Top 10 Underrated Board Games
Transcript
Hello everyone. This is Sonovan
and this is Johannes
and you're watching Board Gaming Ramblings.
And today we are going to talk to you about our top 10 underrated games
because we did this a few years ago and we want to do it again because the thing is we look a lot to to the now and to the future. There's a lot of the cult of the new. There's a lot on this channel which are new games, new games, new games, new games. And we like to look back as well. We did a couple of videos where we looked back at all their top 10 list. We might want to do more of that.
Yes, that was fun.
And someday I would like to start a new round of Deep Cull. We will see when that's going to happen. Never. But for now, this is a great way I feel like to highlight some games that I we feel that aren't talked about enough.
Yes,
there's a couple of rules. There's basically only two rules, three rules with the one rule that's kind of a rule, but only two. If you don't account that one rule, that is kind of a rule. Okay,
rule number one, the game has to be at least 2 years old, which means not like to this date, but it has to be from 2023 or earlier
or earlier. Not not like exactly 2 years. Uh or under budget game only two years old. So, it cannot be a game from this year obviously or last year because like those games can still climb. Most of them probably won't, but after a couple years, you more see where it lands on the BG rating. That is the other rule is that it has to be at least ranked a thousand or higher on BG
like worse than a thousand.
Yes. Higher number.
Yeah. The higher number.
Yes. Not lower number because that would be like this is Frost Haven is very should be number one.
Yeah. So the last thing which is not a rule it's kind of rule. It's just the way we ordered them. Like sometimes when top 10 is most of the time it's like the worst to best. This is basically ranked from the one closest to a thousand to which is number 10.
Yeah.
To the one that's farthest away to from thousand which is basically the one
the one we think is the most or the one that is the most underrated.
Yeah.
Kind of that is that is the the thing. So from the closest to a thousand to the closest to a million that is the one. I don't have anyone close to a million. I'm very uh excited or curious to see if we got Yep. Both uh just can't hide it. Uh to see uh how many crossovers we have for this song wouldn't be as good.
I'm so curious. I just can't hurious. No, wouldn't be. Yes, crossovers. Sorry. Uh as always, we don't know each other's list. Yeah. Uh because we like to do it that way. A couple of times it does a joint top 10 list and it is something that we we do from time to time, but most of the time we think it's more fun. Even though sometimes we have similar taste. Okay, I think we're going to have I don't think we're going to have many. I think we're going to have one, two, three. Maybe that four. Okay, I'm going to go with Oh, you're first. You're first.
I was thinking
we're guessing the number of crossovers.
I was thinking four.
Yes.
So, I'm putting one extra. So, I'm going five.
Then I'm going to go six. Oh, you remember
what what was your initial thought? Five years. But basically, the last time we did a guess
Mhm.
I was actually right.
Oh, yeah.
Because we on the top 10 trick taking games because we counted it wrong.
Yes.
Yes. So, I was correct.
I was It was weird. Yes.
Are you ready?
And these are going to be a lot of different kind of games. They're not going to be
put all the same game is only the never gets old.
Okay. Let's start number 10. And let's see who begins by doing rock, paper, scissors.
Okay, cool.
One, two, three. No, it's Oh, okay. On three. Okay. One, two, three. No, on three. What happened? On three. You did on three and then you suddenly don't do on three. You changed your own rules.
What?
You did one, two, three, and then you did it again. You did one, two, three, and continued. So, you did different. But now, let's do it. One, two, three. On three. One, two, three. I begin. I don't. It's very hard rules. You're very very hard for you to know the rules.
Loser.
What am I a sore loser?
I just did the rock and you had this. Yeah. Just
No. No. You didn't. You continued. Okay, you can start because No, no, you always start. So, let's go. You start or else it's going to be weird. I don't know why we even did this thing because it wasn't found in my brain and then you didn't know the rules to the game.
My number 10
is rock paper scissors
is Signori. Okay. It is a game from 2015. So, it's been on the market for a while.
I don't think it's on the market anymore for many years.
Oh, that's maybe I don't think you can get it like at all.
And then I will redact it from
It can be underrated even though you can't get it. That's not true.
