Skip to main content
Loading video...

Drafting the WORST Gameday for a New Gamer

Transcript 22:41

So, last time we were here, we drafted the best game day for a new player. But that's not as fun as drafting potentially the worst game day for a new gamer. So, now you have lured somebody in. Yep. To your dungeon. Oh, let's play Carcone and then you got to come over for a game weekend. Yeah. So, yeah, we've had a good time and now we're going to hit them with the heaviest worst thing. Now, I'm not saying these are necessarily all bad games. No, they're great games, but these are not the things you should just hit someone who's barely in the hobby with. Yes, we're talking you know, it's got Katan and maybe Sushi Go and you're like, "And this game." So, the worst possible game day weekend. We We'll do it in chronological order so we can really gear up, you know, uh, ratchet up the psychological torture. So, Mikey, what is going to be the first game you're playing to make it the worst game day/game weekend, whatever, for a newer gamer.

So, we're going for maximum psychological damage. Not necessarily. Do you want to ease up the psychological damage? Maybe. But what I want to do is I want to do stuff that's going to overall inflict the most damage possible. So I might be going a little higher, a little lower. Um, so to start, um, I got to do it. I got to start big. I got to start big. Wow. We're going straight away. Oh god. We're going to hit you with some Horseless Carriage. Yeah, Horseless Carriage is a splatter game. These games are big. Show the back of the box real quick. These games are heavy. They go real deep on the art. Um they The reason they don't show the back is because the art in the inside is awful. It is awful. It's clip art. It's the worst. These games are good. These games are often types of games where it's like if you don't have a good first turn, you're going to lose.

So, if I'm going to really let someone know what's about to happen, I'm starting here with one of the ugliest heaviest games. They're prettier games which says says stuff a lot. Um but yeah, we're going to start with Horses Carriage. It's 3 to five player and it is 180 to 240 minutes. So we are starting off 3 hours deep at the minimum. I feel like that's a good start. This game is so heavy I have not played it yet. Yeah, it's true. And so I'm going to subject it to someone who's played even less games than I have. Boom. You know, horses carriage, John of the Automobile. Okay, that's a good start. That is a good start. Dang, that's a very good start. I'm trying to think. I kind of also want to go like pretty big. Uh, but I'm gonna go big, confusing, and you kind of can't talk. So, I'm going to go let's do a big four player only game of Deal with the Devil. I really like this game. Here's the thing. Deal with the Devil is four player only. You can only play it four player.

Sure. Uh, again, same thing. Two-hour game. So, we're starting off big. So, this is a game where someone is the devil, someone is uh like uh a cultist, and then the other people are villagers. The thing is is once you have your role, you can't really talk about your role because you're trying to stay hidden. You also can't really ask questions about anything. So, we're going to get into a complicated ass game where you also aren't ever allowed to ask any clarifying questions. So, we're go with Deal with the Devil, a big chunky Euro game that is tough to play even for experienced gamers. H. Yeah, that's rough. To add a little bit more juice to my first pick with Horseless Carriage, because I don't know it, when I sit them down to play it, I'm going to then crack open the rule book for the first time, sit there and read the rules in front of them, and then try my best to then explain the game, which will require several more references to that rule book. And I think that will really add Yeah. to the uh torture factor.

Yes. Um, Nick, Mike, I'm not all bad. No, I'm not all bad. Okay. Uh, after just pummeling them, woping with horseless carriage with horseless carriage, I feel like I should go a little bit easier on them. Um, and I'm going to I'm gonna do this, man. Go with me here. Yeah. I'm gonna hit them with some real time stress of kites. That's interesting. Okay. So, you've just gone through four plus hours of plotting and thinking and now we have sand timers and you have to be quick and you have to yell and stuff and I think that will be such a wild shift in the other direction. Granted, it's a fun game. I like this game.

Yeah. I think it'll just be jarring. So, I think the the the lightness of it, they won't be able to enjoy the beautiful kites because they will have been so used to not seeing color for so long that the vibrancy of Bessobel's art might make them cry. It might make them hurt inside. Yeah, that's an that's an interesting low-key sinister choice. Like, yeah, go with a crazy realtime game right after Horseless Carriage. Rough. Um, okay. So, I think we also we're going to be like, "Hey, let's after Deal with the Devil, I know you were very confused. Let's pick a game, a party game this time that'll be, you know, lot a lot more fun." But they don't know that I'm going to pick then, which is, in my opinion, more or less an unplayable game.

