Top 10 Games Best Played Without Noobs
Transcript
trespassing in this city and on this planet I need to centrate here for a second come on come on man dude you're embarrassing me in front of the Wiz I'm sorry I I stand down keep an eye on him thank
you hi everyone I'm luk Hector and this is the broken me a show where I RAV and ran to about board game but usually more on the ranting part this is another top 10 as was included on my list that I gave to my patrons to vote on but it's a little bit further down the scale as some of the other ones and that's mostly my fault because after the last one I did which was by far the most popular the next couple that were in the rankings were actually harder to make than I thought one of them was my top 10 games that indued anger and then when I tried to come up with the list I realized that it wasn't so much anger it was just more turn angst that was the games I was thinking you know there aren't that many games that induce actual anger that I would say I enjoy so it didn't really feel like a list I could do then the other one which I thought would be quite amusing was my top 10 train themed games because I normally don't like games with trains in them but then when I tried to write that list I struggled to come up with anywhere near 10 so I was like hm okay and even then I'd be stretching the definition somewhat by putting stuff like on the Underground you know as a train game or next London or something certainly any age of steam fans or agx fans would have been grotting me here as a result of that list so that one didn't work either so this is the next one down and to be fair this is one I kind of wanted to do myself as well my top 10 games that I don't want to play with Noobs noobs and by before you all get your knickers in the twist I'm not using the word Noob as a derogative I may be a simple country hyper chicken but I know when we're finger licked okay thises is not like to insult people are new to
games or anything like that I love teaching games okay teaching games is great but I'd be lying if I said that these 10 games in particular if I have a chance to play them with people who know the game already I'm instantly in a better mood than than the other I mean it's it's it's not that I will never teach these games these games I will teach now and again although I must admit one or two on this list I'm not sure I would ever teach I think I don't think I've ever taught one or two of these but yeah that it's if I can I'd rather do it it's that situation where you go oh you're playing that game oh I really like that one oh that could be fun yeah yeah and you got a new person in ah then you sort of freeze up and you think maybe I'll go over to that one instead and it makes you hesitate makes you want to maybe try something out or just go back to playing it solo if need be again this is not to say that you're you know that I don't like it if you're a noob and you want to teach this and you want to learn this game what do you say we plead Insanity it's just one of those things I mean everybody's got them okay you must have some games that you like or some games that you're a big fan of that you think I'd rather play this with people who know the game so if there is a new player I'm a little bit less wanting to I think your reasons are going to kind of overlap with mine because typically it tends to come down to added game length cuz playing with new players typically makes the game take longer uh not being able to use certain expansion items like you can't use complicated expansions or player powers and stuff like that too often when teaching a new player cuz it's too
overwhelming for them but it could also just be sometimes the balance of the game like the balance of the game is just a bit off-kilter if not everybody is kind of on the same page you know and certain games I mean I i' not put it on this list but root is a perfect example I can imagine that that is a game that people hate to teach because root seriously you might as well just give somebody a Fiverr and tell them to buy the app it's such a good way to learn the game but you know if you've got an asymmetrical game like that do you want to have three factions by people who know the game well and one person controlling a faction who hasn't got a clue you you know the balance does kind of you know the scales do tip a little bit on that one so that's like a kind of an example so without further Ado yes get over it my number 10 is definitely a little weaker on this list because a I taught it like two weeks ago or maybe last week even it was quite recent but I played a couple of games of this recently and both of them were teaching games however I taught one someone else taught the other and one thing that CER certainly came about with teaching these games is firstly you don't get to use some of the expansion material pretty often although I did in one game because I trusted the two people that were there but then the other problem that comes with it is that this game does take a bit long a little bit too long if you've got nothing but new players because there's a lot for them to kind of delve into that is lost ruins of arnac the check game editions game I do love this game do love playing it and as I say I have taught it
