sides.

Oh, it's a fantasy D6.

I've seen weird stuff like that. Those are cool. Yeah.

Batman the the Dark Knight Returns.

That's right.

Has D4s that have like Batman sticking out the side. And that's

such a great Yeah.

All right. Ben L says, "Playing old favorite games that you know you love is far more satisfying than playing new games." This is 100% speaking to me. Absolutely.

I mean, I just think this is who you are. You like old games or maybe I like It depends on my day.

Uh, no. I I'm I I I think this is definitely a personality thing. It's not that this is better, this is not. I mean, this is you are speaking to my play style right there. You know, I'll play a game I know and love over learning a new one nine times out of 10. There's also the thing that we as as people that do what we do uh under I don't know like we we forget the comfort sometimes of being able to pull a game off a shelf and start playing.

Oh, I know.

Like that. I mean, when was the last time you did that? You took a game off a shelf and there wasn't a teach involved. It sometimes goes and it's a while. And so when you do it, you're like, "Oh my gosh, I forgot the beauty of this, the comfort of being able to go, you want to play a game? Okay, go ahead." Like, we're ready to play. It's not like, "Okay, in this game, there's comfort in that. That is a warm blanket." Uh, I agree with this a lot.

Funny say, I almost never do that because even though I play old games, I'm probably teaching to somebody at the table.

Yeah,

I like that though a lot. But

yeah, but there is some comfort.

Sure.

And that goes back to the whole playing with family.

Yeah.

That group who is not who that that doesn't associate playing a game with learning a game. Those are almost like separate activities.

100%.

Uh they really appreciate it.

They want the warm blanket. They don't want to march through the snow uphill both directions first and feel dumb and like have to ask questions or feel uncomfortable. Yeah.

Yeah.

All right. James D says, "Big

Dean,

big boxes don't make it harder to get the game played. The bigger box just makes it more noticeable how little you are actually playing your games."

That's a I I like this. I disagree with it, but I I kind of like this idea that we're bad at estimating things,

right? Like Tom says this a lot, right? If you say, "What's one of your favorite games? Galactic. How many times do you think you've played it this year?"

Like 12. No, it's not actually 12. It's it's lower than that, right? It might be closer to eight.

And then and but it can also just be off by huge scales. So yeah, how much do you play a game before you buy the $450 version of it? The ratio might not actually change, but you've you feel more guilt because you got the big one now.

Well, I think there there's two different things happening with this statement, and I don't know which one they mean. Do they mean that that it's like I feel worse about not playing that one because it's bigger and in my face as opposed to that little one in the back that I forgot about that's collecting dust, you know. And so is it that emotional value or is it the it it doesn't make it harder to get the game played? No, it to me does sometimes I will take that little one in the back that maybe I haven't played in a while over going through and I know we harp on this one. It's just an easy example, but rather than pulling off the Everdell big box and be like, "All right, here's base game. What do I want to play? Let me shuffle in this expansion. Oh, no. I I left this expansion in it last time. Let me pull that expansion out. Let me pull this one. There's too many decisions. So, that does actively get in the way of getting the game to the table emotionally. So, I don't know which way this statement is meaning it if it is that way. No. Big boxes oftentimes have so much content in them that it is actively harder to get it to the table.

Or is it the emotional guilt I feel because it's big and in my face? You know,

generally a bigger box is a more complex game. I mean, if it isn't

I think they mean like the big box editions because it's something that we've said a lot, right? Big box edition.

I see. Okay, I understand. I wasn't putting that together. They mean big box editions, not big boxes.

Oh, I see that.

Yeah, this is something we've talked of. Joey said it with Firefly Huge Crate and he's like, "Ah, I'm worried of pulling it off less now." Pulling off the shelf less now. You know, I've said that with

Okay, that makes a lot more sense now. I was thinking they just meant bigger games.

I disagree. I think when it's a bigger box, it gets played less.

Yeah, 100% it does. This is this is not that you feel what is it that it's more notable not noticeable how little you're playing it. No,

it's literally harder to take off the shelf and play.

And it's that that again kind of mental barrier of it of like how many decisions do I have to make to be able to play this game?

You know, it's the game before the game almost in some of these cases.

