Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 57:42

So, hello and a warm welcome. It's great that you're tuning in to my next Patreon voting video. They’ve had a little break recently. I have a Patreon campaign running, and anyone who supports this channel on Patreon can take part in a vote once a month. Yes, where it's decided which topic I should make a video about next month. It’s a small thank you, and well, if people are really supporting me financially because they like my work and think it's good, that makes me really happy and I'm super grateful for it, but I also always want to give something back in some way, and if the campaign keeps growing, there will be even more, but these are small things for now that I try to do, which always seem to be quite popular. I’ve already made a few videos, for example, there was a Patreon voting video about the best dice games, and yes, today it’s about the topic of dungeon crawlers. With these votes, it can happen that topics come up that I’m not really into, or where I might have to talk about a type of game or a subject where I don’t really have much expertise. Um, recently there was a vote about a designer portrait of Reiner Knizia, and yeah, I’m not really that into that.

I haven’t played anywhere near everything by him. Um, in that case, I can often only rely on hearsay and what I know from my research. I’ve obviously spent a lot of time with board games and know a lot from a theoretical perspective, but some things I just don't know from practice. And I will always try to find a good mix—what I know, combined with things that I think have good potential for fans of the genre or the topic, things that could be good. And as I said, it’s turned out to be dungeon crawlers this time, right? I was supposed to do, well, in principle, the best dungeon crawlers, and I’ve been putting this video off for a while for time reasons, because with trade fairs, a thousand review copies to play, and lots of work to do. Uh, as a one-man project, it’s really tough, and people who know my channel, what do I mean by tough? In any case, it’s time-consuming, and people who know my channel know that whenever I say, "Wow, I'm going to do this regularly for the next four weeks," it often doesn't happen, because I try not to force it, but rather do it when I think it will be good, it fits, and I can actually do it. And that’s why I'm starting the videos again now, because I think I have the time for it on a regular basis again. And I’ve also been putting this topic off for so long because I’ve already spent a lot of time dealing with it over the past few weeks . But the real question is, what is a dungeon crawler? What defines it? Um, there isn't a real definition for it. I mean, you won't find anything on Wikipedia, at most for computer games.

But that’s really a completely different corner than board games, especially in this genre. We also live in the age of hybrids. It's not just Ameritrash games and Eurogames anymore. There are often just overlaps, and these days it can really be everything. And yeah, so I found a pretty good definition on BGG, which is actually very simple, saying it's exploration, fighting monsters, collecting loot, and leveling up. So, you explore something, you fight against opponents, usually monsters, you collect loot, you find items, you make your hero better, you can usually level up and get new abilities, and you can equip your character with great skills. Often it’s also the case that between missions you can simply choose how you improve yourself, what items you buy at the market, so that you go into the next mission in better shape. In the past, it was actually the standard for one person to play against many. One person was the Overlord who controlled all the monsters. The other players were the heroes playing against them, and uh, that’s no longer the standard at all these days. It still exists, but very, very, very many games simply put an AI in the place of the Overlord so that all players can play together, which definitely has its advantages.

We’ll get to that in a moment. And yeah, I’ve taken that as my criteria for what makes a dungeon crawler. I'm going to share my top five dungeon crawlers with you, based on my own experience—some only from playing a game or two—and I can simply say they're good and worth recommending for these specific reasons. After that, I’ll just throw a few other games out there that are definitely somehow dungeon crawler-ish. And also somehow not. That’s something we’ll just have to discuss. We can definitely do that. You are also welcome to do that in the comments. And the first game that you basically have to mention when talking about dungeon crawlers is the mother of all dungeon crawlers. Um, that is Descent. It's the game that almost everyone actually knows. A game that brought a great, great many people into the hobby in the first place, where many had their first acquaintance with games that are something other than Risk and Monopoly. And Descent was originally that very, very classic type of game. We have an Overlord who controls all the monsters. We have four different heroes who can each choose a character and then they go into this huge dungeon system. Beat up monsters, get loot, upgrade in between, and the original Descent could easily take, I don't know, 8 or 9 hours. That means you really played it over a weekend, and yeah, that's no longer modern. Uh,

that's not what corresponds to the current zeitgeist. It’s cool if you’re a student or something and have all the time. But most people simply don't have the time, and board game companies have naturally realized that many board gamers are in their 30s , 40s, 50 s—that this really makes up the lion's share of the market—and of course you have to react to that a little bit. Make games that people can actually play, time-wise. It's often that age where you have parents, kids, and yeah, you have to juggle all that, and Descent: Road to Legend compressed this intense, epic game while staying true to its core. So, in principle, anyone who has played Descent 1 can jump right into the second one. Usually , you have missions that consist of two parts. And depending on how well one side—the good guys or the bad guys— performed in the first part of the mission, it has an impact on the second part of the mission. Descent is now also campaign-based. That means you usually play a campaign; there is one in the base game, although it's been a long, long time since I played it, unfortunately. Um, I believe it has about 15, 18 missions. So you spend roughly 20 hours on it, and then there are the big boxes, which are the same size as Descent itself, or smaller boxes, where you either get another whole big new campaign or smaller campaigns. Sometimes a small campaign was simply split in two; you could play them independently, but they formed a bigger whole, and these new expansion

boxes often contain new heroes. The Overlord always has a deck of cards that they can play. There are also different types of card decks, either just a completely new type of deck or new cards for existing decks. There are usually some new tokens, some new conditions, and new enemies. The game works by having the levels generally predetermined, and certain enemies are also fixed. But for other enemies, it just says here on this tile, there's an open group with some kind of tree symbol, and then you can look through all your uh enemies that you basically have, your minions as a villain, uh what units do I have with a tree symbol , and I can then place them there, like spiders or foxes or golems or whatever, and that's how it's always a bit variable, and yeah, I played it a few times when it came out. I never really finished a full campaign. That is also always a bit of a problem with this video game. I am almost, well, dungeon crawlers, in theory, that should be exactly my genre because I like thematic games, I like games that tell a story, I like dice rolls, I like it when you have heroes that level up, but despite that, most dungeon crawlers don't really grab me, or I think they're good, but I don't find the time to really sit down and play through them. And that was often a problem with Descent back in the day, that you just started it. I also once had friends who , well, I still do, uh, who were totally into it, with whom we also started a campaign. We managed to meet twice, then one didn't have time, then another, then another, then another.

