Skip to main content
Loading video...

Talking about publishing expansions with Jamey Stegmaier of Stonemaier Games - TCbH Expansion Month

Transcript 36:19

Hello and welcome back to another episode of Cardboard Herald. I chance talk with creative gamers and game creators and I feel like I've been saying that to you for a decade now, Jamie. Welcome back to the show. Hey, good to good to see you. I I meant last night as I was falling asleep, I was like before I get on with Jack today, I should listen to your other episode about expansions cuz like maybe 2 months ago you recorded one and then I forgot today to do that. So

Right, right.

in without that fresh in my mind. That that's okay. That's okay because we got a lot to talk about here and speaking of expansions, this is kind of part of an effort that we're doing in preparation for April's expansion month. It just kind of happened to be that we had a bunch of expansions to cover. It's a concept that has a long loomed over board games and I think has really evolved as the industry's grown over the last decade or so and so we're recording this now in March and I'll go up in April and I thought who better to talk to about the like publishing arm of expansions than Jamey Stegmaier himself. So I guess let's dive right in it. First off, you have two brand new expansions that you released at the same time. They're they're over my shoulder right over there. You have Bordeaux and Americas and is there any sort of like business calculus that went into whether it was like a good decision or a bad decision to release two different expansion products all at once? Yes. Yeah, that's a great question.

And this is a good just in case someone doesn't know what Stonemaier Games is or who Jamey Stegmaier is, this is a good introduction because Wingspan is probably our most popular game. Viticulture is our oldest game. Those are the two expansions that you just mentioned there, Bordeaux and and Wingspan Americas. And a few years ago basically our our launch process for any product now is that we make the product and then we announce it a few weeks before we are ready to ship it and then we put it on our web store and we start shipping it right away to customers. And we realized a few years ago that when we put a a new like $20 product, 20 to even $30 product on our web store people are somewhat hesitant sometimes to buy it because they're then paying for shipping for a single product. So you're paying $25 and then you're paying another 10 in shipping. We have $10 flat rate shipping. The you know, the in our psychologically that math is a little bit difficult to do. But if you're getting two expansions that add up to like 55 and then you're paying $10, it's a little bit easier for you for people to to do that. And it's not a trick.

It's just we're consolidating shipping so you don't have to do it twice. So a few years ago we realized that and started grouping together certain products, not always two expansions, but often two smaller priced products at the same time.

Have you noticed that there's a lot of people who are buying them both at once? Yeah. I mean there's certainly people when we did the Wingspan Viticulture launch recently, there's certainly some people who were only interested in one or the other and they were they were more likely to add something else to the order, maybe Wingspan metal coins or another Wingspan expansion. Um but there was a decent overlap. There was a decent overlap of people getting both. How about you as a gamer? Do do you buy expansions for the games that you get? You know, like what to you is attractive about adding to a game versus going like, yeah, I think I'm going to pass on this one.

Yeah, I I was hoping you would bring that up and I'm I'm curious to hear your thoughts over the

today and over the podcast over the next month as you talk about this topic because I have been somewhat introspective about this recently. I recently recorded my top 10 games of all time. I do this every 6 months and two of the top ones were the Star Wars deck building game and the Lord of the Rings Duel for Middle-earth. Right. Both of which had expansions come out in the last year. There was a Mandalorian expansion and the kind of a mini expansion for for Lord of the Rings. You're a big Lord of the Rings Alliances, yeah. The the little tiny like comes in a booster pack looking thing. Exactly. Both were kind of booster pack size. They're both pretty small expansions. And I bought the Mandalo- I love both games. Like they're number two and three for me of all time as of right now. I instantly bought the Mandalorian expansion. I did not buy the the Duel for Middle-earth expansion and I've been trying to figure out why because I love them almost equally.

And I think this is I mean this falls Actually, I don't have a full answer, but I know that asymmetry adding asymmetry in an expansion or adding more asymmetry is something that maybe I'm more drawn to in a game that features asymmetry like the Star Wars deck building game. And Duel for Middle-earth, I love the game maybe it's because I love the game so much as it is and I still feel like there's a lot more to explore in the game that I didn't feel the need to. I don't know. Can you relate to that at all when you when you think about expansions? Yeah, I think that there's definitely some consideration as to like is this providing more of what you already love? Like when you take a look at a game like Root, I think is kind of the the extreme example where there's different factions that completely fundamentally change the the way the game is played. If that's what you really love about Root, then anything that's going to give you more lenses to see the game in different ways, you're going to be interested in. And you've had success with this certainly with like Tapestry is another great example. People want more factions. They they want more asymmetric powers, those kinds of things. Whereas Alliances, I think it's called Alliances for the Duel for Middle-earth kind of adds an extra layer on top of the game and it does feel somewhat inconsequential. Like it it doesn't feel like it was how the game was originally designed. I do like it and I have it. I enjoy it, but it definitely feels like it's