recently but I taught it to two people like know at my games club that I could trust to handle the player powers that being said the game did take a lot longer than it probably should have done you know they're not the quickest players when it comes to AP and it you know it just made that the game that could have easily finished in about 90 minutes given it was only three of us was taking like two and a half hours and I'm kind of like okay we kind of need to wrap this up now guys you know is there any way we can Rush the end because you know I'm you know you shouldn't be taking this lawn on your turns now so there is that aspect on top of that I want to use those player powers and yes it worked with those two but when when it was being taught the other week at an old event you know there was three um I think one person had played it before two knew I obviously knew how to play it but we couldn't use the player Powers with them and yeah we couldn't use one of the new funky research boards so we had to use I think we did use the snake board on the original base game but even then that's only so so I want to use the the monkey board and the waterfall board and all that stuff from the new expansions I want the expansion content in my game of arnac and that being able to use it is a little bit annoying especially as it's a game that doesn't hit the table that often but yeah it's lower down on the list because I will teach this one because the rule book to give it credit is pretty smooth the rules are smooth and the actions aren't terribly complicated but just something about the game length and the the fact that you can't use the expansion con it does make me feel like uh have you played arnac before would be great if
you had you're the diet coke of evil just one calorie not evil enough my number nine is on here because there's just a lot of rules in the game and this could apply to one or two other similar Rosenberg games in this instance but the other one that I have in mind which is Fields ofal I actually don't mind teaching this one yes there's a lot of rules but because everything gets you points it's kind of one that you can sort of go look just do what you want do because it's all going to be good at the end of the day this one comes close to that but in fields of art I've only got to teach one other person maybe two in Cera you got to teach a few more players and if you're playing a big group and most of them are new this Cerna game is going to take for freaking ever to finish but there's a lot of rules you've got to teach because it's not just yeah the work placement aspect might be simple but then there's a lot of spaces that you've got to explain then you've got all those buildings that you got to look look at and then you've just got the way that the ex the the whole board works I mean you've got this outside bit and the inside bit both of them function differently okay those are Fields those are what Caverns you need Tunnels for this you need Caverns for this these you know you need to get kids you also need to think about what animal do you like or donkeys do this in the mines and you know sheep and what it dogs can do this outside with sheep here's the way that is like the two or three ways you can store sheep oh no I've gone crosseyed a
lot of little niche rules which trying to teach this to new players is a bit of a nightmare now you could argue Fe um Feast of Odin which is on my shelf although I'm not entirely sure why it is because I am starting to get to the point where I might want to sell it but it does have Norwegians in it and it's all right solo I haven't wanted to bring it out solo I don't know anyway I digress but you know Feast of Odin's got a similar problem I don't like teaching that one because there's all those actions you've got to teach on the massive board and on top of all the other niche that you've got and it's not an intuitive game in any way shape or form and kerer yeah I wouldn't say is the most intuitive game either there's just a lot of moving Parts a lot going on then going back to the whole expansion thing forgotten folk forgotten folk is a great way to throw in player powers and you know teaching the player powers to new players is a very hdden Mis aair because you could argue that because those player Powers kind of direct you into a particular strategy it's easier to teach new players with it but then having special player powers does restrict you in other ways and it's obviously more stuff to teach on top especially if you use the factions that give you things like the mushrooms and the goblins and stuff it I'm in two minds but part of me thinks I don't want to teach forgotten folk to new players I'm more on that side of the scale I know some people will differ and that's fine because I can see the argument the other way but yeah it's a lot of rules it's a lot of teach it's a lot of moving
bits we're just too different different my number eight is w i did consider putting this at nine but uh you on the basis that this one doesn't have anywhere near as many rules as CER but the more I've been playing this lately the more I'm in that state where this kind of is similar to the one that's actually next on this list where it's not so much oh there's too many rules to teach or stuff like that it's more that I just want the game to go at a quick Pace you you want it to go speedy nice and Speedy straight through get the game done in an hour and all well and good and it is so rewarding to play this game with people who know it already so that you can go at that speed but when you play Earth at you know with brand new players particularly if most of the players are new that 1 hour time limit is wishful thinking at the best you there's not a huge amount to teach in terms of rules but you know new players especially people who aren't used to this type of engine builder game are going to trip up on the fact that there are just so many little things that you can trigger you've got to think about your Island and your climate board and then you've got to think about all these things in front of you and when you've got when you give them a hand of cards because all the cards are unique Earth is one of those games where you need to be you know mindful of what is garbage in your hand and what isn't and I've played Earth so many times I can do that in barely a few seconds I can look at my hand and go that's good that's good right that's good for that objective that works with two of them probably want to do that one first that's fine but those five building that order that