You might know what it's like when playing with five people. Um, and maybe it's not exactly a hardcore group of friends, and people who partly know each other very casually through one mutual buddy, then it doesn't always work out, or maybe you're just not in the mood or don't have time, and that was a problem with Descent. You could also play it with two. Three people were actually better, and four or five even better. That just had the most dynamics, although the Overlord often had to wait quite a long time. And there is now, I don't even know when the app was released in German, Road to Legend. Road to Legend was a huge expansion for the first edition of Descent back in the day. You could travel to different cities there. It was truly a campaign that you played for weeks and months, I think. I never tried it out, but it just sounds cool if you have the time for it. And now they’ve used that name, because it stood for something big, epic, and great, and named the app that. There is an app for Descent that you can download, and then it becomes a fully cooperative game. Meaning, you can play it really well with just two people.

You have campaigns in the app with a main quest line and side quests that you can do, and the app basically dictates how the dungeon is set up. So you don't see the entire dungeon at once, but actually discover it bit by bit. And um, the app just always tells you which monster is activated. It has an AI system, and I was able to test that out in practice once in my demo video, and otherwise, as I said, I unfortunately don't get around to getting these games on the table more often, but I have a couple of friends —two couples, actually—who both said it's super good. Uh, both were players who actually found Descent itself to be totally great, but also had the same problem that it never made it to the table. And with this app, it actually gets on the table; one of the couples has a game table at home where they left it set up for a relatively long time, for an entire campaign, and with that, you can play it super well as a pair. It's supposed to work really , really well. You can then enter which expansions you have into the app. Then the app also suggests the corresponding monsters to you, right? This open group just acts as the monster, essentially.

Um, there are campaigns that you can download, where there’s simply additional content available. That’s now available in board games too, and it seems to work really well and is a lot of fun. And the reason Descent is in first place here is simply because there’s so much stuff available for it. There’s a kit you can use to carry over all the materials from the first edition. I don’t even know how many big campaigns there are now. Five, definitely, and of these small boxes, maybe 5, 6, 7, 8. Unfortunately, I don’t follow it as actively anymore because I don’t get around to playing it, but there is just a ton of content for it. New expansions are released regularly, at least that’s my latest update. I read a job posting at Fantasy Flight at one point where it just said: "Okay, um, we’re looking for developers to create scenario expansions for Descent." So, for just this one game, they had full-time positions dedicated solely to further developing it. And I think it’s a really good entry point into the topic; it’s definitely one of the best games , one that offers the biggest universe, where you really get a lot for your money and can spend a lot of time with it—especially if you really like it and aren't someone who wants to buy 1,000 games, but rather says: "Okay, a cool game we can play for a long time, has lots of expansions, and always features self-contained scenarios that consist of, I don’t know, depending on the size, five or six missions for the small ones, and 10, 15, or sometimes 20 for the big ones." And

that’s why Descent is definitely a recommendation from me; it’s a cool game, and, as I said, I can absolutely recommend the cooperative version, at least from what I’ve heard, but I also know from my own experience that this “together against the game” system works super well, and from everything I’ve heard, it has been implemented really well in Descent. So, if you’re looking for something in that vein and don’t know Descent yet, then definitely check it out. It’s absolutely worth it, though there is actually a different front-runner in the dungeon crawl area right now, and that’s Gloomhaven. Gloomhaven was a Kickstarter that took off really well. Then there was a second Kickstarter, which went even crazier. The game was only available in English until now, and Feuerland Spiele currently has a pre-order campaign running. It's supposed to be released in German at the end of the year. And for that, we'll take a look at the Feuerland website. It's absolutely worth it because, as I just mentioned, there are tons of expansions for Descent.

Expansions have already been announced for Gloomhaven, but the base game itself simply contains 95 missions, and the main campaign you play spans about 60 to 65 missions, each of which takes about 2 to 3 hours. That means you have about 180 hours of playtime there. You can try calculating how many hours of playtime you really get per week on average and figure out how long you'll have something to play with Gloomhaven, and then there are the expansions that will likely extend that significantly. There will probably be some fan-made scenarios as well. There is a scenario generator you can use. So what is truly cool about Gloomhaven, and why is it the number one board game? It is simply a game with cool mechanics, because with Descent, for example, why? You have heroes, and these heroes all play exactly the same. They might have different health points, or one has this special ability and another has that one, but you always perform the same actions—you move, you walk— there's no difference, and you also have a bit of an alpha player problem.

It can happen that one player says, " Okay, we'll do this, that, and that," and, "Okay, you go do that." Then you just do exactly what they told you to do. That can definitely be a problem with that game. You don't have that with Gloomhaven, because Gloomhaven has card management that is super good. Every character in this game has their own complete set of hand cards. At the beginning, you even have all of them in your hand and have to consider which two cards to play, what we want to do right now, where we want to go, who we want to attack, where we want to go through, which door we want to open, and then see how to combine those two cards. And no one can really interfere, because you're very busy with your own cards and, in principle, have your own tasks. You are immediately fully engaged, unlike other games like Kingdom Death: Monster, for example, which I don't really see as a dungeon crawler, which is why it's not on this list. You might know this from some games, especially co-op games, where there's a lot happening, a lot of story , you experience a lot. I also think KM is absolutely great, but when you play it as a beginner, the other person plays the game, and you just experience it. You don't even understand why everything is happening the way it is.

