Heavy Board Games Are OVERRATED (only play small box..)
Transcript
Okay, I want to start with a confession because I think every board gamer listening is going to recognize exactly what I'm about to describe. How many times have you sat down for a game night, watched someone pull out a box the size of a small microwave, waited 20 minutes for setup, listened to a rules teach that feels like a TED Talk, and then finished the game at midnight not quite sure whether you actually had fun. You just know you invested a lot of time, and that investment has to mean something, right?
Oh, every single week. And here's the kicker, the part that honestly kills me. Meanwhile, there's a small box sitting on the side of the table, something with, I don't know, 16 cards in it, and that's the game that made everyone laugh, everyone lean forward, everyone argue, everyone immediately ask for another round, but we treat that little box like it's the appetizer, like it's what we played while we were waiting for the real meal. And that is exactly what we want to push back on today because the hobby has this completely backwards. Small box light board games are not the appetizer. For most groups, most of the time in the actual real world where we actually play these things, they are the main course, and the sooner we stop treating complexity as a proxy for quality, the better off everyone's game nights are going to be.
Strong opening, and I want to get into why because I know there are people hearing this right now going, "Wait, but BGG disagrees with you. Every top 100 list disagrees with you. The hobby consensus disagrees with you." So, let's start there. Let's start with the Board Game Geek problem because I think that's where a lot of this mythology gets built. Right. So, if you mention a game that sits in the BGG top 10, eyebrows rise. People nod. They take it seriously. If you pull out something that ranks in the 2000s, everyone assumes it's lesser. And look, BGG has become the de facto standard by which hobby gamers measure quality, and I understand why. It's a massive community with huge amounts of data, but here's what I think people miss. The top 100 is disproportionately dominated by big, complex games, and it's not because those games are inherently better. It's a sampling bias problem fundamentally.
Exactly. The people rating games on BGG are overwhelmingly hardcore hobbyists with hundreds of plays under their belts and a taste for heavy systems. When you ask that specific population to rate games, of course their preferences dominate the output. You're asking the most committed, complexity-loving slice of the hobby to tell you what the hobby values, and then treating that result as objective truth.
And the really damning part, the part I think deserves way more attention, is that our view is that when you correct for that bias mathematically, when you strip out the complexity premium from the ratings, lighter games would climb significantly. Games that were buried would get lifted. Small, elegant designs that were being underrated by a skewed audience would start to look exactly as good as they actually play. Which means the BGG top 100 is not really a list of the best board games. It's a list of what a very specific type of gamer finds most impressive, and those are very different things. So, the next time someone dismisses a small box game because, and I quote, "It ranks low on BGG," understand that's not a verdict on the game. That's a statement about who was doing the rating. Okay, so that's the data problem. Let's talk about the language problem because I think this is maybe even worse in some ways. We have a vocabulary in the hobby that is actively working against light games, and I don't think we notice it anymore because we've internalized it.
Yeah, and the biggest offender is the word deep. In tabletop culture, deep has become synonymous with complicated. We call games deep when they have a lot of rules, a lot of subsystems, a lot of things to track, and that's just wrong. A better word for most of what we call deep would be broad.
Unpack that. What's the difference? A game like A Feast for Odin has enormous surface area, over 60 action spaces, cascading resource chains, and overwhelming number of paths to points, but surface area is not the same as depth. Breadth means many things to do. Depth means meaningful decisions where the right answer is genuinely hard to find. Those are completely different properties of a game. And when you split that hair properly, some of the most strategically demanding games ever designed are small box light games. Skull is my go-to example here, Hervé Marlys' design. You start with four discs, three flowers, and one skull. Everyone simultaneously places one disc face down on their mat to start. From there, on each player's turn, they can either add another disc to their stack or open the bidding. When someone feels confident, they bid on how many total discs across the whole table they can flip without revealing a skull. Other players raise or pass. The highest bidder has to back up the claim, and they always start by flipping their own stack first. Two successful challenges wins the game or be the last player left if everyone else has been eliminated.
