Skip to main content
Loading video...

TCbH's Top 10 Board Game Pet Peeves

Transcript 17:32

y'all i like games and i like talking about games i like discovering things in games and discovering new games to play it's one of the reasons that i'm doing this in the hobby is i i like to ring the most out of gaming and broaden my horizons and as part of that i tend to be pretty forgiving about little nuisances in games but sometimes i have to get a little bit petty i have to talk about things that make me angry when it comes to games mainly because even in games that i love there are what i see as glaring problems that shouldn't be anywhere near games that are still being made today so we're going to get a little bit petty just a little bit petty in talking about my top 10 gaming pet peeves but in the spirit of not just punching down we're going to talk about these 10 pet peeves in the context of examples from some of my absolute favorite games both to show that you know these are games that i love and i get it but also these are still some of the shining examples of the greatest things that our hobby has to offer and yet we are still kind of dealing with some of this stuff we got some growing to do so i would like to see this as a call to action

that we can do better so here are the cardboard heralds top 10 gaming pet peeves number 10 pallet swapped illustrations i mean come on this is this is something that i think largely we've moved past but even in flam rouge one of the most iconic racing games of all time that is still constantly recommended even by myself we have racers who on your player met are barely changed from one another and clearly are the same model but have little different illustrations to the cards where they're wearing different colored shirts you went through the process of having different identifiable colors but they are truly just palette swaps of those shirts it feels so lazy i mean i get it artwork is expensive but at the same time you had to print this material you are putting out a product it feels like you could go the extra mile so anytime where there's just a pallet swap of one color to another in different player factions or identities it just i i die a little inside number nine is a sexy but space wasting insert which is kind of like a little double tap it is just a little cherry on the top of pissing me off because not only do you have a game like splendor a wonderful game with

beautiful components that could be fit into something that's like a tenth of the size of the box that it comes in but the box that it comes in has this perfectly sculpted insert that only gives you exactly enough room for the components themselves and nothing else so it's already laughing at you for wasting so much space and packing so much air but then they say hey get yourself an expansion it ain't going to fit in this beautifully crafted insert that we have here so it's just like an ultimate waste that insert just gets thrown out the door so now i have more recycling material to have it's already an insult to have a largely empty box and then when that largely empty box is crafted in such a way to pretend that it's something much more substantial than it is is just demeaning number eight is where we start actually getting into game design itself and something that just always strikes me as a weakness in game design is overly homogenized or equitable values and the way that i think about this is like in dulles or island where you have all these different dinosaurs that are different types and different shapes and they cost different dna in order to create them but the value exchanges are so tight and rigid that effectively there is zero difference between the types of dna that you're using between the dinosaurs that you're using it saps all the life and

flavor and color out of it and it also undermines the sense that you are investing in something as you play the game that you're you're sculpting a strategy that you are really building up to something or risking something when everything has too precise of an equitable value even if that's kind of hidden a little bit underneath the hood as soon as you start noticing this in a game where everything has a rough exchange rate of any action essentially being the same value as another action it just takes a lot of the fun and interest out of that game number seven is a lack of color blind accessibility options and i'm not color blind i should say that right up front but i do have some fellow gamers who are and i know that it's a prevalent problem that there's a lack of colorblind accessibility options in many games such as five tribes a game that if you are colorblind is virtually unplayable uh or at least certain types of colorblind but also having just color be the visual distinction between different items on a board reduces general readability and just kind of makes a a colorful mess whereas if you have different shapes of pieces or different shapes printed on pieces or some other visual identifier that can help you make distinctions between all the different sets it allows you to bank information a lot easier it helps with

retention of rules it helps with distinction of these as separate identifiers of groups of items and also it makes it so more gamers can play your game so when you don't have colorblind accessibility options not only does it dramatically limit the pool of players that are going to be able to play your game but also it just makes your game a lot harder to get a visual read on we can grow beyond this six is lack of components and i'm talking eldritch horror here no i don't mean that eldritch horror didn't have all the components you must have to play but y'all that game came with four dice four freaking dice that is the biggest joke in the world because you are almost always going to be rolling more than four dice and they expect you to like roll four dice and then pick up some of those and roll them again because you're rolling 15 dice to fight a shotgun this turn i mean it's ridiculous and it's insulting anytime that a game doesn't give you a full complement of the components that you would realistically need in order to play i mean i'm fine sharing dice with other players at the table so long as you give me a realistic amount of dice or coins or whatever non-component limited aspect of the game that i'm going to need in order to feel like i'm not having to bring extra material into

a typical game session it feels cheap it feels insulting it's just bad it's bad number five is back to some game design choices and i'm bringing up what is for many people their favorite game of all time and that is scythe i love scythe but man do i not like the ending of scythe or other games that have an abrupt triggered game end i mean there are a lot of games that end at a defined point because you hit a certain number of rounds or whatever it is but that's something that all players can see coming whereas psy it's a triggered game and condition where once someone puts six stars out then their turn is the last turn and there's no ability for anyone else to recover from that yeah i get it there's some design philosophy stuff there wanting other players to pay attention to everyone else at the table looking at realistic capabilities and then also talking about like well does it undermine the value of movement if other people can take a turn i don't really care it just there there's a better solution out there than having someone be able to both trigger and finalize the game all on that one single turn without any repercussions for anyone else it's annoying it's not fun it kind of takes away some of the agency for everyone else and it just makes it feel like oh okay well i guess but the game just ended number four

