The Best Modern Alternatives to Classic Games – Board Games & Coffee Ep. 7
Transcript
good morning and welcome to board games and coffee today I have a very uh interesting episode for you something I've never done before this is actually a brainstorm for a future pre-recorded um video that I'd like to release incoming weeks I'd like to talk about uh my favorite alternatives for classic board games and this is in part inspired by the series that I've done called the better than Series so I've got my better than everdell better better than wingspan better than Ticket to Ride I do all of these videos and a lot of feedback has been coming back from them people really like them and they want to see some more so I thought why don't I tackle all of the classics so uh I'll tell you what the classics are and I'm going to go through I've got at least 13 here but I want to emphasize that the purpose of this video uh isn't to show you all the games but to talk through what I'm thinking about because I'm looking for feedback from my subscribers so if you've got a recommendation please include it in the chat or if you're watching this after the live recording you can write it in the comments the one thing I'm going to say though is that I'm going to do comments at the end so if you're writing out your recommendation for the game that I'm currently talking about I'll need context when I go over that so don't just write like oh that you know this reminds me of such and such game like tell me for Monopoly it reminds me
of such and such game that'll help me out a lot when I'm reviewing at the end um so first to get your gears turning on what your favorite recommendations are for classic board games I will tell you the 13 that I have in in mind and then just to make sure that this video isn't too long CU I can go on and on talking about games I'll probably just tell you one thing about each of my own recommendations we'll keep it short and then if you want to learn more about the games you can wait until I do the full you know pre-recorded episode or you know video it won't be a live show um yes so first these are the classic board games that I'll be talking about today so there's in no particular order Monopoly Scrabble Guess Who Clue taboo man risk life Checkers chess back gaming cribbage connect for and Battleship so those are the games and I think what we'll do is we'll just start talking about what I've got planned so I guess start at the top Monopoly so one alternative and one best thing about it keeping this short it's Monopoly my alternative it was tough because I wanted something that has some sort of dice role but I decided to
emphasize the property and the earning of money in for Monopoly so I'm going with for sale because in for sale you spend one round bidding on all the properties and in the second round you are using the properties that you purchased in the first round to uh essentially bid for the most money so it's got some really interesting Dynamic it's a lot shorter than Monopoly that's that's my one thing about for sale I'm going to move on so Scrabble oh you know what I have copies of these games for Scrabble my favorite game is actually a deck builder paperback now paperback uh has you constructing words with point value like Scrabble and you use the point value of the word you spell to buy higher valued cards so you can score more and more points it's got a it's a really fun deck builder that's paperback now for Guess Who and clue the game is the same game let me get ready so what I think is essential about those games is every player has some piece of information and everyone is trying to piece it together together so the game that does that but logically with great uh much much more logic
involved is the game crypted so this is a game where much like clue everybody has a piece of evidence about where the crypted exists and you're asking questions to all players in order to deduce it is a lot more complicated logically than something as simple as clue or guess who but it's an excellent um modern alternative all right for taboo I love this so I recommend trap words what I love about trap words is it's just like taboo you're trying to guess the words that uh your teammate has they're hiding but instead of being able to uh or instead of your opponents having a list of things you can't say your opponents are responsible for making the list so there's a lot of strategy as you as the opponents are thinking about what words might you say and they're recording a list and then you're thinking about what words might our opponent say it is a ton of fun and it's a brilliant alternative to Taboo now Malala is next on my list Malala has a that picking up Stones mechanic and dropping the stones off and in modern Euro board games there aren't
a lot of games like it and I couldn't find something that was as simple but I did find something that had that same element of planning Crusaders so Crusaders has a manala action element where you're dropping off stones to select what action you'll do and then the big differences you're moving on a map of Europe because you're Crusaders oh look at that boom anyway I think it's awesome and it's not too hard it really does Center on that mangala element whereas a game like five tribes which is an alternative I was thinking about five tribes has a Malala element but it's much more complicated so I didn't include it on this list the next one is uh risk so you know a game of World Domination now what's fun is beefing up your armies and going out and dominating the world uh the game that captures that but does not embody any of the luck no dice rolling at all it's one of my favorite games ever it's the game Imperial I'm not going to pull out but uh uh Imperial is actually more about investing in countries and so as you're investing in the bonds of one country you get to control it and you get to
control its armies and so you spread out your armies but then an opponent can invest more than you and take control of the company out from under you and you can do that to other opponents as well uh it's more about money than it is about world domination but I do really enjoy that it escapes the frustration of luck from risk I'm not going to relive those high school years on this video today all right next one the next one is The Game of Life which hold on a second this is a big box it's it's a big box okay I choose the pursuit of happiness wow okay I found this one on Amazon I could not find like a standard size okay the pursuit of happiness is a worker placement game in the style of the game of life so if what you enjoy about the game of life is talking about your spouse or whether you go to college or what kind of job you get or if you have kids like all of these things those are all options and choices that you can pursue in the pursuit of happiness but you have a lot more choice because it's worker place placement and it is thematically much richer um and harder too but it's it's fantastic and then I've