After five or six games, you eventually get into it, things click, you understand what's going on, and then you can really actively participate and think about many things. Uh, but that often takes a bit of time to get going, whereas with Gloomhaven, you're usually right in it. You get these hand cards, you think, okay, I'll play this and that, and once I've played all my cards , I have to decide which one to remove from the game for the rest of the mission. And then I play through my hand cards again over several turns. We combine our efforts, have great synergies, and have to coordinate when we do what, who uses which energies, and uh—that's just so much fun. Especially because you have your hand cards, and you also have this damage deck, where whenever you deal damage, you draw a card that shows how you modify the damage. Like +2, -2, miss, or nothing at all. And character development happens very slowly. You get experience points. You usually have to play about 3, 4, or 5 missions to get enough experience points for a level upgrade, and then you can swap out a card in your damage modifier deck . This means you might take out a -2 card and put a zero card in its place.

That doesn't sound like much at first, but over 5, 6, 7, 8 levels you notice, okay, this deck is significantly better , and a new player can join the campaign at any time playing a rookie, and you really notice, okay, the other one is just more powerful. It doesn't feel like that to you in the first moment, because you don't get that big new thing where you say, "Wow, now I'm really going all out." But you do notice: "Okay, they're just cooler, they have a cooler deck, they miss less often, and they consistently deal more damage." And these hand cards too: If a character has about 12 cards, when you get a level upgrade, you swap out one of those cards, and they're usually all good. You get a new one and think, "Oh, that's cool." But they all, well, maybe not quite, because they all do such different things, you really don't want to part with any of them, and that's just well done. The level design is also great. Well, okay, regarding the design, I have to say, I'm a bit, that's a bit of a point of criticism for me in the game. Um, often it's like , go into a dungeon, kill all the monsters. Um, the missions I've played so far, it was relatively often like that. I've also heard from many people that it's just often like that. And, um , there are of course always a few other ideas that have been incorporated here and there. And yes, that is a bit annoying, especially because it has a system where, once I'm through the dungeon, I'm out, then I've made it.

But I can't collect anything anymore. That means I can't pick up the treasure chests that I haven't looted. Money that might still be lying around is lost. That doesn't make much sense thematically. And it's also a brief comparison to KDM again. KDM has these high points, it has these extreme experiences, it really has ups and downs and highs and lows. The game really works hard against you, and everything that's good and where you roll an epic ten, bringing that super cool loot, that just stays in your memory. Those are really moments that are created. Gloomhaven, they say it's a bit of a Euro dungeon crawler, and it is in that regard, at least from my impression so far and what I've heard. It is fun to play. You combine things, you play your cards down, but you rarely have truly epic sessions that stick in your memory, and it's all a bit more streamlined. But it's still fun, though it's really more of this hero thing, where you say, okay, this hand management and such, you always really have control over what happens and the game is actually only positive.

So with KDM, the two games always seem to invite comparison, even though they are really so different. But with KDM, it's just the case that the game works hard against you and you often really get punched in the face, while in Gloomhaven, you're basically always moving forward. You get upgrades, you get experience points. As far as I know , the character can also never really fully die. He can retire at some point, there are legacy elements included in that. But it is definitely a very positive game. Where KDM Kingdom Death really has death in it, Gloomhaven is just the kind of game where you always move forward, always progress, and you just house-rule some things, right? If you've finished a level and didn't loot the treasure chest, you would theoretically have to play this whole level again. And when you, um, then you just take out the treasure chest and you can just say: "Okay, let's write down the treasure chest," because playing this scenario again for two hours makes little sense. I'm also someone who says I don't like playing this game [on hard]. I don't play it on the hard difficulty, at most normal, or even easy, because you want to succeed; because if I really sit on a scenario for two hours and then have to play it again, I’ve seen 90%of this scenario, it feels kind of stupid, you don’t want that. You want to advance in the story, and with 60 or 70 missions to play, I don't want to have to play half of them twice because I might die due to bad luck or something. You really have to find your own way there. But Gloomhaven definitely gets an absolute recommendation. I wish I had more time for it. I would love to get really into it, because at the beginning I think

there are six characters in cardboard boxes and there are, I don't know, eight or nine other boxes inside that you can unlock when a character has fulfilled their life goal and retires. I would love to see that. I would love to get to grips with this hand management system. I would love to beat these levels. Um, unfortunately, this game is almost too big, especially if you really have KDM and Gloomhaven. Doing both in parallel just takes a hell of a lot of time. But Gloomhaven is definitely a very beginner-friendly experience. It’s a really, you know, you actually meet up with your friends regularly to play it. I would almost recommend playing it with two people. That’s how you get through it the fastest. With three or four players, you obviously have much cooler synergy effects because energies are always being unlocked that you can use there. But as I said, Gloomhaven is definitely number 1 on BoardGameGeek. That in itself is a good indicator. It's just a top-tier game. While there are definitely various things where you have to say, okay, those are things you could or should know beforehand, all in all, it's a game I can absolutely recommend. Well, I can already tell this is going to be very detailed again . The next dungeon crawler is actually my personal favorite dungeon crawler: Zombicide, specifically Black Plague.

In it, we have the fantasy setting again. I would even include it in this list if only the standard base game existed. Um, you don't really have a dungeon you walk into, and it's not fantasy where you could argue whether zombies are fantasy or not, but in principle, it has all the elements. We fight against monsters, we level up our heroes, we get loot, we discover buildings and, yes, explore things and have missions that we need to fulfill. So, for me, it's definitely a dungeon crawler, also the most played dungeon crawler in my collection, because the nice thing about it is it doesn't have, I mean you can somehow cobble together a campaign from it. There are certainly already variants out there on how to play it as a campaign, but it doesn't actually have a campaign system. You sit down, play a mission, which can last 2 to 4 hours, but afterwards you're done and the next time you start from scratch again. Some people will say that's stupid because, well, a campaign is pretty awesome. Really leveling up your heroes over the long term. The successor tries that, but it doesn't feel like it works quite as well, but Zombicide is really a one-shot thing that is still great nonetheless. It is not complex at all.

