Kyle's Top 10 Board Games of All Time!
Transcript
hi i'm sorry i forgot to press record okay lanolin like like sheep's wool i don't believe hello everyone and welcome back to kyle's channel maple it is today is kyle day we are here to introduce you to our lovely friend and new member of foster the meeple yeah kyle cornelius king i thought his middle name was stacy no i'm pretty sure it's clear i'm pretty sure it's cornelius the third anyways today kyle is going to be sharing his top 10. we're not going to be taking up much more of your time we're just very excited to be introducing him to you in the channel so please enjoy kyle cornelius tandy stacy king's top 10 top 10 board games of all time take it away kyle off to you what up bam welcome back to foster the meeple a channel all about line a channel all about board games and board gaming things my name is kyle and i am new here i thought i would go over my top 10 games of all time give you a little bit better insight into what kind of games i like since i'll be contributing to the channel a little bit it's going to be metal and in true ftm fashion i did not stick to 10 games i have 12 that we're gonna call top 11 because my 11 i couldn't decide between two games my number 11 a is a
feast for odin by ube rosenberg and my 11b is caverna by uva rosenberg both of these games are phenomenal i'm not going to go too far into why i like them or anything just like i love ube rosenberg and you will not see a new favorite virtual top 10. which is going to shock some people from the discord but that's why i had to shout them out give them an honorary mention i love those games they're fantastic they're super pretty charming to look at so let's go into the top ten number 10 is a very little known game by a designer called called a designer named jacob frexilius called terraforming mars performing mars is a pablo engine building game in which you're drafting cards which i love drafting to play in front of your tableau and when you play them they're either gonna trigger you can use them in the future for something but that's not exactly why i love the game there's a ton of engine building games out there that do kind of what terraforming mars does in that realm and quicker like wingspan is very similar to terraforming mars res arcana any of this engine building tabloid builder games you get the same feel but what makes terraforming mars great is the board in the middle the whole point of terraforming mars is to terra for mars and every player is working cooperatively to do that so this is a true semi co-op and not a lot of games do semi-co-op well or they do it false like marvel legendary just calls it a semicolon that's that's a cooperative game i think terraforming mars is a true
semi-co-op and that is competitive but everybody's working towards the same goal i just think that's a really neat design choice because it's thematic and it just makes the game just kind of sing my number nine game is clans of caledonia by someone by someone by someone jhuma al juju and karma games so classic caledonia is in the bgg top 100. i still think it's criminally underrated it's a game that i don't know if it got more than one print run it's a game that could have endless expansions it has had zero expansions but in queens of caledonia it's it's very much of the vein of terra misca and gaia project if you're familiar with those and the designer even states that those were some of the influences it's got area control on your turn you're doing action selection you have eight actions the actions are very very simple you can buy or you can sell or you can put people out on the board or you can make your shipping better so you can expand across the map better the scoring is kind of unique it's really the trickiest part is like the scoring on the area because you have to have like these clusters of groups divided by rivers but what i love about queens of caledonia is actually twofold one is the stock market and the stock market is very very simple in this game very bare bones supply and demand and i think it does it super well what i also like about the game is the contract fulfillment is just like it's just really really cool you need four stakes and three cheese and one milk complete the contract you turn all that stuff in then you flip it over it's gonna have
rewards for you right off the rip but it also has these things called export goods and whichever thing got sent the least amount of on contracts is going to be worth the most points at the end of the game i just think manipulating those contracts is like just really cool that's really why i think clinton caledonia sings my number eight game is kind of a twofer it's brass but specifically brass lancashire it's by martin wallace and roxley games it is a kind of a route building game heavy heavy economics pretty much you're going to have a hand of cards and every time you take an action you're going to discard one of your cards and the cards are either going to have an industry on it or they're going to have a city on it and if you want to build in that city you have to discard a city card if you want to build a certain industry you can discard that industry card to go somewhere you only need cards for two of the five actions you can do but you don't want to discard them because you may need them later and you're like i'm discrediting this card because i don't eat it now but then you get later in the game you're like oh my god i wish i had westminster abbey or whatever the cities are in england liam will have to tell me and it's it's very simple that's something i love is when something's crunchy but the rule set is actually very easy and i think that's why i like lancashire a little bit more than birmingham one of my pal said that he thinks lancashire works best at three and birmingham works best at four and i i really think that's true and i would just always opt for lancashire at three over here before even though they're like really like that and the roxie edition is beautiful to look at i love that dark setting i know i think jeff feels the same way there's that kind of dingy industrial looking england is just really really cool my number seven game