got the big box there which has all of these expansions so you can have experiences and Nostalgia there's there's a lot of stuff to unload in that game and I think it's wonderful I'm going to do a bigger review for that sometime soon I want to play through some of the expansions first all right next one Checkers all right I get two for Checkers one of them I don't own one of them is battles sheep which you can find on board game arena I'll talk about the one that I own it's hey that's my fish so hey that's my fish is a oh man you're moving Penguins so it's it's more for it's for more than two players so you're moving penguin SPS around on a hexagonal grid and every time you move you remove the tile that you were previously on so the board is getting smaller and smaller and smaller now it doesn't have the element of capturing pieces like Checkers does but what it does have is the element of trapping pieces because as you reduce the size of the board and you're removing these hexes players get kind of abandoned on these ice flows so um and it's really quick to play it has a much quicker ending because the board is getting smaller as you play whereas checkers can go on and on only one thing on each game Ben all
right next one did I pull it out yep the next one is my modern adaptation of Chess so what's the alternative for chess this is my favorite abstract modern game of of all Santorini Santorini is uh you got builders in your you're moving your building so the board is always changing which I understand that's not in chess uh but one thing it does get is that once you have uh mastered the base game you can throw in all of these expansions or or sorry not expansions God powers to give your pieces something a new twist so that's my favorite one it's thematic as well um all right there's a lot man I trying to stick to only one per game all right next one what is it back gaming back is the next game and so my favorite alternative to back gam is mountain goats so mountain goats you think about what's fun about back gamon you're planning on which piece to move
in order to get home or in order to uh capture your opponents and so mountain goats has a really similar element you're rolling Dice and you you have more dice you have four dice and you canair them however you'd like to move up the mountains and when you move up on mountains you'll get points at the top of the mountain or you can try to knock an opponent off the mountain and send them back down to the bottom kind of like sending or trapping a piece in back ging so I think those are actually relatively similar in both luck and um duration okay I'm making a good time the next one okay uh you know I'm going to say that for last the next one is Connect 4 so Connect 4 this is far better than Connect 4 but I was looking at a list of of uh classic games all right Boop a lot of people have discovered my channel through a short that I did on the game of boop boop you're trying to collect or put three cats in a row you're not dropping the pieces in that TR prey so you don't get the satisfaction of that rattling sound and that click as they land but you do get the satisfaction of booping in the game called Boop which means bumping other pieces off the board you're trying to get three in a row but you got to be
careful because you can bump bump your own pieces as well all right and oh Battleship okay so Battleship um the the mechanic that I would compare the element of Battleship to is the secret movement mechanic there's a whole class of games that are secret movement games I'm going to show you my favorite it is mind management so mind management almost like battleship in that you there's a grid you're trying to think of where your opponent is or guess where your opponent is but there are certain objectives because they're always moving so you're always guessing they're always moving moving and there are certain events that you can use to kind of mix up uh your plans and try to confuse your opponent from from both sides um worth looking at a little a little more complicated than Battleship though for sure all right and the last one is cribbage and I saved it for last because cribbage you've got a card game with multiple phases right you've got the pegging and then you're counting and and of course you get to pick out cards I couldn't decide if I wanted to pick a game that was most like it or in in mechanics or most like it in the feeling and so I'm a little split on
this and I I got three options but maybe I'll I'll end the video with this one and see what kind of feedback I get later on so for cribbage I'll get all three of them all right one at a time if you're familiar with these games please let me know what you think is the best alternative for cribbage so the first one is the fox in the forest which is a trick-taking Cooperative game it's a Cooperative game so it's not like cribbage it doesn't have the same uh you know rivalry about it but the thing with fox in the forest is that it's a card game and there's a board that you Peg through you're just trying to cooperatively move through the board so that was mechanically most like cribbage except it's trick taking the next one is Lost Cities Lost Cities you're essentially trying to make runs you get more points for longer runs but you only you have a very strict card limit and you can't take something without giving something so you're always giving cards that are going to be available to your opponent and and then they're doing the same for you so if you're ever you know that familiar feeling in Cribbage where you're going oh I hate to give you this I just I hate to give you this I don't know how to what to choose oh okay well I'm going to be kind I'm going to give you this thing like that is captured in Lost Cities and
then the last one I I choose because it has these two phases of the game it's the game Nirvana and Nirvana is a rolling right kind of it's a Rolland right with a card playing mechanic here's how this works you're rolling here just put it really close to the camera so you see that grid there you're rolling you're filling out that grid and as you do that you're you're adding the the The Columns of dice and every wonder if I can show you this like actually show it's such a weird game and I probably haven't heard of it before because it's not a well-known game that's why I'm putting so much time into this one not trust a lot of people so you've got a grid and as you add the columns they give you the values of cards and so on the side here oops on the side over here where my index finger is you are writing the values of all of the cards that you make at the end of the game and then after all of the dice have been rolled and all of those colored spaces are filled you play a round of of cards where you're playing a card and then your opponent has to try to beat the card and the first person to go out wins so it's a it's a weird it's a weird game but it's neat um and I like that it had that two phases of play first you have to pick how to um write in your dice how to play your dice and then you have to figure out how to play your
cards so those are the the games that I am suggesting the Alternatives that I've got um pretty quick today there was one more game that I put on the list and I didn't address so if you don't have a recommendation for one of the 13 that I have on here or if you don't have an opinion about what is the best alternative to cribbage when I give three options my last question that I leave you the viewer is what is the best alternative for the word for the for the game go for the the game go I couldn't think of a really great option um except well I I got an idea should I tell you about it or should I just let you see what you say I'll let you see what you say anyway thanks for watching I'll see you