The rules are super simple. You can move around, you can search a room, you can attack enemies. Um, the AI is really, um, tough. It feels a bit like Zombieland. You really notice the zombies coming, they have their spawn points and they come slowly, but they come in large numbers and at some point they're there, and hopefully you have a Molotov cocktail or something similar to take them out. The memory card was full then, and yes, as I said, you fight these enemies, get experience points for it, and then level up. You have to make sure that all players level up as evenly as possible. Uh, because when someone reaches a higher level, from certain points on more and tougher enemies always spawn, and if someone is already at, like, level 30 and someone else is at level 5, it’s pretty annoying if they have to fight against people, because maybe they aren't even equipped for it. You also gain new abilities over the course of the mission by leveling up within that mission as you earn experience points.

So it keeps getting better and, yeah, I think it’s just really well implemented because it's easy to learn. You can already play it with two people . You can also play it with up to six people. You can tell anyone at the table, "Hey, if you don't have a total problem with zombies, sit down, play, have fun," and you also have to coordinate the whole time, who goes where and when, who takes which actions , and how you split up. If you split up , although you should never actually do that, as we’ve learned from the movies, but yes, there is, as I said, Zombicide 1, 2, and 3, in principle, then there is Zombicide Black Plague. Then there is also an Orc Zombicide, and I participated in the Black Plague Kickstarter at the time, and if you join such a Cool Mini or Not Zombicide Kickstarter, you pay about $ 100 once and have a lot to unpack. So, there are six heroes in the base game. I think I have 36 or so. I think there is one abomination in the base game. I have, I don't know, five or six without having bought anything extra, except for the first expansion that came with it. And even that I have unfortunately only played five or six times in that version, but that is enough for me. So, more Zombicides keep coming out because people say, "Oh, I'll get that, I need it, I want it, Cool Mini or Not Kickstarter, I'm in immediately." Um, no, I have the thing, and if I have actually played Zombicide to the point where I've played all the missions and all the levels, then I can consider getting something new. But yeah, the suffering of a board gamer is that you play a lot. You often play a lot of new games. Um, if a game really hits the

table often, then that always means something. Then it somehow clicked really well with me or the group. And Zombicide is actually a game where even the core of my group says, "Hey, a cool game." But it comes down to the fact that it often takes a long time, and unfortunately, I'm having a bit of trouble with my groups right now. Some don't have much time, others can only start relatively late, and then it's always hard to get such big games to the table. But I can absolutely recommend Zombicide. I can also highly recommend just joining a Kickstarter. The next Zombicide will be Zombicide in space. The theme just has to grab you, though. It looks a bit like, well, Warhammer 40k or that Space Quest game that used to exist. And if you don't have it yet, you can also join in, because you simply get a lot of stuff, many heroes, many monsters. You can play it until you drop, and you don't really need—well, I also know people who join every single one, saying "Wow, Zombicide," and when you ask, they’ve only played like four or five missions of the old Zombicide. Yes, for those who just want to have everything, that's no problem at all. I am absolutely happy with Zombicide: Black Plague. It has good rules, in my opinion. It works, it's fun, it feels fresh and modern, and it's also a game I can really recommend because it's completely cooperative. You’re basically playing against the game. The enemies are controlled by the AI and, like I said, I think it's really great.

It would probably be at number one for me among dungeon crawlers if I were to rank them, so just take a look at it if you don't know it, even if you say, " Zombies, well, not really my thing." Just check it out anyway. It's a cool game. So, then a game I unfortunately haven't really played extensively: Sword&Sorcery. It is basically the successor to Galaxy Defenders. Galaxy Defenders had a very cool leveling system where you could level up your hero. There is something similar in Sword&Sorcery. It is basically the fantasy successor to it, where thematically you play heroes who have actually died, but their souls are somehow trapped. They are denied access to the afterlife or the heavenly realm, and they first have to fight again as lost souls to break the curse and truly be able to pass on to the beyond.

That's already a pretty cool theme, that we're playing failed heroes, and it also feels like a very classic dungeon crawler. So you walk around, and while all the heroes are similar in principle, they have special traits, where each hero also has their own deck that you can puzzle together to decide which special abilities to use. These special abilities also sometimes have a cooldown. Sometimes they need a few rounds until they're ready again, depending on how powerful they are. Um, you can die, then you have to return to a sort of soul fountain. It’s a bit like in World of Warcraft, when you, um , die and end up in a graveyard and have to run back to your corpse; it’s relatively similar. It also has a dungeon that gets set up where you usually see the whole dungeon in principle, but there is a Book of Secrets where different points, like trigger points, are laid out in the campaign or mission where markers are placed. And when you go there, activate them, walk over them, or talk to people , you read from this book and then new things happen, suddenly new enemies appear, or maybe new map tiles are added. There’s also a sense of progression, so you don't see everything immediately on the table like in the old days, and it's fun to really level up your hero in the long term. They get new items, they get great new abilities; you want more, you want better things, and the gameplay, yes, it feels like an absolutely classic dungeon crawler, but there's nothing negative to say about it. If you follow the discussions on Facebook,

I think it should be available in German by now. Um, Sword and Sorcery is also mentioned often, that many people are really having a lot of fun, which I find a bit of a shame. In the base game , you only get the first part of the campaign; you have to get the second one in an expansion. So I think there are only about 10 to 12 missions in it. That feels like a bit too little, but, well, I enjoyed it back then. It also has the dungeon crawler problem again. I like trying them out, I like checking them out, but unfortunately, I always know that they don't really hit the table that often. That's almost a bit of a shame because, as I said, the theme and setting are exactly my thing, and currently, I even have someone in my group with whom I know I could really play this regularly. Yeah, but maybe that will change in the future, so that dungeon crawlers might actually hit the table a bit more often or we manage to play through at least one campaign or half a campaign. Then I will definitely report on it, and you'll see it on my live channel too.