I honestly would recommend if you find that to be true, take out pieces of it and make them ready to play and put the rest of the big box away. Yeah. I think you will play the game more. And then in between sessions, not right before you play, swap pieces out. If you want to experience this thing next time, put that in the small piece you have ready to go. Put the rest of it in a closet and your game is going to get played more.

Yeah.

You know what that makes me think of this as a small aside? When my daughter was younger and she had, you know, a bucket of toys, we would throw about half of them in the closet and she would play with whatever. And then when she kind of got tired of playing with her toys, we just swap what was in the bucket. And it was amazing cuz she had brand new toys.

Yep. I did that.

Well, think about this. Think about you have people come over and you want to play games

and you spend 20 minutes picking a game.

But if you go away for the weekend and you take three games off your shelf with you, you will play each of those three games twice each.

Yeah.

If you limit the input,

judge me. If you limit that input to like if you prep for the

the gaming moment ahead of time, you'll be ready to go when you get there and it'll feel better and then you get back home and you go, "Oh yeah, I have all these. I'll put these three back and maybe these three will go with me next time."

That'll help. And that helps that big box thing.

Come on. Any idea? Okay.

You like it, right?

Steve C. Yeah, Steve Bushi

says that's what we're about.

Party games are not great welcoming games to the greater hobby. He says they are a welcoming game for other party games. Only doing party games for newcomers to the hobby builds a wall between them and more strategy style games. One day you might be able to handle this seems a little pretentious. He really kind of went off the wall there. Um I mean over he he kind of wavered like I agree with his first two sentences together. They're not welcoming. Like if you teach them a party game, they're not suddenly going to be like, "You know what? I I also want to play heavier games." They'll be like, "What other cool party games do you have?"

Okay,

I agree with that. But then he says, "Only doing party games for newcomers in the hobby builds a wall between them and more strategy style games.

I don't think it does anything. It's just it's neutral. I don't think it makes them less inclined to play strategy."

I think it's just a different part of the hobby that you're showing. You know, in the same way if you're showing the lawn games we talked about or dexterity games, where you I stole it.

You know what I mean? Like and so I don't think it's a barrier. You're showing a different angle of the hobby.

You just taught me darts. No one want to learn apples to apples. Now I have darts.

Yeah. No, I don't agree with this at all.

Yeah.

I'll tell you what though, people definitely

I've noticed when I I bring a pile of party games somewhere,

people will rank those so fast because you'll play one, people love it. You play that one, people like that was fun. Hey, can we play that first one again? They're always very clear to tell you which party games they like the best.

Right. Right. Yeah. Yeah. So, okay, a thing that I feel about the term welcoming is that welcoming doesn't have to mean bridge or gateway to more stuff.

Just means that that game itself is welcoming,

right? Yes.

Is a party game a welcoming game? Sometimes, sometimes not. Right. But many of them are very welcoming because they have less time that you feel dumb, less time that you're learning all that stuff. And that's fantastic. I don't think a a welcoming games merits at all lies in how much it makes people want to go explore more.

I agree 150%.

Welcoming games like if you are someone who is

like if you're socially awkward or you feel very shy, an acting game will not be welcoming.

Right. Yes.

You're going to we're going to put you on the spot in front of strangers and make you quack like a duck. That is not welcoming for a lot of people.

Yeah. That's that's the thing. It's not it's not about rules, complexity. It's not about, you know, any of that stuff. And the fun that you derive from any activity has nothing to do with whether it's strategic or not. Some people love to do sudoku.

It's not about like I don't expect anybody to be playing sudoku and laughing actively. You know what I mean? But they might be really if they are if they are you're like we need to get some help for these people.

Agree. seek help. But um yeah, no, it's an extrapolation of of of what that welcoming thing is to them. And I don't think that there is a barrier created by you playing a party game with someone and now they look at a strategy game and go, "There's a different beast."

Yeah.

No. Have you watched Brooklyn 999?

Yeah.

I'm just imagine Captain Holt doing Sudoku.

You did you dirty seven. Yeah,

he he would laugh at Sudok.

He would. He would. Absolutely. All right. Scott P says, "It's time to admit that IP, intellectual property based games are good now. Actually, the days of the cheap cash grab are mostly gone." Scott P apparently never goes to Walmart because the cash grab is still here.