It's not your job to go in and see, can you buy this on Amazon?
Well, it should be in print because it's an amazing game. I think it's it's a really good game. It's uh ranked
What kind of game is it? It's ranked uh,092 on BG BG
for at this moment. Maybe not anymore, but yeah. Um, it is a game uh with dice in it and it has a pretty cool dice mechanism where you're drafting dice in different colors and depending on which color they are, you do different actions and you can also upgrade those actions so they get better. And there are different uh things you can do in the game, but depending on if you have a high dye or a low dye, it will give you the opportunity to do um the more if you have the high dye. But you're trying to get the low dice because those are cheaper and also if you don't exceed an limit, you will get some extra bonus at the end of the round. And you do your stuff basically and little like stuff.
But but
you do your stuff and a little stuff.
I like the dice mechanism a lot in this game.
And also it's a very nice theme where you
No,
it's a very
they're marrying off your daughters and stuff.
And stuff. It's a lot of stuff in this game.
Yes, it's things and stuff.
Things and stuff. This is like one of the best games ever. There's things and then there's hero things and stuff. I think it has like a random thing where you roll for what gender your kids are going to be. No, that's not that one.
I don't I don't think I don't remember what this is at all.
Oh, maybe it's just like the
No, no, you're speaking about a completely different game.
I thought this was it.
No, I think you're that's like No, that's I don't think it's
Forget about that.
It might be. Do you It's like I don't even know anything about this game. It's just on my list.
No, I know a lot about it. Just not that part.
No. So, that's why you brought it up. It's a great way of showing that you have a lot of information and also I think there's mechanisms in this game. My number 10 I don't know
my number 10 is uh ranked 1,091 on board game geek and it was mine,91.
No 1,092.
So it actually moved down a step because mine is senor. So from you I made my list you made your list something moved up. Yes.
Yes. Senoria I like for all the reasons you said for example the Euro stuff and the things. This is one of my favorite part of the game where you do things and then euro stuff and then other stuff.
I really enjoy the dice drafting. Dice drafting is kind of the mechanism of the game but you also have this board where you upgrade your actions so that you get better things in your draft. You will draft only one of each color each round. So it's also interaction in that part where I'm like I really need that six uh and I know that I'm going to get that four because you already took that dice. So the other four players, other two players or three players took the dice already in that color. So now that's going to be mine and that's could be good or it could be bad. And there's a lot of different reasons for doing different things and stuff and euro greatness. So I really like it. It's not going to be easy to get I think because it's what's your game game, but it is a good one and I think it's underrated. My number nine is I I'm pretty sure this is on your list, too, because it's one of the games where we always think, "Oh, that's that's the hidden gem."
I'm going to guess that it is number on the BJ stats. I'm going to guess it's 11:47.
Oh, it's actually 11:48.
It went even one more because it's the same game.
Yes, it's a river boat. This is fun because this means that this might be a list where we get more perfect crossovers because of the thing. We will see. But yeah, uh river boat.
It's it's both our list. So giant banner at the bottom. Riverboat.
Riverboat from 2017. It was uh the year that Michael Keling released two other games.
I think there were four.
There were Azul, Riverboat, the beer game, what's it called? Heaven. Ever nail and Reworld.
Oh, that was also Yes,
that was also a game.
Yes. Um but but Riverboat is a very nice game that gets too little um attention in my in our opinion
and Reorld was also a game that doesn't need to be remembered.
The other ones Soul is like become an old like old time now and also having a nail is a super solid game and that has gotten more recognition for sure. river boat has very like um concrete phases like in this phase of the game you're doing this and you go through these I think it's four or five phases in a round and you're basically uh sewing uh what crops crops and you're harvesting them and you're using those crops to buy river boats to get
send them on the boats ascending on the boats yes thematic it has like a drafting phase in the beginning where you draft which player is going start each phase. So then you get a bonus when you do that phase and you get to start that phase. So it's it's one of those where I always call perfect medium game because it's just it's just buttery smooth. It's easy to teach because of the faces because you always do the same thing. It's basically oh now we're going to flip the cards. Everyone going to place a thing there. Now we're going to flip that. It's not like oh it's your turn. What do you want to do?
