What is the PERFECT Board Game?
Transcript
I want you to think of your favorite board game in your collection or one that you've played recently now hold that thought would you consider that game that you're thinking of as the perfect board game well that's what we're going to be talking about in this video we're going to ask the question what makes the perfect board game and it's a question that I've pondered for many years about and I've come to some interesting conclusions hi my name's Danny I'm an avid modern board gamer from Australia who loves sharing my passion for this hobby with you my friends and my family come and join me for another talking Sanctuary video
board games are a huge part of our Lives whether we're at the beginning of the board game hobby Journey where we're discovering the mountain and Treasure of games out there or whether we're 10 years or 20 years down the track where we've kind of sifted through and cultivated our board game collections to a point where we're kind of satisfied with the games that we've got or you're like me we're constantly still moving games along and also so getting new games in and I've often wondered um about the perfect board game what makes the perfect board game and it is often something that I think people search for people often use the term perfect board game in their everyday language um I mean I've been at a store and I've used the word perfect um myself when describing a game that I've discovered that I think ooh this board game would be perfect for my hubby and I or this game would be perfect for our non-gamer friends or this game would be perfect for you know our friends and family and so it got me wondering about what makes the perfect board game to say something is perfect is basically to describe an object or an ID that has no imperfections whatsoever that means everything works everything does what it needs to do and everything succeeds in expressing the ideas the thoughts the mechanics and the theme in such an elegant and clean way and so when I
think of perfect there's a few things that I consider the games that you see on this shelf right behind me are some of my favorite board games in my collection which is why I kind of have showcased the games kind of like when people showcase their favorite books on their bookshelf these are my favorite Euro games that I love very dearly and so when I think of a perfect game I often think well maybe I should start with the games that I really love games that make me feel um really passionate about wanting to play that game again or maybe a game that really immerses me in a theme or allows me to explore different strategies or approach different puzzles with a new mindset a new sense of freshness or that motivation to just really want to do really well maybe a game has a really great sense of interaction and that's what brings me to the table and go H I really want to play this game with my partner so I'm going to save this game for when my partner's free to play with them because it would be the perfect game and the perfect way to spend time together quality time that is and so my first point that I want to say in terms of exploring this idea of perfection is that different board games are for different people and not every board game is going to suit every everyone some people love word games and some people absolutely despise them and so if you're someone whose mind really works linguistically well then maybe word
games will definitely play to your strengths maybe you're someone who loves crime and fiction and so deduction games are probably more your flavor of the month or maybe you're someone who loves War gaming where you just really want to get that sense of putting troops on the field using mechanics to kind of move around and navigate and tachy attack the other plays and so everyone has their own interest and I guess the way to describe this is when you walk into a Bookshop there's all these different genres where you can kind of explore biographies Fiction comics graphic novels you're always going to kind of wander into the section that really appeals to you most if you love biographies you're going to go to that section if you love Science Fiction and Fantasy you're going to go to that section those books speak to you those stories speak to you those themes really reach out to you and so when I walk into a board game store and I think o I'm going to find the perfect game in some ways I'm saying I'm finding the perfect game for the person that this game is actually intended for so if I'm playing with a group of people and I'm going away for an Airbnb the perfect game would be a light game where there's you know lots of players easy to set up lots of simple rules really highly interactive but if I want to play or pick a game that I think oo I really want something that's going to challenge my way of thinking then I'm probably