something that is an added on mechanic. It's not necessarily organic to the original game structure. Um And I think that's a that's a tougher sell, you know, especially if it's game that you already love, you're risking changing the ecosystem that you love about the game. That's that's well said. Yeah. I think some of that was was in there as to why I didn't pursue it. And I'm happy to play I mean there might be a day that comes that I play it and I'm like, oh I should have bought this and play with it the whole time, but that day has not come yet. Right, right. I I think there's also some arguments that there's some whiffs in that expansion. Like just as Lord of the Rings uber fan, picking some of the characters from the lore but not other characters from the lore to represent like additional heroes that you you want to have is just like do I really need a Sackville-Baggins as like a heroic extra? There are so many characters that you could pull from. Kind of cool representation-wise.

Artwork's kind of cool, but yeah, I don't know. Aside from all that, how about as a publisher because, you know,

[clears throat]

Viticulture, you mentioned is the original game. That's the OG that made your company what it is today. Yeah.

Um And that in itself has an interesting history because you had Viticulture and then there were a bunch of modular expansions that came out and then you eventually were like, all right, we need to go back. We have essential edition which is going to consolidate some of this and then you add Tuscany essential edition as like if you want more Viticulture, here's the things that really work and and add on more. But you you departed from a lot of the content from the original Viticulture and expansion releases. How have your feelings as a publisher changed to expanding content, to adding more content to what the taste of the consumer are?

Yeah, I mean it really depends on the game / the brand in some ways. And and to compare and contrast a little bit, two very different stories. With Wingspan, when we published it we you know, out of the gate we didn't know if there would be an expansion. I think maybe we Elizabeth and I had talked a little bit about what could come next if the game did well, but there's always that contingency. Will do people want more? If they don't, then that's it. We have we have to go back to

Can you imagine like just going back to that conversation? Will will Wingspan do well? I mean of course hindsight is 20/20 and everything, but one of the best-selling hobby board games of all time and yet there was still this conversation of like well, if it does well, we might have more content.

It is odd thinking back about that time and it was not for lack of enthusiasm on my part about the game, but you never know which game is going to hit with people or not hit. Um but with Wingspan, we once we saw that people were resonating with it uh we kind of laid out a plan and we kind of have said for many years, our hope is to have one expansion per continent. It's kind of very easy to think about that way since the core game was structured around a specific continent. We have a similar somewhat plan for Fins Span, not based on continents, but based on different types of creature aquatic creatures. But with Viticulture, as you said a a lot of the history that you just described for it happened within a fairly tight period of time between 2013 and 2015. And other than Viticulture World I well, even aside from Viticulture World, I have not designed an expansion for Viticulture in 10 years.

And then last year so there there was no plan. There was no future for Viticulture beyond reprinting it and continuing to support the community in other ways. But then last year I I was like, I kind of want to revisit it. I've learned a lot from this game over the years. I've learned a lot from playing it, hearing what people say about it, and I've learned a lot from Tuscany, too, and how people played with this extended board and how they liked having four seasons. And so, even in the in the Bordeaux rulebook, I outlined some of the things I started to think about as goals that I had for revisiting the game. So, two very different maps there for two two games. Um a desire from a designer to come back to revisit it versus a a plan that we wanted to execute over time. That's actually something that I really appreciated about both those releases, and I noticed that in the rulebooks, as I'm reading them through, because I I tend to be the kind of person who wants to I I'm a record guy, right? You know, like I read the liner notes. I want to know like every nook and cranny of what the people who made these things, you know, feel like should be in there. So, I like reading the special thanks. I like, you know, just gazing through the the um the playtesters to see is there someone I know in here, or you know, like I've seen that name come up. But, in both of these expansions, you have uh kind of that designer note, the intent of the expansion, what what it's meant to convey, what it's um uh I guess the the aim of it both uh thematically and also like your personal

experience. Um I thought it was really cool uh reading about um the hummingbirds, first off. I I had no idea how many hummingbirds were in South America. Um but, it just uh the notes about um kind of what Elizabeth was trying to accomplish mechanically with that to the ecosystem. Uh it's really cool. And like one of the things that kind of inspired expansion month was thinking about, you know, this isn't just additional content. The there is, you know, like experience designers who are thinking about their games as kind of a platform, and what they can add to it, what they can change, how they can fix it, how they can grow the game. Um so, that that's cool that you uh made sure to highlight those as part of the rulebooks. Yeah, it's fun. I I appreciate you reading those little parts of the rulebooks. Yeah, I think the Viticulture one, Bordeaux, is more focused on mechanical stuff, and you're right that the Elizabeth, when she researches a new area, a new region, she often visits that region, and uh she really comes at it from a theme-first perspective, which I appreciate. Yeah.