But I’d say Sword&Sorcery is a very good game based on my personal impressions so far. Everything I’m reading on the internet says it’s also a very good game. So check it out. If you’re interested in dungeon crawlers and it maybe shouldn't be that one, or Gloomhaven is too expensive for you—though you really do get a lot for your money there. Sword&Sorcery is definitely a top title as well. So, the last game in the top five I’m doing here. Although there will be a few more titles after that, it’s Star Wars Imperial Assault. It’s basically Star Wars Descent; they took the Descent rulebook, rebuilt, modified, and adapted it a bit, modernized it, put the Star Wars license on it, and included heroes from the Star Wars universe. The biggest change is essentially that in the past, it was always the Overlord's turn, then all the heroes, then the Overlord, then all the heroes, then the Overlord. That means you sometimes sat there as the Overlord for a long time and just waited. Now you have alternating activations, meaning one hero goes, then the Overlord can activate a group.

The heroes take their turns, then the Overlord can activate a group. That feels better, at least for the Overlord . He can now, because otherwise he just sat around for a long time and couldn't really plan because so much happened before it was his turn again. He had to roll dice, obviously, because he was usually being attacked, but yeah, it could get a bit long. Now it's the case that the Overlord is constantly active, and if we play with five people and have four heroes, it can happen that the first hero goes and then has to wait a long time until it’s their turn again. You can, of course, coordinate with the other players, and yeah, maybe you shouldn't play with five, but rather with just three; then the problem is a bit less severe. And what’s cool about this game is that we have, in principle, two games in one . For one, we have this dungeon crawler that includes a campaign with missions —really consisting of about 12, 13, or 14 missions—where you spend 20, 30 hours, or even longer, and there is always a big finale where the Overlord, who plays the Empire, really tries to win the thing and focuses everything on that last mission. There are already expansion boxes for it, tons of extra stuff you can buy, but you also get a skirmish miniatures game included.

Meaning, you always play with those plastic figures in there, and it's basically the Overlord against all the heroes. But then there are also extra cards for all the heroes, which state: Okay, this one costs so many points, and it has these specific abilities. And then everyone has, I don't know, let's say 100 points, and can think: Okay, for 100 points I can get Vader in there, he costs 40 points, then I can get these Rebels or these Stormtroopers as a squad, a squad costs like 15 points, I'll take one, I'll take two, they get a flamethrower upgrade for 20 points extra, and you just piece your armies together like that. And you have various scenarios, different maps you can play on, and in principle, like a tabletop game but more as a board game, you can fight against each other, carry out various skirmishes, and keep rebuilding your armies. So you really have two games in one, two games in one —once this dungeon crawler and then this skirmish game, this miniatures tabletop-style game, and that is really very cool. I just made a video about Star Wars Legion. That is truly a pure tabletop game, which allows a bit more freedom, feels a bit larger overall, but where you also have to assemble the miniatures yourself and have to buy a whole lot of stuff for it. And yes, that’s why Imperial Assault is really great, because you actually get these two games in one nowadays. I haven't tried it out yet, but I've heard that the app for it is supposed to be out.

Just like with Descent, for Imperial Assault—I don't know if it's already available in German—there is also an app with which you can play it fully cooperatively. So, you actually have three games, right? One is Overlord against the heroes, one is a one-on-one battle, which is also really well done. I played that three times. Uh, that was very fun. I think, if I were to play this regularly, I would actually play this skirmish mode more often, because it really is quite fun. But for that, you obviously need someone who knows the game, knows it well, and plays at a similar level to you, or is perhaps even a little better. Um, that is naturally easier with the campaign. You can just bring in new people, sit them down, and say, "Here, let's play cooperatively." You can discuss things well, and that is honestly really good; it’s definitely a strength of the game. Thematically, the missions I played didn't really feel much like Star Wars. You had the setting, all the figures and such, but in principle, it was just another dungeon crawler. And what was a bit annoying, at least in the first mission, was that the heroes mostly just had to get somewhere. So, the rebels essentially ran through the dungeon, tried to complete their mission objectives along the way, while the Overlord could just sit there, set up traps, stand around, and shoot at people. And he already knew the dungeon's design; sometimes a door would open, new things would be set up, and he could, if he wanted to play really hard, set up traps and, um, yeah , I don't know, I haven't played it enough for that yet. It's definitely a very successful game, so I don't think it'll be quite that bad. And yeah, so if you like Star Wars and maybe don't

want to spend a super huge amount of money on Star Wars Legion, or aren't really into tabletop games and don't want to assemble miniatures, then take a look at Imperial Assault. The games are unfortunately not compatible with each other, but for all Star Wars fans, it's a damn good game. So, it's definitely worth putting your time into , and yeah, I can absolutely recommend it. It obviously has its weaknesses, you can read up on that online, just watch a few more reviews about it. I made a video about it where I think I really present the whole thing in a Let's Play style. You can take a look at that, and um, yeah, I also have a little insider tip for you when it comes to dungeon crawlers that I just discovered and introduced a few days ago: Stuffed Fables. Stuffed Fables is a "choose your own adventure" dungeon crawl game. So we play as fairy tale characters—or not fairy tale characters, we play as toys. In principle, it’s like Toy Story meets Monsters, Inc. in a dungeon-crawling board game. Meaning, we have this book, we play inside this storybook, we flip through the pages, and sometimes the game board is printed right on the page , which is very cool. This allows you to simply have a huge number of—well, in principle, for every page, for every setting, you have a completely unique game board. You can't really do that with, say, Gloomhaven, because there’s only a limited amount of pieces you can put in there, and you’re always building the same, well , just a dungeon out of those same pieces. It always looks the same.