would be pretty cool unless anything else comes up garbage garbage garbage garbage garbage we done last compost you know and it' take me like 10 15 seconds and I can work this stuff out new players can't do that yeah a new player gets an island that says draw 12 cards at the start of the game and only bin five of them in your compost it's going to take them a long time to decide which of these 12 cards they want you know I deliberately like to give new players you know ones with bad starting hands you know not bad starting like resources but you know like not many cards to begin with because then they don't have as much to look at but you know you could argue that's maybe harder for them because you want to have lots of options but the takes on time to decide on the options and you know even though thetion actions are simultaneous you only go in as fast as your lowest common denominator so with all these games that are like oh everybody acts at the same time I'm trying to concentrate on my own engine while also trying to explain the rules 100 times to the people who haven't played it before and then I'll no doubt get to the end of my multi-action red thing you know cool right we done with red and I can see that the persons that are new have barely even begun and then you're waiting and waiting and then you move on and then you're waiting some more it's it's say I will teach Earth I have taught it to many people and I do enjoy it you know when I'm teaching it but it's I will say that when I do get a situation like with free mates of mine who I meet up with every now and again uh who all love Earth and we've all played it before we all know the rules
to it ah man it's nice to be able to crank out a couple of games of that in quick succession especially when I have to throw in that prototypic the abundance expansion I've got in Prototype form looking forward to getting the actual physical copy so I can replace the cards with it but you know I can teach them those rules but when you throw in those expansion cards and you try to teach new players that just adds to the problem again of complexity and it's not like you can just separate out the cards because if you want to go through the step-by-step process of mixing the cards to begin with OR separating them out of the deck and then trying to put them back in later how about new you crazy Dutch bastard yeah have fun with that you know have fun with that you go right ahead cuz I sure as hell ain't doing it it's not for me so yeah I just want a nice Speedy game and when you have lots of new players in Earth it ain't going to be Speedy
anymore which kind of has a similar vibe to my number seven in fact my number seven is probably arguably easier to play than Earth uh a drafting game a very popular drafting game one of my favorite drafting games maybe even my favorite who knows but hm it's not a Gateway game as much as some people would have you believe there is still a reasonable amount to teach there is a bit of depth to the game of like which card should you be looking at in favor and you have to pay attention to what your neighbor is doing because if you give them all the cards that they want they're just going to steamroll with the game these are things that new players cannot grasp when they first place set Seven Wonders and Seven Wonders again I have played this to death and you know not to death cuz I still love it but you know there's a couple of things with this firstly the game will drag with new players I mean I have seen on our Southampton group where you know this game has been taught by a friend of mine to six new players so they've played a seven player game of this where only one maybe two players know what the game is I cannot run away from those games fast enough I mean you know the they drag on for ages especially if there's one or two people in there that AP like mad and for a game that should take you 30 minutes it takes forever and I would not want to be in those because I'm pretty sure I would just be so B you know ending it right now but you know it's just not one that they grasp quick enough and so I don't really want to have to teach it I want again like Earth a setup where we can go right five or
six of us now to play Seven Wonders yeah it's Bel out nice and quick all right choose this card right everybody good right flip all right next cards oh that's going to be good oh that's good but I'll choose that one cool right flip go right and and just nice and Speedy and quick and on top of that all the expansions do you want to throw in leaders cities God forbid Armada with new players yeah have fun with that it's not going to go down well especially with leaders and cities and leaders and cities are my two favorite expansions that I want to throw in so all that extra iconography I mean there are people I know who have played Seven Wonders quite a few times in their Liv and they still trip up with the iconography and leaders and cities what do you think a new player is going to do you cannot throw it in ironically I must admit is I have not lost the RN that my first game I ever played at a board game club that got me into the hobby was Seven Wonders with leaders included where I actually won the game but then I like to think of myself as a fast learner if I'm motivated to learn something I will learn it pretty damn quick you know and I just seem to have an ability to learn games fairly quick not necessarily their in-depth strategies to death but I will be able to pick up the basics of A game pretty well and you know hold my own you know rarely do I play a game and then find oh God I did absolutely rubish I had no idea what I was doing granted uh some train games might have that problem but I digress so yeah I just want nice Speedy smooth game and you're not going to get that with new players in s wonders me not you guys maybe a little