games with squared corners on cards it's horrible why is this still done like i i don't understand it like if you have cardstock cards and they have squared corners you realize they're just going to get mushed right like i love discoveries the journals of lewis and clark i think it's a brilliant game but it's one of the most insulting things ever that they have an entire stack of 55 cards where one corner is squared and the rest are rounded it's i guess like a an aesthetic design choice that they made but it's a really bad one and the fact that it got so close also makes me feel like they fell so far and anytime in which i'm playing with cards and it has squared corners it doesn't feel good they're pokey they get mushed they don't function well it's just bad design uh as part of a user experience a component quality uh issue i i never want to play with squared corner cards again and if you do well yes you're a bad person number three is inconsistent terminology in a game and dune imperium i love you baby you're a game that made a huge splash on this entire hobby recently but what is up with this fremen bond where it's a shorthand for giving you some sort of bonus on some cards that are based off of two cards that are actively in play in your side of the

camp that have fremen on them and you just assume that that means something but at the same time you have the bene jesuit who say that if you've played another bene jesuit then it bla bla da blah which means exactly the same thing but having two different ways of approaching the exact same concept in relation to the exact same component cards and their identifiers the the affiliation of those just undermines that you actually understand the game like if you are playing the game and you're like oh freman bond okay look it up in the rules okay it means this okay now the bennett jesuit cards don't have been a jesuit bond so okay maybe they don't mean the same thing what am i missing here why is one it's terrible we have a hard enough time grasping all the rules of the games that are presented to us it makes it feel like it didn't get to an editor that someone didn't look over this or if they did and they let it slide what were you thinking you could have had consistency and instead it's just disparate and and not great it's i i don't know i do not have a foreign bond number two could be any game oh not any game not every game but most games including i don't know spirit island or imperial settlers or dune imperium or any of these other games which are some of my favorite games of all time but it's big floppy rulebooks i know the the

temptation to have this enormous freaking box here and be like well i have space in order to make this rule book that's going to fit and you can just have this enormous floppy rulebook that is terrible and unwieldy and hard to distinguish different sections and doesn't fit well on the table and isn't good to reference as you play it's abysmal i hate these enormous rule books we gotta be dumb with them they they are hard to read like if you're trying to read in advance and you're like oh i'm just going to stay in bed and read this rule book they're hard to have on the table rule books should be treated with the same degree of care and precision when they're being created as any other game component and if i have this big unwieldy nasty floppy rulebook i'm not going to be able to use that for anything it's a waste of space it's a waste of time the rule books that are more concise or more easy to fit into your hands that are more easy to flip through those are the rule books that are succeeding in conveying information which is the point of rule books in the first place so yeah i get a little irrationally upset when it comes to these big floppy rulebooks but it's not number one but only because i made an entire other video about big floppy robux so i figured i'd let it pass and be added number two here which brings us to the top number one my pet peeve is implicit rather than explicit

rules or really just not having clearly defined rules in your freaking rule book and you know what sleeping gods you're great you are a darling you are just a peach but how the campaign ends if you're in the middle of a campaign and you're like oh geez we've been playing like 12 hours of this game across several sessions how does the game end and you start looking through the rule books and you're like there was something about totems how does the game end i can i can see game loss well are we supposed to play to a certain time do we just i think it was supposed to be seven totems do we just hang it up at that point you start looking through the rulebooks and there is not a clear like this is what the game is and what you need to expect out of the game now there is something that references i don't want to get into too many spoilers but when a a certain deck runs out several times you read entry f something well that's really what's going to trigger the end of the game but that's not clearly defined anywhere and this is a problem i mean sleeping gods is a wonderful game but clearly by the number of questions that are on the internet about this exact issue and the amount of time that my group spent trying to figure out like wait is there something we're supposed to do as soon as we get to seven totems or is there a certain number of totems

or or what makes the end of the campaign happen because this is kind of like a free-form jazz type of thing um that's a problem and there are all kinds of examples of this in our hobby where there's something that the rule book kind of implies but doesn't clearly define and i get it that if you're trying to hide certain information or in the event of a storytelling game you're trying to hide spoilers or keep certain things a surprise still having a very clearly defined section on what to anticipate in the event that someone is looking for that information you you need to have it available and there are so many offenders in this regard which is why the amazing community at board game geek has grown to what it is because there's so many people answering these questions so many faqs so many erratas and i get it writing rules is hard making sure that you've addressed all the use case scenarios for so many different moving parts is hard but especially on fundamental concepts and games when there are so many different types of games out there it is really important that you use explicit directions not implicit directions that is my number one pet peeve on all games in this hobby anytime that it comes up and of course on these examples bear in mind before you start knocking over my door these are all on

games that i love and have in my collection and routinely play and have overcome these issues but they still nag at me anytime that i break them out but i want to know what are your top 10 pet peeves or just your number one pet peeve and do you think that some of these are solvable or some of my issues just kind of blown entirely out of proportion let me know in the comments below and as always thanks for watching thanks for supporting thanks for being such an amazing community where you can say these things out loud and hopefully not have the pitchforks at your door i love doing this and i hope you love me doing it too thank you so much for watching i've been jack for the cardboard herald

Progress saved