Now, with uh expansions, do you uh think about expansion potential when deciding if you're going to publish a game? Like, clearly, with Wingspan, you, you know, were like, "Well, if it is successful, we can do X, Y, and Z." But, do you actually consider we need to create games that at least give us the wiggle room to add more content down the road? Mhm. That's a That's a good way to phrase it. Um because yes, I do think about the future of a game as I'm working on it, whether I'm working on it as a designer, developer, or publisher.

But, I try to actively counter that by making sure that my primary focus, and really my sole focus, when we are creating a new game, that the that the game does not need anything else to be fun and functional and intuitive and balanced and all that stuff. All those things aim for. I don't We don't always achieve them, but all those things that we aim for out of the box, can this be the most complete, the most fun game out of the box as possible? Um we're not holding anything back, for sure. There are, even with Scythe, I don't know if you remember like the first time you you opened Scythe and saw the board, you saw two factions on the board. It's in my notes. I got it on my notes here. I was going to to bring it up to see if this is, you know, like a decision that you'd repeat having I think about this in the context of Lords of Waterdeep, as well, where there was the sixth player outline printed on the retail board, and it was a controversy. It was a controversy with Scythe, where it was like, "Oh, okay, you know, Jamie here thinks that we can just be hooked into an extra two factions that printing it on the board, but they're holding it back to, you know, bleed us dry of more money." You know, like tell me about the decision-making process there, and if that is a decision that you would repeat now.

I don't know if I would I don't know if I would repeat it. At the time, it was it was still a very tough decision of um so so, for context, going back to the past, uh those two factions did not exist yet. The the purple and the green factions in Scythe, they didn't exist. But, I there was room on the board for new factions to come in, and so I asked Jamey, the the creator of this this world, I was like, "Do you What do you think? Should we, knowing that we might add new factions in the future, should we put them on the board now, so it feels cohesive, or should we find some other way to add them later? Again, with these factions not existing yet, just the hypothetical idea that they could exist. And we decided to do it. Um but, it certainly did give the perception, as you just said, of that we are holding something back. Mhm.

And so, I would be and knowing what I know now about how we like now we have these little faction markers that you can put anywhere on the board if you want to with a modular board, like it would have actually been fairly easy to add places to put those factions without printing them on the board. Probably wouldn't have done that, and probably wouldn't do it again. Maybe someone in the comments can think of an exception to that that I've done since then, but probably would not do that again. Mhm. Yeah. Perception matters, I think. I've learned a lot about how people perceive things over the years, and how even if

[snorts]

even if something is, for example, uh objectively balanced in a game, if it doesn't feel balanced, that is just as relevant and just as important.

How do you feel about simultaneously released expansions? Like releasing the core the expansion at the same time as the core game? That's right. Yeah. I I am often bewildered by that choice. Um I know there are pros to doing it, especially with crowdfunding. You know, it's a it's a it's a stretch goal, it's an add-on, it can consolidate shipping. I don't understand it. I think the the build bewilderment comes from me as a designer and a developer, where I just don't have the brain space to focus on what could come next until I've finished Right. making what is what doesn't exist yet as the core game. Um so, maybe I should be in more in awe of designers who can do that. Um but, instead, it's more a little bit more of bewilderment of like, "Why would you do that before you even release the core thing and gotten feedback from, instead of 100 people or 200 people, from 10,000 people who play this thing and give you probably a lot of good constructive feedback Right.

to to both for that for that expansion." What's your What's your your hot short take on on that? I kind of agree. Like, I want it all there at once. Like, I I see if there is specific game modes why you might back it out, but it often feels like the the cost of creating additional materials to package it separately counteracts any of the benefits that you have. I've seen some people, you know, say like, "Oh, why is solo included in all this stuff? You know, why am I paying for solo stuff?" I'm sure that you, as one of the largest promoters, uh especially early promoters of solo in hobby games, uh and making it a consistent, ubiquitous, we're always going to have a solo mode.