It’s never something very specific, whereas here you can print a nursery on it, a church, a hallway, a garden, a forest, anything, or even five different forests that look five times completely different, where sometimes you see a well in the forest, or a clearing, or some deer—so you just have complete freedom. That is just super cool. Plus, it's a "choose your own adventure" style. Meaning, at the beginning, you might be told, okay, you have to fight this or that person or go over there, and depending on how well or poorly that goes, you then continue reading at 51 or 52. This means the story can always develop in very different ways, and it might happen that you talk about it with someone else who also played the game, and they say, "Oh, no, we never went there." We saw something completely different in that scenario, and that is really cool.

But it is definitely, as those stuffed animals in the fable suggest: if you like this theme, this slightly fairy-tale-like, Toy Story-esque vibe in a dungeon-crawl setting, and you're not expecting an super intensely challenging strategic dungeon crawler, but care more about the story, then I think you can definitely play this with adults, too. Even if you are, you know, gamers and your girlfriend or boyfriend —I think a bit more, it's a cliché, I know, but with girlfriends it can be that they say: "Wow, that's totally adorable!" Even if they otherwise don't care for dungeon crawlers, if you come to them with Gloomhaven, they'll say: " Oh, get lost." If you say: "Hey, we're playing with toys here and it's totally adorable and there's a cool story too. I think they'd be into that, and I think, as I said, my nephew is three, I don't have kids myself, and I can't play it with my nephew yet. I'll probably do that in about three years, I think, he'll be able to manage it then. And I think it's a super cool family game. It's not really a family game like The Game of Life, Monopoly, or Azul, you know, all those Euro family games. It's a different kind of thing, but if you are one of those people who found all the games I've mentioned so far totally cool and want to play something like that with your kids, want to experience a story, and want to combine both really well—like this game with a great story that deals with child-friendly themes—but they aren't written in a simplistic way.

They have intelligent language that I think still appeals to kids, confronts them with problems kids understand, that they can overcome together, where you learn to play together with Mom and Dad to solve the whole thing, and that I think is a cool experience. So if I had kids and they were around that age, from 7 it's fun, I think you can also play it with 12, 13, 14, 15-year-olds as a family together. It's a cool experience, but it's not exactly a hardcore gamer game, so it's obviously no Gloomhaven, and no Descent either; it's more like, I draw dice and see what colors they are, and then I can take certain actions. In my experience, it's really about experiencing this story, seeing the different outcomes, and also, of course, developing your character a bit, although the possibilities there are very limited. But it really is a hidden gem.

Unfortunately, it's only available in English so far, but in 2019—so you can already mark this down for next year, maybe for Christmas or the fair, um—it will be released in German. I think probably from Asmodee Play Games, it is the successor to Mice and Mystics , and that thing is cool. So, I've now played the first scenario, the first mission, the first campaign, the first story essentially, and it took about two, two and a half hours. And yeah, I would definitely be up for trying the other six out too, because that's also something—what I find cool about this game—is that there's a lot of story in it. With all the others, it's really this dungeon crawl-style running around , killing monsters, that's cool for sure. For a limited amount of time. I like games with a lot of story in them, and there is a lot of story in this one . It's a different kind of story than what you're used to, because it really picks up on these childhood themes, but they're also handled quite sweetly, because it's partly just about this girl, who is the protagonist, waking up at night and just wanting to go to the bathroom. And it's dark and she's scared and her stuffed animals have to protect her somehow, uh, without her noticing. And these are topics that children definitely understand, uh, that they can deal with, but that adults can also relate to, who know them from their own kids or from their own experience, and that still has something to it. So it's not just a total kids 'game, and I give the game credit for that. I think that's very good. Um, then, the true mother of all

dungeon crawlers, HeroQuest, right? High Adventure in a World of Magic. I had that as a kid, too. I lent it to my school friend, my buddy Niklas, back then, along with StarQuest. It lay around there forever and we just got older, like 14, 15, 16, 17, and it was always like," I still have it, "and," Yeah, I don't need that crap, "because we were kind of past that age for playing. Yeah, today I'm annoyed that I didn't go back and get it. Although, I probably would have, um, yeah, in the meantime, somehow sorted it out and sold it and so on anyway. Uh, that is like the ultimate, I mean, people my age, like mid-30s, I think many of those who played back then as kids and who liked fantasy, they will have played HeroQuest, they will know it. It was just super cool running around with that Barbarian. The Gargoyle, who was super powerful. um, through this pre-built dungeon where there were so many different scenarios. Um, it's cool if you don't know it yet, and I've talked about it once or twice already, but then look on YouTube, stop right now, open a new tab, and look up on YouTube, what's it called," Why HeroQuest is the best game in the world ? "I will try to put a link in the description. A very cool video, really very well made. It definitely captures the essence of the game; it's obviously just meant to be funny, but the guy who makes it is just totally on point. I mean, if Meritens did them in that style, I would watch them; it's really

very entertaining. Um, one of the best gaming YouTube videos I know. I would love to have a talent like that, but you really have to be that type of guy. I'm just not that guy in that sense. But it really is such an old classic. I think if you played it today, it would be totally bad and totally trashy, but if you really associate childhood memories with it, then I think it's a cool experience to play it again, just to play one or two missions for a laugh . Unfortunately, it is incredibly expensive. If you still have a HeroQuest lying around somewhere and you don't need it and don't want moon-high prices for it, then write to me. I would take it off your hands immediately. I really want to have it again. If I don't get it really affordably sometime in the next year or two, I'll probably just cough up the money and buy it at a bit of a higher price. Yeah, maybe not yet, don't know.