is a game that i've played the most of ever and that game is root by cole worley and leader games and i played this time on uh the app this summer and i'm sure you heard like jeff and jamie talk about it on a few of their videos because we played it so much over the summer it's like we had two or three games going at all times the the app really does what's the word it implements the game very well it really helps you learn the game because you can't make illegal moves root is a coin game essentially it's a it's a watered down coin game which means counter insurgency which is a style of war game where every faction is different completely asymmetrical and that can seem daunting i think a lot of people see root and they see the the lovely forest animals and they see the cool theme and they're like i want to try that but then they hear about how daunting that roles teach is and i agree that can be rough but what's cool about root is even though everybody's asymmetric there is a central core rule set that everybody abides by everybody is the same one condition gets a 30.
first person to get the 30 points wins the game the the player boards are just so good and so smartly laid out that after like two turns around you're like i got it and you may not play it well but at least you'll make legal moves another thing that root does well is how you're playing the players more than you're playing the table there are stronger factions than others there's no doubt about that vagabond the woodland alliance much better than the cats everybody knows that meta going into it so it's like we know the cats are weak we don't have to worry about it and then the cats are suddenly at 17 and you're like oh okay so we got to deal with the cats now once you develop that medicine with your friends and you can say like i know you can start sandbagging it and you just got like more more it just really creates great moments and i think that's one of the reasons we played the game so much this summer is we just had so much chirping going on became so much fun i can't imagine if we were playing around the table like feelings might have been hurt if we were in person number six on my top 100 is a pretty new game to me i got it in the summer i've played a ton ton and gamer terms is like four i've played it six times this i'm like i could write uh dissertation on this game my number six game is by luke glory and breaking games it is dwellings of elder veil and in this game it is a a work replacement game and a tableau builder the map is we're going to be putting workers and each hex is either going to be take a resource off if you put your work there or do the action and the actions are very simple it's like buy a new worker or build a dwelling or buy a
card and put a new tile on the map very simple stuff but what makes dwellings of elder veil sing is the word replacement interaction is different than any other work replacement interaction in a game because first off there are npc monsters that if you go to a hex adjacent to a monster they rush in and you're gonna have to fight them also you can go to a hex that somebody else is already in but then you're fighting them that just makes a really neat design choice because it allows everybody to do what they want but it comes at a cost and the battling is just like fun because you're you're rolling dice based on how many people you have in the fight and how many of your dwellings which are these houses you put on for scoring that you have around you so you can roll some dice based on that number it's a very simple combat system it's whoever has the highest eye is the winner and people have that upset on that about that online they just think it's a little too probably a little too luck based and i don't feel that way because you can just make sure you have the dice advantage and more often than not it's gonna work out in your favor and really nice is fun people like get over it it makes this euro game really really fun that's one neat thing about dwindling the builder i love the work replacement i also love when you are out of workers when you call them back you're putting them on the cards on your tablet to activate more actions when you pull back you're activating these cards which are might be better than putting workers on the board you may need to call back just to activate those cards when you still have workers in hand so i think that's a really really good element until it's photographed one of the reasons i love that game number five this is a foster the meeple favorite people i i think i can speak for ftm