Um I'm sure you've had criticism levied at you for like, "Why am I paying for solo when I'm never going to play solo?" And my my reaction to that is like, well, you might never play above two, but most of the time you're playing paying for the materials for more than two players, and if solo were backed out into a separate packaging, then that packaging is going to be more costly than the content of it for the vast majority of the the solo stuff. Like, someone might be paying an extra 50 cents for the deck of automa cards that they're actually getting that they can just ignore. If you never want to look at it, you can just throw it away. Um I I I think yeah. Yeah, I agree. I I can kind of see that as a I can kind of understand the argument for why you might want separate modes being like a a different thing. But, I I'm also like I don't really love modular expansions in general. I don't really love modular content in general.

Like, I'm kind of the purist in the sense that, you know, I want you to give me the game that you designed. Uh and that you think is the best version of this game that you really honed, and I am naturally kind of suspicious if there are like 16 modes to play the game, especially if those are broken out in different content packs and that kind of thing. It makes me less likely to dive into that content or or kind of even explore the game in the first place. I I'm not in a smile, because I I I feel the the exact same way. Um I And there are there are I think there are actually ways to package modules in a way that is a little bit more exciting for me. Like, in the game Meadow. Have you played Meadow? I haven't. Oh. So, Meadow has it has some modules that you can add in, and I think they're essentially just more cards or tiles. Right. And you add them in at different seasons or different times. Like, it like for one of the modules, it says, "Okay, the next time you take a a long walk, you could add in this module afterwards." Well, that's kind of delightful.

Yes, it's delightful. It's cute. It gives you a reason to uh you Um whereas if it is just a bunch of modes, I I get like you said, I I generally just want the the way the primary way that they spent the most time working on the game. I want that mode. And uh so I think there are ways to maybe package modules in but it usually I I I want the the core experience, whatever the designer intended that to be. Well, with the unusual nature of you acquiring Tokaido, that resulted in you having a simultaneously released expansion or I guess two expansions. And this is one of the things that um you know, like was a soft criticism in my own review of it that it's such a a storied uh and maybe not maybe I'm elevating it too much to say it's like an important game, but it was kind of like a milestone when it came out and has stood this uh test of time that there was almost like a wish from my perspective that I wanted like a Criterion Collection version of Tokaido. You know, like put it all in there, the expansions, have it all at once, nicely fitting in and showing like we are preserving this so that way it is a a piece of gaming history that you can acquire.

Um but you uh decided or the company decided to release it as the the base game and then you combined uh Crossroads and Matsuri, right? Into one expansion set there. So, what was the decision process in whether or not you were going to combine it all into one thing as opposed to combining just the expansions, you know, like walk me through how that's different than your other releases. That's it it's it's an excellent point and it was definitely a big point of discussion even when we were deciding whether or not to acquire the brand. And um the I guess the crux of the decision was we saw Tokaido. The reason that we Tokaido appealed to us was that it has sold consistently and really well in retail for a long long time. And we didn't want to take this $30 product such a great price point for retail and even mass market like a Target um and turn it into a game that uh that was no longer that no longer had that price appeal. Like And yes, we could have put everything in there. We could have put the fancy miniatures in there.

We could have put the expansions in there. The expansions probably would not have bumped it above 45. But if we had gone with the Criterion Collection, put all the fancy stuff, could have been easily a $75 game and suddenly that's that's a very different product. Um However, with Namiji, which uh we have our version of that coming out this year, I took a close look at that expansion and it's it's almost it's a very seamless expansion to add to the core game and Namiji is already a little bit of a step up from Tokaido that we decided to put it in the game and without we I think we maintained we're maintaining pretty close to a 30 maybe 35 $5 price point. So, we're kind of we're able to keep it at that level. Again, we're not we didn't put the fancy ships in there, but we we were able to put the expansion in there without increasing the complexity too much. Yeah. Complexity factored into not just the price. Yeah.

Are there hard metrics that you look at when deciding if you're going forth on an expansion or not? You know, like as you said earlier, we come back to this with Elizabeth you were talking about, well, there's potential if it hits, here's what I want to do. What is that? Is there a gut instinct that you have? Is it a certain market penetration that you have? A certain number of sales? What goes into deciding yes, it's worth doing an expansion or not?

