Skip to main content
Loading video...

Top Ten Campaign and Legacy Games

Transcript 29:09

welcome to allies or enemies I'm Jess and I am Sean and today we are talking about Campaign games and Campaign games I know is a it's like a bit of a a strange term what does it mean exactly campaign versus Legacy and what else in that we're kind of talking about both so what we mean by Campaign games kind of is that they kind of tell a story that they've got a bunch of games that are going to link together maybe that some things change maybe that some things are added not all these games are gonna have all of those elements but they'll all have most of those elements and we love campaign style games we play probably about 25 games and we've narrowed it down to our top ten the tricky is it would be very easy to give spoilers because of the nature of it being Campaign games but we will not give any spoilers that's our spoiler-free guarantee there are going to be no spoilers in this video that will mean that there are fewer photos than we usually have just because we can't take photos of some of these games but we're really I think it is important for for all of these games not a giveaway anything that is going to be a nice surprise and we're not going to do that thing either where we're like it's not a spoiler but no nothing we're not even coming close to spoilers so on that note let's kick it off with our honorable mentions

my first honorable mention well my one honorable mention is Marvel Champions and I love love love love love this game and it's got a whole bunch of these campaigns so there's a bunch of expansion boxes that add campaigns for like Guardians of the Galaxy X-Men guys um there's a Spider-Man one and they are really cool and they kind of string together five different bad guys but the reason it's not in here is I just feel like you could play those five bad guys there wouldn't be an enormous difference in how you played them if you played them separately as if you played them in the campaign yeah it's a really good game but didn't make our list for top Campaign games this one is it's my honorable mention and it's mice and Mystics and I think this is one of the stronger narratives that we have on our list I really liked the story of the mice that are in the dungeon but it is a Dungeon Crawler dice rolling game and Sean does not really like dice dice don't agree with him um so I I like playing it but as an experience for the two of us it wasn't necessarily the best fit so we did the thing where we both rank them separately and then we mushed them together and this one would have easily I think made the top 10 if it was just on Jess's it was nowhere near the top of mine but I do really appreciate the story to it it's just the mechanics um well super good for an awful lot of people just didn't mesh with me

number 10 is Harry Potter Hogwarts battle is a deck building game and you go through the seven years of Hogwarts and so you are adding different friends and items and fighting the appropriate bad guys for each year as you go along and it is based on the the movies so it's the artist's snapshots from the films and I think as a campaign game it it does work pretty well you definitely feel more like your hairy like you know in year one at the start and things get a lot harder as you progress through the years they get a lot harder I think that's the thing with that surprises people about this game is that they think it's going to be like a kids game because it is it's a pretty simple deck builder it really like it doesn't break the mold in any major way but boy does it ramp up and then when you add the first the first expansion is impossible oh my goodness is it hard then the second one tries to make it kind of goes way too far the other way so that's what heads a little low but we're both Harry Potter fans and it's um yeah it's great and I I love being Neville but the tricky is a couple of the characters are way stronger than the other characters thankfully one of them is Neville who as we all know is actually the hero of the story and actually the one that all of the prophecies were about I really have some theories about Neville and character is Harry so I would have preferred to be some of the other characters we did find the Harry

Neville matchup was was too strong to really mix in the other ones too often and that's our number 10. number nine is the adventures of Robin Hood and this one I knew I would like already because I love Robin Hood my family's all from Nottingham and I grew up with Robin Hood everything uh it was just it was all over my childhood and so I've always really liked it even the not very good Robin Hood movies I've liked all of them and it's got will Scarlett in it I love will scarlet and it's got one of the better stories and it's this weird thing with an amazingly cool this book is really cool yeah and then the game board is set up like you pop out these little bits like an advent calendar a little yeah so you're popping out these guys um and putting them back in and and it works it works really well but it's got It's got some weird mechanics to it yeah and the narrative element is strong but the main mechanic is a shared bag builder of different two only two different types of Cubes that you're putting in and so then mechanically there is isn't a lot going on but as an experience it is really fun and I really like that we have our own emergent narrative that comes through based on which characters are doing what actions that go beyond the story which is nice yeah even though there's kind of a set goal how you get there can be super different where yeah Robin's doing