more than than my number six is going to shock a few people the fact that I even like this game already like confuses me you know I mean it took him what like a base game an expansion and then a second edition and then another ex you know another base game which I haven't played yet and then another base game before I got to an element of this franchise that I actually really really like I'm still confused to this day now I would argue that the rest of the Great West trail series is probably not the best game to teach a new players anyway because of the kind of intricacies of the deck building and all the other stuff but particularly the one that I like the one that's on my shelf and that I'm willing to play New Zealand is um a little bit of a chore when you are teaching that game especially if someone has never played you know I mean if they've not played a deck builder before you really screw but if they've not played a Great Western Trail game before it's going to be a slow SLO because you not only do you have those elements of Great Western Trail that you have with all the other games but then you've got all those different bonus cards to use you've got four characters not three you've got the different all the different buildings that they have to be taught and but that point God knows what they'll do in terms of tactics and strategy because they won't have a slightest clue what it is they're trying to do and it just makes the game a lit more of a SLO you know a bit more of a chore to get through you know it's already a long game you know
it's going to take a while and the rules teach is not short there's quite a lot to get through in the teaching of Great Western tra New Zealand it's definitely more of a more of an investment that is required but I'm willing to put up with that investment you know now and again but we when I get mates of mine that all have played New Zealand and we know what we're doing ah it's a great bit of fun to Belt this one out now I'll cave it that if somebody has played Great Western Trail and just hasn't played New Zealand I'm more than willing to teach it because they've already got the fundamental basics down and I've just got to teaching the Nob bits but teaching a complete Noob Great Western Trail New Zealand I admit not the most recommended action in the world but New Zealand's the one I like you know I mean I'll play the original Great Western Trail second edition but mainly only with the expansion and even then the expansion kind of pigeon holes you into doing what the expansion opens because that's the best way to win the game at that point I've not played Argentina but all I keep hearing is that it's not as good as the rest and you know I want to try it out curiosity but I'm not EX desperate to I just don't think any Great Western Trail is going to surpass New Zealand for me and it's got the most stuff in it which also makes it the harder one to play with Noobs your
mother my number five you might argue should really be higher up on this list because whoa does this have quite a few rules to go through and asymmetrical um factions you know not just player Powers no we're talking for a symmetrical sides but there is a couple of advantages that this one has over some of those other ones I mentioned like root I have taught this game many a time because when it first came out I had to teach it a bucketload of times because I had to review it but it's one of my favorite games of all time it is fantastic to play this you know regardless of whether I've got to teach it or not but man it's so refreshing to go to a convention and not have to teach hegemony hegemony is a brilliant game I love it if you've got four people who know what they're doing it's even better because teaching this game already has a lot of rules involved it's already a bit of a SLO but this now brings out that bit I mentioned at the start about balance because aemon is designed very well where the game I think is very well balanced you know probably some skews in one or two areas but for what it could have been like an unbalanced mess look at most things that snowm make oh come on yeah easily could have been like a a massive flop but the fact that there is a Fred on BGG for every single one of the four factions saying it's overpowered kind of speaks volumes really and I do find it kind of amusing that there is but the the thing with this game is that you know teaching