Reveal a skull, you permanently lose a disc with the player whose skull you uncovered randomly selecting which one gets removed. Run out of discs, you're eliminated. The rules literally fit on one page. One page, and the game is a masterclass in psychological depth. Reading body language, managing your credibility across rounds, deciding when to lay a trap, knowing when an opponent is bluffing against you, managing the consistency of your own behavior so people can't read your tells across multiple games. None of that is in the rulebook because none of it needs to be. The depth emerges entirely from human interaction. That's not a shallow game. That is one of the purest, most demanding social games ever designed, and calling it light because the rule set is simple is like calling chess simple because there only six piece types. And then there's filler, which I think does even more damage. When we call small box games fillers, we are preemptively dismissing them as content that occupies time while we wait for the real game. That framing is not just unfair, it's inaccurate, and we'll come back to that one at the end because it deserves its own moment. Let's get into the next big problem, which is that heavy games have a complexity creep problem, and we don't talk about it enough. Complexity creep is real. It's been happening in the hobby for years.
It's the tendency for games and their expansions to accumulate more and more mechanics over time beyond what the design actually needs, and it happens at three levels. Designer, publisher, consumer. Designers who are deeply familiar with their own games fail to notice how daunting the experience is for new players. That's level one. Exactly. Publishers respond to a market that's been conditioned to associate value with component count. Bigger box, more chits, more cards, thicker rulebook must be worth more money. That's level two. And then consumers, having absorbed that conditioning, reach for the heavier box because it feels like more value for the dollar. That's level three. Those three levels reinforce each other until you've got a whole ecosystem optimizing for the wrong thing, which is basically wine snobbery at that point. More complex tastes get treated as simply better, and nobody stops to ask if they're actually delivering a better experience. And it's worth pointing out, almost nobody in this hobby started with a heavy game. We all started with something accessible, and we got into heavier stuff as we found our feet, but the culture treats that starting point as something you graduate out of rather than something to appreciate on its own merits. The result is a market flooded with games that are heavy not because heaviness serves the experience, but because the audience has been conditioned to reward it. That is not good design philosophy. Adding complexity is easy. Stripping a game to its essentials and making every rule and every component carry its weight, that is hard. That is a design achievement.
And the game I always pull out to make that point is Coup, Rikki Tahta's design, political bluffing card game. And I swear, every time I bring it to a table, it proves the whole thesis. Walk people through it because it really is elegant. Each player gets two face-down character cards representing their influence at court plus two coins. On your turn, you take an action, collect income, use a character's ability, or spend seven coins to launch a coup against someone, which forces them to lose an influence. Every character ability can be bluffed. You can claim to be the Duke and take three coins from the treasury whether you have the Duke or not because nobody can see your cards. Anyone can challenge you. Wrong challenge, the challenger loses an influence. Right challenge, you lose an influence. Lose both cards, you're out. The whole thing fits in a small box.
Setup is two minutes. A game takes 15 minutes on the outside, and the decisions are real. When to bluff, when to hold the truth in reserve, when to call someone out, when to let a lie pass because the timing isn't right, and calling it hurts you more than it hurts them. I have had post-game Coup discussions that ran longer than the game itself because every decision had stakes, and everyone had an opinion on what they would have done differently. That is not filler. That is a complete game. Complete game, and this is where we need to talk about something that advocates for heavy games rarely want to say out loud, which is that those games are actively punishing to the people who are not having as much fun as the optimizer at the table. Analysis paralysis, that's the name for it. It's well documented. It happens when the decision space in a game is so large that a player becomes cognitively overwhelmed and just takes forever to act. A game that should take 60 minutes drags into a four-hour affair that is sluggish and boring for everyone involved. And the keyword is everyone.
The person experiencing paralysis is not the only one suffering. The whole table is stuck waiting for them to make a decision, which is a structural problem with heavy games, not a personal failing of individual players. A Feast for Odin has 60 action spaces. Analysis paralysis is practically baked in for a new player. There's nothing wrong with that player. The game is handing them a cognitive problem that genuinely takes time to solve. Small box games solve this architecturally. When the decision space is constrained by design, the tempo of the game stays up. Love Letter is my favorite example of this principle in action. 16 cards. That's the entire deck. That's it. On your turn, you draw one card and choose which of the two cards in your hand to play. That's your complete decision. One card, two options. The card has an effect. Maybe you secretly look at someone's hand.