something and maybe he's not even doing the real hero thing and we found a lot of the times they just end up kind of doing the thing we would want them to do it ends up kind of fitting the characters and that movement thing is interesting how they move it's got like five pieces and there's two little pieces and then two medium pieces and then one long piece and when you play them you're kind of stringing them together but it kind of makes it so like you're gonna cheat with that a lot because it's it really is a life well you know it's almost there so it's good that it's a co-op game because it there's more of that than there is in most co-op games that we've played of just Little oh I can just oh yeah I'm totally in the shade it would definitely get me there meaning I'm safe whether we do do that a bit but because we're both doing it against the game it's it's more okay and that one is our number nine our number eight is tartarstone and this is interesting because a lot on our list are Cooperative games I think that makes sense for campaign style games but this is a competitive game and so you are each building out different buildings that you're you're sharing on your board as worker placement to collect resources and then trade those resources in for for various things that are helping out the town as you go along It's tricky to not say too much about the game I think uh one of the things I do like about

charterstone is the fact that it is a competitive campaign experience and the production is really good the production almost feels too good it's like there's a couple of campaign games like this that I feel bad because I'm like oh no I'm gonna throw this away at the end but I don't want to and definitely the coins in this you're going to want to keep those coins because they're amazing but there's also the meeples are lovely there's so much nice production into it and um it really it's it's a resource management game but it's got some nice some cool surprises a bit of an emergent narrative and it's it's fun I've heard like mixed things but I really liked it yeah and I think we've heard different things for two players how we really like the two players with each choosing two characters because we both ended up with like one that seemed to be a bit of a dud so it was nice that we weren't stuck with that one for the whole campaign uh but I know other people who have used just two in the Bots and they've liked it fine I think yeah I think you'd need at least the Bots though I don't think you'd want to play one-on-one without anything else but I think the two characters because it's not particularly heavy it's it's plenty easy to hop back and forth between this character and this character without losing your brain in it yeah definitely it is not like any AP so you can very easily control two characters and then you're not putting all of your eggs in one basket and that is our number eight on number seven I'm smushing two

together here it is zombie kids and zombie teens and a big reason for this is just my enthusiasm has won you over I know and we we bought this when we bought um teens I think we actually played first and we got this the first time that I had coveted uh and so we we got this and my brain was barely working and I was fully covered this was before the boosters had started and so I wasn't immune at all yet so I was full full covered uh and thinking very slowly and this was great and it would be such a great game for kids too because it's just it's fun it looks we were just talking about the production being too good production in this is phenomenal it looks so great you're adding stickers you're adding all sorts of fun stuff as you go it it is really fun and I think we do have a really soft spot in our hearts because of when we played it because we love playing games it's what we do and you weren't up for really any kind of game then and what we thought well for a week what can we get and this was wonderful because it is a great campaign and it does introduce elements and the actions you're doing on your turn are really simple but we did lose some games it's not like you're always gonna win and it's and it's no point in playing you know it is a little bit of a challenge but the decision making is really easy yeah it's got this cool kind of like Xbox award style like achievement style challenges where it's got all these different challenges that

you kind of put on yourself and some of them are really hard and then as you complete those challenges you get to open up stuff and get different things and it's super fast like it's like a 15-20 minute game yeah but it's fun every time and both of them are solid they're both different enough that I think they're worthwhile yeah that is true and I think there is the campaign element moving you through but I think the achievements is what kept us playing beyond that to try and get all of them which is an interesting way of keeping you in the game yeah the actual story is just this little comic book and it's very very simple but it's yeah it's those achievements that really bring you back and back and for kids if you're an adult who takes yourself real seriously doesn't watch cartoons uh I don't understand you first of all but also this maybe isn't for you but if you're the sort of person who can still really enjoy a good episode of avatar The Last Airbender for Phineas and Ferb or Phineas and Ferb which are both tremendous or if you've got kids I give this a shot especially you can pick it up for like 20 bucks I would give this quite affordable for how much you'll play it yeah it's a light kids game but it gets harder as you go trust me and it's it's just fun light nonsense so that is our number seven our number six is my city and this is a polyamano Style game so you are putting out shapes building your city but they did a really interesting campaign so it