It is, but I think his point is just because it's IP does not mean it's a bad game. I think that's to his point. Also, that's not what he said.

Thank you for the super chat. Uh, appreciate horse IRL.

That's a real life horse.

IRL.

Tap twice if you're like the dice tower.

I don't But he didn't say that there's more good IP games now. We've been saying that for years. I I still if it's I if it's an intellectual property, I'm still nervous out out the gate.

I think that's what he's saying is it's time to admit that you don't have to be nervous anymore. It's there's good ones out there.

There are some good ones out there. Absolutely. But we are also you're watching this channel so you're ignoring a lot of mass market games out there and those are still going to be not great if they're just some quick cash grab based on like

I just thought that I was about to say Squid Game. Yeah. Um

there's a lot of bad party adjacent.

This TV show had this one scene. So we're making a slapping game. You know,

there's a lot of crap.

Wow, that's a deep cut. There's not been a good

there not been like a good The Office game yet.

Right.

Right. Like it it kind of depends on the IP.

That's true. I don't think there's almost any good TV show board game.

I think nerd court culture.

Can you think of one?

Like Lord of the Rings

TV show. Well, there's like Stranger Things has a Semon game

which is Star Trek game.

And then Stranger Things has a mass market game from someone. I don't know who.

You know what I mean? Like,

so I think maybe to make this statement correct, it's hobby games, hobby IP games, you don't necessarily need to be scared of. You're not saying they're going to be good. You're saying there's a chance they'll be good.

I think the hobby, sorry.

Yep.

The hobby IP game at this point probably has the same hit and miss percentage as just an average board game now. Yes.

Right. Yeah.

Not that they're all

depending on the company. If it's Steam Forge, I'm suspicious.

As I'll get out,

sure, but those games are generally still going to be better than like,

I don't know, a game about God of War from

or something, you know? I don't know. Like, I'm picking a random thing, but like that that game from Mattel, from Hasbro, from whoever,

it might not be great.

Right.

Right.

All right. Carmen is back with another hot take. Carmen says, "Screen/shields are the worst components ever created.

Carvin says, "If I see a game with personal screens, it will almost always be an instant turnoff. There are better, more effective ways to hide information. If you're going to use screens, give them utility and durability like Mysterium. Otherwise, no one can sneak behind you to go to the bathroom. Don't bother reaching across table or even breathing too hard. And don't you dare sit up too tall or peer my way and look over my teeny tiny piece of flimsy paper at my stuff."

This seems like a very like they're targeting a specific experience and I can't figure out what experience. I tell you what, I if they said most screen shields, I would agree 100%. There's so many bad ones out there.

So many bad flimsy ones. Ones that don't have the angle cut

so they have to rest back. Yeah. Oh my god.

You know, one of the best one of the best recently I think is in Sky Team because you're actually building it and the way as long as you do those folds correctly. Got that stuck on my finger. As long as you

look like a stream. Um

um but yeah, the way it comes together and so you actually build this like almost kind of dome as long as you put those flaps the right way and you'll know you don't because it collapses and it's fantastic. It's

you can actually sit side by side with them because they have like the side ventricles or whatever you want to call

the ventricles of the heart.

Yeah.

Yeah. I agree. Usually components uh like this can be very flimsy and they're it's easy to go okay cut out the shape. Okay, we're done. Well, build it, use it. If it's not, if it's too lightweight, if it doesn't sit back,

that lightweightenness. How many times have you dropped your SHIELD LIKE DON'T LOOK, DON'T LOOK.

IT'S AWFUL. YEAH. NO, I agree. They need a little more engineering in that area, you know. Um I'm not I don't I can't think Speaking of that, like there's a lot of companies that make storage solutions that make bins, but there's no one that makes screens that are good hardy like, you know, aftermarket screens for games

besides your just big like DM screen, right? Yeah. Which is really kind of like, you know, having to deal with a problem this little with a jackhammer. So,

yeah.

Are you going to get into it with that though? I mean, people like metal coins for this specific game, you know? And so, you get into that like how do you get a generic screen shield that they want to use in Mysterium, but also

in whatever

in whatever else, you know what I mean? Like, do people want that? So, that that's tough.