going to go for a 4H hour EUR game I know that's not everyone's cup of tea but that's what I enjoy that's what's perfect for me and so for me it also depends on the time of day time of year and what I actually feel ready for like if it's a long weekend I'm going to really get out some of those big Euros that I don't often get out but if it's a week night after work the perfect you know filler or coffee table game is going to really satisfy that aspect of what I need in terms of gaming at that moment in time so I think different games appeal to different people they appeal to their interests they appeal to what sort of availability they have to engage with a game and it also becomes a little bit more contextualized as well so where you are if you're playing at a bar if you're playing at home if you're playing at a friend's house a convention you're probably going to more be inclined to perceive a game in a certain way and the perception is actually a very strong thing that I've discovered in fact it's taken about 10 years of reflecting my experiences the highs and lows in being in this board gaming hobby to really understand how perception can really warp your reality or understand what a game can really provide for you when I first got into the hobby I was more inclined to lean towards games with lots of color you know takenoko was one of those games where was drawn into its cool Japanese theme and also the fact that you got these 3D bamboo pieces and the hex tiles and so the communication
of an expression of those games really spoke to me cuz I liked the theme but I also felt o this is really warm this is really inviting and so my perception of those sorts of family games was really quite good but then over time I was like my perception kind of games change especially when I saw mechanics and IDs repeated in other games throughout the years and so I was like H maybe there are other games that I haven't explored where my perceptions need to be challenged a bit a lot of these Euros especially the Stephen fiur that you see up here um I would have just walked by you know 8 years ago would have just said nope there's no way I'm going to pull off you know oracle of delie or laav off the shelf and be interested in it um the art itself is probably not as appealing I mean you've got carpedm which is just in this white box I was probably less inclined to pick up those games cuz my perception of those games was that they were really difficult they're really challenging and it wasn't something that I could connect with and so at that time my idea of a perfect game wasn't you know a beig Euro it was more like okay what speaks to me what do I perceive is something that I will enjoy and so in the early days I really enjoy just playing lots of colorful games like camel up and games like steampunk rally where there's lots of dice and there's things that you can do and everything's very tactile but I'm
kind of in this like weird phase right now where my perception is the more beige a game looks and the more classical a game looks the more I think it's going to be a good game for me and see I think 5 years ago would never have been able to say that I would have said you know what Yokohama cast's burgundy there's no way I'm going to try them they look way too intimidating but now it's something I embrace and so I realize your perception of a game does really influence what you think the perfect game is for you now when discovering the perfect game mechanics are a very important aspect of it lots of people often think well I really like lost ruins of arnac are they similar games out there or I really liked the card play in terraforming Mars do you have other games that kind of tick that kind of same feeling and gives you that same hit of endorphin rush and positive interaction when you play it and so plays or I've discovered that along the way certain mechanics have reached out to me in certain ways and I will always love worker placement games it doesn't matter how you repackage rethe the game worker placement games will always speak to me but not every worker placement game I think is perfect there are different games that do worker placement well in certain areas and other games do worker placement worlds in different ways and so sometimes my collection of worker placement games collectively by
allowing or having games in my collection and explore that mechanic in multiple ways from multiple angles and multiple twists to that familiar mechanic is something that I will be drawing to because I just find that mechanic is satisfying you know I've got a friend who really loves card play or deck building and so players who like that mechanic are probably going to search for games that Express that mechanic in different ways whether it's tucking cards or coloring cards in different ways or building your deck of cards in you know an interesting way that no one else has built it before or it might be you know multi-sided multi-functional cards that have multiple uses and so I find that when you're exploring or trying to find that perfect game you've got to take into account what you like in terms of the mechanisms and how those mechanisms are conveyed and you often really really gravitate towards games that have mechanisms that you are often uh feel comfortable and safe with and I think that's probably the word I'm looking for that if a board game makes you feel really safe but also really excited to play it that marriage of the two kind of equates to a lot of the enjoyment that you have and if you can find someone else who shares that same love then you're going to be playing board games up until like 4:00 a.m. in the morning but mechanics don't always gel well together there is some games which are really good but they kind of just pick