right now and saying that this is probably single-handedly our favorite game and that is pandemic legacy season one breaking news we're just here to interrupt that is false epic is not it's just not why would you why would you do that what are you doing we invited you here to our channel that is now your channel also and you think you can come in here and sass us poop on our front step hey poo mouth he'll poop mouth how rude if it's anybody's first video they do not like pandemic i am the outlier in that i think pandemic is just masterful design it's balanced uh you're either gonna win close or you're going to lose clothes and every game is a a puzzle and i think pandemic gets a lot of crap for quarterbacking and i'm sorry if that's your complaint with pandemic it's because your friends suck and let me explain what pandemic is so a pandemic's a cooperative game and so that's why people think it has a quarterbacking problem because in cooperative games everybody's working together well if one person thinks they're the smartest guy in the room they can say like oh we can we need to do this we need to go here we need you here we need to do that and then they can kind of take over the game and like yeah that's not cool that's not fun but pandemic is a cooperative game everything is pretty much open information and on your turn you get to do four things you can move you can discard a card to move farther you can trade cards or you can kill a disease or some take a cube off because when these cubes are on the board if there are three in a city and another one comes out uh it explodes and the cubes expand out and if you run out of cube color you lose and if you run out
of your deck you think there's like multiple ways to lose so you're constantly battling like with oh can we just let this city blow up and yeah it's going to explode into other cities but that's okay because we're this close to winning so it just really creates these interesting choices so that's it that's base pandemic pandemic legacy season one my number five is probably my favorite gaming experience of all time but what makes pandemic legacy so special is like the story in the game and the twists and turns and you're adding in new elements every time you're just like it's just so incredible and i don't want to get into too much of it but there's there's something that happens and you're i was like i like threw my hat because like i couldn't believe what was going on it was just so exciting it was just so fun to work with my friends on this and we we played it like two or three times a night for five or six weeks it was just a really good experience i loved bass pandemic and legacy just gave it that story and there's twists and turns that made it really really fun my number four game of all time has rocketed up if i would have done this list this time last year this probably this game probably would have been in the 30s or 40s but i played it a lot solo and i think that's helped it a bit there's also been a lot more content to come out for it and that game is marvel champions by fantasy flight it's one of their living card games you're playing as a hero you everybody gets to be one hero my favorite peter parker wanda steve rogers to captain america scarlet witch spider-man those are my three favorite heroes in the mcu so you can you pick one of those and you face off against a villain and so say you're scarlet witch and you're facing off against stannis
and thanos has a scheme he wants to do and if he gets through his scheme you lose if he kills you you lose and your job is to kill him and what makes marvel champions really thematically sing is every deck is unique to that character so if you're scarlet witch she dives into chaos magic right so she is very chaotic she is very emotional if you've seen one division you're going to be taking big swings and if you're iron man you start off like really really weak but as you add on like your helmet and your booster legs and your rocket arms and you start playing these cards out in front of you you start to get more powerful you start to feel like iron man you're making these bigger turns and every deck feels like the character they are and if that wasn't enough thematically every hero has a alter ego side so if you're a spider-man you can flip to peter parker and when you're in peter parker the villain can't hit you but he will scheme because he knows you're off duty and i think that's just that's really cool every expansion makes me love it even more the campaign games rise of red skull and galaxies wanted were so much fun to go through and the story elements are not huge like you're not going to be reading like you are in gloomhaven you're creating your own story which is what i like my number three game of all time is a game i just acquired not last chris two christmases ago now and i played twice this year the first game i played after i got vaccinated and my friends could come over and that is twilight imperium fourth edition this game is a mega event game everything you've heard about it is true it will take you 12 hours and it will be totally worth it so in ti4 everybody is a an alien race and