It's awful. It is so bad. It is not good. It it's basically this game where you have these like ven diagrams and these kind of crazy pictures and you're basically trying to relate the things. We we have tried to play this game multiple times like sat down try to play and every single time we have not finished it because it is too hard. It is too confusing. So now we're going to go like oh let's play a party game. It's after deal of the devil. Let's play a party game. Let's clean that pallet and we're going to play this one. Here's the thing. Things and Rings does a similar thing, but does it well. So, play Things and Rings. Do not play Vent. Um, man, that's a that's a rad choice, dude. That is pretty pretty gnarly.

Pretty gnar dogs, huh? Okay, so I have had them play Horse's Carriage. You have? I have had them play Kites. You haven't had them play Millie Fury yet? I have not. Oh, I I wish I could. Um, we're going to play Task Team. Oh, now Task Team is an interesting game, but this one is all about multitasking. Okay, because you have to Okay, let's see. You have someone who has to like do stuff with counters and spinners and dice and stuff. people have to like stack cards and do all these different things all at the same time. So again, it's like you've you've played something plotting and heavy. You've now played something quick and stuff like that and you're like, "Oh, well, if you're so good at kites and let's multitask and do a bunch more like crazy index stuff." So again, it's just going to now like start twist the blade.

Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. That game that game is play. It's a stressful play. Have played it before and it is it is it's stressful. Um okay. So now plus it plays three to 18 players and we will be playing it at 18 players. Yes, even if even if you there's only four of you, you have to take multiple roles. Um that's important. So man, gosh, this is tough because again, you don't want to just go like all these kids roll too big and heavy for a new person. That's not fun. And it's just that's the same psychological torture over and over and over again. Yeah. So I think I'm gonna go real weird with it. And um I am going to Oh, you man, you stole my idea.

Here's the thing. Technically, you can play Nemo's War Cooperative. We are not though cuz this is a solo game. So, they will be instead playing this game and I will just be yelling at them the entire time to play certain ways. I'm going to like quarterback the entire play of this or they can sit there and watch me play and I will yell at them if they speak to me. Yeah. So, I think a solo game would be a weird game to play on a game day with a new gamer, especially like a big heavy solo game. So, we're going to go with Nemo's War. I was going to say Black Sonata, but I'm going to play it and insist that I don't want help on clues. I'm like, do not tell me anything. Just sit there silently. Um, that's such a good pick, Nick. Nice. Um, let's make it real weird where they're just confused about what you're doing and why you're doing this.

Yes. Um, all right, man. We got to go back. We got to go back heavy. We're adding some some high conflict now, right? From what I understand, Fire in the Lake, Insurgency in Vietnam is one of the heavier GMT war games. Uh, you know, you know, this would be preferable if they're like, I don't want to re recreate that war. And like, we're doing it, man. Uh, and let's just check our time. Yeah, the complexity. Um, oh, it's at a five. It's a medium. Solitary stability at a nine. Very high. Um, it's one to two year uh years per campaign between coups. Uh, one to four full solitire system.

Um, and we're also going to learn this one out of the rule book because it's not even drank. Out of the rule book, baby. You can't just learn it. You gota No, that'd be crazy. Um. O. Okay. So, trying to think. So, let me see. What do I got over here? We got four. Oh, I have three. Okay. Yeah. I feel like, man, I also feel like I should give them a slight break or make them feel like they're taking a break because they've had a bunch of stuff. H trying to think of a game that's like just really stressful. And gosh, I don't know. Or maybe I should just go go big because we just hit him with Nemo's war.

So, let's do this. Let's go. Um, we're going to go back to big and we're going to go hegemony because this is also a big asymmetric game where everyone is trying to do their own thing. So, that'll be even more confusing. But, it's a big game, really, really heavy. Uh, lots and lots of stuff going on. Uh, and I just feel like it'd be rough for a first time. So, we're gonna choose Heijgemany. Lead your class to victory. Solid choice, man. Um, the problem with doing this draft is our collection is amazing. Too many good games. Too many good games. I'm like, well, how could they not love this? It's great.