it will take a while the game's going to be a 4H hour plus Affair regardless you know I mean the game's normally a 4H hour Affair anyway even with players who know what they're doing but you know you're going to be there for four or five hours plus to play this game with people who don't know what they're doing and it's you know I actually do I've had to teach this game from scratch one once or twice because I've asked everybody who's going to play it you need to watch a video watch the playthrough that Paul grogan's done watch any type of rules video or read the rule book something just get the fundamentals down and then I can explain your faction if need be and then I had one or two times where the person was too lazy to do it or made up an excuse and is like well I've got to teach it now great and yeah that gets annoying but you know even when I am teaching this game I'm telling people watch the video they you kind of need to you need to have some background knowledge to make it easier on me but when you go to a convention which especially these days I don't think I've gone to a single convention where I have not played a game of the geminy since it came out you know it handy con it Shake battle and roll you know U I suppose Essen is probably the only one where that's going to be the case but yeah certainly even games Expo I took it to I think I played it this year at games Expo yeah I'm pretty sure yeah I taught Mark monk ninja geek games I taught him and his mates it so but even then they had at least watched a video beforehand but yeah it's just so easy to get it to
the game table at a convention and at most conventions when you put it on the booking sheet to say right I'm bringing hegemony who wants to fill the slots does not take long to find free players that are willing to play it and that's a good thing you know it's it's definitely so much better when you've got it it's more balanced there's not one faction who's kind of screwing it up for other players it's just a well oiled machine but you got to get people who know what they're doing and it's a tall order for a game that is this big and this sort of heavy and this invested but the fans are out there I know a fair few of them and at a convention it's not difficult to find them and when I do who boy am I in for a treat I never get involved in politics
my number four speaking of stonem um where I all died in earlier this one oh God man I really actually do quite hate playing this with new players now this one would be higher if I enjoyed it more it's definitely come down a little bit you know so I don't play this one as often but out of all the ston Meer games most of them I would happily teach I'd happily teach viticulture I'm more than happy to teach wingspan you know wingspan's a great game to teach but this one game up to seven players expansion factions as well it's for some reason Scythe is not a fun one to teach I love playing it with people who know what they're doing because you can go nice and quick you've only got to do one action on your turn top and bottom basically and then move on to the next player and I remember a time when a bunch of us mates played a game of Scythe seven player with expansion in 90 minutes we were super lightning fast although that was partially helped by a mate of mine who is probably the best moderator you will get for any game ever you will not be able to Dilly daddy with him in there he will get you moving in a good way but scyth could blim me yeah the amount of times I've been turned off this game when I've seen it when I used to see it in my Portsmith Club because ports Club played it quite a lot and I would see it and I'd go oh I'm intrigued to play scy again it's been a while and oh for God's sake and you realize that there's you know free people who have not played the
game and it's like ah and every time I've played this game with people who don't know it I mean there's already a lot of rules to teach because you got to teach a lot of the intricacy rules it's not just simply what your board does there's all other bits as well H they throw the balance off kilter because they're not really making the right moves to Scupper other players and stuff but the game then just drags on because they just cannot do their turns quick enough for somebody being new to the game and so I really do regularly skip this game if I see that there's a teaching session going on you know if four or five of us have played the game before and understand it but maybe they just need a rules refresher fine I don't mind rules refreshing but teaching it brand new I'd rather not and if I must be in one of those games I'm going to do something else while you're teaching the game get a drink coffee go out for a walk or something I don't know because I don't want to be around for that bit I much prefer to get scy to the T table with people who can just get going get going do their actions reasonably quick and we get it done because the game does not warrant like a 2our plus time limit on it it really does need to be kept to a kind of 90 minute length and this is one of the things that's kind of made me not play it in a while you know it's difficult to get this one to the table because with so many players that can play it you're more than likely to have a new player in there and then what you're going to do so cyh is it's dropping for me it is dropping since the days when I used to give it a 10 out of 10 I think it's closer to an8 out of 10 now I think it's actually fallen out of