Maybe you compare values with a neighbor. Maybe you protect yourself from effects for a round. The round ends when the deck runs out or when one player is the last one standing. And whoever holds the highest card wins that round. Seiji Kanai for anyone keeping track of designers. And in our group, we played four full rounds of Love Letter in under 30 minutes one evening, and every single person was engaged for every single turn of every round. Because the turns are fast and the tension is constant. Knowing there's only one card of each key value in the deck turns every discard into information, every draw into an opportunity, every bluff into a gamble. The deduction layer sits perfectly on top of the simplicity. And nobody is waiting more than 30 seconds for the person next to them. That is what good design looks like. The constraint is not a limitation. It is a feature. Okay, now this is the argument that I genuinely believe should end the debate. And yet it somehow never does. And I want us to just sit with it for a minute. That copy of Gloomhaven sitting in the corner of your gaming shelf. Think hard. How many times have you played it in the last year? Oof. Now ask yourself how many times you've played Skull or Coup or Love Letter in the same period.
And be honest.
The ratio is embarrassing. It's genuinely embarrassing. The most objectively impressive board game is worthless if it never hits the table. And heavy games for the vast majority of gaming groups face a brutal barrier to play. Coordinating three to five adults for a free evening is already hard. Then you add a four-hour time commitment. Then you add the need for everyone to have done their homework on the rules. Then you add the 30-minute teach if anyone new is joining. The math is not in your favor. Small box games have none of those barriers. They live in your bag. They come out at restaurants while you wait for food. They work when someone cancels and you're down from four players to three. They are the games that get played when someone suggests one quick game before we go, and you actually end up playing for two hours because everyone's having too much fun to stop. Portable, easy to learn, quick to play, addictive to revisit. The kind of game you can toss in your bag, bring to a gathering, take on a trip, and break out without a second thought.
I have never once canceled a game of Skull because someone was tired. You can play it at any energy level because the game meets you where you are. And I think this is connected to something that deserves its own moment, which is that small box games are the real design achievement. Not just also good, not just valid on their own terms, actually objectively harder to pull off. The hobby has a romance with ambition. Big games signal ambition. Look at everything we packed in here. Look at the rulebook. Look at the interlocking systems. That is a lot of work. Nobody's denying it's a lot of work. But stripping a game to its essentials and delivering a complete, satisfying experience with the minimum possible complexity, that is one of the hardest things to do in game design. Reiner Knizia has built a career on exactly that principle. His best games give players a tiny number of actions, sometimes literally one choice per turn, and generate enormous strategic tension from those minimal inputs. Easy to learn, hard to master. Maximum depth for minimum cost and complexity. When you play a small box game that genuinely clicks, where the decisions are real, the interaction is constant, and the 20-minute runtime leaves you immediately wanting another round, you are experiencing design at its most disciplined. That is harder to achieve than putting 60 action spaces on a board and asking players to optimize across all of them. The design restraint is the achievement. Adding more rules is easy. Making fewer rules do more is the work. That reframe changes everything about how you look at these games. And
then there's the real-world argument, which I think we need to spend a minute on because it's the one that gets dismissed most often but matters most. Board games do not exist in a vacuum. They exist in the real world where adults have jobs, families, limited energy, and limited time. Any honest conversation about which games are better has to account for the context in which games actually get played. Heavy games are implicitly luxury goods. They require a luxury of time, a luxury of dedicated space, a luxury of a group that is equally committed to a long-form experience. For some groups, on some evenings, that luxury is available. Great. But for most groups, most of the time, it is not. Small box games fit into real life. They are portable. They scale gracefully. A game of Skull is genuinely excellent anywhere from three to six players, which means it survives the chaos of real group scheduling. They teach in minutes, which means you can bring in new players without anxiety.
And they are affordable, which matters way more than the hobby usually acknowledges.
When I travel, my gaming bag contains small box games. Not because I'm settling for less, because those are the games that will actually get played. The games that come out on a hotel table, in an airport lounge, at a family gathering where half the people have never played a hobbyist game in their lives.
And that connects to the growth argument, which I think is the one the hobby really needs to internalize. Board games have been growing. More people are discovering tabletop at this moment than at any previous point in history. And gateway games, accessible titles, small box games, those are the reason for that growth. It's not heavy games that are bringing new people in. It's the small, welcoming, elegant ones.