That's the thing. We only have good games. That's That's the best part. Yeah. I'm also trying to think like I can't I can't just throw in stuff that I don't like. Sure. Yeah. No, of course. Because I'm We have to go through this game day, too, so we should at least enjoy ourselves. Yeah. Right. All right. Now, I'm choosing through the ages. Oh, God. New Story of Civilization. First of all, big game, heavy game. Second of all, everyone says, "Got to play this game digitally. It has a fantastic app. I've played over 300 times on the app. There's a lot of bookkeeping and stuff, a lot of pieces and things. And so they say like this game's rough to play in person. So that's what we're going to do. We're going to put the screens down. We're going to play this baby IRL. Probably to its detriment.

Yeah. But it's a great SID builder. This game's amazing. And so they should love it and be thankful that I'm showing it to them. They should be thankful. Dang it. Um Oh, that's a that's a in terms of like the big heavy ones that are gonna be very hard to understand. NASA up there. Okay. I had I just had an idea. What was it? Oh, yeah. That's right. So, here's the thing. I feel like I've been throwing a lot of bad stuff. A lot of stuff where they think they're doing good. They're not. So, I feel like at this point, this be the fifth game. They're be pretty angry. So, I'm like, look, let's just play a a co-op game. It's not super complicated. Too bad it is weirdly complicated. And it's also super passive aggressive. We're going to choose Decorum. I really love this game, but I feel like at this point in the night, they're pretty over us. And so, a cooperative game where you just have to be super passive aggressive the whole time.

That's a psychological really ratchet up the psychological torture. So, we're go to Cororum. You're trying to decorate a house together, but you're not allowed to tell each other what you want. You just kind of have to do it through like I don't really like that that much. It's great. I love it. But at this point in the night, I feel like it would not go over well. Okay. Okay.

Okay. Actually, one second. Be right back. Burbles. H. Trying to think of what's next. We got How many? We got five, six, nine, seven, eight, got five. So, three more. Huh? We're playing horseless carriage again. Yeah, baby. That's right. We are going back for seconds of that delicious in the rules. This time we know the rules. Can't be more than like 3, four hours. That was five or six. The first time it's going to be a breeze. We're playing horse carriage again. Again. I did I did not know that we were allowed to do that. I made it allowed.

Oh lordy. Okay, I would choose I think the worst thing you can possibly do. Think of what will happen to their psyche this and I think the worst thing you can do is subscribe. So, don't do that to us. That don't do that to us. That would really hurt us. I hate to see that. So, please don't do that. Um, okay. So, man, that is an interesting choice. Think about what happens the second time I pull it and set it on the Oh, I know, right? Like again, and you see them just shrink. Yeah. Just start to crumble. Yeah. Yeah. You really start to see it. Brutality, man. Man, tough.

Oh, man. I really want because again, now we're kind of in this they're angry and passive aggressive. I feel like I've got to hit him with something big again. Trying to think what's big and again also kind of complicated or just kind of confusing with lots, you know, let's do this. We're going to go tracaron because tracarion when you kind of like teach the game or learn the rules, I feel like a lot of it you're like, you know, this isn't actually that complicated. Sure. But people always talk about how heavy it is because when you get to like the second half of the game and your decisions really start to matter, your brain starts to crunch. And so I feel like we get in this like, oh my god, they're pulling out another big game for us to play. And then we learn and they're like, okay, this is big, but like I feel like maybe I can handle this.

But then it does and then it starts ratcheting up and the vice starts to tighten. I fear for for getting on Nick's wrong side. This guy is pretty pretty uh pretty gnarly. Um, you know what, man? I want to take it a little easy on my peeps. And so we're just gonna do some fun trivia, you know. And what's more fun than trivia about Justin Bieber as a child, folks? Justin Bieber's backstage pass. We will play this game to completion. You cannot end the game once you start the game until the game ends. Okay? And if you don't know Justin Bieber child Justin Bieber trivia, which none of us do, game's going to go on a while. Not going to lie. We punish ourselves with it occasionally. And now we're going to punish y'all. Okay. Trust me, backstage hats, baby. What a what a choice. What a choice. Um, okay.

Okay. So, we just came off of absolute pandemic with Mikey's kind of thing earlier. So, we just came off of another massive heavy game and then it's like, "Hey, let's do real time somewhat dexterity type stuff. We're going to do Rush MD, which is a real time cooperative game where you're running a hospital and you're having to flip stuff over. It's crazy. It's nuts." And I think at this point they'd be crying. Yeah. But we they're required to play. Oh, yeah. Oh, yeah. So, they're just knocking stuff over. Real time game in a hospital gets real crazy in this game. So, I think we're go with that. I do like that, man. All right, that's my final pick. We're at the end of the night.