And that was also my number nine. So let's go back. Maybe this is just going to be 10 perfect crossovers. I don't think so. Oh, I think this is on your list, too.
I'm going to guess it's number 1437.
It's 1436.
Oh, it that only moved once. I weird how things something moved twice and another.
No, no, no. It has moved once for all of them. You said uh 11:47 10 91.
Oh, I just Okay.
But th those two moved uh backwards, but this have moved up a space
to 34.
No, 36. You had 35. Okay, so it has moved down.
I was thinking not underrated anymore. It's the same for me. This is super weird. We never This is a crisis.
Yes. Judo talk.
Crisis is a no-brainer on this list. Uh it is a super solid work placement game with like a semicolop aspect in it.
And before you hate it, it's not semi co-op. Yes. It's basically everyone can lose. Yes. Or one player can win.
Yeah. And it's basically if one player does really poorly,
the game ends. Or Yes. Not if another player does very well.
That's true. That's true. But in this game, you're basically trying to um make factories, have people work at your factories, and then convert resources into other resources and also get points.
And it has like
It sounds so much fun. It has like a programming kind of worker placement uh style where you're placing all the workers first and then you go through the action spaces um which sometimes can be a little weird when you're planning like
but it's not really a programming like there's many worker placement games where you place everything first and you resolve in an order basically. It's super good. We played it pretty recently. I don't remember why.
It's probably a few years ago. Do you think so? Okay. I feel like Oh, I feel like I played it. I actually think that I played it previously.
Yes, you did. Without me, probably two years or one year. But it's a fantastic game. It is one of those where you everything you do feels important and it's very hard to know what you're supposed to do. You're trying to get enough resources and to get these factories running is so satisfying. Yeah.
Like, okay, but because I put this there, then I produce a lot of victory points and I produce these things that I need for the other factory for next round. is just like it's a super good game and this one I think you can get pretty cheaply. So if you can find a copy and you like medium euro games I highly recommend.
Yes. And my number seven um I'm I'm
Let's see if we avert now.
Yeah, I think we do.
Okay. Which which rank is it?
It is 1463
is the same one.
Okay. So we could just make the same. It's It's hard to know,
but this is actually quite funny because this has never happened before in this way.
I think I'm not going to win the crossover thing.
I know. I think I will win.
Uh, that time you killed me 2021.
This is so I think this is so funny because I I I don't think we're going to I don't think it's going to happen all the way to the top. I think it's No, it's not. But I think it's really fun
because we Some people say, "Why don't you have a joint list because of this?" Because this is fun. This is fun for us as well. And I really think it's fun how we we like have very similar taste in some things. So yeah, continue talking about that time you killed me, a time traveling game.
It is a very clever abstract game. I would say it's one of the best abstracts games that I've played and that's also why I think it's underrated. I think it should be higher also among the abstract games if you just like look at that as a genre.
One of the most thematic abstract games. Yes. It's just like
but it's weird like it's
and it has fun storytelling in when you're like because you're escalating kind of how you're getting into the game. It's scenario. Yeah. Scenario based. So it's it's very clever. It's funny. It's um a lots of lots of replayability. Um so if you're into abstracts,
you probably already played it.
Yes. It's good. You should you should
the cool thing is that's a time traveling theme. So you're playing on three boards and whatever happens in the f like in the past will also happen in the past the present and the future but if you do something in the future it won't also happen in the past. So it's like it's all of these different things that is super duper cool. I really want to play it again. Uh it's a really great game and that was also my number eight.
Oh it's back to me again. And I I think now is where we're going to we're going to going to not have the same anymore.
Really? Right now, you think?
Yes, I do.
Mhm.
If not, I'm going to be pretty surprised.
Okay. My number six is Lenum Second Edition.
Oh,
you'd skip that one.
No. Are you Are you sure? Then then we're going to have a lot of games that are not the same.
Oh,
basically.
Okay.
Yes. Because this is 2340
41.
Yes.
So, it's moved
again. Everything moved. Yes, it's from 2017. I'm guessing this is also on your list later.
Maybe. I don't know. Spoiler alert.