seal of seal of Distinction range you know is it SE I forget which seal I have now but yeah um it's h it's dropping it's dropping and a lot of that reason is because I just don't want to play it with Noobs well that's a lot less fun my number three probably the lightest game on this entire list actually yeah I mean this is literally just a small box filler you can play each subsequent game of this in like five minutes I mean that's all it takes and even then I still don't want to play this with Noobs so what filler game can possibly be so much of a chore to not play with new players it's not that it's so much of a chore but if you play this game with people who have never seen a trick taking game before in their lives yeah the crew the crew is a great trick taking game one of my favorite trick takers I played it the other day actually I think earlier this week I we played three games of it group of five of us the problem is is that the group included people not only people who had not played the crew before but that's fine we've not played the crew before as long as you know what a trick taker is that's fine but then you have a person who doesn't know what trick taking is this hurts the crew badly I mean you are trying to do these missions where you want to do more than just the basic mission of objectives which isn't that fun I want to do some of the really funky missions that require you to
really be you know smart and think and you know really get into the heads of the other players you can't do that with somebody who doesn't know what a trick taking is because the mind of that you know if the if my mind is trying to make calculations go you know like you know processing information like a supercomputer trying to figure out right right they played that card probably should play this but we need to get that person the free yellow what can they do you know and then you go to this other person's mind or something who's never played a trick-taking game and it's just basically a monkey you're just
going it might as well be that crazy because I can't figure out what they're going to do and they have no idea what they're doing so the whole game just falls off balance and you'll be like right played that card you haven't you haven't play that's free play the free pink yes You' played the free pink right why are you trying to win the trick you and it not called them a but it induces anger in that respect because you're thinking for crying out loud this isn't rocket science yes the number I was thinking of was the letter M now I realize that some of that is on me because I've got it into my head that everybody should know what a trick-taking game is and a lot of people don't which surprises me but then I grew up in a family where with relatives and various other people we have played regularly with a deck of cards hearts and trumps and Ry and you know happy families and whatever you know in fact the only I haven't played bridge I would like to try bridge but I've played a lot of other card games so I already knew before I got into board gaming what a trick-taking game was and when somebody showed me a trick taking game and I don't know what my first one was but once I tried one it's like oh yeah I know how this works yeah I've done it before who doesn't and I can't get this out of my mind that this is a concept that's alien to a lot of people especially as I'm obviously getting older now and playing with some like you know younger folks who probably never play never played with a deck of cards in their life because their generation never really bothered with those sort of things so it's hard to get my brain out
of this sort of way of thinking but what it does mean is that trick-taking games in general can be a bit of a chore to teach but most of them are simple enough that they'll get it but the crew requires the group to be on point it requires it to be you know like as perfect as it can get and as soon as you throw that balance off it starts to fall apart it almost wanted I almost wanted this to be my number one but I had to think hm investment is not that much time trick taking is not the hardest thing to grasp and if we must play the easier missions usually most people get it after a game or two and it's only five minutes a game so it's it's not too bad but yeah I did contemplate this one being number one because yeah really just want you know you don't have to rep the crew but at least know what a sming trick take here is 17 no no no no no 17 18 no no you got a 14
now my number two my favorite game of all time at least as of the last top 100 who knows if it was remain there but yes I have played this game a lot and it's a still a fantastic fun game but I play it on board game arena now and again although I must admit playing onboard game arena with randoms is not as fun as it could be but yeah teaching Arc NOA is not easy it's uh quite a fair amount of rules it's a mechanic that's only really been seen in I think one or two other games before the whole typewriter mechanic there's a lot of iconography on cards there's a lot of uh interactions with cards and various other aspects of the game you've then got the two point tracks you got to concentrate on you've got the five actions in general and then because I can't separate out the expansion I have to play you know Marine worlds with this which means they've got to learn the sea creatures as well granted I canot use the uh special upgrade cards but I want to use the upgrade cards they're really really cool but it's the only real thing out of the Marine worlds expansion that you can easily separate out I'm not going through that massive deck of cards and separating out all the sea creatures and the expansion cards screw that you know I'm not buying that for a dollar you know this one though I you know but the upgrade cards you can but yeah it's a lot and it's a lot of rules to get through and their turns are going to take forever and you're constantly going to have to remind them of rules during the game and it's just going to make this