Tears have been shed. Enemies made. I am going to give a peace offering of a proper board game. Proper Euro game. Some people really like this game. I'm not one of those people. This is Hamlet. This game is awful. Um, Mike does not like this game. Hate to say it. Hate to say it. It's not a good game. It's got massive legibility issues. It's got strange tile placement. And 90% of the things you do do not score you points in any one way. And so it really makes you wonder why we do them because they also don't seem to like factor into getting the things that do give you the points. It's going to be a game where you're going to be like leaning over the thing like what does that say? And you're just going to be like I can't bother with these strange shapes. They're not even polyominos. They're just some other thing. I think it will be the final the final thing that will just break them and turn them into a zombie.

That's fair. Hamlet. Boom. Boom. Okay. Could have been great. Huh. So, what for my last one? So, we just did what did I just pick? Oh, yeah. Rush MD. Rush MD was your last choice. Yes. So, what to end on? Maybe a nice game. I'm thinking about I'm thinking about throwing a bit of a bone. Maybe I can feel good. I don't know. But I don't I don't I don't know if I wanna I don't know if I want to. So I think we are then Hold on. I think Nick leaving the room is not a good sign. Is not a good sign for y'all.

I have a Happy gota guess to end our evening. We got to guess. We are going to play through all of Oath Sword. Yes. We are going to play through. Yes. It's the same thing like the entire box. The entirety of Oath Sword at the end of the night. Huge campaign game. Really complicated. Tough to learn. Tough to play. Great game. Yeah. But we're gonna play through the entire thing at at the end of the night. That will not be a short amount of time. It won't be Mikey. All right. I like that. Let's head over here. See how we did. Okay. So, here is our list. So, Mikey, so you're starting off with horseless carriage.

Starting off with horseless carriage. Okay. After that, we're going to hit him with some kites. Then we're going to make you multitask with some task team. Yeah. Then we are going to play in Fire in the Lake Insurgency in Vietnam. Big war game. They're going to play through the ages physically. We're back to horseless carriage. Justin Bieber backstage pass, which honestly after all of that anything to be anything different, this is actually a good good game in the situation. And on Hamlet, which is fine. Let's end on a mid note because it's almost more mentally damaging than another truly bad game. It's just like that was fine and that somehow hurts more. Yeah. All right. for me my game day game weekend. We're gonna start a deal devil four player complicated Euro where you kind of can't ask questions once you start. So hope they understand the rules. They won't. We're go to then we're let's keep up with a party game.

We're play we're going to play a party game that is basically unplayable in my opinion. Then they're going to watch me play a solo game and I will scream at them if they try to give me any suggestions. Then we're going to play hegemony. Four players. Everyone has an asymmetric um faction that you're trying to do. Big crazy heavy game. Then we're going to go decorum, which is a nice cooperative game where the whole point is you're being as passive aggressive to each other as humanly possible. Then trarion, which again is a heavy game that doesn't feel as heavy until you get halfway through and then the crunch really starts. Then we're going straight into like real time some dexterity. You're trying to make decisions. You're all feels like a party game, but it's actually really hard. Yeah, you're all talking at the exact same time. Kind of a Euro game crazy. And then we're finishing it off with all of Oath Sworn. So, down in the comments, let us know who had the best worst game day for new gamers. Let us know. And also put down your own list. Please put down your own list. But what do you think would be the worst game day for new gamers from your collection?

And the thing is is we're making this video and writing these lists so that we don't actually do this to anybody because that would be a bad thing. We want more board gamers, not less. So, don't do this to anybody, but have a thought about what you would if you did do it to somebody you didn't like. You know what I mean? Uh, and then we will share our hot goss in the comments uh, about our choices and stuff. If you like this kind of thing, please let us know. You want to see us do more board game drafts. We love doing them. We'd like to know if you enjoy them as well. If you are new to us, we won't ever do this to you. I promise. Just subscribe and then that won't happen. That's right. Uh, and we'll see youall next time. Bye everybody. Thank you for coming to the horrendous game day. Tune in next time to find out if Mike and Nick can draft more games. So, you get it. You get the idea of the channel. Like, comment, and subscribe.

Even if you don't get it, I can't play horseless cares again. Please.

Progress saved