But maybe you still have it lying around somewhere, gathering dust, and you think to yourself," Okay, um, I don't need it. "And, um, also happy to take it at Christmas or something, I'm quite open to that. But, uh, it would be cool if someone still had it lying around and would maybe actually give it away, because I would just really like to play it again, because I really associate...it was just really cool. So , both HeroQuest as well as StarQuest, um, I found them both great. I enjoyed playing them as a child and it's really more of a retro thing now, but now there are a few other things we can talk about. Five Minute Dungeon has" dungeon "right in the name, right? A game where we just really, in real-time , we reveal monsters and have to play specific cards. Um, if we have them and play them at the same time, we have defeated the monster. Sometimes we don't have the cards, then we have to play with other effects somehow. You really have 5 minutes to get through such a huge stack of monsters. It’s super funny, the cards are just flying all over the table. Is it a dungeon crawler or not? On one hand yes, because you thematically enter a dungeon, have to defeat five bosses there, the final boss at the end, and then you’ve made it. Um, you just don't really get loot, you don't really build up a character. It definitely has the fantasy theme, it has the dungeon theme. Yes, it's entertaining, but really a dungeon crawler? I would say yes. Other people would say no, just like Dungeon Fighter, it actually really fulfills all the criteria. We fight against monsters. We have heroes.

The heroes, they don't level up, but they at least get better equipment and, with the expansions, better abilities. Um, you explore a dungeon, meet some monsters there that you fight, and this is really a very, very cool game that is completely different from all the games I've told you about so far, because here you really have to take action to defeat these monsters. Um, maybe you can see it in the image that is displayed somewhere here. Um, there are lots of targets. There is really a big target lying on the table, you have a die and have to let the die bounce on the table once and then it should ideally land in the middle of this target. Then you deal damage, the monster is dead immediately. Otherwise, there are these circles, um, that go concentrically around it, where you just deal much less damage. And if a die—if you try this out, you can try to throw it relatively accurately, but it is just a die, it can sometimes roll off the crosshairs, uh, or not land on it at all, but bounce right past it, then the monster deals damage to you.

Your character has special abilities that, um, you have dice for. There are, I think, red, blue, green dice and we just have three dice worth of time to kill this monster. If I use my blue die , well, you know, there's a blue die, and if I use it, the other players can't use it anymore, and so you have to coordinate who uses which die and when, and whether you take damage if you fail to kill the monster to get those dice back, and of course, that would be relatively boring. There’s like, the Medusa, for example, has a symbol of a figure covering its eyes, which means you aren't allowed to look, you have to throw blind, or another one where you have to throw against a card, where you set up certain obstacles on the board, uh, others where you have to jump and throw while jumping. That’s like some frog you have to fight. There are so many different ways you have to defeat these enemies, and it's a game I played, and I thought it was complete garbage. I said, God, what a terrible game this is. Kind of hopping and spinning and then throwing and hitting the table and stuff. Um, get away from me with that. But I played it, played it again, didn't think it was quite as bad, played it again in the same group that same evening, and it was like, yeah, it’s getting better, you slowly figure out how it works, and by now it's one of my absolute favorite games because it’s just so different with this, uh, the dungeon is made of small cards that lie to the side, where you push a little marker through. The exciting part is definitely the enemies . Which enemy do we get, how can we defeat it? Every few, uh, rooms that we have to go through in this dungeon, we

can go to a shop. There we get new weapons, um, where you might have to do a prayer throw, where you take the die into your, uh, hands like in prayer and let it fall out and then see where it lands, or where you, um, have to use someone else's hand to roll with. Or, or there are so many different, uh, weapons you can get, which make the whole thing even more interesting, and it’s definitely a very cool game. I have all the expansions for it. Sadly, there are only four. It would be cool if there were more, but actually, that's enough. It's also not a game that hits the table constantly. It really is more of a party dungeon crawler, but super cool. I can highly recommend it. And if you don't think it's totally great the first time, give it a chance, play it two or three more times, it takes about an hour. Um, you can play it solo, it works well. With two, three, four, or five. It can take a bit long until it's your turn again, but with 2 to 4 players I would definitely absolutely recommend it. So, then Clank. Clank is basically also a type of dungeon crawler. It is a deck-building push-your-luck game, where we are like thieves who descend into a dragon's lair. We have enemies we can defeat along the way, they are very abstract though, we build up our hero, we have talent, for which we can buy new cards from a card row that we add to our deck. We get loot, we have spoils, whoever has the most loot wins and it actually fulfills all the criteria of a dungeon crawler. It is actually also a dungeon crawler, even

if many people would say, nah, it's not . Actually, it is. So for me, it counts in that category, even if it's naturally not like in Descent or Imperial Assault or something, where miniatures really run through a dungeon . But my god, in Gloomhaven those are also just tokens, depending on which version you have, and I think it fits in well. Unfortunately the game is a bit expensive, but very, very good, very entertaining. It often hits our table. Especially when we have a nice chunk of time and are four people, then Clank is often suggested. Often we are unfortunately five, then it doesn't work, because it's only for up to four players. That's a bit annoying. Um, another thing is also Welcome to the Dungeon. Also a completely different interesting game concept. Um, we have this hero, who is laid out, he has some armor, a shield, a weapon, a potion, another weapon, maybe some spell or something and then there is this dungeon we have to go into. And we are all basically playing this hero, but only one can go inside with them. And um these monsters you have to fight against are shuffled and put into a stack. And when it's my turn, I draw a monster, put it in the dungeon and I'm done, or I draw this monster, discard it and take out an item. And depending on the card, some, well, some of these items can defeat all monsters with a level of three or less. One, the one item defeats the dragon, the other protects you when this or that monster is revealed. With another one, you can heal yourself by three. With another one, you get five life points, with the other item two life points. Meaning,