Well, yeah, there's a couple considerations. Um Part of it is a gut feeling based on uh how much people seem to be actively playing and or talking about the game. Um I [clears throat] I'm very active on some social media like Instagram and our Facebook groups and BoardGameGeek and YouTube uh to pay attention to that sort of thing. There's also I would say a a soft but also quantifiable or quantitative metric of is the is this game popular enough that um that we need a reprint or need a couple that we're going to reprint this more than once. Um but there's even a soft spot in between because like with Libertalia: Winds of Galecrest, we had a pretty big first printing. I think it was around 20 or 25 thousand first printing copies. And it took a few years for us to sell through them. We're doing the first reprint right now, I believe. Maybe we did a small one that I'm forgetting about, but so it took a while. But we still decided during that time to release a mini expansion of more loot tiles. And I think we were able to do that because it was it did not take a lot of time to to design. It did not like it did not take a big expense to print. And so there was a low uh a low cost of failure if no one wanted it in a way. Um and we made a few thousand of them. We sold through them.

We're making another thousand of those little loot things. So, I think sometimes that can factor in as well. Like how how big do we want to go for an expansion? And if we just want to do a little thing, we could probably add that to any game if we think there's a thousand people out there who want to buy it. Right. I I always wonder if there's like a a critical mass you have to hit as a publisher to make expansions viable. I've talked with a lot of smaller publishers who have said like, man, you know, like even some of our best-selling games, it's a tough call to put out expansions because you already have a limited market for that expansion as opposed to releasing a new game. Um what sort of balance do you try to strive as far as like your release schedule?

How many games that you want to release in a year versus expansions? You know, like is there a proportion? Again, is it gut instinct? Uh you know, like how do you decide where best to put Stonemaier's money? Well, it's time and money. I'll throw time in there, too, because uh it is significantly easier, in my opinion, to design an expansion for a game than to design a game from scratch. So, that is certainly a factor. Doesn't mean that we'll that it it I would still only make an expansion if there is a drive or an inspiration and a desire for it to do that. Um As for the the the do we invest the money in making an expansion? I think that that factors into whether or not we we think we can actually uh actually sell it. But there isn't a hard like data point to say this is when it's worth spending that money and this is when it isn't.

It kind of it depends vastly based on the on the on the on the various circumstances around it. Are there any expansions that got away? You know, like either games that didn't sell quite as hard as you wanted them to or it was an expansion that you really loved, but it just didn't translate to what other people loved in playtesting or whatever, you know, is there a little behind-the-scenes Stonemaier nugget that you can share about, you know, like an expansion that could have been? Oh. I wish I had a good enough memory to have a great story. There probably is a story about that. Um I I can Well, I know there's a current expansion that we're working on where I think it's another designer who's working on it on the expansion and this is more fresh on my memory. Um where uh the designer I think went tried to add too much to it. And so we we're pulling back on it. The expansion will happen, but we're pulling back on it to make it uh a little bit easier to integrate with the game. I think that maybe comes from some personal bias on my part as to how easy it is for someone to just add an expansion.

And uh just probably have those expansion elements in the game. Um I'm all often teaching games for the first time to people and so I it's easier to keep everything together. And so I'm I'm more inclined to to to have these types of expansions. And for this particular game, it's an icon-heavy game and there are other expansions that that will exist or that have that do exist for this game, too. So, I was we're looking at it not only for the the context of what if someone just buys this expansion, but also what if they have the other two or three expansions, too? Suddenly they have what, four different reference guides of all these icons? How do we Yeah, how much is too much with that sort of thing? Well, you have Wingspan: Americas, you have Viticulture: Bordeaux having just released. We've talked about uh the the recent release of Tokaido with expansions there.

Uh any other expansions that uh are announced uh that are on the horizon that people should look out for from Stonemaier? Yeah, we have two. Even as we're talking about it, I'm like, how do we have so many expansions at Stonemaier Games? It it it it yeah, it seems like a lot, maybe too many um because we have two more coming this year. We have a mini expansion for Origin Story, which that one is actually it was very easy and fun to design. They're fun they're fun to design cuz you can just throw them into a game they already have. Um That one's nice. It just adds more superheroes to Origin Story, the the last round of the game. I love it. I love that game, by the way. This isn't a This isn't uh you know, like uh one thing viewers might not know uh is that if you're a content creator, uh Jamie at least says, and I trust him on this because I've been talking to to Jamie for, like I said, a decade. Um says he doesn't watch the the reviews so that way the the critical autonomy of the review channel is out there.