All right, five more. Chris B says, "Ties in games are fine, especially if they're rare, and 95% of tiebreers in board games are extremely anticlimatic and make winning less satisfying. It's actually exciting when a game falls down to an occasional tie. Look how exciting it is when there's a double KO in a fighting game or how hype people get when there's a long run of rock, paper, scissors with tie after tie after tie. I'd rather tie and want to settle the tie with another game instead of saying, "Uh, well, it looks like we have a tie. Let me check the rule book. Looks like whoever has the most food. Yeah, I guess I win.

I 100% agree with this because unless it's coming down to the last turn, I'm like, there's nothing else I can do for points. Fine. Tell me the tiebreaker so I can make sure I have that tiebreaker the most also. But it's usually not until that last turn that I'm thinking of it. So therefore, I would absolutely rather it just end in a tie. Don't detract from the game like that and be like, "Oh, and that time we tied, I'll get you next time." I would 100% choose that experience over I lost on a tiebreaker which is doesn't feel good. It's like they were almost there. I I don't know. I don't like that. I think that that is it feels it feels less of a win to win on a tiebreaker and it feels more of a loss to lose on a tiebreaker and I don't like that. Just rematch.

I disagree with the second half of that. I mean I I don't like ties. I always want there to be a tiebreaker, but at the end of the day, if me and Chris tie and then Chris has a little bit more food than me, for example, and he wins, I go home thinking, nah, it was a tie. You know, I agree.

But I I still want them to say who did because I like it slightly better. I'm just saying I don't feel bad about it.

But no, if you ignore it, then you're saying like, okay, cool. He won on tiebreaker, therefore I won, too. House ruling vessel.

Yeah, I don't.

But there's also some games where it really does matter. Power grid is the ultimate one here. Money isn't everything, but it is a tiebreaker mind to tie [clears throat] almost. You know what I mean?

And that would be different.

That's different. There's reasons you, you know, the tiebreers there are very very logical. But I agree. Sometimes it is sort of

I agree that I do that thing too where it's like we tied. What's a tiebreaker? Okay. Leftover money. I have three. You have four. Oh, nice. We tied. In my head, I'm like, that was an exciting tie.

So, I'm I guess I should just let that go then and say it's it's a tie.

But I don't want to let it go. I like the fact that it says it feels like it comes down to randomness because if you're not thinking about that tiebreaker and strategically planning for it as you go, then it's random. Why don't we just flip a coin?

But the tiebreaker isn't

my coin. I have more

tiebreaker isn't necessarily The tiebreaker isn't random. It's basically saying collect $1,000 and whoever has more cents. That means you got the same score as me, but you use less resources to do so. You deserve to win.

I have many, many thoughts on this. I've thought about this tremendously. do a video.

Most of the time people do not factor tiebreaker into their gameplay, especially the first time, two, three times you play a game. Maybe

that I agree on.

It's random, right? It is. I won cuz I have more radishes. Why are radishes the first tiebreaker and not squash?

Right.

But Krist said though, it's because you did the same as me, but you use fewer resources.

It is. But he wasn't thinking about that during the play,

right? He went the squash route without thinking I should keep one radish in case I tie. You're not thinking about that. I agree with you.

He pursued a different strategy.

Thank you Uber MX for the merry Christmas super chat.

Thank you.

Thank you. Thank you.

I think any game that has say under 30 points must have a series of tie breakers because if you are playing a game that has like power grid a small point threshold, you need to declare a winner. There's going to be way too many ties.

Sure. If you have a game that's like say 31 to 100 points, this is a very random arbitrary range,

you should have a tiebreaker, maybe two logical ones and then a tie is welcome. I think any game that has over aundred points and ends in a tie is almost more thrilling that you landed at the same point threshold as someone else. And I am a 100 percent okay if there is no tiebreaker at that point rather than an arbitrary one.

This would be a good poll. I'm curious what people

I like that.

I I mean I I agree. I I still like to know but at the end of the day I don't

assume you did better.

I always assume I did worse.

All right. Well, that's not either.

All right. Sean S says, "More stuff variety expansions are always better than more complexity expansions."

Yes, 90% of the time I think so.

I think this is a personal thing, but I always I'm I'm with him.