game that's already admittedly probably too long you know well probably no it is too long when you play this with three or four players I do wish the game was shorter now that being said when I play this with people who know what they're doing the game does finish in a reasonable time like 90 minutes for free player sometimes or two hours Max and maybe two and a half hours max for a four player game you know it does finish in a reable time frame with people to know what they're doing but when you throw the new people in uh 3 hours 3 and a half oh boy it can take a while and that's not even including the teach yeah I mean this game really does want people who have played the game before at least once or twice and have an idea of what's going on but brand brand new I have taught these games before but part of me is almost twitching as I explained some of the rules and realizing they're not grasping it and it's just like this is going to be one of those games isn't it why didn't I opt to play that instead and it's just yeah you know I like playing OVA solo um although you know the problem with the solo mode I mean the solo mode in the game is not bad but it's only it's somewhat limiting the solo mode that uh was done on BGG is very swingy but it is a way to play it solo so board game arena helps me to play this game with people who know what they're doing and blind me there some strong players out there that give me for a run for my money but playing with randoms on the internet want to have some of that interaction with other people at the table and it's just not easy to get those sort of people in real life although that being said this is improved with my sampton grou because a
few of us do own AR over there and a few of us have played it so it does occasionally hit the table nicely there and I can certainly play it with people to know what they're doing at a convention but yeah I mean I love the game but BL me yeah a new player h
and my number one and yeah I've noticed that a lot of these games I've mentioned are in my top 10 of all time or at least they were in my recent list so maybe that kind of speaks volumes because some of these games have had expansions which means I love introducing that content some of these games are definitely more fun when people are on the same wavelength which is going to impact the ability to play this with Noobs but this one um I tend to more be the noob in this one I mean I know what I'm doing in this game but I am by no means an expert I mean I can barely beat difficulty three and four on this game and there are people out there who can beat difficulty five and six and they sleep still don't know how they do it but I'm the one that wants to be the noob in this game I don't want other people to be the noob in spirit Island Spirit Island's fantastic it is one of my favorite co-ops of all time it is a brilliant game not for everybody which is fair play to say you know there are people that are going to bounce off this quite hard but I had a chance to play this and they were saying oh there's going to be four of us if we play this and it's like oh I'm already a bit hesitant wanting to play this for three or four but well three is not bad but four is quite a SLO and I was about to sort of jump into it thinking you know what this would be quite cool and then they said oh and I'm teaching two new people oh yeah and I moved over to the arnac game Spirit Island I this game is a long game as it is it's Lex there's a lot of
interactions you've got a ton of discussion to deal with for how you're going to deal with the Invaders from turn to turn I don't have the Strategic expertise of this game to be able to make the best decisions in the world but trying to teach the rules of this game of which there are a fair few trying to make people understand their character Spirit panels which even with the low complexity ones are still going to have a fair amount to deal with you know unique cards and strategies and that and get through the game in a reasonable time frame when it's already going to burn your brain because you got to keep track of all this stuff that's going on oh my god oh this is this is a SLO let me go back in there and face the Peril it's too perilous and it's all right if I'm the noob here because then at least I already know the rules I understand the interactions but then somebody else who knows the game better can at least guide me a little bit through like the tracking of what's going on with a lot of these creatures or like here's how we deal with this difficulty six monstrosity you know we just got to do this and this and it's like you know thanks I'm learning something here but I'm at the lowest playing level here in terms of the noob factor and I know the game fairly well you know sorry I know the game very well but in terms of strategic nature I'm probably only intermediate at the game but to do brand new no no no no no no it just takes way too long people have asked me if I'm willing to teach Spirit Island the three of them and I'm just like no not happening don't want to teach this game I just want to play it with people who