Well, Lingum is a super crunchy game. One of the heaviest games that I have played because of the harshness of the oneway street and also that you're like trying to deduce where the people are going, their players are going to cut their wood at the beginning. And if you go to the same place, you only get half of the things that you wanted to get. And that really sucks. And also, you need everything on that oneway street. Uh but you can't get everything because people will get Yes.
So you really uh have to pick and choose carefully where you're stopping. Everything seems super important. And also on top of that, you're trying to plan something several turns ahead, which seems super duper impossible, especially the first times around. If you're into heavy games, highly recommend if you're not, steer clear of this game.
Not go away, but stay away from this game. Go away. I'm going to say that I was thinking, and this is kind of funny because I never think about theme.
I was thinking I wonder why street makes no sense thematically. Like when you're sailing for example in Francis Drake it kind of makes sense because you can't like turn your ship around but I I was thinking there is no thematic and I thought for one second and I could make up a thematic for it.
But in Francis Drake you're shopping in the wonder street before you go on so it doesn't make any sense.
Makes it doesn't matter. I don't know but the thing is I was thinking the reason here and that's the same I would say for that one is that you're in a rush.
Yes.
You don't have time like thematically. I don't I don't know. Why is this channel only about theme? I don't like it. Let's go to my number six, which is not the same as yours. My number six is 1855, so probably 1856 and maybe 1857 or eight when you see this, which is Wild Tiled West.
Wild Tiled West was is one of the very few games, if any, game where I borrowed it or we borrowed it, played it, and then we bought it. Have we opened that copy that we bought? No.
Will we open it?
I hope so.
I don't know. When will we open it?
Yes.
2028.
So, but it's a it's a really good game and it's another lightish game. It's a tie placement game. It has some randomness in you're rolling some dice to be able to know what you can draft. So, you can be like, "Oh, the thing I want never comes up." There's ways around that. And there's always something good. You're trying to fill in things in specific ways. Many different reasons why you want to fill in these different things. And it's a suburb game. Not like suburbia, but a superb game. That's what I was trying to say. Really good one. That was my number seven, I think. Back to you.
Yeah. Wild. I'm excited for rest of your list.
Was on my short list, so I That was really close to making it. I agree. It's underrated as well. My number five is Doodle Dash.
Okay.
From 2021. It's ranked 3,23 23 as of maybe now. We don't know. Yes, we we said that. We're gonna No more of that thing.
Oh, we're not going to say it anymore.
Are we going to say the ranking? We're just going to not say every time. Maybe something else.
I will probably say it four more times.
Doodle Dash. It's a clever party drawing game. What I think it's clever about this game is that it's fun.
It's Yes. You don't need to be good at drawing to be good in this game because you have basically the best thing is to do to match speed and skill. So you don't want to draw sit and be like super detailed like some of other games that will help you with that note because people are not going to guess your your drawing because you're late to the party. You're drawing as simple, as fast as you can, making it somewhat understandable, and you're grabbing like a piece, and then the people are going to guess the fastest players first, basically. And that kind of solves my problem with some of the other drawing games. Um, Pto Mania is another I like, but that's high higher ranked. And also, Doodle Dash is more like for everyone.
So, if you haven't heard of this, go check it out.
100% fantastic. One of my two favorite drawing games with Ptomania being the other one. Next one for me is 1865. So, very close to the other one.
And this is Shogun No Katana.
Shogun No Katana is a fantastic worker placement game with its biggest downside being it's long.
It's so long.
It's very long. It's like an hour per player, which is long,
but it is so good. It has a super good worker placement system, but where it shines is your board where you are basically moving these resources around to build swords and you're trying to move them in specific ways to to to to score the specific swords and and it's just a super unique interesting puzzle I've never seen before and probably will never see again. M I totally skipped. It might have been on the list because it's really good.
Yes.
And underrated.
And what was the rank you said?
Uh 118. No, 1865.
Okay. Yeah. And my number four is Electropolis from 2019 and we're up in 3,476. And Electropolis is one of my favorite like city building games. It's super tight. It's pretty difficult to do the things you're trying to do without doing a lot of bad stuff on the way because you're drafting tiles, but the more tiles you decide to take, the later you will be in the drafting. And also, you have to take pieces that are adjacent to each other. That means if I'm a third player to draft then the people have taken other stuff and suddenly the things that I thought was going to be adjacent to each other is not anymore.