They're they're less they're less investment, right, than adding a new mechanism. Sure,

some games have really benefited from having just a little more meat on the bone, but for the most part, if I get an expansion and it just says like here's more cards in the decks and here's more player powers and more stuff, I'm usually pretty happy with that.

Yeah, I agree.

I think it's more Oh, actually, it just popped up in the chat here. More stuff is always great, but I can't say that for complexity expansions, but that doesn't mean that I don't want complexity expansions. I wish this would have been just a more stuff off the top of my head. Explorers of Neavoria for example,

their fifth player expansion which actually brings in another deck of cards. I use that even not playing with fifth player five players. You know, I wouldn't have wanted just more cards because I think that the number of cards is really well tied in that game. Um that I wouldn't want more of that. So bringing in another mechanism did round that game out very very nicely. So I struggle with that always. More stuff is always better. Not necessarily better than complexity expansions. It's just always better to that game.

Yeah, I like it. All right. Jason says, "Gen Con should rotate weekends similar to the way Essence Spiel has the past couple years." Gen Con always being the first weekend in August makes it hard for some professions to get off work to attend. I feel your pain, Jason. But having run conventions, I guarantee you the benefit of running them at the same time

Yeah. is so beneficial and if you change dates like for example this year we run a small convention that's sold out already um called Dice retreat

we changed the dates of it and if you really want to go dice retreat dice our vacation email me

or east

or dice east right

you want this shirt come to dice east

but because we changed the dates some people who have always come come

and I'd rather keep the people who are coming happy than someone who can't come at That's not fair, right?

With Gen Con, there's such a huge con to move a week would be a logistical nightmare.

Also, how awful would it be if it's always on that first weekend and you plan for that and you're like, "All right, 2027 is the year I'm going to go because I have the leave saved up. I do that, you know, whatever it is that is your barrier." And then that's the the year that they're like, "Just kidding. It's the second weekend, you know." Yeah. So I think that there is because it is so such a large convention there is something to say for that continuity year to year that you can

and spiel does it around the holidays and they also aren't doing it in conjunction with the city. They do it they they rotate because of the two school districts, right? There's some school districts. This one has this one off this year,

but they don't do it in conjunction with the corresponding hotels and everything around Gen Con. Indianapolis is involved.

Oh, yeah.

Right. It's a big There's It's not just Gen Con. There's the the 10 surrounding hotels that are all huge

and the stadium. What's the stadium being

right? They couldn't go later because then they wouldn't get that stadium, right? Oh, yeah.

And they need it. So, it's

like you said, feel your pain 100%. It's really,

as a teacher, I know what you're talking about.

That really is hard.

But logistically,

two more.

Brett B says, "Kickstarter still exists as a main publishing platform for board games largely because consumers allow it to." What he means is he

he says, "We keep tolerating the same issues we complain about. Late delivery, weak communication, and high costs, so nothing changes."

Bottom line is Kickstarter isn't a publisher problem, it's a gamer problem.

Yep.

I mean, like anything that's not Yeah. That's something.

That's true. Everyone yells and complains about these big companies that have these giant Kickstarters and then you all back them anyway.

Yeah. It's a prison. It's It's the prisoner dilemma, right? It's you telling everybody, "Don't back this one." And then they can't publish it.

But But I But this other one, I really like the theme. So, I'm going to back that one. But none of you do it. Okay. Let's punish them. Oh, I want that.

It's You're not going to do it. I mean, people people want what they want.

I also think it is a vocal majority kind of thing. are not, you know, like the ones you hear feel like the majority that aren't. You know, it's those 100 Pokemon. Yeah, sorry. It's that 100 people out of 2,000 backers. Yeah.

That make it feel like, you know, so

all right, our final one here is from Zank again.

Let's go.

Kickstarter exclusives will kill a game in the long term more than it helps the game in the short term.

Now,

I don't know what that means. Kickstarter exclusives kill the game. Well, so Kickstart exclusive. People get all excited about the Kickstarter exclusives. Yeah. And they'll back the game. Then in the long run, people are like, I want that game, but I can't get these things because they're only a Kickstarter, so I'm not going to back it.

You're right. Zombie's gone nowhere.