always, um, when I take out a monster, I also have to take out an item. Meaning, I know which monster I took out and know whether this item was helpful for it or not and know what definitely cannot come up anymore, although most monsters exist twice. Um, but it can also be that, um, yeah, I somehow, you know, there are already three or four monsters there and I think, okay, you can probably just barely manage that with these things. I know maybe two or three of the cards, but not all of them. And then I just draw a card, say, yeah, no, I actually can't do that. I take it out and take the item out and all other players pass and then I have to go into the dungeon with this shrunken hero, meaning all cards that we put in before are taken and then they are revealed one by one and you see if you make it or not. If you make it, you get a medal, if you have two medals, you've won, if you don't make it, you flip your card over, it's then red, if you do that a second time, you're dead and out. Meaning, you can win the game without ever being the active player yourself. But this concept is really like: A hero lies in the middle, whom everyone can modify in turns. But whenever he does something, there is a risk that all other players say:" Okay, I'm out ", and you have to go in yourself. That's a really cool element where you really have to estimate: Is it way too easy right now, if I pass and everyone else does too, and he just goes in, runs through it and gets the victory point? Or is it perhaps already too hard, and I am relatively sure, if I pass now and the other person has to go in, then they die. And if you misjudge that, it's

pretty stupid for yourself. If others misjudge it, it's good for you. You can never really know 100%. There is actually no absolute information there. But it is also, well, a short-lived game. A run takes maybe, I don't know, 10 minutes for that first phase and the entire game maybe half an hour, but again a completely different approach. Yes, also a dungeon crawler in reverse. We go into a dungeon, we fight monsters , we get loot in the form of medals, i.e., victory points, so only sort of, and we don't make our opponent, our character, better, but rather worse. Um , yes, Doom is actually also very, very , very, very coolly done. I've played it for the first time now. I like it a lot in terms of mechanics and everything. So, of the kind, um, one versus many, Overlord versus opponents, it could be one of the best games because there are also a huge number of customization options. You actually don't need any expansions for the game.

Unfortunately, the big weakness, based on everything I've read so far and experienced myself, is. Um, the new version of Doom is super easy for the Marines to win, and the Overlord really has to be on the ball, must know all the rules completely, and exploit everything to his advantage, while the Marines just go," Oh, I'll just run through, oh, I'll deal some damage here . "So, I think it's great. I will play another two or three games more. Although you really should play with four Marines, so it's best with five, which is also a number—when I manage to get them together, people usually don't feel like playing something like Doom. It's more for two to three players. I'll have to see, but, um, I will definitely make a video about that for you as well. And the last game for today, where you can also argue whether it's a dungeon crawler or not, is Mansions of Madness. The dungeon is basically the house. We have characters that fight against monsters. We fight against these monsters and can get loot for it. We can level up our heroes to a certain extent. Um, at least they get better items and maybe even sometimes better abilities during the course of a mission. Super much story in it, of course, although that was also available as an Overlord versus player game. Meanwhile, in the new version, it is only app-controlled, meaning the app says what happens and what happens with which items. You spend so much time in the app, and, um, if you get involved in the story, it's not a big deal. But there are people who say," No, that's too much app for me, "which I can understand. And the big problem is, of course, the price; I think the recommended retail price is somehow 100

€. I think you can get it for about 80, maybe 75 online, but then there are like five scenarios in there that you play and then you're done. You can't really, I mean you can play them again, it's always a bit different, but once you know a scenario, once you know the story, then you're done with it. It just has so much story, meaning playing through these stories, especially if you like this Lovecraft theme, is super fun, but once you're done with that, you're done with it and the expansions aren't exactly cheap either. So, the price is really the thing where I would say:" Oh yeah. "But you notice it, um, there are many games that could generally be a dungeon crawler, where you then ask yourself:" Is this really just fantasy and push your luck or something, or is it already a dungeon crawler combined with maybe push your luck with maybe something else? "Um, yeah, I never find that quite so simple . I think I'm at about an hour in the rough cut for this video now. It will probably be 50 minutes once edited, I would think, because I've actually been talking the whole time. Um, I could name a lot of other games now that I have either played before or that I know from reading and watching videos and such, which would also fall into this dungeon crawler area. But I'll skip that for now, because it's a long video, and again, here's the request.

If you've watched it to the end, feel free to leave me a comment so I know that it's worth making the videos this long and being this detailed. Or, um, if there are only like two comments that have anything to say, I'll know, okay, it's actually too long, I should break it down even more. I've gone into quite a bit of detail again, but yeah, people who watch my videos often know what they're getting into. I'm trying to make the review videos a bit shorter right now and I probably uploaded a supporter update after or before this video. That means: If you want to join in these votes, or perhaps tell me as a Patreon," Hey, make this shorter, do it differently, "then you are cordially invited to participate, to support the channel, so that I can simply make these videos even better, more often, higher quality, with even more technical bells and whistles, maybe some overlays. Um, there are still so many possibilities, primarily time of course, because time is always the biggest problem. And the more people who support this channel, the more time I can take, the more I can invest in new equipment and new technology, and also do other things like traveling to conventions, moving around more in the board game world, and maybe making videos on location, externally, perhaps at the homes of some game designers.

And yeah, I would be super happy if a few more people joined in. Tell me, feel free to give me feedback on the video, give me feedback on dungeon crawlers that were really well received by you. Also write in the comments for others to see what flopped for you, where you thought," oh, huge success, " and then it didn't work at all. And I would just love to know your feedback, what were your highlights and what were your flops. That's it from me. I thank you for watching, say see you soon, and bye. Hey Hey

Progress saved