And what the card you play for that round decides also in where in what sector of the board you can build in. So the tiles that I drafted suddenly I don't want to place in that sector anymore. And also you're building your scoring that way as well. So
a very simple game rules-wise. Not that long either. I find it's pretty simple and short, but it's a lot of puzzly brainy activity going on there. So I would say if you're playing this game, you get a lot of game in a short amount of time. So that's talking about low low complexity, high depth.
It's a great game. I really really like it. My number four is number 2,299 on the list.
Ah, I know exactly what
and is Forge Warh,
the first game from Isaac Childris. This is I don't think you can get it very easily and I don't think it will never get a reprint. Uh, but it just if you like Isaac Childris goes out and he makes this as his as his first game and then he's like, let's make another one. Let's make Gloom Haven as my second game all by myself. He is a genius. Like um Forge War is a big heavy strategic game where you can make a whole army of Rodo. That's my favorite part of it. It's not my favorite part, but I always choose to do that.
Awesome.
I
It starts every round with you basically playing, hey, that's my fish. you are moving a minor inside a mine to get resources and then you can do like one action and then you're trying to get the things you need to be able to fulfill contracts and all these contracts have these timing preferences. So you have to be able to do this this round, then this next round, this this round. And the there is like a short game which is boring and short, but you can play the full game which takes forever, but it's also a lot of fun. A very very game, a game where you have to plan ahead a lot. And I really want to play it again. It's one of those games that I will always be happy to play, but it takes some time to do so.
I agree. It's very game.
It is very game. One of the most game game. subscribe.
Uh yes. Uh my number three is
number three
another city building game and it's Small City from 2015 ranked at 3,691 and it's from the guy who makes all the other city building games. I don't remember his name.
No, we haven't said a single designer in this whole video. So, let's start with one you don't remember the name. Alvin VR.
Thank you. Um,
and he hasn't made all the other city building games. Like, he hasn't made Suburbia. He didn't made Electropolis,
but he did make the other one that you don't like,
but city center.
He's kind of into spatial puzzles is my point. Oh, yeah. And this he's very good at it.
Yes. He's he's not into the mayor.
No, the mayor is is in the game. Small city. It's the mayor that you can play.
It's the mayor.
It's the mayor. the most annoying mayor in the world. He's like standing in the middle of your board being like, "I'm looking around. Do we want to build that?" Nope. I'm looking around.
Back to you.
I would say it's very deserving that this game has gotten a second edition. Yeah, maybe uh more beautiful uh one which we haven't played yet.
We haven't even opened it.
No, we haven't.
We still have We have two versions of this game because I heard there is some things in the new one that isn't as good. So, I want to play that before we get rid of the old one.
And it's very like thematic citybuer puzzle because everything affects everything. So, you're trying to balance what kind of buildings you have and also how they affect each other and how they will like how your city expands basically.
And also so people from dying from pollution.
Yes. Very nice. Um yeah, great game.
And and I have one question.
Yes.
Is it underrated?
It is. My number three
is going to be a crossover.
Mhm.
It's number 2,340 on the list
and it's Lingum.
Yeah.
Yes. I was just I was just make I was just because it's Yes. I was just a bit when off in yeah
I don't know what happened there. My word stopped. Lingum all the reasons you said. I know you like that I also say things and not me specifically but that we don't just say crossover and back to you. Lingum makes my brain work. I haven't played in a few years now. I really want to go back because every time you play a heavier game again, like many years apart, sometimes they go like, "Oh, that wasn't too bad." Yeah,
I think Lingham is still going to be pretty crunchy. I don't know if it's going to be as crunchy as it was when we played it lost, but it is one of those games where
everything matters. Like you do all of the things and they matter.
Great words. I I I was trying to find things that you haven't already said. I said it all.
The oneway street is my favorite of it. And also you have to prepare for winter because winter is coming. It is
and you have to be like sometimes if you have a sled you could do something in the winter or else you will not be able to.