that alien race is a little bit asymmetric different ships maybe one or two unique powers it's a race to ten points every round a new card will get flipped over which tells you how to score points like having eight resources or control four types of a planet something like that so it's a race of ten points the game kind of has like a cold war element where you don't really want to get in a fight so it creates a lot of new negotiation with where you're positioned and what you can sacrifice from your fleet for somebody to get what they may need but where this game really really shines is when somebody reaches the middle hex necatol rex it creates a whole new phase in the game called the agenda phase and in the agenda phase two cards get flipped over one gets flipped over and you read it and you're gonna be voting on it and it's gonna say something like this is a law do you vote for or against it and if it's four do this thing if it's against you this thing and there's one card in there that says like if you vote for this every ship on a wormhole gets blown up and if you vote against it it's like discrimination card so everybody that's on a wormhole is wanting it to be against because they don't want their ships blown up and everybody that's not on a wormhole wants to do it for it because they want everybody ships to go away it's just so much fun to like politic and jockey around with your friends to be like i i'm going to vote for this i hope you're okay with that and of course you're not okay with that so that that's really fun but the beauty of it is when there are two cards that come out so the first one comes out and you vote on it and you use planets to pay for the votes and then the second one comes out and it's something just as
nuts but you've already started your plans to vote so you have no say in what's happening and now the person that just lost all their ships on the wormholes you got time to pay the piper but the experience is is so great and you will be mentally exhausted at the end of the game but it is so worth it and i don't think everybody needs to own ti4 i don't even think anybody everybody will like ti4 but if you ever get a chance to play for free or at like a con or something somebody says hey we got we need one more for ti4 i highly suggest you take you take the opportunity my number two game of all time it really hurts to be here at number two it was my favorite game for a long long time probably since i i think i bought it in 2017 uh it was my favorite up until this year so it's like been my favorite for four years a game near and dear to my heart and that is scythe by jamie stegmeier and stone meyer games so inside this is really a euro game with ameritrash hastings on really good thematics alternate world war one and europe with beautiful art it's got great components but the game is about efficiency you have a player board in front of you a little faction mat and those faction mats have little action rectangles there are four actions every action has a top action and a bottom action and so when you take your little pawn to place on an action you can choose to do the top and then you can choose to do the bottom and the next time around you have to move your pawn to one of the other three actions unless you have the brute combo but i don't
think anybody uses that other than jeff you need to set yourself up to be able to do multiple top and bottom actions in a row you really need to combo like i'm going to go here to move and then i'm going to do the bottom interaction to build and then when my next turn i'm going to upgrade and the next turn i'm going to go back over here where i can move and build again and it's just really really fun puzzle i've played the game 30 times i i don't know how to play every faction mathematically the best i don't think you need to what makes scythe great and why some people do not like scythe is they want a war game fighting rolling dice high action and that's not what side is scythe is a cold war game side is setting yourself up on different areas of the map to control and you want to control them and you want to make yourself powerful enough that nobody wants to fight you that's where the tension comes in not every game needs to be i'm going head to head with you there is passive interaction inside so i think that's what i really actually do like about scythe quite a bit is that it's a euro and you have really cool your mechanics of top action bottom action and resource management and board positioning but there's also that that tension of interaction with their players like you're taking the pexes that's texas they can't be on was one of my favorite games for a long long time it's a game that when i bought it i was like first getting into the hobby i'm like i'm finally gonna buy a big game i had clark soon and king of tokyo and all of those and i was like i'm gonna buy me just a big expensive game and it's gonna be a night and we're gonna have fun with it and it's gonna be our
game kind of like risk was when i was in high school and it was i don't see it leaving my top five anytime soon it's so good and that brings us finally to my number one game of all time and let's just get to it because i got a lot to say about it it's a blood rage by eric m lang and come on games it's an area control game and the map is very is is tiny nine realms and each realm has like three or four villages that can hold one miniature in it so each round can hold three to five pieces so it's air control game and it's a drafting game and i i love the drafting mechanic what makes blood rage's drafting stand out above other drafting is if anybody plays fantasy football when you're drafting which is the best part of the year when you're drafting fantasy football you get to round three and you're like these players suck and you don't want any of them and you're just kind of like taking them because you need to fill out your roster blood rage is the opposite of that to me when you're drafting in blood rage every card seems so so good when i played it earlier in the summer and i was teaching like uh dolan and max i just remember saying like i want i want all of these cards and it's true you're like you're looking at all of them i can make that work i can make that work i can make that work and there's some tension in drafting words like i it's very easy choice boom i'm taking that and it's not in this game and i think it's just really really fun when you feel like no matter what card you take you're going to be doing something cool with it that's what one of the things that makes that drafting stand out especially because you can like you're going to be hate drafting cards like in terrifying mars when you hate draft you're just