starts off pretty straightforward and the new elements get added with each chapter and I think how long it's eight chapters in each one is three so 24 to play through which is a decent amount of games and if you play two players then you're you can just do the boards you didn't use and play through it again yeah they have the exact amount of components that if you play through it once you're going to have everything you need again we've just finished or we've just about we got two games left in the last chapter of our second playthrough absolutely no problems with having enough stickers and enough everything else to play back through again so highly recommended for that and it's great it's just it's a Reiner konitzia polyamano placing game that just as technically very sound and each one takes like 20 minutes but I don't think there's ever been a time we've played this one time we play this two or three times every single time we play yeah it's kind of built into that because they have three games in one chapter kind of like we we know you're gonna play three so here's the envelope open it up and play through the three but we love polyamino so it was a really interesting way of playing it and I think it was fairly affordable extraordinarily affordable so you cannot go wrong with this it is very yeah over here it's you can get it for less than 20 pounds um so yeah it's like a no-brainer really looking forward to very much number six

number five is in this is an interesting one because it's actually an expansion that added a campaign to a game and that is Scythe rise of Fenris we already really liked size before we got this I think me a little bit more than you but you're really on board at first but it's a little bit tricky to play at two players it's not its best self at two players but when we added the campaign I think it made a lot more interesting for us and this is one we really have to avoid talking about too much because of there's there's a lot of cool things to spoil but as you're going you're adding stuff that you can add to the game later as well as to the stuff now and the narrative is actually interesting the stuff you get is fantastic opening those boxes blew my mind and that it's an expansion to an existing game that takes a cool game and adds to it it's just awesome and it's such an interesting world because the art for Scythe is is beautiful and so having the campaign that takes you narratively into that world and has really big meaningful and like impactful things that happen with each chapter is is really interesting and like you say it's so hard to not give anything away but we really liked it we played through it the two of us then we played through it with a couple of our friends and then I think we went to play through it again yeah I think we've done this one this is super rare that we've done this what but yeah we packed the stuff back up in the boxes

and did it again even knowing everything that was going to come out of those boxes and it was like almost as much fun the second time as it was the first time and I'm a hundred percent on board for playing it again again like you could play through this over and over I think and still enjoy it gets permanently changed so if that's one of the differences maybe between a legacy because you're not gonna yeah you don't wreck up your copy of Scythe yeah exactly so nothing's permanently changed so it lets you play through it as many times as you want and we are holding to it because we will keep playing through it and I'm sure yeah and there's different paths you can take too so there's reasons to play through it at least twice yeah and that is our number five our number four is sleeping Gods which is a really open World sandbox kind of game I think this is the closest that we have found for something like a video game exploration world it is basically you you have your crew and you are on your ship and you have this whole world to explore and you can do it in whatever way you want so you visit places you get certain Clues to visit other places but there's nothing making you follow in those directions you can completely go completely off what Clues you have and keep pursuing other ones and it does such a great job of building this world and setting the scene and and having the decisions that you make in in one sitting be impactful for for another

sitting yeah it's got this really great system of like keywords so sometimes when you do things you just get a card that has a keyword and then that affects you in some way way and it's such a neat way of just having that keyword putting that aside and then and you have no idea sometimes sometimes they're like oh yeah go here oh you should go over to this party you should go over to this part or check out in the North or whatever it is but sometimes they're just like oh great to see you and then you just go on about your business and then later on you're like oh yeah that character oh yeah that thing and that was neat and this one took me a little bit of warming up too because the plays are long it's a lot of setups I think that's the trick it's not divided because it's however you want to do it it's not divided into any kind of chapters so you set it up and then you just play as long as you want and then there is a bit of a safe system and then you just continue so I think it takes maybe 15 to 20 hours to play through and so it's up to you whether that's you know two plays of ten hours or or lots of plays of two hours and we tend to prefer playing a game from one to two hours and that made it a bit tricky for us because it is if we're playing a short game of it it's a pretty big setup only to pack it away fairly quickly and not make much of a dent yet the save system is really good um because it's saving a lot of things but it does it very very smartly but it does mean a lot of setup and a lot of takedown and we would end up having four