I'm very curious what other games you have now.
Number two back to you.
My number two is uh a fairly new game. You just made this
2023.
2023. It's L ranked 4,288. That's too low.
Great game.
It's a great game. It's pretty simple and it's about like having a production line and you're drafting cards to get at that inter production line and you're kind of bidding with your action points. So, the fewer things you're saying you're going to do this turn, the earlier you will be in the turn order. and that it seems so crucial. So this is a very like interactive game in in that regards. So you're trying to make production line trying to produce the things you need to score points and also trying to to basically see what other players are likely going to take and how many action points you can squeeze out without being the person going lost.
Yeah, really really good game. I want to play it again. Yes,
we still own it. My number two is going to be another uh crossover.
It's 3,474 Electropolis.
For all the reasons you said, I really enjoy the drafting of the tiles, like the dilemma of do I want to get that exact thing I want or do I just want to get more stuff? But like you you didn't like go in deep with it because there is a lot of tiles that are bad and you don't want them. But if you are stuck like you see some rounds you're going to put out the doors and be like ah it's not going to be good to be lost this round because you're going to get stuck with all these bad buildings. But maybe there is a way you can turn it around do something good with it. But it is one of those where it's it's as you said like it's it's pretty simple. It's a lightish game but with a lot of great decisions and a lot of fun.
Yeah.
Number one. It's the only one left. It is number one.
Number one. My number one is also from 2023.
What
do you want to guess what it is?
I know because there's How would I know? There's so many games.
I think maybe this was from the same company that did L or the same publisher. It's ranked at 4,942. It's Kelte. Kelte is a great game. It is also super interactive and you're moving um between these different like action. Yeah, it's a rondelle and you're trying to collect these colored pieces and how many colored pieces are in your player board and also which colors they are makes you better or worse at different actions. So it's a very I would say um tactical game. We're trying to see opportunities like oh now you opened up that opportunity. I should probably capitalize on that but that was not my plan to stop there. Then I move past that space in the rondelle that makes and it it's when it's nearing its end it's like suddenly over. So you're feeling like you have to race for the things that you're you wanting the entire time and it's pretty short also.
I very Yes. So So this is also a game where you get a lot of crunchy decision making in a short amount of time and it's really good at four players.
I think we did a play through of this and I think it was like 25 minutes the whole video. Like it's a very short game. I think we can play it in 20 minutes with two players and maybe 25. But it's a really really good one. My number one is going to be a crossover. It's going to be Small City because Small City from the second time I played it. Actually, from the first time I played it, just the other people around the table didn't understand anything that was going on. It was in the middle of the night. I was super excited to teach it. I just got it at a convention one of the last times we went to Gothcon in Gutenberg in Sweden. And it was you and it was two more people. I will not name them. Maybe they want don't want to be named. Don't know why, but I will not name them. Those who should not be named, let's call them Bob and Bobby.
Bob Bobby socks. Bob. Uh, but but from the second time, I I don't know how, but you both you all want to play it again the next time day. Maybe because I said we're playing this and we did. And it's it's a great game. H the feeling it's interactive. It has frustrating moments. And the mayor is always there. If you're a first player, you're going to get that mayor plunk down your city and he's not going to move. He's just going to be looking at your buildings and standing in the way of your building plans because all the other people decide where the mayor goes and you're going to draft people which have abilities on them and then you're going to build all these buildings and trying to be the best at doing these things. It is a it has like a player shields because you're building is hidden so people don't see what you're doing. It is a great game and it is more available now. I think because of the new edition. I don't know how available it is. I don't know if there's like a a a big printing of it, but it is one I I recommend if you are into heavy games.
If you're not into heavy games, go away. I mean, stay away from the game. And now you can
subscribe.
Yes. And that is going to be the end of the video.
How many crossovers did we get?
I don't know. Maybe six.
One, two, three, four, five, six, seven.
I win.
Yay.
And those are our top 10 underrated games. What is your top underway games? Let us know in the comments. Maybe there are some great games that we need to check out. And that is going to be the end of this video. Thank you so much for watching. I'm Johannes.
I'm Sen.
And you've been watching Board Gaming Ramblings. And bye-bye.