Almost nobody starts with A Feast for Odin. Nobody's introduction to the hobby is, "Here's a four-hour Euro game with 17 subsystems. Have fun." People come in through Love Letter, through Codenames, through Sushi Go. Those are the building blocks. So if the community valorizes only heavy games, if the conversations, the reviews, the rankings, the YouTube content are all oriented around complexity and weight, then we're building a hobby that is hostile to newcomers. We are communicating implicitly that you are not a real gamer until you can handle a four-hour Euro with 17 subsystems. That is not a welcoming message, and frankly, it's not accurate.
who has played a hundred games of Skull is not a lesser gamer than the person who's played 10 games of Twilight Imperium. They've had a hundred experiences of psychological tension, social reading, bluffing, risk management, shared laughter. That is what games are for.
And this brings me to the thing that I think genuinely needs to die. The word filler. In board game circles, calling a game a filler is meant to be descriptive, but it functions as dismissal. A filler is something you play while you wait for the real game to arrive. It occupies time without mattering. It is the bread basket, not the meal.
And that framing is wrong on every level.
Empirically, first of all, a game like Skull has won awards, has been praised by professional critics, has been played by millions of people across dozens of countries. It's not filling a gap, it's creating an experience. The filler label is applied based on box size and rulebook length, not on the quality of what the game actually does.
Second, it reveals a set of values the hobby has absorbed from the wrong places. Bigger is better is a marketing idea, not a design principle. The assumption that more rules means more value is the same logic that leads people to buy overpackaged products because the box looks impressive on the shelf.
And third, and this is the one that genuinely bothers me. Calling small games fillers communicates something harmful to new players.
It tells them that the game they enjoyed, the game they laughed hardest at, the one they immediately wanted to play again, is not the good stuff. That the good stuff is something they haven't earned yet. That is not an invitation. That is a gatekeeping mechanism with a velvet rope.
Every game that delivers what games are supposed to deliver, tension, social connection, meaningful decisions, memorable moments, is a complete game. Box size has absolutely nothing to do with it.
And I want to be clear before we wrap, because this is important. We are not saying heavy games are bad.
Please, nobody throw your Gloomhaven in the bin. Don't do it. Twilight Struggle is a masterpiece. Root rewards hundreds of hours of study with something genuinely brilliant. The Old King's Crown is one of the most interesting designs of the last five years. There's real value in the deep end of the hobby. What we're saying is narrower and more specific. The hobby has a prestige problem. Heavy games receive cultural status they haven't entirely earned. Light games get dismissed using a vocabulary that was never designed fairly. And the ranking system that most hobbyists treat as gospel is demonstrably biased towards complexity in a way that misleads the majority of players who aren't hardcore enthusiasts. When someone who just discovered the hobby asks, "What should I play?" and the answer they get is a list of games weighing 4 kg each with rulebooks the length of a master's thesis, we are failing them. And when someone pulls out Skull at a game night and an experienced player sighs and says, "Oh, a filler."
we are failing the game. The goal is not to tear down heavy games. The goal is to build up the honest conversation around small ones. I want to tell one story to close this out because abstract arguments only go so far. We had a game night recently, planned around a heavy Euro. Resource tracks, central board covered in action spaces, individual player boards with upgrade trees, all of it. The teach alone ran close to 40 minutes. By the time we actually started playing, two of the six people at the table had that glazed-eye look of someone who had committed to a thing they were no longer sure about.
The worst look at game night. The worst look at game night. Exactly. And we had 30 minutes left. Someone pulled out Skull. No explanation needed for anyone. Two minutes of setup and for those 30 minutes that table was alive in a way it had not been during the previous three hours. People were laughing. People were calling each other out. Someone slammed the table when a bluff got caught. The session ended on the right note and the Skull game was the one everyone talked about on the way home. That is not an anomaly. That is the pattern repeated across countless game nights, across every group we've ever played with. The small game delivers every single time. The BGG data tells us the rankings are biased toward complexity. The design thinking tells us elegance is harder to achieve than breadth. The actual play data tells us small games get to the table more often, reach more players, and create more shared moments. And the cultural criticism tells us that our vocabulary itself, heavy, deep, filler, is working against the games most people actually love. Put all of that together and the argument writes itself. Small box light board games are not a lesser tier of the hobby. For most people, in most situations, with most groups, they are the better choice. They're the games that get played, that bring people in, that generate the moments you talk about for weeks afterwards. They're designed with restraint, which is harder than it looks. They're accessible, portable, and social in ways that heavy games often
aren't. So stop calling them fillers. Stop treating complexity as a virtue. Stop letting a biased ranking system tell you what is good. Grab the small box. Sit down. Play. And on that note, we'll catch you next week. Happy gaming, everyone.