mechanics from all these different places and meld them together to kind of express some of the themes in the game they've used this work placement mechanic but they've also this card play mechanic and they've also use you know this drafting mechanic I'm not a fan of you know drafting but I like worker placement and so some games because they a Frankenstein meld of different mechanics it can kind of affect your uh perception and whether that game might be perfect for you having an emotional connection and an emotional feeling with a theme is something that will influence and often influences me as to whether I think a game will be perfect if it is a game about going to the shops in Ido Japan and you know moving your workers around a Rond Del in the game iy compared to the same mechanics in a game about you know collecting rocks I might feel more of an emotional connection with the Japanese theme game because you know of my cultural background but I also love that theme and I love what it does and the way the art might be expressed in the game really influences whether you think it's a perfect game for you or not there are some people out there who love abstract games I do like some really paired back Euros where there's just a you know simple track simple symbols as long as the mechanics uh kind of evoke that thought process in a more interesting and Innovative and creative way I'm you know definitely down to play a game that isn't got all the you know cool dressings but more and
more these days there's a lot of games that are really really over produced they come with all these Miniatures uh you can op from upgrade creting your cardboard tokens into wooden tokens you can get 3D printed trays and everything there's all this over production and then you think about what is the core element of this game that I like is it the miniature model if I just wanted a miniature I could just print one myself or go and buy a miniature but if the Miniatures actually enhance the experience in some way then or a part of or integral to the gaml that's going to make you feel an emotional connection to the mechanics the theme and the story and so it does come down to how you relate to games just like in real life when we have our friendship groups or our close friends or our family members we relate to different people in different ways because we understand who they are holistically as an individual and we're like oh I get that person that person gets me and so board games are kind of like that too where each board game has its own little personality I know this is really weird this analogy of using but stick with me but yeah like if it's a game like root I feel connected to the theme I feel connected to the presentation I feel connected to the uh world but I don't really feel a strong connection to the mechanics so I know what I'm going to be getting myself into and for me rude is not going to be the perfect game whilst it is a cool
game it is not the perfect one for me I don't have that Affinity with wanting to engage in tactical battles around the map and then learning Asm metric Powers but if it's a game like you know Great Western Trail or Ark Nova the idea of building a zoo or sifting through cards to get high quality cattle I'm going to feel great more Affinity with it whilst I'm not a farmer or a zooe keeper by any sorts the idea of the animals and building properties is something that really speaks to me and my values and so your core beliefs as an individual as a player and as a gamer is really important because we often look in games for reflections of ourselves we look in a game for people that represent who we are so if I look in an South Asian themed board game I'm going to look for characters ideas themes that represent who I am because that's where I'm from and other people going to look for other things that represent where they're from whether it's their cultural background their gender their ethnicity all of these things are important to us and so when we find a game that expresses those idas we value those games more we place more value on a game and this can be applied to pretty much most games even if it's a space game because people who really love and value the progression of
technology and science and exploration my hubby loves astronomy he loves you know he plays a game where he builds rockets on the computer like that sort of stuff he connects with it appeals to him it's part of his values that he enjoys creating designing testing and seeing these things play out I'm more of an emotional person I kind of go on this little weird emotional wave or emotional Journey where I'm like okay you know games like decorum or Roco will appeal to me because you know I love you know the idea of creating clothing for people or moving into a house and I can relate to those ideas these themes really connect with us and without that connection that game is meaningless to us and so this thematic emotional feeling and tug that we have with a game often is the thing that brings us most Joy from it so what I've spoken about so far is all about how we relate to games but then there's another whole as aspect that kind of influences what we think a perfect game is and if you actually browse Board Game Geek each game kind of has its own rating and I have a general rule when I'm looking up and deciding whether to purchase a game I'll often look at the board game geek rating look at people's comments look at the mechanics go to the official website watch videos and often a rating of 7.2