So, I don't know if Jamie actually gets to hear me say like, holy crap, Origin Story is probably my favorite Stonemaier game since Wingspan. Like it is just that good. So a from the expansion discussion, I love that game. Well, thanks. I appreciate it you saying that and I should throw in the caveat that I do subscribe to a lot of the content creators that we send stuff to because I like their content that and so I do see thumbnails. There you go. But I don't [clears throat] I don't watch everything else. So if you really want me to know that you don't like a game or like a game, you can put it in the thumbnail. I'll probably see it. Okay. But the for orchestra yes, so more more superheroes on the other end of the spectrum is a Scythe versus Expeditions.

It is both a standalone dueling game those two things versus one another a Scythe faction versus an expedition the player playing as Expeditions but it is also an expansion like it has expansion stuff or it is an expansion for Scythe. It is also an expansion for Expeditions and everything or most of the things that you own if you own Expeditions or Scythe expand this thing like you can plug in any Scythe faction. You can plug in any character from Expeditions. So this was a bit more ambitious a little bit more difficult to design. That's coming out this summer as well. And it's joyous and fun. It feels like you're breaking out your toy box and getting to play with everything at once you know. It does feel that way. I'm curious I will be curious to see what you think when it comes out because I think it is a It's a it was a lot of fun to design.

I think the I'm curious to see what people say about the challenge of knowing two the rules for two different games because you have to know the Expeditions rules and the Scythe rules which is a lot to ask of people. But I think those who buy into that will probably have a lot of fun with it. Well, this has been a great discussion and an enlightening discussion. One of the most directed discussions that I've had with you in the many that we've had over the years on the channel where instead of asking about how those Scythe miniatures smell, I'm actually just talking to you about the cold hard facts that hopefully the audience got something out of. Before I go, can I ask you a quick fire question? Okay, of course. I have something queued up here. I filmed a video a few years ago describing like the different categories of expansions that we've released as Stonemaier Games. And so I just wanted to throw them at you real quick and if you could maybe tell me the top two types of expansions from the ones that I say you get the most excited about. It's going to be two new words but that's okay. I love it.

More stuff expansions. Uh-huh. Expanded player count expansions. Yeah. Increased depth and complexity. Okay. Campaign expansions. Uh-huh. And new locations like a new map for Ticket to Ride that sort of thing. Right. I think more stuff tends to be my favorite and increased depth and complexity as well and I think if I were um if I were categorizing this from like a Wingspan perspective you know like when I want more stuff I want something that again um gives me more content more things to view and so the Europe expansion all the expansions give me that with just birds.

I'm just going to shuffle in all the birds. I tend to really love an increase in complexity. I thought the benchmark for the best expansion for Wingspan was Oceania but I actually maybe thinking America's is even better at this point because I love how the hummingbirds interact with the game and it adds the nectar. So you know like it it really knocks it out of the park there. Um you'll get to hear Mrs. Cardboard Herald's opinion on that. She's going to guest review the expansion for expansion month. Um and then the types of expansions that I tend to not like as much or care about as much tend to be additional player count expansions.

So you know like the the flock mode for Wingspan. Someone may like that. Someone may love that but that's just honestly something that I'm never going to touch. So it it doesn't really mean anything to me. And then also like things that fundamentally change the nature of the game. The the duet mode out of the Asia expansion which that was a standalone release right? Like you could just buy Asia and play it out the box. So I understand the the purpose and the point of that. However, as someone who already loved it and is viewing Wingspan as the base game and then that as an expansion I like two player Wingspan anyway. I'm not going to like mess around with what the formula is.

If someone was only ever going to play it two player then maybe duet's for them. But and it is cool but not cool enough that I want to change how I play that game. So more stuff increased complexity those are top of the list. Additional player counts or like fundamentally changing game modes that tends to be at the bottom. That makes it that's interesting to hear. Yeah, I don't want to say it makes sense because it might vary vastly for different people but I appreciate you sharing that. And it was interesting to learn I did not know that people were playing flock mode all that much. I'm glad that is there for those rare instances. But recently with America's we didn't really make it compatible for flock mode because we're like yeah you know it already adds playing time to the game are you really going to play this flock mode? And I've heard from now a bit via a survey that well over a thousand people at least

not only regularly play flock mode but subscribe to the Wingspan newsletter and wanted us to know that. So Right. Okay. There there's people out there who do it on a regular basis. So Hey. Yeah. You know like there there's Birds of a Feather or something to that effect. Well, thanks for for giving me those hot fire questions there and thanks again for coming on to the show Jamie. My pleasure. Good to see you.

Progress saved