There are times where I was I'm very annoyed by it. I don't care about Zombie Side, but Tasty Mineral

Uhhuh.

for they did that really nice versions, the deluxified they called them. They were just nowadays it's almost normal version of board games. And then they're like, "This will be Kickstarter exclusive." And then they told me later on they're like, "We wish we hadn't said that because we would still be selling hundreds and thousands of copies of these, but we said and then the Kickstart people would whine and moan."

Yeah. Right. Which part of the argument is that supporting? I'm not sure.

I think they do hurt it sometimes in the long run. I don't But it depends what it is. Those extra minis, that extra art, there's only a few people. those completionists who care about that like Blood Rage has not been hurt by that

art

that the Kickstarter exclusive box.

Right. Right. If you can still get the game, you can get the game. I know it sucks to be like, "Well, but there's parts of it that they made for this that I can't get."

Yeah. But if you go down that rabbit hole, there's also like things the designer designed that they didn't print that you can't get. Is that going to keep you from getting a game? I think that's more the the thought is like again we allow that to happen. I think we put too much stock in Kickstarter exclusives. I'll take Kickstarter exclusives, especially if it's gameplay, are usually not as play tested and developed. They're not usually the good parts of the game, right? You know, and so I think I think that is I think we give too much weight and valance to Kickstarter exclusives.

I will say I think sometimes maybe this is what they're referring to. I think sometimes those Kickstarter exclusives will dilute an experience that could have been really tight and focused and deliver consistently. And by introducing Kickstarter exclusives, i.e. things that are a little less developed, things that are a little more loose in what they do, you get a game experience that is not as reliable.

If nothing else,

maybe that's what maybe that's a little bit of what you're talking about. That feeling of the game didn't hit. Like I played with this one thing and it wasn't that good. Okay, maybe I don't like that expansion or that module. I'll try this one. Oh, I also didn't like it with that one. It's killing the game for me.

Or did you play with that expansion character that was just the funny, you know, it's like, oh, this is a cool one because, you know, that I've helped vote on, so I want to play with that one. Maybe it wasn't as well developed. At very, very least base minimal. It splits the focus of the design team. You know what I mean? Like, they're now focusing on all these other little tidbits they have to design. And again, specifically talking about gameplay, not talking about wooden components or something like that. Yeah. But if it is game changing or play, then it splits that design team's focus and and fractures it a little bit sometimes.

It's also the fact that if you come up with an expansion immediately when you come up with a game, that expansion has no time to react to how the game is received.

Yeah.

What parts of that game are perceived as weaker? You can't react to that if the expansion comes out at the same time. You don't know that yet. That's the beauty of an expansion two years after the game.

I agree.

You can be like, you know what? You guys in law in mass were right. This strategy is weak or this thing isn't as fun. We changed it. We tightened it up that now these things are better. Whatever. You can't do that. All right, folks. That's our hot takes. You can get in more. We'll we'll be doing these occasionally over the next year. Send them in at tomdicire.com and I'll keep saving them up. Um, we want to say merry Christmas to you all. Uh, this is the last live video we're doing for a week and a half. We're taking next week off completely. You'll still see videos going up this week. Uh, Graham's final 10 go up today.

That's right.

Um, the playthroughs we did last week are being reposted. And there's a the

Wendy's top 10 of the year that she wasn't able to do live is being posted tomorrow. So, that'll be up as well.

And our blooper video is going up somewhere.

It's probably around was around Christmas, I think.

I don't remember. I don't know.

It's going up. just keep an eye on it. So, that's all coming. Uh Joey is out of town, Wendy's home, uh Mike is still in Indianapolis, but coming back soon. So, from them and from all of us, merry Christmas to you all. Thank you for the super chats in the chat. We'll see you guys next time. I'm Tom.

I'm Z.

I'm Camila.

I'm Chris.

Just kidding. I'm Santa. Hey, uh, thanks for watching another video here on the Dice Tower. Uh, we really appreciate you stopping by and checking our things out. Thanks so much for joining us today. And hey, if you really like what we're doing here at the Dice Tower, then there are different ways to support the Dice. One of those ways is through Patreon. We have links in the description to this video. We have links to lots of other things we do down there. So, definitely check it out. But either way, we're glad you watch us. Tell your friends about the Dice Tower. Until next time though, I'm Tom Vassel and I hope you enjoyed this video.

Progress saved