know what they're doing and you know I'll have a lot of fun I mean Spirit Island honestly is a game I play solo more often than multiplayer anyway because of how long it takes and the fact that I don't want to teach it but I can play it true solo if I'm mad I could even play it two-handed although I just find that a bit too much to track I'd much prefer to just play it true solo that does limit me on certain Spirit but what you going to do but I just save those spirits that don't work solo for multiplayer games but but yeah I there's a reason I do play this one so though because noobs for this one kind of scare me they scare me I'm I don't want to be teaching this one there's too much going on too much to track too much complexity too much interaction even though it's a co-op which normally should be a better one to teach because you can teach co-ops in a specific way and make it easier for new players but for example I mean you know I've just got all the uh Deep Rock Galactic expansions through cannot wait to play through these but this game Co-op I don't have to teach probably more than a third of the rules in this game maybe half tops before we can get stuck into a game and then I can just teach you the stuff as we go through this one in contrast to something like Spirit island is an absolute pleasure to like teach with new players I will gladly play Deep Rock Galactic with new players any day of the week but you can't do that with Spirit Island it's just way too much and for me it's why it boosted up to number one even above Arc nover two of my favorite games of all well three of my favorite
games of all time in fact actually how many of these were on my top 10 Arc nover gin Spirit Island uh and Earth I'm not sure about arnac did arnac get the top 10 I'm not sure but maybe Seven Wonders but yeah we're talking not nearly half of this list are my favorite games of all time I guess that speaks some volumes you know I like to play some of my favorite games with people who also find them to be their favorite games and therefore are on a similar playing field just the way it is this is the way so there you have it my top 10 games and I don't like to play with Noobs but again I'm not mean meaning it as a derogative it's just you know newer players you know some of these games I think function better for me personally when I play it with people who know what they're doing it's not to say I will never teach any of these games although I think like I said Spirit island is probably one I will never teach you know there are certainly there are things like that but I mean I've taught kerer I've taught Scythe I've taught Great Western Trail New Zealand I've taught Arn I've taught her geminy you know those games I have taught but if you give me the option I'm naturally going to take the other one in a lot of these other games I'd probably rather play with people who know what they're doing I mean you know de Rock Galactic I love teaching that to new players but if people know what they're doing it's probably going to be a better experience overall but not enough to make me not want to teach it um you know Star Wars alter Rim love to play that game with people don't know what they're doing but teaching it's not that bad it's F Matic it's story driven and people usually get it after short while and I think a lot of it does come down to like the
immersion and the like the length and complexity cuz there's a fair amount of rules and Star Wars outter Rim but the immersion factor is so high that you're playing this with the right people you don't mind teaching it and having it take a bit longer CU you're you're engaged in what's going on Deep Rock Galactic again immersive but also smooth to teach it's a very easy one to teach Deep Rock Galactic and the smoother a game is to teach the more likely I'm willing to play this with new players cuz it doesn't feel like a slug anymore more and certainly if the game has not been expanded up the wazu with all these extra bits that I want to throw in then that's an advantage in itself although some of these games are actually just as good with expansions and without I mean Pursuit of Happiness I can teach that with expansions although the game will take a bit longer so I'm sometimes a bit hesitant on that but you know as I look around yeah let's see what the games what games with expansions do I not well Seven Wonders Architects one of the easiest games to teach in the world that's not an expansion wingspan I'll happily teach wingspan with every single expansion included all the European birds the Asia Birds and the Oceana Birds barely changes the complexity all you got to do is teach one or two with little extra things that the Oceana board throws in and the Oceana board balances a few other aspects so you know why would you not you a lot of these games do work even while teaching them and some of these games are still good fun to teach to other players and I mean all games are fun to teach in some respect but yeah when you start getting to these top 10 and maybe a few others on top I mean I did consider xcon XCOM was hard to say I've played it with new players before and it's been good
fun but because it's a Speed game in some respects a new player dealing with the whole speed aspect can be a little bit problematic but there wasn't really much I could think of with honorable mentions on this one so I'd be interested to know your thoughts on the subject what games do you not want to play with Noobs or are you less wanting to teach what are your reasons do they overlap with mine or particularly do you have a reason that you don't want to teach these games that I have haven't thought of I'd definitely be interested to know that so that's it for me on this episode of the broken meeple if you like what you see then please thumb it up and leave a comment as requested check out all the other content I've been doing from best and worst series to Normal reviews to speed reviews and as we get up to Essen it's going to be a lot more content besides I mean that deep rock Galactic expansion I was showing there oh yeah I'm going to do a beyond the base game video for that so there's a lot stuff to come in the next few weeks but until next time remember regardless of whether you consider yourself a noob or not we still enjoy teaching games to you it's all good and it's only a game bye for now