or five hour game sessions and I think you're into that yeah but after two hours I'm my my attention span is waning and that is our number four number three is kalink Legacy or Clank Legacy Acquisitions Incorporated I believe is the whole thing and this this one's great and I this was like our first introduction I believe to Clank as well we haven't played a client game and this one came out and we'd heard good things about Clank so we jumped on it this is we've since played I think pretty much every kind of Clank that one could play this is the best way to play Clank I would say if you haven't played Clank you're just getting into Clank even Clan catacombs which I like quite a bit this is the one and it's crazy it's the story is super super short super tiny bits but they're legitimately funny which is so rare in a board game yeah and it's it's not just board game funny like we we enjoyed the the story elements and normally when we play a game you're not thrilled with having to Stomp the game to read The Narrative but this just nailed it because it was only ever like a couple of sentences and so it was perfect and it's got this neat thing too where you're competitive but we found we're sometimes a little bit cooperative and I think that might be part of the two player experience because people were worried about this are you going to open everything to player first of all yeah totally we I don't think there's anything I felt like we hadn't done but also you just find yourself being like well we want to make

sure this happens so there's like an unsteady truce and then we just turn on that especially you Jess would turn on me no but but it does work where you want to open everything so I know I could win the game by racing on the dungeon right now but then we wouldn't get this opportunity so I would let Sean if he was pretty further further deeper in the dungeon he would be able to open that thing up and then I would give him a turn to try and make it out so uh it might mean that he's playing with me just like a cat just playing with it I never like lie to you I always follow through with like yes it is true and so it does create an interesting slightly Cooperative EX experience because you're so interested in making sure you you experience the full campaign and everything's unlocked and you do change the board so it is it can't be like reset to play again but it is one that you can very easily play afterwards because then you have a great Clank game at the end yeah it's one of the only ones on this list actually because often an expansion game will say oh totally playable afterwards it's not it almost never has this one honestly gives you the best version of Clank at the end um I I would say I've had more fun playing this version of Clank than any of the other ones and and I think that that like that tense Cooperative competitive fits for your both burglars you're both sneaking in you're both gonna get killed by that Dragon if you

don't get out quick enough so there is that little bit of thematic like you an unsteady cooperation before before it's all gonna blow up at some point it does it does suit it yeah and that is our number three our number two is gloomhaven slash Frost Haven and when we got gloomhaven we played it all of the time and this I think one of the reasons I really like it is I love Dungeon Crawlers and for ages had been trying to get Sean into them but so many uh at the time use dice rolling and so this was more of a Euro style Dungeon Crawler that you were okay with yeah it's a card based really smart card based Euro so this is this is a euro game disguised as a Dungeon Crawler sometimes people use that as a criticism that is not that is 100 a compliment for me and it it does campaign so well because you really get the sense of the character building up and getting stronger and then the retirement and being able to even play new characters which is neat because I don't think a lot of this give you that opportunity so it's great to have lots of characters that you can play through so I do not like the story here I do not like the writing I am not interested in the overall story at all like it just it does not connect with me but the emergent narrative from making those characters and building them up and getting new cards and getting new powers and go taking them all the way to