going to pitch that card you're not even going to buy it but in blood rage you will use that card and you will use it advantageously and the person that wanted that that you hate drafted a problem seemed like i could use that you're like i know but i'm i'm better at the game than you and i took it and now i'm going to use the second thing i like about blood rage every clan starts off bare bones the same there's nothing special about you at all but the card you're drafting is what makes you asymmetric so in root everybody's faction is asymmetric right off the right side every faction is asymmetric right off the rip ti4 every faction's asymmetric right off the rip but in blood rage you build your asymmetry you build your clan how you want to build it how you think will do well and you can make your ships better you can make your leader better you can make your clan as a whole better you can acquire monsters all that stuff i think in those other asymmetric games it's gonna be like okay i'm playing this faction they're good at this so i need to do this and blood rage you're saying like i want to do this so i will do this by building my faction the way i want and i love that i love a game that's asymmetric and it's not putting the game on rails for you you're making the choices of how you're asymmetric blood rage does that better than almost any other game i've played third reason i love blood rage and this might be the top of the list is i mentioned that the map is tight at the beginning you're vying for control over a tight map already but the end of each round ragnarok happens and one of those regions will be destroyed and be of no use the rest of the game and not only thematically is that a beautiful thing
because ragnarok is high in viking lore dying to go to valhalla dying an honorable death in battle but it really creates uh like a knife and a phone booth type fight later in the game where everybody's vying for four areas instead of eight uh because of previous rounds there could be already troops out on the map already and just like i have nowhere to go but i really need to get to this spot because i have a quest that says like control yodenheim or something like that and it's just i love how it scales towards the end of the game it creates the battles whereas like some games you can like avoid battles you can't in blood rage and i think that's really why i i really started to dig this game because i really like that it forced the battles to happen while scythe was uh my love for a long time i just think blood rage is just kind of more me and now that we've gone through the top ten i'll kind of wrap up and kind of go over like why i like these 10 games because i think they all have very similar elements one i like player interaction a whole bunch i like area control a whole bunch one two three four five six i have seven of my top ten games have some kind of area control in them so i love area control and i think that provides player interaction at the wazoo i also love like economic games which like claims of caledonia um terraforming mars a little bit brass i i really like those games because there's also provide player interaction area control your vine you're jockeying for position but in like games like brass and queens of
caledonia the stock market and stuff just creates kind of like a passive player interaction that i really really enjoy and i love manipulating other players and don't get me wrong i love like head down the euros like puzzle it out it doesn't really matter what your opponent is doing i like this too but if you're talking about my favorite games of all time i think you can you can truly see what i'm what i'm looking for in those 10. well that's about wraps it up uh jim i hope i didn't screw that up if you want to buy any of these games or any other games may i suggest starting off at your friendly local game store for those people up in halifax that's the boardroom game cafe i'm barrington if you're in columbus ohio i like to go to the guard tower on trade view about 15 minutes for me that's all i have thank you so much to jeff and jamie for allowing me to be on the channel hopefully i get better as we go along please join our discord if you want to talk about these games with me or anybody else it's such an awesome community i've had so much fun over these past few months talking to everybody having fun and like you truly get to know people in there we all cut up every ask themselves it's just it's a great time in the discord so if you want to come yell at me post in the comments below but if you want me to like if you want to engage and discuss like why these games are good or why you think they're bad come to the discord please join and until then i gotta say stay sweet a piece for a odin i feel like was there one more thing i want to bring and you have to deal with some peter parker like you have to deal with an eviction notice or you have to go visit anthony's apartment to draw some more cards or something like that
it's just this isn't our video oh geez oh wait i forgot i don't know that was so good sorry jamie i'm gonna start this one over again number two you