or higher will say to me that a lot of people like the game it also depends on how many votes there are and sometimes there are games that hit kind of like the 6.5 to 6.7 I'll be like oh maybe I don't need that game now but that Collective scoring system influences our opinion on what a perfect game is and there are no games with an overall average Board Game Geek rating of 10 out of 10 even the number one game doesn't have that rating and so when you browse those online forums some people rate games a one a 10 and nine and you know there's a whole you know dynamic behind and reason behind why people vote in that way but that kind of influences our perception of the game and what makes it perfect and so if I see a rating of eight I'll start thinking well that was good for that player maybe it's perfect for me too and so it'll get me that one step closer to envisioning this game that I haven't actually feel physically got in my hands yet as this is the next perfect game I must buy it I must acquire it I must search all online forums and eBay and find the best price and who will ship it to me the quickest but that my most of the time 10 times out of 10 that game is not going to be the perfect game for you what you thought was going to be the perfect game or was an interesting game
probably wasn't the perfect game and sometimes you do need to sit down down and play a game uh and actually and play it physically or online to actually discover whether you know what actually what I thought was a perfect game was not really a perfect game and one example that I have of this is Forest Shuffle and I think Forest Shuffle was a game or is a game which has multi-use uh cards and it just for some reason didn't make it to Australia it's now available in Australia which is great um so the first time I played the game I got to play it at a convention called playcon uh earli in the year and I was like I really want to play Forest Shuffle this is a game I've been waiting my entire 2 years for but I was like this is a game for me it's got animals it's got engine building it's got combos it's got card play ah sign me up and then I played it and then I was like okay okay I see what this game's doing okay I like the cards okay and I like the the way you score and things and then I came out at the end of the game and I was like huh that's probably not as great as I thought the game was going to be and the main reason for me and I think I've only played this really once so obviously I can change my opinion about this but the idea that certain scoring methods in the game lead you down certain Pathways and force well not
forces you but entices you to to collect certain card types I think that's probably um something that I noticed straight away and I was like uh I enjoyed my game of this but you know what maybe I don't need to get it maybe I don't need to own this game and then all of a sudden my expectations that were up here were kind of realistically adjusted and I was like ah I've just Sav myself you know 30 bucks or 40 bucks maybe I'll get this game when it's a little bit cheaper or maybe when there's more expansions we get this idea in our head that Perfection is going to make us happy or this game is going to be perfect in this situation and I can tell you there are lots of times where I thought this game is going to be perfect we play and like actually that game is horrible into the sell par it goes and yeah you can never really predict these things but having or using the word perfect probably isn't the right word to describe a game I'd probably use the word fit the right fit this game fits with interest that I like people that enjoy playing this mechanic or genre and I think it will fit uh the group of people that I've got and so I think I'm feeling like that I need to move away from the using the word perfect to describe board games which kind of has given me a little bit of a reality check
because using the word perfect implies that there are no imperfections there's nothing wrong with the game something that is perfect cannot exist in the board gaming World it might do lots of things that you enjoy and so when I go back to that first question I asked you at the beginning of the video uh think of your favorite game would you say it's a perfect game most likely my answer to that question would be no it's not a perfect game but it doesn't mean that it's not my favorite game and that's because I recognize that the imperfections in the game make it a really good fit for me the imperfections is what makes me like it the imperfections and the fact that it stands out it's Unique it expresses mechanisms in ways that I may not have thought about really give me that uplifting satisfying feeling of like yes I love this game yes I want to play it again next week yes I just want to play this on rotation and share it with every single person I know and that's how you know you find when you found the right game for you the right game for your collection it's because it fits so neatly into your life it fits so neatly onto your shelf it fits so neatly into your values how you feel what you want from a board gameing experience and that's truly for me the definition of it uh if you found this video super
insightful helpful bit philosophical I mean I've just been really talking off the coffee so there's been no script so if you really really appreciate the content that I make uh please consider buying me a coffee every month by heading over to my patreon page I would so appreciate it because I love making more modern board gaming content and yeah I would love for you to add to this discussion what do you think is the perfect board game should we be using the word perfect to describe board games or does it not exist at all thanks once again for joining me for another board game sanctury video please consider subscribing and liking uh my channel and this video if you want to check out some more of my amazing board game content please head over to my main YouTube page and there's hundreds of videos on there this is Danny sna I'll see you again soon for another video