retirement with their like little goal and then opening up a new character is so interesting to me that despite any flaws with the story despite my just I can't overstate my lack of interest in the overarching narrative I'm still so invested in it and that is that's really impressive and I do like that aspect because I I like following through that story and so it is great that Sean is still on board so we are both enjoying it it and it is impressive that we like it so much because there is a lot to set up we're always looking up little rules here and there and I think that's little things like that is what made it our number two probably and that setting up the Outpost phase I some people love it and it really brings them into the narrative more and I can totally see that but for me it's that little bit like in RPG video games I'm not into crafting stuff and adding weapons and going through all the stuff I've got and changing my outfits and going back to my Homeville straight to the mission so for me it's pulling me away from that a little bit um so that's been a bit of tricky but I don't think that's the case for you at all no I I do like that and so it's just trying to find that balance of making sure we do it because I I like the story and that is a key part of it but how to do it efficiently um so Sean is still on board with playing by the time you get to the mission so I'm like an eight-year-old you gotta she what she does is she gives me a juice box and a snack and she just

sets up an iPod with Dora the Explorer you know what I feel like that would work yeah just about and that is our number two so our number one our top Campaign games the Conor McDavid of campaign games his pandemic I had to say something to explain why I would be wearing this very bright Jersey you're Canadian yeah it is Ann albertan but um is pandemic and pandemic this has got to be this is the obvious this is the obvious choice because not only is like the first pandemic which I don't know I think we're still on the fence about if that's the best one but that first pandemic Legacy game that broke that that made Legacy games be a thing like I know Risk Legacy was officially the first one um we still haven't played that one yeah but pandemic Legacy took it to that whole other crazy level that everyone was like oh yeah this is a thing it even took us a while too because I thought we're gonna play it 12 times and throw it away forget it yeah we were on the fence about getting it because of that experience of it not being replayable afterwards we didn't see the value but it made every gameplay feel important because it was so limited it almost got to the stage when I wanted us to lose so that we would have happened but what's interesting too is you can only lose twice in a month which is nice it means you can't get like super stuck

where you're stuck playing it for five or six times you know it's definitely going to be between 12 and 24 games and and that's it and I think it's so approachable I I know a lot of people who aren't big Gamers who have played through pandemic Legacy because of that it's easy to set up you know the first game is is basically like pandemic and anything else gets added in uh enough in a way that you it's comfortable it's not big jumps yeah they just slowly kind of drip it I think and it's nice because they also slowly drip the idea of like oh man I got up like right on my game board I gotta put a sticker I gotta rip up this we never ripped up a card all those cards we kept and it's good because if you design it all you can use all that stuff for prototypes so keep it nice no reason no reason to rip it up but adding the stickers to the board and everything else once you start to do it it's a little bit free and you're like breaking this board game Taboo and it's yeah and now we've we've broke down that barrier we're just we're sticking stickers to everything we're sticking stickers to non-camping no we're not we're not but also the the season three or season zero or the third one that came out season zero we really liked we thought they did some really interesting different things with it so pandemic Legacy we think is just it's been so strong because like season one and season Zero have been some of our best experiences in season two is it's I really appreciate what they were trying to do and it is still like it was still a really interesting

play it's just if you compare it to one is not as strong but it's I think totally worth playing still and it's worth for the whole thing too because there's surprisingly a lot of narrative through the three even though it's tiny little bits that they're drip feeding you it's it does end up telling a kind of an interesting story between them that is true so you should play it as one two then zero yeah I would say play them all play them in the order chronologically they came out yeah and they're all totally worth it but that that's our number one that is I think still we together this was both of our we both had this number one on the list I think so uh so it's the unanimous choice and those are our slash that we have haven't tried some of the ones we'd be Keen to try are mechs versus minions it sounds really great and dice Throne Adventures we think would be a really good fit yeah I really want to play dice Throne adventures and then there's other ones too that I hear great things about but just might not be a fit um King's dilemma which I think you just you need a bigger group than what we've got Kingdom Death monster that you just need more money than what we've got but I've heard good things about both of those but there and there are more things coming out as well the van Campaign games I didn't think we like them and obviously we do we played a lot of them yeah and we would be Keen to hear what your favorites are were

they anyway that we mentioned or some of the ones that we haven't tried yet please pop them in the comments and as usual please like subscribe and hopefully we'll see you for the next one thank you

Progress saved